How Do Type II Topoisomerases Use ATP Hydrolysis to Simplify DNA Topology beyond Equilibrium? Investigating the Relaxation Reaction of Nonsupercoiling Type II Topoisomerases

DNA topoisomerases control the topology of DNA (e.g., the level of supercoiling) in all cells. Type IIA topoisomerases are ATP-dependent enzymes that have been shown to simplify the topology of their DNA substrates to a level beyond that expected at equilibrium (i.e., more relaxed than the product of relaxation by ATP-independent enzymes, such as type I topoisomerases, or a lower-than-equilibrium level of catenation). The mechanism of this effect is currently unknown, although several models have been suggested. We have analyzed the DNA relaxation reactions of type II topoisomerases to further explore this phenomenon. We find that all type IIA topoisomerases tested exhibit the effect to a similar degree and that it is not dependent on the supercoil-sensing C-terminal domains of the enzymes. As recently reported, the type IIB topoisomerase, topoisomerase VI (which is only distantly related to type IIA enzymes), does not exhibit topology simplification. We find that topology simplification is not significantly dependent on circle size in the range ∼ 2-9 kbp and is not altered by reducing the free energy available from ATP hydrolysis by varying the ADP:ATP ratio. A direct test of one model (DNA tracking; i.e., sliding of a protein clamp along DNA to trap supercoils) suggests that this is unlikely to be the explanation for the effect. We conclude that geometric selection of DNA segments by the enzymes is likely to be a primary source of the effect, but that it is possible that other kinetic factors contribute. We also speculate whether topology simplification might simply be an evolutionary relic, with no adaptive significance.     

Holoenzyme assembly and ATP-mediated conformational dynamics of topoisomerase VI

Type II topoisomerases help disentangle chromosomes to facilitate cell division. To advance understanding of the structure and dynamics of these essential enzymes, we have determined the crystal structure of an archaeal type IIB topoisomerase, topo VI, at 4.0-A resolution. The 220-kDa heterotetramer adopts a 'twin-gate' architecture, in which a pair of ATPase domains at one end of the enzyme is poised to coordinate DNA movements into the enzyme and through a set of DNA-cleaving domains at the other end. Small-angle X-ray scattering studies show that nucleotide binding elicits a major structural reorganization that is propagated to the enzyme's DNA-cleavage center, explaining how ATP is coupled to DNA capture and strand scission. These data afford important insights into the mechanisms of topo VI and related proteins, including type IIA topoisomerases and the Spo11 meiotic recombination endonuclease.     

The role of DNA bending in type IIA topoisomerase function

Type IIA topoisomerases control DNA supercoiling and separate newly replicated chromosomes using a complex DNA strand cleavage and passage mechanism. Structural and biochemical studies have shown that these enzymes sharply bend DNA by as much as 150°; an invariant isoleucine, which has been seen structurally to intercalate between two base pairs outside of the DNA cleavage site, has been suggested to promote deformation. To test this assumption, we examined the role of isoleucine on DNA binding, bending and catalytic activity for a bacterial type IIA topoisomerase, Escherichia coli topoisomerase IV (topo IV), using a combination of site-directed mutagenesis and biochemical assays. Our data show that alteration of the isoleucine (Ile₁₇₂) did not affect the basal ATPase activity of topo IV or its affinity for DNA. However, the amino acid was important for DNA bending, DNA cleavage and supercoil relaxation. Moreover, an ability to bend DNA correlated with efficacy with which nucleic acid substrates stimulate ATP hydrolysis. These data show that DNA binding and bending by topo IV can be uncoupled, and indicate that the stabilization of a highly curved DNA geometry is critical to the type IIA topoisomerase catalytic cycle.     

Structure of the topoisomerase VI-B subunit: implications for type II topoisomerase mechanism and evolution

Type IIA and type IIB topoisomerases each possess the ability to pass one DNA duplex through another in an ATP-dependent manner. The role of ATP in the strand passage reaction is poorly understood, particularly for the type IIB (topoisomerase VI) family. We have solved the structure of the ATP-binding subunit of topoisomerase VI (topoVI-B) in two states: an unliganded monomer and a nucleotide-bound dimer. We find that topoVI-B is highly structurally homologous to the entire 40-43 kDa ATPase region of type IIA topoisomerases and MutL proteins. Nucleotide binding to topoVI-B leads to dimerization of the protein and causes dramatic conformational changes within each protomer. Our data demonstrate that type IIA and type IIB topoisomerases have descended from a common ancestor and reveal how ATP turnover generates structural signals in the reactions of both type II topoisomerase families. When combined with the structure of the A subunit to create a picture of the intact topoisomerase VI holoenzyme, the ATP-driven motions of topoVI-B reveal a simple mechanism for strand passage by the type IIB topoisomerases.     

