Development of Seed Immunoblot Binding Assay for Detection of Karnal bunt (Tilletia indica) of Wheat

Polyclonal antisera were produced in albino white rabbits against intact teliospores of Karnal bunt (Tilletia indica). The Immunoprobe generated was used for the development of Immunoblot binding assay for detecting Karnal bunt (KB) infections in wheat seed samples. The antiserum reacted strongly with intact teliospores of T. indica, Pantnagar isolate in agglutination reaction. Wheat grains with different grades of infection could be readily detected by Seed Immunoblot Binding Assay (SIBA). Karnal bunt infected wheat seeds when kept for vigour testing on nitrocellulose paper, formed a coloured imprint after the paper was immunoprocessed. The SIBA would not only be a better Indication of teliospores load on seed but also quality of seed in terms of vigour. This method is expected to be useful in routine monitoring of wheat lots for the presence of KB teliospores.     

Towards Molecular Tagging of Karnal Bunt Resistance Gene(s) in Wheat

We describe preliminary results of cosegregation of a DNA probe with Karnal bunt resistance genets) in wheat. The tagging strategy utilized 4 uniformly resistant and 13 uniformly susceptible F³ families from a cross of Karnal bunt resistant (HD29) and susceptible (WL711) lines of Triticum aestivum. Bulked DNA of 8–10 plants in each family were tested by gel blot DNA hybridization. Thirty three per cent of the probes (11/33) detected restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) between Karnal bunt resistant and susceptible lines. Probe Cxp1 from chromosome group 6 detected the resistant parent (HD29) polymorphic band in all the resistant family bulks but was missing in 6 uniformly susceptible family bulks. A similar pattern was observed with probe XKsu G34 from 1DL. The intensity of the resistant parent band in the susceptible family bulks was less as compared to the resistant family bulks. Probe Xksu H8 which mapped on chromosomes 2, 3, 5 and 7D on the T. tauschii map did not differentiate resistant family bulks from susceptible family bulks. Our results indicated that one or more resistance genets) are located on chromosome groups 1 and 6 of wheat.     

Mapping of a resistance gene effective against Karnal bunt pathogen of wheat

A set of 130 wheat recombinant inbred lines (RILs) developed from a cross between parents susceptible (WL711) and resistant (HD29) to Karnal bunt (caused by Tilletia indica), were screened for 3 years with the pathogen populations prevalent in northern India. When 90 simple sequence repeats (SSRs) and 81 amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) loci were mapped on the RILs, markers on chromosomes 2A, 4B and 7B accounted collectively for about one-third of the variation in the disease reaction. The genomic region of largest effect, identified on the long arm of chromosome 4B, reduced Karnal bunt disease by half in three different experiments and accounted for up to 25% of the phenotypic variation for KB reaction. A closely linked SSR marker, GWM538, may be useful in marker-assisted selection for Karnal bunt resistance in wheat.     

Intraspecific genetic variability analysis of Neovossia indica causing Karnal bunt of wheat using repetitive elements

Neovossia indica (Tilletia indica), causing Karnal bunt of wheat, affects major wheat growing regions all over the world. Karnal bunt ranks as one of the major diseases of wheat causing quality losses and monetary losses due to international quarantine regulations. The present work is the first report of a genetic diversity analysis of Indian isolates of N. indica. A library of N. indica isolate Ni7 was constructed in a λZAPII system, and three repetitive elements were identified for molecular analysis. These repetitive elements generated complex hybridization profiles producing fingerprint patterns of all seven isolates. Copy-number estimation of these three elements, pNiR9, pNiR12 and pNiR16, indicated the presence of 32, 61 and 64 copies, respectively. Cluster analysis based on hybridization patterns grouped together moderately virulent isolates Ni1, Ni7 and Ni8, thus suggesting a positive correlation between virulence typing and cluster analysis based on molecular data. Variability analysis of N. indica isolates will aid in checking new resistant sources in host germplasm. Received: 20 April 1999 / Accepted: 29 July 1999     

Determination of genetic and pathological variance among Tilletia indica isolates and monosporidial lines using PCR based markers and host differentials

Karnal bunt of wheat caused by Tilletia indica is an important international quarantine disease in many countries. In this investigation, genetic and pathological variation among the 10 isolates and 15 monosporidial (Ms) lines belonged to different locations of North-West India was studied. Depending upon the pathogenic potential, most virulent and least aggressive isolate was found from Chaksu (Rajasthan) and Tarau (HP), which scored coefficients of infection 70.98 and 6.22, respectively, on susceptible host genotype HD 2009 under artificially inoculated conditions. Fifteen Ms lines were inoculated in 20 combinations. Most virulent compatible combination was found KB2MsD?×?KB6MsA, which scored co-efficient of infection 74.91%. Out of 32 Inter Simple Sequence Repeats based molecular markers, 28 were polymorphic generating 192 reproducible bands for all the T. indica isolates and Ms lines in this study. A grouping analysis using the unrooted neighbour – joining method was consistent with DARwin software and winboot analysis and combination approach suggested that self-paired Ms lines exhibit narrow genetic diversity. This result will be useful for developing integrated strategies for disease management and breeding programmes for improvement of the varieties.     

