Transposition of two amino acids changes a promiscuous RNA binding protein into a sequence-specific RNA binding protein

In yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae), the branchpoint binding protein (BBP) recognizes the conserved yeast branchpoint sequence (UACUAAC) with a high level of specificity and affinity, while the human branchpoint binding protein (SF1) binds the less-conserved consensus branchpoint sequence (CURAY) in human introns with a lower level of specificity and affinity. To determine which amino acids in BBP provide the additional specificity and affinity absent in SF1, a panel of chimeric SF1 proteins was tested in RNA binding assays with wild-type and mutant RNA substrates. This approach revealed that the QUA2 domain of BBP is responsible for the enhanced RNA binding affinity and specificity displayed by BBP compared with SF1. Within the QUA2 domain, a transposition of adjacent arginine and lysine residues is primarily responsible for the switch in RNA binding between BBP and SF1. Alignment of multiple branchpoint binding proteins and the related STAR/GSG proteins suggests that the identity of these two amino acids and the RNA target sequences of all of these proteins are correlated.     

Structure-function analysis and genetic interactions of the yeast branchpoint binding protein Msl5

Saccharomyces cerevisiae Msl5 (branchpoint binding protein) orchestrates spliceosome assembly by binding the branchpoint sequence 5'-UACUAAC and establishing cross intron-bridging interactions with other components of the splicing machinery. Reciprocal tandem affinity purifications verify that Msl5 exists in vivo as a heterodimer with Mud2 and that the Msl5-Mud2 complex is associated with the U1 snRNP. By gauging the ability of mutants of Msl5 to complement msl5Δ, we find that the Mud2-binding (amino acids 35-54) and putative Prp40-binding (PPxY(100)) elements of the Msl5 N-terminal domain are inessential, as are the C-terminal proline-rich domain (amino acids 382-476) and two zinc-binding CxxCxxxxHxxxxC motifs (amino acids 273-286 and 299-312). A subset of conserved branchpoint RNA-binding amino acids in the central KH-QUA2 domain (amino acids 146-269) are essential pairwise (Ile198-Arg190; Leu256-Leu259) or in trios (Leu169-Arg172-Leu176), whereas other pairs of RNA-binding residues are dispensable. We used our collection of viable Msl5 mutants to interrogate synthetic genetic interactions, in cis between the inessential structural elements of the Msl5 polypeptide and in trans between Msl5 and yeast splicing factors (Mud2, Nam8 and Tgs1) that are optional for vegetative growth. The results suggest a network of important but functionally buffered protein-protein and protein-RNA interactions between the Mud2-Msl5 complex at the branchpoint and the U1 snRNP at the 5' splice site.     

An extended RNA binding site for the yeast branch point-binding protein and the role of its zinc knuckle domains in RNA binding

The highly conserved branch point sequence (BPS) of UACUAAC in Saccharomyces cerevisiae is initially recognized by the branch point-binding protein (BBP). Using systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment we have determined that yeast BBP binds the branch point sequence UACUAAC with highest affinity and prefers an additional adenosine downstream of the BPS. Furthermore, we also found that a stem-loop upstream of the BPS enhances binding both to an artificially designed RNA (30-fold effect) and to an RNA from a yeast intron (3-fold effect). The zinc knuckles of BBP are partially responsible for the enhanced binding to the stem-loop but do not appear to have a significant role in the binding of BBP to single-strand RNA substrates. C-terminal deletions of BBP reveal that the linker regions between the two zinc knuckles and between the N-terminal RNA binding domains (KH and QUA2 domains) and the first zinc knuckle are important for binding to RNA. The lack of involvement of the second highly conserved zinc knuckle in RNA binding suggests that this zinc knuckle plays a different role in RNA processing than enhancing the binding of BBP to the BPS.     

