The dimeric structure of the cytochrome bc(1) complex prevents center P inhibition by reverse reactions at center N

Energy transduction in the cytochrome bc(1) complex is achieved by catalyzing opposite oxido-reduction reactions at two different quinone binding sites. We have determined the pre-steady state kinetics of cytochrome b and c(1) reduction at varying quinol/quinone ratios in the isolated yeast bc(1) complex to investigate the mechanisms that minimize inhibition of quinol oxidation at center P by reduction of the b(H) heme through center N. The faster rate of initial cytochrome b reduction as well as its lower sensitivity to quinone concentrations with respect to cytochrome c(1) reduction indicated that the b(H) hemes equilibrated with the quinone pool through center N before significant catalysis at center P occurred. The extent of this initial cytochrome b reduction corresponded to a level of b(H) heme reduction of 33%-55% depending on the quinol/quinone ratio. The extent of initial cytochrome c(1) reduction remained constant as long as the fast electron equilibration through center N reduced no more than 50% of the b(H) hemes. Using kinetic modeling, the resilience of center P catalysis to inhibition caused by partial pre-reduction of the b(H) hemes was explained using kinetics in terms of the dimeric structure of the bc(1) complex which allows electrons to equilibrate between monomers.     

Mutations in cytochrome b that affect kinetics of the electron transfer reactions at center N in the yeast cytochrome bc1 complex

We have examined the pre-steady-state kinetics and thermodynamic properties of the b hemes in variants of the yeast cytochrome bc₁ complex that have mutations in the quinone reductase site (center N). Trp-30 is a highly conserved residue, forming a hydrogen bond with the propionate on the high potential b heme (b_H heme). The substitution by a cysteine (W30C) lowers the redox potential of the heme and an apparent consequence is a lower rate of electron transfer between quinol and heme at center N. Leu-198 is also in close proximity to the b_H heme and a L198F mutation alters the spectral properties of the heme but has only minor effects on its redox properties or the electron transfer kinetics at center N. Substitution of Met-221 by glutamine or glutamate results in the loss of a hydrophobic interaction that stabilizes the quinone ligands. Ser-20 and Gln-22 form a hydrogen-bonding network that includes His-202, one of the carbonyl groups of the ubiquinone ring, and an active-site water. A S20T mutation has long-range structural effects on center P and thermodynamic effects on both b hemes. The other mutations (M221E, M221Q, Q22E and Q22T) do not affect the ubiquinol oxidation kinetics at center P, but do modify the electron transfer reactions at center N to various extents. The pre-steady reduction kinetics suggest that these mutations alter the binding of quinone ligands at center N, possibly by widening the binding pocket and thus increasing the distance between the substrate and the b_H heme. These results show that one can distinguish between the contribution of structural and thermodynamic factors to center N function.     

Regulatory interactions in the dimeric cytochrome bc1 complex: The advantages of being a twin

The dimeric cytochrome bc₁ complex catalyzes the oxidation-reduction of quinol and quinone at sites located in opposite sides of the membrane in which it resides. We review the kinetics of electron transfer and inhibitor binding that reveal functional interactions between the quinol oxidation site at center P and quinone reduction site at center N in opposite monomers in conjunction with electron equilibration between the cytochrome b subunits of the dimer. A model for the mechanism of the bc₁ complex has emerged from these studies in which binding of ligands that mimic semiquinone at center N regulates half-of-the-sites reactivity at center P and binding of ligands that mimic catalytically competent binding of ubiquinol at center P regulates half-of-the-sites reactivity at center N. An additional feature of this model is that inhibition of quinol oxidation at the quinone reduction site is avoided by allowing catalysis in only one monomer at a time, which maximizes the number of redox acceptor centers available in cytochrome b for electrons coming from quinol oxidation reactions at center P and minimizes the leakage of electrons that would result in the generation of damaging oxygen radicals.     

