In vitro pollen embryogenesis in Nicotiana tabacum L. and its relation to pollen sterility,sex balance,and floral induction of the pollen donor plants

Pollen sterility, sex balance, and floral induction of the pollen donor plants were tested for a possible relation to embryogenesis from in vitro cultured tobacco pollen (Nicotiana tabacum L. var. Badischer Burley). The pollen grains destined to become embryos in culture (P-grains) were sterile for the donor plants as judged by their staining reaction with acetocarmine and fluorescin-diacetate, and by an in vitro germination test. They were produced in high frequency in flowers which exhibited a shift in sex balance towards femaleness. Sex balance could be measured by the relative length of pistil to stamens. High P-grain frequency, high pollen sterility, and a shift in sex balance towards femaleness could be induced by raising the donor plants under short days and/or low temperature (18–15° C) as compared to long days at 24° C. Short days and/or low temperature also reinforced floral induction, revealing that the tobacco variety Badischer Burley is a quantitative short day and low temperature plant and that the variety follows the rule that conditions of strong floral induction shift sex balance towards femaleness. At 12° C and short days, contabescent flowers were formed with completely sterile anthers containing a few and mostly collapsed P-grains. Based on these results, it is now possible to predict conditions by which haploids via pollen embryogenesis might be produced in high frequency from low-yielding and recalcitrant species.Abbreviations DPF dead pollen grain frequency - LD24 long days at 24° C - PD pollen dimorphism - P:S ratio of pistil to stamen length - SD15 short days at 15° C     

In vitro differentiation of embryogenic pollen,control by cold treatment and embryo formation inab initio pollen cultures ofNicotiana tabacum var. badischer burley

Summary InNicotiana cold treatment causes differentiation of embryogenic pollen. This differentiation initiates on the plant and is completed in culture. Differentiation on the plant results in pollen dimorphism and differentiation in culture leads to pollen embryogenesis. An increased number of pollen capable of embryogenesis is possible on plants induced to flower in short days and low temperature (8 hours light, 18 °C). These embryogenic pollen on selective isolation, from buds at a petal length of 3.4±0.1 cm, fail to form embryos but do so in the cultures which receive cold treatment at 10 °C for 10 days. To some extent the differentiation of embryogenic pollen can be completed on plants induced to flower at 15 °C and embryogenic pollen from such plants form embryos at a low frequency which can be substantially increased on giving the cultures a cold treatment. The frequency of embryogenesis is higher in cultures of 15 °C plants than those of 18 °C plants. Low temperature requirements at two stages—to the plant and to the culture—are essential and complimentary for embryogenesis inab initio pollen cultures.Cold treatment causes repression of gametophytic differentiation and this results in the differentiation of embryogenic potential. The embryogenic pollen, unlike gametophytic pollen, are not fully differentiated structures. They are unable to divide and form embryos in presence of metabolic inhibitors such as actinomycin-D and cycloheximide.     

Differentiation of embryogenic pollen in cold-treated buds ofNicotiana tabacum var. Badischer burley and nutritional requirements of the isolated pollen to form embryos

Summary Embryogenic pollen were selectively isolated from buds after cold treatment at 10 °C for 10 days; it was immaterial whether the buds were taken from short day and low temperature (SD and LT; 8 hours light, 18 °C) or long day and high temperature (LD and HT; 16 hours light, 24 °C) plants. However, in buds from SD and LT plants the differentiation of embryogenic pollen could be detected as early as 7 days after the cold treatment, and pollen from these plants formed embryos at higher frequency (up to 4% of cultured pollen) than those from LD and HT plants (up to 1% only).The embryogenic pollen, in isolated buds, differentiated by way of pollen dimorphism. During cold treatment a fraction of pollen remained small, retained clear cytoplasm and was capable of embryogenesis in comparison to gametophytic pollen which enlarged and acquired granular cytoplasm. In our experiments cold treatment was a key factor in the induction of pollen dimorphism. This aspect of cold treatment in pollen embryogenesis is reported for the first time and was possible on the basis of selection of embryogenic pollen by density gradient centrifugation. The ratio of embryogenic pollen was about one fifth of the total population.The nutritional requirements of isolated pollen for embryogenesis were rather simple. These pollen formed embryos which readily developed into plantlets on a mineral medium supplemented with sucrose provided the pH was 6.8.     

