La filiation et l'aide médicale à la procréation

Kinship following artificial insemination by unknown donor defines the child's mother and father as unknown. Although it could have been possible to construct this kinship on the model of adoption, the model adopted was that of blood and organ donation, which completely erases the donor's identity so that the recipient can take complete possession of the donated substance. But is gamete donation the same thing? Gamete donation concerns procreation and the parents' sexuality. Would it be possible to no longer consider the parents' sexuality to be exclusively reproductive sexuality allowing recognition of the progenitors alongside the mother and father?     

Biases incurred from nonrandom repeat testing of haemoglobin levels in blood donors: Selective testing and its implications

To help prevent anaemia, it is a requisite for blood donors to undergo a haemoglobin test to ensure levels are not too low before donation. It is therefore important to have an accurate testing device and strategy to ensure donors are not being inappropriately bled. A recent study in blood donors used a selective testing strategy where if a donor's haemoglobin level is below the level required for donation, then another reading is taken and if this occurs again, a third and final reading is used. This strategy can reduce the average number of readings required per donor compared to taking three measurements for all donors. However, the final decision‐making measurement will on average be higher than a single measurement. In this paper, a selective testing strategy is compared against other strategies. Individual‐level biases are derived for the selective strategy and are shown to depend on how close a donor's true haemoglobin level is to the donation threshold and the magnitude of error in the testing device. A simulation study was conducted using the distribution of haemoglobin levels from a large donor population to investigate the effects different strategies have on population performance. We consider scenarios based on varying the measurement device bias and error, including differential biases that depend on the underlying haemoglobin level. Discriminatory performance is shown to be affected when using the selective testing strategies, especially when measurement error is large and when differential bias is present in the device. We recommend that the average of a number of readings should be used in preference to selective testing strategies if multiple measurements are available.     

Prenatal care: a comparative evaluation of nurse-midwives and family physicians

We review various organ procurement strategies from ethical and practical perspectives to understand why these strategies have been relatively unsuccessful. We propose that the CMA recommend the implementation of a required-request policy in hospitals. We also propose a possible new approach in which people from the age of 18 years would voluntarily enrol in an organ donation program, agreeing to permit all usable organs to be taken for transplantation at the time of death. In return they would have priority for receiving organs made available by the program. We believe that this program would save lives, respect the donor''s autonomy and satisfy the principles of justice and beneficence.     

Racial classification regarding semen donor selection in Brazil

Brazil has not yet approved legislation on assisted reproduction. For this reason, clinics, hospitals and semen banks active in the area follow Resolution 1358/92 of the Conselho Federal de Medicina, dated 30 September 1992. In respect to semen donation, the object of this article, the Resolution sets out that gamete donation shall be anonymous, that is, that the donor and recipients (and the children who might subsequently be born) shall not be informed of each other's identity. Thus, since recipients are unaware of the donor's identity, semen banks and the medical teams involved in assisted reproduction become the intermediaries in the process. The objective of this article is to show that, in practice, this represents disrespect for the ethical principles of autonomy, privacy and equality. The article also stresses that the problem is compounded by the racial question. In a country like Brazil, where racial classification is so flexible and goes side by side with racist attitudes, the intermediary role played by semen banks and medical teams is conditioned by their own criteria of racial classification, which are not always the same as those of donors and semen recipients. The data presented in this paper were taken from two semen banks located in the city of São Paulo (Brazil). At the time of my research, they were the only semen banks in the state of São Paulo and supplied semen to the capital (São Paulo city), the state of São Paulo, and to cities in other Brazilian states where semen banks were not available.     

Cadaver nephrectomy: an operation on the donor's family.

Thirty-two relatives of cadaver kidney donors were interviewed six months or longer after the donor''s death. Most had positive attitudes to kidney transplantation that had been strengthened by experience, especially when they knew that they were fulfilling the donor''s wishes. Twenty-three of the relatives had gained some solace from knowing that others might benefit from their misfortune, but three claimed adverse effects. In identifying the factors that influenced them to grant permission or hesitate, relatives revealed defects in the way their permission had been sought. Twelve did not clearly understand the donor''s hopeless prognosis until then, and seven reacted adversely to the interviewers, finding them blunt and callous. Nevertheless, most were pleased that they had been asked. Doctors who care for unconscious, dying patients should try to give relatives explicit information on the patient''s condition, whether or not the patient is a potential kidney donor, and permission for organ recovery should not be sought until they understand that death is inevitable.     

