Cardosins in postembryonic development of cardoon: towards an elucidation of the biological function of plant aspartic proteinases

Summary. Following on from previous work, the temporal and spatial accumulation of the aspartic proteinases (EC 3.4.23) cardosin A and cardosin B during postembryonic seed development of cardoon (Cynara cardunculus) was studied. mRNA and protein analyses of both cardosins suggested that the proteins accumulate during seed maturation, and that cardosin A is later synthesised de novo at the time of radicle emergence. Immunocytochemistry revealed that the precursor form of cardosin A accumulates in protein bodies and cell walls. This localisation in seeds is different from that previously described for cardoon flowers, suggesting a tissue-dependent targeting of the protein. It is known that procardosins are active and may have a role in proteolysis and processing of storage proteins. However, the presence of procardosin A in seeds could be related to the proposed role of the plant-specific insert in membrane lipid conversion during water uptake and solute leakage in actively growing tissues. This is in accordance with the recently proposed bifunctional role of aspartic proteinase precursor molecules that possess a membrane-destabilising domain in addition to a protease domain. Mature cardosin B, but not its mRNA, was detected in the first hours after seed imbibition and disappeared at the time of radicle emergence. This extracellular aspartic protease has already been implicated in cell wall loosening and remodelling, and its role in seed germination could be related to loosening tissue constraints for radicle protusion. The described pattern of cardosin A and B expression suggests a finely tuned developmental regulation and prompts an analysis of their possible roles in the physiology of postembryonic development. Correspondence: C. S. Pereira, Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology, Rua do Campo Alegre 823, 4150-180 Porto, Portugal.     

Dissecting cardosin B trafficking pathways in heterologous systems

In cardoon pistils, while cardosin A is detected in the vacuoles of stigmatic papillae, cardosin B accumulates in the extracellular matrix of the transmitting tissue. Given cardosins’ high homology and yet different cellular localisation, cardosins represent a potentially useful model to understand and study the structural and functional plasticity of plant secretory pathways. The vacuolar targeting of cardosin A was replicated in heterologous species so the targeting of cardosin B was examined in these systems. Inducible expression in transgenic Arabidopsis and transient expression in tobacco epidermal cells were used in parallel to study cardosin B intracellular trafficking and localisation. Cardosin B was successfully expressed in both systems where it accumulated mainly in the vacuole but it was also detected in the cell wall. The glycosylation pattern of cardosin B in these systems was in accordance with that observed in cardoon high-mannose-type glycans, suggesting that either the glycans are inaccessible to the Golgi processing enzymes due to cardosin B conformation or the protein leaves the Golgi in an early step before Golgi-modifying enzymes are able to modify the glycans. Concerning cardosin B trafficking pathway, it is transported through the Golgi in a RAB-D2a-dependent route, and is delivered to the vacuole via the prevacuolar compartment in a RAB-F2b-dependent pathway. Since cardosin B is secreted in cardoon pistils, its localisation in the vacuoles in cardoon ovary and in heterologous systems, suggests that the differential targeting of cardosins A and B in cardoon pistils results principally from differences in the cells in which these two proteins are expressed.     

Cardosin A endocytosis mediated by integrin leads to lysosome leakage and apoptosis of epithelial cells

Cardosin A is an aspartic protease present in large amount in the pistils of cardoon flowers. This protease is known to contain an -Arg-Gly-Asp- (RGD) motif located on the molecular surface. In this study, we found that isolated recombinant cardosin A attached to human epithelial cells A549, mediated by the binding of its RGD motif to cell surface integrins. The cell bound cardosin A was internalized to endosomes and lysosomes and triggered the permeability of lysosomal membrane leading to apoptosis of the epithelial cells. These events are identical to those observed for three RGD-containing aspartic proteases, Saps 4-6, secreted by Candida albicans. Such a process, which has been called the Trojan Horse mechanism, is believed to benefit the invasion of C. albican into the epithelium of the host. The location of the RGD motifs of cardosin A and Saps 4-6 are on the opposite ends of the homologous three-dimensional structures, suggesting that the Trojan Horse mechanism is insensitive to the RGD position. Current finding also suggests that cardosin A may have a defensive function against the ingestion of cardoon flowers by human, insects, and other herbivores.     

Multiplicity of aspartic proteinases from Cynara cardunculus L.

