Conformational heterogeneity at position U37 of an all-RNA hairpin ribozyme with implications for metal binding and the catalytic structure of the S-turn

The hairpin ribozyme is an RNA enzyme that performs site-specific phosphodiester bond cleavage between nucleotides A-1 and G+1 within its cognate substrate. Previous functional studies revealed that the minimal hairpin ribozyme exhibited "gain-of-function" cleavage properties resulting from U39C or U39 to propyl linker (C3) modifications. Furthermore, each "mutant" displayed different magnesium-dependence in its activity. To investigate the molecular basis for these gain-of-function variants, crystal structures of minimal, junctionless hairpin ribozymes were solved in native (U39), and mutant U39C and U39(C3) forms. The results revealed an overall molecular architecture comprising two docked internal loop domains folded into a wishbone shape, whose tertiary interface forms a sequestered active site. All three minimal hairpin ribozymes bound Co(NH(3))(6)(3+) at G21/A40, the E-loop/S-turn boundary. The native structure also showed that U37 of the S-turn adopts both sequestered and exposed conformations that differ by a maximum displacement of 13 A. In the sequestered form, the U37 base packs against G36, and its 2'-hydroxyl group forms a water mediated hydrogen bond to O4' of G+1. These interactions were not observed in previous four-way-junction hairpin ribozyme structures due to crystal contacts with the U1A splicing protein. Interestingly, the U39C and U39(C3) mutations shifted the equilibrium conformation of U37 into the sequestered form through formation of new hydrogen bonds in the S-turn, proximal to the essential nucleotide A38. A comparison of all three new structures has implications for the catalytically relevant conformation of the S-turn and suggests a rationale for the distinctive metal dependence of each mutant.     

Tertiary structure stabilization promotes hairpin ribozyme ligation.

The hairpin ribozyme catalyzes a reversible RNA cleavage reaction that participates in processing intermediates of viral satellite RNA replication in plants. A minimal hairpin ribozyme consists of two helix-loop-helix segments. These segments associate noncoaxially in the active folded structure in a way that brings catalytically important loop nucleotides into close proximity. The hairpin ribozyme in the satellite RNA of Tobacco Ringspot Virus assembles in the context of a four-way helical junction. Recent physical characterization of hairpin ribozyme structures using fluorescence resonance energy transfer demonstrated enhanced stability of the folded structure in the context of a four-way helical junction compared to minimal hairpin ribozyme variants. Analysis of the functional consequences of this modification of the helical junction has revealed two changes in the hairpin ribozyme kinetic mechanism. First, ribozymes with a four-way helical junction bind 3' cleavage products with much higher affinity than minimal hairpin ribozymes, evidence that tertiary interactions within the folded structure contribute to product binding energy. Second, the balance between ligation and cleavage shifts in favor of ligation. The enhanced ligation activity of hairpin ribozymes that contain a four-way helical junction supports the notion that tertiary structure stability is a major determinant of the hairpin ribozyme proficiency as a ligase and illustrates the link between RNA structure and biological function.     

A chemo-genetic approach for the study of nucleobase participation in nucleolytic ribozymes

A novel chemo-genetic approach for the analysis of general acid-base catalysis by nucleobases in ribozymes is reviewed. This involves substitution of a C-nucleoside with imidazole in place of a natural nucleobase. The Varkud satellite ribozyme in which the nucleobase at the critical 756 position has been replaced by imidazole is active in both cleavage and ligation reactions. Similarly, a modified hairpin ribozyme with the nucleobase at position 8 substituted by imidazole is active in cleavage and ligation reactions. Although the rates are lower than those of the natural ribozymes, they are significantly greater than other variants at these positions. The dependence of the hairpin ribozyme reaction rates on pH has been studied. Both cleavage and ligation reactions display a bell-shaped pH dependence, consistent with general acid-base catalysis involving the nucleotide at position 8.     

Specificity of the hairpin ribozyme. Sequence requirements surrounding the cleavage site.

