Fidelity of replication of bacteriophage phi X174 DNA in vitro and in vivo

Seven different revertants of bacteriophage phi X174am16 (AB5276G leads to T) have been isolated and the nature of the reversions determined by sequencing their DNA. The revertants each differ from am16 by just a single base substitution. These may be distinguished with varying degrees of ease by characteristic temperature sensitivities of growth. This has facilitated the determination of the frequency at which DNA polymerase III catalyses different types of substitution mutations in copying phi X174 DNA in vitro and in vivo. During the replicative form (RF) leads to single-stranded (SS) stage of replication in vitro, four different revertants may be readily produced according to well-defined rate laws on biasing the concentrations of dNTPs. Transversion mutations are found to be formed predominantly by purine x purine mismatching, whilst transitions are formed predominantly by G x T mismatching. The substitutions via G x T and G x A mismatches are estimated to occur at similar frequencies in vivo. The two most common revertants isolated in vivo, however, are not those readily produced during the RF leads to SS stage in vitro but are those produced on purine x purine mismatching in the SS leads to RF stage. The accuracy of the DNA polymerase in vitro appears to be similar to that in this stage in vivo. However, the overall accuracy of the RF leads to SS replication in vivo is more accurate than predicted from the measurements of the accuracy in vitro.     

The mechanism of replication of phi X 174. XVIII. Gene A and A* proteins of phi X 174 bind tightly to phi X 174 replicative form DNA

Evidence is presented that the gene A and A * proteins of bacteriophage phi X 174 form covalent associations with the 5' ends of the DNA molecules when superhelical phi X replicative form DNA is nicked by a combination of these proteins in vitro. This evidence is: 1, The 5' ends of the DNA molecules nicked by the gene A protein and reacted with bacterial alkaline phosphatase were protected against subsequent phosphorylation by polynucleotide kinase even after treatment of the nicked DNA with SDS and pronase followed by centrifugation on a high-salt neutral sucrose gradient. 2, Iodinated pronase-sensitive material remained attached to the nicked replicative form DNA and could not be removed by exposure to SDS or 2 M NaCl, either by sedimentation through high-salt neutral sucrose gradients, or by CsCl equilibrium centrifugation. 3, Iodinated pronase-sensitive material was detected on DNA that had been nicked during the reaction, but not on unreacted DNA. 4, Electrophoresis of the iodinated pronase-sensitive, DNA-bound material in SDS-polyacrylamide gels after DNAse digestion revealed that it was composed almost entirely polypeptides with electrophoretic mobilities similar to those of the gene A and A * proteins. We speculate that the gene * protein may be essential for normal progeny single-stranded DNA synthesis in vivo.     

In vitro system that synthesizes circular viral DNA of bacteriophage phi X 174.

An extract prepared from Escherichia coli cells infected with phi chi 174 bacteriophage was capable of incorporating dTTP into phage-specific DNAs in vitro. The synthesized DNAs were associated with proteins and sedimented with S values of 20, 50, and 90 in a sucrose gradient sedimentation. DNA isolated from 20S material was open circular replicative form (RF), DNA in 50S material was replicative-form DNA with an extended single-stranded viral DNA that ranged up to one genome in length, and DNA in 90S material consisted of circular and linear single-stranded viral DNA of full genome length and single-stranded viral DNA shorter than full genome length. Pulse and pulse-chase experiments indicated that 90S material derived from 50S material.     

Rep protein as a helicase in an active, isolatable replication fork of duplex phi X174 DNA