Electron sweep across four b-hemes of cytochrome bc1 revealed by unusual paramagnetic properties of the Qi semiquinone intermediate

Dimeric cytochromes bc are central components of photosynthetic and respiratory electron transport chains. In their catalytic core, four hemes b connect four quinone (Q) binding sites. Two of these sites, Q_i sites, reduce quinone to quinol (QH₂) in a step-wise reaction, involving a stable semiquinone intermediate (SQ_i). However, the interaction of the SQ_i with the adjacent hemes remains largely unexplored. Here, by revealing the existence of two populations of SQ_i differing in paramagnetic relaxation, we present a new mechanistic insight into this interaction. Benefiting from a clear separation of these SQ_i species in mutants with a changed redox midpoint potential of hemes b, we identified that the fast-relaxing SQ_i (SQ_iF) corresponds to the form magnetically coupled with the oxidized heme b_H (the heme b adjacent to the Q_i site), while the slow-relaxing SQ_i (SQ_iS) reflects the form present alongside the reduced (and diamagnetic) heme b_H. This so far unreported SQ_iF calls for a reinvestigation of the thermodynamic properties of SQ_i and the Q_i site. The existence of SQ_iF in the native enzyme reveals a possibility of an extended electron equilibration within the dimer, involving all four hemes b and both Q_i sites. This substantiates the predicted earlier electron transfer acting to sweep the b-chain of reduced hemes b to diminish generation of reactive oxygen species by cytochrome bc₁. In analogy to the Q_i site, we anticipate that the quinone binding sites in other enzymes may contain yet undetected semiquinones which interact magnetically with oxidized hemes upon progress of catalytic reactions.     

Differential efficacy of inhibition of mitochondrial and bacterial cytochrome bc1 complexes by center N inhibitors antimycin, ilicicolin H and funiculosin

We have compared the efficacy of inhibition of the cytochrome bc₁ complexes from yeast and bovine heart mitochondria and Paracoccus denitrificans by antimycin, ilicicolin H, and funiculosin, three inhibitors that act at the quinone reduction site at center N of the enzyme. Although the three inhibitors have some structural features in common, they differ significantly in their patterns of inhibition. Also, while the overall folding pattern of cytochrome b around center N is similar in the enzymes from the three species, amino acid sequence differences create sufficient structural differences so that there are striking differences in the inhibitors binding to the three enzymes. Antimycin is the most tightly bound of the three inhibitors, and binds stoichiometrically to the isolated enzymes from all three species under the cytochrome c reductase assay conditions. Ilicicolin H also binds stoichiometrically to the yeast enzyme, but binds approximately 2 orders of magnitude less tightly to the bovine enzyme and is essentially non-inhibitory to the Paracoccus enzyme. Funiculosin on the other hand inhibits the yeast and bovine enzymes similarly, with IC₅₀ ∼ 10 nM, while the IC₅₀ for the Paracoccus enzyme is more than 10-fold higher. Similar differences in inhibitor efficacy were noted in bc₁ complexes from yeast mutants with single amino acid substitutions at the center N site, although the binding affinity of quinone and quinol substrates were not perturbed to a degree that impaired catalytic function in the variant enzymes. These results reveal a high degree of specificity in the determinants of ligand-binding at center N, accompanied by sufficient structural plasticity for substrate binding as to not compromise center N function. The results also demonstrate that, in principle, it should be possible to design novel inhibitors targeted toward center N of the bc₁ complex with appropriate species selectivity to allow their use as drugs against pathogenic fungi and parasites.     

Mutations in cytochrome b that affect kinetics of the electron transfer reactions at center N in the yeast cytochrome bc1 complex

We have examined the pre-steady-state kinetics and thermodynamic properties of the b hemes in variants of the yeast cytochrome bc1 complex that have mutations in the quinone reductase site (center N). Trp-30 is a highly conserved residue, forming a hydrogen bond with the propionate on the high potential b heme (bH heme). The substitution by a cysteine (W30C) lowers the redox potential of the heme and an apparent consequence is a lower rate of electron transfer between quinol and heme at center N. Leu-198 is also in close proximity to the b(H) heme and a L198F mutation alters the spectral properties of the heme but has only minor effects on its redox properties or the electron transfer kinetics at center N. Substitution of Met-221 by glutamine or glutamate results in the loss of a hydrophobic interaction that stabilizes the quinone ligands. Ser-20 and Gln-22 form a hydrogen-bonding network that includes His-202, one of the carbonyl groups of the ubiquinone ring, and an active-site water. A S20T mutation has long-range structural effects on center P and thermodynamic effects on both b hemes. The other mutations (M221E, M221Q, Q22E and Q22T) do not affect the ubiquinol oxidation kinetics at center P, but do modify the electron transfer reactions at center N to various extents. The pre-steady reduction kinetics suggest that these mutations alter the binding of quinone ligands at center N, possibly by widening the binding pocket and thus increasing the distance between the substrate and the bH heme. These results show that one can distinguish between the contribution of structural and thermodynamic factors to center N function.     