Parental attitudes toward pediatric organ donation: a survey.

We conducted a telephone survey of parents in the National Capital Region to assess their intention to donate their child''s organs and to provide physicians with information that could help alleviate their concerns about approaching parents for consent. Of 339 parents who agreed to answer questions after being given details of their child''s "death" 288 (85%) said that they would be willing to donate their child''s organs. The degree of willingness was associated with the certainty of death, altruism and empathy toward children in need of an organ, previous discussion of organ donation with a family member and knowledge of an adolescent or adult child''s attitude toward donation. Factors that inhibited the intention to donate included uncertainty of death, insufficient information from medical professionals and fear of multilation. The child''s age was not significantly associated with intention to donate. Concordance between the results and actual donation rates in Canada and the United States supports the generalizability of the survey findings.     

QUESTIONABLE COMPENSATION CLAIMS—Principles of Special Examination

In deciding a disputed claim of disability arising from occupation, physicians should ascertain whether a patient''s medical history has any bearing on the disability; they should attempt psychologic evaluation of the patient as it may reflect on the conditions they observe in physical examination; they should investigate symptoms complained of by the patient rather than accept them as prima facie evidence of disability; and they must have knowledge of the extent to which an injury can cause disability.It is urged that standards of physical ability and disability, as well as of other physical factors which may affect compensation claims, be established by organized research.     

带血管髂骨移植动物模型的建立与评估

目的:探索一种相对简单稳定的大鼠髂骨皮瓣移植手术方式,为髂骨移植诱导免疫嵌合状态的研究建立可靠的动物模型。方法:实验分为3组:空白对照组,不做任何处理;旧术式组,将供者髂骨肌皮瓣移植入受者腹股沟区,吻合供者髂腰动静脉和受者股动静脉;实验组,剥离供者髂骨臀大肌,取供者的髂骨连带肌肉及皮瓣移植于受者的腹股沟区域,将供者的髂总动脉和髂腰静脉分别与受者的股动静脉吻合,随后缝合皮肤。术后所有大鼠给予环孢素A 28天,始剂量16 mg/kg/d,第三周始每周剂量减半,第28天处死大鼠并选取髂骨做病理学检测,观测骨髓细胞量,骨陷窝是否有骨细胞等,以此判断髂骨是否成活。结果:实验组共进行手术15例,皮瓣成活11例,成功率73%;病理检测皮下髂骨成活7例,成功率47%;旧术式组共进行手术8例,皮瓣成活4例,成功率50%,病理检测皮下髂骨成活3例,成功率37.5%,其中实验组动脉吻合时间(24.7±2.3)min,明显短于旧术式组(36.7±1.5)min(均P0.05),而静脉吻合时间、缺血时间,供受体准备时间并无差异(均P0.05)。结论:通过剥离供者臀大肌,改变动脉吻合对象,可以建立相对简单、稳定的髂骨皮瓣移植模型,为探索带血管骨髓移植诱导嵌合状态提供了新的动物模型。     

Relative contributions of history-taking,physical examination,and laboratory investigation to diagnosis and management of medical outpatients.

To evaluate the relative importance of the medical history, the physical examination, and laboratory investigations in the diagnosis and management of medical outpatients some physicians recorded their diagnosis and a prediction of the method of managementafter reading the patient''s referral letter, again after taking the history, and againafter performing the physical examination. These diagnoses and predictions were compared with the diagnosis and method of management which had been adopted two months after the patient''s initial attendance. A diagnosis that agreed with the one finally accepted was made after reading the referral letter and taking the history in 66 out of 80 new patients; the physical examination was useful in only seven patients, and the laboratory investigations in a further seven. In only one of six patients in whom the physician was unable to make any diagnosis after taking the history and examining the patient did laboratory investigations lead to a positive diagnosis.     

