Structural requirements for efficient prion protein conversion: Cofactors may promote a conversion-competent structure for PrPC

To understand why cross-species infection of prion disease often results in inefficient transmission and reduced protein conversion, most research has focused on defining the effect of variations in PrP primary structures, including sequence compatibility of substrate and seed. By contrast, little research has been aimed at investigating structural differences between different variants of PrP^C and secondary structural requirements for efficient conversion. This is despite a clear role for molecular chaperones in formation of prions in non-mammalian systems, indicating the importance of secondary/tertiary structure during the conversion process. Recent data from our laboratory on the cellular location of disease-specific prion cofactors supports the critical role of specific secondary structural motifs and the stability of these motifs in determining the efficiency of disease-specific prion protein conversion. In this paper we summarize our recent results and build on the hypothesis previously suggested by Wuthrich and colleagues, that stability of certain regions of the prion protein is crucial for protein conversion to abnormal isoforms in vivo. It is suggested that one role for molecular cofactors in the conversion process is to stabilize PrP^C structure in a form that is amenable for conversion to PrP^Sc.Key words: cofactor, structure, cell-free conversion assay, fibrillization, stability, loop region     

An insight of early PrP-E200K aggregation by combined molecular dynamics/fragment molecular orbital approaches

Unveiling the events leading to the formation of prion particles is a nowadays challenge in the field of neurochemistry. Pathogenic mutants of prion protein (PrP) are characterized by both an intrinsic tendency to aggregation and scrapie conversion propensity. However, the question about a possible correlation between these two events lasts still unanswered. Here, a multilayered computational workflow was employed to investigate structure, stability, and molecular interaction properties of a dimer of PrP^C-E200K, a well-known mutant of the PrP that represents a reduced model of early aggregates of this protein. Based on the combination of molecular dynamics and quantum mechanical approaches, this study provided for an in depth insight of PrP^C-E200K dimer in terms of residue-residue interactions. Assembly hypotheses for the early aggregation of PrP^C-E200K are paved and compared with PrP^Sc models reported in the literature to find a structural link between early and late (scrapie) aggregates of this protein.     

Interactome Analyses Identify Ties of PrPC and Its Mammalian Paralogs to Oligomannosidic N-Glycans and Endoplasmic Reticulum-Derived Chaperones

The physiological environment which hosts the conformational conversion of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) to disease-associated isoforms has remained enigmatic. A quantitative investigation of the PrP^C interactome was conducted in a cell culture model permissive to prion replication. To facilitate recognition of relevant interactors, the study was extended to Doppel (Prnd) and Shadoo (Sprn), two mammalian PrP^C paralogs. Interestingly, this work not only established a similar physiological environment for the three prion protein family members in neuroblastoma cells, but also suggested direct interactions amongst them. Furthermore, multiple interactions between PrP^C and the neural cell adhesion molecule, the laminin receptor precursor, Na/K ATPases and protein disulfide isomerases (PDI) were confirmed, thereby reconciling previously separate findings. Subsequent validation experiments established that interactions of PrP^C with PDIs may extend beyond the endoplasmic reticulum and may play a hitherto unrecognized role in the accumulation of PrP^Sc. A simple hypothesis is presented which accounts for the majority of interactions observed in uninfected cells and suggests that PrP^C organizes its molecular environment on account of its ability to bind to adhesion molecules harboring immunoglobulin-like domains, which in turn recognize oligomannose-bearing membrane proteins.     

