Production of biobutanol from acid-pretreated corncob using Clostridium beijerinckii TISTR 1461: Process optimization studies

Corncob is a potential feedstock in Thailand that can be used for fermentable sugar production through dilute sulfuric acid pretreatment and enzymatic hydrolysis. To recover high amounts of monomeric sugars from corncob, the sulfuric pretreatment conditions were optimized by using response surface methodology with three independent variables: sulfuric acid concentration, temperature, and time. The highest response of total sugars, 48.84 g/L, was found at 122.78°C, 4.65 min, and 2.82% (v/v) H₂SO₄. With these conditions, total sugars from the confirmation experiment were 46.29 g/L, with 5.51% error from the predicted value. The hydrolysate was used as a substrate for acetone–butanol–ethanol fermentation to evaluate its potential for microbial growth. The simultaneous saccharification and fermentation (SSF) showed that C. beijerinckii TISTR 1461 can generate acetone–butanol–ethanol products at 11.64 g/L (5.29 g/L acetone, 6.26 g/L butanol, and 0.09 g/L ethanol) instantly using sugars from the hydrolysed corncob with Novozymes 50013 cellulase enzyme without an overliming process.     

Multicomponent cellulase production by Cellulomonas biazotea NCIM‐2550 and its applications for cellulosic biohydrogen production

Among four cellulolytic microorganisms examined, Cellulomonas biazotea NCIM‐2550 can grow on various cellulosic substrates and produce reducing sugar. The activity of cellulases (endoglucanase, exoglucanase, and cellobiase), xylanase, amylase, and lignin class of enzymes produced by C. biazotea was mainly present extracellularly and the enzyme production was dependent on cellulosic substrates (carboxymethyl cellulose [CMC], sugarcane bagasse [SCB], and xylan) used for growth. Effects of physicochemical conditions on cellulolytic enzyme production were systematically investigated. Using MnCl₂ as a metal additive significantly induces the cellulase enzyme system, resulting in more reducing sugar production. The efficiency of fermentative conversion of the hydrolyzed SCB and xylan into clean H₂ energy was examined with seven H₂‐producing pure bacterial isolates. Only Clostridiumbutyricum CGS5 exhibited efficient H₂ production performance with the hydrolysate of SCB and xylan. The cumulative H₂ production and H₂ yield from using bagasse hydrolysate (initial reducing sugar concentration = 1.545 g/L) were approximately 72.61 mL/L and 2.13 mmol H₂/g reducing sugar (or 1.91 mmol H₂/g cellulose), respectively. Using xylan hydrolysate (initial reducing sugar concentration = 0.345 g/L) as substrate could also attain a cumulative H₂ production and H₂ yield of 87.02 mL/L and 5.03 mmol H₂/g reducing sugar (or 4.01 mmol H₂/g cellulose), respectively. © 2009 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2010     

Performance and microbial community analysis of two-stage process with extreme thermophilic hydrogen and thermophilic methane production from hydrolysate in UASB reactors

The two-stage process for extreme thermophilic hydrogen and thermophilic methane production from wheat straw hydrolysate was investigated in up-flow anaerobic sludge bed (UASB) reactors. Specific hydrogen and methane yields of 89 ml-H₂/g-VS (190 ml-H₂/g-sugars) and 307 ml-CH₄/g-VS, respectively were achieved simultaneously with the overall VS removal efficiency of 81% by operating with total hydraulic retention time (HRT) of 4 days . The energy conversion efficiency was dramatically increased from only 7.5% in the hydrogen stage to 87.5% of the potential energy from hydrolysate, corresponding to total energy of 13.4 kJ/g-VS. Dominant hydrogen-producing bacteria in the H₂-UASB reactor were Thermoanaerobacter wiegelii, Caldanaerobacter subteraneus, and Caloramator fervidus. Meanwhile, the CH₄-UASB reactor was dominated with methanogens of Methanosarcina mazei and Methanothermobacter defluvii. The results from this study suggest the two stage anaerobic process can be effectively used for energy recovery and for stabilization of hydrolysate at anaerobic conditions.     

