Plasmodiophora brassicae-induced Cell Death and Medium Alkalization in Clubroot-resistant Cultured Roots of Brassica rapa

Plasmodiophora brassicae causes clubroot in the turnip, Brassica rapa L. We used organ cultures of adventitious roots from B. rapa seedlings to investigate the initial response of resistant and susceptible cultivars to P. brassicae infection. Primary plasmodia of P. brassicae were observed in root hairs of both susceptible and resistant cultured roots. On the other hand, secondary plasmodia were able to proliferate only in the susceptible root culture but not in the resistant one. Root cultures from the susceptible cultivar all developed clubroot 4 weeks after treatment with 10⁴, 10⁵ or 10⁶ spores/ml, but roots from the resistant cultivar did not develop clubroot under the same conditions. Cell death, as measured by Evans blue and TTC dye methods, was observed in cultured roots from the resistant cultivar but did not occur in roots from the susceptible cultivar after exposure to P. brassicae spores. Cell death was inhibited almost completely by EGTA and verapamil but not by the calmodulin antagonist W7. These results suggest the involvement of Ca²⁺ in P. brassicae‐induced cell death. Alkalization of the root culture medium of the resistant cultivar was observed 2 days after treatment with P. brassicae spores but was not observed in root culture medium from the susceptible strain. We conclude that our root culture system must be a useful tool for further studies of the molecular mechanism of clubroot resistance.     

Life Cycle of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Plasmodiophora brassicae</Emphasis>

Plasmodiphora brassicae is a soil-borne obligate parasite. The pathogen has three stages in its life cycle: survival in soil, root hair infection, and cortical infection. Resting spores of P. brassicae have a great ability to survive in soil. These resting spores release primary zoospores. When a zoospore reaches the surface of a root hair, it penetrates through the cell wall. This stage is termed the root hair infection stage. Inside root hairs the pathogen forms primary plasmodia. A number of nuclear divisions occur synchronously in the plasmodia, followed by cleavage into zoosporangia. Later, 4–16 secondary zoospores are formed in each zoosporangium and released into the soil. Secondary zoospores penetrate the cortical tissues of the main roots, a process called cortical infection. Inside invaded roots cells, the pathogen develops into secondary plasmodia which are associated with cellular hypertrophy, followed by gall formation in the tissues. The plasmodia finally develop into a new generation of resting spores, followed by their release back into soil as survival structures. In vitro dual cultures of P. brassicae with hairy root culture and suspension cultures have been developed to provide a way to nondestructively observe the growth of this pathogen within host cells. The development of P. brassicae in the hairy roots was similar to that found in intact plants. The observations of the cortical infection stage suggest that swelling of P. brassicae-infected cells and abnormal cell division of P. brassicae-infected and adjacent cells will induce hypertrophy and that movement of plasmodia by cytoplasmic streaming increases the number of P. brassicae-infected cells during cell division.     

Cytology of infection,development and expression of resistance to Plasmodiophora brassicae in canola

The timing and expression of resistance to four isolates of Plasmodiophora brassicae, collected from research sites where pathotypes 2, 3, 5 and 6 (Williams' system) had been dominant when characterised in 2006, were assessed in four new commercial cultivars of canola (Brassica napus) with resistance to clubroot. Each of the resistant cultivars was highly resistant to all four of the isolates, and there was no difference in their response to infection. Root hair infection occurred at high levels, but pathogen development occurred more slowly than in a susceptible cultivar (control). Secondary infection and development in cortical cells was severely inhibited in each of the resistant cultivars; only a few bi‐nucleated plasmodia were observed at 12 days after inoculation (DAI), and plasmodia were rarely observed at 18 and 24 DAI. In contrast, development in the susceptible cultivar had progressed to resting spores by 24 DAI. A dense ring of accumulated reactive oxygen species (ROS) was observed in the endodermis, pericycle and vascular cambium of non‐inoculated controls and inoculated plants of the resistant cultivars. However, the ROS ring disappeared rapidly in infected plants of the susceptible cultivar. Plasmodia invaded the stele of susceptible roots by preferentially colonising the xylem parenchyma cells. Expansion and enlargement of lignified xylem cells was observed by 35 DAI. The absence of any specific points of ROS accumulation or lignification of epidermal or cortical cells in the resistant cultivars indicates that a hypersensitive response is not the main mechanism of resistance in these lines. The uniform response of these resistant cultivars to the four isolates of P. brassicae indicates that the resistance in each cultivar may be conditioned by a gene(s) from a single source that confers broad resistance, because most sources of resistance to P. brassicae are pathotype specific.     

