Tailored amino acid diversity for the evolution of antibody affinity

Antibodies are a unique class of proteins with the ability to adapt their binding sites for high affinity and high specificity to a multitude of antigens. Many analyses have been performed on antibody sequences and structures to elucidate which amino acids have a predominant role in antibody interactions with antigens. These studies have generally not distinguished between amino acids selected for broad antigen specificity in the primary immune response and those selected for high affinity in the secondary immune response. By studying a large data set of affinity matured antibodies derived from in vitro directed evolution experiments, we were able to specifically highlight a subset of amino acids associated with affinity improvements. In a comparison of affinity maturations using either tailored or full amino acid diversification, the tailored approach was found to be at least as effective at improving affinity while requiring fewer mutagenesis libraries than the traditional method. The resulting sequence data also highlight the potential for further reducing amino acid diversity for high affinity binding interactions.     

Antigen-antibody interaction. Synthetic peptides define linear antigenic determinants recognized by monoclonal antibodies directed to the cytoplasmic carboxyl terminus of rhodopsin

The specificities of four monoclonal antibodies rho 1D4, 1C5, 3A6, and 3D6 prepared by immunization of rod outer segments containing rhodopsin have been defined using synthetic peptides. All of these antibodies interact within the 18 residues at the COOH terminus of rhodopsin and recognize linear antigenic determinants of 4-11 residues. Twenty-seven synthetic peptide analogs of varying lengths of native sequence or containing single amino acid substitutions at each position of the COOH-terminal 18 residues have provided some insight into the mechanism of antigen-antibody binding. Our results clearly demonstrate that antibodies can be highly specific at key positions as shown by the loss of binding on single amino acid substitutions in the binding site. In contrast single amino acid substitutions at other positions in the binding site only affect affinity for some antibodies. Ionic interactions can dominate immunogenic determinants. Immunogenic determinants are not restricted to highly charged hydrophilic regions on the surface of a protein and may be dominated by hydrophobic interactions. Although certain side chains can dominate the interaction of the antigen with antibody, our results are in agreement with the interpretation that the free energies of all the contact points are additive and a certain free energy must be present to achieve binding. Antibodies with different specificities directed to the same region of the protein antigen can be produced in an immune response. Peptide antigens representing regions of a protein antigen bind best to the anti-protein antibody when the sequence is shortened to contain only those residues binding to the specificity site in the antibody. Cross-reactivity between protein antigens can be explained by conservation of the critical residues in the combining site.     

A combinatorial mutagenesis approach for functional epitope mapping on phage-displayed target antigen: Application to antibodies against epidermal growth factor

Although multiple different procedures to characterize the epitopes recognized by antibodies have been developed, site-directed mutagenesis remains the method of choice to define the energetic contribution of antigen residues to binding. These studies are useful to identify critical residues and to delineate functional maps of the epitopes. However, they tend to underestimate the roles of residues that are not critical for binding on their own, but contribute to the formation of the target epitope in an additive, or even cooperative, way. Mapping antigenic determinants with a diffuse energetic landscape, which establish multiple individually weak interactions with the antibody paratope, resulting in high affinity and specificity recognition of the epitope as a whole, is thus technically challenging. The current work was aimed at developing a combinatorial strategy to overcome the limitations of site-directed mutagenesis, relying on comprehensive randomization of discrete antigenic regions within phage-displayed antigen libraries. Two model antibodies recognizing epidermal growth factor were used to validate the mapping platform. Abrogation of antibody recognition due to the introduction of simultaneous replacements was able to show the involvement of particular amino acid clusters in epitope formation. The abundance of some of the original residues (or functionally equivalent amino acids sharing their physicochemical properties) among the set of mutated antigen variants selected on a given antibody highlighted their contributions and allowed delineation of a detailed functional map of the corresponding epitope. The use of the combinatorial approach could be expanded to map the interactions between other antigens/antibodies.     