Identifying critical sites of PrPc-PrPSc interaction in prion-infected cells by dominant-negative inhibition

A direct physical interaction of the prion protein isoforms is a key element in prion conversion. Which sites interact first and which parts of PrP^c are converted subsequently is presently not known in detail. We hypothesized that structural changes induced by PrP^Sc interaction occur in more than one interface and subsequently propagate within the PrP^C substrate, like epicenters of structural changes. To identify potential interfaces we created a series of systematically-designed mutant PrPs and tested them in prion-infected cells for dominant-negative inhibition (DNI) effects. This showed that mutant PrPs with deletions in the region between first and second α-helix are involved in PrP-PrP interaction and conversion of PrP^C into PrP^Sc. Although some PrPs did not reach the plasma membrane, they had access to the locales of prion conversion and PrP^Sc recycling using autophagy pathways. Using other series of mutant PrPs we already have identified additional sites which constitute potential interaction interfaces. Our approach has the potential to characterize PrP-PrP interaction sites in the context of prion-infected cells. Besides providing further insights into the molecular mechanisms of prion conversion, this data may help to further elucidate how prion strain diversity is maintained.     

G-quadruplexes within prion mRNA: the missing link in prion disease?

Cellular ribonucleic acid (RNA) plays a crucial role in the initial conversion of cellular prion protein PrP^C to infectious PrP^Sc or scrapie. The nature of this RNA remains elusive. Previously, RNA aptamers against PrP^C have been isolated and found to form G-quadruplexes (G4s). PrP^C binding to G4 RNAs destabilizes its structure and is thought to trigger its conversion to PrP^Sc. Here it is shown that PrP messenger RNA (mRNA) itself contains several G4 motifs, located in the octarepeat region. Investigation of the RNA structure in one of these repeats by circular dichroism, nuclear magnetic resonance and ultraviolet melting studies shows evidence of G4 formation. In vitro translation of full-length PrP mRNA, naturally harboring five consecutive G4 motifs, was specifically affected by G4-binding ligands, lending support to G4 formation in PrP mRNA. A possible role of PrP binding to its own mRNA and the role of anti-prion drugs, many of which are G4-binding ligands, in prion disease are discussed.     

The role of glycophosphatidylinositol anchor in the amplification of the scrapie isoform of prion protein in vitro

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies are associated with an autocatalytic conversion of normal prion protein, PrP^C, to a protease-resistant form, PrPres. This autocatalytic reaction can be reproduced in vitro using a procedure called protein misfolding cyclic amplification (PMCA). Here we show that, unlike brain-derived PrP^C, bacterially-expressed recombinant prion protein (rPrP) is a poor substrate for PrPres amplification in a standard PMCA reaction. The differences between PrP^C and rPrP appear to be due to the lack of the glycophosphatidylinositol anchor in the recombinant protein. These findings shed a new light on prion protein conversion process and have important implications for the efforts to generate synthetic prions for structural and biophysical studies.     

Prion Protein—Antibody Complexes Characterized by Chromatography-Coupled Small-Angle X-Ray Scattering

Aberrant self-assembly, induced by structural misfolding of the prion proteins, leads to a number of neurodegenerative disorders. In particular, misfolding of the mostly α-helical cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into a β-sheet-rich disease-causing isoform (PrP^Sc) is the key molecular event in the formation of PrP^Sc aggregates. The molecular mechanisms underlying the PrP^C-to-PrP^Sc conversion and subsequent aggregation remain to be elucidated. However, in persistently prion-infected cell-culture models, it was shown that treatment with monoclonal antibodies against defined regions of the prion protein (PrP) led to the clearing of PrP^Sc in cultured cells. To gain more insight into this process, we characterized PrP-antibody complexes in solution using a fast protein liquid chromatography coupled with small-angle x-ray scattering (FPLC-SAXS) procedure. High-quality SAXS data were collected for full-length recombinant mouse PrP [denoted recPrP(23–230)] and N-terminally truncated recPrP(89–230), as well as their complexes with each of two Fab fragments (HuM-P and HuM-R1), which recognize N- and C-terminal epitopes of PrP, respectively. In-line measurements by fast protein liquid chromatography coupled with SAXS minimized data artifacts caused by a non-monodispersed sample, allowing structural analysis of PrP alone and in complex with Fab antibodies. The resulting structural models suggest two mechanisms for how these Fabs may prevent the conversion of PrP^C into PrP^Sc.     