Aspartic proteinases (AP) play major roles in physiologic and pathologic scenarios in a wide range of organisms from vertebrates to plants or viruses. The present work deals with the purification and characterisation of four new APs from the cardoon Cynara cardunculus L., bringing the number of APs that have been isolated, purified and biochemically characterised from this organism to nine. This is, to our knowledge, one of the highest number of APs purified from a single organism, consistent with a specific and important biological function of these protein within C. cardunculus. These enzymes, cardosins E, F, G and H, are dimeric, glycosylated, pepstatin-sensitive APs, active at acidic pH, with a maximum activity around pH 4.3. Their primary structures were partially determined by N- and C-terminal sequence analysis, peptide mass fingerprint analysis on a MALDI-TOF/TOF instrument and by LC–MS/MS analysis on a Q-TRAP instrument. All four enzymes are present on C. cardunculus L. pistils, along with cyprosins and cardosins A and B. Their micro-heterogeneity was detected by 2D-electrophoresis and mass spectrometry. The enzymes resemble cardosin A more than they resemble cardosin B or cyprosin, with cardosin E and cardosin G being more active than cardosin A, towards the synthetic peptide KPAEFF(NO₂)AL. The specificity of these enzymes was investigated and it is shown that cardosin E, although closely related to cardosin A, exhibits different specificity. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Hydrolysis of whey proteins by proteases extracted from Cynara cardunculus and immobilized onto highly activated supports

Blends of cardosins A and B, enzymes present in aqueous extracts of the flowers of the thistle (Cynara cardunculus L.), have for long been used as rennets by the cheesemaking industry in the Iberian Peninsula. These dimeric proteases are present in the stigmae and stylets of said flowers, and are thought to play a role in sexual reproduction of the plant. In the present research effort, production of cardosin derivatives (starting from a crude extract), encompassing full stabilization of their dimeric structure, has been attempted via covalent, multi-subunit immobilization onto highly activated agarose-glutaraldehyde supports. Boiling such enzyme derivatives in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate and beta-mercaptoethanol did not lead to leaching of enzyme, thus proving the effectiveness of the attachment procedure. Furthermore, derivatives prepared under optimal conditions presented ca. half the specific activity of the enzyme in soluble form, and were successfully employed at lab-scale trials to perform (selective) hydrolysis of alpha-lactalbumin, one of the major proteins in bovine whey.     

Purification, cloning and autoproteolytic processing of an aspartic proteinase from Centaurea calcitrapa.

Plant aspartic proteinases (APs) have been isolated from several seed and leaf sources but the only well characterized enzymes from flowers are cardosins and cyprosins from cardoon, Cynara cardunculus L. Here we report a full-length cDNA clone encoding an AP named cenprosin from the flowers of Centaurea calcitrapa L., a thistle related to cardoon. As found for all eukaryotic APs, the deduced primary sequence consists of a signal sequence, a propart and a mature enzyme. In addition, an internal sequence region of 104 residues typical only of plant APs (a plant-specific insert) is present in the primary structure. Northern analysis revealed that the strongest expression is in fresh flowers. The enzyme is also expressed in fairly high amounts in seeds and in leaves, a feature not detected for cardoon APs. The corresponding enzyme was purified in its precursor form from fresh flowers using ammonium-sulfate precipitation followed by ion-exchange and hydrophobic-interaction chromatography. The processing of the precursor into its mature form was studied in vitro. The enzyme underwent autocatalytic processing at pH 3.0 resulting in two chains of 16 and 30 kDa. When dried flowers were used as a starting material for purification, only 16- and 30-kDa chains were obtained, suggesting that autoproteolytic activation of procenprosin in vivo occurs mainly during drying of the flowers. This may indicate a specific degradative role for the enzyme during senescence of the flowers.     

Allocation of proteolytic activity in the seedling of Cynara cardunculus L. in the initial growth stages

Cynara cardunculus L. seeds were germinated in vitro under environmentally controlled conditions. Seeds showed a 60% germination rate, and three growth stages were established based on the seedling mean relative growth rate (RGR). Root, stem and cotyledons were compared in these stages with respect to the emergence of total proteases and cardosin activity and its allocation in the seedling. In growth stage I (1st-5th post-germinative days), seedlings grew very slowly. Total proteases and cardosins were already active at the onset of seedlings in the stem. Total soluble protein remained constant in cardoon seedlings during stage I, and the content of all free amino acids (aa) but proline (Pro) was equally allocated on the 1st post-germinative day. In growth stage II (5th-10th post-germinative days), seedlings grew intensively and exhibited fully developed cotyledons. A pronounced increase in the content of all free aa up to the middle of growth stage II in both stems and roots was observed. In addition, the allocation of the total proteolytic activity and cardosins followed a gradient from the root to the seedling shoot. However, the whole seedling soluble protein remained constant up to the 7th day in and tended to peak on the 10th post-germinative day, being allocated mainly to the seedling stem. In growth stage III (10th-15th post-germinative days), cardoon seedlings exhibited the lowest mean RGR and the highest R/S growth ratio. An intensive degradation of total soluble protein present in the whole seedling except for cotyledons (ca. 5-fold) was observed. Nevertheless, in growth stage III, both the gradients exhibited by total proteases and cardosins activities between the root and the seedling shoot were enhanced, as were contents of all aa except Pro, exhibiting the highest levels in cotyledons on the 15th post-germinative day.     

