Comparison of beta-tubulin mRNA and protein levels in 12 human cancer cell lines

Antimitotic drugs are chemotherapeutic agents that bind tubulin and microtubules. Resistance to these drugs is a major clinical problem. One hypothesis is that the cellular composition of tubulin isotypes may predict the sensitivity of a tumor to antimitotics. Reliable and sensitive methods for measuring tubulin isotype levels in cells and tissues are needed to address this hypothesis. Quantitative measurements of tubulin isotypes have frequently relied upon inferring protein amounts from mRNA levels. To determine whether this approach is justified, protein and mRNA levels of beta-tubulin isotypes from 12 human cancer cell lines were measured. This work focused on only beta-tubulin isotypes because we had readily available monoclonal antibodies for quantitative immunoblots. The percentage of beta-tubulin isotype classes I, II, III, and IVa + IVb mRNA and protein were compared. For beta-tubulin class I that comprises >50% of the beta-tubulin protein in 10 of the 12 cell lines, there was good agreement between mRNA and protein percentages. Agreement between mRNA and protein was also found for beta-tubulin class III. For beta-tubulin classes IVa + IVb, we observed higher protein levels compared to mRNA levels.Beta-tubulin class II protein was found in only four cell lines and in very low abundance. We conclude that quantitative Western blotting is a reliable method for measuring tubulin isotype levels in human cancer cell lines. Inferring protein amounts from mRNA levels should be done with caution, since the correspondence is not one-to-one for all tubulin isotypes.     

In vivo coassembly of a divergent beta-tubulin subunit (c beta 6) into microtubules of different function

alpha- and beta-Tubulin are encoded in vertebrate genomes by a family of approximately 6-7 functional genes whose polypeptide products differ in amino acid sequence. In the chicken, one beta-tubulin isotype (c beta 6) has previously been found to be expressed only in thrombocytes and erythroid cells, where it is assembled into a circumferential ring of marginal band microtubules. In light of its unique in vivo utilization and its divergent assembly properties in vitro, we used DNA transfection to test whether this isotype could be assembled in vivo into microtubules of divergent functions. Using an antibody specific to c beta 6, we have found that upon transfection this polypeptide is freely coassembled into an extensive array of interphase cytoplasmic microtubules and into astral and pole-to-chromosome or pole-to-pole microtubules during mitosis. Further, examination of developing chicken erythrocytes reveals that both beta-tubulins that are expressed in these cells (c beta 6 and c beta 3) are found as co-polymers of the two isoforms. These results, in conjunction with efforts that have localized various other beta-tubulin isotypes, demonstrate that to the resolution limit afforded by light microscopy in vivo microtubules in vertebrates are random copolymers of available isotypes. Although these findings are consistent with functional interchangeability of beta-tubulin isotypes, we have also found that in vivo microtubules enriched in c beta 3 polypeptides are more sensitive to cold depolymerization than those enriched in c beta 6. This differential quantitative utilization of the two endogenous isotypes documents that some in vivo functional differences between isotypes do exist.     

A monoclonal antibody against the type II isotype of beta-tubulin. Preparation of isotypically altered tubulin

Mammalian brain tubulin consists of several isotypes of alpha and beta subunits that separate on polyacrylamide gels into three electrophoretic classes, designated alpha, beta 1, and beta 2. It has not been possible hitherto to resolve the different isotypes in a functional form. To this end, we have now isolated a monoclonal antibody, using as an immunogen a chemically synthesized peptide corresponding to the carboxyl-terminal sequence of the major tubulin isotype (type II) found in the beta 1-tubulin electrophoretic fraction. The antibody binds to beta 1 but not to alpha or beta 2. When pure tubulin from bovine brain is passed through an immunoaffinity column made from the anti-type II antibody, the tubulin that elutes in the unbound fraction is enriched greatly for the beta 2 electrophoretic variant. The tubulin that binds to the column appears to contain only alpha and beta 1, not beta 2. When these tubulin fractions are characterized by immunoblotting using the anti-type II antibody, the antibody binds only to the beta 1 band in the bound fraction, not to the beta 1 band in the unbound fraction. Using polyclonal antibodies generated against the carboxyl-termini of types I, III, and IV, we demonstrate that the beta 1 electrophoretic species is comprised of isotypes I, II, and IV, whereas the beta 2 variant is comprised exclusively of type III beta-tubulin. Further, we calculate that beta-tubulin in purified bovine brain tubulin is comprised of 3% type I, 58% type II, 25% type III, and 13% type IV tubulins.     

