Trapping the on-pathway folding intermediate of Im7 at equilibrium

The four-helical protein Im7 folds via a rapidly formed on-pathway intermediate (k(UI)=3000 s(-1) at pH 7.0, 10 degrees C) that contains three (helices I, II and IV) of the four native alpha-helices. The relatively slow (k(IN)=300 s(-1)) conversion of this intermediate into the native structure is driven by the folding and docking of the six residue helix III onto the developing hydrophobic core. Here, we describe the structural properties of four Im7* variants designed to trap the protein in the intermediate state by disrupting the stabilising interactions formed between helix III and the rest of the protein structure. In two of these variants (I54A and L53AI54A), hydrophobic residues within helix III have been mutated to alanine, whilst in the other two mutants the sequence encompassing the native helix III was replaced by a glycine linker, three (H3G3) or six (H3G6) residues in length. All four variants were shown to be monomeric, as judged by analytical ultracentrifugation, and highly helical as measured by far-UV CD. In addition, all the variants denature co-operatively and have a stability (DeltaG(UF)) and buried hydrophobic surface area (M(UF)) similar to those of the on-pathway kinetic intermediate. Structural characterisation of these variants using 1-anilino-8-napthalene sulphonic acid (ANS) binding, near-UV CD and 1D (1)H NMR demonstrate further that the trapped intermediate ensemble is highly structured with little exposed hydrophobic surface area. Interestingly, however, the structural properties of the variants I54A and L53AI54A differ in detail from those of H3G3 and H3G6. In particular, the single tryptophan residue, located near the end of helix IV, and distant from helix III, is in a distinct environment in the two sets of mutants as judged by fluorescence, near-UV CD and the sensitivity of tryptophan fluorescence to iodide quenching. Overall, the results confirm previous kinetic analysis that demonstrated the hierarchical folding of Im7 via an on-pathway intermediate, and show that this species is a highly helical ensemble with a well-formed hydrophobic core. By contrast with the native state, however, the intermediate ensemble is flexible enough to change in response to mutation, its structural properties being tailored by residues in the sequence encompassing the native helix III.     

Equilibrium amide hydrogen exchange and protein folding kinetics

The classical Linderstrøm-Lang hydrogen exchange (HX) model is extended to describe the relationship between the HX behaviors (EX1 and EX2) and protein folding kinetics for the amide protons that can only exchange by global unfolding in a three-state system including native (N), intermediate (I), and unfolded (U) states. For these slowly exchanging amide protons, it is shown that the existence of an intermediate (I) has no effect on the HX behavior in an off-pathway three-state system (IUN). On the other hand, in an on-pathway three-state system (UIN), the existence of a stable folding intermediate has profound effect on the HX behavior. It is shown that fast refolding from the unfolded state to the stable intermediate state alone does not guarantee EX2 behavior. The rate of refolding from the intermediate state to the native state also plays a crucial role in determining whether EX1 or EX2 behavior should occur. This is mainly due to the fact that only amide protons in the native state are observed in the hydrogen exchange experiment. These new concepts suggest that caution needs to be taken if one tries to derive the kinetic events of protein folding from equilibrium hydrogen exchange experiments.     

Sulfate-induced effects in the on-pathway intermediate of the bacterial immunity protein Im7