Topoisomerase II from Chlorella virus PBCV-1. Characterization of the smallest known type II topoisomerase

Type II topoisomerases, a family of enzymes that govern topological DNA interconversions, are essential to many cellular processes in eukaryotic organisms. Because no data are available about the functions of these enzymes in the replication of viruses that infect eukaryotic hosts, this led us to express and characterize the first topoisomerase II encoded by one of such viruses. Paramecium bursaria chlorella virus 1 (PBCV-1) infects certain chlorella-like green algae and encodes a 120-kDa protein with a similarity to type II topoisomerases. This protein was expressed in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and was highly active in relaxation of both negatively and positively supercoiled plasmid DNA, catenation of plasmid DNA, and decatenation of kinetoplast DNA networks. Its optimal activity was determined, and the omission of Mg(2+) or its replacement with other divalent cations abolished DNA relaxation. All activities of the recombinant enzyme were ATP dependent. Increasing salt concentrations shifted DNA relaxation from a normally processive mechanism to a distributive mode. Thus, even though the PBCV-1 enzyme is considerably smaller than other eukaryotic topoisomerase II enzymes (whose molecular masses are typically 160-180 kDa), it displays all the catalytic properties expected for a type II topoisomerase.     

Inhibition of archaeal growth and DNA topoisomerase VI activities by the Hsp90 inhibitor radicicol

Type II DNA topoisomerases have been classified into two families, Topo IIA and Topo IIB, based on structural and mechanistic dissimilarities. Topo IIA is the target of many important antibiotics and antitumoural drugs, most of them being inactive on Topo IIB. The effects and mode of action of Topo IIA inhibitors in vitro and in vivo have been extensively studied for the last twenty-five years. In contrast, studies of Topo IIB inhibitors were lacking. To document this field, we have studied two Hsp90 inhibitors (radicicol and geldanamycin), known to interact with the ATP-binding site of Hsp90 (the Bergerat fold), which is also present in Topo IIB. Here, we report that radicicol inhibits the decatenation and relaxation activities of Sulfolobus shibatae DNA topoisomerase VI (a Topo IIB) while geldanamycin does not. In addition, radicicol has no effect on the Topo IIA Escherichia coli DNA gyrase. In agreement with their different effects on DNA topoisomerase VI, we found that radicicol can theoretically fit in the ATP-binding pocket of the DNA topoisomerase VI 'Bergerat fold', whereas geldanamycin cannot. Radicicol inhibited growths of Sulfolobus acidocaldarius (a crenarchaeon) and of Haloferax volcanii (a euryarchaeon) at the same doses that inhibited DNA topoisomerase VI in vitro. In contrast, the bacteria E.coli was resistant to this drug. Radicicol thus appears to be a very promising compound to study the mechanism of Topo IIB in vitro, as well as the biological roles of these enzymes in vivo.     

Reconstitution of DNA topoisomerase VI of the thermophilic archaeon Sulfolobus shibatae from subunits separately overexpressed in Escherichia coli.

DNA topoisomerase VI from the hyperthermophilic archaeon Sulfolobus shibatae is the prototype of a novel family of type II DNA topoisomerases that share little sequence similarity with other type II enzymes, including bacterial and eukaryal type II DNA topoisomerases and archaeal DNA gyrases. DNA topoisomerase VI relaxes both negatively and positively supercoiled DNA in the presence of ATP and has no DNA supercoiling activity. The native enzyme is a heterotetramer composed of two subunits, A and B, with apparent molecular masses of 47 and 60 kDa, respectively. Here wereport the overexpression in Escherichia coli and the purification of each subunit. The A subunit exhibits clusters of arginines encoded by rare codons in E.coli . The expression of this protein thus requires the co-expression of the minor E.coli arginyl tRNA which reads AGG and AGA codons. The A subunit expressed in E.coli was obtained from inclusion bodies after denaturation and renaturation. The B subunit was overexpressed in E.coli and purified in soluble form. When purified B subunit was added to the renatured A subunit, ATP-dependent relaxation and decatenation activities of the hyperthermophilic DNA topoisomerase were reconstituted. The reconstituted recombinant enzyme exhibits a specific activity similar to the enzyme purified from S.shibatae . It catalyzes transient double-strand cleavage of DNA and becomes covalently attached to the ends of the cleaved DNA. This cleavage is detected only in the presence of both subunits and in the presence of ATP or its non-hydrolyzable analog AMPPNP.     

