Meiotic behaviour of chromosomes 1R, 2R and 5R in autotetraploid rye

The meiotic behaviour of chromosomes 1R, 2R and 5R was studied in C-banded preparations of autotetraploid rye. Analysis of pairing and chiasma formation was based on metaphase I configurations, using the model designed by Sybenga, with slight modifications. Frequencies of two modes of pairing (one quadrivalent or two bivalents) differed from those expected for random pairing. Although preferential pairing for some arm pairs of chromosome 2R was detected, this did not seem to be the cause of the increased bivalent pairing. This increase was attributed to either the spatial separation of the four homologous chromosomes in some premeiotic cells into two groups of two, or a correction of the synaptonemal complex, or both. The number of chiasmate associations showed variation between chromosomes and between arms within the same chromosome. It was closely related to arm length, but different after quadrivalent and bivalent pairing. This is suggested to be a consequence of partner exchange interfering with pairing and, consequently, with chiasma formation, and a different chiasma distribution after quadrivalent pairing. Variation between chromosomes in the frequencies of alternate and adjacent co-orientation in metaphase I quadrivalents without interstitial chiasmata suggests that the relative positions of the centromeres in the quadrivalent influence their co-orientation.     

Preferential pairing estimates from multivalent frequencies in tetraploids.

Mathematical models are presented for estimating preferential pairing and chiasma parameters in amphidiploids and autotetraploids on the basis of diakinesis or metaphase I configuration frequencies and are compared with other approaches of estimating affinity. With a preferential pairing factor p, estimated from quadrivalent and trivalent frequencies, and estimated chiasmate association factors for the two arms in quadrivalents (a(qu) and b(qu) for arms A and B, respectively) and in bivalents (a(bi) and b(bi)) a perfect fit between observed and predicted configuration frequencies can often be obtained in amphidiploids of several plant species, including Solanaceae and Gramineae. Since several proven autotetraploids give very similar apparent preferential pairing estimates, the biological significance of such parameters as preferential pairing and affinity factors is considered limited. The same is true for pairing parameters estimated by optimizing fit of configuration frequencies expected on the basis of theoretical models to observed data.     

Quantitative analysis of diploid translocation heterozygotes: test of models and equations

Summary Equations have been derived for two different models of chromosome pairing and chiasmata distribution. The first model represents the normal condition and assumes complete synapsis of homologous bivalents and the arms of interchange quadrivalents. This is followed by a nonrandom distribution of chiasmata among bivalents and multivalents such that each bivalent or bivalent-equivalent always has at least one chiasma. Univalents occur only as part of a III, I configuration at diakinesis or metaphase I. The second model assumes that a hologenomic mutation is present in which all chromosomes of a genome are equally affected. Two different assumptions can be made for such a mutation, and both give the same results: (1) homologous or homoeologous chromosome arms may be randomly paired or unpaired, but synapsis always leads to a crossover; (2) homologous or homoeologous arms always pair, but chiasmata are randomly distributed among the arms. The meiotic configurations at diakinesis or metaphase I are the same for both assumptions. Meiotic configurations of normal diploid interchange heterozygotes show good agreement with numbers predicted by the equations for nonrandom chiasmata distribution among configurations. Inter-specific hybrids with supernumerary chromosomes produced meiotic configurations frequencies in agreement with predictions of equations for random chiasmata distribution, but a hybrid without supernumeraries fitted the nonrandom expectations.     

Synapsis in Robertsonian heterozygotes and homozygotes of Dichroplus pratensis (Melanoplinae, Acrididae) and its relationship with chiasma patterns