A combinatorial mutagenesis approach for functional epitope mapping on phage-displayed target antigen

Although multiple different procedures to characterize the epitopes recognized by antibodies have been developed, site-directed mutagenesis remains the method of choice to define the energetic contribution of antigen residues to binding. These studies are useful to identify critical residues and to delineate functional maps of the epitopes. However, they tend to underestimate the roles of residues that are not critical for binding on their own, but contribute to the formation of the target epitope in an additive, or even cooperative, way. Mapping antigenic determinants with a diffuse energetic landscape, which establish multiple individually weak interactions with the antibody paratope, resulting in high affinity and specificity recognition of the epitope as a whole, is thus technically challenging. The current work was aimed at developing a combinatorial strategy to overcome the limitations of site-directed mutagenesis, relying on comprehensive randomization of discrete antigenic regions within phage-displayed antigen libraries. Two model antibodies recognizing epidermal growth factor were used to validate the mapping platform. Abrogation of antibody recognition due to the introduction of simultaneous replacements was able to show the involvement of particular amino acid clusters in epitope formation. The abundance of some of the original residues (or functionally equivalent amino acids sharing their physicochemical properties) among the set of mutated antigen variants selected on a given antibody highlighted their contributions and allowed delineation of a detailed functional map of the corresponding epitope. The use of the combinatorial approach could be expanded to map the interactions between other antigens/antibodies.     

Decision-making critical amino acids: role in designing peptide vaccines for eliciting Th1 and Th2 immune response

CD4 T cells play a cardinal role in orchestrating immune system. Differentiation of CD4 T cells to Th1 and Th2 effector subsets depends on multiple factors such as relative intensity of interactions between T cell receptor with peptide-major histocompatibility complex, cytokine milieu, antigen dose, and costimulatory molecules. Literature supports the critical role of peptide’s binding affinity to Human Leukocyte Antigens (HLAs) and in the differentiation of naïve CD4 T cells to Th1 and Th2 subsets. However, there exists no definite report addressing very precisely the correlation between physicochemical properties (hydrophobicity, hydrophilicity), pattern, position of amino acids in peptide and their role in skewing immune response towards Th1 and Th2 cells. This may play a significant role in designing peptide vaccines. Hence in the present study, we have evaluated the relationship between amino acid pattern and their influence in differentiation of Th1 and Th2 cells. We have used a data set of 320 peptides, whose role has been already established experimentally in the generation of either Th1 or Th2 immune response. Further, characterization was done based on binding affinity, promiscuity, amino acid pattern and binding conformation of peptides. We have observed that distinct amino acids in peptides elicit either Th1 or Th2 immunity. Consequently, this study signifies that alteration in the sequence and type of selected amino acids in the HLA class II binding peptides can modulate the differentiation of Th1 and Th2 cells. Therefore, this study may have an important implication in providing a platform for designing peptide-based vaccine candidates that can trigger desired Th1 or Th2 response.     

Structure, function and properties of antibody binding sites

Do antibody combining sites possess general properties that enable them to bind different antigens with varying affinities and to bind novel antigens? Here, we address this question by examining the physical and chemical characteristics most favourable for residues involved in antigen accommodation and binding. Amphipathic amino acids could readily tolerate the change of environment from hydrophilic to hydrophobic that occurs upon antibody-antigen complex formation. Residues that are large and can participate in a wide variety of van der Waals' and electrostatic interactions would permit binding to a range of antigens. Amino acids with flexible side-chains could generate a structurally plastic region, i.e. a binding site possessing the ability to mould itself around the antigen to improve complementarity of the interacting surfaces. Hence, antibodies could bind to an array of novel antigens using a limited set of residues interspersed with more unique residues to which greater binding specificity can be attributed. An individual antibody molecule could thus be cross-reactive and have the capacity to bind structurally similar ligands. The accommodation of variations in antigenic structure by modest combining site flexibility could make an important contribution to immune defence by allowing antibody binding to distinct but closely related pathogens. Tyr and Trp most readily fulfil these catholic physicochemical requirements and thus would be expected to be common in combining sites on theoretical grounds. Experimental support for this comes from three sources, (1) the high frequency of participation by these amino acids in the antigen binding observed in six crystallographically determined antibody-antigen complexes, (2) their frequent occurrence in the putative binding regions of antibodies as determined from structural and sequence data and (3) the potential for movement of their side-chains in known antibody binding sites and model systems. The six bound antigens comprise two small different haptens, non-overlapping regions of the same large protein and a 19 amino acid residue peptide. Out of a total of 85 complementarity determining region positions, only 37 locations (plus 3 framework) are directly involved in antigen interaction. Of these, light chain residue 91 is utilized by all the complexes examined, whilst light chain 32, light chain 96 and heavy chain 33 are employed by five out of the six. The binding sites in known antibody-antigen complexes as well as the postulated combining sites in free Fab fragments show similar characteristics with regard to the types of amino acids present. The possible role of other amino acids is also assessed.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Effective binding to protein antigens by antibodies from antibody libraries designed with enhanced protein recognition propensities

