γδ T-cell receptor repertoire in human peripheral blood and thymus

T-cell clones expressing the T-cell receptor (Tcr) were generated from peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) and from a thymus sample. In the panel of ten thymus-derived clones, four Tcr phenotypes [as defined by the reaction of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) directed against known V and V regions] were identified. All the clones lacked expression of the V3 V region, while seven clones were V1+ . V1 was found in combination with V9 or with undefined VVregions. In addition, two other Tcr phenotypes were identified on these clones: V9⁺ V1^– V3^– and V9^– V1^– V3^– One of the clones expressed CD4 and another was CD8positive. The remaining clones were CD4^– CD8^–. In the panel of 76 PBL-derived, Tcr-bearing clones, five Tcr phenotypes could be identified. In contrast to the thymus-derived clones, 30% of the clones were V3⁺ whereas V1 was expressed by a minority of the clones only. One clone was CD4-positive and approximately 30% of the clones were CD8-positive. Four of the five mAb-defined Tcr phenotypes could be identified on both thymus and PBL-derived T-cell clones. However, biochemical analysis of the Tcrs demonstrates differences in the usage of Ct- and C2-encoded y chains by T cells derived from the thymus and PBLs. The results therefore indicate that, at the clonal level, similarities and differences exist between the Tcr repertoires expressed in the thymus and by PBLs. Furthermore, they indicate that combinatorial Tcr heterogeneity is larger than has so far been described. The receptor diversity, combined with the potential of Tcr+ cells to express CD4 or CD8, indicates that these cells are a heterogeneous population that might mediate a number of immune functions.     

Transformation of pecan and regeneration of transgenic plants

A gene transfer system developed for walnut (Juglans regia L.) was successfully applied to pecan (Carya illinoensis [Wang] K. Koch). Repetitively embryogenic somatic embryos derived from open-pollinated seed of Elliott, Wichita, and Schley were co-cultivated with Agrobacterium strain EHA 101/pCGN 7001, which contains marker genes for beta-glucuronidase activity and resistance to kanamycin. Several modifications of the standard walnut transformation techniques were tested, including a lower concentration of kanamycin and a modified induction medium, but these treatments had no measurable effect on efficiency of transformation. Nineteen of the 764 viable inoculated embryos produced transgenic subclones; 13 of these were from the line Elliott6, 3 from Schley5/3, and 3 from Wichita9. Transgenic embryos of Wichita9 germinated most readily and three subclones were successfully micropropagated. Three transgenic plants of one of these subclones were obtained by grafting the tissue cultured shoots to seedling pecan rootstock in the greenhouse. Gene insertion, initially detected by GUS activity, was confirmed by detection of integrated T-DNA sequences using Southern analysis.     

Evaluation of structural and physiological plant characteristics in relation to the distribution of cadmium in maize inbred lines

To establish the structural and physiological characteristics related to the genotypic variation in Cd distribution between maize inbred lines (shoot Cd excluders and non-shoot Cd excluders), shoot and root morphological parameters were studied on plants grown in nutrient solution. Furthermore, the xylem sap composition and the desorbability of Cd from roots of these inbreds have been compared. No relationship between the morphological characteristics of either shoot (specific leaf area and leaf area ratio) or root (specific root length, specific surface area, and average diameter) and Cd distribution could be assessed. Cadmium concentrations in the xylem exudates from non-shoot Cd excluders were higher than those from shoot Cd excluders, but not related to citrate and malate concentrations. The absolute and relative amounts of Cd desorbed from roots of shoot Cd excluders were about twice as high compared to those of the non-shoot Cd excluders, especially at the lowest Cd concentration in solution. The absence of a relationship between shoot or root morphological parameters and Cd partitioning and the differences between both groups in the amounts of Cd desorbed, even at similar root Cd concentrations, indicate that the differential Cd distribution between shoot Cd excluders and non-shoot Cd excluders may be related to the observed differences in root Cd concentration, desorption characteristics and binding capacity of Cd inside and/or outside the root and its distribution within the roots.     

