Stereoselective in vitro formation of c-type cytochrome variants from Hydrogenobacter thermophilus containing only a single thioether bond

In vitro formation of Hydrogenobacter thermophilus cytochrome c552 has previously been demonstrated (Daltrop, O., Allen, J. W. A., Willis, A. C., and Ferguson, S. J. (2002) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 99, 7872-7876). Now we report that the single cysteine variants of H. thermophilus c552, which bind heme via a single thioether bond, also form in vitro. Furthermore, reaction of the apocytochromes containing either AXXCH or CXXAH in the binding motif with 2-vinyldeuteroheme and 4-vinyldeuteroheme resulted predominantly in covalent attachment between Cys-11 and the 2-vinyl moiety and Cys-14 and the 4-vinyl functionality. This observation shows that the covalent attachment of heme to apocytochrome is stereoselective, indicating that the initial non-covalent complexes between apoprotein and heme have to be in the correct stereochemical orientation for preferential promotion of thioether bond formation. Additionally, the heme derivatives 2-vinyldeuteroheme and 4-vinyldeuteroheme were reacted with wild-type H. thermophilus c552 to yield another modification of cytochromes containing only one thioether bond. These results show that the formation of the two thioether bonds in typical c-type cytochromes can occur independently from one another. Aspects of rotational isomerism of heme in heme-proteins are discussed.     

Site-directedly mutated human cytochrome c which retains heme c via only one thioether bond

Although Cys-14 (human numbering) of cytochrome c was conserved during its molecular evolution and it is supposed to be essential for most cytochromes c to retain heme c via two thioether bonds, a site-directedly mutated human cytochrome c which has an alanine residue at this position and only one thioether bond through Cys-17 turns out to be functional. This shows that Cys-14 is not essential. The absorption spectrum of the atypical cytochrome c is red shifted, and similar to those of Euglena and Crithidia cytochromes c, which also have only one thioether bond [Pettigrew, G.W., Leaver, J.L., Meyer, T.E., & Ryle, A.P. (1975) Biochem. J. 147, 291-302].     

Biochemical requirements for the maturation of mitochondrial c-type cytochromes

Cytochromes c are metalloproteins that function in electron transfer reactions and contain a heme moiety covalently attached via thioether linkages between the co-factor and a CXXCH motif in the protein. Covalent attachment of the heme group occurs on the positive side of all energy-transducing membranes (bacterial periplasm, mitochondrial intermembrane space and thylakoid lumen) and requires minimally: 1) synthesis and translocation of the apocytochromes c and heme across at least one biological membrane, 2) reduction of apocytochromes c and heme and maintenance under a reduced form prior to 3) catalysis of the heme attachment reaction. Surprisingly, the conversion of apoforms of cytochromes c to their respective holoforms occurs through at least three different pathways (systems I, II and III). In this review, we detail the assembly process of soluble cytochrome c and membrane-bound cytochrome c1, the only two mitochondrial c-type cytochromes that function in respiration. Mitochondrial c-type cytochromes are matured in the intermembrane space via the system I or system III pathway, an intriguing finding considering that the biochemical requirements for cytochrome c maturation are believed to be common regardless of the energy-transducing membrane under study.     

Loss of either of the two heme-binding cysteines from a class I c-type cytochrome has a surprisingly small effect on physicochemical properties

Almost without exception, c-type cytochromes have heme covalently attached via two thioether linkages to the cysteine residues of a CXXCH motif. The reasons for the covalent attachment are not understood. Reported here is cytoplasmic expression in Escherichia coli of AXXCH and CXXAH variants of cytochrome c(552) from Hydrogenobacter thermophilus; remarkably, the single thioether bond proteins have, apart from an altered visible absorption spectrum, almost identical properties, including thermal stability and reduction potential, to the wild type CXXCH protein. In combination with previous work showing that an AXXAH variant of cytochrome c(552) is much less stable than the CXXCH form, it can be concluded that covalent attachment of heme via either of thioether bonds is sufficient to confer considerable stability and that these bonds contribute little to the setting of the reduction potential. The absence of AXXCH or CXXAH heme-binding motifs from bacterial cytochromes c may relate to the coexistence of the assembly pathway with that for formation of disulfide bonds in the bacterial periplasm.     