Differential synthesis of β-tubulin isotypes in gerbil nasal epithelia

Compartmentalization of beta-tubulin isotypes within cells according to function was examined in gerbil olfactory and respiratory epithelia by using specific antibodies to four beta-tubulin isotypes (beta(I), beta(II), beta(III), and beta(IV)). Isotype synthesis was cell-type-specific, but the localization of the isotypes was not compartmentalized. All four isotypes were found in the cilia, dendrites, somata, and axons of olfactory neurons. Only two isotypes (beta(I) and beta(IV)) were present in the cilia of nasal respiratory epithelial cells. The beta(IV) isotype, thought to be an essential component of cilia, was present in olfactory neurons and respiratory epithelial cells, which are ciliated, but was not found in basal cells (the stem cells of olfactory sensory neurons, which have no cilia). Olfactory neurons therefore do not synthesize beta(IV)-tubulin until they mature, when functioning cilia are also elaborated. The failure to observe compartmentalization of beta-tubulin isotypes in olfactory neurons sheds new light on potential functions of the beta-tubulin isotypes.     

Sequence of chicken c beta 7 tubulin. Analysis of a complete set of vertebrate beta-tubulin isotypes

In chicken, beta-tubulin is encoded by a family of seven genes. We have now isolated and sequenced overlapping cDNA clones corresponding to gene c beta 7 (previously designated c beta 4'), the only chicken beta-tubulin not previously characterized. The inferred amino acid sequence of c beta 7 tubulin is identical with the class I beta-tubulin isotype found in human, mouse and rat. Moreover, c beta 7 is highly expressed in almost all tissue and cell types in chicken, a pattern similar to those of the genes for class I beta-tubulin isotypes in other vertebrates. Comparison of the complete family of chicken beta-tubulin gene sequences reveals that the heterogeneity of beta-tubulin polypeptides encoded in a higher eukaryote is confined to six distinct beta-tubulin isotypes. Five of these are members of evolutionarily conserved isotypic classes (I to V), whereas the sixth represents a divergent erythroid-specific tubulin whose sequence has not been conserved.     

In vivo microtubules are copolymers of available beta-tubulin isotypes: localization of each of six vertebrate beta-tubulin isotypes using polyclonal antibodies elicited by synthetic peptide antigens

beta-Tubulin is encoded in the genomes of higher animals by a small multigene family comprising approximately seven functional genes. These genes produce a family of closely related, but distinct polypeptide isotypes that are distinguished principally by sequences within the approximately 15 carboxy-terminal amino acid residues. By immunizing rabbits with chemically synthesized peptides corresponding to these variable domain sequences, we have now prepared polyclonal antibodies specific for each of six distinct isotypes. Specificity of each antiserum has been demonstrated unambiguously by antibody binding to bacterially produced, cloned proteins representing each isotype and by the inhibition of such binding by preincubation of each antiserum only with the immunizing peptide and not with heterologous peptides. Protein blotting of known amounts of cloned, isotypically pure polypeptides has permitted accurate quantitative measurement of the amount of each beta-tubulin isotype present in the soluble and polymer forms in various cells, but has not revealed a bias for preferential assembly of any isotype. Localization of each isotype in three different cell types using indirect immunofluorescence has demonstrated that in vivo each class of microtubules distinguishable by light microscopy is assembled as copolymers of all isotypes expressed in a single cell.     

Distinct colchicine binding kinetics of bovine brain tubulin lacking the type III isotype of beta-tubulin

In mammalian brain, beta-tubulin occurs as a mixture of four isotypes designated as types I, II, III, and IV. It has been speculated in recent years that the different tubulin isotypes may confer functional diversity to microtubules. In an effort to investigate whether different tubulin isotypes differ in their functional properties we have studied the colchicine binding kinetics of bovine brain tubulin upon removal of the beta III isotype. We found that the removal of the beta III isotype alters the binding kinetics from biphasic to monophasic with the disappearance of the slow phase. The kinetics become biphasic with the reappearance of the slow phase when the beta III-depleted tubulin was mixed with the beta III fraction eluted from the affinity column with 0.5 M NaCl. The analysis of the kinetic data reveals that the tubulin dimers containing beta III bind colchicine at an on-rate constant of 35 M-1 s-1 while those lacking beta III bind at 182 M-1 s-1. Our results strongly suggest that the beta-subunit plays a very important role in the interaction of tubulin with colchicine.     

