Evaluation of sampling and screening techniques for tiered monitoring of toxic cyanobacteria in lakes

Exposure to cyanotoxins can pose serious human health consequences both through drinking water and recreational use of a contaminated waterway. We adapted a tiered framework proposed by the World Health Organization (WHO) for monitoring cyanobacteria populations and assessing public health risks and implemented the program in Lake Champlain. This study focused on evaluating the sampling protocols employed in this adapted monitoring program over two field seasons (2003 and 2004). Using a paired sampling design, we evaluated whether 63-μm Wisconsin net samples adequately represented whole-water conditions and whether chlorophyll a concentration could serve as a useful predictor of cyanobacteria density and microcystin concentration. We also evaluated the spatial and temporal dynamics of blooms and their implications for monitoring. Our results suggest that using threshold values of either potentially toxic cyanobacteria density counted using a rapid screening protocol or chlorophyll a concentration serve as initial indicators of potentially high levels of cyanotoxin; however, the utility of chlorophyll a is system-dependent. Whole-water samples provide more accurate estimates of population density and higher microcystin concentrations than net samples, offering a more cautionary approach to assessing risk to recreational lake users. Shoreline samples generally showed higher cyanotoxin concentrations than offshore, but restricting sampling to the shoreline may miss early warnings of bloom development.     

Estimating toxic cyanobacteria in a Brazilian reservoir by quantitative real-time PCR, based on the microcystin synthetase D gene

The production of microcystin toxins by cyanobacteria is an intrapopulation feature and the toxic and nontoxic genotypes can be separated only through molecular analyses targeting the mcy markers. Quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) is a procedure that has been established, not only to detect but to specifically quantify these genotypes. In the present work, primers were designed for the mcyD region to estimate the number of cyanobacteria that are potential microcystin producers. Laboratory tests to verify the efficiency and the specificity of the primers were performed. The methodology was first established for single strain cultures and thereafter was applied in environmental water samples, from a reservoir located in the Brazilian savannah (“cerrado”). The results were very satisfactory, demonstrating the high efficiency and the specificity of the primers used, and their ability to detect different cyanobacteria genera. Of particular interest were the results showing a high proportion of toxic strains (as high as 100 %) in the environmental samples, as previously reported in another tropical system. Furthermore, the occurrence of a smaller fraction of toxic strains at high cyanobacteria densities, and of more toxic populations when fewer cyanobacteria were present, deserves further investigation. Although records of cyanobacteria blooms are very common in the tropics and suggest an increasing incidence of toxic populations, the present research is one of the few applying qPCR in a tropical environment. The results obtained here, by a technique that allows a more precise quantification and in situ follow-up of changes in toxicity, will make possible new observations of seasonal and spatial dynamics in these environments.     

Detection and identification of potentially toxic cyanobacteria in Polish water bodies

The main goal of this study was to determine the distribution of potentially toxic cyanobacteria in 39 selected Polish water bodies. From the water bodies with blooms and also from those in which blooms were not visible 87 samples were investigated. For the first time samples from ponds localized in villages with high agricultural activities were included. Lakes for which microcystin concentrations had been determined before were included as a reference for the research. The detection of cyanobacteria was conducted by microscopic observation as well as by PCR amplification of the rpoC1 gene fragment. Cyanobacteria were present in 75 out of 87 samples. The presence of potentially toxic cyanobacteria was detected by amplification of the mcyB and mcyE genes, which are involved in the biosynthesis of microcystins. Both genes were detected in 7 out of 9 blooms investigated. In the case of samples collected from water bodies in which blooms were not observed, the mcyB and mcyE genes were detected in 20 out of 36. In order to identify the cyanobacteria occurring in selected reservoirs, 16S plus ITS clone libraries were constructed. The method allowed distinguishing 18 different genotypes. After sequence analysis, cyanobacteria belonging to genera Microcystis, Planktothrix, Anabaena, Pseudanabaena, Synechocystis, Synechococcus and Woronichinia were identified. Results confirmed the usefulness of the rpoC1 and mcy genes for monitoring water bodies and detection of potentially toxic cyanobacteria. Application of molecular markers allowed detecting potentially toxic cyanobacteria before the bloom was visible. This is the first comprehensive study concerning cyanobacteria present in different types of Polish water bodies performed using molecular markers.     

