New topics in familial prion diseases

Major advances have been made in the understanding of the molecular basis of phenotypic variability in human prion diseases over the last few years. Strong evidence indicates that a complex interaction between specific mutations and the polymorphic codon 129 of the prion protein gene (PRNP) underlies the genetic control of phenotypic expression in familial human prion diseases. Fatal familial insomnia (FFI) and a subtype of familial CJD (CJD¹⁷⁸), two prion diseases with different clinico-pathological features, the same mutation at codon 178 ofPRNPbut a different amino acid at codon 129 of the mutantPRNPallele, represent the best characterized example of this complex interplay between thePRNPgenotype and phenotypic variability. Protein studies have subsequently shown that the different genotype of the mutant allele in FFI and CJD¹⁷⁸results in the formation of two different protease-resistant prion proteins (PrP^res) which differ in size and glycosylation. These biochemical characteristics of PrP^resas well as differences among distinct brain regions in the timing and rate of PrP^resdeposition and in the vulnerability to PrP^resalso appear to be major determinants of phenotypic expression in human prion diseases.     

Is the prevalent human prion protein 129M/V mutation a living fossil from a Paleolithic panzootic superprion pandemic?

Prion diseases are consistently associated with prion protein (PrP^C) misfolding rendering a cascade of auto-catalytic self-perpetuation of misfolded PrP in an afflicted individual. The molecular process is intriguingly similar to all known amyloid diseases both local and systemic. The prion disease is also infectious by the transfer of misfolded PrP from one individual to the next. Transmissibility is surprisingly efficient in prion diseases and given the rapid disease progression following initial symptoms the prionoses stand out from other amyloidoses, which all may be transmissible under certain circumstances. The nature of the infectious prion as well as the genotype of the host is important for transmissibility. For hitherto unexplained reasons the majority of Europeans carry a missense mutation on one or both alleles of the PrP gene (PRNP), and hence express a variant of PrP with a substitution for valine (V) instead of methionine (M) in position 129. In fact the 129M/V variant is very common in all populations except for the Japanese. Sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease is a disease rarely striking people below the age of 60, where homozygosity especially 129MM is a very strong risk factor. Paradoxically, the 129M/V polymorphism suggestive of heterozygote advantage is one of the most clear cut disease associated traits of the human population, yet prion disease is extraordinarily rare. The genetic basis for how this trait spread with such prevalence within human populations is still target to investigations and deserves attention. This short essay represents a somewhat provocative hypothetical notion of a possible ancient significance of this polymorphism.     

Genotype patterns and characteristics of PRNP in the Korean population

Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD), included in the human transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSE), is widely known to be caused by an abnormal accumulation of misfolding prion protein in the brain. Human prion protein gene (PRNP) is mapped in chromosome 20p13 and many single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in PRNP have been discovered. However, the functionality of SNPs in PRNP is yet unclear, though several SNPs have been known as important mutation related with susceptibility human prion diseases. Our aim is to identify specific genotype patterns and characteristics in the PRNP genomic region and to understand susceptibility among Korean discriminated prion disease patients, suspected CJD patients and the KARE data group. Here, we have researched genotypes and SNPs allele frequencies in PRNP in discriminated prion disease patients group (n = 22), suspected prion diseases patients group (n = 163) and the Korea Association REsource (KARE) data group (n = 296) in Korea. The sequencing regions were promoter region, exon1 and exon2 with their junction parts among 481 samples. A total of 25 SNPs were shown in this study. Nucleotide frequencies of all SNPs are exceedingly tended to bias toward dominant homozygote types except in rs2756271. Genotype frequencies at codon 129 and 219 coding region were similar with previous studies in Korea and Japan. Pathogenic mutations such as 102P/L, 200E/K and 203V/I were observed in discriminated CJD patients group, and 180V/I and 232M/R were shown in suspected prion disease patients group and the KARE data group. A total of 10 SNPs were newly identified, six in the promoter region, one in exon 2 and three in the 3′ UTR. The strong and unique linkage disequilibrium (D' = 0.94, r² = 0.89) was observed between rs57633656 and rs1800014 which is located in codon 219 coding region. We expect that these data can be provided to determine specific susceptibility and a protective factor of prion diseases not only in Koreans but also in East Asians.     