Antibodies provide immune protection by recognizing antigens of diverse chemical properties, but elucidating the amino acid sequence-function relationships underlying the specificity and affinity of antibody-antigen interactions remains challenging. We designed and constructed phage-displayed synthetic antibody libraries with enriched protein antigen-recognition propensities calculated with machine learning predictors, which indicated that the designed single-chain variable fragment variants were encoded with enhanced distributions of complementarity-determining region (CDR) hot spot residues with high protein antigen recognition propensities in comparison with those in the human antibody germline sequences. Antibodies derived directly from the synthetic antibody libraries, without affinity maturation cycles comparable to those in in vivo immune systems, bound to the corresponding protein antigen through diverse conformational or linear epitopes with specificity and affinity comparable to those of the affinity-matured antibodies from in vivo immune systems. The results indicated that more densely populated CDR hot spot residues were sustainable by the antibody structural frameworks and could be accompanied by enhanced functionalities in recognizing protein antigens. Our study results suggest that synthetic antibody libraries, which are not limited by the sequences found in antibodies in nature, could be designed with the guidance of the computational machine learning algorithms that are programmed to predict interaction propensities to molecules of diverse chemical properties, leading to antibodies with optimal characteristics pertinent to their medical applications.     

DNA binding specificity of mutant glucocorticoid receptor DNA-binding domains

Mutation of a small number of amino acids in the DNA-binding domain of the estrogen receptor to the corresponding sequence of the glucocorticoid receptor switches the specificity of the receptor in transactivation assays (Mader, S., Kumar, V., de Verneuil, H., and Chambon, P. (1989) Nature 338, 271-274). We have made the corresponding reciprocal mutations in the context of the glucocorticoid receptor DNA-binding domain and studied the binding of wild type and mutant purified proteins to palindromic glucocorticoid and estrogen response elements as well as to elements of intermediate sequence, using gel mobility shift assays. We show here that a protein with two altered amino acids binds glucocorticoid and estrogen response elements with a low but equal affinity, whereas a protein with an additional changed residue has a high affinity for estrogen response elements but still retains a considerable affinity for glucocorticoid response elements. Using binding sites of intermediate sequence we have further characterized the interaction with DNA. The in vitro DNA binding results are confirmed by in vivo transactivation assays in yeast. Finally we suggest a testable model for amino acid/base pair interactions involved in recognition by the glucocorticoid receptor DNA-binding domain of its target sequence.     

In vitro scanning saturation mutagenesis of all the specificity determining residues in an antibody binding site.

For the first time, each specificity determining residue (SDR) in the binding site of an antibody has been replaced with every other possible single amino acid substitution, and the resulting mutants analyzed for binding affinity and specificity. The studies were conducted on a variant of the 26-10 antidigoxin single chain Fv (scFv) using in vitro scanning saturation mutagenesis, a new process that allows the high throughput production and characterization of antibody mutants [Burks,E.A., Chen,G., Georgiou,G. and Iverson,B.L. (1997) Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 94, 412-417]. Single amino acid mutants of 26-10 scFv were identified that modulated specificity in dramatic fashion. The overall plasticity of the antibody binding site with respect to amino acid replacement was also evaluated, revealing that 86% of all mutants retained measurable binding activity. Finally, by analyzing the physical properties of amino acid substitutions with respect to their effect on hapten binding, conclusions were drawn regarding the functional role played by the wild-type residue at each SDR position. The reported results highlight the value of in vitro scanning saturation mutagenesis for engineering antibody binding specificity, for evaluating the plasticity of proteins, and for comprehensive structure-function studies and analysis.     