Distribution and composition of particulate organic matter in the Ross Sea (Antarctica)

The biochemical composition and spatial distribution of particulate organic matter (POM) were studied in the Ross Sea (Antarctica) in summer 1989 to assess the quantitative role of organic carbon fractions in the cycling of organic matter in the water column. Large differences in chemical composition were observed between surface and deep layers. The results indicated that, despite large geographical differences, POM was quite homogeneous, of phytoplankton origin and mostly detrital. Different ratios were used to investigate the changes in biochemical composition of particulate organic matter in relation to the ice-melting: CN (organic carbonorganic nitrogen ratio) and C-POMPOC (sum of carbohydrate, protein and lipid carbontotal organic carbon ratio) were used to analyse the percentage of refractory organic material. PPRTPCHO (proteincarbohydrate ratio) were used to establish POM age and RNADNA ratios as a relative measure of particulate activity; POCChl a and N-PPRTChl a ratios were used to estimate the autotrophic contribution to the suspended particulate organic matter. Despite its low caloric value (5.3 Kcal g POM^–1), an high caloric content in the photic layer (1.6 Kcal m^–3 of POM and 2.5 Kcal m^–3 of POC) was found thus indicating that a large amount of food was available to higher trophic levels.     

Plastid Sequence Evolution: A New Pattern of Nucleotide Substitutions in the Cucurbitaceae

Nucleotide substitutions (i.e., point mutations) are the primary driving force in generating DNA variation upon which selection can act. Substitutions called transitions, which entail exchanges between purines (A=adenine, G=guanine) or pyrimidines (C=cytosine, T=thymine), typically outnumber transversions (e.g., exchanges between a purine and a pyrimidine) in a DNA strand. With an increasing number of plant studies revealing a transversion rather than transition bias, we chose to perform a detailed substitution analysis for the plant family Cucurbitaceae using data from several short plastid DNA sequences. We generated a phylogenetic tree for 19 taxa of the tribe Benincaseae and related genera and then scored conservative substitution changes (e.g., those not exhibiting homoplasy or reversals) from the unambiguous branches of the tree. Neither the transition nor (A+T)/(G+C) biases found in previous studies were supported by our overall data. More importantly, we found a novel and symmetrical substitution bias in which Gs had been preferentially replaced by A, As by C, Cs by T, and Ts by G, resulting in the GACTG substitution series. Understanding this pattern will lead to new hypotheses concerning plastid evolution, which in turn will affect the choices of substitution models and other tree-building algorithms for phylogenetic analyses based on nucleotide data.     

Indirect effect of salmon carcasses on growth of a freshwater amphipod, <Emphasis Type="Italic">Jesogammarus jesoensis</Emphasis> (Gammaridea): An experimental study

The effect of salmon carcasses on the growth of a freshwater amphipod, Jesogammarus jesoensis (Schellenberg) (Gammaridea, Anisogammaridae), was examined experimentally. Growth rate was determined by rearing juvenile amphipods in four food treatments (leaves, salmon, leaves and salmon and leaves with salmon leachate) for 20days. Mass loss and oxygen consumption of the leaves were also measured in the three treatments with leaves. The oxygen consumption rate of leaves was lower in the leaves treatment than in either the leaves and salmon or leaves with salmon leachate treatments, indicating that microbial activity on leaves was enhanced by the presence of salmon carcasses. Mass loss of leaves did not differ between the three treatments with leaves. The growth rate of the amphipods did not differ between the leaves and salmon treatments, or between the leaves and salmon and leaves with salmon leachate treatments. Growth rates in the two latter treatments were higher than rates in the leaves treatment, but not higher than the rates in the salmon treatment. Therefore, it appears likely that consuming leaves fertilized with nutrients from salmon carcasses facilitates growth in this amphipod.     

The effect of leaf source and developmental stage on shoot organogenic potential of sweetgum (Liquidambar styraciflua L.) leaf explants

Leaf explants harvested from shoot proliferating cultures and intact plants of Liquidambar styraciflua Variegata were placed on solidified Woody Plant medium supplemented with 0.1 mgl^-1 (0.5 M) naphthaleneacetic acid and 2.5 mgl^-1 (11.1 M) benzyladenine to initiate shoot meristems directly. Leaves from intact plants produced over 4 times more adventitious shoots than leaves from in vitro shoots and had a greater tendency to form shoots on the lamina. The relative developmental age of leaf tissue used dramatically influenced the shoot organogenic response observed for leaf explants from intact plants of L. styraciflua Variegata and Moraine.-Leaves that were either 20% or 50% of full size and still actively expanding were superior to other developmental stages for shoot organogenesis. As developmental leaf age increased throughout the period of leaf expansion, the number of shoots forming on the petiole stub remained constant, whereas shoot formation on the lamina increased 8 fold. Shoots derived from Variegata leaves rooted well and grew normally as plants. Differences in rooting ability and plant size could be detected between groups that had been separated according to explant source (in vitro vs. intact plant) and the location of shoot formation (petiole vs. lamina).     

