Differential binding between PatS C-terminal peptide fragments and HetR from Anabaena sp. PCC 7120

Heterocyst differentiation in the filamentous cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120 occurs at regular intervals under nitrogen starvation and is regulated by a host of signaling molecules responsive to availability of fixed nitrogen. The heterocyst differentiation inhibitor PatS contains the active pentapeptide RGSGR (PatS-5) at its C-terminus considered the minimum PatS fragment required for normal heterocyst pattern formation. PatS-5 is known to bind HetR, the master regulator of heterocyst differentiation, with a moderate affinity and a submicromolar dissociation constant. Here we characterized the affinity of HetR for several PatS C-terminal fragments by measuring the relative ability of each fragment to knockdown HetR binding to DNA in electrophoretic mobility shift assays and using isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). HetR bound to PatS-6 (ERGSGR) >30 times tighter (K(d) = 7 nM) than to PatS-5 (K(d) = 227 nM) and >1200 times tighter than to PatS-7 (DERGSGR) (K(d) = 9280 nM). No binding was detected between HetR and PatS-8 (CDERGSGR). Quantitative binding constants obtained from ITC measurements were consistent with qualitative results from the gel shift knockdown assays. CW EPR spectroscopy confirmed that PatS-6 bound to a MTSL spin-labeled HetR L252C mutant at a 10-fold lower concentration compared to PatS-5. Substituting the PatS-6 N-terminal glutamate to aspartate, lysine, or glycine did not alter binding affinity, indicating that neither the charge nor size of the N-terminal residue's side chain played a role in enhanced HetR binding to PatS-6, but rather increased binding affinity resulted from new interactions with the PatS-6 N-terminal residue peptide backbone.     

The RGSGR amino acid motif of the intercellular signalling protein, HetN, is required for patterning of heterocysts in Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120

Nitrogen-fixing heterocysts are arranged in a periodic pattern on filaments of the cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120 under conditions of limiting combined nitrogen. Patterning requires two inhibitors of heterocyst differentiation, PatS and HetN, which work at different stages of differentiation by laterally suppressing levels of an activator of differentiation, HetR, in cells adjacent to source cells. Here we show that the RGSGR sequence in the 287-amino-acid HetN protein, which is shared by PatS, is critical for patterning. Conservative substitutions in any of the five amino acids lowered the extent to which HetN inhibited differentiation when overproduced and altered the pattern of heterocysts in filaments with an otherwise wild-type genetic background. Conversely, substitution of amino acids comprising the putative catalytic triad of this predicted reductase had no effect on inhibition or patterning. Deletion of putative domains of HetN suggested that the RGSGR motif is the primary component of HetN required for both its inhibitory and patterning activity, and that localization to the cell envelope is not required for patterning of heterocysts. The intercellular signalling proteins PatS and HetN use the same amino acid motif to regulate different stages of heterocyst patterning.     

patS minigenes inhibit heterocyst development of Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120

The patS gene encodes a small peptide that is required for normal heterocyst pattern formation in the cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120. PatS is proposed to control the heterocyst pattern by lateral inhibition. patS minigenes were constructed and expressed by different developmentally regulated promoters to gain further insight into PatS signaling. patS minigenes patS4 to patS8 encode PatS C-terminal 4 (GSGR) to 8 (CDERGSGR) oligopeptides. When expressed by P(petE), P(patS), or P(rbcL) promoters, patS5 to patS8 inhibited heterocyst formation but patS4 did not. In contrast to the full-length patS gene, P(hepA)-patS5 failed to restore a wild-type pattern in a patS null mutant, indicating that PatS-5 cannot function in cell-to-cell signaling if it is expressed in proheterocysts. To establish the location of the PatS receptor, PatS-5 was confined within the cytoplasm as a gfp-patS5 fusion. The green fluorescent protein GFP-PatS-5 fusion protein inhibited heterocyst formation. Similarly, full-length PatS with a C-terminal hexahistidine tag inhibited heterocyst formation. These data indicate that the PatS receptor is located in the cytoplasm, which is consistent with recently published data indicating that HetR is a PatS target. We speculated that overexpression of other Anabaena strain PCC 7120 RGSGR-encoding genes might show heterocyst inhibition activity. In addition to patS and hetN, open reading frame (ORF) all3290 and an unannotated ORF, orf77, encode an RGSGR motif. Overexpression of all3290 and orf77 under the control of the petE promoter inhibited heterocyst formation, indicating that the RGSGR motif can inhibit heterocyst development in a variety of contexts.     