Frequency distribution of PRNP polymorphisms in the Pakistani population

Prion diseases are neurodegenerative conditions caused by misfolding of a normal host-encoded prion protein (PrP^C) into pathogenic scrapie prion protein (PrP^Sc). In human prion diseases, the M129V prion protein polymorphism is known to confer susceptibility to the disease, determines PrP^Sc conformation and alters clinicopathological phenotypes. To date, all clinicopathologically confirmed cases of a variant form of Cruetzfeldt-Jacob disease (vCJD) have been 129MM homozygotes. There is also predominance of 129MM homozygotes in sporadic CJD (sCJD). No information regarding prion disorders is available from Pakistan. Although only invasive procedures like brain biopsy can confirm the diagnosis of prion disorders, testing a corresponding human population for variation in the prion protein gene (PRNP) may provide some insights into the presence of these disorders in a locality. The current study therefore aimed at exploring the genetic susceptibility of Pakistani population to CJD. A total of 909 unrelated individuals including 221 hemophiliacs representing all 4 major provinces of Pakistan were screened for M129V polymorphism and insertions or deletions of octapeptide repeats (OPRIs/OPRDs) using Polymerase Chain Reaction coupled with Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism (PCR-RFLP). Concordance of the results of some PCR-RFLP reactions was also confirmed by dideoxy automated Sanger sequencing. The frequencies of M129V alleles (129M and 129V) and genotypes (129MM, 129MV and 129VV) were found in all 909 individuals to be 0.7101, 0.2899, 0.5270, 0.3663 and 0.1067, respectively. Deletion of 1 octapeptide repeat (1-OPRD) was detected in heterozygous state in PRNP of 10 individuals and in homozygous state in 1 individual. An insertion of 3 octapeptide repeats (3-OPRI) was found in 1 individual and an insertion of 1 octapeptide repeat (1-OPRI) in two individuals. Both 3-OPRI and 1-OPRI were present in heterozygous state and were linked to 129M allele. There were no significant χ² differences between M129V allelic and genotypic frequencies of healthy individuals and hemophiliacs. However, M129V allelic and genotypic frequencies differed significantly between Pakistani population and East Asian and Western populations. Non-significant χ² differences between M129V frequencies of healthy individuals and hemophiliacs suggest that individuals manifesting single gene disorders may provide naturally randomized samples for studies aiming at surveying the genetic variation. The combined excess of 129MM and 129VV homozygosity and the presence of 3-OPRI in 1 individual imply that Pakistani population is susceptible to prion disorders. Cases of prion disorders may exist in Pakistan, albeit at lower annual prevalence than other countries where life expectancy is greater than 65 years.     

Rare E196A mutation in PRNP gene of 3 Chinese patients with Creutzfeldt-Jacob disease

Inherited prion diseases are characterized by mutations in the PRNP gene, which account for 5–15% of human prion diseases. Here we reported 3 Chinese genetic Creutzfeldt-Jacob disease cases (gCJD) with a rare mutation in PRNP leading to an exchange of amino acid from glutamic acid (E) to alanine (A) at codon 196 (E196A). All three patients were Han Chinese without any sibship among them. They showed various unspecific symptoms at onset and displayed typical clinical manifestations of sporadic CJD with progress of disease. The same time, 2 cases showed psychotic symptoms during the clinical courses. 14-3-3 proteins were positive in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and special abnormality were detected in MRI of all the cases. The polymorphism of codon 129 was methionin homozygote and that of codon 219 was glutamate homozygote in all 3 patients. The disease durations of the 3 cases varied from 10 to 22 months and no disease associated family history was figured out in all the cases.     