Intracellular sites of the synthesis of sweet potato mitochondrial F1ATPase subunits

Summary Five subunits (-, -, -, - and -subunits) of the six -and -subunits) in the F₁ portion (F₁ATPase) of sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas) mitochondrial adenosine triphosphatase were isolated by an electrophoretic method. The - and -subunits were not distinguishable immunologically but showed completely different tryptic peptide maps, indicating that they were different molecular species. In vitro protein synthesis with isolated sweet potato root mitochondria produced only the -subunit when analyzed with anti-sweet potato F₁ATPase antibody reacting with all the subunits except the -subunit. Sweet potato root poly(A)⁺RNA directed the synthesis of six polypeptides which were immunoprecipitated by the antibody: two of them immunologically related to the -subunit and the others to the - and -subunits. We conclude that the -subunit of the F₁ATPase is synthesized only in the mitochondria and the -, - and -subunits are in the cytoplasm.     

Fever and feeding: Differential actions of macrophage inflammatory protein-1 (MIP-1), MIP-1α and MIP-1β on rat hypothalamus

Changes in body temperature (T_b) and feeding were characterized in unrestrained rats following the micro-injection into the anterior hypothalamic preoptic area (AH/POA) of macrophage inflammatory protein-1 (MIP-1), MIP-1 or MIP-1. After the rats recovered from the stereotaxic implantation of a single guide tube placed in the AH/POA, either one of the MIP-1 compounds or control CSF was micro-injected in a volume of 1.0 l into this area. Changes in body temperature (T_b) and food and water intakes were monitored throughout each experiment. When micro-injected into the AH/POA in a dose of 28 or 280 pg, doublet MIP-1 and MIP-1 evoked a monophasic fever which increased above baseline to a mean maximum of 2.17±0.14°C and 2.1±0.24°C, respectively. MIP-1 micro-injected similarly evoked a biphasic fever, with the T_b declining transiently at the 30 min point 0.4°C lower than the congruent rises in T_b evoked by doublet MIP-1 or MIP-1. The secondary rise in T_b induced by MIP-1 had a latency of 1.5–2.0 hrs and reached a maximum of 1.56±0.16°C. Although all three cytokines significantly attentuated the rats' mean intake of food during the 24 hr interval after their micro-injection into the AH/POA, doublet MIP-1 exerted the most potent anorexic effect in comparison to that of the saline control rats. However, neither body weight nor intake of water was altered significantly by the three cytokines. These results demonstrate a functional distinction between the febrile actions of MIP-1 and MIP-1 on cells of the AH/POA. It is envisaged that MIP-1 underlies the initial phase of a pyrogen-induced fever, whereas MIP-1 could mediate the secondary phase of a biphasic fever. Clearly, the localized elevation of either MIP-1 or MIP-1 in the AH/POA perturbs the neuronal mechanism underlying the set-point for body temperature. Thus, both MIP-1 and MIP-1 could play a functional role in the pathological events occurring in neurons of the AH/POA in response to an endotoxin or other pyrogen challenge.     

Selectivity of ATP-activated GTP-dependent Ca2+-permeable channels in rat macrophage plasma membrane