A molecular protocol using quenched FRET probes for the quarantine surveillance of Tilletia indica, the causal agent of Karnal bunt of wheat

The current surveillance protocol for Karnal bunt of wheat in most countries, including the USA, European Union (EU), and Australia, involves the tentative identification of the spores based on morphology followed by a molecular analysis. Germination of spores is required for confirmation which incurs a delay of about two weeks, which is highly unsatisfactory in a quarantine situation. A two-step PCR protocol using FRET probes for the direct detection and identification of Tilletia indica from a very few number of spores (≤10) is presented. The protocol involves amplification of the ITS1 DNA segment in the highly repeated rDNA unit from any Tilletia species, followed by FRET analysis to detect and unequivocably distinguish T. indica and the closely related T. walkeri. This rapid, highly sensitive, fluorescent molecular tool is species-specific, and could supersede the conventional microscopic diagnosis used in a quarantine surveillance protocol for Karnal bunt which is often confounded by overlapping morphological characters of closely related species.     

Isolation and in-silico characterization of Peroxidase isoenzymes from Wheat (Triticum aestivum) against Karnal Bunt (Tilletia indica)

To investigate the role of Peroxidase and its physiological significance under Karnal Bunt (KB) were determined in resistant (HD-29) and susceptible genotype (WH-542) of wheat during different developmental stages. The enzymes were expressed constitutively in both the susceptible and resistant genotype. In gel assay and differential expression analysis of POD was significantly higher (p >0.05) in Sv and S2, than the S1 and S3 stages. in silico analysis of Peroxidase for eg. physico-chemical properties, secondary structural features and phylogenetic classification for comparative analysis. Motif and Domain analysis of Peroxidase by MEME, to be important for the biological functions, and studies of evolution. Our results clearly indicate that the enhanced expression of POD at the WS2 stage, which reinforces its role in stage dependent immunity against Karnal bunt and role of POD metabolism provides genotype and stage dependant structural barrier resistance in wheat against KB.     

Introgression of diverse genes for resistance to rusts into an improved wheat variety, Kalyansona

Breeding for resistance to the three rusts of wheat usually requires incorporation of genetically independent factors conferring resistance to each rust. Linked resistance genes in some alien translocation stocks permit concurrent transference of resistance for more than one rust. Alien derived resistances, however, are often reported to be associated with reduced yield and other undesirable characters. In our experience, backcross breeding when given a limited number of backcrosses (3–6) and with suitable selection procedures has resulted in lines giving yields higher or comparable to the recurrent wheat parent Kalyansona and resistance to one, two or all three rusts without any adverse effects. Some of the rust resistant derivatives also show resistance to Neovossia indica (Karnal bunt). The derivatives thus developed when used as parents in a breeding programme have produced several improved cultivars with high yields, superior grains and diversity for resistance to rust pathogens. One of the cultivars, named Vaishali (DL784-3), has been officially released for cultivation in the country.     

Determination of variability in monosporidial lines of Tilletia indica by RAPD analysis

Genetic variability in 23 monosporidial lines developed from five isolates of Tilletia indica causing Karnal bunt of wheat isolated from four wheat growing states of India was determined by using 19 rapid amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers. Amplification profile generated with all the 19 primers produced 3–16 numbers of bands of 1.5–5 kb size. High level of polymorphism (95.2%) suggested wide range of variability. Maximum Jaccard's similarity coefficient (80%) was observed between KB2MsB and KB2MsC followed by KB5MsC and KB5MsE with 75% similarity, whereas it was minimum between KB3MsA and Kb4MsB (47%). The dendrogram derived from the fingerprint analysis with 19 RAPD primers by using UPGMA showed different levels of genetic similarity among monosporidial lines. At 35% genetic similarity, the monosporidial lines were grouped in two clusters. Some primers, viz., OPN-1, OPN-6, OPN-9, OPN-12, OPN-13, OPN-18, OPM-2, OPM-8, OPM-10, OPB-8, OPB-17 and OPB-20 showed 100% polymorphism. The RAPD fingerprint generated by OPN-1 and OPM-3 were analysed and showed high range of variation in genetic make-up of monosporidial lines.     

