Stage-related capacity for limb chondrogenesis in cell culture.

Cells from wing buds of varying-stage chick embryos were dissociated and grown in culture to test their capacity for cartilage differentiation. Micro-mass cultures were initiated with a cell layer greater than confluency, which occupied a restricted area of the culture dish surface (10–13 mm²). Cells from stage 24 chick embryo wing buds (prior to the appearance of cartilage in vivo) undergo cartilage differentiation in such cultures. Typically, during the first 1–2 days of culture, cells form aggregates (clusters of cells with a density 1.5 times greater than that of the surrounding nonaggregate area). By Day 3, virtually all aggregates differentiate into cartilage nodules which are easily recognized by their Alcian blue staining (pH 1.0) extracellular matrix. Subsequently, nodules increase in size, and adjacent nodules begin to coalesce. Micro-mass cultures were used to test the chondrogenic capacity of wing bud cells from chick embryos representing the different stages of limb development up to the appearance of cartilage in vivo (stages 17–25). Cells from embryo stages 21–24 form aggregates which differentiate into cartilage nodules in vitro with equal capacity (scored as number of nodules per culture). In contrast, cells from embryo stages 17–19 form aggregates in similar numbers, but these aggregates never differentiate into nodules under routine conditions. However, aggregates which form in cultures of stage 19 wing bud cells do differentiate into cartilage nodules if exposed to dibutyryl cyclic AMP and theophylline. Cells from stage 20 embryos manifest a varying capacity to form cartilage nodules; apparently, this is a transition stage. Cells from stage 25 embryos produce cartilage in vitro without forming either aggregates or nodules. Based on the results presented in this paper, the authors propose a model for cartilage differentiation from embryonic mesoderm cells involving: (1) aggregation, (2) acquisition of the ability to respond to the environment in the aggregate, (3) elevated intracellular cyclic AMP levels, and (4) stabilization and expression of cartilage phenotype.     

Determination of limb bud chondrocytes during a transient block of the cell cycle.

The process of determination is studied by using a cell culture system derived from dissociated chick embryo limb buds. When limb bud cells obtained from embryos younger than stage 25 (undertermined) are temporarily prevented from passing through the cell cycle (either by maintaining the cells on a petri dish or in the presence of high concentrations of cyclic AMP, both of which depress thymidine-H(3) incorporation), some cells subsequently form cartilage colonies. These results support the hypothesis that a temporary block at some stage in the cell cycle causes mesoblasts to acquire the capacity to differentiate into cartilage cells.     

Two distinct regulatory steps in cartilage differentiation

The effect of developmental stage on chondrogenic capacity in high-density cell cultures of chick embryonic wing bud mesenchyme is examined. Mesenchyme from stage 19 embryos forms aggregates of closely associated cells which do not form cartilage matrix, nor contain significant levels of type II collagen that are detectable by immunofluorescence, unless they are treated with dibutyryl cyclic AMP. Mesenchyme from stage 24 embryonic wing buds in high-density cell cultures will spontaneously form cartilage, as defined by electron microscopy and immunofluorescence with antibody to type II collagen. Cultures prepared from stage 26 wings form numerous aggregates which fail to accumulate an Alcian blue-staining matrix and which resemble mesenchyme cells morphologically. However, because these cells show considerable intracellular immunofluorescence for type II collagen, they are actually unexpressed cartilage cells. Several treatments, including exposure to dibutyryl cyclic AMP, ascorbic acid and an atmosphere of 5% oxygen, or mixture with small numbers of stage 24 wing mesenchyme cells, stimulate expression, as determined by the accumulation of an Alcian blue-staining matrix and an ultrastructurally recognizable cartilage matrix. Since the addition of similar numbers of differentiated cartilage cells does not stimulate expression of stage 26 cells, it is proposed that initial cartilage expression is dependent on a mesenchyme-specific influence which might be removed by cell dissociation. These studies demonstrate that there are at least two distinct transitions in cartilage differentiation: one involves the conversion of mesenchyme to unexpressed chondrocytes and the second involves mesenchyme-dependent expression of chondrogenic differentiation.     