The embryo sac of Cynara cardunculus: ultrastructure of the development and localisation of the aspartic proteinase cardosin B

Cynara cardunculus is a native plant with flowers that are used traditionally in the manufacture of ewe’s cheese in the Iberian Peninsula. Milk clotting ability of the plant is attributed to the high concentrations of aspartic proteinases (APs), named cardosins, found in the flowers. Although these enzymes are well characterised on a molecular and biochemical basis, the biological role of the majority of plant APs is yet unassigned. We suspected APs play an important role in ovule function, and we characterised the maturation of the ovules of C. cardunculus and its Polygonum-type embryo sacs. The internal layer of the integument differentiates into an endothelium as described for other Asteraceae, with differentiation of two nucellar layers, a podium and a hypostase coinciding with the onset of pollen receptivity. In flowering plants, programmed cell death (PCD) events are essential for the success of nucellar maturation and consequent differentiation of a fully functional embryo sac. In C. cardunculus, nucellar PCD is integral to the maturation of the embryo sac, which in turn is closely correlated with the accumulation of the AP cardosin B specifically in the hypostase. The onset of cardosin B expression temporally coincides with the degeneration of nucellar cells. In fully mature embryo sacs, cardosin B is localised in both the hypostase and epistase, two regions that differentiate through PCD. Thus, cardosin B localisations closely correlate with events of PCD in the nucellus of C. cardunculus suggesting involvement in ovule and embryo sac development and further suggest the biological significance of APs like cardosin B, in this particular process. This work contributes new data to the plant AP research field and indicates an involvement of cardosin B in the PCD-dependent degeneration of the nucellus.     

Identification of proteins from wild cardoon flowers (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Cynara cardunculus L.</Emphasis>) by a proteomic approach

Proteomic approach was applied to identify total proteins, particularly the enzymatic content, from wild cardoon flowers. As the selection of an appropriate sample preparation method is the key for getting reliable results, two different extraction/precipitation methods (trichloroacetic acid and phenol/ammonium acetate) were tested on fresh and lyophilized flowers. After two-dimensional electrophoresis (2D–E) separations, a better protein pattern was obtained after phenol extraction from lyophilized flowers. Only 46 % of the total analyzed spots resulted in a protein identification by mass spectrometry MALDI-TOF. Four proteases (cardosins A, E, G, and H), which have become a subject of great interest in dairy technology, were identified. They presented molecular weights and isoelectric points very close and high levels of homology between matched peptides sequences. The absence of the other cardosins (B, C, D, and F) could be an advantage, as it reduces the excessive proteolytic activity that causes bitter flavors and texture defects, during cheese making.     

The vegetable rennet of Cynara cardunculus L. contains two proteinases with chymosin and pepsin-like specificities

The flowers of cardoon (genus Cynara) are traditionally used in Portugal for cheese making. In this work the vegetable rennet of the species Cynara cardunculus L. was characterized in terms of enzymic composition and proteolytic specificity of its proteinases (cardosin A and cardosin B). Cardosin A was found to cleave insulin B chain at the bonds Leu15-Tyr16, Leu17-Val18 and Phe25-Tyr26. In addition to the bonds mentioned cardosin B cleaves also Glu13-Ala14, Ala14-Leu15 and Phe24-Phe25 indicating that it has a broader specificity. The kinetic parameters for the hydrolysis of the synthetic peptide Leu-Ser-Phe(NO₂)-Nle-Ala-Leu-oMe were also determined and compared to those of chymosin and pepsin. The results obtained indicate that in terms of specificity and kinetic parameters cardosin A is similar to chymosin whereas cardosin B is similar to pepsin. It appears therefore that the enzyme composition of cardoon rennet closely resembles that of calf rennet.     