Genealogic analysis of the resistance of winter wheat to common bunt

Comparative genealogical analysis of North American (the United States and Canada) and Eastern European (Russia and Ukraine) winter wheat cultivars resistant and susceptible to common bunt has been performed. Analysis of variance applied to North American wheats has demonstrated that resistant and susceptible cultivars significantly differ from each other with respect to the contributions of common ancestors. The contributions of Oro (Bt4 and Bt7), Rio (Bt6), White Odessa (Bt1), and Florence (Bt3) to the resistant cultivars are significantly higher than their contributions to the susceptible ones. This demonstrates that the use of these resistance donors in wheat breeding for several decades has been effective. The contribution of PI-178383 (Bt8, Bt9, and Bt10) is considerably higher in the group of resistant cultivars bred after 1965. The mean contributions of Federation (Bt7) and Nebred (Bt4) are significantly higher in the group of resistant cultivars obtained before 1965; however, the differences in the contributions of these donors between new resistant and susceptible cultivars became nonsignificant. Among the Russian and Ukrainian cultivars, there are differences between groups of resistant and susceptible cultivars from different regions determined by the differences between the regional populations of the pathogen in racial composition. In the northern region, the contributions of the wheat grass (Agropyron glaucum) and the rye cultivar Eliseevskaya are significantly higher in the resistant cultivars; in the southern region, a local cultivar of the Odessa oblast is the prevalent resistant cultivar. In addition, cultivar Yaroslav Emmer is likely to be effective in the northern region; and foreign sources (Oro, Florence, Federation, and Triticum timopheevii), in the southern region. Very few sources of vertical resistance to common bunt are used for winter wheat breeding in Russia and Ukraine. The decrease in genetic diversity in favor of a few identical genes may cause adequate changes in the pathogen population and subsequent proliferation of the pathogen on the genetically identical substrate. A new interpretation of the resistance of line Lutescens 6028 as a source of new genes, Bt12 and Bt13, is suggested. Both genealogical and segregation analyses have shown that the genes determining the resistance of this line may be identical to those described earlier (Bt1, Bt3, Bt4, Bt6, and Bt7); and the high resistance of this line is determined by a combination of these genes.     

Secretome Analysis Identifies Potential Pathogenicity/Virulence Factors of Tilletia indica,a Quarantined Fungal Pathogen Inciting Karnal Bunt Disease in Wheat

Tilletia indica is a smut fungus that incites Karnal bunt in wheat. It has been considered as quarantine pest in more than 70 countries. Despite its quarantine significance, there is meager knowledge regarding the molecular mechanisms of disease pathogenesis. Moreover, various disease management strategies have proven futile. Development of effective disease management strategy requires identification of pathogenicity / virulence factors. With this aim, the present study was conducted to compare the secretomes of T. indica isolates, that is, highly (TiK) and low (TiP) virulent isolates. About 120 and 95 protein spots were detected reproducibly in TiK and TiP secretome gel images. Nineteen protein spots, which were consistently observed as upregulated/differential in the secretome of TiK isolate, were selected for their identification by MALDI‐TOF/TOF. Identified proteins exhibited homology with fungal proteins playing important role in fungal adhesion, penetration, invasion, protection against host‐derived reactive oxygen species, production of virulence factors, cellular signaling, and degradation of host cell wall proteins and antifungal proteins. These results were complemented with T. indica genome sequence leading to identification of candidate pathogenicity / virulence factors homologs that were further subjected to sequence‐ and structure‐based functional annotation. Thus, present study reports the first comparative secretome analysis of T. indica for identification of pathogenicity / virulence factors. This would provide insights into pathogenic mechanisms of T. indica and aid in devising effective disease management strategies.     

Comparative Genealogical Analysis of the Resistance of Winter Wheat to Common Bunt