Dichroplus pratensis has a complex system of Robertsonian rearrangements with central-marginal distribution; marginal populations are standard telocentric. Standard bivalents show a proximal-distal chiasma pattern in both sexes. In Robertsonian individuals a redistribution of chiasmata occurs: proximal chiasmata are suppressed in fusion trivalents and bivalents which usually display a single distal chiasma per chromosome arm. In this paper we studied the synaptic patterns of homologous chromosomes at prophase I of different Robertsonian status in order to find a mechanistic explanation for the observed phenomenon of redistribution of chiasmata. Synaptonemal complexes of males with different karyotypes were analysed by transmission electron microscopy in surface-spread preparations. The study of zygotene and early pachytene nuclei revealed that in the former, pericentromeric regions are the last to synapse in Robertsonian trivalents and bivalents and normally remain asynaptic at pachytene in the case of trivalents, but complete pairing in bivalents. Telocentric (standard) bivalents usually show complete synapsis at pachytene, but different degrees of interstitial asynapsis during zygotene, suggesting that synapsis starts in opposite (centromeric and distal) ends. The sequential nature of synapsis in the three types of configuration is directly related to their patterns of chiasma localisation at diplotene-metaphase I, and strongly supports our previous idea that Rb fusions instantly produce a redistribution of chiasmata towards chromosome ends by reducing the early pairing regions (which pair first, remain paired longer and thus would have a higher probability of forming chiasmata) from four to two (independently of the heterozygous or homozygous status of the fusion). Pericentromeric regions would pair the last, thus chiasma formation is strongly reduced in these areas contrary to what occurs in telocentric bivalents.     

Chiasma frequency,distribution and interference maps of mouse autosomes

Chiasma frequencies were analysed and chiasma positions measured in diakinesis/metaphase I autosomal bivalents from oocytes and spermatocytes of F₁ hybrid C3H/HeH×101/H mice. Twenty chromosome size ranks, including the presumptive X bivalent, could be distinguished in oocytes, and nineteen autosomal ranks plus the XY pair spermatocytes. Overall, mean cell chiasma frequencies of the two sexes did not differ significantly once the contribution of the presumptive X bivalent and the XY pair were taken into account. Sex related differences in chiasma distribution patterns were evident, however. In monochiasmate bivalents, the chiasma was most commonly located interstitially in oocytes while in spermatocytes it could be either interstitial or distal. In dichiasmate bivalents, the chiasmata tended to be more centrally located in oocytes than in spermatocytes. Minimum inter-chiasma distances did not appear to show any great variation in chromosome pairs of different sizes, however, mean inter-chiasma distances did increase with the bivalent length. The minimum-inter chiasma distance data suggest that chiasma interference is complete over a chromosomal segment equating to approximately 60 Mb. Measurement of the positions of chiasmata along chromosome arms open up the possibility of producing chiasma-based genetic maps for all the autosomes of the mouse.     

Lampbrush chromosomes and chiasmata of sex-reversed crested newts

Triturus cristatus carnifex provides a particularly clear example of sexual dimorphism for chiasma frequency and localisation. Oocytes from normal XX females routinely carry one proximal chiasma on each arm of their lampbrush bivalents. Spermatocytes from normal XY males have more numerous and relatively distal chiasmata. Lampbrush chromosomes from the oocytes of sex-reversed XY neofemales are found to resemble those from normal oocytes in having one proximal chiasma on each bivalent arm. A comparison of particular markers on the heteromorphic long arm of chromosome 1 provides evidence to equate the lampbrush 1A to somatic 1A, and confirms previous reports that lampbrush chromosome 1A is slightly longer than 1B. The XY sex bivalent of neofemales does not show any obvious heteromorphy of recognised marker loops. Received: 9 September 1997 / Accepted: 16 October 1997     

ISH-facilitated analysis of meiotic bivalent pairing.

Chiasmata constitute one of the cornerstones of sexual reproduction in most eukaryotes. They mediate the reciprocal genetic exchange between homologues and are essential to the proper orientation of the homologous centromeres in meiosis I. As markers of recombination, they offer a cytological means of mapping. Rather than trying to accurately count individual chiasmata, we have examined properties of the mathematical relationship between frequencies of nonadorned disomic configurations in meiosis (ring, rods, and univalents) and the probabilities at which arms of the respective chromosomes are chiasmate (one or more chiasma per arm). Numerical analyses indicated that conventionally analyzed bivalents with nonidentified arms yield statistically biased estimates of chiasma probabilities under a broad range of circumstances. We subsequently analyzed estimators derived from adorned configurations with ISH-marked arms, which were found to be statistically far superior, and with no assumptions concerning interference across the centromere. We applied this methodology in the study of chromosomes 16 and 23 of cotton (Gossypium hirsutum), and estimated their arm lengths in centimorgans. The results for chromosome 23, the only one of the two chromosomes with a documented RFLP map, were consistent with the literature. Similar molecular-meiotic configuration analyses can be used for a wide variety of eukaryotic organisms and purposes: for example, providing far more powerful meiotic comparisons of genomes of chromosomes, and a rapid means of evaluating effects on recombination. Key words : meiotic configurations, chiasma frequencies, in situ hybridization, cotton.     

