In vitro studies on transplantation immunity. II. The migration inhibition in homograft reactions in guinea pigs

The migration of peritoneal exudate cells from guinea pigs exhibiting transplantation immunity is inhibited in the presence of donor antigens. This inhibition of migration is demonstrable whether the donor transplantation antigens are presented in the form of viable cells (peritoneal exudate cells) or as particulate subcellular antigens (spleen microsomes). A greater degree of inhibition was observed when transplantation immunity was induced with lymphoid cells in Freud's adjuvant compared to sensitization with orthotopic skin grafts. There was no inhibition of migration in mixtures of normal allogeneic cells or when peritoneal cells from guinea pigs exhibiting tuberculin hypersensitivity were mixed with similar cells from normal animals. Finally, supernatants from cultures of sensitive lymphocytes plus donor antigens inhibited the migration of normal peritoneal cells indicating the presence of migration inhibitory factor (MIF) activity.     

Studies on the mechanism of suppression of delayed hypersensitivity by the antischistosomal compund niridazole.

Niridazole given in a single oral dose of 100 mg/kg to guinea pigs sensitized to ortho-chlorobenzoyl chloride-bovine gamma-globulin (OCB-BGG) regularly abolished delayed cutaneous reactivity. Little effect was observed, however, when cells from these animals were tested in vitro with either direct or indirect assays for migration inhibitory factor (MIF). On the other hand, sera taken from nonsensitized guinea pigs after they had received 100 mg/kg of niridazole markedly diminished antigen-induced inhibition of migration of sensitized peritoneal exudate cells in vitro. The immunosuppressive effects of such sera could not be produced by niridazole itself, thereby suggesting an effect of niridazole metabolites. This suppressive activity was readily removed from the serum by dialysis. The active serum blocked the production of MIF by sensitized lymph node cells but did not affect the action of preformed MIF on macrophages. The effect of this serum was reversible; lymph node cells incubated for 24 hr with active serum, then washed and reincubated with antigen in normal serum, produced normal amounts of MIF. These studies suggest that metabolites of niridazole, but not the parent compound itslef, suppress delayed hypersensitivity in guinea pigs and prevent MIF production by lymphocytes without affecting the macrophage response to MIF.     

Macrophages in resistance to rickettsial infection: susceptibility to lethal effects of Rickettsia akari infection in mouse strains with defective macrophage function

We have confirmed the requirement of macrophages in the antigen-induced T-lymphocyte proliferative response and in the generation of migration inhibition factor (MIF) by immune lymphocytes. Extending these observations, we have found that autologous and non-syngeneic, oil-induced peritoneal exudate macrophages were equally effective in restoring the proliferative response and MIF production by column-purified lymph node T cells. MIF activity was optimally restored when T cells were reconstituted with 1 to 40% exudate-derived macrophages whereas 10 to 30% macrophages were needed to optimally restore the T-cell proliferative response. Normal resident macrophages from the peritoneal cavity were also capable of restoring T-cell reactivity as were normal or BCG-activated pulmonary alveolar macrophages. It was also found that the addition of as few as 1.0% glycogen-elicited peritoneal exudate cells restored the production of MIF by T cells. Quantitative considerations demonstrated that the responsible cells in these preparations were polymorphonuclear cells rather than macrophages. In contrast, neither MIF production nor the proliferative response by T cells were restored by the addition of red blood cells. In these studies we were able to demonstrate that freeze-thawed macrophages could restore antigen-induced MIF production, but not antigen-induced cellular proliferation. The ability of freeze-thawed macrophages to stimulate T cells to produce MIF was apparently associated with the macrophage membranes and not with a soluble factor in the macrophage extracts. These results demonstrate that multiple sources of phagocytic cells may interact cooperatively with lymphocytes in reactions of cell-mediated immunity. Further, at least in the case of MIF production, this interaction involves a membrane-bound determinant that is effective even in the absence of viable macrophages.     

Possible role of macrophage glycolipids as receptors for migration inhibitory factor (MIF).

Guinea pig peritoneal exudate cells incubated with water soluble glycolipids obtained from macrophages show an enhanced response to migration inhibitory factor. Incorporation of these glycolipids into liposomes greatly facilitates their interaction with indicator cells. Enhancement of peritoneal exudate cell responsiveness to migration inhibitory factor was specific for glycolipids from guinea pig macrophages. Glycolipids extracted from guinea pig brain and polymorphonuclear leukocytes as well as several bovine and porcine glycolipids had no effect. Specificity of enhancement was not due merely to a preferential association of macrophage glycolipids with indicator cells. The possible role of macrophage glycolipids as receptors for MIF is discussed.     