Effect of reactor configuration on biogas production from wheat straw hydrolysate

The potential of wheat straw hydrolysate for biogas production was investigated in continuous stirred tank reactor (CSTR) and up-flow anaerobic sludge bed (UASB) reactors. The hydrolysate originated as a side stream from a pilot plant pretreating wheat straw hydrothermally (195 °C for 10–12 min) for producing 2nd generation bioethanol [Kaparaju, P., Serrano, M., Thomsen, A.B., Kongjan, P., Angelidaki, I., 2009. Bioethanol, biohydrogen and biogas production from wheat straw in a biorefinery concept. Bioresource Technology 100 (9), 2562–2568]. Results from batch assays showed that hydrolysate had a methane potential of 384 ml/g-volatile solids (VS)_added. Process performance in CTSR and UASB reactors was investigated by varying hydrolysate concentration and/or organic loading rate (OLR). In CSTR, methane yields increased with increase in hydrolysate concentration and maximum yield of 297 ml/g-COD was obtained at an OLR of 1.9 g-COD/l d and 100% (v/v) hydrolysate. On the other hand, process performance and methane yields in UASB were affected by OLR and/or substrate concentration. Maximum methane yields of 267 ml/g-COD (COD removal of 72%) was obtained in UASB reactor when operated at an OLR of 2.8 g-COD/l d but with only 10% (v/v) hydrolysate. However, co-digestion of hydrolysate with pig manure (1:3 v/v ratio) improved the process performance and resulted in methane yield of 219 ml/g-COD (COD removal of 72%). Thus, anaerobic digestion of hydrolysate for biogas production was feasible in both CSTR and UASB reactor types. However, biogas process was affected by the reactor type and operating conditions.     

Simultaneous use of sodium nitrate and urea as nitrogen sources improves biomass composition of Arthrospira platensis cultivated in a tubular photobioreactor

Arthrospira platensis is widely cultivated in open ponds for industrial purposes. However, high‐protein A. platensis biomass produced in photobioreactors (PBRs) is recommended for pharmaceutical and cosmetic formulations. A. platensis was cultivated in a 3.5 L tubular airlift PBR using both sodium nitrate and urea as nitrogen sources. Sodium nitrate was added from the start of the cultivation using a batch process. Urea was supplied daily at exponentially increasing feeding rate using a fed‐batch process. The simultaneous optimization of the independent variables, namely, total quantity of sodium nitrate (m_T1) and total quantity of urea (m_T2), led to an optimal condition of m_T1 = 15.0 mmol/L and m_T2 = 7.5 mmol/L. Maximum biomass concentration (5183 ± 94 mg/L) corresponding to the highest biomass productivity (683 ± 13 mg/L/day) was obtained under such condition. The addition protocol of both nitrogen sources resulted in high productivities of protein (6.2 ± 0.4 mg/L/day) as well as chlorophyll‐a (372.2 ± 7.7 mg/L/day). Such innovative process could be applied in the large‐scale production of A. platensis using tubular PBR for novel applications.     

Influence of initial cellulose concentration on the carbon flow distribution during batch fermentation by Clostridium thermocellum ATCC 27405

The objective of this research was to understand how carbon loading influences hydrogen (H₂) synthesis and metabolic flow patterns in the thermophilic, cellulolytic bacterium, Clostridium thermocellum. C. thermocellum was cultivated in batch cultures with high (5 g L⁻¹) and low (1 g L⁻¹) initial concentrations of α-cellulose at 60°C. The growth rate of C. thermocellum was 22% lower (0.15 h⁻¹) in cultures with low-cellulose concentration compared with cultures with high-cellulose concentrations. Although substrate depletion coincided with the end of log-growth in low-cellulose cultures, the prime reason for growth arrest in high-cellulose cultures was not identified. Ethanol, acetate, and formate were the major soluble end-products with concomitant release of H₂ and CO₂ under both conditions. Lactate appeared during the late log phase in high-carbon cultures when pH dropped below 6.4 and became the major end-product in stationary phase. During the exponential phase of cell growth, significantly higher yields for H₂ and acetate (1.90 ± 0.14 and 1.11 ± 0.04 mol/mol glucose equivalent, respectively) were obtained from low-cellulose cultures compared to those from high-cellulose cultures. The maximum specific rate of H₂ production, 6.41 ± 0.13 mmol H₂/g dry cell/h, obtained during the exponential phase from low-carbon cultures was about 37% higher than that obtained from high-carbon cultures.     

