A preliminary study on genetic differentiation in Littorina saxatilis from Galway Bay,Ireland: Littorina tenebrosa Montagu – a valid species or ecotype?

Littorina tenebrosa is a small fragile-shelled periwinkle which lives on permanently submerged algae in coastal lagoons and non-tidal brackish pools. This periwinkle is a member of the rough periwinkle group which also comprises Littorina saxatilis, L. arcana, L. compressa and L. neglecta and is most closely related to L. saxatilis although its exact systematic status is in some doubt. Based on its unique ecology many believe L. tenebrosa to be a valid species. However, shell morphometric and allozyme analyses on Scottish and Swedish populations of L. tenebrosa and L. saxatilis have indicated that the two periwinkles are virtually identical. Preliminary results on five allozyme loci (AAT-1, GPI, PGM-1, PGM-2 and PNP) in samples of L. tenebrosa and L. saxatilis from Golam Head, Lettermullen, and other locations on the west coast of Ireland show L. tenebrosa to be genetically differentiated from L. saxatilis At Golam Head, where opportunities for gene flow occur between the two taxa, L. tenebrosa is as genetically differentiated from local L. saxatilis as it is from L. saxatilis from more geographically distant locations.     

A striking example of the founder effect in the mollusc Littorina saxatilis

Two South African populations of Littorina saxatilis were examined by starch-gel electrophoresis at 16 enzyme loci and compared with 13 populations of North Atlantic saxatilis from both American and European coasts, and with six British populations of the closely related species Littorina arcana. The South African animals showed a severely reduced heterozygosity (– 0.052) compared with Atlantic populations of saxatilis ( = 0.181), and the mean genetic distance between the two areas was high ( = 0.203) compared with distances within the North Atlantic saxatilis populations (D = 0.034). In fact, the saxatilis from South Africa were genetically more distant from the North Atlantic samples of L. saxatilis than were the arcana from British shores. The reduced genetic heterozygosity and genetic divergence of the South African populations is attributed to founder effects following a postulated recent introduction by man.     

Rough periwinkle polymorphism on the east coast of Yorkshire: comparison of RAPD-DNA data with morphotype

A genetic analysis of morphotypes of Littorina saxatilis from two locations on the north-east coast of England (Filey and Ravenscar), using randomly amplified DNA polymorphisms (RAPD) generated with a single primer, revealed quite different patterns of variation. Thin shelled, wide-apertured (H-form) animals from Ravenscar tended to cluster separately from thick shelled (M) forms, indicating genetic differentiation of these morphs. Animals of similar morphology (H and M) from Filey (about 30 km distant) did not display such an obvious pattern, and although there was still evidence of differentiation from discriminant analysis of RAPD data, levels of correct classification were reduced at Filey. This suggests that the utility of a single RAPD primer for separation of such forms varies over a relatively small distance. L. arcana from Ravenscar, included as an outgroup, were generally well differentiated from L. saxatilis and were noted to exhibit less variation, a phenomenon that has been noted previously in some allozyme and RAPD analyses. A similar RAPD analysis undertaken on small, barnacle dwelling, brooding forms from Peak Steel, Ravenscar revealed that animals appeared to have as great a tendency to cluster together on a microgeographic scale (by collection patch) as by species ( L. neglecta or L. saxatilis b) although predominance of certain species in individual patches largely explains this. Discriminant analysis of RAPD presence/absence data did correctly place over 90% of barnacle dwelling animals to their respective species, and we consider this as evidence of separate gene pools. RAPD is taken to be a useful tool for screening genetic variation in this complex of animals on a local scale when either a pre-selected informative primer is utilised or a battery of primers is used, but its efficacy may be reduced when a single primer is employed for screening animals from different shores.     

A morphologic and genetic analysis of Littorina saxatilis (Prosobranchia) from Venice, and on the problem of saxatilis—rudis nomenclature

Shell morphology and allozyme patterns of 17 enzymes are analysed within the isolated population of L. saxatilis Olivi (1792) from Venice, the type locality of the species. The shell morphology is compared to three different L. saxatilis phenotypes from Sweden, and showed to be similar to the brackish water 'tenebrosa' type. The Venice population is genetically more distant from British and Swedish populations than are the latter from each other. Less variability (heterozygosity) within the Venice compared to the Atlantic populations is probably a consequence of random genetic drift during a period of small population size.
The nomenclature of L. saxatilis in the Atlantic is discussed and it is suggested that until the exact taxonomic relationship between the Mediterranean and the Atlantic populations has been confirmed by, for example, cross-breeding experiments, the name 'saxatilis' should be kept for the non-Venetian populations (described by Maton (1797) under the name 'rudis').     