Brain delivery of AAV9 expressing an anti-PrP monovalent antibody delays prion disease in mice

Prion diseases are caused by a conformational modification of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into disease-specific forms, termed PrP^Sc, that have the ability to interact with PrP^C promoting its conversion to PrP^Sc. In vitro studies demonstrated that anti-PrP antibodies inhibit this process. In particular, the single chain variable fragment D18 antibody (scFvD18) showed high efficiency in curing chronically prion-infected cells. This molecule binds the PrP^C region involved in the interaction with PrP^Sc thus halting further prion formation. These findings prompted us to test the efficiency of scFvD18 in vivo. A recombinant Adeno-Associated Viral vector serotype 9 was used to deliver scFvD18 to the brain of mice that were subsequently infected by intraperitoneal route with the mouse-adapted scrapie strain RML. We found that the treatment was safe, prolonged the incubation time of scrapie-infected animals and decreased the burden of total proteinase-resistant PrP^Sc in the brain, suggesting that scFvD18 interferes with prion replication in vivo. This approach is relevant for designing new therapeutic strategies for prion diseases and other disorders characterized by protein misfolding.     

Nanopore Analysis of Wild-Type and Mutant Prion Protein (PrPC): Single Molecule Discrimination and PrPC Kinetics

Prion diseases are fatal neurodegenerative diseases associated with the conversion of cellular prion protein (PrP^C) in the central nervous system into the infectious isoform (PrP^Sc). The mechanics of conversion are almost entirely unknown, with understanding stymied by the lack of an atomic-level structure for PrP^Sc. A number of pathogenic PrP^C mutants exist that are characterized by an increased propensity for conversion into PrP^Sc and that differ from wild-type by only a single amino-acid point mutation in their primary structure. These mutations are known to perturb the stability and conformational dynamics of the protein. Understanding of how this occurs may provide insight into the mechanism of PrP^C conversion. In this work we sought to explore wild-type and pathogenic mutant prion protein structure and dynamics by analysis of the current fluctuations through an organic α-hemolysin nanometer-scale pore (nanopore) in which a single prion protein has been captured electrophoretically. In doing this, we find that wild-type and D178N mutant PrP^C, (a PrP^C mutant associated with both Fatal Familial Insomnia and Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease), exhibit easily distinguishable current signatures and kinetics inside the pore and we further demonstrate, with the use of Hidden Markov Model signal processing, accurate discrimination between these two proteins at the single molecule level based on the kinetics of a single PrP^C capture event. Moreover, we present a four-state model to describe wild-type PrP^C kinetics in the pore as a first step in our investigation on characterizing the differences in kinetics and conformational dynamics between wild-type and D178N mutant PrP^C. These results demonstrate the potential of nanopore analysis for highly sensitive, real-time protein and small molecule detection based on single molecule kinetics inside a nanopore, and show the utility of this technique as an assay to probe differences in stability between wild-type and mutant prion proteins at the single molecule level.     

Brain delivery of AAV9 expressing an anti-PrP monovalent antibody delays prion disease in mice

Prion diseases are caused by a conformational modification of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) into disease-specific forms, termed PrP^Sc, that have the ability to interact with PrP^C promoting its conversion to PrP^Sc. In vitro studies demonstrated that anti-PrP antibodies inhibit this process. In particular, the single chain variable fragment D18 antibody (scFvD18) showed high efficiency in curing chronically prion-infected cells. This molecule binds the PrP^C region involved in the interaction with PrP^Sc thus halting further prion formation. These findings prompted us to test the efficiency of scFvD18 in vivo. A recombinant Adeno-Associated Viral vector serotype 9 was used to deliver scFvD18 to the brain of mice that were subsequently infected by intraperitoneal route with the mouse-adapted scrapie strain RML. We found that the treatment was safe, prolonged the incubation time of scrapie-infected animals and decreased the burden of total proteinase-resistant PrP^Sc in the brain, suggesting that scFvD18 interferes with prion replication in vivo. This approach is relevant for designing new therapeutic strategies for prion diseases and other disorders characterized by protein misfolding.     