运用分子生物学技术监测水环境中产毒蓝藻

有毒蓝藻在形成水华破坏水体环境的同时,也对人畜产生危害。运用分子生物学技术对水环境中产毒蓝藻进行监测,由于其简单、快速和经济等优点,逐渐成为各国学者关注的热点。本文从以下3个方面对其进行了综述:1)早期分子生物学技术在产毒蓝藻诊断中的运用;2)以产毒基因为靶标进行的产毒蓝藻诊断;3)运用基因芯片技术对产毒蓝藻进行检测。与传统的分子生物学技术相比,生物芯片技术具有体积小、重量轻、便于携带、分析自动快速、高通量等许多传统方法所不能比拟的优势。因此,该技术在蓝藻毒素检测中的运用必将给目前的产毒蓝藻的检测带来一场新的革命。     

Detection of potential microcystin-producing cyanobacteria in Brazilian reservoirs with a mcyB molecular marker

One of the most serious problems related to water eutrophication is the occurrence of increasingly frequent blooms of toxic cyanobacteria in freshwater ecosystems. Microcystin (MCYST) molecular markers may be used for the detection of toxic cyanobacteria, both cultivated strains and environmental samples, independently of their taxonomic category and production of the toxin at the moment of analysis. Sixty Microcystis spp. strains from 15 water reservoirs of south, southeastern and northeastern Brazil were analyzed by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) with oligonucleotide primers for mcyB gene of the operon that encodes a microcystin synthetase. It was found out that the presence of a unique amplified product of approximately 780 bp in 18 strains, indicated the presence of the microcystin-producing genotype. There was correspondence between the presence of the mcyB gene and microcystin determined by ELISA. Eight reservoirs contained toxic strains, two of these reservoirs being used mainly for public water supply. The coexistence of a mixture of toxic and non-toxic genotypes in populations of several reservoirs was found. Thus, it is evident that Microcystis populations present in blooms compose a mosaic, with genetically different individuals within the same population, each one, possibly, with its own tolerance to environmental factors and with distinct toxicity potential.     

Using an online phycocyanin fluorescence probe for rapid monitoring of cyanobacteria in Macau freshwater reservoir

Monitoring of cyanobacteria and their toxins are traditionally conducted by cell counting, chlorophyll-a (chl-a) determination and cyanotoxin measurements, respectively. These methods are tedious, costly, time consuming, and insensitive to rapid changes in water quality and cyanobacterial abundance. We have applied and tested an online phycocyanin (PC) fluorescence probe for rapid monitoring of cyanobacteria in the Macau Storage Reservoir (MSR) that is experiencing cyanobacterial blooms. The relationships among cyanobacterial abundance, biovolume, cylindrospermopsin concentration, and PC fluorescence were analyzed using both laboratory and in-the-field studies. The performance of the probe was compared with traditional methods, and its advantages and limitations were assessed in pure and mixed cyanobacterial cultures in the laboratory. The proposed techniques successfully estimated the species including Microcystis and Cylindrospermopsis, two toxic species recently observed in the MSR. During February–November, 2010, the PC probe detected high correlations between PC and cell numbers (R ² = 0.71). Unlike the chl-a content, which indicates only the total algal biomass, the PC pigment specifically indicates cyanobacteria. These results support the PC parameter as a reliable estimate of cyanobacterial cell number, especially in freshwater bodies where the phytoplankton community and structure are stable. Thus, the PC probe is potentially applicable to online monitoring of cyanobacteria.     

Development and application of a multiplex qPCR technique to detect multiple microcystin-producing cyanobacterial genera in a Canadian freshwater lake