Tuning of Hemes b Equilibrium Redox Potential Is Not Required for Cross-Membrane Electron Transfer

In biological energy conversion, cross-membrane electron transfer often involves an assembly of two hemes b. The hemes display a large difference in redox midpoint potentials (ΔE_{m_}b), which in several proteins is assumed to facilitate cross-membrane electron transfer and overcome a barrier of membrane potential. Here we challenge this assumption reporting on heme b ligand mutants of cytochrome bc₁ in which, for the first time in transmembrane cytochrome, one natural histidine has been replaced by lysine without loss of the native low spin type of heme iron. With these mutants we show that ΔE_{m_}b can be markedly increased, and the redox potential of one of the hemes can stay above the level of quinone pool, or ΔE_{m_}b can be markedly decreased to the point that two hemes are almost isopotential, yet the enzyme retains catalytically competent electron transfer between quinone binding sites and remains functional in vivo. This reveals that cytochrome bc₁ can accommodate large changes in ΔE_{m_}b without hampering catalysis, as long as these changes do not impose overly endergonic steps on downhill electron transfer from substrate to product. We propose that hemes b in this cytochrome and in other membranous cytochromes b act as electronic connectors for the catalytic sites with no fine tuning in ΔE_{m_}b required for efficient cross-membrane electron transfer. We link this concept with a natural flexibility in occurrence of several thermodynamic configurations of the direction of electron flow and the direction of the gradient of potential in relation to the vector of the electric membrane potential.     

Oxygen dependent electron transfer in the cytochrome bc1 complex

The effect of molecular oxygen on the electron transfer activity of the cytochrome bc₁ complex was investigated by determining the activity of the complex under the aerobic and anaerobic conditions. Molecular oxygen increases the activity of Rhodobacter sphaeroides bc₁ complex up to 82%, depending on the intactness of the complex. Since oxygen enhances the reduction rate of heme b_L, but shows no effect on the reduction rate of heme b_H, the effect of oxygen in the electron transfer sequence of the cytochrome bc₁ complex is at the step of heme b_L reduction during bifurcated oxidation of ubiquinol.     

Monitoring the redox and protonation dependent contributions of cardiolipin in electrochemically induced FTIR difference spectra of the cytochrome bc1 complex from yeast

Biochemical studies have shown that cardiolipin is essential for the integrity and activity of the cytochrome bc₁ complex and many other membrane proteins. Recently the direct involvement of a bound cardiolipin molecule (CL) for proton uptake at center N, the site of quinone reduction, was suggested on the basis of a crystallographic study. In the study presented here, we probe the low frequency infrared spectroscopy region as a technique suitable to detect the involvement of the lipids in redox induced reactions of the protein. First the individual infrared spectroscopic features of lipids, typically present in the yeast membrane, have been monitored for different pH values in micelles and vesicles. The pK_a values for cardiolipin molecule have been observed at 4.7 ± 0.3 and 7.9 ± 1.3, respectively. Lipid contributions in the electrochemically induced FTIR spectra of the bc₁ complex from yeast have been identified by comparing the spectra of the as isolated form, with samples where the lipids were digested by lipase-A₂. Overall, a noteworthy perturbation in the spectral region typical for the protein backbone can be reported. Interestingly, signals at 1159, 1113, 1039 and 980 cm^− 1 have shifted, indicating the perturbation of the protonation state of cardiolipin coupled to the reduction of the hemes. Additional shifts are found and are proposed to reflect lipids reorganizing due to a change in their direct environment upon the redox reaction of the hemes. In addition a small shift in the alpha band from 559 to 556 nm can be seen after lipid depletion, reflecting the interaction with heme b_H and heme c. Thus, our work highlights the role of lipids in enzyme reactivity and structure.     