The taxonomy of the Littorina saxatilis speicies-complex, with particular reference to the systemaitc status of Littorina patula Jeffrys

Variation in shell shape and penis morphology of Littorina rudis Maton is examined using data from all parts of Britain. The shell shape variation within populations of L. rudis is shown to account for Liltorina patula Jeffrys at the only site where the latter species was recorded. In addition, the shell shape of I,. rudis varies with exposure, individuals on exposed shores having a relatively larger aperture than those on sheltered shores. Wave action and desiccation are considered the most likely factors maintaining this variation. The penis morphology of L. rudis varies within and between shores to an extent that renders the use of this character invalid for distinguishing L. patula from L. rudis. The radulae of adults of L. rudis, L. patula and Littorina nigrolineata (Gray) are similar in structure having blunt cusps, whilst adult Littorina neglecta Bean and juvenile L. rudis have pointed cusps. The possibility of a neotenous origin of L. neglecta from L. rudis is discussed. On the evidence presented here it is suggested that L. patula must be regarded as a synonym of L. rudis.     

The breeding migration of Littorina arcana Hannaford Ellis, 1978 (Prosobranchia: Littorinidae)

Two species of rough winkle, the oviparous Littorina arcana and the ovoviviparous L. saxatilis are very similar in their outward appearance and are commonly syntopic. This has led some researchers to regard these species as conspecific and to suggest that reproductive modality is not a fixed characteristic. However, the syntopy of these species is much more complex than has been supposed and data presented here show how the seasonally reproducing L. arcana migrates downshore during its breeding period, into areas where L. saxatilis is comparatively sparse. This results in a separation of the breeding populations of the two species and consequently a spatial separation of their juveniles, at least in their early stages. Selection pressures on the breeding animals and young juveniles will therefore differ.     

Phenotypic plasticity in two marine snails: constraints superseding life history

In organisms encountering predictable environments, fixed development is expected, whereas in organisms that cannot predict their future environment, phenotypic plasticity would be optimal to increase local adaptation. To test this prediction we experimentally compared phenotypic plasticity in two rocky-shore snail species; Littorina saxatilis releasing miniature snails on the shore, and Littorina littorea releasing drifting larvae settling on various shores, expecting L. littorea to show more phenotypic plasticity than L. saxatilis. We compared magnitude and direction of vectors of phenotypic difference in juvenile shell traits after 3 months exposure to different stimuli simulating sheltered and crab-rich shores, or wave-exposed and crab-free shores. Both species showed similar direction and magnitude of vectors of phenotypic difference with minor differences only between ecotypes of the nondispersing species, indicating that plasticity is an evolving trait in L. saxatilis. The lack of a strong plastic response in L. littorea might be explained by limits rather than costs to plasticity.     

The role of selection in the colour polymorphism of Littorina rudis Maton and Littorina arcana Hannaford-Ellis (Prosobranchia: Littorinidae)

Forty-one mixed samples of winkles containing the closely related species, Littorina rudis and L. arcana , were collected from different parts of the British Isles. Littorina rudis was the more ubiquitous species, with L. arcana being more-or-less confined to vertical cliffs and rocks. The frequencies of different shell colour patterns were determined for both species in each sample. Several colour morphs were diagnostic of one or other of the species over large areas, which confirms that these are separate species. The frequencies, in the two species, of the two commonest morphs, brown and fawn, were strongly correlated; in several other morphs their presence and absence in the two species was significantly associated; the levels of phenotypic diversity in the two species were also correlated. These patterns could not have arisen if the variation between shores was the result of genetic drift or founder effects, so some form of selection is implicated. In the brown morph there is some evidence for frequency-dependent selection, and it is suggested that the polymorphism may be maintained by visual predators through apostatic selection.     

Radular myoglobin and protein variation within and among some littorinid species (Mollusca: Gastropoda)

The radular muscles of several littorinid species, including Littorina littorea, L. saxatilis, L. obtusata, L. striata and Melarhaphe neritoides, contain myoglobin (Mb). Here we report on the presence of radular Mb in eight other littorinids: L. compressa, L. arcana, L. fabalis, Nodilittorina punctata, N. trochoides, N. radiata, Littoraria undulata and Littoraria cingulifera. Using native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) and isoelectric focusing (IEF) we compared the Mb and soluble protein (SP) profiles of these species. This suggested that: (1) L. saxatilis and L. arcana may have specific Mb/SP profiles, (2) Littoraria spp., Nodilittorina spp. and L. striata share similar Mb patterns, (3) Mb is remarkably diverse in the genus Littorina, (4) L. littorea shows intraspecific Mb/SP variation, (5) L. saxatilis does not show geographic Mb/SP differences, and (6) IEF uncovers substantial hidden Mb/SP heterogeneity not shown by PAGE (particularly for Melarhaphe neritoides). Hence, littorinid Mb/SP may be a useful taxonomic marker whose ecophysiological significance deserves further study, even if its genetic basis remains unclear.     

