Haplotypes That Are Mosaic for Wild-Type and T Complex-Specific Alleles in Wild Mice

Two outstanding problems pertaining to the population dynamics and evolution of the t complex in mice concern the frequency of t haplotypes in the wild and the degree to which these haplotypes recombine with their wild-type homologs. To address these problems, the frequency and distribution of several t complex-associated restriction fragment variants in wild mice were estimated. Sixty-four versions of chromosome 17 from wild-derived Mus musculus musculus and Mus musculus domesticus were examined with DNA probes for six loci within the t complex that exhibit restriction fragment variation. All six probes detect variants that have heretofore been found exclusively associated with the t complex. Haplotype analysis of wild-derived chromosomes revealed a high frequency (45.3%) of "mosaic" haplotypes with a mixture of t-specific and wild-type variants and only one haplotype with t-specific variants at all six loci. When 12 well-characterized t haplotypes isolated from diverse geographic regions were analyzed, only three had a complete set of t-specific restriction fragments for the six loci examined. The preponderance of mosaic haplotypes in both groups of mice can be explained by any one of the following hypotheses: genetic recombination between t haplotypes and their wild-type homologs, the persistence in wild populations of haplotypes that have descended from ancestral partial t haplotypes, or that the restriction fragment variants fixed in the ancestral t haplotype were also fixed in some wild-type haplotypes. There is evidence to support all three of these hypotheses in our data. The allelic composition of some mosaic haplotypes indicates that they may have been formed by segmental recombination, either double crossing over or gene conversion, rather than by simple single crossovers. The occurrence of indistinguishable mosaic haplotypes in both M. m. musculus and M. m. domesticus suggests that these haplotypes are ancestral rather than recently derived.     

Polymorphisms distinguishing different mouse species and t haplotypes.

Three anonymous chromosome 17 DNA markers, D17Tu36, D17Tu43, and D17Le66B, differentiate between house mouse species and/or between t chromosomes. The D17Tu36 probe, which maps near the Fu locus and to the In(17)4 on t chromosomes, identifies at least 15 haplotypes, each haplotype characterized by a particular combination of DNA fragments obtained after digestion with the Taq I restriction endonuclease. Ten of these haplotypes occur in Mus domesticus, while the remaining five occur in M. musculus. In each of these two species, one haplotype is borne by t chromosomes while the other haplotypes are present on non-t chromosomes. The D17Tu43 probe, which maps near the D17Leh122 locus and to the In(17)3 on t chromosomes, also identifies at least 15 haplotypes in Taq I DNA digests, of which nine occur in M. domesticus and six in M. musculus. One of the nine M. domesticus haplotypes is borne by t chromosomes, the other haplotypes are borne by non-t chromosomes; two of the six M. musculus haplotypes are borne by t chromosomes and the remaining four by non-t chromosomes. Some of the D17Tu43 haplotypes are widely distributed in a given species, while others appear to be population-specific. Exceptions to species-specificity are found only in a few mice captured near the M. domesticus-M. musculus hybrid zone or in t chromosomes that appear to be of hybrid origin. The D17Leh66B probe, which maps to the In(17)2, distinguishes three haplotypes of M. domesticus-derived t chromosomes and one haplotype of M. musculus-derived t chromosomes. Because of these characteristics, the three markers are well suited for the study of mouse population genetics in general and of t chromosome population genetics in particular. A preliminary survey of wild M. domesticus and M. musculus populations has not uncovered any evidence of widespread introgression of genes from one species to the other; possible minor introgressions were found only in the vicinity of the hybrid zone. Typing of inbred strains has revealed the contribution of only M. domesticus DNA to the chromosome 17 of the laboratory mouse.     