Diverse VH and VL genes are used to produce antibodies against a defined protein epitope

mAb secreting hybridomas were produced from mice hyperimmune to the model Ag tobacco mosaic virus protein. Six mAb were selected for their ability to bind synthetic peptides corresponding to amino acid residues 103-112 and 97-107 of tobacco mosaic virus protein. These mAb were analyzed for their fine specificity by measuring binding to synthetic analogs of the decapeptide, and cDNA sequences encoding the mAb V regions were determined. These analyses revealed that a wide range of different V regions are capable of binding with the same decapeptide epitope, and that these antibody sequence differences generally coincided with different binding fine specificities. This diverse antibody response with specificity for the same epitope demonstrates both the breadth of potential of the immune system and the lack of exclusivity in specific protein:protein interactions.     

Molecular evolution of antibody cross-reactivity for two subtypes of type A botulinum neurotoxin

Broadening antibody specificity without compromising affinity should facilitate detection and neutralization of toxin and viral subtypes. We used yeast display and a co-selection strategy to increase cross-reactivity of a single chain (sc) Fv antibody to botulinum neurotoxin type A (BoNT/A). Starting with a scFv that binds the BoNT/A1 subtype with high affinity (136 pM) and the BoNT/A2 subtype with low affinity (109 nM), we increased its affinity for BoNT/A2 1,250-fold, to 87 pM, while maintaining high-affinity binding to BoNT/A1 (115 pM). To find the molecular basis for improved cross-reactivity, we determined the X-ray co-crystal structures of wild-type and cross-reactive antibodies complexed to BoNT/A1 at resolutions up to 2.6 A, and measured the thermodynamic contribution of BoNT/A1 and A2 amino acids to wild-type and cross-reactive antibody binding. The results show how an antibody can be engineered to bind two different antigens despite structural differences in the antigen-antibody interface and may provide a general strategy for tuning antibody specificity and cross-reactivity.     

High affinity RNase S-peptide variants obtained by phage display have a novel "hot-spot" of binding energy.

Using phage display mutagenesis, high affinity variants of RNase S-peptide were produced that bind to RNase S-protein over 100-fold more tightly than the wild type S-peptide. The S-peptide: S-protein interface was further characterized using "biased" phage display libraries, where each targeted residue was constrained to be either polar or nonpolar. The use of these tailored libraries placed constraints on the type of interactions present during affinity maturation process and allowed more amino acids to be randomized simultaneously. These results, in conjunction with kinetic association and dissociation constants determined by surface plasmon resonance (SPR), highlight the role of a single mutation (A5W) in increasing S-peptide binding affinity. High affinity S-peptide variants were only identified when tryptophan was present in the phage display library at position 5, suggesting that this residue is a "hot-spot" of binding energy in the high affinity variants. Analysis of SPR data in the presence of denaturant suggests that the increased affinity is a result of increased hydrophobic interactions in the transition state rather than a stabilization of helical structure.     

Cation–π, amino–π, π–π, and H‐bond interactions stabilize antigen–antibody interfaces

The identification of immunogenic regions on the surface of antigens, which are able to stimulate an immune response, is a major challenge for the design of new vaccines. Computational immunology aims at predicting such regions—in particular B‐cell epitopes—but is far from being reliably applicable on a large scale. To gain understanding into the factors that contribute to the antigen–antibody affinity and specificity, we perform a detailed analysis of the amino acid composition and secondary structure of antigen and antibody surfaces, and of the interactions that stabilize the complexes, in comparison with the composition and interactions observed in other heterodimeric protein interfaces. We make a distinction between linear and conformational B‐cell epitopes, according to whether they consist of successive residues along the polypeptide chain or not. The antigen–antibody interfaces were shown to differ from other protein–protein interfaces by their smaller size, their secondary structure with less helices and more loops, and the interactions that stabilize them: more H‐bond, cation–π, amino–π, and π–π interactions, and less hydrophobic packing; linear and conformational epitopes can clearly be distinguished. Often, chains of successive interactions, called cation/amino–π and π–π chains, are formed. The amino acid composition differs significantly between the interfaces: antigen–antibody interfaces are less aliphatic and more charged, polar and aromatic than other heterodimeric protein interfaces. Moreover, paratopes and epitopes—albeit to a lesser extent—have amino acid compositions that are distinct from general protein surfaces. This specificity holds promise for improving B‐cell epitope prediction. Proteins 2014; 82:1734–1746. © 2014 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

The extent of affinity maturation differs between the memory and antibody-forming cell compartments in the primary immune response.

