Natural products and combinatorial chemistry: back to the future

The introduction of high-throughput synthesis and combinatorial chemistry has precipitated a global decline in the screening of natural products by the pharmaceutical industry. Some companies terminated their natural products program, despite the unproven success of the new technologies. This was a premature decision, as natural products have a long history of providing important medicinal agents. Furthermore, they occupy a complementary region of chemical space compared with the typical synthetic compound library. For these reasons, the interest in natural products has been rekindled. Various approaches have evolved that combine the power of natural products and organic chemistry, ranging from the combinatorial total synthesis of analogues to the exploration of natural product scaffolds and the design of completely unnatural molecules that resemble natural products in their molecular characteristics.     

Combinatorial synthesis of natural products

Combinatorial syntheses allow production of compound libraries in an expeditious and organized manner immediately applicable for high-throughput screening. Natural products possess a pedigree to justify quality and appreciation in drug discovery and development. Currently, we are seeing a rapid increase in application of natural products in combinatorial chemistry and vice versa. The therapeutic areas of infectious disease and oncology still dominate but many new areas are emerging. Several complex natural products have now been synthesised by solid-phase methods and have created the foundation for preparation of combinatorial libraries. In other examples, natural products or intermediates have served as building blocks or scaffolds in the synthesis of complex natural products, bioactive analogues or designed hybrid molecules. Finally, structural motifs from the biologically active parent molecule have been identified and have served for design of natural product mimicry, which facilitates the creation of combinatorial libraries.     

Solid phase synthesis of complex natural products and libraries thereof.

Natural products have served as an important source of medicinal compounds and pharmaceutical leads over the last century. Within the last 10 years, significant interest has developed in applying combinatorial chemistry techniques to the study of natural products and their biological activities. In this review, we examine several representative efforts wherein natural product skeletons have been constructed or immobilized on solid support and subsequently derivatized, giving rise to analog libraries useful in understanding the structure-activity relationships of the parent natural product. Issues such as target selection, library design, linker development, automation, and library characterization are addressed.     

Plant natural products: Back to the future or into extinction?

Natural product substances have historically served as the most significant source of new leads for pharmaceutical development. However, with the advent of robotics, bioinformatics, high throughput screening (HTS), molecular biology-biotechnology, combinatorial chemistry, in silico (molecular modeling) and other methodologies, the pharmaceutical industry has largely moved away from plant derived natural products as a source for leads and prospective drug candidates. Can, or will, natural products ever recapture the preeminent position they once held as a foundation for drug discovery and development? The challenges associated with development of natural products as pharmaceuticals are illustrated by the Taxol^® story. Several misconceptions, which constrain utilization of plant natural products, for discovery and development of pharmaceuticals, are addressed to return natural products to the forefront.     

'One bead two compound libraries' for detecting chemical and biochemical conversions

When combinatorial chemistry was introduced 13 years ago, the expectations were high for the delivery of results, particularly in the pharmaceutical industry. However, combinatorial chemistry was implemented independently of the application for which the products were going to be used. Resins developed only for efficient solid-phase synthesis were used and products were employed in existing assays developed for traditional solution studies. There was almost no assay or technology development and the use of real combinatorial methods soon had to give way to high-throughput synthesis and traditional screening. However, during recent years more sophisticated resins and assay techniques have been developed that may result in a second and more successful implementation of real integrated combinatorial chemistry. The first in this line of new developments is the 'one bead two compound' assay, in which the resin bead in addition to a combinatorial library member contains a reporter compound that can act as a beacon to monitor the activity of the library member. This powerful concept can be generally applied in all fields of combinatorial chemistry including drug, catalysts and material development.     

A pipeline for ligand discovery using small-molecule microarrays

Uncovering the functions of thousands of gene products, in various states of post-translational modification, is a key challenge in the post-genome era. To identify small-molecule probes for each protein function, high-throughput methods for ligand discovery are needed. In recent years, small-molecule microarrays (SMMs) have emerged as high-throughput and miniaturized screening tools for discovering protein-small-molecule interactions. Microarrays of small molecules from a variety of sources, including FDA-approved drugs, natural products and products of combinatorial chemistry and diversity-oriented synthesis, have been prepared and screened by several laboratories, leading to several newly discovered protein-ligand pairs.     