Genetic Exchange across a Paracentric Inversion of the Mouse T Complex

Mouse t haplotypes are distinguished from wild-type forms of chromosome 17 by four nonoverlapping paracentric inversions which span a genetic distance of 20 cM. These inversion polymorphisms are responsible for a 100-200-fold suppression of recombination which maintains the integrity of complete t haplotypes and has led to their divergence from the wild-type chromosomes of four species of house mice within which t haplotypes reside. As evidence for the long period of recombinational isolation, alleles that distinguish all t haplotypes from all wild-type chromosomes have been established at a number of loci spread across the 20-cM variant region. However, a more complex picture emerges upon analysis of other t-associated loci. In particular, "mosaic haplotypes" have been identified that carry a mixture of wild-type and t-specific alleles. To investigate the genetic basis for mosaic chromosomes, we conducted a comprehensive analysis of eight t complex loci within 76 animals representing 10 taxa in the genus Mus, and including 23 previously characterized t haplotypes. Higher resolution restriction mapping and sequence analysis was also performed for alleles at the Hba-ps4 locus. The results indicate that a short tract of DNA was transferred relatively recently across an inversion from a t haplotype allele of Hba-ps4 to the corresponding locus on a wild-type homolog leading to the creation of a new hybrid allele. Several classes of wild-type Hba-ps4 alleles, including the most common form in inbred strains, appear to be derived from this hybrid allele. The accumulated data suggest that a common form of genetic exchange across one of the four t-associated inversions is gene conversion at isolated loci that do not play a role in the transmission ratio distortion phenotype required for t haplotype propagation. The implications of the results pose questions concerning the evolutionary stability of gene complexes within large paracentric inversions and suggest that recombinational isolation may be best established for loci residing within a short distance from inversion breakpoints.     

Molecular evidence for the rapid propagation of mouse t haplotypes from a single, recent, ancestral chromosome

Mouse t haplotypes are variant forms of chromosome 17 that exist at high frequencies in worldwide populations of two species of commensal mice. To determine both the relationship of t haplotypes to each other and the species within which they exist, 35 representative t haplotypes were analyzed by means of 10 independent molecular probes, including five DNA clones and five polypeptide spots identified by means of two- dimensional gel electrophoresis. All of the tested haplotypes were found to share restriction fragments and polypeptide spots that are absent in mice carrying wild-type forms of chromosome 17. This observation provides the first direct evidence that all of the known t haplotypes are descendents of a single ancestral chromosome. The absence of variation among t haplotypes could mean that this ancestral chromosome existed relatively recently, in which case it would be necessary to postulate introgressions of t haplotypes across species lines to explain their presence in both Mus domesticus and M. musculus. Alternatively, it is possible that the ancestral chromosome existed prior to the split between M. domesticus and M. musculus and that, by chance, our probes fail to detect polymorphisms that exist among the t haplotypes. A further result of our analysis is the characterization of a partial t haplotype in a wild population of Israeli mice.      

Low Diversity of T Haplotypes in the Eastern Form of the House Mouse, Mus Musculus L

In previous studies, 13 different recessive embryonic lethal genes have been associated with t haplotypes in the wild mice of the species Mus domesticus. In this communication we have analyzed five populations of Mus musculus for the presence and identity of t haplotypes. The populations occupy geographically distant regions in the Soviet Union: Altai Mountains, western and eastern Siberia, Azerbaijan and Turkmenistan. No t haplotypes were found in mice from eastern Siberia. In the remaining four populations, t haplotypes occurred with frequencies ranging from 0.07 to 0.21. All the t haplotypes extracted from these populations and analyzed by the genetic complementation test were shown to carry the same lethal gene tcl-w73. In one population (that of western Siberia), another lethal gene (tcl-w5) was found to be present on the same chromosome as tcl-w73. This situation is in striking contrast to that found in the populations of the western form of the house mouse, M. domesticus. In the latter species, tcl-w73 has not been found at all and the different populations are characterized by the presence of several different lethal genes. The low diversity of t haplotypes in M. musculus is consistent with lower genetic variability of other traits and indicates a different origin and speciation mode compared to M. domesticus. Serological typing for H-2 antigenic determinants suggests that most, if not all, of the newly described t haplotypes might have arisen by recombination of tw73 from M. musculus with t haplotypes from M. domesticus either in the hybrid zone between the two species or in regions where the two species mixed accidentally.     