Rep protein as a helicase combines its actions with those of gene A protein and single-stranded DNA binding protein to separate the strands of phi X174 duplex DNA and thereby can generate and advance a replication fork (Scott, J. F., Eisenberg, S., Bertsch, L. L., and Kornberg, A. (1977) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 74, 193-197). Tritium-labeled rep protein is bound in an active gene A protein. phi X174 closed circular duplex supercoiled DNA complex in a 1:1 ratio. Catalytic separation of the strands of the duplex by rep protein, as measured by incorporation of tritium-labeled single-stranded DNA binding protein, requires ATP at a Km value of 8 microM, and hydrolyzes two molecules of ATP for every base pair melted. When coupled to replication in the synthesis of single-strand viral circles, a "looped" rolling-circle intermediate is formed that can be isolated in an active form containing gene A protein, rep protein, single-stranded DNA binding protein, and DNA polymerase III holoenzyme. Unlike the binding of rep protein to single-stranded DNA, where its ATPase activity is distributive, binding to the replicating fork is not affected by ATP, further suggesting a processive action linked to gene A protein. Limited tryptic hydrolysis of rep protein abolishes its replicative activity without affecting significantly its binding of ATP and its ATPase action on single-stranded DNA. These results augment earlier findings by describing the larger role of rep proteins as a helicase, linked in a complex ith other proteins, at the replication fork of a duplex DNA.     

Effect of phi X C protein on leading strand DNA synthesis in the phi X174 replication pathway

The influence of the bacteriophage phi X174 (phi X) C protein on the replication of bacteriophage phi X174 DNA has been examined. This small viral protein, which is required for the packaging of phi X DNA into proheads, inhibits leading strand DNA synthesis. The inhibitory effect of the phi X C protein requires a DNA template bearing an intact 30-base pair (bp) phi X origin of DNA replication that is the target site recognized by the phi X A protein. Removal of nucleotides from the 3' end of this 30-bp conserved origin sequence prevents the inhibitory effects of the phi X C protein. Leading strand replication of supercoiled DNA substrates containing the wild-type phi X replication origin results in the production of single-stranded circular DNA as well as the formation of small amounts of multimeric and sigma structures. These aberrant products are formed when the termination and reinitiation steps of the replication pathway reactions are skipped as the replication fork moves through the origin sequence. Replication carried out in the presence of the phi X C protein leads to a marked decrease in these aberrant structures. While the exact mechanism of action of the phi X C protein is not clear, the results presented here suggest that the phi X C protein slows the movement of the replication fork through the 30-bp origin sequence, thereby increasing the fidelity of the termination and reinitiation reactions. In keeping with the requirement for the phi X C protein for efficient packaging of progeny phi X DNA into proheads, the phi X C protein-mediated inhibition of leading strand synthesis is reversed by the addition of proteins essential for phi X bacteriophage formation. Incubation of plasmid DNA substrates bearing mutant 30 base pair phi X origin sequences in the complete packaging system results in the in vitro packaging and production of infectious particles in a manner consistent with the replication activity of the origin under study.     

On the fidelity of DNA replication. The accuracy of T4 DNA polymerases in copying phi X174 DNA in vitro

The fidelity with which wild type T4 DNA polymerase copies phi X174 amber 3 plus strand DNA at position 587 in vitro has been measured. Synthesis is initiated by hybridizing to the template a HaeIII restriction fragment whose 3'-OH terminus is 83 nucleotides from the amber 3 site. Based on gel electrophoresis of product DNA molecules and genetic marker rescue data, T4 DNA polymerase copies significantly beyond the mutant site. Transfection analysis shows that the A X T leads to G X C mutation at position 587 occurs 10- to 100-fold less frequently with T4 DNA polymerase than with E. coli DNA polymerase I. The aberrant incorporation of cytosine opposite adenine at position 587 by the T4 polymerase alone is occurring at a frequency not greater than about 10(-7) which, for this particular locus, may be similar to the fidelity exhibited by the T4 accessory proteins plus the polymerase comprising the replication complex. A comparison of the accuracy of mutator L56 and antimutator L141 T4 DNA polymerases relative to wild type shows at most a 2- to 4-fold decrease and increase, respectively, in fidelity. When compared to 10- to 1000-fold effects on mutation frequencies that these same mutant alleles have in vivo, these results suggest that the wide range in expression of mutator and antimutator phenotypes in vivo may be dependent on an abnormal interaction of the aberrant DNA polymerases with other protein components of the replication complex.     

Initiation and termination of the bacteriophage phi X174 rolling circle DNA replication in vivo: packaging of plasmid single-stranded DNA into bacteriophage phi X174 coats.