Outside-out configuration of the patch clamp technique was used to test whether an intracellular application of G protein activator (GTPS) affects ATP-activated Ca²⁺-permeable channels in rat macrophages without any agonist in the bath solution. With 145 mm K⁺ (pCa 8.0) in the pipette solution, activity of channels permeable to a variety of divalent cations and Na⁺ was observed and general channel characteristics were found to be identical to those of ATP-activated ones. Absence of extracellular ATP makes it possible to avoid the influence of ATP receptor desensitization and to study the channel selectivity using a number of divalent cations (105 mm) and Na⁺ (145 mm) as the charge carriers. Permeability sequence estimated by extrapolated reversal potential measurements was: Ca²⁺ Ba²⁺ Mn²⁺ Sr²⁺ Na⁺ K⁺ = 68 30 26 10 3.5 1. Slope conductances (in pS) for permeant ions rank as follows: Ca²⁺ Sr²⁺ Na⁺ Mn²⁺ Ba²⁺ = 19 18 14 12 10. Unitary Ca²⁺ currents display a tendency to saturate with the Ca²⁺ concentration increase with apparent dissociation constant (K _d ) of 10 mm. No block of Na⁺ permeation by extracellular Ca²⁺ in millimolar range was found. The data obtained suggest that (i) activation of some G protein is sufficient to gate the channels without the ATP receptor being occupied, (ii) the ATP receptor activation results in the gating of a special channel with the properties that differ markedly from those of the receptoroperated or voltage-gated Ca²⁺-permeable channels on the other cell types.DeceasedThe authors are grateful to K. Kiselyov and A. Mamin for technical assistance. The work was supported by the Russian Basic Research Foundation, Grant N 93-04-21722 and was made possible in part by Grant N R4A000 from the International Science Foundation.     

Sources and inheritance of resistance to leaf curl virus in Lycopersicon

Summary One hundred and twenty-two varieties, lines and wild accessions of Lycopersicon were screened under three different regimes during the autumn/winter season of 1982–83 and 1983–84 for resistance to tomato leaf curl virus (TLCV). L. hirsutum f. glabratum (B6013) and L. hirsutum f. typicum (A1904) proved to be highly resistant to TLCV in all three environments. Various accessions of L. peruvianum were also highly resistant. L. pimpinellifolium (A1921) exhibited no TLCV symptoms within 90 days. Of the cultivated varieties, Acc 99 exhibited the minimim score for susceptibility; AC 142, Collection No. 2, Kalyanpur Angurlata and HS 101 had a low rating for virus incidence. The inheritance of resistance was studied in the interspecific crosses between a TLCV resistant line of L. pimpinellifolium (A1921) and five (HS 101, HS 102, HS 110, Pusa Ruby and Punjab Chhuhara) susceptible cultivars of L. esculentum. Parents, F₁, F₂ and backcross progenies were artificially inoculated with local strains of TLCV using vector the viruliferious whitefly, Bemisia tabaci (Genn.). Data indicated that the resistance of L. pimpinellifolium (A 1921) is monogenic and incompletely dominant over susceptibility.     

Genetic analysis of two wheat cultivars, ‘Sonalika’ and ‘WL 711’ for reaction to leaf rust (Puccinia recondita)

Summary Genetic analysis for leaf rust reaction of two widely adapted cultivars, Sonalika and WL 711, has been done using 21 near isogenic Lr lines and rust culture IL004 — avirulent on the two cultivars and all the Lr lines used. The segregation pattern in the F₂ generation indicated the presence of a recessive gene in Sonalika and of a dominant gene in WL 711. These genes in cultivars Sonalika and WL 711 have been identified as Lr 11 and Lr 13, respectively. Gene Lr 13 is no longer effective in WL 711 but it continues to give field resistance in the backgrounds of Chris, Prelude and Thatcher. There has been no significant change in the virulence spectrum of the leaf rust pathogen in India with the release of WL 711. High susceptibility of WL 711 seems to be due to the evolution of more aggressive forms of the pathogen to this cultivar. The gene Lr 11, which behaves as a recessive in Sonalika, was effective against leaf rust when this cultivar was released. The high susceptibility of Sonalika is probably due to an increase in the frequency of race 77 virulent on Lr 11. Lr 11 has shown a dominance reversal in the background of Sonalika. Present results suggest that interaction of resistance genes with the background genotype must be studied for their effective use in breeding programme.     