Unexpected behavior of an inverted rye chromosome arm in wheat

Distal location of chiasmata in chromosome arms is thought to be a consequence of the distal initiation of synapsis. Observations of meiotic behavior of a rye chromosome with an inverted arm show that patterns of chiasma distribution and frequency are also inverted; therefore, the patterns of synapsis and chiasma distribution are independent, and recombination frequency along a chromosome is position-independent and segment-specific. Since cases of random distribution of chiasmata and recombination are known in rye, a genetic mechanism must be present that licenses specific chromosome regions for recombination. Large differences in the metaphase I pairing of the inversion in various combinations of two armed and telocentric chromosomes confirm the major role of the telomere bouquet in early homologue recognition. However, occasional synapsis and chiasmate pairing of the distal regions of normal arms with the proximal regions of the inversion suggest that an alternative mechanism for juxtaposing of homologues must also be present. Synapsis in inversion heterozygotes was mostly complete but in the antiparallel orientation, hence defying homology, but non-homologues never synapsed. Instances of synapsis strictly limited to the chiasma-capable segments of the arm suggest that, in rye, both recombination-dependent and recombination-independent mechanisms for homologue recognition must be present.     

The effect of colchicine on meiosis in Lilium speciosum cv. “Rosemede”

Chromosome pairing and chiasma frequency were studied in meiocytes at diakinesis of Lilium speciosum cv. Rosemede fixed up to 21 days after the start of either continuous or 3 day pulse colchicine treatment. The two treatments gave similar results. In pulse treated pollen mother cells (PMCs) the mean chiasma frequency per cell fell from 26.4 in controls to 8.5 after fourteen days while the mean number of univalents per cell increased from 0.05 to 17.58. There was a negative correlation between mean chiasma frequency per bivalent and per PMC in colchicine treated buds; univalents were preferentially induced in bivalents with one chiasma, and preferentially excluded in bivalents with 4 chiasmata. Some chiasmata were redistributed to surviving bivalents despite the concurrent reduction in chiasma frequency per meiocyte. — Colchicine sensitivity began in premeiotic interphase and extended to mid or late zygotene in PMCs; ongoing synapsis was unaffected. However, susceptibility to univalency was asynchronous between bivalents occurring at zygotene in short chromosomes but at late premeiotic interphase in the longest chromosomes. The number of chiasmata per bivalent could be altered by colchicine without inducing univalents, but the ultimate effect was to reduce the number of chiasmata per bivalent (or per chromosome arm) directly to zero. The major factors determining the order and extent of reduced pairing and chiasma number were total chromosome length and arm length. Pairing and chiasma formation in embryo sac mother cells were less sensitive to colchicine than in PMCs, but their behavior was otherwise similar.     

Synaptonemal complex pairing and metaphase I association in a telo-substituted telotrisomic of rye (Secale cereale L.)

The synaptonemal complexes in pollen mother cells (PMCs) of rye in which one chromosome 1R was replaced by the two corresponding telocentrics, and where one additional telocentric 1RS was present, showed approximately the expected 21 ratio of 1R-1RL-1RS trivalent with 1RS univalent versus heteromorphic 1R-1RL bivalent with 1RS bivalent. In addition, however, many cells with a partner exchange were found, several even including bivalents other than 1R. At metaphase I1R-1RL-1RS trivalents predominated, cells with two univalent telocentrics were relatively frequent but partner exchange configurations were extremely rare. It is concluded that the almost consistent failure to form chiasmata in the interstitial region of 1RS after partner exchange, combined with much more frequent chiasma formation in the terminal segment, is the main reason for the unexpected metaphase I configuration frequencies. Possible causes are discussed. The shift observed does not yet explain the erratic variation in relative frequencies of metaphase I configurations reported earlier in similar material. Frequent pairing partner exchange may play a role there also.     