Cytochrome c maturation system on the negative side of bioenergetic membranes: CCB or System IV

Cytochromes of the c-type contain hemes covalently attached via one or, more generally, two thioether bonds between the vinyls of heme b and the thiols of cysteine residues of apocytochromes. This post-translational modification relies on membrane-associated specific biogenesis proteins, referred to as cytochrome c maturation systems. At least three different versions (i.e. Systems I-III) are found on the positive side of bioenergetic membranes in different organisms and compartments. The present minireview is concerned with systems on the negative side of the membranes. It describes System IV, also referred to as cofactor assembly on complex C subunit B, for heme binding on cytochrome b(6) through one thioether bond; this covalent heme is usually called c(i) . This system is found in all organisms with oxygenic photosynthesis but not in Firmicutes, although they also have a cytochrome b protein with an additional heme c(i) covalently attached via a single thioether bond.     

Evidence for formation of two thioether bonds to link heme to apocytochrome c by partially purified cytochrome c synthetase

Cytochrome c synthetase has been solubilized from yeast mitochondria using Triton X-100 and fractionated with ammonium sulfate. Use of this partially purified enzyme has permitted us to isolate a quantity of iso-1-cytochrome c formed from 125I-labeled apocytochrome c and hemin in the presence of a NADPH-generating system. Visible absorption spectra (pH 8.0 or 5.0) including alpha, beta, and Soret bands and their molar absorption coefficients of this enzymatically synthesized cytochrome c in the oxidized and reduced states are the same, within experimental error, as those of native cytochrome c. Pyridine ferrohemochrome (pH 13) of the synthesized species also exhibits the same alpha and beta bands as those of iso-l-cytochrome c and similar to those reported for heme peptides of cytochrome c. If only one or no thioether bond were formed between the two vinyl side groups of heme and the cysteine residues of apocytochrome c, all these alpha and beta bands would have shifted to red (Pettigrew, G. W., Leaver, J. L., Meyer, T. E., and Ryle, T. E. (1975) Biochem J. 147, 291-302). Thus, two thioether bonds appear to be formed to link heme to apocytochrome c by cytochrome c synthetase, completing information of the three-dimensional structure of cytochrome c.     

Controlling the functionality of cytochrome c(1) redox potentials in the Rhodobacter capsulatus bc(1) complex through disulfide anchoring of a loop and a beta-branched amino acid near the heme-ligating methionine.

The cytochrome c(1) subunit of the ubihydroquinone:cytochrome c oxidoreductase (bc(1) complex) contains a single heme group covalently attached to the polypeptide via thioether bonds of two conserved cysteine residues. In the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter (Rba.) capsulatus, cytochrome c(1) contains two additional cysteines, C144 and C167. Site-directed mutagenesis reveals a disulfide bond (rare in monoheme c-type cytochromes) anchoring C144 to C167, which is in the middle of an 18 amino acid loop that is present in some bacterial cytochromes c(1) but absent in higher organisms. Both single and double Cys to Ala substitutions drastically lower the +320 mV redox potential of the native form to below 0 mV, yielding nonfunctional cytochrome bc(1). In sharp contrast to the native protein, mutant cytochrome c(1) binds carbon monoxide (CO) in the reduced form, indicating an opening of the heme environment that is correlated with the drop in potential. In revertants, loss of the disulfide bond is remediated uniquely by insertion of a beta-branched amino acid two residues away from the heme-ligating methionine 183, identifying the pattern betaXM, naturally common in many other high-potential cytochromes c. Despite the unrepaired disulfide bond, the betaXM revertants are no longer vulnerable to CO binding and restore function by raising the redox potential to +227 mV, which is remarkably close to the value of the betaXM containing but loop-free mitochondrial cytochrome c(1). The disulfide anchored loop and betaXM motifs appear to be two independent but nonadditive strategies to control the integrity of the heme-binding pocket and raise cytochrome c midpoint potentials.     