Functional activation of immune lymphocytes by antigenic stimulation in cell mediated immunity: I. Requirement for macrophages in antigen-induced MIF production by guinea pig immune lymphocytes in vitro

The role of macrophages in the process of antigen-induced production of mediators in cellular immune response was studied, using the antigen-induced production of migration inhibitory factor (MIF) as a measure of the activation of immune lymphocytes.The production of MIF by guinea pig immune lymph node cells in response to the stimulation with PPD was abolished when the lymph node cells were depleted of adherent cell population by passing the cells through a Tetron fiber column and incubating the effluent cells in plastic dishes. These purified immune lymphocytes did not respond to particle-bound PPD, either. However, the response was obviously restored by the addition of a small number of the purified peritoneal adherent cells (macrophages) which had been pulse-treated with PPD. The PPD-pulsed macrophages produced no MIF by themselves. Thus, the results clearly indicated the requirement for macrophages in the process of antigen-induced MIF production by immune lymphocytes. Destruction of PPD-pulsed macrophages by freezing and thawing or by homogenization abrogated their ability to stimulate immune lymphocytes. Attempts to restore the response of the purified immune lymphocytes to PPD by adding 2-mercaptoethanol or the culture supernatant of macrophages to the medium have so far been unsuccessful.     

Effect of C-reactive protein on peritoneal macrophages. I. Human C-reactive protein inhibits migration of guinea pig peritoneal macrophages

The effect of human C-reactive protein (CRP) isolated and purified from pooled patients' sera on macrophage function, especially on macrophage migration, was studied. Peritoneal exudate cells (PEC) from guinea pigs were used for macrophage migration inhibition (MMI) test of capillary method. Migration of either PEC or adherent purified macrophages exposed to CRP were inhibited dose-dependently. These findings indicate that CRP inhibits macrophage migration directly, not via activation of lymphocytes contained in PEC. As control, we examined the effect of normal human serum, anti C-polysaccharide antibodies isolated from patients' sera, and free endotoxin at the dose contaminated in CRP preparation on macrophage migration and found that none of them were effective. The effect of CRP on MMI of sensitized PEC exposed to antigen was also studied. Large amounts of CRP inhibited MMI induced by antigen, indicating the possibility that CRP may act on macrophages competitively with migration inhibitory factor (MIF) and may modulate MMI. CRP possesses MIF-like activity and may play a functional role at the site of tissue injury by causing the accumulation of macrophages.     

Release of macrophage migration inhibitory factor(s) from lymphocytes stimulated by streptococcal preparations

Lymphocytes from apparently healthy subjects, incubated for 5 hours with cellular components or extracellular products of group A streptococci and then washed and reincubated, were found to release factor(s) capable of inhibiting guinea pig lung macrophage migration (“indirect method”). Inhibitition of macrophage migration was also obtained when the same preparations were tested directly on guinea pig lung cells, a macrophage-lymphocyte population (“direct method”). The guinea pigs had not been experimentally sensitized. The inhibition of migration appeared to depend on the presence of lymphocytes among the macrophages, since macrophages purified by repeatedly discarding nonadherent cells proved resistant to the migration inhibiting activity of the most active Streptococcal preparation, a 20 × concentrated filtrate. Reconstitution of the original lymphocyte-macrophage mixture reestablished the reactivity. The macrophage migration inhibition did not correlate with the age of the guinea pigs. It could not be obtained with preparations of group D streptococci or of Salmonella paratyphi. Group C streptococci did not inhibit the macrophage migration with the indirect method, but it did with the direct one.The factor(s) released into the medium on stimulation of apparently normal lymphocytes by Streptococcal preparations was relatively heat resistant, nondialyzable, and DNase and RNase resistant; its release was inhibited by puromycin. Pretreatment of the cells with trypsin prevented the absorption of the factor(s) and left migration unaffected. These characteristics are similar to those previously described for the migration inhibitory factor (MIF) produced by the interaction of sensitized lymphocytes and specific antigens. Whether or not these similarities indicate an identity remains to be determined.     

