Association between mitochondrial DNA haplotype compatibility and increased efficiency of bovine intersubspecies cloning

Reconstructed embryos derived from intersubspecies somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) have poorer developmental potential than those from intrasubspecies SCNT. Based on our previous study that Holstein dairy bovine (HD) mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) haplotype compatibility between donor karyoplast and recipient cytoplast is crucial for SCNT embryo development, we performed intersubspecies SCNT using HD as donor karyoplast and Luxi yellow heifer (LY) as recipient cytoplast according to mtDNA haplotypes determined by polymerase chain reactionrestriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR-RFLP) analysis. The results demonstrated that intersubspecies mtDNA homotype SCNT embryos had higher pre- and post-implantation developmental competence than intrasubspecies mtDNA heterotype embryos as well as improved blastocyst reprogramming status, including normal H3K9 dimethylation pattern and promoter hypomethylation of pluripotent genes such as Oct4 and Sox2, suggesting that intersubspecies SCNT using LY oocytes maintains HD cloning efficiency and may reprogram HD nuclei to develop into a normal cloned animal ultimately. Our results indicated that karyoplast-cytoplast interactions and mtDNA haplotype compatibility may affect bovine intersubspecies SCNT efficiency. This study on bovine intersubspecies SCNT is valuable for understanding the mechanisms of mtDNA haplotype compatibility between karyoplast and cytoplast impacting the bovine SCNT efficiency, and provides an alternative and economic resource for HD cloning.     

Noninvasive optical laser technologies for the transplantation of mammalian nuclei

The results of pioneering studies on the development of radically new noninvasive methods for the transplantation of mammalian somatic cell nuclei with the use of optical laser manipulations are presented, and their comparison with traditional invasive methods is performed. It is shown that all the key steps, including the enucleation of a recipient cell, the transfer of a somatic cell (karyoplast), its bringing close together with the recipient cytoplast, and the fusion of the cytoplast with the somatic cell, can be effectively conducted using the laser only with complete replacement by laser of traditional mechanical micromanipulators and other devices, including devices for electrofusion. The results indicate the unique potentialities of laser and the prospects of its application in modern cell engineering in a wide spectrum of studies on oocytes and early mammalian embryos, in particular in technologies of therapeutic and reproductive cloning.     

Review of enucleation methods and procedures used in animal cloning: state of the art

Enucleation of a recipient oocyte is a crucially important process for nuclear transfer efficiency. Several procedures have been developed and used in the production of nuclear transfer embryos. Although the use of excitable fluorochromes and ultraviolet (UV) light are commonly used for complete enucleation, they also pose the risk of damaging the maternal cytoplast. Telophase and chemically assisted enucleation have also been used for cloning, but the quality and quantity of the recipient cytoplasm varies with the procedure used. This paper reviews various methods used for enucleation, and discusses their benefits and limitations with respect to cloning efficiency.     

Asynchronous cytoplast and karyoplast transplantation reveals that the cytoplasm determines the developmental fate of the nucleus in mouse oocytes

The relationship between nucleus and cytoplasm can be well revealed by nuclear transplantation. Here, we have investigated the behavior changes of the reconstructed oocytes after transferring the karyoplasts from mouse GV, MI, and MII oocytes into the cytoplasts at the different developmental stages. When the GV cytoplast was used as recipient and MI or MII karyoplast was used as donor (MI-GV pair and MII-GV pair), the reconstructed pairs extruded a polar body after electrofusion and culture. Both the cytoplasm and the polar body had a metaphase spindle in the MI-GV pair, while only a clutch of condensed chromatin was observed in the cytoplasm and polar body of the MII-GV pair. When the MI cytoplast was used as recipient and GV or MII karyoplast was used as donor (GV-MI pair and MII-MI pair), the reconstructed pairs also extruded a polar body. Each had one spindle and a group of metaphase chromosomes in the cytoplasm and polar body, respectively. When the MII cytoplast was used as recipient and GV or MI karyoplast was used as donor (GV-MII pair and MI-MII pair), the reconstructed pairs were activated, became parthenogenetic embryos and even developed to hatching blastocysts after electrofusion. The result from immunoblotting showed that MAP kinase activity was high in the MI and MII cytoplasts, while not detected in GV cytoplast. The results demonstrate that the cytoplasmic environment determines the behavior of asynchronous donors.     