Identification and characterization of t haplotypes in wild mice populations using molecular markers

As part of a population genetics survey of the hybrid zone between mouse subspecies Mus musculus domesticus and M. m. musculus, we identified and characterized the t haplotypes in 1068 mice from 186 different populations in a 2500 km2 area in central Jutland. On the basis of two t-specific PCR markers, 130 mice possessed this haplotype. The allele frequencies at six microsatellites on the third and fourth chromosomal inversions of the t region were sufficiently different between t-bearing and non-t-bearing mice, and linkage disequilibria sufficiently marked on the t haplotype, to be able to reconstitute the genotype of most t haplotypes. A total of three frequent and 15 rarer haplotypes were identified. These haplotypes resemble each other more than they resemble a panel of known haplotypes from a wide range of geographical regions, except for tw73, which was also extracted from Jutland. The patterns of variation at the microsatellite loci suggest that the Jutland haplotypes were derived from a small number of haplotypes, followed by recombination between complementing haplotypes. Further evidence of recombination came from complementation tests that we performed, showing the lack of concordance between the degrees of complementation and of molecular resemblance between haplotypes. This study shows that it is possible to characterize the presence and variation of t haplotypes by a population genetics approach using simple molecular markers. However recombination between t haplotypes has occurred frequently enough to obscure the links between this variation and the biological properties of distortion and lethality of the haplotypes that originally colonized Jutland.     

Phylogenetic analysis of the alpha-globin pseudogene-4 (Hba-ps4) locus in the house mouse species complex reveals a stepwise evolution of t haplotypes [published erratum appears in Mol Biol Evol 1994 Jan;11(1):158]

A parsimony analysis was performed on restriction sites at the Hba-ps4 pseudogene locus within one of four inversions associated with mouse t haplotypes. The results suggest that all t haplotypes form a monophyletic group and that the in (17)4 inversion originated before the radiation of the Mus musculus species complex but after the divergence of the lineages leading to M. spretus, M. abbotti, and M. hortulanus. A time frame based on the evolutionary rate of mouse pseudogenes places the origin of this t haplotype inversion at 1.5 Mya, or approximately 1.5 Myr after the origin of the more proximal t complex inversion, in (17)2. The accumulated evidence indicates that complete t haplotypes have been assembled in a stepwise manner, with each of these inversions occurring on separate chromosomal lineages and at different evolutionary times. In addition, the evolutionary relationships of pseudogene sequences resulting from genetic exchange between wild-type and t haplotype alleles were examined. Analysis of sequences from the 5' and 3' sides of a putative site of recombination resulted in cladograms with different topologies. The implications for hypotheses concerning the evolutionary forces acting on t haplotypes and their rapid propagation throughout worldwide populations of mice are discussed.      

A Novel Mouse Chromosome 17 Hybrid Sterility Locus: Implications for the Origin of T Haplotypes

The effects of heterospecific combinations of mouse chromosome 17 on male fertility and transmission ratio were investigated through a series of breeding studies. Animals were bred to carry complete chromosome 17 homologs, or portions thereof, from three different sources-Mus domesticus, Mus spretus and t haplotypes. These chromosome 17 combinations were analyzed for fertility within the context of a M. domesticus or M. spretus genetic background. Two new forms of hybrid sterility were identified. First, the heterospecific combination of M. spretus and t haplotype homologs leads to complete male sterility on both M. spretus and M. domesticus genetic backgrounds. This is an example of symmetrical hybrid sterility. Second, the presence of a single M. domesticus chromosome 17 homolog within a M. spretus background causes sterility, however, the same combination of chromosome 17 homologs does not cause sterility within the M. domesticus background. This is a case of asymmetrical hybrid sterility. Through an analysis of recombinant chromosomes, it was possible to map the M. domesticus, M. spretus and t haplotype alleles responsible for these two hybrid sterility phenotypes to the same novel locus (Hybrid sterility-4). Previous structural studies had led to the hypothesis that the ancestral t haplotype originated through an introgression event from M. spretus or a related species. If this were true, one might expect that (1) M. spretus homologs would be transmitted at a non-Mendelian ratio within the M. domesticus background, and (2) t haplotypes would be transmitted at a ratio closer to Mendelian within the M. spretus background.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Fine haplotype structure of a chromosome 17 region in the laboratory and wild mouse