Biphasic kinetics of the colchicine-tubulin interaction: role of amino acids surrounding the A ring of bound colchicine molecule

Isotypes of vertebrate tubulin have variable amino acid sequences, which are clustered at their C-terminal ends. Isotypes bind colchicine at different on-rates and affinity constants. The kinetics of colchicine binding to purified (unfractionated) brain tubulin have been reported to be biphasic under pseudo-first-order conditions. Experiments with individual isotypes established that the presence of beta(III) in the purified tubulin is responsible for the biphasic kinetics. Because the isotypes mainly differ at the C termini, the colchicine-binding kinetics of unfractionated tubulin and the beta(III) isotype, cleaved at the C termini, have been tested under pseudo-first-order conditions. Removal of the C termini made no difference to the nature of the kinetics. Sequence alignment of different beta isotypes of tubulin showed that besides the C-terminal region, there are differences in the main body as well. To establish whether these differences lie at the colchicine-binding site or not, homology modeling of all beta-tubulin isotypes was done. We found that the isotypes differed from each other in the amino acids located near the A ring of colchicine at the colchicine-binding site on beta tubulin. While the beta(III) isotype has two hydrophilic residues (serine(242) and threonine(317)), both beta(II) and beta(IV) have two hydrophobic residues (leucine(242) and alanine(317)). beta(II) has isoleucine at position 318, while beta(III) and beta(IV) have valine at that position. Thus, these alterations in the nature of the amino acids surrounding the colchicine site could be responsible for the different colchicine-binding kinetics of the different isotypes of tubulin.     

Axonal transport of class II and III beta-tubulin: evidence that the slow component wave represents the movement of only a small fraction of the tubulin in mature motor axons.

Pulse-labeling studies demonstrate that tubulin synthesized in the neuron cell body (soma) moves somatofugally within the axon (at a rate of several millimeters per day) as a well-defined wave corresponding to the slow component of axonal transport. A major goal of the present study was to determine what proportion of the tubulin in mature motor axons is transported in this wave. Lumbar motor neurons in 9-wk-old rats were labeled by injecting [35S]methionine into the spinal cord 2 wk after motor axons were injured (axotomized) by crushing the sciatic nerve. Immunoprecipitation with mAbs which recognize either class II or III beta-tubulin were used to analyze the distributions of radioactivity in these isotypes in intact and axotomized motor fibers 5 d after labeling. We found that both isotypes were associated with the slow component wave, and that the leading edge of this wave was enriched in the class III isotype. Axotomy resulted in significant increases in the labeling and transport rates of both isotypes. Immunohistochemical examination of peripheral nerve fibers demonstrated that nearly all of the class II and III beta-tubulin in nerve fibers is located within axons. Although the amounts of radioactivity per millimeter of nerve in class II and III beta-tubulin were significantly greater in axotomized than in control nerves (with increases of +160% and +58%, respectively), immunoassay revealed no differences in the amounts of these isotypes in axotomized and control motor fibers. We consider several explanations for this paradox; these include the possibility that the total tubulin content is relatively insensitive to changes in the amount of tubulin transported in the slow component wave because this wave represents the movement of only a small fraction of the tubulin in these motor fibers.     

Beta-tubulin isotype classes II and V expression patterns in nonsmall cell lung carcinomas