Intermediates have now been identified in the folding of a number of small, single-domain proteins. Here we describe experiments to determine the effect of Na(2)SO(4) on the properties of the on-pathway intermediate formed early during the folding of the four-helical protein, Im7. This intermediate, studied previously in 0.4 M Na(2)SO(4), contains three of the four native helices and is fascinating in that several residues in helices I, II, and IV make non-native interactions that stabilize this state. Whether these contacts form as a consequence of the presence of Na(2)SO(4), however, remained unresolved. Using kinetic analysis of the effect of Na(2)SO(4) on the unfolding and refolding kinetics of Im7*, combined with detailed analysis of the resulting chevron plots, we show that decreasing the concentration of Na(2)SO(4) from 0.4 to 0 M destabilizes the intermediate and rate-limiting transition (TS2) states by 7 and 10 kJ mol(-)(1), respectively, and has little effect on the relative compactness of these states compared with that of the unfolded ensemble (beta(I) approximately 0.8, beta(TS2) approximately 0.9 in 0 to 0.4 M Na(2)SO(4)). Analysis of 10 variants of the protein in 0.2 M Na(2)SO(4) using Phi-values showed that the structural properties of the intermediate and TS2 are not altered significantly by the concentration of the kosmotrope. The data demonstrate that the rapid formation of a compact intermediate stabilized by non-native interactions during Im7* folding is not induced by high concentrations of the stabilizing salt, but is a generic feature of the folding of this protein.     

NMR analysis of the conformational properties of the trapped on-pathway folding intermediate of the bacterial immunity protein Im7

Previous work shows that the transiently populated, on-pathway intermediate in Im7 folding contains three of the four native alpha-helices docked around a core stabilised by native and non-native interactions. To determine the structure and dynamic properties of this species in more detail, we have used protein engineering to trap the intermediate at equilibrium and analysed the resulting proteins using NMR spectroscopy and small angle X-ray scattering. Four variants were created. In L53AI54A, two hydrophobic residues within helix III are truncated, preventing helix III from docking stably onto the developing hydrophobic core. In two other variants, the six residues encompassing the native helix III were replaced with three (H3G3) or six (H3G6) glycine residues. In the fourth variant, YY, two native tyrosine residues (Tyr55 and Tyr56) were re-introduced into H3G6 to examine their role in determining the properties of the intermediate ensemble. All four variants show variable peak intensities and broad peak widths, consistent with these proteins being conformationally dynamic. Chemical shift analyses demonstrated that L53AI54A and YY contain native-like secondary structure in helices I and IV, while helix II is partly formed and helix III is absent. Lack of NOEs and rapid NH exchange for L53AI54A, combined with detailed analysis of the backbone dynamics, indicated that the hydrophobic core of this variant is not uniquely structured, but fluctuates on the NMR timescale. The results demonstrate that though much of the native-like secondary structure of Im7 is present in the variants, their hydrophobic cores remain relatively fluid. The comparison of H3G3/H3G6 and L53AI54A/YY suggests that Tyr55 and/or Tyr56 interact with the three-helix core, leading other residues in this region of the protein to dock with the core as folding progresses. In this respect, the three-helix bundle acts as a template for formation of helix III and the creation of the native fold.     

Primary structure effects on peptide group hydrogen exchange

The rate of exchange of peptide group NH hydrogens with the hydrogens of aqueous solvent is sensitive to neighboring side chains. To evaluate the effects of protein side chains, all 20 naturally occurring amino acids were studied using dipeptide models. Both inductive and steric blocking effects are apparent. The additivity of nearest-neighbor blocking and inductive effects was tested in oligo-and polypeptides and, suprisingly, confirmed. Reference rates for alanine-containing peptides were determined and effects of temperature considered. These results provide the information necessary to evaluate measured protein NH to ND exchange rates by comparing them with rates to be expected for the same amino acid sequence is unstructured aligo- and polypeptides. The application of this approach to protein studies is discussed. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Equilibrium and kinetic folding of rabbit muscle triosephosphate isomerase by hydrogen exchange mass spectrometry