Shell colour polymorphism associated with substrate colour in the intertidal snail Littorina saxatilis Olivi (Prosobranchia: Littorinidae)

Littorina saxatilis Olivi (1792), the rough winkle, is highly polymorphic in shell colour. Shell colour frequencies were studied at six locations in south-western Wales, U.K., each at a geological contact between red sandstone and grey limestone or volcanic rock. At each site shell colour frequencies were determined in samples from the contact zone and on red or grey rock on either side. Highly significant associations were found between shell colour frequencies and substrate colour. Grey shells were always more common on grey rock than on red rock, and brown shells were usually more common on red than on grey rock, suggesting selection for cryptic colouration. Shell colour frequency differences were also found between replicate samples taken only 5 m apart from the same kind of rock, and between samples from the same kind of rock at the six study sites. These latter differences suggest that selection for camouflage is not the only factor involved in maintaining shell colour polymorphism in this species.     

Nuclear DNA restriction site polymorphisms and the phylogeny and population structure of an intertidal snail species complex (Littorina)

Primers for amplification of four novel, unlinked nuclear DNA loci, the first reported for the rough periwinkles of the genus Littorina, are described. Patterns of restriction site polymorphism for these loci are detailed within the rough periwinkles. RFLPs are not found to be diagnostic for any of the currently accepted species within this group, nor for any of the contentious subspecies, or forms, whose taxonomic status is uncertain. However, there are important differences in allele frequencies between these taxa and certain of these mirror differences detected in a previous study of the mitochondrial DNA. These allele frequency data are used to construct a phylogeny in which groupings of the three recognised species are obvious when either Nei's genetic distances or Reynold's distances are clustered. Contentious forms (L. neglecta, L. saxatilis 'b' and L. tenebrosa) do not cluster as distinct taxa, although populations of L. neglecta have important allele frequency differences from L. saxatilis. These four loci have confirmed the consensus view of Littorina phylogeny and provided important information on population structure-however four loci is insufficient for reaching definitive conclusions. Since analysis of nuclear DNA polymorphisms such as these is invaluable for analysis of phylogeny, population structure and phylogeography, identification of additional loci is considered imperative.     

Microgeographic variation in allozyme and shell characters in Littorina saxatilis Olivi (Prosobranchia: Littorinidae)

Twenty-three enzymes and five shell parameters were screened in 11 subpopulations of Littorina saxatilis Olivi (= L. rudis Maton) occupying different habitats over a 1 km stretch of coastline. Shell morphology varied considerably and consistently with respect to degree of exposure, and since there is evidence that such morphology is at least partly under genetic control, it is likely that natural selection selects particular genotypes at particular locations. There was significant allozyme heterogeneity between neighbouring subpopulations, sometimes only metres apart, but little of the allozyme variability could be related directly to environmental pressures. Thus, with the exception of the Odh locus, the considerable morphological differentiation between snails from exposed and sheltered sites was not reflected in differentiation of those genes coding for electrophoretically assayed enzymes. At the Odh locus, virtually all the genetic differentiation between subpopulations was attributable to differentiation between habitat types. Two loci, Sod-1 and Aat-1, showed highly significant genetic disequilibrium, and possible reasons for this are explored. The population structure as assessed electrophoretically accords well with the stepping-stone model which permits greater differentiation of neighbouring populations than the island model, and which seems realistic in the ovoviviparously reproducing L. saxatilis, where the greater part of gene flow is likely to occur through the occasional migration of adults between contiguous populations.     

The taxonomy of some British Littorina species, with notes on their reproduction (Mollusca: Prosobranchia)