High frequency production of embryos inDatura innoxia from isolated pollen grains by combined cold treatment and serial culture of anthers in liquid medium

Summary This study concerns the development of pollen embryos as affected by various physical conditions of culture in media devoid of hormones. Freshly isolated pollen, from anthers ofDatura, failed to form embryos regardless of whether they were cultured on liquid or solid medium. In contrast, pollen isolated from anthers precultured on solid medium did form embryos and the response could be increased by prior cold treatment of anthers at 4 °C for 4 days. However, the best results were obtained when anthers were cultured from the very beginning in liquid medium and transferred serially to fresh medium. Under such conditions, the anthers dehisced, allowing spontaneous shedding of pollen grains. It was thus possible to have several fractions of shed pollen continuing their development into embryos. When serial culture was started with anthers from cold-treated buds not only were embryos formed in all the fractions of shed pollen but the frequency was also considerably higher than in any mode of culturing.     

Androgenesis in isolated pollen cultures ofNicotiana tabacum: Dependence upon pollen development

Summary The influence of the stage of pollen development and of the growth conditions of donor plants on the performance of cultures of isolated pollen fromNicotiana tabacum, var. Badischer Burley has been studied. The method described includes cold treatment (4–5 °C for 3 days) and a pre-culture of the anthers for 7 days at 24 °C before the pollen is isolated. With this system reproducible results were obtained with pollen at the early binucleate stage collected from plants 11–13 weeks old. Another prerequisite for reproducibility is that the donor plants must have been grown for eight weeks in soil with an additional supply of mineral salts. Furthermore, the production of haploids by these pollen cultures was strongly influenced by the photoperiodic and temperature regime experienced by the donor plants; it was best (0.07%) with pollen from short-day plants (8 hours light per day at 18 °C) and rather weak (0.015%) with pollen from long-day plants (16 hours light per day at 24 °C). In contrast to other reports, haploid production from anther cultures was not influenced by the photoperiod or temperature.Cytological studies undertaken at the end of the pre-culture period showed that there were no differences in the percentage of potential embryos for the stages of the late uninucleate, 1. pollen mitosis and early binucleate pollen of long-day plants (1.5%). This value was considerably higher with pollen from short-day plants (7–9%), indicating that short-day conditions at 18 °C of the donor plants are favourable for the induction of androgenesis. However, only the potential embryos formed by the pollen at the initial binucleate stage were able to continue androgenetic development after isolation.     

Heteranthery as a solution to the demand for pollen as food and for pollination – Legitimate flower visitors reject flowers without feeding anthers

• Heteranthery, the presence of feeding and pollinating anthers in the same flower, seems to mediate the evolutionary dilemma for plants to protect their gametes and yet provide food for pollinators. This study aims to elucidate the role of heteranthery in the buzz‐pollinated Senna reniformis.
• The fecundity of pollen from long‐, medium‐ and short‐sized anthers was determined by hand cross‐pollination experiments, and the quantity, size, ornamentation and viability of pollen of different anthers were compared. Rates of flower rejection by bees were measured in anther removal experiments to assess the preferences of flower visitors for feeding or pollinating anthers.
• Large bees, which were the effective pollinators of self‐incompatible S. reniformis, avoided flowers without short feeding anthers, but not those without medium or long anthers. Illegitimate small and medium‐sized bees were unresponsive to anther exclusion experiments. Long anthers deposited pollen on the back and short anthers on the venter of large bees. Pollen from long anthers had higher in vitro viability and higher fruit and seed set after cross‐pollination than pollen from other sized anthers.
• Short anthers produce feeding pollen to effective pollinators and long anthers are related to pollination of S. reniformis. Bee behaviour and size was found to directly influence the role of anthers in the ‘division of labour’. Only large bee pollinators that carry the pollinating pollen from long anthers in ‘safe sites’ associated short anthers with the presence of food. In the absence of these larger bee pollinators, the role of heteranthery in S. reniformis would be strongly compromised and its function would be lost.