Unfolding and refolding of rabbit muscle triosephosphate isomerase (TIM), a model for (betaalpha)8-barrel proteins, has been studied by amide hydrogen exchange/mass spectrometry. Unfolding was studied by destabilizing the protein in guanidine hydrochloride (GdHCl) or urea, pulse-labeling with 2H2O and analyzing the intact protein by HPLC electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. Bimodal isotope patterns were found in the mass spectra of the labeled protein, indicating two-state unfolding behavior. Refolding experiments were performed by diluting solutions of TIM unfolded in GdHCl or urea and pulse-labeling with 2H2O at different times. Mass spectra of the intact protein labeled after one to two minutes had three envelopes of isotope peaks, indicating population of an intermediate. Kinetic modeling indicates that the stability of the folding intermediate in water is only 1.5 kcal/mol. Failure to detect the intermediate in the unfolding experiments was attributed to its low stability and the high concentrations of denaturant required for unfolding experiments. The folding status of each segment of the polypeptide backbone was determined from the deuterium levels found in peptic fragments of the labeled protein. Analysis of these spectra showed that the C-terminal half folds to form the intermediate, which then forms native TIM with folding of the N-terminal half. These results show that TIM folding fits the (4+4) model for folding of (betaalpha)8-barrel proteins. Results of a double-jump experiment indicate that proline isomerization does not contribute to the rate-limiting step in the folding of TIM.     

The folding pathway of T4 lysozyme: an on-pathway hidden folding intermediate

T4 lysozyme has two easily distinguishable but energetically coupled domains: the N and C-terminal domains. In earlier studies, an amide hydrogen/deuterium exchange pulse-labeling experiment detected a stable submillisecond intermediate that accumulates before the rate-limiting transition state. It involves the formation of structures in both the N and C-terminal regions. However, a native-state hydrogen exchange experiment subsequently detected an equilibrium intermediate that only involves the formation of the C-terminal domain. Here, using stopped-flow circular dichroism and fluorescence, amide hydrogen exchange-folding competition, and protein engineering methods, we re-examined the folding pathway of T4-lysozyme. We found no evidence for the existence of a stable folding intermediate before the rate-limiting transition state at neutral pH. In addition, using native-state hydrogen exchange-directed protein engineering, we created a mimic of the equilibrium intermediate. We found that the intermediate mimic folds with the same rate as the wild-type protein, suggesting that the equilibrium intermediate is an on-pathway intermediate that exists after the rate-limiting transition state.     

Multi-state unfolding of the alpha subunit of tryptophan synthase, a TIM barrel protein: insights into the secondary structure of the stable equilibrium intermediates by hydrogen exchange mass spectrometry

The urea-induced unfolding of the alpha subunit of tryptophan synthase (alphaTS) from Escherichia coli, an eight-stranded (beta/alpha)(8) TIM barrel protein, has been shown to involve two stable equilibrium intermediates, I1 and I2, well populated at approximately 3 M and 5 M urea, respectively. The characterization of the I1 intermediate by circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy has shown that I1 retains a significant fraction of the native ellipticity; the far-UV CD signal for the I2 species closely resembles that of the fully unfolded form. To obtain detailed insight into the disruption of secondary structure in the urea-induced unfolding process, a hydrogen exchange-mass spectrometry study was performed on alphaTS. The full-length protein was destabilized in increasing concentration of urea, the amide hydrogen atoms were pulse-labeled with deuterium, the labeled samples were quenched in acid and the products were analyzed by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. Consistent with the CD results, the I1 intermediate protects up to approximately 129 amide hydrogen atoms against exchange while the I2 intermediate offers no protection. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry analysis of the peptic fragments derived from alphaTS labeled at 3 M urea indicates that most of the region between residues 12-130, which constitutes the first four beta strands and three alpha helices, (beta/alpha)(1-3)beta(4), is structured. The (beta/alpha)(1-3)beta(4) module appears to represent the minimum sub-core of stability of the I1 intermediate. A 4+2+2 folding model is proposed as a likely alternative to the earlier 6+2 folding mechanism for alphaTS.     