Insight into early events in the aggregation of the prion protein on lipid membranes

The key molecular event underlying prion diseases is the conversion of the monomeric and α-helical cellular form of the prion protein (PrP^C) to the disease-associated state, which is aggregated and rich in β-sheet (PrP^Sc). The molecular details associated with the conversion of PrP^C into PrP^Sc are not fully understood. The prion protein is attached to the cell membrane via a GPI lipid anchor and evidence suggests that the lipid environment plays an important role in prion conversion and propagation. We have previously shown that the interaction of the prion protein with anionic lipid membranes induces β-sheet structure and promotes prion aggregation, whereas zwitterionic membranes stabilize the α-helical form of the protein. Here, we report on the interaction of recombinant sheep prion protein with planar lipid membranes in real-time, using dual polarization interferometry (DPI). Using this technique, the simultaneous evaluation of multiple physical properties of PrP layers on membranes was achieved. The deposition of prion on membranes of POPC and POPC/POPS mixtures was studied. The properties of the resulting protein layers were found to depend on the lipid composition of the membranes. Denser and thicker protein deposits formed on lipid membranes containing POPS compared to those formed on POPC. DPI thus provides a further insight on the organization of PrP at the surface of lipid membranes.     

The Octarepeat Region of the Prion Protein Is Conformationally Altered in PrPSc

Background

Prion diseases are fatal neurodegenerative disorders characterized by misfolding and aggregation of the normal prion protein PrP^C. Little is known about the details of the structural rearrangement of physiological PrP^C into a still-elusive disease-associated conformation termed PrP^Sc. Increasing evidence suggests that the amino-terminal octapeptide sequences of PrP (huPrP, residues 59–89), though not essential, play a role in modulating prion replication and disease presentation.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Here, we report that trypsin digestion of PrP^Sc from variant and sporadic human CJD results in a disease-specific trypsin-resistant PrP^Sc fragment including amino acids ∼49–231, thus preserving important epitopes such as the octapeptide domain for biochemical examination. Our immunodetection analyses reveal that several epitopes buried in this region of PrP^Sc are exposed in PrP^C.

Conclusions/Significance

We conclude that the octapeptide region undergoes a previously unrecognized conformational transition in the formation of PrP^Sc. This phenomenon may be relevant to the mechanism by which the amino terminus of PrP^C participates in PrP^Sc conversion, and may also be exploited for diagnostic purposes.     

Copper and Zinc Interactions with Cellular Prion Proteins Change Solubility of Full-Length Glycosylated Isoforms and Induce the Occurrence of Heterogeneous Phenotypes

Prion diseases are characterized biochemically by protein aggregation of infectious prion isoforms (PrP^Sc), which result from the conformational conversion of physiological prion proteins (PrP^C). PrP^C are variable post-translationally modified glycoproteins, which exist as full length and as aminoterminally truncated glycosylated proteins and which exhibit differential detergent solubility. This implicates the presence of heterogeneous phenotypes, which overlap as protein complexes at the same molecular masses. Although the biological function of PrP^C is still enigmatic, evidence reveals that PrP^C exhibits metal-binding properties, which result in structural changes and decreased solubility. In this study, we analyzed the yield of PrP^C metal binding affiliated with low solubility and changes in protein banding patterns. By implementing a high-speed centrifugation step, the interaction of zinc ions with PrP^C was shown to generate large quantities of proteins with low solubility, consisting mainly of full-length glycosylated PrP^C; whereas unglycosylated PrP^C remained in the supernatants as well as truncated glycosylated proteins which lack of octarepeat sequence necessary for metal binding. This effect was considerably lower when PrP^C interacted with copper ions; the presence of other metals tested exhibited no effect under these conditions. The binding of zinc and copper to PrP^C demonstrated differentially soluble protein yields within distinct PrP^C subtypes. PrP^C–Zn²⁺-interaction may provide a means to differentiate glycosylated and unglycosylated subtypes and offers detailed analysis of metal-bound and metal-free protein conversion assays.     