Increased birefringence in the meiotic spindle provides a new marker for the onset of activation in living oocytes

The newly developed Pol-Scope allows imaging of spindle retardance, which is an optical property of organized macromolecular structures that can be observed in living cells without fixation or staining. Experiments were undertaken to examine changes in meiotic spindles during the initial stages of activation of living mouse oocytes using the Pol-Scope. Parthenogenetic activation of oocytes treated with calcium ionophore evoked a dynamic increase in meiotic spindle retardance, particularly of the midregion, before spindle rotation and second polar body extrusion. The pronounced increase in spindle retardance, which could, for the first time to our knowledge, be quantified in living oocytes, was maintained during polar body extrusion. Spindle retardance of newly in vivo fertilized oocytes was significantly higher than that of ovulated, metaphase II oocytes. Pol-Scope imaging of fertilized oocytes did not affect subsequent development. These results establish that increased spindle retardance precedes polar body extrusion and pronuclear formation. The increased birefringence in the spindle provides an early indicator of oocyte activation. Thus, noninvasive, quantitative imaging of the onset of activation in living oocytes might improve the efficiency of assisted fertilization and other embryo technologies.     

Dynamic imaging of the metaphase II spindle and maternal chromosomesin bovine oocytes: implications for enucleation efficiency verification, avoidanceof parthenogenesis, and successful embryogenesis

Manipulations of DNA and cellular structures are essential for the propagation of genetically identical animals by nuclear transfer. However, none of the steps have been optimized yet. This study reports a protocol that improves live dynamic imaging of the unfertilized bovine oocyte's meiotic spindle microtubules with microinjected polymerization-competent X-rhodamine-tubulin and/or with vital long-wavelength excited DNA fluorochrome Sybr14 so that the maternal chromosomes can be verifiably removed to make enucleated eggs the starting point for cloning. Suitability of the new fluorochromes was compared to the conventional UV excitable Hoechst 33342 fluorochrome. Enucleation removed the smallest amount of cytoplasm (4-7%) and was 100% efficient only when performed under continuous fluorescence, i.e., longer fluorescence exposure. This was in part due to the finding that the second metaphase spindle is frequently displaced (60.7 +/- 10%) from its previously assumed location subjacent to the first polar body. Removal of as much as 24 +/- 3% of the oocyte cytoplasm underneath the polar body, in the absence of fluorochromes, often resulted in enucleation failure (36 +/- 6%). When labeled oocytes were exposed to fluorescence and later activated, development to the blastocyst stage was lowest in the group labeled with Hoechst 33342 (3%), when compared to Sybr14 (19%), rhodamine-tubulin (23%), or unlabeled oocytes (37%). This suggests that longer wavelength fluorochromes can be employed for live visualization of metaphase spindle components, verification of their complete removal during enucleation, and avoidance of the confusion between artifactual parthenogenesis versus "cloning" success, without compromising the oocyte's developmental potential after activation.     

Association between mitochondrial DNA haplotype compatibility and increased efficiency of bovine intersubspecies cloning

Reconstructed embryos derived from intersubspecies somatic cell nuclear transfer(SCNT) have poorer developmental potential than those from intrasubspecies SCNT.Based on our previous study that Holstein dairy bovine(HD) mitochondrial DNA(mtDNA) haplotype compatibility between donor karyoplast and recipient cytoplast is crucial for SCNT embryo development,we performed intersubspecies SCNT using HD as donor karyoplast and Luxi yellow heifer(LY) as recipient cytoplast according to mtDNA haplotypes determined...     