Rapid electron transfer between monomers when the cytochrome bc1 complex dimer is reduced through center N

We have obtained evidence for electron transfer between cytochrome b subunits of the yeast bc(1) complex dimer by analyzing pre-steady state reduction of cytochrome b in the presence of center P inhibitors. The kinetics and extent of cytochrome b reduced by quinol in the presence of variable concentrations of antimycin decreased non-linearly and could only be fitted to a model in which electrons entering through one center N can equilibrate between the two cytochrome b subunits of the bc(1) complex dimer. The b(H) heme absorbance in a bc(1) complex inhibited at center P and preincubated with substoichiometric concentrations of antimycin showed a red shift upon the addition of substrate, which indicates that electrons from the uninhibited center N in one monomer are able to reach the b(H) heme at the antimycin-blocked site in the other. The extent of cytochrome b reduction by variable concentrations of menaquinol could only be fitted to a kinetic model that assumes electron equilibration between center N sites in the dimer. Kinetic simulations showed that non-rate-limiting electron equilibration between the two b(H) hemes in the dimer through the two b(L) hemes is possible upon reduction through one center N despite the thermodynamically unfavorable b(H) to b(L) electron transfer step. We propose that electron transfer between cytochrome b subunits minimizes the formation of semiquinone-ferrocytochrome b(H) complexes at center N and favors ubiquinol oxidation at center P by increasing the amount of oxidized cytochrome b.     

Traffic within the Cytochrome b6f Lipoprotein Complex: Gating of the Quinone Portal

The cytochrome bc complexes b₆f and bc₁ catalyze proton-coupled quinol/quinone redox reactions to generate a transmembrane proton electrochemical gradient. Quinol oxidation on the electrochemically positive (p) interface of the complex occurs at the end of a narrow quinol/quinone entry/exit Q_p portal, 11 Å long in bc complexes. Superoxide, which has multiple signaling functions, is a by-product of the p-side quinol oxidation. Although the transmembrane core and the chemistry of quinone redox reactions are conserved in bc complexes, the rate of superoxide generation is an order of magnitude greater in the b₆f complex, implying that functionally significant differences in structure exist between the b₆f and bc₁ complexes on the p-side. A unique structure feature of the b₆f p-side quinol oxidation site is the presence of a single chlorophyll-a molecule whose function is unrelated to light harvesting. This study describes a cocrystal structure of the cytochrome b₆f complex with the quinol analog stigmatellin, which partitions in the Q_p portal of the bc₁ complex, but not effectively in b₆f. It is inferred that the Q_p portal is partially occluded in the b₆f complex relative to bc₁. Based on a discrete molecular-dynamics analysis, occlusion of the Q_p portal is attributed to the presence of the chlorophyll phytyl tail, which increases the quinone residence time within the Q_p portal and is inferred to be a cause of enhanced superoxide production. This study attributes a novel (to our knowledge), structure-linked function to the otherwise enigmatic chlorophyll-a in the b₆f complex, which may also be relevant to intracellular redox signaling.     

Traffic within the Cytochrome b6f Lipoprotein Complex: Gating of the Quinone Portal

The cytochrome bc complexes b₆f and bc₁ catalyze proton-coupled quinol/quinone redox reactions to generate a transmembrane proton electrochemical gradient. Quinol oxidation on the electrochemically positive (p) interface of the complex occurs at the end of a narrow quinol/quinone entry/exit Q_p portal, 11 Å long in bc complexes. Superoxide, which has multiple signaling functions, is a by-product of the p-side quinol oxidation. Although the transmembrane core and the chemistry of quinone redox reactions are conserved in bc complexes, the rate of superoxide generation is an order of magnitude greater in the b₆f complex, implying that functionally significant differences in structure exist between the b₆f and bc₁ complexes on the p-side. A unique structure feature of the b₆f p-side quinol oxidation site is the presence of a single chlorophyll-a molecule whose function is unrelated to light harvesting. This study describes a cocrystal structure of the cytochrome b₆f complex with the quinol analog stigmatellin, which partitions in the Q_p portal of the bc₁ complex, but not effectively in b₆f. It is inferred that the Q_p portal is partially occluded in the b₆f complex relative to bc₁. Based on a discrete molecular-dynamics analysis, occlusion of the Q_p portal is attributed to the presence of the chlorophyll phytyl tail, which increases the quinone residence time within the Q_p portal and is inferred to be a cause of enhanced superoxide production. This study attributes a novel (to our knowledge), structure-linked function to the otherwise enigmatic chlorophyll-a in the b₆f complex, which may also be relevant to intracellular redox signaling.     