Comparative genealogical analysis of North American (the United States and Canada) and Eastern European (Russia and Ukraine) winter wheat cultivars resistant and susceptible to common bunt has been performed. Analysis of variance applied to North American wheats has demonstrated that resistant and susceptible cultivars significantly differ from each other with respect to the contributions of common ancestors. The contributions of Oro (Bt4and Bt7), Rio (Bt6), White Odessa (Bt1), and Florence (Bt3) to the resistant cultivars are significantly higher than their contributions to the susceptible ones. This demonstrates that the use of these resistance donors in wheat breeding for several decades has been effective. The contribution of PI-178383 (Bt8, Bt9,and Bt10) is considerably higher in the group of resistant cultivars bred after 1965. The mean contributions of Federation (Bt7) and Nebred (Bt4) are significantly higher in the group of resistant cultivars obtained before 1965; however, the differences in the contributions of these donors between new resistant and susceptible cultivars became nonsignificant. Among the Russian and Ukrainian cultivars, there are differences between groups of resistant and susceptible cultivars from different regions determined by the differences between the regional populations of the pathogen in racial composition. In the northern region, the contributions of the wheat grass (Agropyron glaucum) and the rye cultivar Eliseevskaya are significantly higher in the resistant cultivars; in the southern region, a local cultivar of the Odessa oblast is the prevalent resistant cultivar. In addition, cultivar Yaroslav Emmer is likely to be effective in the northern region; and foreign sources (Oro, Florence, Federation, and Triticum timopheevii), in the southern region. Very few sources of vertical resistance to common bunt are used for winter wheat breeding in Russia and Ukraine. The decrease in genetic diversity in favor of a few identical genes may cause adequate changes in the pathogen population and subsequent proliferation of the pathogen on the genetically identical substrate. A new interpretation of the resistance of line Lutescens 6028 as a source of new genes, Bt12 and Bt13, is suggested. Both genealogical and segregation analyses have shown that the genes determining the resistance of this line may be identical to those described earlier (Bt1, Bt3, Bt4, Bt6, and Bt7); and the high resistance of this line is determined by a combination of these genes.     

Molecular mapping of QTLs for Karnal bunt resistance in two recombinant inbred populations of bread wheat

Karnal bunt (KB) of wheat, caused by the fungus Tilletia indica, is a challenge to the grain industry, owing not to direct yield loss but to quarantine regulations that may restrict international movement of affected grain. Several different sources of resistance to KB have been reported. Understanding the genetics of resistance will facilitate the introgression of resistance into new wheat cultivars. The objectives of this study were to identify quantitative trait loci (QTLs) associated with KB resistance and to identify DNA markers in two recombinant inbred line populations derived from crosses of the susceptible cultivar WH542 with resistant lines HD29 and W485. Populations were evaluated for resistance against the KB pathogen for 3 years at Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana, India. Two new QTLs (Qkb.ksu-5BL.1 and Qkb.ksu-6BS.1) with resistance alleles from HD29 were identified and mapped in the intervals Xgdm116–Xwmc235 on chromosome 5B (deletion bin 5BL9-0.76-0.79) and Xwmc105–Xgwm88 on chromosome 6B (C-6BS5-0.76). They explained up to 19 and 13% of phenotypic variance, respectively. Another QTL (Qkb.ksu-4BL.1) with a resistance allele from W485 mapped in the interval Xgwm6–Xwmc349 on chromosome 4B (4BL5-0.86-1.00) and explained up to 15% of phenotypic variance. Qkb.ksu-6BS.1 showed pairwise interactions with loci on chromosomes 3B and 6A. Markers suitable for marker-assisted selection are available for all three QTLs. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

STS-PCR markers appropriate for wheat-barley introgression

Introgression of chromosomal segments across large taxonomic distances has long been an objective of scientists interested in understanding the relationships between genes and their effect on phenotype. Barley and wheat represent cultivated members of the Triticeae with different zones of adaptation, different responses to pathogens, and different end-use characteristics. Introduction of small, well-characterized chromosomal segments among grass relatives presents an opportunity to both better understand how genes perform in novel genomic environments and to learn more about the evolutionary novelties which differentiate related species. Since the distribution of the wheat-barley addition lines, the potential power and value of a comprehensive series of wheat/barley translocation lines has been widely appreciated. A scarcity of easy-touse markers which unambiguously distinguish barley loci from their wheat homologues has limited the ability of scientists to identify the relatively rare inter-chromosomal recombination events which are the necessary antecedents of these lines. Since the single most critical pathogen affecting U.S. wheat producers is Karnal bunt (Tilletia indica) and since barley carries a gene conferring immunity, molecular markers may prove practically and immediately important. In this report we describe a series of 135 barley-specific markers amplified by 115 primer sets developed from sequences from previously mapped restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) markers. These easily distinguish the cognate barley products from their wheat counterparts and should find ready use in the identification of lines which contain wheat/barley translocation events.     