Previous studies suggest that beta-tubulin isotype protein levels could be useful as indicators of nonsmall cell lung cancer (NSCLC) aggressiveness. However, measurement of protein amounts in tissue samples by staining techniques is semiquantitative at best. Since technologies for measuring mRNA levels have become more efficient and quantitative, we wanted to determine whether beta-tubulin message levels may be useful as biomarkers. Quantitative real-time RT-PCR was used to measure the seven classes of beta-tubulin isotypes, stathmin and MAP4 mRNA levels in 64 NSCLC and 12 normal lung tissue samples. We found significantly higher fractions of beta-tubulin classes II and V mRNA compared to the other isotypes in all lung tumor samples (P < 0.05). In addition, the ratio of beta-tubulin classes II/V mRNA was significantly higher in NSCLCs compared to normal lung tissues (P < 0.001). The data suggest that the ratio of beta-tubulin classes II and V mRNA could be useful as a biomarker for NSCLC tumor differentiation and/or NSCLC aggressiveness. Furthermore, the ratio of MAP4 to stathmin mRNA was found to be higher in diseased lung tissues compared to normal lung tissues, suggesting this ratio might also be used as a clinically relevant biomarker for NSCLCs.     

Localization of betav tubulin in the cochlea and cultured cells with a novel monoclonal antibody

Tubulin, the dimeric structural protein of microtubules, is a heterodimer of alpha and beta subunits; both alpha and beta exist as numerous isotypes encoded by different genes. In vertebrates the sequence differences among the beta(I), beta(II), beta(III), beta(IV) and beta(V) isotypes are highly conserved in evolution, implying that the isotypes may have functional significance. Isotype-specific monoclonal antibodies have been useful in determining the cellular and sub-cellular distributions and possible functions of the beta(I), beta(II), beta(III), and beta(IV) isotypes; however, little is known about the beta(V) isotype. We here report the creation and purification of a monoclonal antibody (SHM.12G11) specific for beta(V). The antibody was designed to be specific for the C-terminal sequence EEEINE, which is unique to rodent and chicken beta(V). The antibody was found to bind specifically to the C-terminal peptide EEEINE, and does not cross-react with the carboxy-termini of either alpha-tubulin or the other beta-tubulin isotypes. However, the antibody also binds to the peptide EEEVNE, but not to the peptide EEEIDG, corresponding respectively to the C-terminal peptides of bovine and human beta(V). Immunofluorescence analysis indicates that beta(V) is found in microtubules of both the interphase network and the mitotic spindle. In gerbils, beta(V) also occurs in the cochlea where it is found largely in the specialized cells that are unique in containing bundled microtubules with 15 protofilaments.     

Tubulin isotype usage in vivo: a unique spatial distribution of the minor neuronal-specific beta-tubulin isotype in pheochromocytoma cells

The neuronal cells of vertebrates express two beta-tubulin isotypes, called Class II and Class III, that are neuronal specific. In order to determine the distribution of the minor Class III isotype, site-directed antibodies were raised to synthetic peptides representing the carboxyl terminal, isotype-defining domains of the tubulins. These antibodies were applied to PC12 cells at various stages of differentiation. The Class III isotype was found to be expressed in undifferentiated PC12 cells as well as in cells at every stage of differentiation. The concentration of the Class III isotype, relative to the total beta-tubulin complement, did not change significantly. Indirect double immunofluorescence microscopy demonstrated that the Class III isotype was found in the soma and the neurites of differentiated PC12 cells; this spatial pattern of Class III expression paralleled the total beta-tubulin pattern. Although the anti-Class III antiserum could stain in vitro assembled neuronal microtubules in a filamentous pattern, a close examination of the Class III staining pattern in flattened PC12 cells revealed that this isotype was not incorporated into the nonaxoplasmic array of microtubules. Rather, the Class III isotype was localized in a nonfilamentous, granular pattern that was not readily extracted with nonionic detergent. Cells treated with taxol and then flattened and stained showed that the Class III isotype could be induced to assemble into microtubule bundles by taxol. Thus, the minor neuronal beta-tubulin isotype appears to be spatially specialized in its pattern of expression.     

The expression and posttranslational modification of a neuron-specific beta-tubulin isotype during chick embryogenesis