A strategic protein in cytochrome c maturation: three-dimensional structure of CcmH and binding to apocytochrome c

CcmH (cytochromes c maturation protein H) is an essential component of the assembly line necessary for the maturation of c-type cytochromes in the periplasm of Gram-negative bacteria. The protein is a membrane-anchored thiol-oxidoreductase that has been hypothesized to be involved in the recognition and reduction of apocytochrome c, a prerequisite for covalent heme attachment. Here, we present the 1.7A crystal structure of the soluble periplasmic domain of CcmH from the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa (Pa-CcmH*). The protein contains a three-helix bundle, i.e. a fold that is different from that of all other thiol-oxidoreductases reported so far. The catalytic Cys residues of the conserved LRCXXC motif (Cys(25) and Cys(28)), located in a long loop connecting the first two helices, form a disulfide bond in the oxidized enzyme. We have determined the pK(a) values of these 2 Cys residues of Pa-CcmH* (both >8) and propose a possible mechanistic role for a conserved Ser(36) and a water molecule in the active site. The interaction between Pa-CcmH* and Pa-apocyt c(551) (where cyt c(551) represents cytochrome c(551)) was characterized in vitro following the binding kinetics by stopped-flow using a Trp-containing fluorescent variant of Pa-CcmH* and a dansylated peptide, mimicking the apocytochrome c(551) heme binding motif. The kinetic results show that the protein has a moderate affinity to its apocyt substrate, consistent with the role of Pa-CcmH as an intermediate component of the assembly line for c-type cytochrome biogenesis.     

The Escherichia coli cytochrome c maturation (Ccm) system does not detectably attach heme to single cysteine variants of an apocytochrome c

Cytochromes c are typically characterized by the covalent attachment of heme to polypeptide through two thioether bonds with the cysteine residues of a Cys-Xaa-Xaa-Cys-His peptide motif. In many Gram-negative bacteria, the heme is attached to the polypeptide by the periplasmically functioning cytochrome c maturation (Ccm) proteins. Exceptionally, Hydrogenobacter thermophilus cytochrome c(552), which has a normal CXXCH heme-binding motif, and variants with AXXCH, CXXAH, and AXXAH motifs, can be expressed as stable holocytochromes in the cytoplasm of Escherichia coli. By targeting these proteins to the periplasm using a signal peptide, with or without co-expression of the Ccm proteins, we have assessed the ability of the Ccm system to attach heme to proteins with no, one, or two cysteine residues in the heme-binding motif. Only the wild-type protein, with two cysteines, was effectively processed and thus accumulated in the periplasm as a holocytochrome. This is strong evidence for disulfide bond formation involving the two cysteine residues of apocytochrome c as an intermediate in Ccm-type Gram-negative bacterial cytochrome c biogenesis and/or that only a pair of cysteines can be recognized by the heme attachment apparatus.     

Design and synthesis of de novo cytochromes c

Natural c-type cytochromes are characterized by the consensus Cys-X-X-Cys-His heme-binding motif (where X is any amino acid) by which the heme is covalently attached to protein by the addition of the sulfhydryl groups of two cysteine residues to the vinyl groups of the heme. In this work, the consensus sequence was used for the heme-binding site of a designed four-helix bundle, and the apoproteins with either a histidine residue or a methionine residue positioned at the sixth coordination site were synthesized and reacted with iron protoporphyrin IX (protoheme) under mild reducing conditions in vitro. These polypeptides bound one heme per helix-loop-helix monomer via a single thioether bond and formed four-helix bundle dimers in the holo forms as designed. They exhibited visible absorption spectra characteristic of c-type cytochromes, in which the absorption bands shifted to lower wavelengths in comparison with the b-type heme binding intermediates of the same proteins. Unexpectedly, the designed cytochromes c with bis-His-coordinated heme iron exhibited oxidation-reduction potentials similar to those of their b-type intermediates, which have no thioether bond. Furthermore, the cytochrome c with His and Met residues as the axial ligands exhibited redox potentials increased by only 15-30 mV in comparison with the cytochrome with the bis-His coordination. These results indicate that highly positive redox potentials of natural cytochromes c are not only due to the heme covalent structure, including the Met ligation, but also due to noncovalent and hydrophobic environments surrounding the heme. The covalent attachment of heme to the polypeptide in natural cytochromes c may contribute to their higher redox potentials by reducing the thermodynamic stability of the oxidized forms relatively against that of the reduced forms without the loss of heme.     