A simple method for maintaining high multiplication of Narcissus shoot cultures in vitro

A simple method for stimulating and maintaining high in vitro multiplication of Narcissus shoot clump cultures was developed. Shoot clumps were subjected either to normal cutting where leaves were trimmed to 20 mm in length at the beginning of each culture passage or to severe cutting where shoot clumps were cut down to the basal plate region removing all green tissue. Severe cutting at the beginning of each culture passage initially doubled the leaf multiplication, compared to normal cutting, but the difference between cutting treatments declined in successive passages. The improvement in leaf multiplication was maintained when shoot clumps were subjected to severe cutting only at every other culture passage, with no cutting in the alternate recovery passages. In vitro multiplication was increased by severe cutting in all seven Narcissus cultivars which were tested.Abbreviations NAA-1 naphthylacetic acid - BAP benzylaminopurine     

C-Terminal exchange between Gα o and Gα i3 proteins differently modulates α2A-adrenoceptor activation

Chimeric G proteins, obtained by exchanging their C-terminal portion for that of a G protein from an unrelated class, drive the receptor selectivity to that corresponding to the introduced G protein domain. The _2A-adrenoceptor (_2AAR), which yielded an efficacious and weak [³⁵S]GTPS binding response by respectively G _o and G _i3 protein, was investigated in CHO-K1 cells co-expressing chimeric G proteins for which the six last C-terminal amino acids between G _o and G _i3 proteins, and reciprocally, were permuted. Activation of the chimeric G _{o / i3} protein was highly efficient whereas the G _{i3 / o} protein yielded a weak stimulation. These [³⁵S]GTPS binding responses were not different from their parental wild-type G _o and G _i3 proteins. Similar results were obtained with an _2AAR carrying a facilitating Thr³⁷³Lys mutation in a putative G protein interaction domain. These data indicate that the six terminal G _o protein amino acids do not constitute a major _2AAR interaction domain for G protein activation.     

The solution structure of rat Aβ-(1–28) and its interaction with zinc ion: insights into the scarcity of amyloid deposition in aged rat brain

The amyloid -peptide (A) is a major component of insoluble amyloid deposits in Alzheimers disease, and the ability of the -peptide to exist in different conformations is dependent on residues 1–28 [-(1–28)]. However, different from humans, no A amyloid deposition has been found in aged rats brains. Studying the three-dimensional solution structure of rat A-(1–28) and the binding circumstance of Zn²⁺ is beneficial to a clear understanding of the potential role of Zn²⁺ in Alzheimer-associated neuropathogenesis and to suggest why there is no amyloid deposition in aged rats brains. Here we used nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy to determine the solution structure of rat A-(1–28) and the binding constant of Zn²⁺ to rat A-(1–28). Our results suggest that (1) the three-dimensional solution structure of rat A-(1–28) is more stable than that of human A-(1–28) in DMSO-d₆ and that a helical region from Glu16 to Val24 exists in the rat A-(1–28); (2) the affinity of Zn²⁺ for rat A-(1–28) is lower than that for human A-(1–28) and the NMR data suggest that Arg13, His6, and His14 residues provide the primary binding sites for Zn²⁺; and (3) the proper binding of Zn²⁺ to rat A-(1–28) can induce the peptide to change to a more stable conformation.Electronic Supplementary Material Supplementary material is available in the online version of this article at http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00775-004-0556-xAbbreviations A amyloid -peptide - AD Alzheimers disease - hA-(1–28) human A-(1–28) - rA-(1-28) rat A-(1–28) - REM restrained energy minimization     

High crossability of wild barley (Hordeum spontaneum C. Koch) with bread wheat and the differential elimination of barley chromosomes in the hybrids

Four bread wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) cultivars, Aobakomugi, Chinese Spring, Norin 61 and Shinchunaga, were pollinated with five barley lines/cultivars consisting of three cultivated barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) lines, Betzes, Kinai 5 and OHL089, and two wild barley (Hordeum spontaneum C. Koch) lines, OUH602 and OUH324. Crossability, expressed as the percentage of embryo formation, varied from 0 to 55.4% among the cross combinations. The two wild barley lines generally had a higher crossability than the previously reported best pollinator, Betzes, and some Japanese wheat cultivars were better as the female parent than Chinese Spring. Ninety four hybrid plants were obtained from 250 embryos cultured, and their somatic chromosome numbers ranged from 21 to 36. Eighteen plants were mosaic in chromosome number. Twenty one-chromosome plants appeared most frequently (45.7%) followed by 28-chromosome plants (14.9%). C-banding analysis revealed that elimination of barley chromosomes was mainly responsible for the occurrence of aneuploid plants. In hypoploids derived from Betzes-crosses, chromosome 5 was preferentially eliminated as previously reported, while in hypoploids derived from OUH602-crosses, chromosome 4 was preferentially eliminated. The wild barley line OUH602 may be a useful parent for producing a new wheat-barley addition set because of its high crossability with wheat and a different pattern of chromosome elimination.     