The rough periwinkle Littorina saxatilis is considered, in current literature, to consist of various sympatric "subspecies" and "varieties". These, it has been suggested, are incipient species and are evidence for sympatric speciation.
This paper shows that in Wales the "saxatilis" aggregate consists of four separate, fully sympatric species: L. rudis, patula, nigrolineata and neglecta . Differences between these species include proportions, sculpture and size of the shell, range of colour patterns, the anatomy of the genitalia, and isozyme patterns. The possible evidence for incipient species is discussed and rejected.
The diversity of penis form amongst the British winkles is remarkable, and it is suggested that in these sympatric species the structure of the penis could be of importance in species recognition.
The four species occupy different zones on the shore and three certainly differ also in their methods of reproduction: L. rudis is ovoviviparous and contains embryos throughout the year, patula is ovoviviparous but contains embryos only in winter, nigrolineata is oviparous. The reproduction and dispersal methods of all British winkles are reviewed. The evidence available supports the view that non-planktonic dispersal is an adaptation which, in species whose shell colour varies considerably from one locality to another, enables each population to become adapted to its local environmental conditions. Ovoviviparity occurs in high-shore non-planktonic species, and may be an adaptation to avoid the dangers of egg desiccation. Planktonic dispersal is found in species whose shell colour does not vary as much as in non-planktonic ones. In these species, it is argued that a common planktonic pool enables a rapid re-colonization in the case of local decrease in population numbers, and also the rapid dispersal of successful mutations.     

Purine nucleoside phosphorylase polymorphism in the genus Littorina (Prosobranchia: Mollusca)

Examination of eight Atlantic species of the genus Littorina by starch gel electrophoresis of purine nucleoside phosphorylase revealed extensive polymorphism within the L. saxatilis complex. In this group, four alleles have been identified. Heterozygotes are four banded, and thus, as in vertebrates, the enzyme is likely to be a trimer. Breeding experiments confirmed the genetic interpretation of the phenotype patterns. Where species of the saxatilis complex [L. saxatilis (=L. rudis), L. arcana, L. nigrolineata, L. neglecta] are sympatric, there are sometimes significant allele frequency differences between them. A fifth allele was present at a high frequency in L. obtusata and L. mariae, and L. littorea and L. neritoides each possessed unique alleles. A total of eight alleles was identified. Densitometric scanning of heterozygote patterns pointed to activity differences between alleles and also showed that, while the heterotrimeric bands were never less intense than the homotrimeric bands, the heterotrimeric bands were sometimes less intense than expected. It is not clear whether this represents nonrandom association of subunits, decreased stability of heterotrimers, or simply an artifact of the staining and quantifying process.This work was supported by NERC Grant GR3/5319.     

Phylogeographic analysis reveals a deep lineage split within North Atlantic Littorina saxatilis

Phylogeographic studies provide critical insight into the evolutionary histories of model organisms; yet, to date, range-wide data are lacking for the rough periwinkle Littorina saxatilis, a classic example of marine sympatric speciation. Here, we use mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequence data to demonstrate that L. saxatilis is not monophyletic for this marker, but is composed of two distinct mtDNA lineages (I and II) that are shared with sister species Littorina arcana and Littorina compressa. Bayesian coalescent dating and phylogeographic patterns indicate that both L. saxatilis lineages originated in the eastern North Atlantic, around the British Isles, at approximately 0.64 Ma. Both lineages are now distributed broadly across the eastern, central and western North Atlantic, and show strong phylogeographic structure among regions. The Iberian Peninsula is genetically distinct, suggesting prolonged isolation from northeastern North Atlantic populations. Western North Atlantic populations of L. saxatilis lineages I and II predate the last glacial maximum and have been isolated from eastern North Atlantic populations since that time. This identification of two distinct, broadly distributed mtDNA lineages further complicates observed patterns of repeated incipient ecological speciation in L. saxatilis, because the sympatric origins of distinct ecotype pairs on eastern North Atlantic shores may be confounded by admixture of divergent lineages.     

Microgeographic variation in shell characters of Littorina saxatilis Olivi—a question mainly of size?

The question of whether there are shape differences between populations of Littorina saxatilis living in different environments is examined by multivariate analyses of 13 morphological characters. Principal component analysis reveals that morphologic differences between populations from habitats with contrasting degrees of wave exposure are mainly due to a general size factor, including shell thickness. Utilizing the group structure among the snails, canonical variate analysis discloses that the main character excluding size that influences subpopulation differentiation is pointedness.     

The close relationship between estimated divergent selection and observed differentiation supports the selective origin of a marine snail hybrid zone

To study the role of divergent selection in the differentiation of the two morphs in a hybrid zone of the intertidal snail Littorina saxatilis, we compared the strength of the divergent selection acting on a series of shell characters (as estimated by the viability of snails in a reciprocal transplant experiment) with the contribution of these characters to the phenotypic differences between the morphs. We found a close correlation between selection and differentiation, which suggests a cause-effect relationship, i.e. that all present differentiation is the result of past divergent selection. In addition, divergent selection was a very important component of the total natural selection acting on shell measures. These novel results support previous evidence, based on allozyme analysis, of a parapatric origin for this hybrid zone. We discuss possible limitations of this interpretation and the circumstances under which allopatric differentiation would produce the same results. Phenotypic analysis of divergent selection may be a useful method of investigating the evolutionary mechanisms involved in differentiation processes.     