Extensive linkage disequilibrium among classical laboratory strains represents an obstacle in the high-resolution haplotype mapping of mouse quantitative trait loci (QTL). To determine the potential of wild-derived mouse strains for fine QTL mapping, we constructed a haplotype map of a 250-kb region of the t-complex on chromosome 17 containing the Hybrid sterility 1 (Hst1) gene. We resequenced 33 loci from up to 80 chromosomes of five mouse (sub)species. Trans-species single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were rare between Mus m. musculus (Mmmu) and Mus m. domesticus (Mmd). The haplotypes in Mmmu and Mmd differed and therefore strains from these subspecies should not be combined for haplotype-associated mapping. The haplotypes of t-chromosomes differed from all non-t Mmmu and Mmd haplotypes. Half of the SNPs and SN indels but only one of seven longer rearrangements found in classical laboratory strains were useful for haplotype mapping in the wild-derived M. m. domesticus. The largest Mmd haplotype block contained three genes of a highly conserved synteny. The lengths of the haplotype blocks deduced from 36 domesticus chromosomes were in tens of kilobases, suggesting that the wild-derived Mmd strains are suitable for fine interval-specific mapping.     

Recombination within mouse <Emphasis Type="Italic">t</Emphasis> haplotypes has replaced significant segments of <Emphasis Type="Italic">t</Emphasis>-specific DNA

Previous studies on the fourth inversion of the t complex, In17(4), suggest that loci near the center of this inversion have been subjected to segmental recombination during the past 1–2 million years. We have used a combination of PCR-based restriction site (PBR) analysis and DNA sequencing to perform a high-resolution analysis of a 2-million base pair (Mbp) segment in the middle of In17(4). We examined 21 restriction sites that are polymorphic between t haplotypes and their wild-type homologs, over nine distinct loci. In addition, we examined several other polymorphic sites through DNA sequence analysis of two of these nine loci. We analyzed several haplotypes in this way, including the “complete” t haplotypes t ^w2 , t ⁰ , t ^w32 , t ^w71 , and t ^w75 . We show that only t ^w32 is a true “complete” t haplotype; the remaining four t haplotypes have segments of wild-type DNA ranging from less than 100 bp to 2 Mbp. The sizes of these wild-type DNA segments are consistent with their being generated by gene-conversion events. The 2-Mbp segment is located in a region that may contain the t-complex distorter gene Tcd2. One of the nine loci examined in this study is Fgd2, a gene that has been proposed to encode Tcd2. Sequencing and PBR data show that at least a portion of the Fgd2 gene has been converted to the wild-type within t ^w71 and t ^w75 mice.     

Narrowing the critical regions for mouse t complex transmission ratio distortion factors by use of deletions

Previously a deletion in mouse chromosome 17, T(22H), was shown to behave like a t allele of the t complex distorter gene Tcd1, and this was attributed to deletion of this locus. Seven further deletions are studied here, with the aim of narrowing the critical region in which Tcd1 must lie. One deletion, T(30H), together with three others, T(31H), T(33H), and T(36H), which extended more proximally, caused male sterility when heterozygous with a complete t haplotype and also enhanced transmission ratio of the partial t haplotype t(6), and this was attributed to deletion of the Tcd1 locus. The deletions T(29H), T(32H), and T(34H) that extended less proximally than T(30H) permitted male fertility when opposite a complete t haplotype. These results enabled narrowing of the critical interval for Tcd1 to between the markers D17Mit164 and D17Leh48. In addition, T(29H) and T(32H) enhanced the transmission ratio of t(6), but significantly less so than T(30H). T(34H) had no effect on transmission ratio. These results could be explained by a new distorter located between the breakpoints of T(29H) and T(34H) (between T and D17Leh66E). It is suggested that the original distorter Tcd1 in fact consists of two loci: Tcd1a, lying between D17Mit164 and D17Leh48, and Tcd1b, lying between T and D17Leh66E.     