Myths and mechanisms of meiosis

A comparative analysis of the meiotic secquence in a wide variety of organisms indicates there is no convincing evidence that: (1) Premeiotic pairing plays any role in the synapsis of homologues. (2) Heterochromatic association facilitates homologous pairing. (3) Chiasmata ever form within segments which are positively heteropycnotic at zygotenepachytene. (4) Localisation of chiasmata depends on prior localisation of pairing or on the occurrence of euchromatin-heterochromatin boundaries. (5) Prior association of centromeres plays any role in determining co-orientation. (6) Any form of supra-chromosomal organisation exists involving permanent association between the members of a haploid complement, and (7) Unequal progeny ratios recovered from structurally modified Drosophila complements arise as a consequence of distributive pairing. — On the other hand there is good evidence that: (1) Interlocking of bivalents can occur regularly in species with a chiasma frequency sufficiently high to regularly produce ring bivalents and in which the chiasmata are localised to the ends of the bivalent. (2) Some forms of terminal association cannot represent terminalised chiasmata. (3) U-type exchanges present at diplotene result from errors in crossing over. (4) Pairing and chiasma formation are not necessary for coorientation, and (5) at least some types of elastic constrictions present at first metaphase represent extended nucleolar organisers.In memory of the late Stanley G. Smith and his signal contribution to the science of cytogenetics.     

Meiosis in trisomic female mice with Robertsonian translocations. II. Chromosome behaviour at first and second meiotic metaphases

First and second meiotic metaphases (MI and MII, respectively) from female mice of Robertsonian translocation (Rb) stock, trisomic for chromosome 16 (Ts16) or 19 (Ts19), were studied. The mature trisomic oocytes were derived from explanted fetal ovaries that had been cultured and then transplanted so as to mature heterotopically. Multivalent configurations involving the Rb chromosomes and the additional trisomic acrocentric were analysed. Pentavalent configurations occurred in 74.5% of 98 Ts16 MI and 44.2% of 249 Ts19 MI oocytes; quadrivalents (with a univalent acrocentric) were found in 9.2% of Ts16 MI and 10.8% of Ts19 MI oocytes. In 1% of Ts16 MI and 4% of Ts19 MI oocytes, there were two Rb bivalents and a univalent trisomic acrocentric. Rb trivalents and Rb bivalents occurred together in 14.3% of Ts16 MI and 39.4% of Ts19 MI oocytes. Chiasma frequencies were similar in trisomic and chromosomally balanced MI. Chiasma position, distribution, and localization were nearly identical, whether they were found in Rb multivalents or acrocentric bivalents, but one control group (from chromosomally balanced Ts19 littermates) had significantly more terminal chiasmata. Within the triple homologous region of 8% of Rb pentavalents, two chiasmata were observed in the same relative position in the two sister chromatids of one of the three homologs, suggesting a lapse in chiasma position interference. Assortment at MI anaphase was influenced by secondary nondisjunction of the Rb. The ratio of balanced to unbalanced MII oocytes was 1:4 in both trisomies.     

Giemsa C-banding of rye meiotic chromosomes and the nature of “terminal” chiasmata

The pattern of homologous chromosome association at metaphase I of meiosis in rye has been analysed and interpreted by means of the Giemsa C-banding procedure. The rationale for this approach stems from the unexpected coincidence of terminal Giemsa-bands in most chromosome arms and distal chiasma localisation which characterises this species. Analysis of banded metaphase I and anaphase I configurations suggests that meiotic exchanges occur proximal to the terminal Giemsa-bands, that is sub-terminally. The apparently terminal appearance of many chiasmata at metaphase I has been analysed by Giemsa-banding and shown to be more likely to result from bivalent distortion due to contraction and/or stretching (pseudoterminalisation) than from chiasma terminalisation in the accepted sense.     