In vitro migration of peritoneal and spleen cells and its inhibition in some avion species

Cell migration and its inhibition was tested by the capillary tube technique with peritoneal exudate cells and spleen cells of chicken, turkey, goose, guinea fowl, and Japanese quail. Peritoneal cells were produced by ip administration of proteose peptone and harvested 24 hr later. Liquid paraffin proved to be unsatisfactory for preparation of peritoneal cells in some avian species. Mononuclear cells represented no more than 50–60% of the peritoneal cell populations, the other 50% being polymorphonuclear cells in all five avian species studied. Cell migration was demonstrated with chicken, turkey, and goose peritoneal and spleen cells, but not with those of guinea fowl and Japanese quail. The composition of the cell populations in the migration areas was nearly the same as in the initial preparations of peritoneal and spleen cells. Spleen cell migration was inhibited to a greater extent than that of peritoneal cells. Migration inhibitory factor (MIF) produced by chicken and turkey lymphocytes exhibited some species specificity.     

A migration inhibition-factor assay for tumor immunity in man

A migration inhibition factor (MIF) assay to detect cellular immunity to tumor antigens in man is described. This assay utilizes a 48-hr incubation period of lymphocytes with the tissue homogenate and subsequent assay of the supernate for inhibition of the migration of guinea pig peritoneal macrophages. With this method MIF is not demonstrable in the supernate of lymphocytes cultured with histoincompatible tissue homogenates and the assay can be applied to homologous as well as autologous tumor homogenates. It can thus be used to detect tumor immunity in patients and their healthy relatives or contacts.     

Modulation of granulomatous inflammation in murine schistosomiasis mansoni by enteric exposure to schistosome ova: in vitro characterization of a regulatory mechanism within the granuloma

Enteric immunization with schistosome ova results in a diminished granulomatous response. This study explored a mechanism by which enteric immunization may decrease granuloma size. Granulomas from livers of acutely infected mice were dissociated and the dispersed cells were depleted of macrophages. As defined by a direct in vitro migration inhibition factor (MIF) assay, the macrophage-depleted cells, composed of lymphocytes and eosinophils, inhibited the migration of normal peritoneal exudate cells when exposed to soluble egg antigens. Anti-Thy 1.2 or -Lyt 1.1, but not -Lyt 2.1, treatment of these cells abrogated MIF activity. Next, mice were exposed enterically to eggs 4 weeks prior to sacrifice. Cells from granulomas isolated from these animals demonstrated no MIF activity unless treated with anti-Lyt 2.1. When granuloma cells from enterically immunized mice were mixed with those from unimmunized animals, MIF activity by the latter was abrogated. Treatment of cells from immunized mice with anti-Lyt 2.1 or -Thy 1.2, but not -Lyt 1.1 prior to mixing once again permitted MIF activity. These results suggest that the diminished granulomatous response induced by enteric immunization could be mediated by Lyt 2+ suppressor T cells. These suppressor cells may regulate the MIF activity of Lyt 1+ T lymphocytes residing within these lesions.     

Mastocytoma cell migration in vitro: inhibition by MIF-containing supernatants.

Supernatants with macrophage migration inhibition factor (MIF) activity were obtained from cultures of antigen-stimulated guinea pig and human lymphocytes, and from SV40-infected monkey kidney cells. The monkey and human but not guinea pig preparations were effective in inhibiting migration of mastocytoma cells as well as macrophages. This inhibition of migration was not associated with cytotoxicity and was reversible.     

In vitro studies on transplantation immunity. I. MIF production by sensitive lymphocytes in mice

Sensitized lymphocytes from mice immunized with skin homografts produce migration inhibitory factor upon incubation with lymphocytes (antigen) from the sensitizing strain. The MIF is produced within 14 hr following incubation of sensitized lymphocytes and antigen. In this reaction, antigenic specificity is a prerequisite for MIF production; however, the action of MIF transcends the strain barrier. Also, MIF produced in homograft reactions in mice inhibited the migration of peritoneal cells from normal guinea pigs. Finally, lymphocytes from mice bearing skin homografts do not develop the capacity to produce MIF prior to the rejection of the sensitizing skin grafts.     