     

Ultrastructure of embryogenic pollen ofNicotiana tabacum var. Badischer burley

Summary Pollen grains capable of embryogenesis were selectively isolated from (a) near-mature buds from plants induced to flower in short days and low temperature (8 hours light and 18 °C) and (b) young buds from these plants with an additional low temperature treatment (10 °C for 10 days) and fixed for electron microscopy. The pollen from the former formed embryos at a very low frequency in culture, and at the subcellular level showed different degrees of regression of cytoplasm and mitochondria. On the contrary, cold-treated pollen were characterized by a high frequency of embryogenesis, up to 25% of the cultured pollen. They did not show regression of cytoplasm or organelles but had an attenuated cytoplasm which was not rich in ribosomes. Another noteworthy feature of embryogenic grains was the condensed nature of mitochondria. These characteristics of embryogenic grains indicate that they are repressed for gametophytic differentiation. The embryogenic pollen did not differentiate from gametophytic pollen which were very distinctive, having a thick exine, and dense cytoplasm rich in ribosomes. The close similarity of embryogenic grains with young microspores in terms of thin exine and sparse cytoplasm is suggestive of an indeterminate state and that determination into gametophytic or sporophytic (embryogenic) type is probably the function of differential gene activity. Of interest, in this context, is the condensation of mitochondria in embryogenic grains. The relationship, if any, between mitochondrial condensation and embryogenesis remains to be resolved.     

Nuclear DNA synthesis during the induction of embryogenesis in cultured microspores and pollen of Brassica napus L.

The dynamics of nuclear DNA synthesis were analysed in isolated microspores and pollen of Brassica napus that were induced to form embryos. DNA synthesis was visualized by the immunocytochemical labelling of incorporated Bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU), applied continuously or as a pulse during the first 24 h of culture under embryogenic (32 °C) and non-embryogenic (18 °C) conditions. Total DNA content of the nuclei was determined by microspectrophotometry. At the moment of isolation, microspore nuclei and nuclei of generative cells were at the G1, S or G2 phase. Vegetative nuclei of pollen were always in G1 at the onset of culture. When microspores were cultured at 18 °C, they followed the normal gametophytic development; when cultured at 32 °C, they divided symmetrically and became embryogenic or continued gametophytic development. Because the two nuclei of the symmetrically divided microspores were either both labelled with BrdU or not labelled at all, we concluded that microspores are inducible to form embryos from the G1 until the G2 phase. When bicellular pollen were cultured at 18 °C, they exhibited labelling exclusively in generative nuclei. This is comparable to the gametophytic development that occurs in vivo. Early bicellular pollen cultured at 32 °C, however, also exhibited replication in vegetative nuclei. The majority of vegetative nuclei re-entered the cell cycle after 12 h of culture. Replication in the vegetative cells preceded division of the vegetative cell, a prerequisite for pollen-derived embryogenesis.     

Microspore embryogenesis in anther cultures of two Indian cultivars of Brassica juncea (L.) Czern.

Direct microspore-derived embryo formation in anther cultures of two cultivars of Brassica juncea was obtained. Preliminary culture of anthers at 35°C for 1–5 days prior to maintenance at 25°C stimulated embryogenesis. Embryogenesis was also stimulated by an initial culture at 5°C for 3 days. Analysis of squashed anthers revealed that approximately 10% of the microspores began dividing, but less than 1% developed into macroscopic embryos. All embryos transferred to embryo culture medium survived, but only 30% of these developed directly into normal plantlets. The androgenic plants were haploid (2n=18).     

The frequency of embryogenic pollen grains is not increased by in vitro anther culture in Nicotiana tabacum L.