Flash-induced turnover of the cytochrome bc1 complex in chromatophores of Rhodobacter capsulatus: binding of Zn decelerates likewise the oxidation of cytochrome b, the reduction of cytochrome c1 and the voltage generation

The effect of Zn²⁺ on the rates of electron transfer and of voltage generation in the cytochrome bc₁ complex (bc₁) was investigated under excitation of Rhodobacter capsulatus chromatophores with flashing light. When added, Zn²⁺ retarded the oxidation of cytochrome b and allowed to monitor (at 561-570 nm) the reduction of its high potential heme b_h (in the absence of Zn²⁺ this reaction was masked by the fast re-oxidation of the heme). The effect was accompanied by the deceleration of both the cytochrome c₁ reduction (as monitored at 552-570 nm) and the generation of transmembrane voltage (monitored by electrochromism at 522 nm). At Zn²⁺ <100 μM the reduction of heme b_h remained 10 times faster than other reactions. The kinetic discrepancy was observed even after an attenuated flash, when bc₁ turned over only once. These observations (1) raise doubt on the notion that the transmembrane electron transfer towards heme b_h is the main electrogenic reaction in the cytochrome bc₁ complex, (2) imply an allosteric link between the site of heme b_h oxidation and the site of cytochrome c₁ reduction at the opposite side of the membrane, and (3) indicate that the internal redistribution of protons might account for the voltage generation by the cytochrome bc₁ complex.     

The cytochrome ba complex from the thermoacidophilic crenarchaeote Acidianus ambivalens is an analog of bc1 complexes

A novel cytochrome ba complex was isolated from aerobically grown cells of the thermoacidophilic archaeon Acidianus ambivalens. The complex was purified with two subunits, which are encoded by the cbsA and soxN genes. These genes are part of the pentacistronic cbsAB-soxLN-odsN locus. The spectroscopic characterization revealed the presence of three low-spin hemes, two of the b and one of the a_s-type with reduction potentials of + 200, + 400 and + 160 mV, respectively. The SoxN protein is proposed to harbor the heme b of lower reduction potential and the heme a_s, and CbsA the other heme b. The soxL gene encodes a Rieske protein, which was expressed in E. coli; its reduction potential was determined to be + 320 mV. Topology predictions showed that SoxN, CbsB and CbsA should contain 12, 9 and one transmembrane α-helices, respectively, with SoxN having a predicted fold very similar to those of the cytochromes b in bc₁ complexes. The presence of two quinol binding motifs was also predicted in SoxN. Based on these findings, we propose that the A. ambivalens cytochrome ba complex is analogous to the bc₁ complexes of bacteria and mitochondria, however with distinct subunits and heme types.     

Regulatory interactions in the dimeric cytochrome bc(1) complex: the advantages of being a twin

The dimeric cytochrome bc(1) complex catalyzes the oxidation-reduction of quinol and quinone at sites located in opposite sides of the membrane in which it resides. We review the kinetics of electron transfer and inhibitor binding that reveal functional interactions between the quinol oxidation site at center P and quinone reduction site at center N in opposite monomers in conjunction with electron equilibration between the cytochrome b subunits of the dimer. A model for the mechanism of the bc(1) complex has emerged from these studies in which binding of ligands that mimic semiquinone at center N regulates half-of-the-sites reactivity at center P and binding of ligands that mimic catalytically competent binding of ubiquinol at center P regulates half-of-the-sites reactivity at center N. An additional feature of this model is that inhibition of quinol oxidation at the quinone reduction site is avoided by allowing catalysis in only one monomer at a time, which maximizes the number of redox acceptor centers available in cytochrome b for electrons coming from quinol oxidation reactions at center P and minimizes the leakage of electrons that would result in the generation of damaging oxygen radicals.     

Superoxide anion generation by the cytochrome bc1 complex

We have measured the rates of superoxide anion generation by cytochrome bc₁ complexes isolated from bovine heart and yeast mitochondria and by cytochrome bc₁ complexes from yeast mutants in which the midpoint potentials of the cytochrome b hemes and the Rieske iron-sulfur cluster were altered by mutations in those proteins. With all of the bc₁ complexes the rate of superoxide anion production was greatest in the absence of bc₁ inhibitor and ranged from 3% to 5% of the rate of cytochrome c reduction. Stigmatellin, an inhibitor that binds to the ubiquinol oxidation site in the bc₁ complex, eliminated superoxide anion formation, while myxothiazol, another inhibitor of ubiquinol oxidation, allowed superoxide anion formation at a low rate. Antimycin, an inhibitor that binds to the ubiquinone reduction site in the bc₁ complex, also allowed superoxide anion formation and at a slightly greater rate than myxothiazol. Changes in the midpoint potentials of the cytochrome b hemes had no significant effect on the rate of cytochrome c reduction and only a small effect on the rate of superoxide anion formation. A mutation in the Rieske iron-sulfur protein that lowers its midpoint potential from +285 to +220 mV caused the rate of superoxide anion to decline in parallel with a decline in cytochrome c reductase activity. These results indicate that superoxide anion is formed by similar mechanisms in mammalian and yeast bc₁ complexes. The results also show that changes in the midpoint potentials of the redox components that accept electrons during ubiquinol oxidation have only small effects on the formation of superoxide anion, except to the extent that they affect the activity of the enzyme.     