Characterization of recombinant horse cytochrome c synthesized with the assistance of Escherichia coli cytochrome c maturation factors

Cytochromes c are characterized by the presence of a protoporphyrin IX group covalently attached to the polypeptide via one or two thioether bonds to Cys side chains. The heme attachment process, known as cytochrome c maturation, occurs posttranslationally in the periplasm (for bacterial cytochromes c) or in the mitochondrial intermembrane space (for eukaryotic cytochromes c) through a pathway dependent on the organism. It is demonstrated in this work that a mitochondrial cytochrome c expressed in Escherichia coli that undergoes maturation under control of the E. coli cytochrome c maturation factors achieves a native-like structure and stability. The recombinant protein is characterized spectroscopically (by circular dichroism (CD), absorption, and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy) and it is verified that the heme and its environment are indistinguishable from authentic horse cytochrome c. Mass spectrometry reveals that the recombinant protein is not acetylated at the N terminus, however, no significant effect on protein structure or stability is detected as a result.     

CcmI subunit of CcmFHI heme ligation complex functions as an apocytochrome c chaperone during c-type cytochrome maturation

Cytochrome c maturation (Ccm) is a sophisticated post-translational process. It occurs after translocation of apocytochromes c to the p side of energy transducing membranes and forms stereo-specific thioether bonds between the vinyl groups of heme b (protoporphyrin IX-Fe) and the thiol groups of cysteines at their conserved heme binding sites. In many organisms this process involves up to 10 (CcmABCDEFGHI and CcdA) membrane proteins. One of these proteins is CcmI, which has an N-terminal membrane-embedded domain with two transmembrane helices and a large C-terminal periplasmic domain with protein-protein interaction motifs. Together with CcmF and CcmH, CcmI forms a multisubunit heme ligation complex. How the CcmFHI complex recognizes its apocytochrome c substrates remained unknown. In this study, using Rhodobacter capsulatus apocytochrome c(2) as a Ccm substrate, we demonstrate for the first time that CcmI binds apocytochrome c(2) but not holocytochrome c(2). Mainly the C-terminal portions of both CcmI and apocytochrome c(2) mediate this binding. Other physical interactions via the conserved structural elements in apocytochrome c(2), like the heme ligating cysteines or heme iron axial ligands, are less crucial. Furthermore, we show that the N-terminal domain of CcmI can also weakly bind apocytochrome c(2), but this interaction requires a free thiol group at apocytochrome c(2) heme binding site. We conclude that the CcmI subunit of the CcmFHI complex functions as an apocytochrome c chaperone during the Ccm process used by proteobacteria, archaea, mitochondria of plants and red algae.     

Characterization of Rhodobacter sphaeroides cytochrome c(2) proteins with altered heme attachment sites

In c-type cytochromes, heme is attached to the polypeptide via thioether linkages between vinyl groups on the tetrapyrrole ring and cysteine thiols in a CX(2)CH motif. To study the role of the heme-binding site in c-type cytochrome assembly and function, we generated amino acid changes in this region of Rhodobacter sphaeroides cytochrome c(2) ((15)Cys-Gln-Thr-Cys-His(19)). Amino acid substitutions at Cys(15), Cys(18), or His(19) produced mutant proteins that did not support growth via photosynthesis where this electron carrier is required. Many of these changes appeared to slow signal peptide removal, suggesting that heme attachment is coupled to processing of the c-type cytochrome precursor protein. Inserting an alanine between the cysteine ligands (CycA-Ins17A) did not significantly alter the behavior of this protein in vivo and in vitro, suggesting that the existence of 2 residues between cysteine thiols is not essential for heme attachment to a Class I c-type cytochrome like cytochrome c(2).     