The role of immunoglobulin receptors on lymphocytes in production of MIF in guinea pigs

The effect of anti-guinea pig IgG sera and anti-rabbit light kappa chain serum on the capacity of sensitized lymphocytes of guinea pigs to production of migration inhibitor factor (MIF) was investigated. The lymph node cells, thymocytes and circulating lymphocytes taken from dinitrophenyl- (DNP) sensitized guinea pigs were preincubated with antisera against gamma₁ + gamma₂ globulins, gamma₁ globulins, gamma₂ globulin, light kappa chains or normal rabbit serum as control and stimulated with antigen in vitro to production of MIF. The inhibitory effect of lymphocyte culture supernates on the migration of guinea pig normal macrophages was determined by capillary tube test. It was found that all the anti-immunoglobulin sera used suppressed, in varied degree, the release of MIF by sensitized lymphocytes. It is suggested that the suppressive influence of anti-IgG sera reflects their blocking effect on surface receptors specific for antigen.     

Similarities in enhanced glucosamine incorporation by macrophages stimulated with migration inhibitory factor and the fucolectin from Lotus tetragonolobus

Fucose-binding protein (FBP), the fucolectin from Lotus tetragonolobus, was compared with migration inhibitory factor (MIF) for its ability to stimulate [¹⁴C]glucosamine incorporation into trichloroacetic acid (TCA)-insoluble material of guinea pig peritoneal exudate cells (PEC) using a microtiter assay. Both MIF and FBP inhibit macrophage migration and were shown to stimulate glucosamine incorporation in a similar dose response fashion over time. Both unpurified PEC and PEC depleted of nonadherent cells displayed significant levels of glucosamine incorporation when stimulated by MIF or FBP. Tunicamycin and 2-deoxy-d-glucose, known inhibitors of glycosylation, inhibited glucosamine incorporation by control and MIF- or FBP-stimulated PEC. These results confirm the similarities between MIF and FBP in their biological activity for macrophages using a second in vitro correlate of cell-mediated immunity and suggest involvement of enhanced glycoprotein or glycolipid biosynthesis by FBP and lymphokine-activated macrophages.     

Role of lymphokines in regulation of macrophage differentiation

The regulatory mechanism of guinea pig lymphokines was investigated in regard to differentiation of myeloid cells to macrophages. The Ml-cell line, established from a myeloid leukemia of an SL-strain mouse, was induced to differentiate in vitro into mature macrophages possessing Fc receptors and the ability to phagocytize latex particles by treatment with crude lymphokines. Both concanavalin A- and antigen-induced lymphokines showed the differentiation-inducing factor (D factor) activity. However, macrophage migration inhibitory factor/ macrophage activation factor (MIF/MAF) purified by an immunoadsorbent column with anti-MIF antibody had no such an activity. The D-factor activity was detected in the lymphokine preparation that was not retained on the immunoadsorbent column. In contrast, colony-stimulating factor (CSF) was adsorbed to the immunoadsorbent column, and could be recovered in the purified MIF/MAF preparation. These findings suggest that the molecular entity of D factor is distinct from MIF/ MAF and CSF. A culture supernatant of guinea pig peritoneal macrophages activated with MIF/ MAF (CSF) exhibited strong D-factor activity. However, the supernatant possessed rather reduced CSF activity as compared to that of the original MIF/MAF (CSF) preparation. Thus, MIF/MAF may play an important role in macrophage differentiation by regulating the production of D factor or CSF from macrophages.     

Identification and purification of immunosuppressive activity in the urine of rats and a human patient treated with niridazole.

Administration of the antischistosomal compound niridazole to mice, guinea pigs, and humans results in the suppression of several manifestations of cell-mediated immunity. Sera from animals treated with niridazole blocked the in vitro production of migration inhibitory factor (MIF) while niridazole itself was inactive, suggesting that these effects are caused by water soluble mediators. We now report that crude extracts prepared from the urine of rats and a patient receiving nirdazole, but not from pretreatment control urine, similarly suppress antigen-induced inhibition of migration of peritoneal exudate cells from sensitized guinea pigs. With immunosuppressive activity monitored by the direct MIF assay, combined solvent extraction and chromatographic techniques were used to fractionate immunosuppressive activity from the urine of niridazole-treated rats and the patient; the most active fractions, purified about 100-to 1000-fold as compared to methanol-water extracts of dried voided urine, inhibited MIF production at 0.1 to 0.01 ng/ml of assay mixture. These purified fractions also showed immunosuppressive activity by an in vivo assay wherein doses as low as 1 mug/kg injected intravenously (i.v.) into mice suppressed cell-mediated granuloma formation around Schistosoma manisoni eggs. Identically purified fractions prepared from urine of rats and the patient before they received niridazole showed no immunosuppressive activity either in the MIF or in the granuloma assay systems.     