Metaphase I orientation of chain-forming interchange quadrivalents: a theoretical consideration

The orientation behavior of chain forming interchange quadrivalents at metaphase I was studied in three interchange heterozygotes of pearl millet [Pennisetum americanum (L.) Leeke] which involve chromosomes 1, 3, 6 and 7 in various combinations. Of these, two combinations predominantly produced rings and the third was a chain-forming type. The chain quadrivalents derived from the two ring-forming interchanges, as well as the chain quadrivalent generated by the third interchange, all showed one adjacent orientation at metaphase I (adjacent-1 or -2, depending upon the formation or failure of chiasmata and their positions in the different segments of the pachytene cross). Homologous centromere co-orientation leading to adjacent-1 and alternate-1 occurs following chiasma failure in the noncentric arms of the pachytene cross, and nonhomologous centromere co-orientation leading to adjacent-2 and alternate-2 occurs following chiasma failure in the centric arms of the pachytene cross. Thus, it has been proposed that, unlike in ring quadrivalents, a specific chain quadrivalent will have only homologous or nonhomologous centromere co-orientations at metaphase I.     

An analysis of frequencies of chromosome configurations in wheat and wheat hybrids

Presynaptic association of homologous chromosomes is a prerequisite to the sequence of events that lead to chiasma formation. This association of homologous chromosomes, as entire units, occurs with probability a, and chiasma formation occurs independently in opposite chromosome arms with probability c. a and c have been estimated from frequencies of different chromosome configurations at metaphase I of euhexaploid wheat and several derived lines. In the euploid, a is essentially unity and c is of the order of 95%. All changes in the aneuploidy studied involved c rather than a, whereas the change induced by colchicine application primarily involved a.—Observed and expected frequencies of configurations were compared in wheat hybrids in which only homoeologues were present. The expected frequencies of configurations were estimated from the data, based on a being unity for entire groups of homoeologues and c being the probability of chiasma formation between random homoeologous arms. Observed and expected frequences of configurations were in general agreement; however, an excess of observed closed bivalents at the expense of multivalents is interpreted to mean that not all homoeologues are effectively associated in all cells.—In euhexaploid wheat, we suggest that homologues associate with almost certainty, whereas homoeologous pairs of chromosomes associate less efficiently. The aneuploidy examined in this study does not appear to affect the association of chromosomes, but rather the number of chiasmata that eventuate and, in the case of deficiency of chromosome 5B, the distribution of chiasmata within homoelogues, perhaps by way of rendering sites for chiasma formation of homoelogues more similar.     

Analysis of centromere co-orientation in a rye-wheat derivative by means of C-banding

The orientation of centromeres of rye chromosomes in a rye-wheat derivative involved in bivalent and quadrivalent associations was analyzed using the C-banding technique. It is concluded that i) the four configurations (Adj-I, Adj-II, Alt-I, Alt-II) of the quadrivalent association appear with different frequencies, ii) the number and distribution of chiasmata (expressed as bound arms) affect the quadrivalent configurations, iii) affinity phenomena are not detected since centromeres belonging to different associations not mechanically connected co-orientate independently, being distributed at random to the cell poles. Consequently, the predominance of alternate configurations over the adjacent ones cannot be attributed to centromeric affinity.     

Chromosome pairing and chiasma formation in autopolyploids of different Lathyrus species.

Chromosome pairing and chiasma formation were studied in natural and induced tetraploids (2n = 28) of Lathyrus odoratus (induced), Lathyrus pratensis (natural and induced), Lathyrus sativus (induced), and Lathyrus venosus (natural), as well as in triploids of L. pratensis and diploids of L. odoratus, L. pratensis, and L. sativus. All natural tetraploids appeared to be autotetraploids and their meiotic metaphase I behaviour was very similar to that of the induced autotetraploids, with average numbers of pairing partner switches exceeding 4 or even 5. Multivalent frequencies were high, but the numbers of chiasmata were not much higher than necessary to maintain the configurations. Interstitial chiasmata were common, but not predominant. Fertility was reduced, but sufficient for predominantly vegetatively reproducing species. The triploids of L. pratensis had an even higher multivalent frequency than the tetraploids, but still produced some viable progeny at or close to the tetraploid level, suggesting that in mixed populations of diploids and tetraploids, triploids can contribute to gene flow between the ploidy levels. There was no significant correlation between chiasma frequency and ring bivalent frequency in the diploids and multivalent frequency in the corresponding tetraploids. In the tetraploids, chiasma frequency and multivalent frequency were negatively correlated.     