Processing, activity, and inhibition of recombinant cyprosin, an aspartic proteinase from cardoon (Cynara cardunculus).

The cDNA encoding the precursor of an aspartic proteinase from the flowers of the cardoon, Cynara cardunculus, was expressed in Pichia pastoris, and the recombinant, mature cyprosin that accumulated in the culture medium was purified and characterized. The resultant mixture of microheterogeneous forms was shown to consist of glycosylated heavy chains (34 or 32 kDa) plus associated light chains with molecular weights in the region of 14,000-18,000, resulting from excision of most, but not all, of the 104 residues contributed by the unique region known as the plant specific insert. SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis under non-reducing conditions indicated that disulfide bonding held the heavy and light chains together in the heterodimeric enzyme forms. In contrast, when a construct was expressed in which the nucleotides encoding the 104 residues of the plant specific insert were deleted, the inactive, unprocessed precursor form (procyprosin) accumulated, indicating that the plant-specific insert has a role in ensuring that the nascent polypeptide is folded properly and rendered capable of being activated to generate mature, active proteinase. Kinetic parameters were derived for the hydrolysis of a synthetic peptide substrate by wild-type, recombinant cyprosin at a variety of pH and temperature values and the subsite requirements of the enzyme were mapped using a systematic series of synthetic inhibitors. The significance is discussed of the susceptibility of cyprosin to inhibitors of human immunodeficiency virus proteinase and particularly of renin, some of which were found to have subnanomolar potencies against the plant enzyme.     

Aspartic proteinase genes in the Brassicaceae Arabidopsis thaliana and Brassica napus

Active aspartic proteinase is isolated from Brassica napus seeds and the peptide sequence is used to generate primers for PCR. We present here cDNA and genomic clones for aspartic proteinases from the closely related Brassicaceae Arabidopsis thaliana and Brassica napus. The Arabidopsis cDNA represents a single gene, while Brassica has at least 4 genes. Like other plant aspartic proteases, the two Brassicaceae enzymes contain an extra protein domain of about 100 amino acids relative to the mammalian forms. The intron/exon arrangement in the Brassica genomic clone is significantly different from that in mammalian genes. As the proteinase is isolated from seeds, the same tissue where 2S albumins are processed, this implies expression of one of the aspartic proteinase genes there.     

Purification of cynarases from artichoke (Cynara scolymus L.): enzymatic properties of cynarase A

Aspartic proteinases from flowers of Cynara cardunculus have been extensively studied and long used as coagulants in the manufacture of several traditional Spanish and Portuguese cheeses. These endopeptidases are called cardosins or cynarases, depending on the authors. However, the proteinases of another plant of the genus Cynara, the artichoke (Cynara scolymus), are less known, probably because the flower of this plant is usually consumed as a vegetable. In the study described here, three proteinases (cynarases A, B and C) with milk-clotting properties were purified from the stigma of artichoke. All three proteinases are glycoproteins and composed of a one large and one small subunit. The enzymatic properties of cynarase A, a glycoprotein containing N-linked high mannose type glycans, which express maximum activity at pH 5.0 and 70 degrees C, were studied in detail. Catalytic and inhibition studies indicated that this cynarase is of the aspartic acid type. The results indicate artichoke extract could also be used in the milk industry in the same way as the extract obtained from the flower of C. cardunculus.     

Cloning and characterization of cDNA encoding cardosin A, an RGD-containing plant aspartic proteinase.

Cardosin A is an abundant aspartic proteinase from pistils of Cynara cardunculus L. whose milk-clotting activity has been exploited for the manufacture of cheese. Here we report the cloning and characterization of cardosin A cDNA. The deduced amino acid sequence contains the conserved features of plant aspartic proteinases, including the plant-specific insertion (PSI), and revealed the presence of an Arg-Gly-Asp (RGD) motif, which is known to function in cell surface receptor binding by extracellular proteins. Cardosin A mRNA was detected predominantly in young flower buds but not in mature or senescent pistils, suggesting that its expression is likely to be developmentally regulated. Procardosin A, the single chain precursor, was found associated with microsomal membranes of flower buds, whereas the active two-chain enzyme generated upon removal of PSI is soluble. This result implies a role for PSI in promoting the association of plant aspartic proteinase precursors to cell membranes. To get further insights about cardosin A, the functional relevance of the RGD motif was also investigated. A 100-kDa protein that interacts specifically with the RGD sequence was isolated from octyl glucoside pollen extracts by affinity chromatography on cardosin A-Sepharose. This result suggests that the 100-kDa protein is a cardosin A receptor and indicates that the interaction between these two proteins is apparently mediated through RGD recognition. It is possible therefore that cardosin A may have a role in adhesion-mediated proteolytic mechanisms involved in pollen recognition and growth.     