Factors associated with outcome of renal transplantation.

To explore the associations between a number of preoperative risk factors and the failure of renal grafts 99 consecutive patients were followed for up to 7 years after transplantation. The patients had all received their grafts from nonliving donors; the operations were performed at one hospital. Statistical analysis in relation to several outcomes showed that rapidly progressive glomerulonephritis, pre-existing cardiovascular disease, the degree of presensitization to histocompatibility antigens and the donor''s being of blood group B were associated with an increased risk of graft rejection or death after transplantation. The risks of acute and accelerated rejection were associated with different factors, which suggests that distinct pathogenetic processes may be involved. The risk of technical failure was associated with immunologic factors, which suggests the possibility that this outcome was not caused by surgical difficulties alone.     

Compelled organ donation

Along with ethical considerations, compelling an individual to donate organs, tissues, or bodily fluids brings several legal doctrines into conflict. The privacy of one's body is generally considered sacrosanct by American courts, which have upheld a competent adult's right to refuse medical procedures, even in cases when they are necessary to save the life of another. Although medical and legal communities stress “respect for the individual” as being paramount under American jurisprudential principles, the doctrine of “substituted judgment” permits a court to act (for example, by consenting to organ donation) on behalf of an incompetent individual or child. Parents also have the right to cause a child to “donate” an organ, and although a means exists by which the child can refuse, this may not be realistically feasible for young children. The revised Uniform Anatomical Gift Act of 2006, while clarifying issues of who may make organ donation decisions, does not resolve all the practical issues of compelled organ donation for minors.     

Pregnancy established in an infertile patient after transfer of a donated embryo fertilised in vitro.

In vitro fertilisation after stimulation of the ovulatory cycle has led to successful pregnancy. If more oocytes are recovered than are needed they may be left unfertilised, preserved, or donated to a recipient couple from whom oocytes cannot be obtained. A case of human pregnancy initiated by transfer of a donated embryo fertilised in vitro is reported. The donor was a 42 year old woman with primary infertility from whom six follicles were aspirated after stimulation of the ovulatory cycle. The recipient was a 38 year old infertile woman who had undergone several unsuccessful attempts for artificial insemination from a donor. Five oocytes were recovered from the donor''s six follicles, four of which were inseminated with spermatozoa of the donor''s husband and the fifth with a frozen sample of semen. Three of the four embryos fertilised by her husband were returned to the donor and the fifth was transferred to the recipient. No pregnancy was recorded in the donor, but pregnancy was confirmed in the recipient, though spontaneous abortion occurred after 10 weeks. This case will give useful information for further study of in vitro fertilisation, but also raises many ethical issues.     

Uncomplicated HL-A Matched Sibling Bone Marrow Graft for Combined Immune Deficiency

When an apparently identical HL-A donor can be found and satisfactorily checked by the mixed lymphocyte reaction, it is worth attempting simple bone marrow grafting in a patient with combined immune deficiency syndrome who otherwise would die. Immunocompetence was given in this way to a baby girl by her 4-year-old brother and was confirmed by the presence of Y-chromosome in most of the transforming lymphocytes. IgA was late to emerge, presumably owing to the immaturity for IgA of the donor''s bone marrow.     

心内膜下心肌梗死的常见误诊病例浅析

目的:探讨心内膜下心肌梗死的常见误诊原因及对策。方法:回顾性分析9例心内膜下心肌梗死患者的病历资料,包括病史、系统体格检查,ECG、心肌酶谱、胸片、超声心动图检查等。结果:9例心内膜下心肌梗死患者均有临床症状、ECG及心肌酶学指标的动态变化,诊断明确,以冠状动脉病变为其主要病因,在此基础上由其他因素诱导发病。结论:临床医师对心内膜下心肌梗死认识不足、对ECG和心肌酶谱的特异性动态改变未充分认识,是导致误诊的主要原因,建议详细询问病史、系统体格检查及辅助检查,综合判断明确诊断。     

Contributions of the history,physical examination,and laboratory investigation in making medical diagnoses.