The emergence and persistence of complex blooms comprising multiple toxigenic cyanobacteria genera pose significant challenges for water quality management worldwide. The co-occurrence of morphologically indistinguishable toxic and non-toxic strains makes monitoring and control of these noxious organisms particularly challenging. Conventional monitoring approaches are not only incapable of discriminating toxic from non-toxic strains but also have proven to be less sensitive and specific. In this study, a multiplex quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) approach was developed and tested for its sensitivity and specificity at detecting, differentiating and estimating potentially toxic Anabaena, Microcystis and Planktothrix genotype compositions in environmental samples. The oligonucleotide primers and probes utilized were designed to target portions of the microcystin synthetase (mcy) E gene that encode synthesis of the unique 3-amino-9-methoxy-2,6,8-trimethyl-10-phenyldeca-4,6-dienoic acid (ADDA) moiety of microcystins in the three target genera. Laboratory evaluation showed the developed assay to be highly sensitive and specific at detecting and quantifying targeted genera. Indeed, the assay standards for the Anabaena, Microcystis and Planktothrix reactions attained efficiencies above 90 %, with coefficients of determination consistently above 0.99. Analysis of water samples from Missisquoi Bay, Quebec, Canada, resulted in successful detection and quantification of target toxigenic cyanobacteria even when cell numbers were below the detection limit for the conventional microscopy methods. Furthermore, toxigenic Microcystis spp. were found to be the main putative microcystin-producing cyanobacteria in the study lake. The qPCR technique developed in this study therefore offers simultaneous detection, differentiation and quantification of multiple toxigenic cyanobacteria that otherwise cannot be accomplished by current monitoring approaches.     

High‐resolution melting analysis: a genotyping tool for population studies on Daphnia

Determining genetic variation at the DNA level within and between natural populations is important for understanding the role of natural selection on phenotypic traits, but many techniques of screening for genetic variation are either cost intensive, not sensitive enough or too labour‐ and time‐consuming. Here, we demonstrate high‐resolution melting analysis (HRMA) as a cost‐effective and powerful tool for screening variable target genes in natural populations. HRMA is based on monitoring the melting of PCR amplicons. Owing to saturating concentrations of a dye that binds at high concentrations to double‐stranded DNA, it is possible to genotype high numbers of samples rapidly and accurately. We analysed digestive trypsins of two Daphnia magna populations as an application example for HRMA. One population originated from a pond containing toxic cyanobacteria that possibly produce protease inhibitors and the other from a pond without such cyanobacteria. The hypothesis was that D. magna clones from ponds with cyanobacteria have undergone selection by these inhibitors, which has led to different trypsin alleles. We first sequenced pooled genomic PCR products of trypsins from both populations to identify variable DNA sequences of active trypsins. Second, we screened variable DNA sequences of each D. magna clone from both populations for single nucleotide polymorphisms via HRMA. The HRMA results revealed that both populations exhibited phenotypic differences in the analysed trypsins. Our results indicate that HRMA is a powerful genotyping tool for studying the variation of target genes in response to selection within and between natural Daphnia populations.     

Molecular techniques for the early warning of toxic cyanobacteria blooms in freshwater lakes and rivers

The aim of this work was to test the efficacy of molecular techniques for detecting toxigenic cyanobacteria in environmental water samples collected from freshwater lakes, rivers and reservoirs in Portugal. Of 26 environmental samples tested, 21 were found to contain Microcystis using a genus-specific polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Another primer pair was applied to the same DNA template to test for the presence of microcystin synthetase genes. This primer pair resulted in the formation of a PCR product in 15 of the samples containing Microcystis and one sample that did not give a positive result in the Microcystis genus-specific PCR. A restriction assay using the enzyme EcoRV was then applied to show that in most cases, the gene fragment was from toxigenic strains of Microcystis and, in one above-mentioned case, from a microcystin-producing strain of Planktothrix. All environmental samples were examined microscopically to confirm the presence of cyanobacteria species. Samples were also tested for the presence of microcystins using the ELISA plate assay. There was good agreement between the results obtained with molecular techniques and those obtained from microscopy and chemical methods. The PCR techniques applied in this paper were found to be useful, particularly when the concentration of the target organism was very low compared with other organisms. This technique can be used to detect inocula for cyanobacterial populations and therefore provide a useful tool for assessing under which conditions particular species can grow into bloom populations.     