Use of sulfate reducing cell suspension bioreactors for the treatment of SO2 rich flue gases

This paper describes a novel bioscrubber concept for biological flue gas desulfurization, based on the recycling of a cell suspension of sulfite/sulfate reducing bacteria between a scrubber and a sulfite/sulfate reducing hydrogen fed bioreactor. Hydrogen metabolism in sulfite/sulfate reducing cell suspensions was investigated using batch activity tests and by operating a completely stirred tank reactor (CSTR). The maximum specific hydrogenotrophic sulfite/sulfate reduction rate increased with 10% and 300%, respectively, by crushing granular inoculum sludge and by cultivation of this sludge as cell suspension in a CSTR. Operation of a sulfite fed CSTR (hydraulic retention time 4 days; pH 7.0; sulfite loading rate 0.5–1.5 g SO ₃ ^2- l^-1 d^-1) with hydrogen as electron donor showed that high (up to 1.6 g l^-1) H₂S concentrations can be obtained within 10 days of operation. H₂S inhibition, however, limited the sulfite reducing capacity of the CSTR. Methane production by the cell suspension disappeared within 20 days reactor operation. The outcompetition of methanogens in excess of H₂ can be attributed to CO₂ limitation and/or to sulfite or sulfide toxicity. The use of cell suspensions opens perspectives for monolith or packed bed reactor configurations, which have a much lower pressure drop compared to air lift reactors, to supply H₂ to sulfite/sulfate reducing bioreactors.     

Start‐up of Anaerobic Hydrogen Producing Reactors Seeded with Sewage Sludge

The procedure for starting‐up continuously stirred tank reactors (CSTR) for acclimating anaerobic hydrogen‐producing microorganisms with sewage sludge was investigated. Initially, feeding with glucose and sucrose as well as mixing were carried out in semicontinuous mode; hydraulic retention time (HRT) was in an order of 20, 15, 10, 5, 2.5 and 2 days. When the pH declined to its lowest value (pH 5.18), it was adjusted to 6.7 using sodium hydroxide (1 N). At the same time, the semi‐continuous operation was changed to a continuous one. Finally, the pH was continuously regulated at approximately 6.7. The results indicate that this procedure can be used to cultivate seed sludge for hydrogen production from sewage sludge resulting in a large hydrogen production in less than 60 days. When the substrate was glucose, a hydrogen yield of 1.63 mol H₂/mol glucose and a specific hydrogen production rate of 321 mmol H₂/g VSS day at an HRT of 13.3 h was achieved. When the substrate was sucrose with the same HTR, a hydrogen yield of 4.45 mol H2/mol sucrose and a specific hydrogen production rate of 707 mmol H₂/g VSS day was obtained.     

Bioconversion of waste office paper to hydrogen using pretreated rumen fluid inoculum

In this study, a microbial consortium from an acid-treated rumen fluid was used to improve the yields of H₂ production from paper residues in batch reactors. The anaerobic batch reactors, which contained paper and cellulose, were operated under three conditions: (1) 0.5 g paper/L, (2) 2 g paper/L, and (3) 4 g paper/L. Cellulase was added to promote the hydrolysis of paper to soluble sugars. The H₂ yields were 5.51, 4.65, and 3.96 mmol H₂/g COD, respectively, with substrate degradation ranging from 56 to 65.4 %. Butyric acid was the primary soluble metabolite in the three reactors, but pronounced solventogenesis was detected in the reactors incubated with increased paper concentrations (2.0 and 4.0 g/L). A substantial prevalence of Clostridium acetobutylicum (99 % similarity) was observed in the acid-treated rumen fluid, which has been recognized as an efficient H₂-producing strain in addition to ethanol and n-butanol which were also detected in the reactors.     

Degradation of starchy substrates by a crude enzyme preparation and utilization of the hydrolysates for lactic fermentation