Evaluation of Brassica germplasm for field resistance against clubroot (Plasmodiophora brassicae Woron)

Of the 124 germplasm accession of oil seed Brassicas screened under field condition against clubroot disease (Plasmodiophora brassicae), 80% were susceptible and 17, 3, 1 and 1 of Brassica juncea, Brassica rapa var. toria, B.rapa var. yellow sarson and B. rapa, respectively, were resistant.     

Molecular Detection and Pathogenicity Assay of Plasmodiophora brassicae in Chicken Manure

To determine the relationship between animal excreta and the occurrence of clubroot disease of cruciferous crops caused by Plasmodiophora brassicae, chickens were fed with resting spores of the pathogen. Their faeces were collected and used to inoculate crucifers. This study proved that both fresh and composted manures could induce clubroot and the presence of the pathogen in the manure was confirmed by PCR amplification. However, composting had detrimental effects on the virulence of the resting spores in the manure. When the temperature was over 32°C, the incidence and severity of clubroot declined with the increase in the exposure time of resting spores to high temperature and the pathogenicity was completely lost when the spores were kept at 48°C for 6 h. The control measures for the clubroot disease were discussed.     

Germination of surface-disinfected resting spores ofPlasmodiophora brassicae and their root hair infection in turnip hairy roots

Germination of surface-disinfected resting spores ofPlasmodiophora brassicae and its infection of turnip hairy root hairs were studied. Surface-disinfected resting spores showed higher germination than non-disinfected resting spores. Root hair infection was most frequent in the section of root formed 1 d before inoculation. Root hair infection began 4 d after inoculation, increased up to 6 d, and continued to increase more slowly until 10 to 12 d after inoculation. Growth ofP. brassicae in the root hair of hairy roots was observed serially. Most primary plasmodia differentiated to mature zoosporangia 8–10 d after inoculation. The secondary zoospores were initially released 6 d after inoculation.     

Development of a PCR-based Assay for the Detection of Plasmodiophora brassicae in Soil

A single-tube nested polymerase chain reaction (STN PCR) method was developed for detecting the causal agent of clubroot disease, Plasmodiophora brassicae. Outer primer PBTZS-2 (5′-CCGAATTCGCGTCAGCGTGA-3′) to amplify a 1457 bp-fragment from P. brassicae DNA and nested primers, PBTZS-3 (5′-CCACGTCGATCACGTTGCAAT-3′) and PBTZS-4 (5′-GCTGGCGTTGATGTACTGGAA-TT-3′), to amplify a 398 bp-fragment internal of the 1457 bp-fragment were used for the STN PCR. The 398 bp-fragment was amplified from as little as 1 fg of P. brassicae DNA with the STN PCR. A protocol for extracting P. brassicae DNA directly from soil was developed. By using the protocol, DNA was extracted from artificially infested soil containing various numbers of P. brassicae resting spores and the resulting DNA was used as template for the STN PCR. As little as one resting spore of P. brassicae per g of soil was detectable with the STN PCR. The STN PCR was applied to naturally infested soil from 3 fields and one canal bed. The 398 bp-fragment was amplified from soil of 2 fields and the canal bed. To improve the detection of P. brassicae, the STN PCR products were subjected to second PCR amplification (double PCR) using the nested primers PBTZS-3 and PBTZS-4. The double PCR amplification generated a single 398 bp-DNA band which was visualized clearly on the agarose gel for all the 4 soil samples tested. A combination of the STN PCR and the double PCR appears a useful assay method for detecting P. brassicae resting spores in field soil.     

SnRK1.1-mediated resistance of Arabidopsis thaliana to clubroot disease is inhibited by the novel Plasmodiophora brassicae effector PBZF1

Plants have evolved a series of strategies to combat pathogen infection. Plant SnRK1 is probably involved in shifting carbon and energy use from growth-associated processes to survival and defence upon pathogen attack, enhancing the resistance to many plant pathogens. The present study demonstrated that SnRK1.1 enhanced the resistance of Arabidopsis thaliana to clubroot disease caused by the plant-pathogenic protozoan Plasmodiophora brassicae. Through a yeast two-hybrid assay, glutathione S-transferase pull-down assay, and bimolecular fluorescence complementation assay, a P. brassicae RxLR effector, PBZF1, was shown to interact with SnRK1.1. Further expression level analysis of SnRK1.1-regulated genes showed that PBZF1 inhibited the biological function of SnRK1.1 as indicated by the disequilibration of the expression level of SnRK1.1-regulated genes in heterogeneous PBZF1-expressing A. thaliana. Moreover, heterogeneous expression of PBZF1 in A. thaliana promoted plant susceptibility to clubroot disease. In addition, PBZF1 was found to be P. brassicae-specific and conserved. This gene was significantly highly expressed in resting spores. Taken together, our results provide new insights into how the plant-pathogenic protist P. brassicae employs an effector to overcome plant resistance, and they offer new insights into the genetic improvement of plant resistance against clubroot disease.     