The rise of potentially toxin producing cyanobacteria in Lake Naivasha,Great African Rift Valley,Kenya

Lake Naivasha, an important inland water ecosystem and a crucial freshwater resource in the Great African Rift Valley, has displayed clear signals of degradation in recent decades. We studied the phytoplankton composition and biomass levels in the period 2001–2013 and noted a progressive increase in the occurrence of potentially toxic cyanobacteria. Analyses for the presence of cyanotoxins such as microcystins (MC), cylindrospermopsin (CYN) and anatoxin-a (ATX-a) were carried out on samples collected in 2008–2013. Among the cyanotoxins tested, low concentrations of MC were detected in the lake. This is the first record of the occurrence of MC in Lake Naivasha. For the first time, molecular phylogenetic investigations of field clones of cyanobacteria from Lake Naivasha were carried out to establish the taxa of the dominant species. Amplification of the aminotrasferase (AMT) domain responsible for cyanotoxin production confirmed the presence of the mcyE gene belonging to the microcystin synthesis gene cluster in field samples containing Microcystis and Planktothrix species. These findings suggest that toxin producing cyanobacteria could become a threat to users of this over-exploited tropical lake in the near future.     

Cyanobacterial bioactive molecules--an overview of their toxic properties

Allelopathic interactions involving cyanobacteria are being increasingly explored for the pharmaceutical and environmental significance of the bioactive molecules. Among the toxic compounds produced by cyanobacteria, the biosynthetic pathways, regulatory mechanisms, and genes involved are well understood, in relation to biotoxins, whereas the cytotoxins are less investigated. A range of laboratory methods have been developed to detect and identify biotoxins in water as well as the causal organisms; these methods vary greatly in their degree of sophistication and the information they provide. Direct molecular probes are also available to detect and (or) differentiate toxic and nontoxic species from environmental samples. This review collates the information available on the diverse types of toxic bioactive molecules produced by cyanobacteria and provides pointers for effective exploitation of these biologically and industrially significant prokaryotes.     

蓝藻毒素对底栖动物的毒理学研究进展

近年,由于人类活动加剧,大量氮磷等营养物质流入湖泊等缓流水体,导致水体富营养化。而由此引起有害蓝藻水华的频繁爆发,使生态环境和人类健康受到严重威胁。相关研究表明,蓝藻水华的爆发不仅能够使水体水质恶化,其中一些产毒藻类还会产生大量蓝藻毒素,对水生生物产生重要影响。底栖动物作为水体生态系统的重要组成部分,在食物网中有重要作用,同时其中的许多种类又与人类息息相关,因此关于水华蓝藻毒素对淡水底栖动物的毒理学研究具有重要意义。在介绍蓝藻毒素概况的基础上,综述了蓝藻毒素的致毒机理和对底栖动物的影响,展望了研究方向。     

First report of cyanobacterial diversity and microcystins in a Microcystis strain from Sidi Boughaba,a Moroccan coastal lagoon

The cyanobacterial diversity of Sidi Boughaba, a Moroccan coastal lagoon and Ramsar site, was evaluated and its potentially toxic species were isolated and characterised. This study was the first time that cyanobacterial diversity and cyanotoxin production have been characterised in a Moroccan coastal lagoon. Samples collected in June 2004, July 2008 and August 2013 contained 41 species. Three strains of cyanobacteria were isolated, cultured and assessed for their potentially toxic levels of microcystins. Only Microcystis flos-aquae exhibited the presence of microcystins, at a concentration of 823.41 µg g?1 as MC-LR equivalents. MC-RR and MC-WR were also detected. The presence of toxic Microcystis and other potentially toxic strains, especially in periods of bloom proliferations, could pose environmental and health hazards. Cyanotoxin monitoring of this lagoon is highly recommended.     

Detection of Toxin-Producing Cyanobacteria by Use of Paramagnetic Beads for Cell Concentration and DNA Purification

Early detection of water blooms caused by potential toxin-producing cyanobacteria is important in environmental monitoring. We present a new nucleic acid-based method for detection of cyanobacteria in water that utilizes the same paramagnetic solid phase (beads) for both bacterial cell concentration and subsequent DNA purification. In the cell concentration step, the beads were attracted to a magnet after cell adsorption (in an alcohol- and salt-containing solution), and the supernatant was removed. For DNA purification, a buffer containing guanidine thiocyanate and Sarkosyl lysed the concentrated cells. The addition of alcohol precipitated the released DNA onto the same solid phase as was used for the cell concentration. Finally, to remove PCR inhibitors, the DNA was washed twice in alcohol while bound to the beads. All of the bead-DNA complex was used in the subsequent PCR amplification. The detection limit, as measured by 16S rDNA PCR amplification, was 50 cells in a 0.5-ml water sample, which is considerably lower than the limit (500 cells/ml) of toxic cyanobacteria tolerated in drinking water (New South Wales Blue-Green Algae Task Force, 1992). Testing of water from natural habitats showed a detection limit in the same range as that for the defined samples. The detection limits and the simplicity of the method (paramagnetic beads can be handled in automated systems) suggest that our method is suitable for routine environmental monitoring.     