Substrate sequence requirements of the hairpin ribozyme have been partially defined by both mutational and in vitro selection experiments. It was considered that the best targets were those that included the N downward arrowGUC sequence surrounding the cleavage site. In contrast to previous studies that failed to evaluate all possible combinations of these nucleotides, we have performed an exhaustive analysis of the cleavage of 64 substrate variants. They represent all possible sequence combinations of the J2/1 nucleotides except the well established G(+1). No cleavage was observed with 24 sequences. C(+2) variants showed little or no cleavage, whereas U(+2) substrates were all cleavable. The maximal cleavage rate was obtained with the AGUC substrate. Cleavage rates of sequences HGUC (H = A, C, or U), GGUN, GGGR (R = A or G), AGUU, and UGUA were up to 5 times lower than the AGUC one. This shows that other sequences besides NGUC could also be considered as good targets. A second group of sequences WGGG (W = A or U), UGUK (K = G or U), MGAG (M = A or C), AGUA, and UGGA were cleaved between 6 and 10 times less efficiently. Furthermore, the UGCU sequence of a noncleavable viral target was mutated to AGUC resulting in a proficiently cleavable substrate by its cognate hairpin ribozyme. This indicates that our conclusions may be extrapolated to other hairpin ribozymes with different specificity.     

Role of an active site adenine in hairpin ribozyme catalysis

The hairpin ribozyme is a small catalytic RNA that accelerates reversible cleavage of a phosphodiester bond. Structural and mechanistic studies suggest that divalent metals stabilize the functional structure but do not participate directly in catalysis. Instead, two active site nucleobases, G8 and A38, appear to participate in catalytic chemistry. The features of A38 that are important for active site structure and chemistry were investigated by comparing cleavage and ligation reactions of ribozyme variants with A38 modifications. An abasic substitution of A38 reduced cleavage and ligation activity by 14,000-fold and 370,000-fold, respectively, highlighting the critical role of this nucleobase in ribozyme function. Cleavage and ligation activity of unmodified ribozymes increased with increasing pH, evidence that deprotonation of some functional group with an apparent pK(a) value near 6 is important for activity. The pH-dependent transition in activity shifted by several pH units in the basic direction when A38 was substituted with an abasic residue, or with nucleobase analogs with very high or low pK(a) values that are expected to retain the same protonation state throughout the experimental pH range. Certain exogenous nucleobases that share the amidine group of adenine restored activity to abasic ribozyme variants that lack A38. The pH dependence of chemical rescue reactions also changed according to the intrinsic basicity of the rescuing nucleobase, providing further evidence that the protonation state of the N1 position of purine analogs is important for rescue activity. These results are consistent with models of the hairpin ribozyme catalytic mechanism in which interactions with A38 provide electrostatic stabilization to the transition state.     

Base pairing between Escherichia coli RNase P RNA and its substrate.

Base pairing between the substrate and the ribozyme has previously been shown to be essential for catalytic activity of most ribozymes, but not for RNase P RNA. By using compensatory mutations we have demonstrated the importance of Watson-Crick complementarity between two well-conserved residues in Escherichia coli RNase P RNA (M1 RNA), G292 and G293, and two residues in the substrate, +74C and +75C (the first and second C residues in CCA). We suggest that these nucleotides base pair (G292/+75C and G293/+74C) in the ribozyme-substrate complex and as a consequence the amino acid acceptor stem of the precursor is partly unfolded. Thus, a function of M1 RNA is to anchor the substrate through this base pairing, thereby exposing the cleavage site such that cleavage is accomplished at the correct position. Our data also suggest possible base pairing between U294 in M1 RNA and the discriminator base at position +73 of the precursor. Our findings are also discussed in terms of evolution.     

Energetics of hydrogen bond networks in RNA: hydrogen bonds surrounding G+1 and U42 are the major determinants for the tertiary structure stability of the hairpin ribozyme

The hairpin ribozyme, a small catalytic RNA consisting of two helix-loop-helix motifs, serves as a paradigm for RNA folding. In the active conformer, the ribozyme is docked into a compact structure via loop-loop interactions. The crystal structure of the docked hairpin ribozyme shows an intricate network of hydrogen bonding interactions at the docking interface, mediated by the base, sugar, and phosphate groups of U42 and G+1 [Rupert, P. B., and Ferre-D'Amare, A. R. (2001) Nature 410, 780-786]. To elucidate the determinants for tertiary structure stability in the hairpin ribozyme, we evaluated the energetic contributions of hydrogen bonds surrounding U42 and G+1 by time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer using modified ribozymes that lack one or more of the individual interactions. Elimination of a single tertiary hydrogen bond consistently resulted in a net destabilization of approximately 2 kJ/mol. The results of double- and triple-mutant cycles suggest that individual hydrogen bonds surrounding G+1 or U42 act cooperatively and form extended hydrogen bond networks that stabilize the docked ribozyme. These results demonstrate that RNAs, similar to proteins, can exploit coupled hydrogen bond networks to stabilize the docking of distant structural domains.     