Preparation of young preactivated oocytes with high enucleation efficiency for bovine nuclear transfer

To improve the enucleation rate in newly matured bovine oocytes, we investigated the position of cytoplasmic chromatin in relation to the polar body and the consequent enucleation efficiency before and after sequential activation with calcium ionophore A23187 and cycloheximide. Oocytes aspirated from the follicles of slaughterhouse-collected ovaries were cultured for 18 to 20 h. With Hoechst staining, only 40.7% of the chromatin material was found adjacent to the first polar body in metaphase II oocytes, while 100% was located adjacent to the second polar body in oocytes after the activation. Enucleation trials after activation showed a higher enucleation rate (91.5%) than that before activation (59.9%). The following experiment determined the effect of using both kinds of cytoplast on the in vitro development of nuclear transfer embryos. Blastomeres of the 32-cell-stage in vitro-produced embryos were transferred, fused to the activated cytoplasts and cultured in vitro. No significant difference was detected in fusion, cleavage or development to blastocysts obtained 7 d (174 h) post fusion. In conclusion, this study showed that young in vitro-matured bovine oocytes sequentially activated with calcium ionophore and cycloheximide have cytoplasmic chromatin material adjacent to the second polar body, leading to a high enucleation rate.     

Mitochondrial behavior and localization in reconstituted oocytes derived from germinal vesicle transfer

We investigated the mitochondrial behavior, localization and heteroplasmy in reconstituted oocytes derived from germinal vesicle (GV) transfers. The karyoplast containing the GV nucleus and the ooplast (enucleated oocyte) were prepared from GV oocytes derived from B6D2F1 mice. Mitochondria in the karyoplast and ooplast were labeled with MitoRed (Dojindo Laboratories, Kummoto, Japan) and MitoTracker Green (Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR, USA), respectively. After labeling the mitochondria, the karyoplast and ooplast were paired and fused. The mitochondrial behavior in fused (reconstituted) oocytes during in vitro maturation and preimplantation development were observed using confocal laser-scanning microscopy. In reconstituted oocytes that had reached to the M-II stage, mitochondria localized and concentrated in the hemispherical area of oocytes containing the M-II spindle. We showed that the two types of mitochondria derived from the GV donor and the recipient in reconstituted oocytes exhibit similar behavior to the normal oocyte during meiosis, and that the mitochondrial heteroplasmy of these oocytes did not influence their in vitro maturation and preimplantation development.     

Donor-host mitochondrial compatibility improves efficiency of bovine somatic cell nuclear transfer

Background  

The interaction between the karyoplast and cytoplast plays an important role in the efficiency of somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT), but the underlying mechanism remains unclear. It is generally accepted that in nuclear transfer embryos, the reprogramming of gene expression is induced by epigenetic mechanisms and does not involve modifications of DNA sequences. In cattle, oocytes with various mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) haplotypes usually have different ATP content and can further affect the efficiency of in vitro production of embryos. As mtDNA comes from the recipient oocyte during SCNT and is regulated by genes in the donor nucleus, it is a perfect model to investigate the interaction between donor nuclei and host oocytes in SCNT.     

Effect of timing of the removal of oocyte chromosomes before or after injection of somatic nucleus on development of NT embryos

Cloning methods are now well described and becoming routine. Yet the frequency at which live cloned offspring are produced (as a percentage of starting one-cell embryos) remains below 5% irrespective of nucleus donor species or cell type. In considering the cause(s) of this universally low efficiency, features common to all cloning protocols are strong candidates. One such shared feature is enucleation; the donor nucleus is inserted into an enucleated cytoplast (ooplast). However, it is not known whether a nucleus-free metaphase II oocyte is developmentally impaired other than by virtue of lacking chromosomes, or if in nuclear transfer protocols, enucleation removes factors necessary to reprogram the incoming nucleus. We have here investigated the role of enucleation in nuclear transfer. Three hours after the injection of cumulus cell nuclei into non-enucleated oocytes, 65% contained two distinct metaphase spindles, with the remainder exhibiting a single spindle in which oocyte-derived and nucleus donor chromosomes were mixed. However, staining only one hour after donor nucleus insertion revealed that most had two discrete spindles. In the absence of staining, the donor nucleus spindle was not visible. This provided a straightforward way to identify and select the oocyte-derived metaphase chromosomes 1 h after donor nucleus microinjection, and 34-41% cloned embryo developed to the morulla-blastocyst stage following Sr(2+)-induced activation. Of these, two (1% of starting one-cell embryos) developed to term, an efficiency which is comparable to that obtained for controls (6 clone; 1-2%) in which enucleation preceded nuclear transfer. In conclusion, the timing of the removal of oocyte chromosomes before or after injection of somatic nucleus had no effect on cloned embryo development. These findings argue that neither oocyte chromosome depletion per se, nor the potential removal of "reprogramming" factors during enucleation explain the low efficiency of nuclear transfer cloning.     