STUDIES ON THE LIFE CYCLE AND TAXONOMY OF LIGNIERA VERRUCOSA

Miller , Charles E. (A. and M. College of Texas, College Station.) Studies on the life cycle and taxonomy of Ligniera verrucosa. Amer. Jour. Bot. 46(10): 725–729. Illus. 1959.—A study of the roots of Veronica persica Poir. and V. hederaefolia L. plants infected with Sorosphaera veronicae Schroeter revealed intracellular cystosori and zoosporangial sori of Ligniera verrucosa. The zoosporangial phase of this species has been heretofore unknown. The plasmodia of L. verrucosa occur in root hairs, and other epidermal and sub-epidermal cells of the roots. Zoosporangial and cystosoral plasmodia are indistinguishable until cleavage has started. It is thought that plasmodia produced during early infection develop into zoosporangia, while those produced later develop into resting spores. Zoospores discharged from zoosporangia may reinfect host cells developing there into zoosporangial or cystosoral plasmodia. No evidence for any sexual process was observed. The spherical zoosporangia making up a single zoosporangial sorus may be interconnected; a single discharge pore may serve to liberate zoospores from different zoosporangia. In the Plasmodiophorales the classical basis for generic distinction has been the arrangement of the resting spores in the sorus. Ligniera, because of the supposedly uncharacteristic nature of its cystosori, has been suggested as a host-variety of Sorosphaera. A comparative study of the cystosori and zoosporangia of Ligniera and Sorosphaera growing in a single host has led to the conclusion that these genera should be considered distinct.     

Indole glucosinolate and auxin biosynthesis in Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh. glucosinolate mutants and the development of clubroot disease

Mutants and wild type plants of Arabidopsis thaliana were analysed for differences in glucosinolate accumulation patterns, indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) biosynthesis and phenotype. A previously identified series of mutants, termed TU, with altered glucosinolate patterns was used in this study. Only the line TU8 was affected in shoot phenotype (shorter stems, altered branching pattern). Synthesis of IAA and metabolism were not much affected in the TU8 mutant during seedling development, although the content of free IAA peaked earlier in TU8 during plant development than in the wild type. Indole glucosinolates and IAA may, however, be involved in the development of clubroot disease caused by the obligate biotrophic fungus Plasmodiophora brassicae since the TU3 line had a lower infection rate than the wild type, and lines TU3 and TU8 showed decreased symptom development. The decline in clubroot formation was accompanied by a reduced number of fungal structures within the root cortex and slower development of the fungus. Indole glucosinolates were lower in infected roots of TU3 and TU8 than in control roots of these lines, whereas in wild-type plants the differences were not as prominent. Free IAA and indole-3-acetonitrile (IAN) were increased in infected roots of the wild type and mutants with normal clubroot symptoms, whereas they were reduced in infected roots of mutants TU3 and TU8. These results indicate a role for indole glucosinolates and IAN/IAA in relation to symptom development in clubroot disease. Received: 23 July 1998 / Accepted: 12 January 1999     

Identification of two loci for resistance to clubroot (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Plasmodiophora brassicae</Emphasis> Woronin) in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Brassica rapa</Emphasis> L.

In an analysis of 114 F₂ individuals from a cross between clubroot-resistant and susceptible lines of Brassica rapa L., 'G004' and 'Hakusai Chukanbohon Nou 7' (A9709), respectively, we identified two loci, Crr1 and Crr2, for clubroot (caused by Plasmodiophora brassicae Woronin) resistance. Each locus segregated independently among the F₂ population, indicating that the loci reside on a different region of chromosomes or on different chromosomes. Genetic analysis showed that each locus had little effect on clubroot resistance by itself, indicating that these two loci are complementary for clubroot resistance. The resistance to clubroot was much stronger when both loci were homozygous for resistant alleles than when they were heterozygous. These results indicate that clubroot resistance in B. rapa is under oligogenic control and at least two loci are necessary for resistance.Communicated by H.C. Becker     

Consecutive and Simultaneous Competition ELISA of Monoclonal Antibodies: Characterization of Epitope Relationships or Immunoglobulin Idiotypes

Three populations of Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh. were inoculated with three isolates of Plasmodiophora brassicae Woron. Inoculation of young Arabidopsis plants caused clubbing of roots and, in the late flowering population CrGC 9–4, infection of shoots. In this population, the number of inoculated plants reaching the flowering stage was reduced, and the majority of plants died prematurely. Symptoms of shoot infections were compressed rosettes with thickened and stunted leaves containing resting spores of P. brassicae. The results showed clearly that A. thaliana is susceptible to P. brassicae.     