Functional dissection and evidence for intercellular transfer of the heterocyst‐differentiation PatS morphogen

The formation of a diazotrophic cyanobacterial filament represents a simple example of biological development. In Anabaena, a non‐random pattern of one nitrogen‐fixing heterocyst separated by about 10 photosynthetic vegetative cells results from lateral inhibition elicited by the cells differentiating into heterocysts. Key to this process is the patS gene, which has been shown to produce an inhibitor of heterocyst differentiation that involves the C‐terminal RGSGR pentapeptide. Complementation of a ΔpatS Anabaena mutant with different versions of PatS, including point mutations or tag fusions, showed that patS is translated into a 17‐amino acid polypeptide. Alterations in the N‐terminal part of PatS produced inhibition of heterocyst differentiation, thus this part of the peptide appears necessary for proper processing and self‐immunity in the producing cells. Alterations in the C‐terminal part of PatS led to over‐differentiation, thus supporting its role in inhibition of heterocyst differentiation. A polypeptide, produced in proheterocysts, consisting of a methionine followed by the eight, but not the five, terminal amino acids of PatS recreated the full activity of the native peptide. Immunofluorescence detection showed that an RGSGR‐containing peptide accumulated in the cells adjacent to the producing proheterocysts, illustrating intercellular transfer of a morphogen in the cyanobacterial filaments.     

Heterocyst patterns without patterning proteins in cyanobacterial filaments

We have quantitatively modeled heterocyst differentiation after fixed nitrogen step-down in the filamentous cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. PCC 7120 without lateral inhibition due to the patterning proteins PatS or HetN. We use cell growth and division together with fixed-nitrogen dynamics and allow heterocysts to differentiate upon the local exhaustion of available fixed nitrogen. Slow transport of fixed nitrogen along a shared periplasmic space allows for fast growing cells to differentiate ahead of their neighbors. Cell-to-cell variability in growth rate determines the initial heterocyst pattern. Early release of fixed nitrogen from committed heterocysts allows a significant fraction of vegetative cells to be retained at later times. We recover the experimental heterocyst spacing distributions and cluster size distributions of Khudyakov and Golden [Khudyakov, I.Y., Golden, J.W., 2004. Different functions of HetR, a master regulator of heterocyst differentiation in Anabaena sp PCC 7120, can be separated by mutation. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 101, 16040-16045].     

Subcellular Localization and Clues for the Function of the HetN Factor Influencing Heterocyst Distribution in Anabaena sp. Strain PCC 7120

In the filamentous cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120, heterocysts are formed in the absence of combined nitrogen, following a specific distribution pattern along the filament. The PatS and HetN factors contribute to the heterocyst pattern by inhibiting the formation of consecutive heterocysts. Thus, inactivation of any of these factors produces the multiple contiguous heterocyst (Mch) phenotype. Upon N stepdown, a HetN protein with its C terminus fused to a superfolder version of green fluorescent protein (sf-GFP) or to GFP-mut2 was observed, localized first throughout the whole area of differentiating cells and later specifically on the peripheries and in the polar regions of mature heterocysts, coinciding with the location of the thylakoids. Polar localization required an N-terminal stretch comprising residues 2 to 27 that may represent an unconventional signal peptide. Anabaena strains expressing a version of HetN lacking this fragment from a mutant gene placed at the native hetN locus exhibited a mild Mch phenotype. In agreement with previous results, deletion of an internal ERGSGR sequence, which is identical to the C-terminal sequence of PatS, also led to the Mch phenotype. The subcellular localization in heterocysts of fluorescence resulting from the fusion of GFP to the C terminus of HetN suggests that a full HetN protein is present in these cells. Furthermore, the full HetN protein is more conserved among cyanobacteria than the internal ERGSGR sequence. These observations suggest that HetN anchored to thylakoid membranes in heterocysts may serve a function besides that of generating a regulatory (ERGSGR) peptide.     