Application of the restriction landmark genomic scanning (RLGS) method to rice cultivars as a new fingerprinting technique

The restriction landmark genomic scanning (RLGS) method was applied to rice, using two Japanese cultivars, Nipponbare and Koshihikari, and a Chinese landrace, LiuZhou'Bao'Ya'Zao'. More than 3000 landmarks were detected as spots on the individual autoradiograms of each cultivar. Nipponbare and LiuZhou' Bao'Ya'Zao' showed apparently different RLGS profiles, from which the genetic similarity (GS) between them was estimated as 0.344. Although the two Japanese cultivars, Nipponbare and Koshihikari showed quite similar RLGS profiles, they were easily distinguished on the basis of the presence or absence of specific spots; the GS value between them was calculated as 0.980. The RLGS method is shown to be a powerful fingerprinting technique, especially for the classification and identification of cultivars in rice and probably in other crops as well.     

Evaluation of chemical pretreatment of contaminated soil for improved PAH bioremediation

The efficiency of several chemical treatments as potential enhancers of the biodegradation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in contaminated soil was evaluated by analyzing the mineralization of ¹⁴C-labeled phenanthrene, pyrene, and benzo(a)pyrene. The effect of nonionic surfactants with Fenton oxidation and combinations of surfactants with the Fenton oxidation was evaluated in a microtiter plate assay. The surfactants selected for the study were Tween 80, Brij 35, Tergitol NP-10, and Triton X-100. The addition of Fentons reagent significantly enhanced the mineralization of pyrene at the two concentrations studied: 2.8 M H₂O₂ with 0.1 M FeSO₄ and 0.7 M H₂O₂ with 0.025 M FeSO₄. Phenanthrene mineralization was also positively induced by the Fenton treatments. However, none of the treatments had a significant effect on benzo(a)pyrene mineralization. Surfactant additions at concentrations of 20% and 80% of the aqueous critical micelle concentration did not significantly affect the mineralization rates. When surfactant addition was combined with the Fenton oxidation, reduced mineralization rates were obtained when compared with mineralization after Fentons treatment alone. The results indicate that the addition of Fentons reagent may enhance the mineralization of PAHs in contaminated soil, whereas the addition of surfactants has no significant beneficial effect. The efficiency of the Fenton oxidation may decrease when surfactants are added simultaneously with Fentons reagent to contaminated soil.     

Effect of nitrogen on thiocyanate content of Brassica oleracea var. acephala leaves

An experiment was carried out to study the effect of nitrogen fertilizer application levels (0, 47, 94 and 188 kg N/ha) on thiocyanate contents of petioles and lamina of two Brassica oleracea L. var. acephala varieties (Thousand-headed kale and Georgia collards).The results showed that N application significantly decreased thiocyanate contents of both laminae and petioles. Applying 47, 94, 188 kg N/ha reduced thiocyanate of laminae and petioles by 26, 41 and 52% and 2, 9 and 39%, respectively. The results also showed that thiocyanate of leaves from Thousand-headed kale was significantly higher than that of Georgia collards. Lamina and petiole thiocyanates of Georgia collards were 79% and 83% of those of Thousand-headed kale, respectively.     

Viability and activity in readily culturable bacteria: a review and discussion of the practical issues

In microbiology the terms viability and culturability are often equated. However, in recent years the apparently self-contradictory expression viable-but-nonculturable (VBNC) has been applied to cells with various and often poorly defined physiological attributes but which, nonetheless, could not be cultured by methods normally appropriate to the organism concerned. These attributes include apparent cell integrity, the possession of some form of measurable cellular activity and the apparent capacity to regain culturability. We review the evidence relating to putative VBNC cells and stress our view that most of the reports claiming a return to culturability have failed to exclude the regrowth of a limited number of cells which had never lost culturability. We argue that failure to differentiate clearly between use of the terms viability and culturability in an operational versus a conceptual sense is fuelling the current debate, and conclude with a number of proposals that are designed to help clarify the major issues involved. In particular, we suggest an alternative operational terminology that replaces VBNC with expressions that are internally consistent.