An enzyme preparation obtained from Aspergillus ustus, possessing cellulase, α-amylase, amyloglucosidase, proteinase and d-xylanase activities, was used along with commercial bacterial α-amylase and amyloglucosidase for the degradation of ragi (Eleusine coracana) flour and wheat (Triticum vulgare) bran. Lactic acid yield from ragi hydrolysate, adjusted to 5% reducing sugars (w/v), was 25% when fermented with Lactobacillus plantarum. The yields increased to 78% and 94% when the ragi hydrolysate was fortified with 20% and 60% (v/v) wheat bran hydrolysate, respectively. When commercial α-amylase and amyloglucosidase were used for the hydrolysis of ragi and wheat bran and L. plantarum was employed to ferment the hydrolysates containing 5% reducing sugars (w/v), lactic acid yields were 10% in ragi hydrolysate and 57% and 90% when the ragi hydrolysate was fortified with 20% and 60% (v/v) of wheat bran hydrolysate, respectively. α-Amylase and amyloglucosidase hydrolysed wheat bran added at 20% (v/v) as the sole source of nutrient to soluble starch hydrolysate (5% reducing sugars) gave 22% yield of lactic acid. The yield increased to 55% by the utilization of A. ustus enzyme preparation in addition to α-amylase and amyloglucosidase for wheat bran hydrolysis.     

Batch and multistage continuous ethanol fermentation of cellulose hydrolysate and optimum design of fermentor by graphical analysis

Batch and single-flow four-stage continuous ethanol fermentations of bagasse hydrolysate have been investigated at pH 4.0 and 30°C with a strain of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The studies were carried out in the laboratory four-stage cascade continuous stirred-tank fermentors at varying feed glucose concentrations (10, 14, 18, and 22%). The range of dilution rates employed varied from 0.05 to 0.2 hr^?1. The hydrolysate was supplemented with a cheap nitrogen source (CNS), CaCl₂·H₂O and MgSO₄·7H₂O. A 2% (v/v) CNS concentration was found to be sufficient to avoid growth limitation at a glucose concentration of 116 g/liter. The conditions of continuous culture in a multistage system are predicted by a graphical method based on batch-culture data. The results thus obtained are compared with those predicted by kinetic models and with the experimental results. The variations between the results obtained experimentally and those computed either by a kinetic model or by graphical analyses were found to be within the limits of experimental error. The solutions based on the concept of minimum residence time necessary to achieve the desired biomass or product concentrations are also discussed.     

Comparative study of the effect of ultrasonication on the anaerobic biodegradability of food waste in single and two-stage systems

Five different mesophilic systems were evaluated in this study for the anaerobic treatment of food waste. Systems A and B were one stage methane with unsonicated and sonicated feeds, respectively, while, systems C and D were two-stage hydrogen and methane with unsonicated and sonicated feeds, respectively. System E comprised a novel sonicated biological hydrogen reactor (SBHR) followed by methane reactor. The results showed that sonication inside the reactor in the first stage (system E) showed superior results compared to all other systems. Overall VSS removal efficiencies of 67%, 59%, 51%, 44%, and 36% were achieved in systems E, D, C, B, and A, respectively. Volumetric hydrogen production rates of 4.8, 3.3, and 2.6 L H₂/L_reactor d were achieved in the SBHR, CSTR with and without sonicated feed, respectively, while, methane production rates of 1.6, 2.1, 2.3, 2.6, and 3.2 L CH₄/L_reactor d were achieved in systems A-E, respectively.     

Upgrading of straw hydrolysate for production of hydrogen and phenols in a microbial electrolysis cell (MEC)

In a microbial electrolysis cell (MEC), hydrolysate produced by hydrothermal treatment of wheat straw was used for hydrogen production during selective recovery of phenols. The average H₂ production rate was 0.61 m³ H₂/m³ MEC·day and equivalent to a rate of 0.40 kg COD/m³ MEC·day. The microbial community in the anode biofilm was adapted by establishment of xylose-degrading bacteria of the Bacteriodetes phylum (16%) and Geobacter sulfurreducens (49%). During the process, 61% of the chemical oxygen demand was removed as hydrogen at 64% yield. The total energy production yield was 78% considering the energy content in the consumed compounds and the cell voltage of 0.7 V. The highest hydrogen production was equivalent to 0.8 kg COD/m³ MEC·day and was obtained at pH 7–8 and 25°C. Accumulation of 53% w/v phenolic compounds in the liquor was obtained by stepwise addition of the hydrolysate during simultaneous production of hydrogen from consumption of 95% for the hemicellulose and 100% of the fatty acids. Final calculations showed that hydrolysate produced from 1 kg wheat straw was upgraded by means of the MEC to 22 g hydrogen (266 L), 8 g xylan, and 9 g polyphenolics for potential utilization in biobased materials.     