Mechanisms of the biofungicide Serenade (Bacillus subtilis QST713) in suppressing clubroot

Clubroot is a serious threat to canola production in western Canada. The biofungicide Serenade® (Bacillus subtilis QST713) reduced the disease substantially in controlled environment, but showed variable efficacy in field trials. To better understand how this biofungicide works, two of the product components, i.e., B. subtilis and its metabolites (product filtrate), were assessed under controlled conditions for their relative contribution to clubroot control. The information may be used to optimize the product formulation. The bacterium or product filtrate alone was only partially effective against clubroot, reducing disease severity by about 60% relative to untreated controls. In contrast, Serenade controlled the disease by over 90%. This pattern of response was mirrored in quantitative PCR assessment on P. brassicae DNA within canola roots; the lowest and highest amounts of pathogen DNA were found in roots of Serenade treatment (0.02 and 0.01 ng/g) and controls (0.52 and 13.35 ng/g), respectively, at 2 and 3 weeks after treatment. During this period, the amount of DNA changed little in Serenade-treated roots but increased by almost 30-fold in the control. The product filtrate or B. subtilis also reduced the pathogen DNA substantially (0.03–1.16 ng/g). Serenade decreased the germination and viability of P. brassicae resting spores only marginally. It is suggested that biofungicide Serenade controls clubroot largely via suppressing root-hair and cortical infection by P. brassicae zoospores. The bacterial metabolites in the product formulation possibly assist B. subtilis in rhizosphere colonization and clubroot control by minimizing the competition from other soil microbes.     

Antifungal and Biocontrol Evaluation of Four <Emphasis Type="Italic">Lysobacter</Emphasis> Strains Against Clubroot Disease

The effect of crude extract (Ce), seed coating agent (SCA) and whole bacterial broth culture (WBC) of Lysobacter strains was evaluated against the causal agent of clubroot formation in Cruciferous vegetables. The ability of four Lysobacter strains (L. antibioticus 6-B-1, L. antibioticus 6-T-4, L. antibioticus 13-B-1 and L. capsici ZST1-2) inhibited Plasmodiophora brassicae of resting spores and disease. Application of WBC of four Lysobacter strains inhibited clubroot disease, indicating that the disease suppression was due to antifungal compounds produced by the biocontrol bacterium in the culture. Development of clubroot on Chinese cabbage was inhibited when the WBC and SCA were applied before P. brassicae inoculation. Crude extract (Ce) of culture filtrate was effective in arresting the germination of resting spores of P. brassicae on slides. However, Lysobacter strains differed in their biocontrol effects, the strain L. capsci ZST1-2 recorded a high level of disease limiting effect.     

Status and Perspectives of Clubroot Resistance Breeding in Crucifer Crops

Clubroot disease is a major threat to crops belonging to the Brassicaceae. It is controlled most effectively by the use of resistant cultivars. Plasmodiophora brassicae, the causal agent, shows a wide variation for pathogenicity, which can be displayed by using differential host sets. Except for Brassica juncea and B. carinata, resistant accessions can be found in all major crops. Most resistance sources are race-specific, despite some race-independent resistant accessions which can be found in B. oleracea. European field isolates from P. brassicae display great variation and show a tendency to overcome different resistance sources from either B. rapa or B. oleracea. At present, resistance genes from stubble turnips (B. rapa) are most effective and most widely used in resistance breeding of different Brassica crops. Resistance to P. brassicae from turnips was introduced into Chinese cabbage, oilseed rape, and B. oleracea. Although most turnips carry more than one resistance gene, the resistant cultivars from other crops received primarily a single, dominant resistance gene having a race-specific effect. Populations of P. brassicae that are compatible against most of the used resistance sources have been present in certain European areas for many decades. Such pathogen populations appeared in Japanese Chinese cabbage crops only a few years after the introduction of resistant cultivars. As the spread of virulent P. brassicae pathotypes seems to be slow, resistant cultivars are still a very effective method of control in many cropping areas. Mapping studies have revealed the presence of several clubroot-resistance genes in the Brassica A and C genomes; most of these genes are showing race specificity. Only in B. oleracea was one broad-spectrum locus detected. Two loci from the A genome confer resistance to more than one pathotype, but not to all isolates. Progress made in the determination of resistance loci should be used to formulate and introduce an improved differential set. Future efforts for breeding P. brassicae resistance will focus on durability by broadening the genetic basis of clubroot resistance by using either natural variation or transgenic strategies.     