The kinetic mechanism of the hairpin ribozyme in vivo: influence of RNA helix stability on intracellular cleavage kinetics

The relationship between hairpin ribozyme structure, and cleavage and ligation kinetics, and equilibria has been characterized extensively under a variety of reaction conditions in vitro. We developed a quantitative assay of hairpin ribozyme cleavage activity in yeast to learn how structure-function relationships defined for RNA enzymes in vitro relate to RNA-mediated reactions in cells. Here, we report the effects of variation in the stability of an essential secondary structure element, H1, on intracellular cleavage kinetics. H1 is the base-paired helix formed between ribozyme and 3' cleavage product RNAs. H1 sequences with fewer than three base-pairs fail to support full activity in vitro or in vivo, arguing against any significant difference in the stability of short RNA helices under in vitro and intracellular conditions. Under standard conditions in vitro that include 10 mM MgCl(2), the internal equilibrium between cleavage and ligation of ribozyme-bound products favors ligation. Consequently, ribozymes with stable H1 sequences display sharply reduced self-cleavage rates, because cleavage is reversed by rapid re-ligation of bound products. In contrast, ribozymes with as many as 26 base-pairs in H1 continue to self-cleave at maximum rates in vivo. The failure of large products to inhibit cleavage could be explained if intracellular conditions promote rapid product dissociation or shift the internal equilibrium to favor cleavage. Model experiments in vitro suggest that the internal equilibrium between cleavage and ligation of bound products is likely to favor cleavage under intracellular ionic conditions.     

Mutational inhibition of ligation in the hairpin ribozyme: substitutions of conserved nucleobases A9 and A10 destabilize tertiary structure and selectively promote cleavage

The hairpin ribozyme acts as a reversible, site-specific endoribonuclease that ligates much more rapidly than it cleaves cognate substrate. While the reaction pathway for ligation is the reversal of cleavage, little is known about the atomic and electrostatic details of the two processes. Here, we report the functional consequences of molecular substitutions of A9 and A10, two highly conserved nucleobases located adjacent to the hairpin ribozyme active site, using G, C, U, 2-aminopurine, 2,6-diaminopurine, purine, and inosine. Cleavage and ligation kinetics were analyzed, tertiary folding was monitored by hydroxyl radical footprinting, and interdomain docking was studied by native gel electrophoresis. We determined that nucleobase substitutions that exhibit significant levels of interference with tertiary folding and interdomain docking have relatively large inhibitory effects on ligation rates while showing little inhibition of cleavage. Indeed, one variant, A10G, showed a fivefold enhancement of cleavage rate and no detectable ligation, and we suggest that this property may be uniquely well suited to intracellular targeted RNA cleavage applications. Results support a model in which formation of a kinetically stable tertiary structure is essential for ligation of the hairpin ribozyme, but is not necessary for cleavage.     

Sequence elements outside the catalytic core of natural hairpin ribozymes modulate the reactions differentially

Abstract Hairpin ribozymes occur naturally only in the satellite RNAs of tobacco ringspot virus (TRsV), chicory yellow mottle virus (CYMoV) and arabis mosaic virus (ArMV). The catalytic centre of the predominantly studied sTRsV hairpin ribozyme, and of sArMV is organised around a four-way helical junction. We show here that sCYMoV features a five-way helical junction instead. Mutational analysis indicates that the fifth stem does not influence kinetic parameters of the sCYMoV hairpin ribozyme in vitro reactions, and therefore seems an appendix to that junction in the other ribozymes. We report further that all three ribozymes feature a three-way helical junction outside the catalytic core in stem A, with Watson-Crick complementarity to loop nucleotides in stem B. Kinetic analyses of cleavage and ligation reactions of several variants of the sTRsV and sCYMoV hairpin ribozymes in vitro show that the presence of this junction interferes with their reactions, particularly the ligation. We provide evidence that this is not due to a presumed interaction of the afore-mentioned elements in stems A and B. The evolutionary survival of this cis-inhibiting element seems rather to be caused by the coincidence of its position with that of the hammerhead ribozyme in the other RNA polarity.     