Heterologous expression and characterization of a proxidomal ascorbate peroxidase from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Populus tomentosa</Emphasis>

The present study reported for the first time, cloning, expression and characteristics of a Proxidomal APX gene (PpAPX) from Populus tomentosa. The PpAPX gene encodes a protein of 287 amino acid residues with a calculated molecular mass of 31.58 kDa. The over-expressed recombinant PpAPX protein showed high activity towards the substrates ascorbate aicd (ASA) and H₂O₂. At fixed ASA concentrations, the K _m and V _max values were 0.12 ± 0.01 mM and 23.4 ± 4.2 mmol/min mg for H₂O₂. And at fixed H₂O₂ concentrations, the K _m and V _max values were 0.53 ± 0.04 mM and 20.0 ± 2.3 mmol/min mg for ASA.     

Utilization of agricultural residues for poly(3-hydroxybutyrate) production by Halomonas boliviensis LC1

Aims: Utilization of cheap and readily available agricultural residues as cheap carbon sources for poly(3‐hydroxybutyrate) (PHB) production by Halomonas boliviensis. Methods and Results: Wheat bran was hydrolysed by a crude enzyme preparation from Aspergillus oryzae NM1 to provide a mixture of reducing sugars composed mainly of glucose, mannose, xylose and arabinose. Growth of H. boliviensis using a mixture of glucose (0·75% w/v) and xylose (0·25% w/v) in the medium led to a PHB content and concentration of 45 wt% and 1 g l^?1, respectively, after 30 h. A similar PHB concentration was attained when H. boliviensis was grown on wheat bran hydrolysate but with a lower PHB content, 34 wt%. In a batch cultivation mode in a fermentor, using 1·8% (w/v) reducing sugars, the maximum PHB accumulation by H. boliviensis was attained in 20 h, but was reduced to about 30 wt%. By adding butyric acid (0·8% v/v), sodium acetate (0·8% w/v) and decreasing the reducing sugars concentration to 1·0% w/v in the medium, PHB accumulation and concentration were increased to 50 wt% and 4 g l^?1, respectively, after 20 h. Butyric acid and sodium acetate for PHB production could also be provided by anaerobic digestion of solid potato waste. Conclusions: Cheap and readily available agricultural residues can be used as substrates to produce PHB. The production of PHB by H. boliviensis using wheat bran hydrolysate as source of carbon is expected to reduce the production cost and motivates further studies. Significance and Impact of the Study: Large‐scale commercial utilization of PHB is mainly hampered by its high production cost. Carbon source for PHB production accounts up to 50% of the total production costs. Thus, the use of waste agricultural residues can substantially reduce the substrate cost (and in turn even provide value to the waste), and can downsize the production costs. This improves the market competitiveness. Studies on PHB production by moderate halophiles were recently initiated with H. boliviensis and findings show that it has potential for commercial exploitation. PHB production by H. boliviensis using wheat bran and potato waste is hence interesting.     

Kinetic modeling of light limitation and sulfur deprivation effects in the induction of hydrogen production with Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Part II: Definition of model‐based protocols and experimental validation

Photosynthetic hydrogen production under light by the green microalga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii was investigated in a torus‐shaped PBR in sulfur‐deprived conditions. Culture conditions, represented by the dry biomass concentration of the inoculum, sulfate concentration, and incident photon flux density (PFD), were optimized based on a previously published model (Fouchard et al., 2009. Biotechnol Bioeng 102:232–245). This allowed a strictly autotrophic production, whereas the sulfur‐deprived protocol is usually applied in photoheterotrophic conditions. Experimental results combined with additional information from kinetic simulations emphasize effects of sulfur deprivation and light attenuation in the PBR in inducing anoxia and hydrogen production. A broad range of PFD was tested (up to 500 µmol photons m⁻² s⁻¹). Maximum hydrogen productivities were 1.0 ± 0.2 mL H₂/h/L (or 25 ± 5 mL H₂/m² h) and 3.1 mL ± 0.4 H₂/h L (or 77.5 ± 10 mL H₂/m² h), at 110 and 500 µmol photons m⁻² s⁻¹, respectively. These values approached a maximum specific productivity of approximately 1.9 mL ± 0.4 H₂/h/g of biomass dry weight, clearly indicative of a limitation in cell capacity to produce hydrogen. The efficiency of the process and further optimizations are discussed. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2011;108: 2288–2299. © 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Progress toward a biomimetic leaf: 4,000 h of hydrogen production by coating‐stabilized nongrowing photosynthetic Rhodopseudomonas palustris