The numbers of embryogenic (S) grains present in in-situ mature anthers of Nicotiana tabacum L. were compared to the numbers of embryos and plantlets produced in cultured anthers excised at the optimal mitotic stage of development for anther culture. The Feulgen technique of staining embryos caused a considerable loss of grains from cultured anthers but this did not seriously affect the determination of the percentage of embryos present. In no instance did the numbers of embryos produced exceed the maximum number of S grains found, and the distributions of S grain and embryo frequencies in anthers were similar. In rare instances S grains which had undergone the first embryogenic division were observed in situ. The results indicate that all grains capable of embryogenesis are determined during early flower formation and that their number is not increased by in vitro culture.     

A study of factors affecting embryo yields from anther culture of cabbage

In cabbage (Brassica oleracea var. capitata), a thermal shock treatment of 24 h at 35 °C at the start of the culture period resulted in higher embryos per 100 anthers (30.0) compared to a treatment of 48 h. Similarly , a chilling treatment of 24 h at 4 °C resulted in a higher embryo yield (6.0) per 100 anthers compared to a treatment of 48 h. However, the embryo yields were significantly higher (p> 0.01) in thermal shock than chilling treatments in all experiments. Treatments of 6 days at either 35 °C or 4 °C gave no embryos. The most responsive cultivar was the F₁ hybrid , Hercules, in all experiments. Although anther culture was successful in the other genotypes, the open pollinated ones, the highest number of embryo yields per 100 anthers was obtained in the hybrid. High temperature treatment before culture had a beneficial effect on the embryo yields. The responsiveness of anthers to addition of increasing concentration of silver nitrate (AgN0₃) (the ethylene inhibitor) to the culture medium, showed a progressive increase in the embryo yields in all the genotypes. Since embryos were also formed in the absence of silver nitrate, probably, due to a greater genotype × medium interaction, it is noted that the presence of silver nitrate in the medium may not be essential for cabbage anther culture as reported earlier. The findings of this study may be recommended for large production of cabbage embryos in culture.     

Haploid plants from in vitro anther culture of the leguminous tree,Peltophorum pterocarpum (DC) K. Hayne (Copper pod)

The development of haploid callus, embryos and plantlets from cultured anthers and the various factors affecting androgenesis in Peltophorum pterocarpum (Copper pod), a tropical legume tree is reported. A pretreatment of flower buds at moderate temperature of 14°C for 8 days was most effective for callus production. The colour of the anther was found to be a reliable and efficient indicator for identification of suitable stage of anther for culture. The frequency of anthers which produced callus and shoots was highest when anthers were cultured at mid or late-uninucleate stage. A high sucrose concentration of 10% is a specific media requirement for androgenesis. The haploid nature of the embryos, callus and regenerated plants (n=14) were confirmed by chromosome count.Abbreviations 2,4-D 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid - KN kinetin - NAA naphthaleneacetic acid - BAP bezylaminopurine     

Bees assess pollen returns while sonicating Solanum flowers

Summary Can bees accurately gauge accumulating bodily pollen as they harvest pollen from flowers? Several recent reports conclude that bees fail to assess pollen harvest rates when foraging for nectar and pollen. A native nightshade (Solanum elaeagnifolium Cavanilles) that is visited exclusively for pollen by both solitary and social bees (eg. Ptiloglossa and Bombus) was studied in SE Arizona and SW New Mexico. The flowers have no nectaries. Two experiments were deployed that eliminated pollen feedback to the bees by experimentally manipulating flowers prior to bee visits. The two methods were 1) plugging poricidal anthers with glue and 2) emptying anthers of pollen by vibration prior to bee visitation. Both experiments demonstrated that bees directly assess pollen harvest on a flower-by-flower basis, and significantly tailor their handling times, number of vibratile buzzes per flower and grooming bouts according to the ongoing harvest on a given flower. In comparison to experimental flowers, floral handling times were extended for both Bombus and Ptiloglossa on virgin flowers. Greater numbers of intrafloral buzzes and numbers of times bees groomed pollen and packed it into their scopae while still on the flower were also more frequent at virgin versus experimental flowers. Flowers with glued andreocia received uniformly brief visits from Bombus and Ptiloglossa with fewer sonications and virtually no bouts of grooming. Curtailed handling with few buzzes and grooms also characterized visits to our manually harvested flowers wherein pollen was artificially depleted. Sonicating bees respond positively to pollen-feedback while harvesting from individual flowers, and therefore we expect them to adjust their harvesting tempo according to the currency of available pollen (standing crop) within Solanum floral patches.     