Engineered RNase P ribozymes increase their cleavage activities and efficacies in inhibiting viral gene expression in cells by enhancing the rate of cleavage and binding of the target mRNA

Engineered RNase P ribozymes are promising gene-targeting agents that can be used in both basic research and clinical applications. We have previously selected ribozyme variants for their activity in cleaving an mRNA substrate from a pool of ribozymes containing randomized sequences. In this study, one of the variants was used to target the mRNA encoding thymidine kinase (TK) of herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1). The variant exhibited enhanced cleavage and substrate binding and was at least 30 times more efficient in cleaving TK mRNA in vitro than the ribozyme derived from the wild type sequence. Our results provide the first direct evidence to suggest that a point mutation at nucleotide 95 of RNase P catalytic RNA from Escherichia coli (G(95) --> U(95)) increases the rate of cleavage, whereas another mutation at nucleotide 200 (A(200) --> C(200)) enhances substrate binding of the ribozyme. A reduction of about 99% in TK expression was observed in cells expressing the variant, whereas a 70% reduction was found in cells expressing the ribozyme derived from the wild type sequence. Thus, the RNase P ribozyme variant is highly effective in inhibiting HSV-1 gene expression. Our study demonstrates that ribozyme variants increase their cleavage activity and efficacy in blocking gene expression in cells through enhanced substrate binding and rate of cleavage. These results also provide insights into the mechanism of how RNase P ribozymes efficiently cleave an mRNA substrate and, furthermore, facilitate the development of highly active RNase P ribozymes for gene-targeting applications.     

Essential nucleotide sequences and secondary structure elements of the hairpin ribozyme.

In vitro selection experiments have been used to isolate active variants of the 50 nt hairpin catalytic RNA motif following randomization of individual ribozyme domains and intensive mutagenesis of the ribozyme-substrate complex. Active and inactive variants were characterized by sequencing, analysis of RNA cleavage activity in cis and in trans, and by substrate binding studies. Results precisely define base-pairing requirements for ribozyme helices 3 and 4, and identify eight essential nucleotides (G8, A9, A10, G21, A22, A23, A24 and C25) within the catalytic core of the ribozyme. Activity and substrate binding assays show that point mutations at these eight sites eliminate cleavage activity but do not significantly decrease substrate binding, demonstrating that these bases contribute to catalytic function. The mutation U39C has been isolated from different selection experiments as a second-site suppressor of the down mutants G21U and A43G. Assays of the U39C mutation in the wild-type ribozyme and in a variety of mutant backgrounds show that this variant is a general up mutation. Results from selection experiments involving populations totaling more than 10(10) variants are summarized, and consensus sequences including 16 essential nucleotides and a secondary structure model of four short helices, encompassing 18 bp for the ribozyme-substrate complex are derived.     

Efficient RNA ligation by reverse-joined hairpin ribozymes and engineering of twin ribozymes consisting of conventional and reverse-joined hairpin ribozyme units

In recent years major progress has been made in elucidating the mechanism and structure of catalytic RNA molecules, and we are now beginning to understand ribozymes well enough to turn them into useful tools. Work in our laboratory has focused on the development of twin ribozymes for site-specific RNA sequence alteration. To this end, we followed a strategy that relies on the combination of two ribozyme units into one molecule (hence dubbed twin ribozyme). Here, we present reverse-joined hairpin ribozymes that are structurally optimized and which, in addition to cleavage, catalyse efficient RNA ligation. The most efficient variant ligated its appropriate RNA substrate with a single turnover rate constant of 1.1 min(-1) and a final yield of 70%. We combined a reverse-joined hairpin ribozyme with a conventional hairpin ribozyme to create a twin ribozyme that mediates the insertion of four additional nucleotides into a predetermined position of a substrate RNA, and thus mimics, at the RNA level, the repair of a short deletion mutation; 17% of the initial substrate was converted to the insertion product.     

Mechanistic considerations for general acid-base catalysis by RNA: revisiting the mechanism of the hairpin ribozyme

Several small ribozymes carry out self-cleavage at a specific phosphodiester bond to yield 2',3'-cyclic phosphate and 5'-hydroxyl termini. Prior mechanistic and structural studies on the HDV ribozymes led to the proposal that the pK(a) of C75 is shifted toward neutrality, making it an effective general acid. Recent mechanistic studies on the hairpin ribozyme have led to models in which protonation of G8 is required for phosphodiester cleavage, either for general acid catalysis or for electrostatic stabilization. Inspection of recent crystal structures of the hairpin ribozyme, including a complex with a vanadate transition state mimic, suggests an alternative model involving general acid-base catalysis with G8 serving as the general base and A38 as the general acid. This model is consistent with the literature on the hairpin ribozyme, including pH-rate profiles of wild-type and mutant ribozymes and solvent isotope effects. General mechanistic considerations for RNA catalysis suggest that the penalty for having general acids and bases with pK(a)s removed from neutrality is not as severe as expected. These considerations suggest that general acid-base catalysis may be a common mechanistic strategy of RNA enzymes.     

Cross-ligation and exchange reactions catalyzed by hairpin ribozymes.