Domain conformational switch of the iron–sulfur protein in cytochrome bc1 complex is induced by the electron transfer from cytochrome bL to bH

Intensive biochemical, biophysical and structural studies of the cytochrome (cyt) bc₁ complex in the past have led to the formulation of the “protonmotive Q-cycle” mechanism for electron and proton transfer in this vitally important complex. The key step of this mechanism is the separation of electrons during the oxidation of a substrate quinol at the Q_P site with both electrons transferred simultaneously to ISP and cyt b_L when the extrinsic domain of ISP (ISP-ED) is located at the b-position. Pre-steady state fast kinetic analysis of bc₁ demonstrates that the reduced ISP-ED moves to the c₁-position to reduce cyt c₁ only after the reduced cyt b_L is oxidized by cyt b_H. However, the question of how the conformational switch of ISP-ED is initiated remains unanswered. The results obtained from analysis of inhibitory efficacy and binding affinity of two types of Q_P site inhibitors, Pm and Pf, under various redox states of the bc₁ complex, suggest that the electron transfer from heme b_L to b_H is the driving force for the releasing of the reduced ISP-ED from the b-position to c₁-position to reduce cyt c₁.     

Reaction center and UQH2:cytc 2 oxidoreductase act as independent enzymes inRps. sphaeroides

Turnover of the ubiquinol oxidizing site of the UQH₂:cyt c₂ oxidoreductase (b/c ₁ complex) ofRps. sphaeroides can be assayed by measuring the rate of reduction of cytb ₅₆₁ in the presence of antimycin (AA). Oxidation of ubiquinol is a second-order process, with a value ofk ₂ of about 3 × 10⁵ M^–1. The reaction shows saturation at high quinol concentrations, with an apparentK _m of about 6–8 mM (with respect to the concentration of quinol in the membrane). When the quinone pool is oxidized before illumination, reduction of the complex shows a substantial lag (about 1 ms) after a flash, indicating that the quinol produced as a result of the photochemical reactions is not immediately available to the complex. We have suggested that the lag may be due to several factors, including the leaving time of the quinol from the reaction center, the diffusion time to the complex, and the time for the head group to cross the membrane. We have suggested aminimal value for the diffusion coefficient of ubiquinone in the membrane (assuming that the lag is due entirely to diffusion) of about 10^–9 cm^–2 sec^–1. The lag is reduced to about 100 µsec when the pool is significantly reduced, showing that quinol from the pool is more rapidly available to the complex than that from the reaction center. With the pool oxidized, similar kinetics are seen when the reduction of cytb ₅₆₁ occurs through the AA-sensitive site (with reactions at the quinol oxidizing site blocked by myxothiazol). These results show that there is no preferential reaction pathway for transfer of reducing equivalents from reaction center tob/c ₁ complex. Oxidation of cytb ₅₆₁ through the AA-sensitive site can be assayed from the slow phase of the carotenoid electrochromic change, and by comparison with the kinetics of cytb ₅₆₁. As long as the quinone pool is significantly oxidized, the reaction is not rate-determining for the electrogenic process. On reduction of the pool below 1 quinone per complex, a slowing of the electrogenic process occurs, which could reflect a dependence on the concentration of quinone. If the process is second-order, the rate constant must be about 2–5 times greater than that for quinol oxidation, since the effect on rate is relatively small compared with the effect seen at the quinol oxidizing site when the quinol concentration is changed over theE _h range where the first few quinols are produced on reductive titration. When the quinone pool is extracted (experiments in collaboration with G. Venturoli and B. A. Melandri), the slowing of the electrochromic change on reduction of the pool is not enhanced; we assume that this is due to the fact that a minimum of one quinone per active complex is produced by turnover of the quinol oxidizing site. Two lines of research lead us to revise our previous estimate for the minimal value of the quinone diffusion coefficient. These relate to the relation between the diffusion coefficient and the rate constants for processes involving the quinones: (a) The estimated rate constant for reaction of quinone at the AA-site approaches the calculated diffusion limited rate constant, implying an improbably efficient reaction. (b) From a preliminary set of experiments, the activation energy determined by measuring the variation of the rate constant for quinol oxidation with temperature, is about 8 kcal mol^–1. Although we do not know the contribution of entropic terms to the pre-exponential factor, the result is consistent with a considerably larger value for the diffusion coefficient than that previously suggested.     