Single-Molecule Studies of the Im7 Folding Landscape

Under appropriate conditions, the four-helical Im7 (immunity protein 7) folds from an ensemble of unfolded conformers to a highly compact native state via an on-pathway intermediate. Here, we investigate the unfolded, intermediate, and native states populated during folding using diffusion single-pair fluorescence resonance energy transfer by measuring the efficiency of energy transfer (or proximity or P ratio) between pairs of fluorophores introduced into the side chains of cysteine residues placed in the center of helices 1 and 4, 1 and 3, or 2 and 4. We show that while the native states of each variant give rise to a single narrow distribution with high P values, the distributions of the intermediates trapped at equilibrium (denoted I^eqm) are fitted by two Gaussian distributions. Modulation of the folding conditions from those that stabilize the intermediate to those that destabilize the intermediate enabled the distribution of lower P value to be assigned to the population of the unfolded ensemble in equilibrium with the intermediate state. The reduced stability of the I^eqm variants allowed analysis of the effect of denaturant concentration on the compaction and breadth of the unfolded state ensemble to be quantified from 0 to 6 M urea. Significant compaction is observed as the concentration of urea is decreased in both the presence and absence of sodium sulfate, as previously reported for a variety of proteins. In the presence of Na₂SO₄ in 0 M urea, the P value of the unfolded state ensemble approaches that of the native state. Concurrent with compaction, the ensemble displays increased peak width of P values, possibly reflecting a reduction in the rate of conformational exchange among iso-energetic unfolded, but compact conformations. The results provide new insights into the initial stages of folding of Im7 and suggest that the unfolded state is highly conformationally constrained at the outset of folding.     

The solid-state catalytic isotope exchange of hydrogen in dalargin

A [³H]Dalargin preparation with a molar radioactivity of 52 Ci/mmol was obtained by the high temperature solid-state catalytic isotope exchange (HSCIE) of tritium for hydrogen at 150°C. This tritium-labeled peptide was shown to completely retain its biological activity in the test of binding to opioid receptors from rat brain. The dissociation constant of the Dalargin-opioid receptor complex was found to be 4.3 nM. The dependences of the chemical yield and the molar radioactivity on the reaction time and temperature of HSCIE were determined. The activation energy of the HSCIE reaction for the peptide was calculated to be 32 kcal/mol. The amino acid analysis showed that tritium is distributed between all the amino acid residues of [³H]Dalargin at the HSCIE reaction, with the temperature growth significantly increasing the total tritium incorporation and, especially, enhancing the radioactivity incorporation into aromatic residues.     

Thermodynamic and kinetic exploration of the energy landscape of Borrelia burgdorferi OspA by native-state hydrogen exchange

We report a native-state hydrogen-exchange (HX) method to simultaneously obtain both thermodynamic and kinetic information on the formation of multiple excited states in a folding energy landscape. Our method exploits the inherent dispersion and pH dependence of the intrinsic HX rates to cover both the EX2 (thermodynamic) and EX1 (kinetic) regimes. At each concentration of denaturant, HX measurements are performed over a range of pH values. Using this strategy, we dissected Borrelia burgdorferi OspA, a predominantly beta-sheet protein containing a unique single-layer beta-sheet, into five cooperative units and postulated excited states predominantly responsible for HX. More importantly, we determined the interconversion rates between these excited states and the native state. The use of both thermodynamic and kinetic information from native-state HX enabled us to construct a folding landscape of this 28kDa protein, including local minima and maxima, and to discriminate on-pathway and off-pathway intermediates. This method, which we term EX2/EX1 HX, should be a powerful tool for characterizing the complex folding mechanisms exhibited by the majority of proteins.     

The "two-state folder" MerP forms partially unfolded structures that show temperature dependent hydrogen exchange

We have analysed the folding energy landscape of the 72 amino acid protein MerP by monitoring native state hydrogen exchange as a function of temperature in the range of 7-55 degrees C. The temperature dependence of the hydrogen exchange has allowed us to determine DeltaG, DeltaH and DeltaC(p) values for the conformational processes that permit hydrogen exchange. When studied with the traditional probes, fluorescence and CD, MerP appears to behave as a typical two-state protein, but the results from the hydrogen exchange analysis reveal a much more complex energy landscape. Analysis at the individual amino acid level show that exchange is allowed from an ensemble of partially unfolded structures (i.e. intermediates) in which the stabilities at the amino acid level form a broad distribution throughout the protein. The formation of partially unfolded structures might contribute to the unusually slow folding of MerP.     

