Malaria vaccines: triumphs or tribulations?

A safe and effective malaria vaccine will greatly facilitate efforts to control the global spread of malaria. This paper discusses the conceptual framework for developing malaria vaccines and some of the difficulties that the various approaches face. It emphasizes the role of pre-erythrocytic malaria vaccines, which are designed to protect against malaria infection, rather than simply prevent clinical disease. It describes recent encouraging results in human subjects with the RTS,S vaccine, a promising pre-erythrocytic malaria vaccine candidate.     

Progress towards the development of malaria vaccines

The misery and suffering caused worldwide by infection with the malaria parasite, especially Plasmodium falciparum, has been well documented. Although no licensed vaccine against malaria currently exists, progress has accelerated in recent years towards the goal of developing one. Although the complexity of the malaria parasite has made the malaria vaccine development process tenuous, advances in science and in the vaccine development process as well as increases in funding are encouraging. These advances, coupled with the results of the recent clinical trial of the vaccine candidate RTS,S, have added new vigor to the idea that a malaria vaccine is not only possible but probable.     

Protective immunity to pre-erythrocytic stage malaria

The development of a vaccine against malaria is a major research priority given the burden of disease, death and economic loss inflicted upon the tropical world by this parasite. Despite decades of effort, however, a vaccine remains elusive. The best candidate is a subunit vaccine termed RTS,S but this provides only partial protection against clinical disease. This review examines what is known about protective immunity against pre-erythrocytic stage malaria by considering the humoral and T cell-mediated immune responses that are induced by attenuated sporozoites and by the RTS,S vaccine. On the basis of these observations a set of research priorities are defined that are crucial for the development of a vaccine capable of inducing long-lasting and high-grade protection against malaria.     

Malaria vaccines: if at first you don't succeed..

The Roll Back Malaria campaign vowed to halve the global burden of malaria in ten years but, midway into that campaign, few new malaria control tools have been introduced, and many established methods appear to be failing with effective chemotherapy being perhaps the most problematic. It has been repeatedly argued that the discovery and implementation of a safe and effective vaccine against malaria is a major priority in the control of the disease. Indeed, many malaria control experts believe that sustainable reductions in malaria control will be nigh on impossible in the absence of such a vaccine. While most would agree that we are still some way from being able to introduce a vaccine, steady progress is being made. We review here some new approaches and developments in vaccine research that were discussed at the Molecular Approaches to Malaria conference held 1-5 February 2004 in Lorne, Australia.     

Malaria vaccine trials in a wormy world

The promising malaria vaccine candidates that have been tested in the field have, so far, yielded disappointing and, at times, conflicting results. Considerable efforts are being made to isolate new immunogenic molecules. However, the fact that most populations in malaria endemic areas are also infected by helminths appears to be overlooked. Helminth-related hyporesponsiveness to tetanus or cholera vaccines, and the interactions between malaria parasites and helminths, raise the possibility that a potent malaria vaccine will not be identified in helminth-infected populations, thus necessitating a change in vaccine trial design.     

Towards a blood-stage vaccine for malaria: are we following all the leads?

Although the malaria parasite was discovered more than 120 years ago, it is only during the past 20 years, following the cloning of malaria genes, that we have been able to think rationally about vaccine design and development. Effective vaccines for malaria could interrupt the life cycle of the parasite at different stages in the human host or in the mosquito. The purpose of this review is to outline the challenges we face in developing a vaccine that will limit growth of the parasite during the stage within red blood cells--the stage responsible for all the symptoms and pathology of malaria. More than 15 vaccine trials have either been completed or are in progress, and many more are planned. Success in current trials could lead to a vaccine capable of saving more than 2 million lives per year.     