Hypertonic medium treatment for localization of nuclear material in bovine metaphase II oocytes

Oocytes enucleated at the second metaphase stage (MII) are often used as recipient cytoplasts for nuclear transfer. The oocyte's nuclear material has been traditionally removed blindly by aspirating the first polar body (Pb1) along with a portion of the cytoplasm. However, the Pb1-guided enucleation method is unreliable because the position of the Pb1 is variable. A previous study showed that pretreatment of mouse oocytes with 3% (0.09 M) sucrose allowed visualization of the metaphase spindle and chromosomes under standard light microscopy and led to a 100% enucleation rate. The same sucrose treatment, however, did not produce the same effect in bovine oocytes. In this study, we increased the concentration of sucrose to 0.3-0.9 M in PBS containing 20% fetal bovine serum (SPF) and found that the majority of the treated bovine oocytes (75%-86%) formed a small transparent bud into the perivitelline space, as compared with the 0.1 M sucrose (6%) or the no sucrose (0%) control groups. Staining of DNA with Hoechst 33342 revealed that these projections coincided with the position of the metaphase chromosomes in 100% of sucrose-treated oocytes, whereas only 31% of oocytes showed alignment of the position of Pb1 with their nuclear materials. Furthermore, 95% of oocytes treated in 0.3 M SPF were successfully enucleated by removing a small amount of cytoplasm adjacent to the projection. This is a significantly higher enucleation rate than that obtained by conventional Pb1-guided enucleation, even when a larger amount of cytoplasm was removed. For nuclear transfer, the enucleated oocytes treated with sucrose did not differ from the control oocytes in rates of fusion, cleavage, or development to blastocysts, or in the average cell numbers in blastocysts. This study demonstrated that 0.3 M sucrose treatment of bovine oocytes facilitates the localization of metaphase chromosomes under normal light microscopy and hence increases enucleation efficiency without compromising the in vitro development potential of cloned embryos by nuclear transfer.     

The influence of enucleation on the ultrastructure of in vitro matured and enucleated cattle oocytes

The enucleation of recipient oocytes in nuclear transfer experiments is generally carried out by aspirating one third of the ooplasm adjacent to the first polar body. It was supposed that this enucleation step affects the ultrastructure of the remaining cytoplast, resulting in a decline or destruction of its cellular compartments. Even if the transferred nucleus had the potential to support the development of a single-cell nucleus transfer embryo to the blastocyst stage, meiotic division could be stopped at any stage if the destruction of the ultrastructure of host cytoplasm resulted in a limited metabolism. The present study was conducted to investigate the influence of the enucleation procedure on the ultrastructure of the remaining ooplast. In vitro matured oocytes; in vitro matured and enucleated oocytes; and in vitro matured and enucleated oocytes that were subsequently cultivated in vitro for additional 4 h were prepared for transmission electron microscopy (TEM). An examination of ultra-thin sections showed that the arrangement of organelles in all matured oocytes was in accordance with that already described for normal oocyte development. Immediately after enucleation no major differences in the arrangement of cortical granules, mitochondria, smooth endoplasmic reticulum (SER), lipid droplets and vacuoles were found compared with nonmanipulated oocytes. After enucleation and 4 h of culture, 24- and 36-h matured oocytes differed from each other in the arrangement of large aggregates of SER surrounded by a wall of mitochondria and lipid droplets. These complexes were still found in the 24-h but not in 36-h matured, enucleated and cultivated oocytes. Clusters of SER, mitochondria and lipid droplets were described by different authors as having metabolic activity. The results of this study in connection with results from nuclear transfer experiments suggest that these aggregates and their metabolic activity can be transferred with cytoplasm from 24- but not 36-h matured oocytes. Only cytoplasm from the 24-h matured oocytes showed a development-supporting effect when fused to enucleated recipient cells before nuclear transfer.     