Oxidation-reduction properties of disulfide-containing proteins of the Rhodobacter capsulatus cytochrome c biogenesis system

Oxidation-reduction titrations for the active-site disulfide/dithiol couples of the helX- and ccl2-encoded proteins involved in cytochrome c biogenesis in the purple non-sulfur bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus have been carried out. The R. capsulatus HelX and Ccl2 proteins are predicted to function as part of a dithiol/disulfide cascade that reduces a disulfide on the apocytochromes c so that two cysteine thiols are available to form thioether linkages between the heme prosthetic group and the protein. Oxidation-reduction midpoint potential (E(m)) values, at pH 7.0, of -300 +/- 10 and -210 +/- 10 mV were measured for the HelX and Ccl2 (a soluble, truncated form of Ccl2) R. capsulatus proteins, respectively. Titrations of the disulfide/dithiol couple of a peptide designed to serve as a model for R. capsulatus apocytochrome c(2) have also been carried out, and an E(m) value of -170 +/- 10 mV was measured for the model peptide at pH 7.0. E(m) versus pH plots for HelX, Ccl2, and the apocytochrome c(2) model peptide were all linear over the pH range from 5.0 to 8.0, with the -59 mV/pH unit slope expected for a reaction in which two protons are taken up for each disulfide that is reduced. These results provide thermodynamic support for the proposal that HelX reduces Ccl2 and that reduced Ccl2, in turn, serves as the reductant for the production of the two thiols of the CysXxxYyyCysHis heme-binding motif of the apocytochromes.     

A homolog of prokaryotic thiol disulfide transporter CcdA is required for the assembly of the cytochrome b6f complex in Arabidopsis chloroplasts

The c-type cytochromes are defined by the occurrence of heme covalently linked to the polypeptide via thioether bonds between heme and the cysteine sulfhydryls in the CXXCH motif of apocytochrome. Maintenance of apocytochrome sulfhydryls in a reduced state is a prerequisite for covalent ligation of heme to the CXXCH motif. In bacteria, a thiol disulfide transporter and a thioredoxin are two components in a thio-reduction pathway involved in c-type cytochrome assembly. We have identified in photosynthetic eukaryotes nucleus-encoded homologs of a prokaryotic thiol disulfide transporter, CcdA, which all display an N-terminal extension with respect to their bacterial counterparts. The extension of Arabidopsis CCDA functions as a targeting sequence, suggesting a plastid site of action for CCDA in eukaryotes. Using PhoA and LacZ as topological reporters, we established that Arabidopsis CCDA is a polytopic protein with within-membrane strictly conserved cysteine residues. Insertional mutants in the Arabidopsis CCDA gene were identified, and loss-of-function alleles were shown to impair photosynthesis because of a defect in cytochrome b(6)f accumulation, which we attribute to a block in the maturation of holocytochrome f, whose heme binding domain resides in the thylakoid lumen. We postulate that plastid cytochrome c maturation requires CCDA, thioredoxin HCF164, and other molecules in a membrane-associated trans-thylakoid thiol-reducing pathway.     

Cytochrome c reductase purified from Crithidia fasciculata contains an atypical cytochrome c1.

Cytochrome c reductase purified from the trypanosomatid Crithidia fasciculata retained antimycin A sensitivity and catalyzed the reduction of horse heart ferricytochrome c in the presence of reduced coenzyme Q10. The complex contained heme b and heme c1 in a ratio of 2:1. Nine major protein bands ranging in size from 55.3 to approximately 12.8 kDa were resolved by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. A 31.6-kDa protein was identified as cytochrome c1 by the presence of a covalently attached heme. A red shift in the alpha-absorbance band of the cytochrome c1 absolute absorbance spectrum, difference absorbance spectrum, and pyridine ferrohemochrome absorbance spectrum suggested that the heme prosthetic group of C. fasciculata cytochrome c1 is bound to the apoprotein through only one thioether bond. A fragment of the cytochrome c1 gene was amplified from C. fasciculata, Trypanosoma brucei, Leishmania tarentolae, and Bodo caudatus. The deduced heme binding site sequence of each of these kinetoplastid species, Phe-Ala-Pro-Cys-His, contains a phenylalanine rather that a cysteine at the first position so that only one thioether bond can be formed between heme and apoprotein. This phenylalanine substitution and the presence of a conserved proline in the sequence may represent compensatory changes that are necessary for optimal interaction of the cytochromes c1 with the atypical cytochromes c of these species.     