Genotype patterns and characteristics of PRNP in the Korean population

Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD), included in the human transmissible spongiform encephalopathies (TSE), is widely known to be caused by an abnormal accumulation of misfolding prion protein in the brain. Human prion protein gene (PRNP) is mapped in chromosome 20p13 and many single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in PRNP have been discovered. However, the functionality of SNPs in PRNP is yet unclear, though several SNPs have been known as important mutation related with susceptibility human prion diseases. Our aim is to identify specific genotype patterns and characteristics in the PRNP genomic region and to understand susceptibility among Korean discriminated prion disease patients, suspected CJD patients and the KARE data group. Here, we have researched genotypes and SNPs allele frequencies in PRNP in discriminated prion disease patients group (n = 22), suspected prion diseases patients group (n = 163) and the Korea Association REsource (KARE) data group (n = 296) in Korea. The sequencing regions were promoter region, exon1 and exon2 with their junction parts among 481 samples. A total of 25 SNPs were shown in this study. Nucleotide frequencies of all SNPs are exceedingly tended to bias toward dominant homozygote types except in rs2756271. Genotype frequencies at codon 129 and 219 coding region were similar with previous studies in Korea and Japan. Pathogenic mutations such as 102P/L, 200E/K and 203V/I were observed in discriminated CJD patients group, and 180V/I and 232M/R were shown in suspected prion disease patients group and the KARE data group. A total of 10 SNPs were newly identified, six in the promoter region, one in exon 2 and three in the 3′ UTR. The strong and unique linkage disequilibrium (D' = 0.94, r² = 0.89) was observed between rs57633656 and rs1800014 which is located in codon 219 coding region. We expect that these data can be provided to determine specific susceptibility and a protective factor of prion diseases not only in Koreans but also in East Asians.     

Heterozygous inhibition in prion infection: The stone fence model

The human PrP gene (PRNP) has two major polymorphic codons: 129 for methionine (M) or valine (V) and 219 for glutamate (E) or lysine (K). The PRNP heterozygotes appear to be protected from sporadic CJD compared to the PRNP homozygotes. The molecular mechanism responsible for these protective effects of PRNP heterozygosity has remained elusive. In this review, we describe the inhibition of PrP conversion observed in a series of transmission studies using PRNP heterozygous animal models. In vCJD infection, the conversion incompetent human PrP 129V molecules showed an inhibitory effect on the conversion of human PrP 129M molecules in the 129M/V heterozygous mice. Furthermore, though the human PrP 219E and PrP 219K were both conversion competent in vCJD infection, these conversion competent PrP molecules showed an inhibitory effect in the 219E/K heterozygous animals. To explain this heterozygous inhibition, we propose a possible mechanism designated as the stone fence model.Key words: prion protein, Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, polymorphism, knock-in mouse, conversion, heterozygous inhibition, stone fence model     

Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease associated with a V203I homozygous mutation in the prion protein gene

We report a Japanese patient with Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD) with a V203I homozygous mutation of the prion protein gene (PRNP). A 73-year-old woman developed rapidly progressive gait disturbance and cognitive dysfunction. Four months after the onset, she entered a state of an akinetic mutism. Gene analysis revealed a homozygous V203I mutation in the PRNP. Familial CJD with a V203I mutation is rare, and all previously reported cases had a heterozygous mutation showing manifestations similar to those of typical sporadic CJD. Although genetic prion diseases with homozygous PRNP mutations often present with an earlier onset and more rapid clinical course than those with heterozygous mutations, no difference was found in clinical phenotype between our homozygous case and reported heterozygous cases.     

Leu138 in bovine prion peptide fibrils is involved in seeding discrimination related to codon 129 M/V polymorphism in the prion peptide seeding experiment

The risk of acquiring variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease is closely related to polymorphism at codon 129 of the human prion gene, because almost all variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease patients are Met/Met homozygotes. Although animal transmission experiments corroborated this seeding discrimination, the origin of the differential seeding efficiency of the bovine prion seed for human codon 129 polymorphism remained elusive. Here, we used a short prion protein (PrP) peptide as a model system to test whether seeding discrimination can be found in this simple system. We used a previously developed 'seed-titration method' and time-resolved CD spectroscopy to compare sequence-dependent seeding efficiency regarding codon 129 polymorphism. Our results showed that the Met→Val substitution on the human PrP (huPrP) peptide decreased seeding efficiency by 10 times when fibrils formed from bovine PrP (bPrP) peptide were used as the seed. To explore whether the different seeding barrier is due to the chemical and structural properties of Met and Val or whether another residue is involved in this peptide model, we constructed three bPrP mutants, V112M, L138I and N143S, in each of which one residue was replaced by the corresponding human residue. Our data showed that Leu138 in the bPrP seed might be the key residue causing the different seeding efficiencies related to 129M/V polymorphism and the interference effect of huPrP129V in the huPrP129M/V mixture. We propose a 'surface competition hypothesis' to explain the big seeding barrier caused by 129V in the PrP peptide seeding experiment.     