A ParE-ParC fusion protein is a functional topoisomerase.

Type II topoisomerases are responsible for DNA unlinking during DNA replication and chromosome segregation. Although eukaryotic enzymes are homodimers and prokaryotic enzymes are heterotetramers, both prokaryotic and eukaryotic type II topoisomerases belong to a single protein family. The amino- and carboxyl-terminal domains of eukaryotic enzymes are homologous to the ATP-binding and catalytic subunits of prokaryotic enzymes, respectively. Topoisomerase IV, a prokaryotic type II topoisomerase, consists of the ATP-binding subunit, ParE, and the catalytic subunit, ParC. We have joined the coding regions of parE and parC in frame and constructed a fusion protein of the two subunits of topoisomerase IV. This fusion protein, ParEC, can catalyze both decatenation and relaxation reactions. The ParEC protein is also capable of decatenating replicating daughter DNA molecules during oriC DNA replication in vitro. Furthermore, the fusion gene, parEC, complements the temperature-sensitive growth of both parC and parE strains, indicating that the ParEC protein can substitute for topoisomerase IV in vivo. These results demonstrate that a fusion protein of the two subunits of topoisomerase IV is a functional topoisomerase. Thus, a heterotetrameric type II topoisomerase can be converted into a homodimeric type II topoisomerase by gene fusion.     

Direct measurement of DNA bending by type IIA topoisomerases: implications for non-equilibrium topology simplification

Type IIA topoisomerases modify DNA topology by passing one segment of duplex DNA (transfer or T–segment) through a transient double-strand break in a second segment of DNA (gate or G–segment) in an ATP-dependent reaction. Type IIA topoisomerases decatenate, unknot and relax supercoiled DNA to levels below equilibrium, resulting in global topology simplification. The mechanism underlying this non-equilibrium topology simplification remains speculative. The bend angle model postulates that non-equilibrium topology simplification scales with the bend angle imposed on the G–segment DNA by the binding of a type IIA topoisomerase. To test this bend angle model, we used atomic force microscopy and single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer to measure the extent of bending imposed on DNA by three type IIA topoisomerases that span the range of topology simplification activity. We found that Escherichia coli topoisomerase IV, yeast topoisomerase II and human topoisomerase IIα each bend DNA to a similar degree. These data suggest that DNA bending is not the sole determinant of non-equilibrium topology simplification. Rather, they suggest a fundamental and conserved role for DNA bending in the enzymatic cycle of type IIA topoisomerases.     

Phylogenomics of type II DNA topoisomerases

Type II DNA topoisomerases (Topo II) are essential enzymes implicated in key nuclear processes. The recent discovery of a novel kind of Topo II (DNA topoisomerase VI) in Archaea led to a division of these enzymes into two non-homologous families, (Topo IIA and Topo IIB) and to the identification of the eukaryotic protein that initiates meiotic recombination, Spo11. In the present report, we have updated the distribution of all Topo II in the three domains of life by a phylogenomic approach. Both families exhibit an atypical distribution by comparison with other informational proteins, with predominance of Topo IIA in Bacteria, Eukarya and viruses, and Topo IIB in Archaea. However, plants and some Archaea contain Topo II from both families. We confront this atypical distribution with current hypotheses on the evolution of the three domains of life and origin of DNA genomes.     