The Rate-limiting Step in the Cytochrome bc1 Complex (Ubiquinol-Cytochrome c Oxidoreductase) Is Not Changed by Inhibition of Cytochrome b-dependent Deprotonation: IMPLICATIONS FOR THE MECHANISM OF UBIQUINOL OXIDATION AT CENTER P OF THE bc1 COMPLEX*S?

Quinol oxidation at center P of the cytochrome bc₁ complex involves bifurcated electron transfer to the Rieske iron-sulfur protein and cytochrome b. It is unknown whether both electrons are transferred from the same domain close to the Rieske protein, or if an unstable semiquinone anion intermediate diffuses rapidly to the vicinity of the b_L heme. We have determined the pre-steady state rate and activation energy (E_a) for quinol oxidation in purified yeast bc₁ complexes harboring either a Y185F mutation in the Rieske protein, which decreases the redox potential of the FeS cluster, or a E272Q cytochrome b mutation, which eliminates the proton acceptor in cytochrome b. The rate of the bifurcated reaction in the E272Q mutant (<10% of the wild type) was even lower than that of the Y185F enzyme (∼20% of the wild type). However, the E272Q enzyme showed the same E_a (61 kJ mol^-1) with respect to the wild type (62 kJ mol^-1), in contrast with the Y185F mutation, which increased E_a to 73 kJ mol^-1. The rate and E_a of the slow reaction of quinol with oxygen that are observed after cytochrome b is reduced were unaffected by the E272Q substitution, whereas the Y185F mutation modified only its rate. The Y185F/E272Q double mutation resulted in a synergistic decrease in the rate of quinol oxidation (0.7% of the wild type). These results are inconsistent with a sequential “movable semiquinone” mechanism but are consistent with a model in which both electrons are transferred simultaneously from the same domain in center P.The cytochrome bc₁ complex couples the oxidation of a two-electron carrier molecule of quinol to the movement of protons across the inner mitochondrial or bacterial membrane. The key reaction in this energy-conserving mechanism, known as the Q-cycle (1, 2), is the bifurcation of electrons at the active site located closer to the positive side of the membrane, termed center P or Q_o site. One of the electrons from quinol is transferred to a chain of one-electron carriers with relatively high redox potentials that include the FeS cluster of the Rieske protein and the hemes of cytochromes c₁ and c. The other electron is donated to the low potential (b_L) heme of cytochrome b, from which it crosses most of the membrane width to the high potential b_H heme, located close to another active site (center N or Q_i site), where quinone is reduced to quinol after two center P turnovers. Proton release and uptake at each active site are achieved by taking advantage of the chemistry of quinol and quinone, which can only stably exist at physiological pH in the protonated and deprotonated forms, respectively.Critical to the electron bifurcation reaction at center P is the arrangement of protonatable groups (His¹⁸¹ of the Rieske protein and Glu²⁷² of cytochrome b) close to the electron acceptors at opposite sides of the substrate (see Fig. 1). However, the exact mechanism of electron bifurcation at center P is still an unresolved issue. Proposed models have ranged from strictly concerted mechanisms in which both electrons from quinol are extracted simultaneously (3, 4) to those that postulate a highly stabilized semiquinone intermediate (5). Between these two extremes are mechanisms that propose the formation of an unstable semiquinone intermediate after a first electron transfer from quinol to the Rieske protein (6–8), which seem to be supported by recent reports that claim to have detected low concentrations of semiquinone at center P when reoxidation of cytochrome b is impeded under special conditions (9, 10). One version of the unstable semiquinone mechanism proposes that this intermediate diffuses from the vicinity of the Rieske protein to a location within center P located closer to the b_L heme, which would allow non-rate-limiting rates of b_L reduction to occur even at very low semiquinone occupancy (11). In this proposal, the movement of the unstable semiquinone would be allowed by protonation and rotation of Glu²⁷² in cytochrome b, which occupies different conformations in crystallographic structures (Fig. 1) (11–14).Open in a separate windowFIGURE 1.Electron and proton acceptors involved in quinol oxidation at center P. Crystallographic structures 1EZV (12) and 1P84 (13) show stigmatellin (A) or 5-n-heptyl-6-hydroxy-4,7-dioxobenzothiazole (B) bound at center P forming a hydrogen bond to the His¹⁸¹ residue of the Rieske protein, which is a ligand to the FeS cluster. The Tyr¹⁸⁵ residue in the Rieske protein influences the E_m value of the FeS cluster (22). On the side pointing to the b_L heme, a bound water molecule is also hydrogen-bonded to the inhibitor, either to the Glu²⁷² carboxylate in cytochrome b (A), or to its backbone amino group (B), when the side chain is rotated toward a water network that connects to the propionate of the b_L heme and to Arg⁷⁹ of cytochrome b.An important prediction of the movable semiquinone model (11) is that mutation of Glu²⁷² should impede diffusion of the anionic semiquinone, forcing electron transfer to the b_L heme to occur through a longer distance from the position closer to the Rieske FeS cluster (15), thereby shifting the rate-limiting step from the first to the second electron transfer. Although it has already been reported that different mutations at Glu²⁷² partially slow down quinol oxidation at center P (15–17), no effort has been made so far to evaluate whether the rate-limiting step changes upon inhibition of the deprotonation of quinol (or of a putative semiquinone intermediate) by mutation of the cytochrome b Glu²⁷². In the present work, we analyze the energy of activation of quinol oxidation at center P and show that the rate-limiting step when Glu²⁷² is mutated to glutamine, although slower, is still determined by the driving force for electron transfer to the Rieske protein. We also show that decreasing this driving force enhances the relative inhibition caused by mutating Glu²⁷², suggesting a tight coupling of reactions involved in quinol oxidation and deprotonation. In contrast, reactions with oxygen that bypass the electron bifurcation at center P, which are likely to involve a semiquinone intermediate, are independent of Glu²⁷² and go through an energetic barrier different from that of the bifurcated reaction. We discuss how these results support a mechanism in which both electron transfer events from quinol to the Rieske protein and the b_L heme occur from the same position and at the same time.     