Loss of Residues 119–136, Including the First β-strand of Human Prion Protein,Generates an Aggregation-competent Partially “Open” Form

In prion replication, the cellular form of prion protein (PrP^C) must undergo a full conformational transition to its disease-associated fibrillar form. Transmembrane forms of PrP have been implicated in this structural conversion. The cooperative unfolding of a structural core in PrP^C presents a substantial energy barrier to prion formation, with membrane insertion and detachment of parts of PrP presenting a plausible route to its reduction. Here, we examined the removal of residues 119–136 of PrP, a region which includes the first β-strand and a substantial portion of the conserved hydrophobic region of PrP, a region which associates with the ER membrane, on the structure, stability and self-association of the folded domain of PrP^C. We see an “open” native-like conformer with increased solvent exposure which fibrilises more readily than the native state. These data suggest a stepwise folding transition, which is initiated by the conformational switch to this “open” form of PrP^C.     

Low Density Subcellular Fractions Enhance Disease-specific Prion Protein Misfolding

The production of prion particles in vitro by amplification with or without exogenous seed typically results in infectivity titers less than those associated with PrP^Sc isolated ex vivo and highlights the potential role of co-factors that can catalyze disease-specific prion protein misfolding in vivo. We used a cell-free conversion assay previously shown to replicate many aspects of transmissible spongiform encephalopathy disease to investigate the cellular location of disease-specific co-factors using fractions derived from gradient centrifugation of a scrapie-susceptible cell line. Fractions from the low density region of the gradient doubled the efficiency of conversion of recombinant PrP. These fractions contain plasma membrane and cytoplasmic proteins, and conversion enhancement can be achieved using PrP^Sc derived from two different strains of mouse-passaged scrapie as seed. Equivalent fractions from a second scrapie-susceptible cell line also stimulate conversion. We also show that subcellular fractions enhancing disease-specific prion protein conversion prevent in vitro fibrillization of recombinant prion protein, suggesting the existence of separate, competing mechanisms of disease-specific and nonspecific misfolding in vivo.     

Pressure-assisted dissociation and degradation of “proteinase K-resistant” fibrils prepared by seeding with scrapie-infected hamster prion protein

The crucial step for the fatal neurodegenerative prion diseases involves the conversion of a normal cellular protein, PrP^C, into a fibrous pathogenic form, PrP^Sc, which has an unusual stability against heat and resistance against proteinase K digestion. A successful challenge to reverse the reaction from PrP^Sc into PrP^C is considered valuable, as it would give a key to dissolving the complex molecular events into thermodynamic and kinetic analyses and may also provide a means to prevent the formation of PrP^Sc from PrP^C eventually in vivo. Here we show that, by applying pressures at kbar range, the “proteinase K-resistant” fibrils (rHaPrP^res) prepared from hamster prion protein (rHaPrP [23–231]) by seeding with brain homogenate of scrapie-infected hamster, becomes easily digestible. The result is consistent with the notion that rHaPrP^res fibrils are dissociated into rHaPrP monomers under pressure and that the formation of PrP^Sc from PrP^C is thermodynamically controlled. Moreover, the efficient degradation of prion fibrils under pressure provides a novel means of eliminating infectious PrP^Sc from various systems of pathogenic concern.     

Mammalian prions

Upon prion infection, abnormal prion protein (PrP^Sc) self-perpetuate by conformational conversion of α-helix-rich PrP^C into β sheet enriched form, leading to formation and deposition of PrP^Sc aggregates in affected brains. However the process remains poorly understood at the molecular level and the regions of PrP critical for conversion are still debated. Minimal amino acid substitutions can impair prion replication at many places in PrP. Conversely, we recently showed that bona fide prions could be generated after introduction of eight and up to 16 additional amino acids in the H2-H3 inter-helix loop of PrP. Prion replication also accommodated the insertions of an octapeptide at different places in the last turns of H2. This reverse genetic approach reveals an unexpected tolerance of prions to substantial sequence changes in the protease-resistant part which is associated with infectivity. It also demonstrates that conversion does not require the presence of a specific sequence in the middle of the H2-H3 area. We discuss the implications of our findings according to different structural models proposed for PrP^Sc and questioned the postulated existence of an N- or C-terminal prion domain in the protease-resistant region.     