Suppression of lymphokine production: I. Macrophage-mediated inhibition of MIF production

Macrophages have been found to suppress the in vitro production by stimulated T lymphocytes of a lymphokine, migration inhibitory factor. When macrophages isolated from primary MSV-induced tumors were added to antigen-stimulated MSV-immune spleen cells, a complete suppression of MIF production was observed. This suppression was nonspecific, since MIF production by antigen-stimulated alloimmune spleen cells and by PHA-stimulated normal spleen cells was also inhibited. Suppressor macrophages could also be induced by inoculation with Corynebacterium parvum, whereas light mineral oil-induced peritoneal macrophages had no detectable effect on MIF production. The failure to detect MIF in the supernatants of stimulated cultures containing activated macrophages appeared to be due to inhibition of lymphokine production rather than to absorption or inactivation of MIF or to interference with the assay for detection of MIF. Macrophages were able to suppress MIF production only when added during the first 4–5 hr of culture and they had no effect when added later. These data show that activated macrophages can nonspecifically suppress lymphokine production and that this appears to be due to inhibition of an early step in lymphocyte stimulation.     

Activity and Properties of Macrophage Migration Inhibitory Factor produced by Mixed Lymphocyte Cultures

THE macrophage migration test is an in vitro demonstration of delayed hypersensitivity. Supernatant fluids of sensitive lymphocytes cultured for 24 h in the presence of specific antigen contain migration inhibitory factor (MIF) that arrests the migration of macrophages of unsensitized animals in vitro¹,². In vivo, it induces delayed skin reactions³. The use of the macrophage migration test, based on differences of transplantation antigens in donor and recipient, to show histocompatibility has been suggested⁴. The test was also recommended as an indicator of immunological reactivity after organ transplantation, to demonstrate impending rejection⁵. It can demonstrate homograft sensitivity, for migration of peritoneal exudate cells (containing lymphocytes and macrophages) of CBA mice previously sensitized by grafts from A/Jax donors was inhibited when they were mixed with peritoneal exudate cells of the donor strain. However, histocompatibility was not demonstrated, for mixtures of peritoneal exudate cells of ungrafted CBA mice and A/Jax mice migrated regularly during the 24 h test⁶.     

Macrophage Migration Inhibition by Serum from Desensitized Animals Previously Sensitized with Tubercle Bacilli

MIGRATION of peritoneal exudate cells removed from guinea-pigs or mice exhibiting delayed hypersensitivity is inhibited by specific antigen^1–3. This in vitro macrophage migration inhibition has been regarded as a useful immunological test for delayed skin hypersensitivity^4,5. Studies of the mechanism of this phenomenon revealed that, in contact with specific antigen, lymphocytes from sensitized animals released into the medium a specific substance (migration inhibitory factor; MIF) capable of inhibiting the migration of normal macrophages^6,7. When injected intradermally into normal guinea-pigs, MIF elicits inflammatory reactions characterized by induration, erythema and mononuclear cell infiltration⁸.     

Cell surface receptors for lymphokines. I. The possible role of glycolipids as receptors for macrophage migration inhibitory factor (MIF) and macrophage activation factor (MAF).

Incubation of culture supernatants from concanavalin A-stimulated guinea pig and rat lymphocytes with protein-free preparations of bovine brain gangliosides abolished their macrophage migration inhibitory factor (MIF) and macrophage activation factor (MAF) activity. The identity of the MIF/MAF-binding component(s) present in these glycolipid mixtures has yet to be established, but adsorption experiments using purified preparations of mono- (GM₁, GM₂, and GM₃), di- (GD_1a), and trisialogangliosides (GT₁) were negative. Since these gangliosides account for over 90% of the glycolipid content in brain ganglioside mixtures it appears that the MIF-binding component(s) is present only in very small amounts. Treatment of guinea pig peritoneal macrophages with liposomes containing similar brain gangliosides or water-soluble glycolipids extracted from guinea pig macrophages enhanced their responsiveness to MIF. The enhanced response to MIF of liposome-treated macrophages was abolished by incubation of the treated macrophages with fucose-binding lectins (Lotus agglutinin and Ulex europaeus agglutinin I) before exposure to MIF, suggesting that the MIF-binding component donated by the liposomes may be a fucose-containing glycolipid. The possible role of glycolipids as surface receptors for MIF and MAF is discussed.