Immunization with protein-containing antigens results in two types of antigen-specific B cell: antibody forming cells (AFCs) producing antibody of progressively higher affinity and memory lymphocytes capable of producing high affinity antibody upon re-exposure to antigen. The issue of the inter-relationship between affinity maturation of memory B cells and AFCs was addressed through analysis of single, antigen-specific B cells from the memory and AFC compartments during the primary response to a model antigen. Only 65% of splenic memory B cells were found capable of producing high affinity antibody, meaning that low affinity cells persist into this compartment. In contrast, by 28 days after immunization all AFCs produced high affinity antibody. We identified a unique, persistent sub-population of bone marrow AFCs containing few somatic mutations, suggesting they arose early in the response, yet highly enriched for an identical affinity-enhancing amino acid exchange, suggesting strong selection. Our results imply that affinity maturation of a primary immune response occurs by the early selective differentiation of high affinity variants into AFCs which subsequently persist in the bone marrow. In contrast, the memory B-cell population contains few, if any, cells from the early response and is less stringently selected.     

Diversification of specificity after maturation of the antibody response to the HIV gp41 epitope ELDKWA

During maturing antibody responses the increase in affinity for target antigens is achieved by genetic diversification of antibody genes followed by selection for improved binding. The effect this process has on the specificity of antibody for variants of the antigen is not well-defined, despite the potential role of antibody diversification in generating enhanced protection against pathogen escape mutants, or novel specificities after vaccination. To investigate this, a library of single amino-acid substitution epitope variants has been screened with serum obtained at different time-points after immunization of mice with the HIV gp41 peptide epitope ELDKWA. The serum IgG response is shown to mature and increase affinity for ELDKWA, and the titre and affinity of IgG against most epitope variants tested increases. Furthermore there is a bias towards high affinity serum IgG binding to variant epitopes with conservative substitutions, although underlying this trend there is also significant binding to many epitopes with non-conservative substitutions. Thus, maturation of the antibody response to a single epitope results in a broadening of the high-affinity response toward variant epitopes. This implies that many pathogen epitope escape variants that could manifest as single amino-acid substitutions would not emerge by escaping immune surveillance.     

Quantitative specificity‐based display library screening identifies determinants of antibody‐epitope binding specificity

Despite the critical importance of molecular specificity in bimolecular systems, in vitro display technologies have been applied extensively for affinity maturation of peptides and antibodies without explicitly measuring the specificity of the desired interaction. We devised a general strategy to measure, screen, and evolve specificity of protein ligand interactions analogous to widely used affinity maturation strategies. The specificity of binding to target and nontarget antibodies labeled with spectrally distinct fluorophores was measured simultaneously in protein mixtures via multiparameter flow cytometry, thereby enabling screening for high target antibody specificity. Isolated antibody specific ligands exhibited varying specificity, revealing critical amino acid determinants for target recognition and nontarget avoidance in complex mixtures. Molecular specificity in the mixture was further enhanced by quantitative directed evolution, yielding a family of epitopes exhibiting improved specificities equivalent, or superior to, the native peptide antigen to which the antibody was raised. Specificity screening simultaneously favored affinity, yielding ligands with three‐fold improved affinity relative to the parent epitope. Quantitative specificity screening will be useful to screen, evolve, and characterize the specificity of protein and peptide interactions for molecular recognition applications.     

Heavy and light chain variable region sequences and antibody properties of anti-phosphotyrosine antibodies reveal both common and distinct features.