Structural analysis of the rate-limiting transition states in the folding of Im7 and Im9: similarities and differences in the folding of homologous proteins

The bacterial immunity proteins Im7 and Im9 fold with mechanisms of different kinetic complexity. Whilst Im9 folds in a two-state transition at pH 7.0 and 10 degrees C, Im7 populates an on-pathway intermediate under these conditions. In order to assess the role of sequence versus topology in the folding of these proteins, and to analyse the effect of populating an intermediate on the landscape for folding, we have determined the conformational properties of the rate-limiting transition state for Im9 folding/unfolding using Phi(F)-value analysis and have compared the results with similar data obtained previously for Im7. The data show that the rate-limiting transition states for Im9 and Im7 folding/unfolding are similar: both are compact (beta(T)=0.94 and 0.89, respectively) and contain three of the four native helices docked around a specific hydrophobic core. Significant differences are observed, however, in the magnitude of the Phi(F)-values obtained for the two proteins. Of the 20 residues studied in both proteins, ten have Phi(F)-values in Im7 that exceed those in Im9 by more than 0.2, and of these five differ by more than 0.4. The data suggest that the population of an intermediate in Im7 results in folding via a transition state ensemble that is conformationally restricted relative to that of Im9. The data are consistent with the view that topology is an important determinant of folding. Importantly, however, they also demonstrate that while the folding transition state may be conserved in homologous proteins that fold with two and three-state kinetics, the population of an intermediate can have a significant effect on the breadth of the transition state ensemble.     

Differences in hydrogen exchange behavior between the oxidized and reduced forms of Escherichia coli thioredoxin.

Amide proton exchange of thioredoxin is used to monitor the structural effects of reduction of its single disulfide. An effective 3-5-proton difference between the oxidized and reduced protein form is observed early in proton out-exchange of the whole protein, which is independent of temperature in the range of 5-45 degrees C, indicating that redox-sensitive changes are probably not due to low-energy structural fluctuations. Medium resolution hydrogen exchange experiments have localized the redox-sensitive amide protons to two parts of the sequence that are distant from each other in the three-dimensional structure: the active-site turn and the first beta-strand. The sum of the proton differences observed in the peptides from these regions is equal to that of the whole protein, indicating that all redox-sensitive hydrogen exchange effects are observed in the peptide experiments. A model combining structural changes within the protein matrix with changes in the surface hydration properties is proposed as a mechanism for the communication between distant sites within the protein. Sound velocity and density measurements of reduced and oxidized thioredoxin are presented in the accompanying paper (Kaminsky, S.M. & Richards, F.M., 1992, Protein Sci. 1, 22-30).     

The apomyoglobin folding pathway revisited: structural heterogeneity in the kinetic burst phase intermediate

Extensive analysis of accurate quench-flow hydrogen exchange results indicates that the burst phase kinetic intermediate in the folding of apomyoglobin (apoMb) from urea is structurally heterogeneous. The structural variability is associated with the partial folding of the E helix during the burst phase (<6.4ms) of the folding process. Analysis of the effects of exchange-out of amide proton labels during the labeling pulse ( approximately pH 10) of the quench-flow process indicates that three of the amide protons in the E helix are in fact largely protected in the burst phase of folding, while the remainder of the E helix has a substantial complement of amide protons that show biphasic kinetics, i.e. are protected partly during the burst phase and partly during the slow phase of folding. The locations of these amide protons can be used to map the sites of structural heterogeneity in the kinetic molten globule. These sites include, besides the E helix, the ends of the A and B helices and part of the C helix. Our results give significant support to the hypothesis that the kinetic molten globule intermediate of apoMb is native-like.     