Clonal lines of transgenic fibroblast cells derived from the same fetus result in different development when used for nuclear transfer in pigs

Different factors are believed to influence the outcome of nuclear transfer (NT) experiments. Besides the cell cycle stage of both recipient cytoplast and donor karyoplast, the origin of the donor cells (embryonic, fetal, and adult) is of interest. We compared in vitro development of NT embryos derived from small serum-starved (G0) or small cycling (G1) porcine fetal fibroblast cells. Serum starvation did not have a positive effect on cleavage rate or the percentage of embryos that developed to the morula and blastocyst stages. Next, we investigated the development of porcine NT embryos derived from different transgenic clonal cell lines that had originated from the same fetus. When different clonal lines of fetal fibroblasts were fused to enucleated metaphase II oocytes, differences in fusion rates as well as in development to the morula and blastocyst stages were observed (P < 0.05). When oocytes derived from sow ovaries were used as recipient cytoplasts, significantly better cleavage (P = 0.03) and blastocyst formation (P < 0.014) was obtained when compared with oocytes derived from gilts. Our data indicate that not only different cell lines, but also different clones derived from one primary cell line, result in different development when used for NT. In addition, the use of sow oocytes as a cytoplast source also improves the efficiency of NT experiments.     

Optimization strategies for production of mammalian embryos by nuclear transfer

In order to optimize each of the individual steps in the nuclear transfer procedure, we report alternative protocols useful for producing recipient cytoplasts and for improving the success rate of nuclear transfer embryos in cattle, rhesus monkey, and hamster. Vital labeling of maternal chromatin/spindle is accomplished by long wavelength fluorochromes Sybr14 and rhodamine labeled tubulin allowing constant monitoring and verification during enucleation. The use of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) donor cells expressing the viral influenza hemagglutinin fusion protein (HA-300a+), to adhere and induce fusion between the donor cells and enucleated cow, rhesus and hamster oocytes was examined. Cell surface hemagglutinin was activated with trypsin prior to nuclear transfer and fusion was induced by a short incubation of a newly created nuclear transfer couplet at pH 5.2 at room temperature. Donor cell cytoplasm was dynamically labeled with CMFDA, or further transfected with the green fluorescence protein (GFP) gene, so that fusion could be directly monitored using live imaging. High rates of fusion were observed between CHO donor cells and hamster (100%), rhesus (100%), and cow recipient cytoplasts (81.6%). Live imaging during fusion revealed rapid intermixing of cytoplasmic components between a recipient and a donor cell. Prelabeled donor cytoplasmic components were uniformly distributed throughout the recipient cytoplast, within minutes of fusion, while the newly introduced nucleus remained at the periphery. The fusion process did not induce activation as evidenced by unchanged distribution and density of cortical granules in the recipient cytoplasts. After artificial activation, the nuclear transfer embryos created in this manner were capable of completing several embryonic cell divisions. These procedures hold promise for enhancing the efficiency of nuclear transfer in mammals of importance for biomedical research, agriculture, biotechnology, and preserving unique, rare, and endangered species.     

Most iodinatable fibroblast surface proteins accompany the cytoplast membrane during cytochalasin B-mediated enucleation of chick embryo fibroblasts

Six different proteins are found to be reproducibly exposed on the cell surface of chicken embryo fibroblasts (CEF) by the criterion of lactoperoxidase-catalyzed iodination (250,000, 185,000, 130,000, 100,000, 87,000, and 75,000 daltons). We wondered whether cell enucleation might lead to a differential partition of these surface proteins with the karyoplast or cytoplast membrane. We found that there is a marked enrichment of most iodinatable cell surface proteins in the cytoplast after cytochalasin-mediated enucleation of cell monolayers. Nearly all the iodinatable fibronectin remains with the cytoplast. Of the six labeled proteins, the karyoplast membrane contains a small amount of the 130 kdalton protein as well as trace levels of the 100-, 85-, and 75-kdalton proteins. Proteolysis or selective shedding of membrane proteins were not significant factors in the relative exclusion of iodinatable membrane proteins from the karyoplast. The cytoplast could replace some exposed membrane proteins after removal by trypsinization; however, fibronectin was not detectable within 10 h. That the karyoplast was not capable of membrane protein synthesis and/or insertion was suggested by the lack of any change in the labeling pattern of karyoplasts up to 8-h incubation after enucleation. A variety of control studies indicated that the surface proteins identified in this report were cell-derived and not adsorbed serum components. That some of the iodinatable proteins are intrinsic membrane proteins was suggested by their resistance to removal by conditions thought to extract extrinsic membrane proteins (i.e., low salt, high salt, and NaOH washes). lack of effect of cytoskeletal disrupting agents (preliminary evidence) suggests the nonrandom partition of membrane proteins may depend on anchoring of membrane proteins by a system(s) in the cytoplast other than intact microtubules and microfilaments.     