Enhanced proteolysis leads to pre-mature cell death under the influence of elicitor like mycelial components from karnal bunt (tilletia indica) pathogen in wheat callus cultures

Calli raised from mature embryos of susceptible wheat cultivar WH 542 were used in the present study as in vitro bioassay system to study the influence of disease determinant(s) of Karnal bunt (Tilletia indica), a semi-biotrophic fungal pathogen of wheat. Influence of elicitor and conditioned medium (CM) prepared from fungal cultures of T. indica was investigated on induction of programmed cell death (PCD). Induction of PCD was observed as hypersensitive response (HR) in terms of browning at localized regions of callus cultures and induction of proteolytic enzyme(s). Elicitor treated calli showed higher induction of protease activity than untreated and CM-treated cultures, which showed not much change in the activity. It was further substantiated by gel protease assay and activation of caspase-3 like protein(s) in callus cultures that clearly suggested the presence of signaling molecule(s) in the fungal elicitor preparation rather than in conditioned medium. This study further demonstrated that only elicitor preparation possesses such molecule(s), which might be cell wall bound components, rather than secretory in nature as CM was unable to induce PCD in wheat callus cultivars.     

Synthesis and evaluation of Triticum durum — T. monococcum amphiploids

Summary Nine Triticum durum — T. monococcum amphiploids (AABBA^mA^m) were synthesized by chromosome doubling of sterile triploid F₁ hybrids involving nine T. durum (AABB) cultivars and a T. monococcum (A^mA^m) line. The triploid F₁ hybrids had a range of 4–7 bivalents and 7–13 univalents per PMC. The synthetic amphiploids, however, showed a high degree of preferential pairing of chromosomes of the A genomes of diploid and tetraploid wheats. The amphiploids were meiotically stable and fully fertile. Superiority of four amphiploids for tiller number per plant, 100-grain weight, protein content and resistance to Karnal bunt demonstrated that these could either be commercially exploited as such after overcoming certain inherent defects or used to introgress desirable genes into durum and bread wheat cultivars. Methods for improvement of these amphiploids are discussed.     

Variability of Indian Isolates of Tilletia indica Assessed by Pathogenicity and Molecular Markers

Twenty isolates of Tilletia indica collected from sites in North and North‐western India showed pathogenic variation on 18 host differentials. Sixteen aggressive pathotypes were identified on the basis of percent coefficient of infection (PCI). Two major clusters were apparent in the dendrogram; cluster 1 comprised 13 isolates and cluster two consisted of seven isolates. One of the isolate Kashipur had a high PCI on most of the host differentials compared to other isolates. Polymerase chain reaction‐based random amplified polymorphic DNA (PCR – RAPD) analysis also divided isolates into two major clusters, one comprising of 5 isolates collected from hill and foot‐hill sites and another group comprising of 15 isolates collected from plain sites. Thus, the clusters identified based on PCI did not match closely with those identified by molecular analysis based on RAPD. Although diversity among the isolates of T. indica was absent in the rDNA‐ITS region, our study based on pathogenicity and molecular markers confirms the existence of great diversity in the pathogen, also shifting of ‘hot spot’ areas from one place to another within Karnal bunt prevailing areas.     

Markers to a common bunt resistance gene derived from ‘Blizzard’ wheat (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Triticum aestivum</Emphasis> L.) and mapped to chromosome arm 1BS

Common bunt, caused by Tilletia caries (DC.) Tul. &; C. Tul. and T. laevis J.G Kuhn, is an economically important disease of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) worldwide. The resistance in the winter wheat cultivar ‘Blizzard’ is effective against known races of common bunt in western Canada. The incorporation of resistance from Blizzard into field-ready cultivars may be accelerated through the use of molecular markers. Using the maize pollen method, a doubled haploid population of 147 lines was developed from the F₁ of the second backcross of Blizzard (resistant) by breeding line ‘8405-JC3C’ (susceptible). Doubled haploid lines were inoculated at seeding with race T19 or T19 and L16 and disease reaction was examined under controlled conditions in 1999 and natural conditions in 2002, and 2003. Resistant:susceptible-doubled haploid lines segregated in a 1:1 ratio for bunt reaction, indicating single major gene segregation. Microsatellite primers polymorphic on the parents were screened on the population. Initial qualitative segregation analysis indicated that the wheat microsatellite markers Xgwm374, Xbarc128 and Xgwm264, located on wheat chromosome 1BS, were significantly linked to the resistance locus. Qualitative results were confirmed with quantitative trait locus analysis. The genetic distance, calculated with JoinMap^®, between the bunt resistance locus and overlapping markers Xgwm374, Xgwm264 and Xbarc128 was 3.9 cM. The three markers were validated on doubled haploid populations BW337/P9502&;DAF1BB and Blizzard/P9514-AR17A3E evaluated for common bunt reaction in the growth chamber in 2007. These markers will be useful in selecting for the common bunt resistance from Blizzard and assist in identifying the resistance among potential new sources of resistance.