Evolution of adaptation through allometric shifts in a marine snail

Variation in ontogenetic development among individuals may be a major contributor to morphological variation within species. Evolution of different growth trajectories might, for example, evolve as a response to varying ecological contexts of individuals living in different environments, or by life-stage or gender differences. The intertidal periwinkle Littorina saxatilis is strongly polymorphic in shell shape. We compared ontogenetic trajectories between life stages, local populations, and sexes to understand how different morphological end points are reached during ontogeny and what might cause these differences. Applying landmark-based geometric morphometrics, we captured shell shape variation for four Swedish populations of this species. We also derived a method to visualize ontogenetic trajectories described by the relationship of size to the multivariate shape space. We found that growth trajectories differed between individuals living in different habitats, as well as between sexes and maturity stages. Males living on rocky cliffs grew isometrically throughout life, whereas females from the same habitat switched from isometric growth as juveniles to allometric growth as adults. In contrast, males and females living on boulders grew allometrically as juveniles but changed to isometric growth at sexual maturity. Thus, in this species, ontogenetic growth seems influenced by habitat-associated selection as well as by gender and age-specific selection. These differing selection regimes result in ontogenetic shifts in allometry in three of the four groups examined.     

Infection of the mollusc Littorina saxatilis with parthenites of trematodes and their impact on a shell form: analysis of populations inhabiting the littoral coast of the White Sea

12 rocky shore populations of Littorina saxatilis from three islands of Chupa Inlet (Kandalaksha Bay, White Sea) were examined for infection with trematodes. Morphometric characters (6 indexes of the shell and aperture shape) of molluscs were investigated for all these populations. Exposed and sheltered sites were considered at every island and high and low littoral samples were fulfilled at every site. Seven species of trematodes, Podocotyle atomon, Cryptocotyle lingua, Renicola sp., Himasthla sp., Microphallus piriformes, M. pygmaeus, M. pseudopygmaeus, were found. Uneven distribution of trematodes was confirmed by log-linear analysis. Sheltered populations of L. saxatilis have the greater infection prevalence than exposed ones. This is due to the heavy infection with M. piriformes and M. pygmaeus. The prevalences by these trematodes are up to 52.97% and 27.16% respectively in sheltered populations of the host. The prevalence of M. piriformes tend to be higher at the upper shore level of sheltered sites. In a contrast, the prevalence of M. pygmaeus is significantly higher at the low part of such sites. Factor analysis shows a significant association of the indices of L. saxatilis shell shape with three factors. The first one is associated with the "elongation" of a shell and reveals L. saxatilis from the exposed rocky shore to be more elongated than the molluscs from sheltered sites. The second one is connected with the "aperture shape" index. There is an association of this factor with the shore level position of samples. The third factor reflects the affect of trematodes on the shell shape. The molluscs infected with M. piriformes show "elongated" shell shape and relatively smaller aperture. Shall peculiarities of the hosts infected with M. piriformes and M. pygmaeus are somewhat different. The results of the factor analysis is justified by the series of analysis of variances on the values of shell indices (MANOVA) according to the factors "exposure", "shore level" and "infection".     

Assortative mating between two distinct micro-allopatric populations of Littorina saxatilis (Olivi) on the northeast coast of England

Size assortative mating is a common invertebrate mating pattern and is usually accompanied by male and female sexual selection, and these three behaviours can contribute to reproductive isolation. Two distinct populations of the marine prosobranch Littorina saxatilis, H and M, occur within 15 m of each other on the same shore. Previous studies have demonstrated that these two forms have different reproductive strategies and that the rare hybrids between the two forms show evidence of reproductive dysfunction and hence are less fit than the assumed parental forms. In both populations, female shell height was shown to be a predictor of the number of embryos contained within the brood pouch. The mean shell height of the M population was significantly larger than that of the H population, and the M population matures at a larger shell size than the H population. The two populations show complete assortative mating to type in the field, and occupy different microhabitats on the same shore. Therefore, laboratory-based experiments were performed to determine if assortative mating was maintained in sympatry and also to determine the effect of population density on mate choice. The males of both populations showed sexual selection for female size, choosing to mate with females approximately 10% larger than themselves from an assortment of female sizes. The M population showed complete assortative mating to type, irrespective of the density of H and M females, whereas at low densities the H males did occasionally mate with M females. The role of assortative mating and reinforcement (due to natural selection acting against the less fit hybrids), in maintaining the partial reproductive barrier between the two populations is discussed.