The bacteriophage phi X174 viral (+) origin when inserted in a plasmid can interact in vivo with the A protein produced by infecting phi X174 phages. A consequence of this interaction is packaging of single-stranded plasmid DNA into preformed phage coats resulting in infective particles (1). This property was used to study morphogenesis and to analyse the signals for initiation and termination of the rolling circle DNA replication in vivo. It is shown that the size of the DNA had a strong effect on the encapsidation by the phage coats and the infectivity of the particle. Termination was analysed by using plasmids with two phi X (+) origins either in the same orientation or in opposite orientation. Both origins were used with equal frequency. Initiation at one origin resulted in very efficient termination (greater than 96%) at the second origin in the case of two origins in the same orientation. When the two (+) origins have opposite orientations, no correct termination was observed. The second origin in the opposite strand effectively inhibits (greater than 98%) the normal DNA synthesis; i.e. the covalently bound A protein present in the replication fork interacts with the (+) origin sequence in the opposite strand.     

Mechanism of replication of bacteriophage phi X174 XIX. Initiation of phi X174 viral strand DNA synthesis at internal sites on the genome.

Bacteriophage phi X174 viral strand DNA molecules shorter than genome length found late in the infectious cycle in Escherichia coli were 5' end labeled with 32P. Hybridization of the 32P-labeled molecules to restriction enzyme fragments of phi X replicative form DNA revealed an excess of phi X molecules whose 5' ends mapped in HaeIII fragments Z3 and Z4 in comparison with fragments Z1 and Z2. This suggests that initiation of phi X174 viral strand DNA synthesis may occur at internal sites on the complementary strand. There are several appropriately located sequences that might serve as n' (factor Y) recognition sequences and thereby facilitate discontinuous synthesis of the viral strand.     

Synthesis of bacteriophage phi X174 in vitro: mechanism of switch from DNA replication to DNA packaging

Replication of a replicative form DNA of bacteriophage phi X174 initiates by rolling-circle synthesis of the viral DNA followed by discontinuous synthesis of the complementary DNA. Gene C protein of phi X174, which is involved in DNA packaging, inhibits the rolling-circle DNA synthesis by binding to the initiation complex in vitro. The gene C protein-associated initiation complex can synthesize and package the viral DNA to produce infectious phage when supplemented with phi X174 gene J protein and the prohead. Multiple rounds of phage synthesis occur without dissociation of the gene C protein from the complex. These results indicate that gene C protein is central in the switch from replication of a replicative form DNA to synthesis and concomitant packaging of viral DNA into phage capsid, which occurs in the late stage of infection.     

Enzymatic properties of the bacteriophage phi X174 A protein on superhelical phi X174 DNA: a model for the termination of the rolling circle DNA replication.

Incubation of phi X174 replication form I DNA with the A* protein of phi X174 in the presence of MN2+ results in the formation of three different types of DNA molecules: open circular form DNA (RFII), linear form DNA (RFIII) and the relaxed covalently closed form DNA (RFIV). The RFII and RFIII DNAs are shown to be A* protein-DNA complexes by electron microscopy using the protein labeling technique of Wu and Davidson (1). The linear double-stranded RFIII DNA molecule carries at one end a covalently attached A* protein whereas at the other end of the molecule the single-stranded termini are covalently linked to each other. The structure of the RFIII DNA shows its way of formation. The described properties of the A* protein indicate the way the larger A protein functions in the termination step of the rolling-circle type of phi X174 DNA replication.     

Formation of rolling-circle molecules during phi X174 complementary strand DNA replication