The negative strand of the satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus (sTobRV(-)) contains a hairpin catalytic domain that shows self-cleavage and self-ligation activities in the presence of magnesium ions. We describe here that the minimal catalytic domain can catalyze a cross-ligation reaction between two kinds of substrates in trans. The cross-ligated product increased when the reaction temperature was decreased during the reaction from 37 degrees C to 4 degrees C. A two-stranded hairpin ribozyme, divided into two fragments between G45 and U46 in a hairpin loop, showed higher ligation activity than the nondivided ribozyme. The two stranded ribozyme also catalyzed an exchange reaction of the 3'-portion of the cleavage site.     

A cis and trans adenine-dependent hairpin ribozyme against Tpl-2 target

Ribozymes are catalytic RNAs that possess the property of cutting an RNA target via site-specific cleavage after sequence-specific recognition. Ribozymes can moreover cleave multiple substrate molecules. An increasing number of studies show that ribozymes are particularly well adapted tools against cancer, silencing or down-regulating gene expression at the RNA level. We have constructed an adenine-dependent hairpin ribozyme that cleaves the sequence at nucleotides A(225)(downward arrow)G(226) relative to the start codon of translation of the Tpl-2 kinase mRNA; this serine/threonine kinase activates the mitogen-activated protein kinase pathway implicated in cell proliferation in breast cancer. An adenine-dependent hairpin ribozyme 1 (ADHR1) was previously isolated using the Systematic Evolution of Ligands by EXponential enrichment procedure. Switch on/switch off ribozymes are particularly useful since high amounts of stable ribozyme can be produced in the absence of adenine and the ribozyme specifically cleaves its target in the presence of adenine. The ADHR1 target sequence was replaced by a sequence derived from the Tpl-2 kinase mRNA. The resulting Tpl-2 ribozyme is active in cis cleavage: kinetic studies have been performed as a function of Mg2+ concentration, adenine concentration, as well as at different pH and with various cofactors. Finally, the Tpl-2 ribozyme was shown to cleave its target in trans successfully. These findings demonstrate that a potential therapeutic ribozyme can be produced by simple sequence modification.     

A comparison of vanadate to a 2'-5' linkage at the active site of a small ribozyme suggests a role for water in transition-state stabilization

The potential for water to participate in RNA catalyzed reactions has been the topic of several recent studies. Here, we report crystals of a minimal, hinged hairpin ribozyme in complex with the transition-state analog vanadate at 2.05 A resolution. Waters are present in the active site and are discussed in light of existing views of catalytic strategies employed by the hairpin ribozyme. A second structure harboring a 2',5'-phosphodiester linkage at the site of cleavage was also solved at 2.35 A resolution and corroborates the assignment of active site waters in the structure containing vanadate. A comparison of the two structures reveals that the 2',5' structure adopts a conformation that resembles the reaction intermediate in terms of (1) the positioning of its nonbridging oxygens and (2) the covalent attachment of the 2'-O nucleophile with the scissile G+1 phosphorus. The 2',5'-linked structure was then overlaid with scissile bonds of other small ribozymes including the glmS metabolite-sensing riboswitch and the hammerhead ribozyme, and suggests the potential of the 2',5' linkage to elicit a reaction-intermediate conformation without the need to form metalloenzyme complexes. The hairpin ribozyme structures presented here also suggest how water molecules bound at each of the nonbridging oxygens of G+1 may electrostatically stabilize the transition state in a manner that supplements nucleobase functional groups. Such coordination has not been reported for small ribozymes, but is consistent with the structures of protein enzymes. Overall, this work establishes significant parallels between the RNA and protein enzyme worlds.     

Properties of antigenomic hepatitis delta virus ribozyme cis- and trans- analogs

A series of permuted variants of antigenomic HDV ribozyme and trans-acting variants were constructed. The catalytic activity study of the ribozymes has shown that all the variants were capable of self-cleaving with equally biphasic kinetics. Ribonuclease and Fe(II)-EDTA cleavage have provided evidence that all designed ribozymes fold according to the pseudoknot model and the conformations of the initial and cleaved ribozyme are different. A scheme of HDV ribozyme self-cleavage reaction was suggested. The role of hydrogen bonds in the reaction was evaluated by substitution of ribose in the ribozyme for deoxyribose. It was found that the 2'-OH group of U23 and C27 is critical for the reaction to occur; the 2'-OH group of U32 and U39 is important, while 2'-OH groups of other nucleotides of loop 3, stem 4 and stem 1 are unimportant for the cleavage activity.