In vitro histogenic capacities of limb mesenchyme from various stage mouse embryos

Mesenchyme cells isolated from mouse embryo forelimb buds (stages 15 through 21) and placed in high-density micromass cultures are compared with respect to their in vitro histogenic capacities. Particular emphasis is placed on changes in in vitro chondrogenic capacity. Stage 15 mouse limb cultures form numerous aggregates which uniformly fail to differentiate into cartilage nodules. On the other hand, cartilage nodules are observed in cultures prepared from all subsequent stage limbs, although there is a linear decrease in the size of nodules between stage 16–17 and middle-late stage 21 cultures. This decrease correlates with simultaneous decreases in both the proportion of aggregating cells and the extent of dibutyryl cyclic AMP-stimulated cartilage formation. At the same time, observations indicate that the proportions of nonaggregating and nonchondrogenic mesenchyme, myogenic cells, and, perhaps, fibrogenic mesenchyme are increasing. The only exceptions to these patterns are observed in cultures from middle-late stage 21 limbs, when cartilage differentiation in situ is already extensive. Unlike earlier stage cultures, which form nearly identical numbers of aggregates and nodules, middle-late stage 21 cultures form variable numbers of aggregates, only a few of which differentiate into cartilage nodules. Middle-late stage 21 cultures also contain unexpectedly low numbers of myogenic cells/unit area of culture. Based on changes in the in vitro histogenic capacities, it is concluded that concurrent with a progression of morphogenic events in the limb, there is a progression of changes in the relative proportions of cell subpopulations. Both the existence of the different subpopulations and the changes in their relative proportions can be detected in vitro. Furthermore, it is concluded that cartilage formation in the limbs of both mouse and chick embryos probably occurs according to very similar developmental programs.     

Cyclic AMP derivatives stimulate the chondrogenic differentiation of the mesoderm subjacent to the apical ectodermal ridge of the chick limb bud.

Recent studies indicate that one of the major functions of the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) of the embryonic chick limb bud is to maintain mesenchymal cells directly subjacent to it (i.e., cells extending 0.4-0.5 mm from the AER) in a labile, undifferentiated condition. Furthermore, when mesenchymal cells are freed from the AER's influence, either artifically or as a result of normal polarized proximal-to-distal limb outgrowth, they are freed to commence cytodifferentiation. In a preliminary attempt to investigate at a molecular level the mechanism by which the AER exerts its "negative" effect on the cytodifferentiation of subridge mesenchymal cells, we have examined the effect of a variety of agents that elevate cyclic AMP levels on the chondrogenic differentiation of the unspecialized subridge mesoderm of the limb bud in an organ culture system. Dibutyryl- and 8-hydroxy-cyclic AMP elicit a dose-dependent increase in the rate and amount of cartilage matrix formation and a corresponding dose-dependent increase in sulfated glycosaminoglycan accumulation by subridge mesoderm explants. The stimulatory effect of suboptimal concentrations of cyclic AMP derivatives is potentiated by the addition of theophylline. The stimulatory effect is limited to cyclic AMP derivatives, since dibutyryl-cyclic GMP and 5'-AMP have no effect. Thus agents that elevate intracellular cyclic AMP levels stimulate the chondrogenic differentiation of the unspecialized subridge mesoderm of the embryonic chick limb bud.     

Evidence for histogenic interactions during in vitro limb chondrogenesis

The requirement for homotypic cell interaction was studied by making chimeric micromass cultures containing various proportions of chick and quail limb mesenchyme. Cultures made from limb mesenchyme from embryos of Hamburger and Hamilton stages 23–24 produce large clumps of cartilage cells, identified by the accumulation of an extracellular matrix which stains with alcian blue at pH 1 and by the ability of cells to take up ³⁵SO₄ rapidly, as demonstrated autoradiographically. Dissociated mesenchyme from stage 19 embryos did not produce cartilage in micromass cultures, but only precartilage cell aggregates. Micromass cultures prepared from mixtures of mesenchyme cells obtained from stage 19 and stages 23–24 embryos contained decreasing numbers of cartilage nodules as the proportion of stage 19-derived mesenchyme increased. At the same time the number of aggregates was not affected. When the ratio of stage 19- to stage 24-derived cells was 3:1 or greater, no nodules were detected. The actual number of cells from each stage was verified by using mixtures of quail and chick cells, which are microscopically distinguishable. Additional evidence suggests that the stage 19-derived mesenchyme inhibits chondrogenesis by passively preventing stage 24-derived cells from interacting. The results presented are consistent with the suggestions that (1) homotypic cell interaction plays a role in limb chondrogenesis and (2) the capacity to interact in the required manner is acquired after the embryos have reached stage 19. These phenomena might be involved in the normal histogenesis of cartilage tissue.     