The 2A resolution crystal structure of HetL, a pentapeptide repeat protein involved in regulation of heterocyst differentiation in the cyanobacterium Nostoc sp. strain PCC 7120

The hetL gene from the cyanobacterium Nostoc sp. PCC 7120 encodes a 237 amino acid protein (25.6kDa) containing 40 predicted tandem pentapeptide repeats. Nostoc sp. PCC 7120 is a filamentous cyanobacterium that forms heterocysts, specialized cells capable of fixing atmospheric N(2) during nitrogen starvation in its aqueous environment. Under these conditions, heterocysts occur in a regular pattern of approximately one out of every 10-15 vegetative cells. Heterocyst differentiation is highly regulated involving hundreds of genes, one of which encodes PatS, thought to be an intercellular peptide signal made by developing heterocysts to inhibit heterocyst differentiation in neighboring vegetative cells, thus contributing to pattern formation and spacing of heterocysts along the filament. While overexpression of PatS suppresses heterocyst differentiation in Nostoc sp. PCC 7120, overexpression of HetL produces a multiple contiguous heterocyst phenotype with loss of the wild type heterocyst pattern, and strains containing extra copies of hetL allow heterocyst formation even in cells overexpressing PatS. Thus, HetL appears to interfere with heterocyst differentiation inhibition by PatS, however, the mechanism for HetL function remains unknown. As a first step towards exploring the mechanism for its biochemical function, the crystal structure of HetL has been solved at 2.0A resolution using sulfur anomalous scattering.     

The role of HetN in maintenance of the heterocyst pattern in Anabaena sp. PCC 7120

The gene hetN encodes a putative oxidoreductase that is known to suppress heterocyst differentiation when present on a multicopy plasmid in Anabaena sp. PCC 7120. To mimic the hetN null phenotype and to examine where HetN acts in the regulatory cascade that controls heterocyst differentiation, we replaced the native chromosomal hetN promoter with the copper-inducible petE promoter. In the presence of copper, heterocyst formation was suppressed in undifferentiated filaments. When hetN expression was turned off by transferring cells to media lacking copper, the filaments initially displayed the wild-type pattern of single heterocysts but, 48 h after the induction of heterocyst formation, a pattern of multiple contiguous heterocysts predominated. Suppression of heterocyst formation by HetN appears to occur both upstream and downstream of the positive regulator HetR: overexpression of hetN in undifferentiated filaments prevents the wild-type pattern of hetR expression as well as the multiheterocyst phenotype normally observed when hetR is expressed from an inducible promoter. Green fluorescent protein fusions show that the expression of hetN in wild-type filaments normally occurs primarily in heterocysts. We propose that HetN is normally involved in the maintenance of heterocyst spacing after the initial heterocyst pattern has been established, but ectopic expression of hetN can also block the initial establishment of the pattern.     

Mutagenesis of hetR reveals amino acids necessary for HetR function in the heterocystous cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120

HetR is the master regulator of heterocyst differentiation in the filamentous cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120. Genetic selection was used to identify 33 amino acid substitutions in HetR that reduced the proportion of cells undergoing heterocyst differentiation to less than 2%. Conservative substitutions in the wild-type HetR protein revealed three mutations that dramatically reduced the amount of heterocyst differentiation when the mutant allele was present in place of the wild-type allele on a replicating plasmid in a mutant lacking hetR on the chromosome. An H69Y substitution resulted in heterocyst formation among less than 0.1% of cells, and D17E and G36A substitutions resulted in a Het- phenotype, compared to heterocyst formation among approximately 25% of cells with the wild-type hetR under the same conditions. The D17E substitution prevented DNA binding activity exhibited by wild-type HetR in mobility shift assays, whereas G36A and H69Y substitutions had no affect on DNA binding. D17E, G36A, and H69Y substitutions also resulted in higher levels of the corresponding HetR protein than of the wild-type protein when each was expressed from an inducible promoter in a hetR deletion strain, suggesting an effect on HetR protein turnover. Surprisingly, C48A and S152A substitutions, which were previously reported to result in a Het- phenotype, were found to have no effect on heterocyst differentiation or patterning when the corresponding mutations were introduced into an otherwise wild-type genetic background in Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120. The clustering of mutations that satisfied the positive selection near the amino terminus suggests an important role for this part of the protein in HetR function.     

Heterocyst formation in cyanobacteria

When deprived of combined nitrogen, many filamentous cyanobacteria develop a one-dimensional pattern of specialised nitrogen-fixing cells, known as heterocysts. Recent years have seen the identification and characterisation of some of the key genes and proteins involved in heterocyst development and spacing, including the positive regulator HetR and the diffusible inhibitor PatS.     