Solid-phase synthesis: a paradigm shift.

A personal review by the first graduate student of Professor R. Bruce Merrifield of the evolution of solid-phase synthesis and its acceptance by various subsets of the chemistry community. Solid-phase synthesis, as currently practised in the synthesis of biopolymers, combinatorial solid-phase organic chemistry, synthesis of natural products, catalyst selection, chemical ligation and materials development, has proven a paradigm shift for the chemistry community.     

Combinatorial biocatalysis: taking the lead from nature

Combinatorial biocatalysis is an emerging technology in the field of drug discovery. The biocatalytic approach to combinatorial chemistry uses enzymatic, chemoenzymatic, and microbial transformations to generate libraries from lead compounds. Important recent advances in combinatorial biocatalysis include iterative derivatization of small molecules and complex natural products, regioselectively controlled libraries, novel one-pot library syntheses, process automation, and biocatalyst enhancements.     

High-diversity combinatorial libraries

The synthesis of complex chemical structures by combinatorial chemistry has gained considerable interest. New chemical methods have been developed that enable the synthesis of compound libraries exhibiting structural diversities similar to those of natural products. The concept of 'chemical genomics' has been introduced, reflecting a new quality of understanding and creating the relationship between diverse artificial chemical structures with the space of biological responses and possible protein ligands.     

Combinatorial chemistry in the agrosciences

Combinatorial chemistry and high throughput screening have had a profound effect upon the way in which agrochemical companies conduct their lead discovery research. The article reviews recent applications of combinatorial synthesis in the lead discovery process for new fungicides, herbicides and insecticides. The role and importance of bioavailability guidelines, natural products, privileged structures, virtual screening and X-ray crystallographic protein structures on the design of solid- and solution-phase compound libraries is discussed and illustrated.     

Diketopiperazines in peptide and combinatorial chemistry.

Diketopiperazines (DKPs), the smallest cyclic peptides, represent an important class of biologically active natural products and their research has been fundamental to many aspects of peptide chemistry. The advent of combinatorial chemistry has revived interest in DKPs for two reasons: firstly, they are simple heterocyclic scaffolds in which diversity can be introduced and stereochemically controlled at up to four positions; secondly, they can be prepared from readily available alpha-amino acids using very robust chemistry. Here synthetic methods, conformation, as well as applications of DKPs are summarized and discussed critically.     

非核糖体肽合成酶工程改造研究进展

非核糖体肽合成酶合成的非核糖体肽类天然产物具有丰富的结构和多样的功能,在医药、农业、工业等领域具有广泛的应用潜力.利用合成生物技术工程改造非核糖体肽合成酶,在微生物细胞工厂中组合生物合成新型非核糖体肽分子顺应绿色化学的发展理念,是国内外学者关注的热点.文中归纳了3种不同的非核糖体肽合成酶工程改造策略,并对近年来相关领域...     

Introduction of New Tools for Chemical Biology Research on Microbial Metabolites

Recently, high-throughput screening (HTS) has become the mainstream technique for drug discovery. Compounds that are synthesized by combinatorial chemistry might be more suitable than natural products to apply to HTS, because the purification procedure is a drawback of using natural products. Nevertheless, natural products remain an extremely important source of drugs. To overcome the demerits of natural products, we are constructing the RIKEN Natural Products Depository (NPDepo) that is focused primarily on microbial metabolites. In this review, I describe (i) engineering pathways for biosynthetic gene clusters of microbial metabolites, (ii) construction of fraction libraries of microbial metabolites, and (iii) the development of a new screening system using a chemical array and a protein library produced by GLORIA.     

Design of compound libraries based on natural product scaffolds and protein structure similarity clustering (PSSC)

Recent advances in structural biology, bioinformatics and combinatorial chemistry have significantly impacted the discovery of small molecules that modulate protein functions. Natural products which have evolved to bind to proteins may serve as biologically validated starting points for the design of focused libraries that might provide protein ligands with enhanced quality and probability. The combined application of natural product derived scaffolds with a new approach that clusters proteins according to structural similarity of their ligand sensing cores provides a new principle for the design and synthesis of such libraries. This article discusses recent advances in the synthesis of natural product inspired compound collections and the application of protein structure similarity clustering for the development of such libraries.     