A BBP-Mud2p heterodimer mediates branchpoint recognition and influences splicing substrate abundance in budding yeast

The 3' end of mammalian introns is marked by the branchpoint binding protein, SF1, and the U2AF65-U2AF35 heterodimer bound at an adjacent sequence. Baker's yeast has equivalent proteins, branchpoint binding protein (BBP) (SF1) and Mud2p (U2AF65), but lacks an obvious U2AF35 homolog, leaving open the question of whether another protein substitutes during spliceosome assembly. Gel filtration, affinity selection and mass spectrometry were used to show that rather than a U2AF65/U2AF35-like heterodimer, Mud2p forms a complex with BBP without a third (U2AF35-like) factor. Using mutants of MUD2 and BBP, we show that the BBP-Mud2p complex bridges partner-specific Prp39p, Mer1p, Clf1p and Smy2p two-hybrid interactions. In addition to inhibiting Mud2p association, the bbpDelta56 mutation impairs splicing, enhances pre-mRNA release from the nucleus, and similar to a mud2::KAN knockout, suppresses a lethal sub2::KAN mutation. Unexpectedly, rather than exacerbating bbpDelta56, the mud2::KAN mutation partially suppresses a pre-mRNA accumulation defect observed with bbpDelta56. We propose that a BBP-Mud2p heterodimer binds as a unit to the branchpoint in vivo and serves as a target for the Sub2p-DExD/H-box ATPase and for other splicing factors during spliceosome assembly. In addition, our results suggest the possibility that the Mud2p may enhance the turnover of pre-mRNA with impaired BBP-branchpoint association.     

A putative ATP binding protein influences the fidelity of branchpoint recognition in yeast splicing

We previously described a dominant suppressor of the splicing defect conferred by an A----C intron branchpoint mutation in S. cerevisiae. Suppression occurs by increasing the frequency with which the mutant branchpoint is utilized. We have now cloned the genomic region encoding the prp16-1 suppressor function and have demonstrated that PRP16 is essential for viability. A 1071 amino acid open reading frame contains sequence motifs characteristic of an NTP binding fold and further similarities to a superfamily of proteins that includes members with demonstrated RNA-dependent ATPase activity. A single nucleotide change necessary to confer the prp16-1 suppressor phenotype results in a Tyr----Asp substitution near the "A site" consensus for NTP binding proteins. We propose that PRP16 is an excellent candidate for mediating one of the many ATP-requiring steps of spliceosome assembly and that accuracy of branchpoint recognition may be coupled to ATP binding and/or hydrolysis.     

Crystal structures of Nova-1 and Nova-2 K-homology RNA-binding domains.

BACKGROUND: Nova-1 and Nova-2 are related neuronal proteins that were initially cloned using antisera obtained from patients with the autoimmune neurological disease paraneoplastic opsoclonus-myoclonus ataxia (POMA). Both of these disease gene products contain three RNA-binding motifs known as K-homology or KH domains, and their RNA ligands have been identified via binding-site selection experiments. The KH motif structure has been determined previously using NMR spectroscopy, but not using X-ray crystallography. Many proteins contain more than one KH domain, yet there is no published structural information regarding the behavior of such multimers. RESULTS: We have obtained the first X-ray crystallographic structures of KH-domain-containing proteins. Structures of the third KH domains (KH3) of Nova-1 and Nova-2 were determined by multiple isomorphous replacement and molecular replacement at 2.6 A and 2.0 A, respectively. These highly similar RNA-binding motifs form a compact protease-resistant domain resembling an open-faced sandwich, consisting of a three-stranded antiparallel beta sheet topped by three alpha helices. In both Nova crystals, the lattice is composed of symmetric tetramers of KH3 domains that are created by two dimer interfaces. CONCLUSIONS: The crystal structures of both Nova KH3 domains are similar to the previously determined NMR structures. The most significant differences among the KH domains involve changes in the positioning of one or more of the alpha helices with respect to the betasheet, particularly in the NMR structure of the KH1 domain of the Fragile X disease protein FMR-1. Loop regions in the KH domains are clearly visible in the crystal structure, unlike the NMR structures, revealing the conformation of the invariant Gly-X-X-Gly segment that is thought to participate in RNA-binding and of the variable region. The tetrameric arrangements of the Nova KH3 domains provide insights into how KH domains may interact with each other in proteins containing multiple KH motifs.     