Phorbol esters inhibit chondrogenesis in limb mesenchyme by mechanisms independent of PGE2 or cyclic AMP1

Effects of the phorbol ester 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA) on chondrogenesis and concentrations of prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) and cyclic AMP (cAMP) were investigated in micromass cultures of chick limb mesenchyme derived from the distal tip of stage 25 limb buds. TPA completely inhibited chondrogenesis during the first 4 days of culture; however, a few small cartilage nodules formed by day 6. Relative to control cultures, both PGE2 and cAMP concentrations were altered by TPA treatment during the 6-day period of cell culture. Concentrations of both compounds increased in control cells during the first 24 h of culture and then declined during the remaining 5 days. In TPA-treated cells both PGE2 and cAMP levels increased progressively during the 6 days of days of cell culture, each being elevated at day 6 by twofold over control cells. The results suggest the presence of regulatory pathways important in chondrogenesis which occur independent of those initiated by PGE2 and the cAMP system.     

Accelerated maturation of limb mesenchyme by the BrachypodH mouse mutation

Mesenchyme cell populations prepared from proximal and distal halves of stage 20 mouse forelimb buds are shown to behave under in vitro micromass culture conditions like analogous cell populations obtained from chick embryo limb buds. While the distal cells are spontaneously chondrogenic, the proximal cells make aggregates which are only potentially chondrogenic after treatment with dibutyryl cyclic AMP. In addition, stage 20 mouse whole limb bud cells homozygous for the brachypodismH (bpH) mutation are shown to behave similarly to 'normal' proximal cells. Both make fewer aggregates and nodules and both have faster aggregation rates (determined as the rate of disappearance of single cells over time) in rotation cultures than 'normal' distal or whole limb bud cells. These results support the hypothesis that the bpH mutation specifically decreases the proportion of spontaneously chondrogenic mesenchyme cells (that is, distal-like cells) present at certain developmental stages in the limb bud, resulting in a prematurely high proportion of proximal-like cells.     

Accelerated maturation of limb mesenchyme by the BrachypodH mouse mutation

Abstract. Mesenchyme cell populations prepared from proximal and distal halves of stage 20 mouse forelimb buds are shown to behave under in vitro micromass culture conditions like analogous cell populations obtained from chick embryo limb buds. While the distal cells are spontaneously chondrogenic, the proximal cells make aggregates which are only potentially chondrogenic after treatment with dibutyryl cyclic AMP. In addition, stage 20 mouse whole limb bud cells homozygous for the brachypodism^H ( bp ^H ) mutation are shown to behave similarly to 'normal' proximal cells. Both make fewer aggregates and nodules and both have faster aggregation rates (determined as the rate of disappearance of single cells over time) in rotation cultures than 'normal' distal or whole limb bud cells. These results support the hypothesis that the bp ^H mutation specifically decreases the proportion of spontaneously chondrogenic mesenchyme cells (that is, distal-like cells) present at certain developmental stages in the limb bud, resulting in a prematurely high proportion of proximal-like cells.     