Phosphotyrosine and similar analogs have been used to elicit antibodies that have found widespread use in the study of cellular tyrosine phosphorylation. In order to better understand the anti-phosphotyrosine immune response and to elucidate the details of the specific association between a tyrosine phosphate and an antibody combining site, we have undertaken a detailed comparison of antibody stability, specificity, apparent affinity, and primary structure for eight different anti-phosphotyrosine antibodies derived from immunizations with three different antigens. Two of these, 2G8 and 1G2, were derived from an immunization using azobenzylphosphonate conjugated to carrier, and five others, Py2, Py20, Py42, Py54, and Py69, were the products of an immunization with phosphotyrosine conjugated to carrier. Each of these anti-hapten antibodies was an IgG. One antibody, 129, an IgM, was the result of an immunization with a mixture of tyrosine-phosphorylated proteins which had been purified from growth factor treated cells. We found that antibody binding was significantly inhibited by millimolar levels of divalent cations or high concentrations of monovalent salt, with the exception of the antibody 129 where binding was significantly enhanced by both. Under optimal conditions, the highest apparent affinities for phosphotyrosine were observed for antibodies Py69 and Py20 (10(-6)-10(-7) M) and the lowest for 129 and 1G2 (10(-3)-10(-4). The heavy and light chain variable regions of seven of these antibodies were cloned and sequenced and a predominant anti-phosphotyrosine response was observed. The light chains of these antibodies could be assigned to one of two major VK groups, VK10 and VK19, with sequence identity between the different light chains of each class ranging from 65 to 100% at the amino acid level. Similar sequence identity was found among the heavy chain sequences (89-98% identity at the amino acid level) with the exception of one antibody, 2G8, which was only distantly related to the others (61-64% amino acid identity). These heavy chains belong to the same heavy chain family, J558. Two of the antibodies, Py20 and Py69, were clearly derived from the same progenitor cell since both share a highly unusual apparent V-D-D-JH organization. However, a significant level of somatic mutation has occurred between the two antibodies resulting in subtle changes in their apparent affinity and specificity.     

Identification of the β-Lactamase Inhibitor Protein-II (BLIP-II) Interface Residues Essential for Binding Affinity and Specificity for Class A β-Lactamases

The interactions between β-lactamase inhibitory proteins (BLIPs) and β-lactamases have been used as model systems to understand the principles of affinity and specificity in protein-protein interactions. The most extensively studied tight binding inhibitor, BLIP, has been characterized with respect to amino acid determinants of affinity and specificity for binding β-lactamases. BLIP-II, however, shares no sequence or structural homology to BLIP and is a femtomolar to picomolar potency inhibitor, and the amino acid determinants of binding affinity and specificity are unknown. In this study, alanine scanning mutagenesis was used in combination with determinations of on and off rates for each mutant to define the contribution of residues on the BLIP-II binding surface to both affinity and specificity toward four β-lactamases of diverse sequence. The residues making the largest contribution to binding energy are heavily biased toward aromatic amino acids near the center of the binding surface. In addition, substitutions that reduce binding energy do so by increasing off rates without impacting on rates. Also, residues with large contributions to binding energy generally exhibit low temperature factors in the structures of complexes. Finally, with the exception of D206A, BLIP-II alanine substitutions exhibit a similar trend of effect for all β-lactamases, i.e., a substitution that reduces affinity for one β-lactamase usually reduces affinity for all β-lactamases tested.     

Aberrant maturational characteristics of the immune responses of NZB mice to autologous and heterologous erythrocyte antigens

The maturational characteristics of the humoral immune responses of C3H and NZB mice to autologous and heterologous erythrocyte antigens were investigated. Clonal selection of antibody-secreting B lymphocytes was examined at the plaque-forming cell level of analysis of changes in mean antibody affinity and the heterogeneity of binding affinities. The primary immune response of C3H mice to SRBC exhibited a progressive temporal increase in mean relative antibody affinity and a concomitant restriction in the heterogeneity of binding affinities consistent with clonal selection and restriction of B lymphocytes to high affinity antibody-secreting cells. By contrast, the anti-SRBC immune response of NZB mice displayed aberrant maturational characteristics with a progressive decrease in mean relative antibody affinity but also clonal restriction with selection of clones of cells secreting low affinity antibodies. The spontaneous autoimmune responses of NZB mice to autologous erythrocyte surface autoantigens X and HB were different from the response to heterologous erythrocytes in that there was neither a progressive change in mean relative binding affinity nor evidence of progressive clonal restriction. Although the precise mechanisms responsible for the aberrant selection and derepression of B lymphocyte clones in NZB mice have not been identified, the very nature of the aberration suggests the existence of one or more defects which may be intrinsic to the B lymphocytes of NZB mice.