The primosome is a mobile multiprotein priming apparatus that requires seven Escherichia coli proteins for assembly (the products of the dnaB, dnaC and dnaG genes; replication factor Y (protein n'); and proteins i, n, and n"). While the primosome is analagous to the phage T7 gene 4 protein and phage T4 gene 41/61 proteins in its DNA G-catalyzed priming function, its ability to act similarly also as a DNA helicase has remained equivocal. The role of the primosome in unwinding duplex DNA strands was investigated in the coliphage phi X174 SS(c)----replicative form DNA replication reaction in vitro, which requires the E. coli single-stranded DNA binding protein, the primosomal proteins, and the DNA polymerase III holoenzyme. Multigenome-length, linear, double-stranded DNA molecules were generated in this reaction, presumably via a rolling circle-type mechanism. Synthesis of these products required the presence of a helicase-catalyzed strand-displacement activity to permit multiple cycles of continuous complementary (-) strand synthesis. The participation of the primosome in this helicase activity was supported by demonstrating that other SS(c) DNA templates (G4 and alpha-3), which lack primosome assembly sites, failed to support significant linear multimer production and that replication of phi X174 with the general priming system (the DNA B and DNA G proteins and DNA polymerase III holoenzyme) resulted in a 13-fold lower rate of linear multimer synthesis.     

Mechanism of replication of bacteriophage phi X174. XXII. Site-specific mutagenesis of the A* gene reveals that A* protein is not essential for phi X174 DNA replication

The A and A* proteins of phage phi X174 are encoded in the same reading frame in the viral genome; the smaller A protein is the result of a translational start signal with the A gene. To differentiate their respective functions, oligonucleotide-directed site-specific mutagenesis was used to change the ATG start codon of the phi X 174 A* gene, previously cloned into pCQV2 under lambda repressor control, into a TAG stop codon. The altered A gene was then inserted back into phi X replicative form DNA to produce an amber mutant, phi XamA*. Two different Escherichia coli amber suppressor strains infected with this mutant produced viable progeny phage with only a slight reduction in yield. In Su+ cells infected with phi XamA*, phi X gene A protein, altered at one amino acid, was synthesized at normal levels; A* protein was not detectable. These observations indicate that the A* protein increases the replicative efficiency of the phage, perhaps by shutting down host DNA replication, but is not required for replication of phi X174 DNA or the packaging of the viral strand under the conditions tested.     

Bacteriophage phi X174 RF DNA replication in vivo. A study by electron microscopy.

We have investigated bacteriophage φX174 RF ² DNA replication by electron microscopy. Three different, types of replicative intermediates were observed: rolling circles, partially duplex DNA circles and structures consisting of two DNA circles connected at a single point.Rolling circles with a single-stranded or partially double-stranded DNA tail were both observed. After cleavage of the rolling circles with the restriction endonuclease from Providentia stuartii 164 (PstI) the startpoint of rolling circle replication could be located at 21 map units from the PstI cleavage site in agreement with the previously determined position of the origin of φX RF DNA replication.Partially duplex DNA circles consist of circular viral DNA strands and incomplete complementary DNA strands. After cleavage of these molecules with PstI information about the startpoints of the synthesis of the complementary DNA strand was obtained.The connected DNA circles always contain one completely double-stranded DNA circle whereas the other circle consists of either single-stranded, partially duplex or completely duplex DNA.Part of the duplex-to-duplex DNA circles represent the well-known figure eight or catenated circular dimers. The other connected DNA circles presumably represent replication intermediates which arise by the association of the end of the genome length tail of the rolling circle with the origin-terminus region. This is suggested by the fact that the point of contact between the two DNA circles is located at approximately 21 map units from the Pst1 cleavage site, i.e. at the origin-terminus region of the φX genome. The connected DNA circles may be intermediates in the circularization and cleavage of the genome-length tail of the rolling circles in vivo.A model for φX174 RF DNA replication in vivo summarizing the data obtained by biochemical (Baas et al., 1978) and electron microscopic analysis of replicative intermediates is presented (Fig. 9).     