Cyanotoxins in small artificial dams in Kenya utilised for cage fish farming – a threat to local people?

Nine small artificial dams located in different climatic regions of Kenya were studied. The local communities use the stored water for various purposes, such as irrigation, domestic use, watering of livestock and cage fish farming. Such intense use is commonly accompanied by eutrophication, including fast growth of cyanobacteria, which at times produce cyanotoxins threatening human and animal life. We studied the pelagic community, analysed abiotic variables and identified microcystins by means of high performance liquid chromatography and ELISA kits at monthly intervals over a period of one year. Mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS) was used to identify structural variants of microcystins by their protonated masses (M + H). Three dams contained microcystins, with the highly toxic Microcystin-LR being identified as the most prominent substance. Cell content of the toxin varied from 7.2 to 686.7 fg cell^?1. Basic limnological variables that indicate the probability of toxin presence were also recorded. Non-parametric Mann–Whitney U-test revealed significant differences in soluble reactive phosphorous, nitrate-N, water depth, total hardness and post-Nauplii stages sampled between toxin-producing and non-toxin-producing dams. Although most of the samples did not contain high amounts of cyanobacteria, the cyanotoxin-problem was evident, suggesting the need for regular cyanotoxin monitoring programs.     

A review of microcystin detections in Estuarine and Marine waters: Environmental implications and human health risk

Toxin production by harmful cyanobacteria blooms (CyanoHABs) constitutes a major, worldwide environmental threat to freshwater aquatic resources that is expected to expand in scale and intensity with global climate change. Extensive literature exists on the most frequently encountered cyanotoxin, microcystin, in freshwater environments. Yet, the expansion of microcystin producing CyanoHABs and the transport of contaminated inland waters to estuarine and coastal marine waters has only recently received attention. This paper synthesizes information on the salinity tolerance of microcystin producing cyanobacteria and summarizes available case reports on microcystin presence in estuarine and coastal waters. We highlight a potential food-borne exposure route to humans by reviewing the growing body of evidence that shows microcystins can accumulate in coastal seafood. These cases reinforce the importance of freshwater nutrient reduction and the need for freshwater management efforts to look beyond lacustrine and riverine systems. Events reviewed here likely only represent a small proportion of cases where microcystins affect estuarine and coastal waters. We strongly suggest increased monitoring and research efforts to understand, react to, and prevent ecological and health problems associated with the growing problem of toxic CyanoHABs in coastal environments.     

Molecular (PCR-DGGE) versus morphological approach: analysis of taxonomic composition of potentially toxic cyanobacteria in freshwater lakes

Background

The microscopic Utermöhl method is commonly used for the recognition of the presence and taxonomic composition of potentially toxic cyanobacteria and is especially useful for monitoring reservoirs used as drinking water, recreation and fishery resources. However, this method is time-consuming and does not allow potentially toxic and nontoxic cyanobacterial strains to be distinguished. We have developed a method based on denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) of the marker gene ITS and the mcy-gene cluster, and DNA sequencing. We have attempted to calibrate the DGGE-method with a microscopic procedure, using water samples taken in 2011 from four lakes of the Great Mazurian Lakes system.

Results

Results showed that the classic microscopic method was much more precise and allowed the classification of the majority of cyanobacterial taxa to the species or genus. Using the molecular approach, most of the sequences could only be assigned to a genus or family. The results of DGGE and microscopic analyses overlapped in the detection of the filamentous cyanobacteria. For coccoid cyanobacteria, we only found two taxa using the molecular method, which represented 17% of the total taxa identified using microscopic observations. The DGGE method allowed the identification of two genera of cyanobacteria (Planktothrix and Microcystis) in the studied samples, which have the potential ability to produce toxins from the microcystins group.