Comparison of fungal mitochondrial introns reveals extensive homologies in RNA secondary structure

The complete sequences of nine Saccharomyces cerevisiae mitochondrial introns, six of which carry long open reading frames, have already been published. We have recently determined the sequence of an intron in the large ribosomal mitochondrial RNA of Kluyveromyces thermotolerans (Jacquier et al., in preparation), which we found to be closely related to its S. cerevisiae counterpart. This latter result prompted us to undertake a systematic search for possible homologous elements in the other, available sequences with the help of an original computer program. A previously unsuspected wealth of evolutionarily conserved sequences and secondary structures was thus uncovered. Seven at least of the available sequences may be folded up into elaborate secondary structure models, the cores of which are nearly identical. These models result in bringing together the exon-intron junctions into relatively close spatial proximity and looping out either all or most of the sequences in open reading frame, when present. These results and their possible implications with respect to the mechanism of splicing are discussed in the light of available genetic and biochemical data.     

Integration of hydrogen/deuterium exchange and cyanylation-based methodology for conformational studies of cystinyl proteins

This report documents the feasibility and advantages of integrating hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) methodology with cyanylation (CN)-based methodology to determine the conformation of cystinyl proteins and intermediates during refolding. The CN-based methodology can be used to trap, identify, and preserve the disulfide structure of a given cystinyl protein folding intermediate, while the HDX methodology can be used to assess other conformational features of the intermediate. Specifically, in this study, CN-based methodology was used to trap a 1-disulfide bond and a 2-disulfide intermediate of long Arg(3) insulin-like growth factor-I (LR(3)IGF-I), which was then exposed to HDX using D(2)O at pD 6.8 and subsequently digested with pepsin before analysis by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry. The HDX results show an increasing degree of secondary and tertiary structure as a function of disulfide bond formation. In addition, the HDX results for two overlapping peptic fragments suggest that a segment of the polypeptide exists in two conformations, which can be distinguished by HDX and pepsin. These results from HDX mass spectrometry are in reasonably good agreement with those from nuclear magnetic resonance studies of native LR(3)IGF-I and IGF-I, in which approximately 5000 times more material was used than in our study. Indications are that the integrated use of HDX and CN-based methodologies will be effective in studying the refolding of cystinyl proteins at the subnanomole level.     

Future directions in folding: The multi-state nature of protein structure

All possible protein folding intermediates exist in equilibrium with the native protein at native as well as non-native conditions, with occupation determined by their free energy level. The study of these forms can illuminate the fundamental principles of protein structure and folding. Hydrogen exchange methods can be used to detect and characterize these partially unfolded forms at native conditions and as a function of mild denaturant and temperature. This information illuminates the requirements that govern the ability of kinetic and equilibrium methods to study folding intermediates.     

GuHCl and NaCl-dependent hydrogen exchange in MerP reveals a well-defined core with an unusual exchange pattern

We have analysed hydrogen exchange at amide groups to characterise the energy landscape of the 72 amino acid residue protein MerP. From the guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) dependence of exchange in the pre-transitional region we have determined free energy values of exchange (DeltaG(HX)) and corresponding m-values for individual amide protons. Detailed analysis of the exchange patterns indicates that for one set of amide protons there is a weak dependence on denaturant, indicating that the exchange is dominated by local fluctuations. For another set of amide protons a linear, but much stronger, denaturant dependence is observed. Notably, the plots of free energy of exchange versus [GuHCl] for 16 amide protons show pronounced upward curvature, and a close inspection of the structure shows that these residues form a well-defined core in the protein. The hydrogen exchange that was measured at various concentrations of NaCl shows an apparent selective stabilisation of this core. Detailed analysis of this exchange pattern indicates that it may originate from selective destabilisation of the unfolded state by guanidinium ions and/or selective stabilisation of the core in the native state by chloride ions.