We report an attempt to quantitate the relative contributions of the history, physical examination, and laboratory investigation in making medical diagnoses. In this prospective study of 80 medical outpatients with new or previously undiagnosed conditions, internists were asked to list their differential diagnoses and to estimate their confidence in each diagnostic possibility after the history, after the physical examination, and after the laboratory investigation. In 61 patients (76%), the history led to the final diagnosis. The physical examination led to the diagnosis in 10 patients (12%), and the laboratory investigation led to the diagnosis in 9 patients (11%). The internists'' confidence in the correct diagnosis increased from 7.1 on a scale of 1 to 10 after the history to 8.2 after the physical examination and 9.3 after the laboratory investigation. These data support the concept that most diagnoses are made from the medical history. The results of physical examination and the laboratory investigation led to fewer diagnoses, but they were instrumental in excluding certain diagnostic possibilities and in increasing the physicians'' confidence in their diagnoses.     

Public awareness of organ donation.

A telephone survey of public attitudes toward organ donation and transplantation was conducted in a community in southwestern Ontario. The subjects were selected at random; the response rate was 57%. Of the 50 respondents 62% stated that they had signed the organ donor card accompanying their driver''s licence. These respondents were more likely than those who did not sign it to have discussed organ donation with their families. At least 80% of the respondents said they would agree to donate their organs and those of their next-of-kin, and 80% said that the organ donor card should be considered a legal document. Organ transplantation was regarded by all but one respondent as an acceptable medical procedure. Also discussed were concerns about organ donation and possible strategies to improve the availability of organs for transplantation.     

Collective Philanthropy: Describing and Modeling the Ecology of Giving

Reflective of income and wealth distributions, philanthropic gifting appears to follow an approximate power-law size distribution as measured by the size of gifts received by individual institutions. We explore the ecology of gifting by analysing data sets of individual gifts for a diverse group of institutions dedicated to education, medicine, art, public support, and religion. We find that the detailed forms of gift-size distributions differ across but are relatively constant within charity categories. We construct a model for how a donor''s income affects their giving preferences in different charity categories, offering a mechanistic explanation for variations in institutional gift-size distributions. We discuss how knowledge of gift-sized distributions may be used to assess an institution''s gift-giving profile, to help set fundraising goals, and to design an institution-specific giving pyramid.     

Psychiatric illness in inpatients with neurological disorders: patients' views on discussion of emotional problems with neurologists.

The prevalence of psychiatric morbidity in inpatients with neurological disorders and the extent to which it is detected by neurologists were measured by using a two stage model of psychiatric assessment and from information recorded in the patients'' medical notes. The prevalence of psychiatric morbidity was estimated as 39%, of which 72% was unrecognised by the neurologists. Only a minority of patients with an uncertain physical diagnosis had a psychiatric illness, showing the error in assuming that a patient''s physical symptoms arise from a psychological disturbance if an organic aetiology cannot be determined. When the patients were interviewed on their discharge from hospital they were divided on whether they had wished to discuss their mood with neurologists while they were in hospital. The reasons that they gave suggested that interactions between patients and doctors and the lack of ward facilities for private consultations with doctors are important determinants of hidden psychiatric morbidity in medical inpatients.     

Management of the rape victim.

A woman''s response to rape can be divided into three phases: an acute reaction, an intermediate stage and a period of resolution. Proper management of the physical and emotional problems of each phase, ideally by the woman''s family doctor or gynecologist, may prevent future problems. Treatment during the first phase includes responding to the emotional needs of the patient as well as doing a pelvic and general physical examination to detect any injuries; information for possible legal procedures may be obtained quickly and efficiently. Follow-up particularly psychological, is important in the second and third phases.     

Function of Cadaver Renal Homografts in Relation to Age of Donor,Cause of Death,and Ischaemia Time

Twenty-six renal grafts four months or more after transplantation have been shown to function satisfactorily when the donor''s age has varied from 10 to 64 years and the period of warm ischaemia has been between 26 and 133 minutes. It is suggested that a more lenient view be adopted with respect to the age of the donor, but that a warm ischaemia time of two hours should not be exceeded.