The development of hormonal responses of cultured embryonic chick limb mesenchymal cells

Cells obtained from stage 24 chick limb buds were cultured and assayed for their ability to respond to exogenously supplied parathyroid hormone (PTH) as monitored by analysis of cellular cyclic AMP (cAMP). After 3–4 days in culture, these cells developed a striking responsiveness to the hormone; 20 -to 50-fold elevations in cAMP were routinely observed upon exposure to 10^?8, M hormone for 2 min. This response was greatest in cells initially plated at low densities (1 × 10⁶ cells/35-mm dish) and was inversely correlated to the amount of cartilage which developed in such cultures. Cells obtained from limbs of stages 23–26 embryos developed a similar responsiveness to PTH after 3–4 days in culture, but cells obtained from limbs of stage 22 embryos showed no such responsiveness even after 6 days in culture. A response to calcitonin also was noted in cultures of stage 24 limb mesenchymal cells after 4–5 days in culture, but this was of much smaller magnitude than the PTH response. Of 12 other hormones tested, only β agonists elicited any cAMP response in the cultered stage 24 limb mesenchymal cells. Although cells initially plated at a high density and grown for 8 days in culture show no response to PTH, the presence of PTH-responsive cells in such cultures could be demonstrated by sequential digestion with collagenase and replating the extracellular matrix-free cells released by this treatment. Such replated cells then exhibited a responsiveness to PTH. Thus, the responsiveness of cultured limb mesenchymal cells depends on the developmental stage of the starting limb mesenchyme, the phenotypes which develop, and physical factors such as accessibility to exogenously supplied hormone.     

The patterns on chondrogenesis of cells from facial primordia of chick embryos in micromass culture

Chondrogenesis of mesenchymal cells from the frontonasal mass, mandibles and maxillae of stage-24 chick embryos has been investigated in micromass (high-density) cultures. Distinct differences in the amount and pattern of cartilage differentiation are found. In cultures of frontonasal mass cells, a central sheet of cartilage develops; in cultures of mandible cells, less cartilage differentiates and nodules form; while in cultures of maxillae cells, virtually no chondrogenesis takes place. The same patterns of cartilage are found in cultures established from stage-20 embryos. At stage 28, frontonasal mass cultures form cartilage nodules and the number of nodules in mandible cultures is markedly decreased. There are striking parallels between the chondrogenic patterns of cells from the face and limb buds in micromass culture. The frontonasal mass cell cultures of stage-20 and -24 chick embryos resemble those established from the progress zone of limb buds. The progress zone is an undifferentiated region of the limb in which positional cues operate. Cultures established from the frontonasal mass of stage-28 chick embryos and from the mandibles of all stages resemble cultures of whole limb buds. These contain a mixture of committed and uncommitted cells. Ectoderm from facial primordia locally inhibits chondrogenesis in micromass cultures and this could provide a positional cue. The differences in chondrogenic potential of cells from facial primordia may underlie the specific retinoid effects on the frontonasal mass.     

Synergistic Effects of Adenosine and Compounds Related to Adenosine 3': 5'-cyclic Monophosphate on Dedifferentiating Iris Epithelial Cells in Culture

Addition of adenosine or 5' AMP to the primary culture of newt iris epithelial cells produces an extensive array of fine cytoplasmic processes in a fraction of the cell population. Dibutyryl cyclic AMP, monobutyryl cyclic AMP, cyclic AMP and theophylline have the same effect, but the minimum effective concentrations of the latter four compounds are higher than those of the former two. When the primary cultures are treated simultaneously with two effective compounds at various concentrations a synergis-tic effect is observed between dibutyryl cyclic AMP and theophylline; cyclic AMP and theophylline; adenosine and theophylline; adenosine and cyclic AMP. The results support the interpretation that an increase in cellular level of cyclic AMP, which is produced by exogenous adenosine or 5' AMP as well as by exogenous cyclic AMP, its derivatives or theophylline, is responsible for the formation of radial cytoplasmic processes. The morphogenetic response does not depend on the presence of serum in the culture medium. The possibility is discussed that the cellular level of cyclic AMP is involved as one link of the sequential events which control the dedifferentiation of iris epithelial cells in cell-type conversion.     