Sensitivity of human type II topoisomerases to DNA damage: stimulation of enzyme-mediated DNA cleavage by abasic, oxidized and alkylated lesions

Type II topoisomerases are essential enzymes that are also the primary cellular targets for a number of important anticancer drugs. These drugs act by increasing levels of topoisomerase II-mediated DNA cleavage. Recent studies indicate that endogenous forms of DNA damage, such as abasic sites and base mismatches, also stimulate the DNA scission activity of the enzyme. To extend our understanding of how type II topoisomerases react to DNA damage, the effects of abasic sites, and oxidized and alkylated bases on DNA cleavage mediated by human topo-isomerase IIα and β were determined. Based on experiments that incorporated random abasic sites into plasmid DNA, human type II enzymes can locate lesions even within a background of several thousand undamaged base pairs. As determined by experiments that utilized site-specific forms of DNA lesions, oxidized or monoalkylated purines that allow base pairing and induce little distortion in the double helix have modest effects on topoisomerase II-mediated DNA cleavage. In contrast, 1,N⁶-ethenoadenine, a bulky lesion that disrupts base pairing, enhanced DNA cleavage ~10-fold. 1,N⁶-Ethenoadenine is the first lesion found to rival the stimulatory effects of apurinic sites on the DNA scission activity of eukaryotic type II topoisomerases.     

DNA topoisomerase VI generates ATP-dependent double-strand breaks with two-nucleotide overhangs

A key step in the DNA transport by type II DNA topoisomerase is the formation of a double-strand break with the enzyme being covalently linked to the broken DNA ends (referred to as the cleavage complex). In the present study, we have analyzed the formation and structure of the cleavage complex catalyzed by Sufolobus shibatae DNA topoisomerase VI (topoVI), a member of the recently described type IIB DNA topoisomerase family. A purification procedure of a fully soluble recombinant topoVI was developed by expressing both subunits simultaneously in Escherichia coli. Using this recombinant enzyme, we observed that the formation of the double-strand breaks on supercoiled or linear DNA is strictly dependent on the presence of ATP or AMP-PNP. This result suggests that ATP binding is required to stabilize an enzyme conformation able to cleave the DNA backbone. The structure of cleavage complexes on a linear DNA fragment have been analyzed at the nucleotide level. Similarly to other type II DNA topoisomerases, topoVI is covalently attached to the 5'-ends of the broken DNA. However, sequence analysis of the double-strand breaks revealed that they are all characterized by staggered two-nucleotide long 5' overhangs, contrasting with the four-base staggered double-strand breaks catalyzed by type IIA DNA topoisomerases. While no clear consensus sequences surrounding the cleavage sites could be described, interestingly A and T nucleotides are highly represented on the 5' extensions, giving a first insight on the preferred sequences recognized by this type II DNA topoisomerase.     

Inhibition of Zn(II) Binding Type IA Topoisomerases by Organomercury Compounds and Hg(II)

Type IA topoisomerase activities are essential for resolving DNA topological barriers via an enzyme-mediated transient single strand DNA break. Accumulation of topoisomerase DNA cleavage product can lead to cell death or genomic rearrangement. Many antibacterial and anticancer drugs act as topoisomerase poison inhibitors that form stabilized ternary complexes with the topoisomerase covalent intermediate, so it is desirable to identify such inhibitors for type IA topoisomerases. Here we report that organomercury compounds were identified during a fluorescence based screening of the NIH diversity set of small molecules for topoisomerase inhibitors that can increase the DNA cleavage product of Yersinia pestis topoisomerase I. Inhibition of relaxation activity and accumulation of DNA cleavage product were confirmed for these organomercury compounds in gel based assays of Escherichia coli topoisomerase I. Hg(II), but not As(III), could also target the cysteines that form the multiple Zn(II) binding tetra-cysteine motifs found in the C-terminal domains of these bacterial topoisomerase I for relaxation activity inhibition. Mycobacterium tuberculosis topoisomerase I activity is not sensitive to Hg(II) or the organomercury compounds due to the absence of the Zn(II) binding cysteines. It is significant that the type IA topoisomerases with Zn(II) binding domains can still cleave DNA when interfered by Hg(II) or organomercury compounds. The Zn(II) binding domains found in human Top3α and Top3β may be potential targets of toxic metals and organometallic complexes, with potential consequence on genomic stability and development.     