Widespread tissue expression of nepenthesin-like aspartic protease genes in Arabidopsis thaliana.

There are approximately 69 genes encoding aspartyl protease homologues in Arabidopsis thaliana, and most of the gene products constitute a novel subfamily of aspartic proteases. However, their physiological roles are largely unknown. As an initial step to shed light on the roles of these nepenthesin-like aspartic proteases (NAPs), a phylogenetic tree was constructed, which indicated that these proteases are classified into several distinct sub-sub-groups. Based on these results, specific primers were designed for genes selected from several of these groups and their tissue expression was investigated using RT-PCR. The results indicated that these genes are widely expressed in several tissues, such as leaves, stems, seeds and pods, suggesting ubiquitous occurrence and multiple functions of the corresponding proteases in the tissues of A. thaliana.     

Isolation and characterization of a cDNA from flowers of Cynara cardunculus encoding cyprosin (an aspartic proteinase) and its use to study the organ-specific expression of cyprosin

Poly(A)⁺ RNA isolated from flower buds of Cynara cardunculus has been used to prepare a cDNA library. Screening of the cDNA after expression of cloned DNA with antibodies raised against the large subunit of cyprosin 3 resulted in the isolation of six positive clones. One of these clones (cypro1s; a 1.7 kb Eco RI fragment) codes for cyprosin. The nucleotide sequence contain a 1419 bp open reading frame coding for 473 amino acids (aa) including a putative full-length mature protein (440 aa) and a partial prosequence (33 aa). Cypro1s contains a 162 bp 3 non-coding region followed by a poly(A) tail. The deduced amino acid sequence shows high homology to other plant aspartic proteinases. The homology to mammalian and microbial aspartic proteinases is somewhat lower. Plant aspartic proteinases contain an insert of around 100 aa. We are modelling where this plant-specific insert will appear in the structure of cyprosin. Using cypro1s as a probe in northern blot analysis, the expression of cyprosin in developing flowers and other tissues has been studied. The signal on the northern blot increased for RNA samples from early (flower buds 6 mm in length) to later stages of floral development (flower buds up to 40 mm in length). In late stages of floral development (open flowers 50 mm in length and styles from such flowers) no hybridization signal was visualized showing that the synthesis of mRNA encoding the cyprosin starts in early stages of floral development and switches off at maturation of the flower. Southern blot analysis of genomic DNA showed 4–5 strong hybridizing bands and several minor bands indicating that the cyprosin genes are organized as a multi-gene family in C. cardunculus.     

Processing and trafficking of a single isoform of the aspartic proteinase cardosin A on the vacuolar pathway

Cardosin A is the major vacuolar aspartic proteinase (APs) (E.C.3.4.23) in pistils of Cynara cardunculus L. (cardoon). Plant APs carry a unique domain, the plant-specific-insert (PSI), and a pro-segment which are separated from the catalytic domains during maturation but the sequence and location of processing steps for cardosins have not been established. Here transient expression in tobacco and inducible expression in Arabidopsis indicate that processing of cardosin A is conserved in heterologous species. Pulse chase analysis in tobacco protoplasts indicated that cleavage at the carboxy-terminus of the PSI could generate a short-lived 50 kDa intermediate which was converted to a more stable 35 kDa intermediate by removal of the PSI. Processing intermediates detected immunologically in tobacco leaves and Arabidopsis seedlings confirmed that cleavage at the amino-terminus of the PSI either preceded or followed quickly after cleavage at its carboxy-terminus. Thus removal of PSI preceded the loss of the prosegment in contrast to the well-characterised barley AP, phytepsin. PreprocardosinA acquired a complex glycan and its processing was inhibited by brefeldin A and dominant-inhibitory AtSAR1 or AtRAB-D2^a mutants indicating that it was transported via the Golgi and that processing followed ER export. The 35 kDa intermediate was present in the cell wall and protoplast culture medium as well as the vacuole but the 31 kDa mature subunit, lacking the amino-terminal prosegment, was detected only in the vacuole. Thus maturation appears to occur only after sorting from the trans-Golgi to the vacuole. Processing or transport of cardosin A was apparently slower in tobacco protoplasts than in whole cells. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.