The prion protein M129V polymorphism

The PRNP gene encodes the cellular isoform of prion protein (PrP^c). The M129V polymorphism influences the risk of prion diseases and may modulate the rate of neurodegeneration with age. We present the first study of the polymorphism among Polish centenarians. In the control group (n = 165, ages 18 to 56 years) the observed M129V genotype frequencies agreed with those expected according to the Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium (MM, MV, VV): 43%, 44%, 13% (HWE p > 0.05). Among centenarians (n = 150, ages 100 to 107) both homozygotes were more common than expected and HWE was rejected: 46%, 37%, 17% (expected 42%, 46%, 13%; HWE p = 0.025). This finding is consistent with a higher mortality rate among heterozygotes. However, the observed allele and genotype frequencies did not differ significantly between the oldest-old and the young controls. The genotypic frequencies were not related to severe cognitive impairment among the centenarians.     

Characterization of Variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease Prions in Prion Protein-humanized Mice Carrying Distinct Codon 129 Genotypes

To date, all clinical variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (vCJD) patients are homozygous for methionine at polymorphic codon 129 (129M/M) of the prion protein (PrP) gene. However, the appearance of asymptomatic secondary vCJD infection in individuals with a PRNP codon 129 genotype other than M/M and transmission studies using animal models have raised the concern that all humans might be susceptible to vCJD prions, especially via secondary infection. To reevaluate this possibility and to analyze in detail the transmission properties of vCJD prions to transgenic animals carrying distinct codon 129 genotype, we performed intracerebral inoculation of vCJD prions to humanized knock-in mice carrying all possible codon 129 genotypes (129M/M, 129M/V, or 129V/V). All humanized knock-in mouse lines were susceptible to vCJD infection, although the attack rate gradually decreased from 129M/M to 129M/V and to 129V/V. The amount of PrP deposition including florid/amyloid plaques in the brain also gradually decreased from 129M/M to 129M/V and to 129V/V. The biochemical properties of protease-resistant abnormal PrP in the brain and transmissibility of these humanized mouse-passaged vCJD prions upon subpassage into knock-in mice expressing bovine PrP were not affected by the codon 129 genotype. These results indicate that individuals with the 129V/V genotype may be more susceptible to secondary vCJD infection than expected and may lack the neuropathological characteristics observed in vCJD patients with the 129M/M genotype. Besides the molecular typing of protease-resistant PrP in the brain, transmission studies using knock-in mice carrying bovine PrP may aid the differential diagnosis of secondary vCJD infection, especially in individuals with the 129V/V genotype.     

A Chinese Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease patient with E196K mutation in PRNP

Genetic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (gCJD) is caused by a range of mutations in the prion protein gene (PRNP) and account for approximately 10–15% of overall human prion diseases worldwide. They are different with disease onset, disease duration, clinical signs and diagnostic findings. Here we reported a 71 year-old female with an E196K mutation in one PRNP allele, while the codon 129 was a methionine homozygous genotype. The patient started with non-specific symptoms, but displayed rapidly progressive disturbances of speech, memory, cognitive and physical movement. No periodic activity was recorded at electroencephalography (EEG) during the entire disease course. Retrospective investigation of her family members did not reveal similar neurological disorders. Total clinical course was about seven months.Key words: Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, PRNP, E196K     

Population distribution of the methionine allele at the PRNP codon 129 polymorphism in Europe and the Middle East

Methionine homozygosity at codon 129 of the prion protein gene is a risk factor for Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease. Knowledge of M129V polymorphism in normal populations may contribute to a better understanding of prion diseases. M129V polymorphism was studied in 2201 normal subjects, originating from 15 populations from Europe and the Middle East. Mean heterozygosity in these populations is 38.9%, and there is some significant geographic heterogeneity between them. A comparison of M129 allele frequencies in these 15 populations to those already published for 8 European countries plus Turkey shows significant correlations with both latitude (r = -0.77) and longitude (r = 0.69). The geographic map of methionine allele frequencies indicates an east-west gradient of decreasing methionine allele values from the Middle East to Western Europe.     