The diverse origins of New Zealand house mice

Molecular markers and morphological characters can help infer the colonization history of organisms. A combination of mitochondrial (mt) D-loop DNA sequences, nuclear DNA data, external measurements and skull characteristics shows that house mice (Mus musculus) in New Zealand and its outlying islands are descended from very diverse sources. The predominant genome is Mus musculus domesticus (from western Europe), but Mus musculus musculus (from central Europe) and Mus musculus castaneus (from southern Asia) are also represented genetically. These subspecies have hybridized to produce combinations of musculus and domesticus nuclear DNA coupled with domesticus mtDNA, and castaneus or musculus mtDNA with domesticus nuclear DNA. The majority of the mice with domesticus mtDNA that we sampled had D-loop sequences identical to two haplotypes common in Britain. This is consistent with long-term British-New Zealand cultural linkages. The origins of the castaneus mtDNA sequences widespread in New Zealand are less easy to identify.     

Polymorphism and Gene Conversion in Mouse α-Globin Haplotypes

We have cloned and characterized three distinct alpha-globin haplotypes obtained from inbred strains of the mouse, Mus domesticus. We report here the complete nucleotide sequence of the six alpha-globin genes that the haplotypes contain. Our analysis of these genes and those from one other previously described haplotype indicates that recurrent gene conversion events have played a major role in their history. The pattern of nucleotide substitutions suggests that conversions have occurred both within and between haplotypes. Limited segments of coding and noncoding DNA have been involved in these gene conversion events. In two of the haplotypes, the nonallelic genes of each maintain DNA sequence identity over discrete intervals and encode the same alpha-globin polypeptide. On the other hand, the coding regions of some genes have accumulated replacement changes that result in distinct alpha-globins. In one instance, these changes appear to reflect positive selection of advantageous mutations.     

Molecular cloning and sequence analysis of a haploid expressed gene encoding t complex polypeptide 1

The mouse t haplotypes show defects in spermatogenesis attributed to multiple loci on chromosome 17. We have cloned the gene for an abundant testicular germ cell protein, t complex polypeptide 1, which has a variant form in t haplotypes, TCP-1A. A cDNA clone, pB1.4, which hybridizes to a 19S mRNA that is abundant in haploid cells during mouse spermatogenesis, derives from the 3' end of the mRNA encoding TCP-1B. The Tcp-1 gene appears to be a member of a novel gene family and shows multiple changes between the predicted amino acid sequences of TCP-1B and TCP-1A. An additional Taq1 site is created by a T to C transition in the predicted open reading frame of the Tcp-1a gene. The resultant RFLP has allowed typing of the Tcp-1 gene cluster in 54 complete and partial t haplotype chromosomes. DNA sequence comparison of the Tcp-1 genes suggests that the t haplotype chromosome arose within the genus Mus more than one million years ago.     

Phylogenetic distribution in the genus Mus of t-complex-specific DNA and protein markers: inferences on the origin of t-haplotypes

We have examined the phylogenetic distribution of two t-specific markers among representatives of various taxa belonging to the genus Mus. The centromeric TCP-1a marker (a testicular protein variant specific for all t-haplotypes so far studied) has also been apparently detected in several non-t representatives of the Mus IVA, Mus IVB, and probably M. cervicolor species. By contrast, a t-specific restriction- fragment-length polymorphism allele (RFLP) of the telomeric alpha- globin pseudogene DNA marker alpha-psi-4 was found only in animals belonging to the M. musculus-complex species either bearing genuine t- haplotypes or, like the M. m. bactrianus specimen studied here, likely to do so. This t-specific alpha-psi-4 RFLP allele was found to be as divergent from the RFLP alleles of the latter, non-t, taxonomical groups as it is from Mus 4A, Mus 4B, or M. spretus ones. These results suggest the presence of t-haplotypes and of t-specific markers in populations other than those belonging to the M. m. domesticus and M. m. musculus subspecies, implying a possible origin for t-haplotypes prior to the radiation of the most recent offshoot of the Mus genus (i.e., the spretus/domesticus divergence), some 1-3 Myr ago.      