Caffeine effects on cyclic AMP levels in the mouse embryonic limb and palate in vitro

Caffeine is a teratogen that causes limb and palate malformations in rodents. Since the ability to raise cyclic nucleotide levels is a known biological action of caffeine, cyclic AMP levels were measured in CD-1 mouse embryonic forelimb from whole embryo culture and embryonic limb and palate cells grown in primary culture following treatment with various concentrations of caffeine (0, 1, 3, or 10 mM). In forelimb buds from whole embryo culture, a dose-dependent response was observed. Caffeine at 1 mM concentration stimulated cyclic AMP levels to 151% of control value at 60 min. Even greater stimulation of cyclic AMP occurred at higher caffeine concentrations. A dose-dependent response was seen in both limb and palate cell culture. In limb cell culture, all caffeine concentrations significantly stimulated cyclic AMP after 10 min compared to control. In palate cell culture, there was a twofold increase in cyclic AMP at the 1-mM caffeine concentration. At higher caffeine concentrations, cyclic AMP was significantly increased after 60 min. In addition, stimulation of cyclic AMP in cultured limb and palate cells by isoproterenol, a beta-adrenergic agonist, was used as a positive control. Isoproterenol stimulated a 2.5-fold greater response in the palate cells than in the limb bud cells at isoproterenol levels of 10(-5) or 10(-4) M. The increase of cyclic AMP may be influential in the process of abnormal limb or palate development.     

Phorbol esters inhibit chondrogenesis in limb mesenchyme by mechanisms independent of PGE2 or cyclic AMP

Effects of the phorbol ester 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA) on chondrogenesis and concentrations of prostaglandin E₂ (PGE₂) and cyclic AMP (cAMP) were investigated in micromass cultures of chick limb mesenchyme derived from the distal tip of stage 25 limb buds. TPA completely inhibited Chondrogenesis during the first 4 days of culture; however, a few small cartilage nodules formed by day 6. Relative to control cultures, both PGE₂ and cAMP concentrations were altered by TPA treatment during the 6-day period of cell culture. Concentrations of both compounds increased in control cells during the first 24 h of culture and then declined during the remaining 5 days. In TPA-treated cells both PGE₂ and cAMP levels increased progressively during the 6 days of cell culture, each being elevated at day 6 by twofold over control cells. The results suggest the presence of regulatory pathways important in Chondrogenesis which occur independent of those initiated by PGE₂ and the cAMP system.     

Dibutyryl cyclic AMP treatment of 3T3 and SV40 virus-transformed 3T3 cells in aggregates. Effects on mobility and cell contact ultrastructure

The random cell movement of BALB/c 3T3 and SV40 virus-transformed BALB/c 3T3 cells within homogeneous aggregates was studied by observing the degree of penetration of newly attached [3H]thymidine-labeled cells into the interior of the aggregates. The 3T3 cells penetrated into 3T3 aggregates an average of 0.89 cell diameter in 1.5 days, whereas the SV40-3T3 cells penetrated into SV40-3T3 aggregates an average of 3.20 cell diameters in the same time. Treatment of the aggregates with theophylline, theophylline plus prostaglandin E1, or theophylline plus dibutyryl cyclic AMP all decreased the penetration of the SV40-3T3 cells into SV40-3T3 aggregates (2.36, 1.22, and 0.79 cell diameters, respectively). The same treatments had little effect on 3T3 aggregates. The ultrastructure of 3T3 and SV40-3T3 cells in aggregates was examined by transmission electron microscopy. The 3T3 cells in aggregates were surrounded by microvilli and lamellipodia which were in contact with neighboring cells, whereas SV40-3T3 cells were nearly devoid of microvilli and lamellipodia and made contact at broader, less regular surface undulations. Treatment with theophylline plus dibutyryl cyclic AMP resulted in the appearance of microvilli on SV40-3T3 cells and also appeared to increase the area of intercellular contacts in both 3T3 and SV40-3T3 cells. These observations were supported for the surface cells of the aggregates by scanning electron microscopy.     

Cyclic AMP calcium and the growth of mastocytoma cells

Arresting P815 mastocytoma cell growth with N6, O2'-dibutyryladenosine 3':5' cyclic monophosphate (db cAMP) and theophylline increased 45Ca2+ uptake and efflux by the cells (i.e, Ca2+ cycling) without altering cytoplasmic free Ca2+ concentrations or the amount or distribution of protein kinase C in the cells. Attempts to identify the Ca2+ channels involved using a wide variety of drugs were unsuccessful. However, the inhibitory effect of db cAMP on growth was greatly increase in medium containing low Ca2+ concentrations, confirming that interactions between Ca2+ and cyclic AMP can affect mastocytoma cell growth.     