In vivo relations between pAMβ1-encoded type I topoisomerase and plasmid replication

A number of large extrachromosomal elements encode prokaryotic type I topoisomerases of unknown functions. Here, we analysed the topoisomerase Topβ encoded by the Gram-positive broad-host-range plasmid pAMβ1. We show that this enzyme possesses the DNA relaxation activity of type I topoisomerases. Interestingly, it is active only on plasmids that use DNA polymerase I to initiate replication, such as pAMβ1, and depends on the activity of this polymerase. This is the first example, to our knowledge, of prokaryotic type I topoisomerase that is specific for a given type of replicon. During pAMβ1 replication in Bacillus subtilis cells, Topβ promotes premature arrest of DNA polymerase I, ≈190 bp downstream of the replication initiation point. We propose that Topβ acts on the early replication intermediates of pAMβ1, which contain D-loops formed by DNA polymerase I-mediated strand displacement. The possible role of the resulting DNA Pol I arrest in plasmid replication is discussed.     

High-throughput assays for DNA gyrase and other topoisomerases

We have developed high-throughput microtitre plate-based assays for DNA gyrase and other DNA topoisomerases. These assays exploit the fact that negatively supercoiled plasmids form intermolecular triplexes more efficiently than when they are relaxed. Two assays are presented, one using capture of a plasmid containing a single triplex-forming sequence by an oligonucleotide tethered to the surface of a microtitre plate and subsequent detection by staining with a DNA-specific fluorescent dye. The other uses capture of a plasmid containing two triplex-forming sequences by an oligonucleotide tethered to the surface of a microtitre plate and subsequent detection by a second oligonucleotide that is radiolabelled. The assays are shown to be appropriate for assaying DNA supercoiling by Escherichia coli DNA gyrase and DNA relaxation by eukaryotic topoisomerases I and II, and E.coli topoisomerase IV. The assays are readily adaptable to other enzymes that change DNA supercoiling (e.g. restriction enzymes) and are suitable for use in a high-throughput format.     

Structure and function of an archaeal topoisomerase VI subunit with homology to the meiotic recombination factor Spo11.

In all organisms, type II DNA topoisomerases are essential for untangling chromosomal DNA. We have determined the structure of the DNA-binding core of the Methanococcus jannaschii DNA topoisomerase VI A subunit at 2.0 A resolution. The overall structure of this subunit is unique, demonstrating that archaeal type II enzymes are distinct from other type II topoisomerases. However, the core structure contains a pair of domains that are also found in type IA and classic type II topoisomerases. Together, these regions may form the basis of a DNA cleavage mechanism shared among these enzymes. The core A subunit is a dimer that contains a deep groove that spans both protomers. The dimer architecture suggests that DNA is bound in the groove, across the A subunit interface, and that the two monomers separate during DNA transport. The A subunit of topoisomerase VI is homologous to the meiotic recombination factor, Spo11, and this structure can serve as a template for probing Spo11 function in eukaryotes.     

DNA supercoiling during ATP-dependent DNA translocation by the type I restriction enzyme EcoAI

Type I restriction enzymes cleave DNA at non-specific sites far from their recognition sequence as a consequence of ATP-dependent DNA translocation past the enzyme. During this reaction, the enzyme remains bound to the recognition sequence and translocates DNA towards itself simultaneously from both directions, generating DNA loops, which appear to be supercoiled when visualised by electron microscopy. To further investigate the mechanism of DNA translocation by type I restriction enzymes, we have probed the reaction intermediates with DNA topoisomerases. A DNA cleavage-deficient mutant of EcoAI, which has normal DNA translocation and ATPase activities, was used in these DNA supercoiling assays. In the presence of eubacterial DNA topoisomerase I, which specifically removes negative supercoils, the EcoAI mutant introduced positive supercoils into relaxed plasmid DNA substrate in a reaction dependent on ATP hydrolysis. The same DNA supercoiling activity followed by DNA cleavage was observed with the wild-type EcoAI endonuclease. Positive supercoils were not seen when eubacterial DNA topoisomerase I was replaced by eukaryotic DNA topoisomerase I, which removes both positive and negative supercoils. Furthermore, addition of eukaryotic DNA topoisomerase I to the product of the supercoiling reaction resulted in its rapid relaxation. These results are consistent with a model in which EcoAI translocation along the helical path of closed circular DNA duplex simultaneously generates positive supercoils ahead and negative supercoils behind the moving complex in the contracting and expanding DNA loops, respectively. In addition, we show that the highly positively supercoiled DNA generated by the EcoAI mutant is cleaved by EcoAI wild-type endonuclease much more slowly than relaxed DNA. This suggests that the topological changes in the DNA substrate associated with DNA translocation by type I restriction enzymes do not appear to be the trigger for DNA cleavage.     