Studies on the role of the phi X174 gene A protein in phi X174 viral strand synthesis. III. Replication of DNA containing two viral replication origins

Supercoiled plasmid bearing two wild-type phi X origin sequences on the same strand supported the phi X A protein-dependent in vitro formation of two smaller single-stranded circles, the lengths of which were equivalent to the distance between the two origins. Additional double origin plasmids were utilized to determine whether origins defective in the initial nicking event (initiation) could support circularization (termination). In all cases tested, the presence of a mutant origin on the same strand with a wild-type origin affected the level of replication in a manner consistent with the previously determined activity of the mutant origin. When a functional mutant origin was present on the same strand as a wild-type origin, the efficiency of replication and the DNA products formed were almost identical to those of the plasmid containing two wild-type origins. Plasmid DNA bearing both a wild-type origin and a mutant origin that did not support phi X A protein binding or nicking activity, on the other hand, supported efficient DNA synthesis of only full-length circular products, indicating that the origin defective for initiation was incapable of supporting termination. In contrast, the presence of a wild-type origin and an origin that did bind the phi X A protein but was not cleaved resulted in a marked decrease in DNA synthesis along with the production of only full-length products. This suggests that the phi X A protein stalls when it encounters a sequence to which it can bind but cannot cleave. Replication of double origin plasmids containing one functional phi X origin on each strand of the supercoiled DNA was also examined. With such templates, synthesis from the wild-type origin predominated, indicating preferential cleavage of the intact origin sequence. Replication of such substrates also produced a number of aberrant structures, the properties of which suggested that interstrand exchange of the phi X A protein had occurred.     

Mutational analysis of the bacteriophage phi X174 replication origin

Bacteriophage phi X174 mutants within the 30 base-pair replication origin were constructed using oligodeoxynucleotide-directed mutagenesis. A total of 18 viable base substitution mutants at 13 different positions within the origin region were obtained. The majority of these ori mutants have a plaque morphology and burst size comparable to that of wild-type phi X174. Two phi X174 ori mutants with a reduced growth ability spontaneously acquired additional mutations that enhanced the growth rate. The additional mutation was located at the same site as the original mutation or was located in the N-terminal part of the gene A protein. This latter secondary mutation is responsible for a better binding and/or recognition of the gene A protein to the mutated origin. In a Darwinian experiment wild-type phi X174 outgrows all phi X174 ori mutants, indicating the superiority of the wild-type ori sequence for the reproduction of bacteriophage phi 174. Insertions and deletions were constructed at different positions within the phi X174 replication origin cloned in a plasmid. Small insertions and deletions in the A + T-rich spacer region do not inhibit phi X174 gene A protein cleavage in vitro, but severely impair packaging of single-stranded plasmid DNA in viral coats.     

Effects of palindromes on in vivo DNA replication and mutagenesis in bacteriophage phi X174 RF DNA.

Bacteriophage phi X174 mutants with insertions of palindromic DNA sequences are rapidly outgrown by competing wild-type phage (Müller & Turnage, J. Mol. Biol. 189: 285). The basis for this defect was investigated and found to be due to an exclusion event early in the infectious cycle, in which phage genomes with palindromic inserts were preferentially excluded by wt phage. In addition, we have obtained further evidence for a palindrome induced genetic instability. Both defects are dependent on palindrome size and sequence, consistent with a model which involves formation of cruciforms, or cruciform-like structures. We propose that formation of unusual DNA secondary structures reduces the effectiveness of replicative form (RF) DNA to interact with limiting replication factors or membrane binding sites, possibly because of interaction with the host recombination system.     

Cloned bacteriophage phi X174 DNA sequence interferes with synthesis of the complementary strand of infecting bacteriophage phi X174.

The insertion of a particular phi X DNA sequence in the plasmid pACYC177 strongly decreased the capacity of Escherichia coli cells containing such a plasmid to propagate bacteriophage phi X174. The smallest DNA sequence tested that showed the effect was the HindII fragment R4. This fragment does not code for a complete protein. It contains the sequence specifying the C-terminal part of the gene H protein and the N-terminal part of the gene A protein, as well as the noncoding region between these genes. Analysis of cells that contain plasmids with the "reduction sequence" showed that (i) the adsorption of the phages to the host cells is normal, (ii) in a single infection cycle much less phage is formed, (iii) only 10% of the infecting viral single-stranded DNA is converted to double-stranded replicative-form DNA, and (iv) less progeny replicative form DNA is synthesized. The reduction process is phi X174 specific, since the growth of the related G4 and St-1 phages was not affected in these cells. The effect of the recombinant plasmids on infecting phage DNA shows similarity to the process of superinfection exclusion.