Prion Protein Expression and Processing in Human Mononuclear Cells: The Impact of the Codon 129 Prion Gene Polymorphism

Background

So far, all clinical cases of new variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (vCJD), thought to result from the Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE) prion agent, have shown Methionine–Methionine (M/M) homozygosity at the M129V polymorphism of the PRNP gene. Although established, this relationship is still not understood. In both vCJD and experimental BSE models prion agents do reach the bloodstream, raising concerns regarding disease transmission through blood transfusion.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We investigated the impact of the M129V polymorphism on the expression and processing of the prion protein in human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) from three blood donor populations with Methionine-Methionine (M/M), Valine-Valine (V/V) and M/V genotypes. Using real-time PCR, ELISA and immunoblot assays we were unable to find differences in prion protein expression and processing relating to the M129V polymorphism.

Conclusions/Significance

These results suggest that in PBMCs, the M129V PrP polymorphism has no significant impact on PrP expression, processing and the apparent glycoform distribution. Prion propagation should be investigated further in other cell types or tissues.     

Genetic basis of Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease in the United Kingdom: a systematic analysis of predisposing mutations and allelic variation in the PRNP gene

Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD) is a transmissible neurodegenerative disorder characterized by the accumulation of aggregates of a cellular protein, PrP, in the brain. In both human and animals, genetic alterations to the gene encoding PrP (PRNP in human) modulate susceptiblity to CJD. The recent epidemic of bovine spongiform encephalopathy in the UK has raised the possibility of transmission from animal produce to humans. To provide a baseline against which to assess possible risk factors, we have determined the frequencies of predisposing mutations and allelic variants in PRNP and their relative contributions to disease. Systematic PRNP genotype analysis was performed on suspected CJD cases referred to the National Surveillance Unit in the UK over the period 1990–1993. Inspection of 120 candidate cases revealed 67 patients with definite and probable CJD, based on clinical and neuropathological criteria. No PRNP mutations were detected in any of the remaining 53 patients assessed as “non-CJD”. A disease-associated mutation in the PRNP gene was identified in nine (13.4%) definite and probable cases of CJD, a reliable estimate of the incidence of PRNP-related inherited CJD based on a prospective epidemiological series. Within the group of sporadic CJD patients (lacking PRNP mutations), we confirmed that the genotype distribution with respect to the common methionine/valine (Met/Val) polymorphism at codon 129 within PRNP was significantly different from the normal Caucasian population. The incidence of Met homozygosity at this site was more than doubled and correlated with increased susceptibility to the development of sporadic CJD. Unlike other recent studies, Val homozygosity was also confirmed to be a significant risk factor in sporadic CJD, with the relative risks for the three genotypes Met/Met:Val/Val:Met/Val being 11:4:1. Received: 18 December 1995 / Revised: 19 January 1996     

Iatrogenic and sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease in 2 sisters without mutation in the prion protein gene

ABSTRACT

Human genetic prion diseases have invariably been linked to alterations of the prion protein (PrP) gene PRNP. Two sisters died from probable Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD) in Switzerland within 14 y. At autopsy, both patients had typical spongiform change in their brains accompanied by punctuate deposits of PrP. Biochemical analyses demonstrated proteinase K-resistant PrP. Sequencing of PRNP showed 2 wild-type alleles in both siblings. Retrospectively, clinical data revealed a history of dural transplantation in the initially deceased sister, compatible with a diagnosis of iatrogenic CJD. Clinical and familial histories provided no evidence for potential horizontal transmission. This observation of 2 siblings suffering from CJD without mutations in the PRNP gene suggests potential involvement of non-PRNP genes in prion disease etiology.     

Copper has differential effect on prion protein with polymorphism of position 129

The pathology of human prion diseases is affected by polymorphism at amino acid residue 129 of the prion protein gene. Recombinant mouse prion proteins mimicking either form of the polymorphism were prepared to examine their effect on the conformation and the level of superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity of the prion protein. Following the binding of copper atoms to prion protein, antibody mapping and CD analysis detected conformational differences between the two forms of protein. However, neither the level of copper binding nor the level of SOD activity associated with this form of prion protein altered with the identity of codon 129. These results suggest that in the holo-metal binding form of the protein, prion structure but not its SOD activity is affected by polymorphism at codon 129.