A case of convergent evolution of nucleic acid binding modules

Divergent evolution can explain how many proteins containing structurally similar domains, which perform a variety of related functions, have evolved from a relatively small number of modules or protein domains. However, it cannot explain how protein domains with similar, but distinguishable, functions and similar, but distinguishable, structures have evolved. Examples of this are the RNA-binding proteins containing the RNA-binding domain (RBD), and a newly established protein group, the cold-shock domain (CSD) protein family. Both protein domains contain conserved RNP motifs on similar single-stranded nucleic acid-binding surfaces. Apart from the RNP motifs, which have a similar function, the two families show little similarity in topology or amino acid sequence. This can be considered an interesting example of convergent evolution at the molecular level. Previously, a β-sheet surface was found to interact with RNA in non-homologous proteins from yeast, phage and man, revealing that this mode of RNA binding may be a widely recurring theme.     

Dissecting FMR1, the protein responsible for fragile X syndrome, in its structural and functional domains.

FMR1 is an RNA-binding protein that is either absent or mutated in patients affected by the fragile X syndrome, the most common inherited cause of mental retardation in humans. Sequence analysis of the FMR1 protein has suggested that RNA binding is related to the presence of two K-homologous (KH) modules and an RGG box. However, no attempt has been so far made to map the RNA-binding sites along the protein sequence and to identify possible differential RNA-sequence specificity. In the present article, we describe work done to dissect FMR1 into regions with structurally and functionally distinct properties. A semirational approach was followed to identify four regions: an N-terminal stretch of 200 amino acids, the two KH regions, and a C-terminal stretch. Each region was produced as a recombinant protein, purified, and probed for its state of folding by spectroscopical techniques. Circular dichroism and NMR spectra of the N-terminus show formation of secondary structure with a strong tendency to aggregate. Of the two homologous KH motifs, only the first one is folded whereas the second remains unfolded even when it is extended both N- and C-terminally. The C-terminus is, as expected from its amino acid composition, nonglobular. Binding assays were then performed using the 4-nt homopolymers. Our results show that only the first KH domain but not the second binds to RNA, and provide the first direct evidence for RNA binding of both the N-terminal and the C-terminal regions. RNA binding for the N-terminus could not be predicted from sequence analysis because no known RNA-binding motif is identifiable in this region. Different sequence specificity was observed for the fragments: both the N-terminus of the protein and KH1 bind preferentially to poly-(rG). The C-terminal region, which contains the RGG box, is nonspecific, as it recognizes the bases with comparable affinity. We therefore conclude that FMR1 is a protein with multiple sites of interaction with RNA: sequence specificity is most likely achieved by the whole block that comprises the first approximately 400 residues, whereas the C-terminus provides a nonspecific binding surface.     

The structure of the C-terminal KH domains of KSRP reveals a noncanonical motif important for mRNA degradation

The AU-rich element (ARE) RNA-binding protein KSRP (K-homology splicing regulator protein) contains four KH domains and promotes the degradation of specific mRNAs that encode proteins with functions in cellular proliferation and inflammatory response. The fourth KH domain (KH4) is essential for mRNA recognition and decay but requires the third KH domain (KH3) for its function. We show that KH3 and KH4 behave as independent binding modules and can interact with different regions of the AU-rich RNA targets of KSRP. This provides KSRP with the structural flexibility needed to recognize a set of different targets in the context of their 3'UTR structural settings. Surprisingly, we find that KH4 binds to its target AREs with lower affinity than KH3 and that KSRP's mRNA binding, and mRNA degradation activities are closely associated with a conserved structural element of KH4.     

Role of dimerization in KH/RNA complexes: the example of Nova KH3

The K homology module, one of the most common RNA-binding motifs, is present in multiple copies in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic regulatory proteins. Increasing evidence suggests that self-aggregation of KH modules has a functional role. We have used a combination of techniques to characterize the behavior in solution of the third KH domain of Nova-1, a paradigmatic KH protein. The possibility of working on the isolated module allowed us to observe specifically the homodimerization and RNA-binding properties of KH domains. We provide conclusive evidence that self-association of Nova-1 KH3 occurs in solution even in the absence of RNA. Homodimerization involves a specific protein/protein interface. We also studied the dynamical behavior of Nova-1 KH3 in isolation and in complex with RNA. These data provide a model for the mechanism of KH/RNA recognition and suggest functional implications of dimerization in KH complexes. We discuss our findings in the context of the whole KH family and suggest a generalized mode of interaction.     