Cytochrome b oxidation and reduction reactions in the ubiquinone-cytochrome b/c2 oxidoreductase from Rhodopseudomonas Sphaeroides

1. The kinetics of cytochrome b reduction and oxidation in the ubiquinone-cytochrome b/c₂ oxidoreductase of chromatophores from Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides Ga have been measured both in the presence and absence of anti-mycin, after subtraction of contributions due to absorption changes from cytochrome c₂, the oxidized bacteriochlorophyll dimer of the reaction center, and a red shift of the antenna bacteriochlorophyll.2. A small red shift of the antenna bacteriochlorophyll band centered at 589 nm has been identified and found to be kinetically similar to the carotenoid bandshift.3. Antimycin inhibits the oxidation of ferrocytochrome b under all conditions; it also stimulates the amount of single flash activated cytochrome b reduction 3- to 4-fold under certain if not all conditions.4. A maximum of approximately 0.6 cytochrome b-560 (E_m(7) = 50 mV, n = 1, previously cytochrome b₅₀) hemes per reaction center are reduced following activating flashes. This ratio suggests that there is one cytochrome b-560 heme functional per ubiquinone-cytochrome b/c₂ oxidoreductase.5. Under the experimental conditions used here, only cytochrome b-560 is observed functional in cyclic electron transfer.6. We describe the existence of three distinct states of reduction of the ubiquinone-cytochrome b/c₂ oxidoreductase which can be established before activation, and result in markedly different reaction sequences involving cytochrome b after the flash activation. Poising such that the special ubiquinone (Q_z) is reduced and cytochrome b-560 is oxidized yields the conditions for optimal flash activated electron transfer rates through the ubiquinone-cytochrome b/c₂ oxidoreductase. However when the ambient redox state is lowered to reduce cytochrome b-560 or raised to oxidize Q_z, single turnover flash induced electron transfer through the ubiquinone-cytochrome b/c₂ oxidoreductase appears impeded; the points of the impediment are tentatively identified with the electron transfer step from the reduced secondary quinone (Q_II) of the reaction center to ferricytochrome b-560 and from the ferrocytochrome b-560 to oxidized Q_z, respectively.