Importance of microbial natural products and the need to revitalize their discovery

Microbes are the leading producers of useful natural products. Natural products from microbes and plants make excellent drugs. Significant portions of the microbial genomes are devoted to production of these useful secondary metabolites. A single microbe can make a number of secondary metabolites, as high as 50 compounds. The most useful products include antibiotics, anticancer agents, immunosuppressants, but products for many other applications, e.g., antivirals, anthelmintics, enzyme inhibitors, nutraceuticals, polymers, surfactants, bioherbicides, and vaccines have been commercialized. Unfortunately, due to the decrease in natural product discovery efforts, drug discovery has decreased in the past 20 years. The reasons include excessive costs for clinical trials, too short a window before the products become generics, difficulty in discovery of antibiotics against resistant organisms, and short treatment times by patients for products such as antibiotics. Despite these difficulties, technology to discover new drugs has advanced, e.g., combinatorial chemistry of natural product scaffolds, discoveries in biodiversity, genome mining, and systems biology. Of great help would be government extension of the time before products become generic.     

Microfluidic combinatorial chemistry

Microreactors are finding increasing application in the field of combinatorial chemistry. In the past few years, microreactor chemistry has shown great promise as a novel method on which to build new chemical technology and processes. It has been conclusively demonstrated that reactions performed within microreactors invariably generate relatively pure products in high yield. One of the immediate and obvious applications is therefore in combinatorial chemistry and drug discovery.     

Role of natural product diversity in chemical biology

Through the natural selection process, natural products possess a unique and vast chemical diversity and have been evolved for optimal interactions with biological macromolecules. Owing to their diversity, target affinity, and specificity, natural products have demonstrated enormous potential as modulators of biomolecular function, been an essential source for drug discovery, and provided design principles for combinatorial library development.     

Natural products: A continuing source of novel drug leads

Background

Nature has been a source of medicinal products for millennia, with many useful drugs developed from plant sources. Following discovery of the penicillins, drug discovery from microbial sources occurred and diving techniques in the 1970s opened the seas. Combinatorial chemistry (late 1980s), shifted the focus of drug discovery efforts from Nature to the laboratory bench.

Scope of Review

This review traces natural products drug discovery, outlining important drugs from natural sources that revolutionized treatment of serious diseases. It is clear Nature will continue to be a major source of new structural leads, and effective drug development depends on multidisciplinary collaborations.

Major Conclusions

The explosion of genetic information led not only to novel screens, but the genetic techniques permitted the implementation of combinatorial biosynthetic technology and genome mining. The knowledge gained has allowed unknown molecules to be identified. These novel bioactive structures can be optimized by using combinatorial chemistry generating new drug candidates for many diseases.

General Significance

The advent of genetic techniques that permitted the isolation / expression of biosynthetic cassettes from microbes may well be the new frontier for natural products lead discovery. It is now apparent that biodiversity may be much greater in those organisms. The numbers of potential species involved in the microbial world are many orders of magnitude greater than those of plants and multi-celled animals. Coupling these numbers to the number of currently unexpressed biosynthetic clusters now identified (> 10 per species) the potential of microbial diversity remains essentially untapped.     

以生物合成为基础的代谢工程和组合生物合成

代谢工程和组合生物合成在筛选和发展新型药物方面日益成为生物、化学和医药界关注的重点。基于聚酮和聚肽类天然产物的独特化学结构和良好生物活性,研究它们的生物合成机制,将为合理化遗传修饰生物合成途径获得结构类似物提供遗传和生物化学的基础,实现利用现代生物学和化学的技术手段在微生物体内进行药物开发的目的。     

A road less traveled by: exploring a decade of Ellman chemistry

The Ellman group has been one of the most influential in the development and widespread adoption of combinatorial chemistry techniques for biomedical research. Their work has included substantial methodological development for library synthesis with a particular focus on new scaffolds rationally targeted to biomolecules of interest and biologically relevant natural products. Herein we analyze a representative set of libraries from this group with respect to their biological and biomedical relevance in comparison to existing drugs and probe compounds. This analysis reveals that the Ellman group has not only provided new methodologies to the community but also provided libraries with unique potential for further biological study.