Selection of embryogenic pollen from cold-treated buds ofNicotiana tabacum var. badischer burley and their development into embryos in cultures

Summary By using density gradient centrifugation, employing 55% percoll and 4% sucrose as suspension medium, it is possible to select embryogenic pollen from buds after cold treatment at 10 °C for 8 or more days. These buds at the uninucleate stage of pollen were collected from plants grown in 8 hours photocycles at 18 °C and supplied with mineral salts. The embryogenic pollen are small, starch-free with a clear cytoplasm whereas large starch-filled ones are nonembryogenic. The embryogenic pollen regularly form embryos at a frequency of 2% on a mineral medium supplemented with glutamine, asparagine and sucrose at pH 6.5.These results demonstrate, for the first time, that it is possible to have embryos in appreciable frequencies in ab initio pollen cultures raised from cold treated anthers.On leave from University of Delhi.     

REVERSIBLE ANTHER OPENING IN LILIUM PHILADELPHICUM (LILIACEAE): A POSSIBLE MEANS OF ENHANCING MALE FITNESS

Studies of Lilium philadelphicum on Isle Royale National Park, Lake Superior, show that thecae (pollen-containing sacs) of dehisced anthers close in the rain, thus protecting the pollen and prolonging the pollen donor phase of the flower. To our knowledge, this is the first report of anthers with longitudinal dehiscence reclosing after opening. Individual flowers of L. philadelphicum are long lived (8–11 d), do not shorten their flowering period in response to successful fertilization of the ovules, and are primarily pollinated by butterflies. Butterflies do not forage in the rain and may first visit a flower several days after anthesis. Under such circumstances, strong selection may exist to protect pollen during unfavorable weather conditions in order to prolong the pollen donor phase. Flowers with long pollen donor phases are likely to contribute more offspring to the next generation than flowers with short pollen donor phases.     

Assessment of pollen reward and pollen availability in Solanum stramoniifolium and Solanum paniculatum for buzz‐pollinating carpenter bees

The two widespread tropical Solanum species S. paniculatum and S. stramoniifolium are highly dependent on the visits of large bees that pollinate the flowers while buzzing them. Both Solanum species do not offer nectar reward; the rewarding of bees is thus solely dependent on the availability of pollen. Flower visitors are unable to visually assess the amount of pollen, because the pollen is hidden in poricidal anthers. In this study we ask whether and how the amount of pollen determines the attractiveness of flowers for bees. The number of pollen grains in anthers of S. stramoniifolium was seven times higher than in S. paniculatum. By contrast, the handling time per five flowers for carpenter bees visiting S. paniculatum was 3.5 times shorter than of those visiting S. stramoniifolium. As a result foraging carpenter bees collected a similar number of pollen grains per unit time on flowers of both species. Experimental manipulation of pollen availability by gluing the anther pores showed that the carpenter bees were unable to detect the availability of pollen by means of chemical cues before landing and without buzzing. Our study shows that the efficiency of pollen collecting on S. paniculatum is based on large inflorescences with short between‐flower search times and short handling time of individual flowers, whereas that of S. stramoniifolium relies on a large amount of pollen per flower. Interestingly, large carpenter bees are able to adjust their foraging behaviour to drastically different strategies of pollen reward in otherwise very similar plant species.     