Cell sorting and chondrogenic aggregate formation in micromass culture

A fundamental feature of cartilage differentiation in the developing limb is the formation of a prechondrogenic cell condensation. An apparently similar process of prechondrogenic cell aggregation occurs in micromass cultures of limb bud mesenchyme with the formation of cellular aggregates which often differentiate into cartilage nodules. We have investigated the process of aggregate formation in micromass culture using chimaeric mixtures of potentially chondrogenic and nonchondrogenic cell types. Two systems were studied: mixtures of distal and proximal limb mesenchyme cells and mixtures of distal limb cells with avian tendon fibroblasts. In both cases cultures of varying proportions of each cell type have been prepared. The results demonstrate that aggregate formation in vitro is the consequence of a cell sorting process which can involve prechondrogenic cells of widely different spatial origins within the developing limb. This contrasts with in vivo prechondrogenic condensation in which there is no evidence of cell sorting (Searls, R.L. (1967), J. Exp. Zool. 166, 39-50). However, our findings do indicate that cell surface differences occur in apparently undifferentiated limb mesenchyme. The results also suggest that mesenchymal cell aggregates must achieve a threshold size before chondrogenesis can proceed. In addition, the results show that under some culture conditions nonchondrogenic cells will form aggregates.     

Dibutyryl cyclic AMP affects hyaluronate synthesis and macromolecular organization in normal adult articular cartilage in vitro

When normal adult dog articular cartilage was cultured in the presence of dibutyryl cyclic AMP a higher proportion than normal of newly synthesized 35S-labeled glycosaminoglycans was released from the tissue into the culture medium, although their net synthesis was not affected. In conjunction with this release of sulfated glycosaminoglycans, 24 times more [3H]glucosamine-labeled hyaluronic acid was released from the cartilage into the medium, and net hyaluronate synthesis was enhanced 3-fold. Virtually all of the newly synthesized hyaluronic acid in the medium was associated with proteoglycans. The proteoglycans in the medium of the dibutyryl cyclic AMP treated cultures were normal in hydrodynamic size and interacted normally with hyaluronic acid to form large aggregates. These results suggest that the increase in hyaluronate synthesis caused by dibutyryl cyclic AMP mayt have destabilized the interaction of proteoglycans with the collagen meshwork of the cartilage. The changes seen in normal adult articular cartilage after incubation with dibutyryl cyclic AMP, therefore, are similar to those which are observed in cartilage of osteoarthritic joints.     

The effect of growth rate on differentiation of chick embryo limb bud mesenchyme in organ culture

Small explants of limb bud mesenchyme of day chick embryos which form muscle in organ culture synthesize proportionally less protein than DNA than do large explants which form cartilage. Chondrogenesis occurred in the central area of greatest population density in reaggregating limb bud cells, myotubes in areas of lesser density and fibroblasts in the sparsely populated periphery. Small explants grown in microdrops in plastic dishes undergo less cell division and form cartilage, but not muscle. Small explants on lens paper undergo more cell division and form muscle, but not cartilage.     

Prostaglandin biosynthesis and stimulation of cyclic AMP in primary monolayer cultures of epithelial cells from mouse mammary gland.

Cyclic AMP levels in primary monolayer cultures of epithelial cells prepared from mid-pregnant mice are stimulated by prostaglandin E1 and E2. Prostaglandin F1alpha and F2alpha have only a slight effect upon cyclic AMP levels. In the absence of phosphodiesterase inhibitors the rise in cyclic AMP produced by PGE1 is only transient and the levels return to normal within 30 minutes. High concentrations (16 mM) of theophylline are needed to prevent this decline, suggesting that the phosphodiesterase activity of epithelial cells in culture is high. However, theophylline alone produced only a small increase in basal cyclic AMP levels even over a 2-hour period indicating that basal cyclic AMP is turned over more slowly than cyclic AMP produced in response to stimulation with PGE1. Both PGE and PGF synthesis were monitored using radioimmunoassay procedures previously reported. The observed levels were found to decrease as cell density increased and were sensitive to the addition of agents such as collagen and naproxen.