Ability of viral topoisomerase II to discern the handedness of supercoiled DNA: bimodal recognition of DNA geometry by type II enzymes

Previous studies with human and bacterial topoisomerases suggest that the type II enzyme utilizes two distinct mechanisms to recognize the handedness of DNA supercoils. It has been proposed that the ability of some type II enzymes, such as human topoisomerase IIalpha and Escherichia coli topoisomerase IV, to distinguish supercoil geometry during DNA relaxation is mediated by elements in the variable C-terminal domain of the protein. In contrast, the ability of human topoisomerase IIalpha and topoisomerase IIbeta to discern the handedness of supercoils during DNA cleavage suggests that residues in the conserved N-terminal or central domain of the protein are involved in this process. To test this hypothesis, the ability of Paramecium bursaria chlorella virus-1 (PBCV-1) and chlorella virus Marburg-1 (CVM-1) topoisomerase II to relax and cleave negatively and positively supercoiled plasmids was assessed. These enzymes display a high degree of sequence identity with the N-terminal and central domains of eukaryotic topoisomerase II but naturally lack the C-terminal domain. While PBCV-1 and CVM-1 topoisomerase II relaxed under- and overwound substrates at similar rates, they were able to discern the handedness of supercoils during the cleavage reaction and preferentially cut negatively supercoiled DNA. Preferential cleavage was not due to a change in site specificity, DNA binding, or religation. These findings are consistent with a bimodal recognition of DNA geometry in which topoisomerase II uses elements in the C-terminal domain to sense the handedness of supercoils during DNA relaxation and elements in the conserved N-terminal or central domain during DNA cleavage.     

Human topoisomerase IIalpha rapidly relaxes positively supercoiled DNA: implications for enzyme action ahead of replication forks

Movement of the DNA replication machinery through the double helix induces acute positive supercoiling ahead of the fork and precatenanes behind it. Because topoisomerase I and II create transient single- and double-stranded DNA breaks, respectively, it has been assumed that type I enzymes relax the positive supercoils that precede the replication fork. Conversely, type II enzymes primarily resolve the precatenanes and untangle catenated daughter chromosomes. However, studies on yeast and bacteria suggest that type II topoisomerases may also function ahead of the replication machinery. If this is the case, then positive DNA supercoils should be the preferred relaxation substrate for topoisomerase IIalpha, the enzyme isoform involved in replicative processes in humans. Results indicate that human topoisomerase IIalpha relaxes positively supercoiled plasmids >10-fold faster than negatively supercoiled molecules. In contrast, topoisomerase IIbeta, which is not required for DNA replication, displays no such preference. In addition to its high rates of relaxation, topoisomerase IIalpha maintains lower levels of DNA cleavage complexes with positively supercoiled molecules. These properties suggest that human topoisomerase IIalpha has the potential to alleviate torsional stress ahead of replication forks in an efficient and safe manner.     

Local sensing of global DNA topology: from crossover geometry to type II topoisomerase processivity

Type II topoisomerases are ubiquitous enzymes that control the topology and higher order structures of DNA. Type IIA enzymes have the remarkable property to sense locally the global DNA topology. Although many theoretical models have been proposed, the molecular mechanism of chiral discrimination is still unclear. While experimental studies have established that topoisomerases IIA discriminate topology on the basis of crossover geometry, a recent single-molecule experiment has shown that the enzyme has a different processivity on supercoiled DNA of opposite sign. Understanding how cross-over geometry influences enzyme processivity is, therefore, the key to elucidate the mechanism of chiral discrimination. Analysing this question from the DNA side reveals first, that the different stability of chiral DNA cross-overs provides a way to locally sense the global DNA topology. Second, it shows that these enzymes have evolved to recognize the G- and T-segments stably assembled into a right-handed cross-over. Third, it demonstrates how binding right-handed cross-overs across their large angle imposes a different topological link between the topoIIA rings and the plectonemes of opposite sign thus directly affecting the enzyme freedom of motion and processivity. In bridging geometry and kinetic data, this study brings a simple solution for type IIA topoisomerase chiral discrimination.