PrP N-terminal domain triggers PrP(Sc)-like aggregation of Dpl

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies are fatal neurodegenerative disorders thought to be transmitted by self-perpetuating conformational conversion of a neuronal membrane glycoprotein (PrP^C, for “cellular prion protein”) into an abnormal state (PrP^Sc, for “scrapie prion protein”). Doppel (Dpl) is a protein that shares significant biochemical and structural homology with PrP^C. In contrast to its homologue PrP^C, Dpl is unable to participate in prion disease progression or to achieve an abnormal PrP^Sc-like state. We have constructed a chimeric mouse protein, composed of the N-terminal domain of PrP^C (residues 23-125) and the C-terminal part of Dpl (residues 58-157). This chimeric protein displays PrP-like biochemical and structural features; when incubated in presence of NaCl, the α-helical monomer forms soluble β-sheet-rich oligomers which acquire partial resistance to pepsin proteolysis in vitro, as do PrP oligomers. Moreover, the presence of aggregates akin to protofibrils is observed in soluble oligomeric species by electron microscopy.     

Role of Lipid Rafts and GM1 in the Segregation and Processing of Prion Protein

The prion protein (PrP^C) is highly expressed within the nervous system. Similar to other GPI-anchored proteins, PrP^C is found in lipid rafts, membrane domains enriched in cholesterol and sphingolipids. PrP^C raft association, together with raft lipid composition, appears essential for the conversion of PrP^C into the scrapie isoform PrP^Sc, and the development of prion disease. Controversial findings were reported on the nature of PrP^C-containing rafts, as well as on the distribution of PrP^C between rafts and non-raft membranes. We investigated PrP^C/ganglioside relationships and their influence on PrP^C localization in a neuronal cellular model, cerebellar granule cells. Our findings argue that in these cells at least two PrP^C conformations coexist: in lipid rafts PrP^C is present in the native folding (α-helical), stabilized by chemico-physical condition, while it is mainly present in other membrane compartments in a PrP^Sc-like conformation. We verified, by means of antibody reactivity and circular dichroism spectroscopy, that changes in lipid raft-ganglioside content alters PrP^C conformation and interaction with lipid bilayers, without modifying PrP^C distribution or cleavage. Our data provide new insights into the cellular mechanism of prion conversion and suggest that GM1-prion protein interaction at the cell surface could play a significant role in the mechanism predisposing to pathology.     

Lipopolysaccharide induced conversion of recombinant prion protein

The conformational conversion of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C) to the β-rich infectious isoform PrP^Sc is considered a critical and central feature in prion pathology. Although PrP^Sc is the critical component of the infectious agent, as proposed in the “protein-only” prion hypothesis, cellular components have been identified as important cofactors in triggering and enhancing the conversion of PrP^C to proteinase K resistant PrP^Sc. A number of in vitro systems using various chemical and/or physical agents such as guanidine hydrochloride, urea, SDS, high temperature, and low pH, have been developed that cause PrP^C conversion, their amplification, and amyloid fibril formation often under non-physiological conditions. In our ongoing efforts to look for endogenous and exogenous chemical mediators that might initiate, influence, or result in the natural conversion of PrP^C to PrP^Sc, we discovered that lipopolysaccharide (LPS), a component of gram-negative bacterial membranes interacts with recombinant prion proteins and induces conversion to an isoform richer in β sheet at near physiological conditions as long as the LPS concentration remains above the critical micelle concentration (CMC). More significant was the LPS mediated conversion that was observed even at sub-molar ratios of LPS to recombinant ShPrP (90–232).