Inversions of chromosome arms 4AL and 2BS in wheat invert the patterns of chiasma distribution

In many species, including wheat, crossing over is distal, and the proximal regions of chromosome arms contribute little to genetic maps. This was thought to be a consequence of terminal initiation of synapsis favoring distal crossing over. However, in an inverted rye chromosome arm, the pattern of metaphase I chiasmata was also inverted, suggesting that crossover frequencies were specific to chromosome segments. Here, wheat chromosome arms 2BS and 4AL, with essentially entire arms inverted in reverse tandem duplications (rtd), were studied in the MI of meiosis. Inversion–duplication placed the recombining segments in the middle of the arms. While the overall pairing frequencies of the inverted–duplicated arms were considerably reduced relative to normal arms, chiasmata, if present, were always located in the same regions as in structurally normal arms, and relative chiasma frequencies remained the same. The frequencies of fragment or fragment + bridge configurations in AI and AII indicated that of the two tandemly arranged copies of segments in rtds, the more distal inverted segments were more likely to cross over than the segments in their original orientations. These observations show that also in wheat, relative crossover frequencies along chromosome arms are predetermined and independent of the segment location. The segments normally not licensed to cross over do not do so even when placed in seemingly most favorable positions for it.     

SUPERNUMERARY CHROMOSOMES IN TRADESCANTIA II. EFFECT OF COLCHICINE ON MEIOTIC ISOCHROMOSOME CONFIGURATIONS

The effect of colchicine on meiotic pairing and configuration frequencies of three homologous isosupernumerary chromosomes was investigated. In the absence of colchicine, the three isochromosomes displayed a high degree of interchromosomal pairing and chiasma formation. As a consequence, a high frequency of bivalents and trivalents were observed at diakinesis-metaphase I. The unique structure of isochromosomes enables them to pair intrachromosomally (i.e., foldback pairing) yet the preferential occurrence of interchromosomal pairing suggests that all six arms of the three isosupernumerary chromosomes were in close association prior to or upon initiation of synapsis. Supernumerary chromosomes in microsporocytes treated during presynapsis or early synapsis with colchicine exhibited a significant reduction (P < 0.001) in the number of bivalents and trivalents at diakinesis. However, there was no reduction in overall chiasma frequency among supernumeraries due to the induction of increased intrachromosomal pairing and chiasma formation. A colchicine-sensitive association or alignment of homologues preceding effective pairing has been demonstrated in standard chromosomes of a number of plant species. This study provides the first evidence to indicate that at least certain supernumerary chromosomes may display presynaptic association as well. The results also support the strongly held contention that colchicine is not directly preventing or inhibiting the actual formation of chiasmata, since no reduction in chiasma frequency was observed in the isochromosomes.     

The quantitative analysis of chromosome pairing and chiasma formation based on the relative frequencies of M I configurations. II. Primary trisomics

On an earlier occasion the estimation of the “crossing-over potentials” of the two arms of a chromosome from the relative frequencies of the different types of bivalent was discussed. When in normal diploids the bivalents in M I can not be distinguished from each other, primary trisomics may be used to mark particular chromosomes. For the estimation of the “crossingover potentials” of the two arms the only type of configuration available (trivalent) is not sufficient. The required additional information may be obtained from the average probability (b) of the chromosome arms to be bound. Using the satellite chromosome trisomic ofSecale cereale it is shown that the use ofb introduces an excessive error, especially with highb values. Consequently, the primary trisomics can not be recommended for the estimation of the “crossing-over potentials” of the two arms of particular chromosomes. The telocentric trisomics permit the recognition of more configurations and are to be preferred. Partner exchange and nucleolus may both interfere with chiasma formation. The data suggest that the three homologous chromosomes may not be equal in respect to pairing and chiasma formations. There are indications that the initiation of pairing is localized in one locus on each arm.