Identification of proteins that interact with exon sequences, splice sites, and the branchpoint sequence during each stage of spliceosome assembly.

We have carried out a systematic analysis of the proteins that interact with specific intron and exon sequences during each stage of mammalian spliceosome assembly. This was achieved by site-specifically labeling individual nucleotides within the 5' and 3' splice sites, the branchpoint sequence (BPS), or the exons with 32P and identifying UV-cross-linked proteins in the E, A, B, or C spliceosomal complex. Significantly, two members of the SR family of splicing factors, which are known to promote E-complex assembly, cross-link within exon sequences to a region approximately 25 nucleotides upstream from the 5' splice site. At the 5' splice site, cross-linking of the U5 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein particle protein, U5(200), was detected in both the B and C complexes. As observed in yeast cells, U5(200), also cross-links to intron/exon sequences at the 3' splice site in the C complex and may play a role in aligning the 5' and 3' exons for ligation. With label at the branch site, we detected three distinct proteins, designated BPS72,BpS70, and BPS56, which replace one another in the E, A, and C complexes. Another dynamic exchange was detected with pre-mRNA labeled at the AG dinucleotide of the 3' splice site. In this case, a protein, AG100,cross-links in the A complex and is replaced by another protein, AG75, in the C complex. The observation that these proteins are specifically associated with critical pre-mRNA sequence elements in functional complexes at different stages of spliceosome assembly implicates roles for these factors in key recognition events during the splicing pathway.     

KH domains with impaired nucleic acid binding as a tool for functional analysis

In eukaryotes, RNA-binding proteins that contain multiple K homology (KH) domains play a key role in coordinating the different steps of RNA synthesis, metabolism and localization. Understanding how the different KH modules participate in the recognition of the RNA targets is necessary to dissect the way these proteins operate. We have designed a KH mutant with impaired RNA-binding capability for general use in exploring the role of individual KH domains in the combinatorial functional recognition of RNA targets. A double mutation in the hallmark GxxG loop (GxxG-to-GDDG) impairs nucleic acid binding without compromising the stability of the domain. We analysed the impact of the GDDG mutations in individual KH domains on the functional properties of KSRP as a prototype of multiple KH domain-containing proteins. We show how the GDDG mutant can be used to directly link biophysical information on the sequence specificity of the different KH domains of KSRP and their role in mRNA recognition and decay. This work defines a general molecular biology tool for the investigation of the function of individual KH domains in nucleic acid binding proteins.     

Arginine-serine-rich domains bound at splicing enhancers contact the branchpoint to promote prespliceosome assembly

Exonic splicing enhancers (ESEs) are required for splicing of certain pre-mRNAs and function by providing binding sites for serine-arginine (SR) proteins, which contain an arginine-serine-rich (RS) domain. How an RS domain bound at the ESE promotes splicing is poorly understood. We have developed an RNA-protein crosslinking procedure to identify the target of the ESE-bound RS domain. Using this approach, we show that the ESE-bound RS domain specifically contacts the pre-mRNA branchpoint. The interaction between the ESE-bound RS domain and the branchpoint occurs in the prespliceosome and is dependent upon the same splicing signals, biochemical factors, and reaction conditions required to support prespliceosome assembly. Analysis of RS domain mutants demonstrates that the ability to interact with the branchpoint, to promote prespliceosome assembly, and to support splicing are related activities. We conclude that the ESE-bound RS domain functions by contacting the branchpoint to promote prespliceosome assembly.     

Identification of an export control sequence and a requirement for the KH domains in ICP27 from herpes simplex virus type 1

The herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) immediate-early protein ICP27 is an RNA-binding protein that performs multiple functions required for the expression of HSV-1 genes during a productive infection. One essential function involves shuttling between the nucleus and the cytoplasm. Some of the domains identified in ICP27 include a leucine-rich nuclear export sequence (NES), a nuclear localization signal, three KH-like RNA-binding domains, and an RGG-box type RNA-binding motif. To study the contribution of two of the essential domains in ICP27 to HSV gene expression, we generated recombinant herpesviruses carrying deleterious mutations in the NES and KH domains of ICP27. To accomplish this, we fused the green fluorescent protein (GFP) to ICP27 and utilized fluorescence as a marker to isolate recombinant herpesviruses. Fusion of GFP to wild-type ICP27 did not disturb its localization or function or significantly reduce virus yield. Analysis of HSV gene expression in cells infected with a recombinant virus carrying a point mutation in the first KH-like RNA-binding domain revealed that nuclear export of ICP27 was not blocked, and the expression of only a subset of ICP27-dependent late genes was affected. These findings suggest that individual KH-like RNA-binding motifs in ICP27 may be involved in binding distinct RNAs. Analysis of recombinant viruses carrying a lethal mutation in the NES of ICP27 was not accomplished because this mutation results in a strong dominant-negative phenotype. Finally, we demonstrate that shuttling by ICP27 is regulated by an export control sequence adjacent to its NES that functions like the inhibitory sequence element found adjacent to the NES of NS1 from influenza virus.     

The sequence selectivity of KSRP explains its flexibility in the recognition of the RNA targets

K-homology (KH) splicing regulator protein (KSRP) is a multi-domain RNA-binding protein that regulates different steps of mRNA metabolism, from mRNA splicing to mRNA decay, interacting with a broad range of RNA sequences. To understand how KSRP recognizes its different RNA targets it is necessary to define the general rules of KSRP–RNA interaction. We describe here a complete scaffold-independent analysis of the RNA-binding potential of the four KH domains of KSRP. The analysis shows that KH3 binds to the RNA with a significantly higher affinity than the other domains and recognizes specifically a G-rich target. It also demonstrates that the other KH domains of KSRP display different sequence preferences explaining the broad range of targets recognized by the protein. Further, KSRP shows a strong negative selectivity for sequences containing several adjacent Cytosines limiting the target choice of KSRP within single-stranded RNA regions. The in-depth analysis of the RNA-binding potential of the KH domains of KSRP provides us with an understanding of the role of low sequence specificity domains in RNA recognition by multi-domain RNA-binding proteins.     

The NECAP PHear domain increases clathrin accessory protein binding potential

AP-2 is a key regulator of the endocytic protein machinery driving clathrin-coated vesicle (CCV) formation. One critical function, mediated primarily by the AP-2 alpha-ear, is the recruitment of accessory proteins. NECAPs are alpha-ear-binding proteins that enrich on CCVs. Here, we have solved the structure of the conserved N-terminal region of NECAP 1, revealing a unique module in the pleckstrin homology (PH) domain superfamily, which we named the PHear domain. The PHear domain binds accessory proteins bearing FxDxF motifs, which were previously thought to bind exclusively to the AP-2 alpha-ear. Structural analysis of the PHear domain reveals the molecular surface for FxDxF motif binding, which was confirmed by site-directed mutagenesis. The reciprocal analysis of the FxDxF motif in amphiphysin I identified distinct binding requirements for binding to the alpha-ear and PHear domain. We show that NECAP knockdown compromises transferrin uptake and establish a functional role for NECAPs in clathrin-mediated endocytosis. Our data uncover a striking convergence of two evolutionarily and structurally distinct modules to recognize a common peptide motif and promote efficient endocytosis.     

Determination and augmentation of RNA sequence specificity of the Nova K-homology domains

The Nova onconeural antigens are implicated in the pathogenesis of paraneoplastic opsoclonus-myoclonus-ataxia (POMA). The Nova antigens are neuron-specific RNA-binding proteins harboring three repeats of the K-homology (KH) motif; they have been implicated in the regulation of alternative splicing of a host of genes involved in inhibitory synaptic transmission. Although the third Nova KH domain (KH3) has been extensively characterized using biochemical and crystallographic techniques, the roles of the KH1 and KH2 domains remain unclear. Furthermore, the specificity determinants that distinguish the Nova KH domains from those of the closely related hnRNP E and hnRNP K proteins are undefined. We demonstrate through the use of RNA selection and biochemical analysis that the sequence specificity of the Nova KH1/2 domains is similar to that of Nova KH3. We also show that the mutagenesis of a Nova KH domain to render it similar to the KH domains of the heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein E (hnRNP E) and hnRNP K allow it to recognize longer RNA sequences. These data yield important insights into KH domain function and suggest a strategy by which to engineer KH domains with novel sequence preferences.