Conclusions

The results confirmed that the molecular approach is useful for the rapid detection and taxonomic distinction of potentially toxic cyanobacteria in lake-water samples, also in very diverse cyanobacterial communities. Such rapid detection is unattainable by other methods. However, with still limited nucleotide sequences deposited in the public databases, this method is currently not sufficient to evaluate the entire taxonomic composition of cyanobacteria in lakes.     

Development of a universal microarray based on the ligation detection reaction and 16S rrna gene polymorphism to target diversity of cyanobacteria

The cyanobacteria are photosynthetic prokaryotes of significant ecological and biotechnological interest, since they strongly contribute to primary production and are a rich source of bioactive compounds. In eutrophic fresh and brackish waters, their mass occurrences (water blooms) are often toxic and constitute a high potential risk for human health. Therefore, rapid and reliable identification of cyanobacterial species in complex environmental samples is important. Here we describe the development and validation of a microarray for the identification of cyanobacteria in aquatic environments. Our approach is based on the use of a ligation detection reaction coupled to a universal array. Probes were designed for detecting 19 cyanobacterial groups including Anabaena/Aphanizomenon, Calothrix, Cylindrospermopsis, Cylindrospermum, Gloeothece, halotolerants, Leptolyngbya, Palau Lyngbya, Microcystis, Nodularia, Nostoc, Planktothrix, Antarctic Phormidium, Prochlorococcus, Spirulina, Synechococcus, Synechocystis, Trichodesmium, and Woronichinia. These groups were identified based on an alignment of over 300 cyanobacterial 16S rRNA sequences. For validation of the microarrays, 95 samples (24 axenic strains from culture collections, 27 isolated strains, and 44 cloned fragments recovered from environmental samples) were tested. The results demonstrated a high discriminative power and sensitivity to 1 fmol of the PCR-amplified 16S rRNA gene. Accurate identification of target strains was also achieved with unbalanced mixes of PCR amplicons from different cyanobacteria and an environmental sample. Our universal array method shows great potential for rapid and reliable identification of cyanobacteria. It can be easily adapted to future development and could thus be applied both in research and environmental monitoring.     

Detection of saxitoxin-producing cyanobacteria and Anabaena circinalis in environmental water blooms by quantitative PCR

Saxitoxins (STXs) are carbamate alkaloid neurotoxins produced by marine "red tide" dinoflagellates and several species of freshwater filamentous cyanobacteria, including Anabaena circinalis, Aphanizomenon spp., Lyngbya wollei, and Cylindrospermopsis raciborskii. A specific quantitative PCR (qPCR) method based on SYBR green chemistry was developed to quantify saxitoxin-producing Anabaena circinalis cyanobacteria, which are major bloom-forming freshwater cyanobacteria. The aim of this study was to infer the potential toxigenicity of samples by determining the copy number of a unique and unusual polyketide synthase (PKS) sequence (sxtA) in the STX biosynthesis gene cluster identified in cyanobacteria. Our qPCR approach was applied to water samples collected from different Australian lakes, dams, and rivers. The STX concentration and cyanobacterial cell density of these blooms were also determined by high-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) and microscopic cell counting, respectively. STX concentrations correlated positively with STX gene copy numbers, indicating that the latter can be used as a measure of potential toxigenicity in Anabaena circinalis and possibly other cyanobacterial blooms. The qPCR method targeting STX genes can also be employed for both monitoring and ecophysiological studies of toxic Anabaena circinalis blooms and potentially several other STX-producing cyanobacteria.     

水华蓝藻产毒特性的PCR检测法

特异引物对（TOX 1P／1F;TOX 2P／2F）用于检测微囊灌毒素合成酶基因mcyB片段在38种水华蓝藻中的分布情况。结果显示,所有能产生微囊灌毒素的微囊藻都有特异扩增条带,非产毒株则没有,几种常规的毒性检测方法验证了PCR方法所获结果的准确性。本研究发展了以全细胞PCR法检测mcyB片断,说明全细胞PCR检测法适用于不同来源的蓝藻材料。结果证明以DNA为基因鉴别产毒和非产毒微囊藻及其他水华蓝藻的方法是可行的和实用的。