A novel methyltransferase from the intracellular pathogen Plasmodiophora brassicae methylates salicylic acid

The obligate biotrophic pathogen Plasmodiophora brassicae causes clubroot disease in Arabidopsis thaliana, which is characterized by large root galls. Salicylic acid (SA) production is a defence response in plants, and its methyl ester is involved in systemic signalling. Plasmodiophora brassicae seems to suppress plant defence reactions, but information on how this is achieved is scarce. Here, we profile the changes in SA metabolism during Arabidopsis clubroot disease. The accumulation of SA and the emission of methylated SA (methyl salicylate, MeSA) were observed in P. brassicae‐infected Arabidopsis 28 days after inoculation. There is evidence that MeSA is transported from infected roots to the upper plant. Analysis of the mutant Atbsmt1, deficient in the methylation of SA, indicated that the Arabidopsis SA methyltransferase was not responsible for alterations in clubroot symptoms. We found that P. brassicae possesses a methyltransferase (PbBSMT) with homology to plant methyltransferases. The PbBSMT gene is maximally transcribed when SA production is highest. By heterologous expression and enzymatic analyses, we showed that PbBSMT can methylate SA, benzoic and anthranilic acids.     

Detection and Measurement of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Plasmodiophora brassicae</Emphasis>

Clubroot, caused by Plasmodiophora brassicae, is one of the most important diseases of brassicas. Management of clubroot is difficult, and the best means of avoiding the disease include planting in areas where P. brassicae is not present and using plants and growing media free from pathogen inoculum. As P. brassicae is not culturable, its detection has traditionally relied on plant bioassays, which are time-consuming and require large amounts of glasshouse space. More recently, fluorescence microscopy, serology, and DNA-based methods have all been used to test soil, water, or plant samples for clubroot. The use of fluorescence microscopy to detect and count pathogen spores in the soil requires significant operator skill and is unlikely to serve as the basis for a routine diagnostic test. By contrast, serologic assays are inexpensive and amenable to high-throughput screening but need to be based on monoclonal antibodies because polyclonal antisera cannot be reproduced and are therefore of limited quantity. Several polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based assays have also been developed; these are highly specific for P. brassicae and have been well-correlated with disease severity. As such, PCR-based diagnostic tests have been adopted to varying extents in Canada and Australia, but wide implementation has been restricted by sample processing costs. Efforts are underway to develop inexpensive serologic on-farm diagnostic kits and to improve quantification of pathogen inoculum levels through real-time PCR. Proper detection and quantification of P. brassicae will likely play an increasingly important role in the development of effective clubroot management strategies.     

Powdery mildew suppresses herbivore‐induced plant volatiles and interferes with parasitoid attraction in Brassica rapa

The co‐occurrence of different antagonists on a plant can greatly affect infochemicals with ecological consequences for higher trophic levels. Here we investigated how the presence of a plant pathogen, the powdery mildew Erysiphe cruciferarum, on Brassica rapa affects (1) plant volatiles emitted in response to damage by a specialist herbivore, Pieris brassicae; (2) the attraction of the parasitic wasp Cotesia glomerata and (3) the performance of P. brassicae and C. glomerata. Plant volatiles were significantly induced by herbivory in both healthy and mildew‐infected plants, but were quantitatively 41% lower for mildew‐infected plants compared to healthy plants. Parasitoids strongly preferred Pieris‐infested plants to dually‐infested (Pieris + mildew) plants, and preferred dually infested plants over only mildew‐infected plants. The performance of P. brassicae was unaffected by powdery mildew, but C. glomerata cocoon mass was reduced when parasitized caterpillars developed on mildew‐infected plants. Thus, avoidance of mildew‐infested plants may be adaptive for C. glomerata parasitoids, whereas P. brassicae caterpillars may suffer less parasitism on mildew‐infected plants in nature. From a pest management standpoint, the concurrent presence of multiple plant antagonists can affect the efficiency of specific natural enemies, which may in turn have a negative impact on the regulation of pest populations.