Heterocyst differentiation and pattern formation in cyanobacteria: a chorus of signals

Heterocyst differentiation in filamentous cyanobacteria provides an excellent prokaryotic model for studying multicellular behaviour and pattern formation. In Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120, for example, 5-10% of the cells along each filament are induced, when deprived of combined nitrogen, to differentiate into heterocysts. Heterocysts are specialized in the fixation of N(2) under oxic conditions and are semi-regularly spaced among vegetative cells. This developmental programme leads to spatial separation of oxygen-sensitive nitrogen fixation (by heterocysts) and oxygen-producing photosynthesis (by vegetative cells). The interdependence between these two cell types ensures filament growth under conditions of combined-nitrogen limitation. Multiple signals have recently been identified as necessary for the initiation of heterocyst differentiation, the formation of the heterocyst pattern and pattern maintenance. The Krebs cycle metabolite 2-oxoglutarate (2-OG) serves as a signal of nitrogen deprivation. Accumulation of a non-metabolizable analogue of 2-OG triggers the complex developmental process of heterocyst differentiation. Once heterocyst development has been initiated, interactions among the various components involved in heterocyst differentiation determine the developmental fate of each cell. The free calcium concentration is crucial to heterocyst differentiation. Lateral diffusion of the PatS peptide or a derivative of it from a developing cell may inhibit the differentiation of neighbouring cells. HetR, a protease showing DNA-binding activity, is crucial to heterocyst differentiation and appears to be the central processor of various early signals involved in the developmental process. How the various signalling pathways are integrated and used to control heterocyst differentiation processes is a challenging question that still remains to be elucidated.     

Relationships between the ABC-Exporter HetC and Peptides that Regulate the Spatiotemporal Pattern of Heterocyst Distribution in Anabaena

In the model cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. PCC 7120, cells called heterocysts that are specialized in the fixation of atmospheric nitrogen differentiate from vegetative cells of the filament in the absence of combined nitrogen. Heterocysts follow a specific distribution pattern along the filament, and a number of regulators have been identified that influence the heterocyst pattern. PatS and HetN, expressed in the differentiating cells, inhibit the differentiation of neighboring cells. At least PatS appears to be processed and transferred from cell to cell. HetC is similar to ABC exporters and is required for differentiation. We present an epistasis analysis of these regulatory genes and of genes, hetP and asr2819, successively downstream from hetC, and we have studied the localization of HetC and HetP by use of GFP fusions. Inactivation of patS, but not of hetN, allowed differentiation to proceed in a hetC background, whereas inactivation of hetC in patS or patS hetN backgrounds decreased the frequency of contiguous proheterocysts. A HetC-GFP protein is localized to the heterocysts and especially near their cell poles, and a putative HetC peptidase domain was required for heterocyst differentiation but not for HetC-GFP localization. hetP is also required for heterocyst differentiation. A HetP-GFP protein localized mostly near the heterocyst poles. ORF asr2819, which we denote patC, encodes an 84-residue peptide and is induced upon nitrogen step-down. Inactivation of patC led to a late spreading of the heterocyst pattern. Whereas HetC and HetP appear to have linked functions that allow heterocyst differentiation to progress, PatC may have a role in selecting sites of differentiation, suggesting that these closely positioned genes may be functionally related.     

Maintenance of heterocyst patterning in a filamentous cyanobacterium

In the absence of sufficient combined nitrogen, some filamentous cyanobacteria differentiate nitrogen-fixing heterocysts at approximately every 10th cell position. As cells between heterocysts grow and divide, this initial pattern is maintained by the differentiation of a single cell approximately midway between existing heterocysts. This paper introduces a mathematical model for the maintenance of the periodic pattern of heterocysts differentiated by Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120 based on the current experimental knowledge of the system. The model equations describe a non-diffusing activator (HetR) and two inhibitors (PatS and HetN) that undergo diffusion in a growing one-dimensional domain. The inhibitors in this model have distinct diffusion rates and temporal expression patterns. These unique aspects of the model reflect recent experimental findings regarding the molecular interactions that regulate patterning in Anabaena. Output from the model is in good agreement with both the temporal and spatial characteristics of the pattern maintenance process observed experimentally.