Five beta-tubulin isotypes are expressed differentially during chicken brain development. One of these isotypes is encoded by the gene c beta 4 and has been assigned to an isotypic family designated as Class III (beta III). In the nervous system of higher vertebrates, beta III is synthesized exclusively by neurons. A beta III-specific monoclonal antibody was used to determine when during chick embryogenesis c beta 4 is expressed, the cellular localization of beta III, and the number of charge variants (isoforms) into which beta III can be resolved by isoelectric focusing. On Western blots, beta III is first detectable at stages 12-13. Thereafter, the relative abundance of beta III in brain increases steadily, apparently in conjunction with the rate of neural differentiation. The isotype was not detectable in non-neural tissue extracts from older embryos (days 10-14) and hatchlings. Western blots of protein separated by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2D-PAGE) reveal that the number of beta III isoforms increases from one to three during neural development. This evidence indicates that beta III is a substrate for developmentally regulated, multiple-site posttranslational modification. Immunocytochemical studies reveal that while c beta 4 expression is restricted predominantly to the nervous system, it is transiently expressed in some embryonic structures. More importantly, in the nervous system, immunoreactive cells were located primarily in the non-proliferative marginal zone of the neural epithelia. Regions containing primarily mitotic neuroblasts were virtually unstained. This localization pattern indicates that c beta 4 expression occurs either during or immediately following terminal mitosis, and suggests that beta III may have a unique role during early neuronal differentiation and neurite outgrowth.     

Expression and function of beta-tubulin isotypes in Chinese hamster ovary cells

The availability of isotype-specific antisera for beta-tubulin, coupled with genetic and biochemical analysis, has allowed the determination of beta-tubulin isotype expression and distribution in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. Using genetic manipulations involving selection for colcemid resistance followed by reversion and reselection for drug resistance, we have succeeded in isolating cell lines that exhibit three major and one minor beta-tubulin spots by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. In concert with isotype-specific antibodies, analysis of these mutants demonstrates that CHO cells express two copies of isotype I, at least one copy of isotype IV, and very small amounts of isotype V. All three isotypes assemble into both cytoplasmic and spindle microtubules and are similar in their responses to cold, colcemid, and calcium-induced depolymerization. They have comparable turnover rates and are equally sensitive to depression of synthesis upon colchicine treatment. These results suggest that beta-tubulin isotypes are used interchangeably to assemble microtubule structures in CHO cells. However, of 18 colcemid-resistant mutants with a demonstrable alteration in beta-tubulin, all were found to have the alteration in isotype I, thus leaving open the possibility that subtle differences in isotype properties may exist.     

A ubiquitous beta-tubulin disrupts microtubule assembly and inhibits cell proliferation

Vertebrate tubulin is encoded by a multigene family that produces distinct gene products, or isotypes, of both the alpha- and beta-tubulin subunits. The isotype sequences are conserved across species supporting the hypothesis that different isotypes subserve different functions. To date, however, most studies have demonstrated that tubulin isotypes are freely interchangeable and coassemble into all classes of microtubules. We now report that, in contrast to other isotypes, overexpression of a mouse class V beta-tubulin cDNA in mammalian cells produces a strong, dose-dependent disruption of microtubule organization, increased microtubule fragmentation, and a concomitant reduction in cellular microtubule polymer levels. These changes also disrupt mitotic spindle assembly and block cell proliferation. Consistent with diminished microtubule assembly, there is an increased tolerance for the microtubule stabilizing drug, paclitaxel, which is able to reverse many of the effects of class V beta-tubulin overexpression. Moreover, transfected cells selected in paclitaxel exhibit increased expression of class V beta-tubulin, indicating that this isotype is responsible for the drug resistance. The results show that class V beta-tubulin is functionally distinct from other tubulin isotypes and imparts unique properties on the microtubules into which it incorporates.     

Free intermingling of mammalian beta-tubulin isotypes among functionally distinct microtubules

Mammalian cells express a spectrum of tubulin isotypes whose relationship to the diversity of microtubule function is unknown. To examine whether different isotypes are segregated into functionally distinct microtubules, we generated immune sera capable of discriminating among the various naturally occurring beta-tubulin isotypes. Cloned fusion proteins encoding each isotype were used first to tolerogenize animals against shared epitopes, and then as immunogens to elicit a specific response. In experiments using these sera, we show that there is neither complete nor partial segregation of beta-tubulin isotypes: both interphase cytoskeletal and mitotic spindle microtubules are mixed copolymers of all expressed beta-tubulin isotypes. Indeed, a highly divergent isotype normally expressed only in certain hematopoietic cells is also indiscriminately assembled into all microtubules both in their normal context and when transfected into HeLa cells.     