Intact cells are the most stable form of nature's photosynthetic machinery. Coating‐immobilized microbes have the potential to revolutionize the design of photoabsorbers for conversion of sunlight into fuels. Multi‐layer adhesive polymer coatings could spatially combine photoreactive bacteria and algae (complementary biological irradiance spectra) creating high surface area, thin, flexible structures optimized for light trapping, and production of hydrogen (H₂) from water, lignin, pollutants, or waste organics. We report a model coating system which produced 2.08 ± 0.01 mmol H₂ m^?2 h^?1 for 4,000 h with nongrowing Rhodopseudomonas palustris, a purple nonsulfur photosynthetic bacterium. This adhesive, flexible, nanoporous Rps. palustris latex coating produced 8.24 ± 0.03 mol H₂ m^?2 in an argon atmosphere when supplied with acetate and light. A simple low‐pressure hydrogen production and trapping system was tested using a 100 cm² coating. Rps. palustris CGA009 was combined in a bilayer coating with a carotenoid‐less mutant of Rps. palustris (CrtI^?) deficient in peripheral light harvesting (LH2) function. Cryogenic field emission gun scanning electron microscopy (cryo‐FEG‐SEM) and high‐pressure freezing were used to visualize the microstructure of hydrated coatings. A light interaction and reactivity model was evaluated to predict optimal coating thickness for light absorption using the Kubelka‐Munk theory (KMT) of reflectance and absorptance. A two‐flux model predicted light saturation thickness with good agreement to observed H₂ evolution rate. A combined materials and modeling approach could be used for guiding cellular engineering of light trapping and reactivity to enhance overall photosynthetic efficiency per meter square of sunlight incident on photocatalysts. © 2010 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2010     

Assessment of DNA damage in sperm after repeated non‐invasive sampling in zebrafish Danio rerio

Repeated non‐invasive sampling of zebrafish Danio rerio sperm was conducted, sperm counts were obtained and a method for measurement of DNA damage in sperm was developed and validated (single‐cell gel electrophoresis, comet, assay). DNA damage in sperm increased with concentration of hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂, 0–200 µM), and in vitro exposure of sperm to 200 µM H₂O₂ produced 88·7 ± 3·9% tail DNA compared to unexposed controls [12 ± 0·7% tail DNA (mean ± s.e ., n = 3)]. Frequency of sperm sampling (sampled every 2, 4 or 7 days) did not affect DNA damage in sperm, but sperm counts decreased 57 and 22% for fish sampled every 2 or 4 days, respectively.     

Improving the performance of bioelectrochemical sulfate removal by applying flow mode

Treatment of wastewater contaminated with high sulfate concentrations is an environmental imperative lacking a sustainable and environmental friendly technological solution. Microbial electrochemical technology (MET) represents a promising approach for sulfate reduction. In MET, a cathode is introduced as inexhaustible electron source for promoting sulfate reduction via direct or mediated electron transfer. So far, this is mainly studied in batch mode representing straightforward and easy-to-use systems, but their practical implementation seems unlikely, as treatment capacities are limited. Here, we investigated bioelectrochemical sulfate reduction in flow mode and achieved removal efficiencies (E_sulfate, 89.2 ± 0.4%) being comparable to batch experiments, while sulfate removal rates (R_sulfate, 3.1 ± 0.2 mmol L⁻¹) and Coulombic efficiencies (CE, 85.2 ± 17.7%) were significantly increased. Different temperatures and hydraulic retention times (HRT) were applied and the best performance was achieved at HRT 3.5 days and 30°C. Microbial community analysis based on amplicon sequencing demonstrated that sulfate reduction was mainly performed by prokaryotes belonging to the genera Desulfomicrobium, Desulfovibrio, and Desulfococcus, indicating that hydrogenotrophic and heterotrophic sulfate reduction occurred by utilizing cathodically produced H₂ or acetate produced by homoacetogens (Acetobacterium). The advantage of flow operation for bioelectrochemical sulfate reduction is likely based on higher absolute biomass, stable pH, and selection of sulfate reducers with a higher sulfide tolerance, and improved ratio between sulfate-reducing prokaryotes and homoacetogens.