The Putative Oncogene Pim-1 in the Mouse: Its Linkage and Variation among t Haplotypes

Pim-1, a putative oncogene involved in T-cell lymphomagenesis, was mapped between the pseudo-alpha globin gene Hba-4ps and the alpha-crystallin gene Crya-1 on mouse chromosome 17 and therefore within the t complex. Pim-1 restriction fragment variants were identified among t haplotypes. Analysis of restriction fragment sizes obtained with 12 endonucleases demonstrated that the Pim-1 genes in some t haplotypes were indistinguishable from the sizes for the Pim-1b allele in BALB/c inbred mice. There are now three genes, Pim-1, Crya-1 and H-2 I-E, that vary among independently derived t haplotypes and that have indistinguishable alleles in t haplotypes and inbred strains. These genes are closely linked within the distal inversion of the t complex. Because it is unlikely that these variants arose independently in t haplotypes and their wild-type homologues, we propose that an exchange of chromosomal segments, probably through double crossingover, was responsible for indistinguishable Pim-1 genes shared by certain t haplotypes and their wild-type homologues. There was, however, no apparent association between variant alleles of these three genes among t haplotypes as would be expected if a single exchange introduced these alleles into t haplotypes. If these variant alleles can be shown to be identical to the wild-type allele, then lack of association suggests that multiple exchanges have occurred during the evolution of the t complex.     

Structural organization and evolution of t-complex in Mus genus

Modern data on the structure and evolution of the t complex are discussed. The t complex is a series of inversions in the proximal region of murine chromosome 17; it contains a set of genes that determine its predominant transmission to the offspring of heterozygous males. Variants of structural organization of this genetic system (t haplotypes) have been found in wild populations of four species of genus Mus (M. domesticus, M. musculus, M. molossinus, and M. castaneus), but not in representatives of other, evolutionarily remote species of this genus. The so-called vertical, horizontal, and introgressive hypotheses are discussed of the origin and evolution of the t complex. Based on population genetic studies and molecular analysis a new hypothesis on the origin of the t-complex is put forward. This hypothesis is a synthesis between the vertical and horizontal models and assumes that all known t haplotypes had a common ancestral chromosome 17 carrying a proximal inversion.     

Can the variability of mitochondrial DNA distinguish between commensal and feral populations of the house mouse?

The dynamics and variability of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) were compared in one commensal and one feral population of the house mouse ( Mus domesticus ) in Israel. The rate of turnover was high in both populations (the average proportion of new or discontinuing mice per trapping session was about 50%), as was the level of heterogeneity of mtDNA: using six restriction enzymes, 18 mice from the commensal population had eight different haplotypes (the degree of heterogeneity, h , was 0.802), and 412 mice from the feral population had 16 ( h = 0.894). These results suggest that neither population was composed of rigid breeding units made up of relatives, but that in the commensal population the few neighbouring resident mice that had the same mtDNA haplotype may have been siblings.     

Characterization of a novel wild-type t(wMPI) haplotype of the house mouse (Mus domesticus L.) from Peru]

Data on molecular genetic analysis of the novel wild-type twMP1 haplotype found in a population of Mus domesticus from Peru are presented. Complementation attribution of the novel haplotype as well as fertility of heterozygotes and transmission ratio distortion (TRD) of the t-carrying chromosome in the progeny of the heterozygous males were studied. Molecular analysis was carried out by means of blot hybridization with the four t-specific probes (Tu48, Tu66, Tu119, and Tu122). Comparison of the results obtained with the data on the structure and properties of the t complexes permitted conclusion on the complete lethality of the haplotype described.