Cytochrome c biogenesis System I

Cytochromes c are widespread respiratory proteins characterized by the covalent attachment of heme. The formation of c-type cytochromes requires, in all but a few exceptional cases, the formation of two thioether bonds between the two cysteine sulfurs in a -CXXCH- motif in the protein and the vinyl groups of heme. The vinyl groups of the heme are not particularly activated and therefore the addition reaction does not physiologically occur spontaneously in cells. There are several diverse post-translational modification systems for forming these bonds. Here, we describe the complex multiprotein cytochrome c maturation (Ccm) system (in Escherichia coli comprising the proteins CcmABCDEFGH), also called System I, that performs the heme attachment. System I is found in plant mitochondria, archaea and many Gram-negative bacteria; the systems found in other organisms and organelles are described elsewhere in this minireview series.     

The Heme Chaperone ApoCcmE Forms a Ternary Complex with CcmI and Apocytochrome c

Cytochrome c maturation (Ccm) is a post-translational process that occurs after translocation of apocytochromes c to the positive (p) side of energy-transducing membranes. Ccm is responsible for the formation of covalent bonds between the thiol groups of two cysteines residues at the heme-binding sites of the apocytochromes and the vinyl groups of heme b (protoporphyrin IX-Fe). Among the proteins (CcmABCDEFGHI and CcdA) required for this process, CcmABCD are involved in loading heme b to apoCcmE. The holoCcmE thus formed provides heme b to the apocytochromes. Catalysis of the thioether bonds between the apocytochromes c and heme b is mediated by the heme ligation core complex, which in Rhodobacter capsulatus contains at least the CcmF, CcmH, and CcmI components. In this work we show that the heme chaperone apoCcmE binds to the apocytochrome c and the apocytochrome c chaperone CcmI to yield stable binary and ternary complexes in the absence of heme in vitro. We found that during these protein-protein interactions, apoCcmE favors the presence of a disulfide bond at the apocytochrome c heme-binding site. We also establish using detergent-dispersed membranes that apoCcmE interacts directly with CcmI and CcmH of the heme ligation core complex CcmFHI. Implications of these findings are discussed with respect to heme transfer from CcmE to the apocytochromes c during heme ligation assisted by the core complex CcmFHI.     

Identification of a gene encoding a thioredoxin-like product necessary for cytochrome c biosynthesis and symbiotic nitrogen fixation in Rhizobium leguminosarum.

A Tn5-induced mutant of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae could not form nitrogen-fixing nodules on pea or vetch because of a lesion in electron transport to oxygen. The mutant lacked spectroscopically detectable cytochromes c and aa3. No proteins containing c-type cytochrome could be identified in the mutant by heme staining of proteins fractionated on polyacrylamide gels, indicating that the mutant was defective in maturation of all c-type cytochromes. The Tn5 mutation was determined to be located in a gene that was called cycY. The cycY gene product is homologous to the thioredoxin-like protein HelX involved in the assembly of c-type cytochromes in Rhodobacter capsulatus and to an open reading frame from a Bradyrhizobium japonicum gene cluster containing other genes involved in cytochrome c biogenesis. Our observations are consistent with CycY functioning as a thioredoxin that reduces cysteine residues in apocytochromes c before heme attachment.     

Mutations in the thiol-disulfide oxidoreductases BdbC and BdbD can suppress cytochrome c deficiency of CcdA-defective Bacillus subtilis cells

Cytochromes of the c type in the gram-positive bacterium Bacillus subtilis are all membrane anchored, with their heme domains exposed on the outer side of the cytoplasmic membrane. They are distinguished from other cytochromes by having heme covalently attached by two thioether bonds. The cysteinyls in the heme-binding site (CXXCH) in apocytochrome c must be reduced in order for the covalent attachment of the heme to occur. It has been proposed that CcdA, a membrane protein, transfers reducing equivalents from thioredoxin in the cytoplasm to proteins on the outer side of the cytoplasmic membrane. Strains deficient in the CcdA protein are defective in cytochrome c and spore synthesis. We have discovered that mutations in the bdbC and bdbD genes can suppress the defects caused by lack of CcdA. BdbC and BdbD are thiol-disulfide oxidoreductases. Our experimental findings indicate that these B. subtilis proteins functionally correspond to the well-characterized Escherichia coli DsbB and DsbA proteins, which catalyze the formation of disulfide bonds in proteins in the periplasmic space.