Identification by mass spectrometry of a new alpha-tubulin isotype expressed in human breast and lung carcinoma cell lines

The extensive C-terminal molecular heterogeneity of alpha- and beta-tubulin is a consequence of multiple isotypes, the products of distinct genes, that undergo several posttranslational modifications. These include polyglutamylation and polyglycylation of both subunits, reversible tyrosination and removal of the penultimate glutamate from alpha-tubulin, and phosphorylation of the beta III isotype. A mass spectrometry-based method has been developed for the analysis of the C-terminal diversity of tubulin from human cell lines. Total cell extracts are resolved by SDS--PAGE and transferred to nitrocellulose, and the region of the blot corresponding to tubulin (approximately 50 kDa) was excised and digested with CNBr to release the highly divergent C-terminal tubulin fragments. The masses of the human alpha- and beta-tubulin CNBr-derived C-terminal peptides are all in the 1500--4000 Da mass range and can be analyzed directly by MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry in the negative ion mode without significant interference from other released peptides. In this study, the tubulin isotype diversity in MDA-MB-231, a human breast carcinoma cell line, and A549, a human non-small lung cancer cell line, is reported. The major tubulin isotypes present in both cell lines are k-alpha 1 and beta 1. Importantly, we report a previously unknown alpha isotype present at significant levels in both cell lines. Moreover, the degree of posttranslational modifications to all isotypes was limited. Glu-tubulin, in which the C-terminal tyrosine of alpha-tubulin is removed, was not detected. In contrast to mammalian neuronal tubulin which exhibits extensive polyglutamylation, only low-level monoglutamylation of the k-alpha 1 and beta 1 isotypes was observed in these two human cell lines.     

Occurrence of nuclear beta(II)-tubulin in cultured cells

Microtubules are cylindrical organelles that play critical roles in cell division. Their subunit protein, tubulin, is a target for various antitumor drugs. Tubulin exists as various forms, known as isotypes. In most normal cells, tubulin occurs only in the cytosol and not in the nucleus. However, we have recently reported the finding of the beta(II) isotype of tubulin in the nuclei of cultured rat kidney mesangial cells. Mesangial cells, unlike most normal cell lines, have the ability to proliferate rapidly in culture. In efforts to determine whether nuclear beta(II)-tubulin occurred in other cell lines, we examined the distribution of the beta(I), beta(II), and beta(IV) mammalian tubulin isotypes in a variety of normal and cancer human cell lines by immunofluorescence microscopy. We have found that, in the normal cell lines, all three isotypes are present only in the cytoplasm. However, the beta(II) isotype of tubulin is located not only in the cytoplasm, but also in the nuclei of the following cell lines: LNCaP prostate carcinoma, MCF-7, MDA-MB-231, MDA-MB-435, and Calc18 breast carcinoma, C6 and T98G glioma, and HeLa cells. In contrast, the beta(I) and beta(IV) isotypes, which are also synthesized in cancer cells, are not localized to the nucleus but are restricted to the cytoplasm. We have also seen beta(II) in breast cancer excisions. In most of these cells, beta(II) appears to be concentrated in the nucleoli. These results suggest that transformation may lead to localization of beta(II)-tubulin in cell nuclei, serving an as yet unknown function, and that nuclear beta(II) may be a useful marker for detection of tumor cells.     

Differential and developmental expression of beta-tubulins in a higher plant

By using two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and immunoblotting, we have analyzed the expression of beta-tubulin isotypes in the higher plant, carrot. We report a complex expression of beta-tubulins that is dependent on the developmental stage of the tissues analyzed. Consequently, each tissue examined can be identified by its unique composition of beta-tubulins. In total, there are six electrophoretically separable beta-tubulins. In no tissue, however, is there less than two or more than five beta-tubulins. Within this framework we have detected a beta-tubulin specific to seedling tissue beta 6, and a beta-tubulin, beta 5, that is found only in the vegetative tissues of the mature plant. Traced from stem to midrib to leaf lamina, the beta 5 isotype becomes progressively dominant relative to beta 1. Another beta-tubulin isotype, beta 4, appears in marked abundance in immature and mature stamens. In isolated mature pollen the beta 4-tubulin overwhelmingly predominates the ubiquitously expressed beta 2-tubulin isotype. The remaining beta-tubulin isotypes also have specific expression programs with beta 1 present in all tissues except pollen and beta 3 absent only from pollen and leafy tissues.