Improvement of a porcine somatic cell nuclear transfer technique by optimizing donor cell and recipient oocyte preparations

This study was conducted to improve a porcine somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) technique by optimizing donor cell and recipient oocyte preparations. Adult and fetal fibroblasts, and cumulus and oviduct cells were used as donor cells, and in vivo- and in vitro-matured oocytes were employed as recipient oocytes. The percentages of fusion and development to the blastocyst stage, the ratio of blastocysts to 2-cell embryos, and cell number of blastocysts were monitored as experimental parameters. In Experiment 1, donor cells of four different types were transferred to enucleated oocytes matured in vitro, and more (P < 0.05) blastocysts were derived from SCNT of fetal fibroblasts than from that of other cells (15.9% versus 3.1-7.9%). For SCNT using fetal fibroblasts, increasing the number of subcultures up to 15 times did not improve developmental competence to the blastocyst stage (12.2-16.7%). In Experiment 2, fetal fibroblasts were transferred to enucleated oocytes that matured in vivo or in vitro. When parthenogenetic activation of both types of oocytes was conducted as a preliminary control treatment, a significant increase in blastocyst formation was found for in vivo-matured compared with in vitro-matured oocytes (36.4% versus 29.5%). However, no improvement was achieved in SCNT using in vivo-matured oocytes. In conclusion, the type of donor somatic cell is important for improving development after porcine SCNT, and fetal fibroblasts were the most effective among examined cells. A system with good reproducibility has been established using fetal fibroblasts as the donor karyoplast after subculturing 1-10 times, and using both in vivo and in vitro-matured oocytes as the recipient cytoplast.     

Influence of cell cycle stage at nuclear transplantation on the development in vitro of mouse embryos

Nuclei were transplanted from embryos of mice at different stages of the 1st and 2nd cell cycle to oocytes enucleated at various times after fertilization. After transfer of pronuclei, a greater proportion of embryos developed to blastocysts if donor and recipient embryos were at the same stage of the cell cycle (synchronous transfer = 94%, asynchronous transfer = 76%). By contrast, when 2-cell blastomere nuclei were fused to the cytoplasm of enucleated zygotes, there was a significant effect of both cytoplast and karyoplast cell cycle stage on the development of the reconstituted embryos. Karyoplasts and cytoplasts derived from embryos at later stages of the cell cycle had greater potential to support development to blastocysts in vitro. It is suggested that the secretion of stage-specific messengers and the timing of nuclear membrane breakdown are the main factors causing the karyoplast and cytoplast effects, respectively.     

The effects of chemical enucleation combined with whole cell intracytoplasmic injection on panda-rabbit interspecies nuclear transfer

Conventional methods of somatic cell nuclear transfer either by electrofusion or direct nucleus injection have very low efficiency in animal cloning, especially interspecies cloning. To increase the efficiency of interspecies somatic cell nuclear transfer, in the present study we introduced a method of whole cell intracytoplasmic injection (WCICI) combined with chemical enucleation into panda-rabbit nuclear transfer and assessed the effects of this method on the enucleation rate of rabbit oocytes and the in vitro development and spindle structures of giant panda-rabbit reconstructed embryos. Our results demonstrated that chemical enucleation can be used in rabbit oocytes and the optimal enucleation result can be obtained. When we compared the rates of cleavage and blastocyst formation of subzonal injection (SUZI) and WCICI using chemically enucleated rabbit oocytes as cytoplasm recipients, the rates in the WCICI group were higher than those in the SUZI group, but there was no statistically siginificant difference (p > 0.05) between the two methods. The microtubule structures of rabbit oocytes enucleated by chemicals and giant panda-rabbit embryos reconstructed by WCICI combined with chemical enucleation were normal. Therefore the present study suggests that WCICI combined with chemical enucleation can provide an efficient and less labor-intensive protocol of interspecies somatic cell nuclear transfer for producing giant panda cloned embryos.