Division of labor of anthers in heterantherous plants: flexibility of bee pollen collection behavior may serve to keep plants honest

Heteranthery is thought to reflect a division of labor, with some anthers serving a pollinator-feeding function and others serving a pollinating function. Mutualism theory predicts that each participant should try to maximize the benefit it receives from its partner: plants should allocate more pollen to pollination, and pollinators should collect more pollen. Accordingly, plant and pollinator may engage in a ‘tug of war’ with respect to pollen from each anther type, resulting in incomplete division of labor. Here, we explored this idea by conducting a fully factorial manipulation of the availability of pollen in long and short anthers of staminate flowers of Solanum houstonii. We found the following: (1) Bumble bees (Bombus impatiens) preferred to sonicate (collect pollen from) short anthers over long anthers, consistent with a role as feeding and pollinating anthers, respectively; (2) Blocking short anther pores alone increased sonication of long anthers and resulted in collection of pollen from long anthers; (3) Blocking long anther pores alone did not influence sonication of short anthers; (4) The increase in sonication of long anthers, when short anther pores are blocked, was greater when pollen was available in long anthers; (5) Despite shifting sonication effort to long anthers, bees do not move their bodies closer to long anther pores where pollen could be collected more effectively; and (6) analysis of the growth of corbicular loads over time spent buzzing indicates that significant amounts of pollen are collected from long anthers as well as short anthers. We conclude that bees can flexibly increase pollen collection from pollinating anthers, but are constrained from fully exploiting this pollen. This results in checks and balances between plant and bee that may help maintain heteranthery.     

Modification of cell development in vitro: The effect of colchicine on anther and isolated microspore culture in Brassica napus

In an attempt to discover the biological basis of microspore derived embryogenesis, the effect of the antimicrotubule agent colchicine on anther and free microspore embryogenesis was investigated. The microtubule inhibitor colchicine promoted embryogenesis from cultured anthers, both with regard to the number of anthers responding and the number of embryos being produced per anther. A similar promotional response was also observed with cultured microspores. Although the parameters for cultured anthers and free microspores differed, administration of the drug for a short period immediately prior to pollen mitosis I seems to exert the maximum promotional effect. Of the five cultivars of Brassica napus studied, all responded to colchicine treatment. However, the drug did release more embryogenic potential in poor-responding varieties (i.e. Lirawell and Optima) than in the highest responding variety (Topas). Colchicine also resulted in increased embryogenic response in microspores cultured at lower temperatures.These results are considered in terms of models proposed to explain the switch in microspore development from a gametophytic to a sporophytic pathway. The use ofcolchicine as agent to promote embryogenesis in previously recalcitrant species other than Brassica is also discussed.     

Short-term storage of cotton pollen

Several methods of storing cotton pollen (Gossypium hirsutum L.) were evaluated. A successful pollen storage method that maintains fertility would enhance the crossing of breeding materials. Storing pollen at ultra-low temperatures in liquid nitrogen or at 5°C was not successful. No storage method maintained pollen fertility for more than 72 h. Cotton pollen did maintain adequate fertility up to 24 h at 10 and 15°C, at both low and high humidity when the pollen was stored in the detached flowers. Minimally acceptable pollen fertility was maintained in flowers stored at 15°C at 100% R.H. for 72 h. Use of these methods will allow for better utilization of parental plants when both parents do not flower on the same days.USDA-ARS, in cooperation with the New Mexico Agricultural Experimental Station, Journal Article No. 1161, Las Cruces, NM 88003, USA     

Maturation of maize pollen in vitro

Summary Maturation of maize pollen was obtained in male reproductive structures cultured in vitro. Immature tassels containing microspores at the mid-uninucleate to late-binucleate stage of development were excised and spikelets, anthers, and/or isolated microspores were cultured on a medium capable of supporting pollen maturation. Microspore mitosis, culminating in the production of starch-filled, trinucleate pollen capable of germination, was observed after 7–15 days, depending on the genotype and stage at which the cultures were initiated. Up to 100%, 70%, and 20% of the cultured spikelets, anthers, and isolated microspores, respectively, produced mature pollen, which germinated, however, at different frequencies (i.e., spikelets, 50–70%; anthers, 5–10%; microspores, <1%). Mature kernels were produced following fertilization with pollen from cultured spikelets and anthers. These procedures provide methods for the in vitro manipulation of a significant phase of the maize life cycle.