A review of malaria vaccine clinical projects based on the WHO rainbow table

Development and Phase 3 testing of the most advanced malaria vaccine, RTS,S/AS01, indicates that malaria vaccine R&D is moving into a new phase. Field trials of several research malaria vaccines have also confirmed that it is possible to impact the host-parasite relationship through vaccine-induced immune responses to multiple antigenic targets using different platforms. Other approaches have been appropriately tested but turned out to be disappointing after clinical evaluation. As the malaria community considers the potential role of a first-generation malaria vaccine in malaria control efforts, it is an apposite time to carefully document terminated and ongoing malaria vaccine research projects so that lessons learned can be applied to increase the chances of success for second-generation malaria vaccines over the next 10 years. The most comprehensive resource of malaria vaccine projects is a spreadsheet compiled by WHO thanks to the input from funding agencies, sponsors and investigators worldwide. This spreadsheet, available from WHO's website, is known as "the rainbow table". By summarizing the published and some unpublished information available for each project on the rainbow table, the most comprehensive review of malaria vaccine projects to be published in the last several years is provided below.     

Pre-erythrocytic malaria vaccines: towards greater efficacy

The complex life cycle of the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum provides many options for vaccine design. Several new types of vaccine are now being evaluated in clinical trials. Recently, two vaccine candidates that target the pre-erythrocytic stages of the malaria life cycle - a protein particle vaccine with a powerful adjuvant and a prime-boost viral-vector vaccine - have entered Phase II clinical trials in the field and the first has shown partial efficacy in preventing malarial disease in African children. This Review focuses on the potential immunological basis for the encouraging partial protection induced by these vaccines, and it considers ways for developing more effective malaria vaccines.     

Malaria vaccines

Although the possibility of a live attenuated malaria vaccine has been considered, current malaria vaccine development activities are dominated by attempts to develop a subunit vaccine. Hence, it is entirely appropriate that a session of the Molecular Approaches to Malaria conference, Lorne, Australia, 2-5 February 2000, was devoted to vaccine development. The oral presentations in this session and the relevant poster presentations are outlined here by Robin Anders and Allan Saul.     

The importance of the spleen in malaria

There are several malaria vaccine candidates at various stages of development. Many of these target blood stages of Plasmodium falciparum. The spleen is a key site for removal of parasitized red blood cells, generation of immunity and production of new red blood cells during malaria. This article describes how all of these processes are modified following infection, and suggests that until we fully understand how these processes function and are modulated by infection, appropriate malaria vaccine design and delivery will be extremely difficult to achieve.     

Malaria vaccine development: progress and challenges

A safe and effective malaria vaccine would contribute greatly to the control and prevention of the disease. Although a review of global activity in malaria vaccine development does reflect significant activity, progress has remained slow. This article discusses the current vaccine candidates, with emphasis on those in the clinic, and explains the numerous challenges to making and evaluating malaria vaccines, which have resulted in only a few approaches being adopted and repeatedly evaluated. Against a parasite with more than 5200 genes, the lack of definitive knowledge regarding the nature of protective immunity and absence of reliable surrogates of protection are among the key challenges to a rational evaluation and prioritization of candidate vaccines. Pursuing the current R&D strategies may not result in the availability of a vaccine with characteristics suitable to impact significantly on disease morbidity in developing countries. Therefore, it is critical that the main challenges to malaria vaccine development be unambiguously identified and collectively addressed.     

New World monkey efficacy trials for malaria vaccine development: critical path or detour?

Neither GMP malaria antigens nor GMP vaccines have been compared for efficacy in monkeys and humans. It is too risky to base categorical (go/no go) development decisions on results obtained using partially characterized (non-GMP) antigens, adjuvants that are too toxic for human use or unvalidated primate models. Such practices will lead to serious errors (e.g. failure to identify and stop flawed efforts, rejection of effective vaccine strategies) and unjustifiable delays. Successful malaria vaccine development will emphasize definitive field trials in populations at risk of malaria to define and improve vaccine efficacy.     

Malaria vaccine development: current status

The development of an effective malaria vaccine represents one of the most important approaches that would provide a cost-effective intervention for addition to currently available malaria control strategies. Here, Howard Engers and Tore Godal review recent advances. Over the past decade there has been considerable progress in the understanding of immune mechanisms involved in conferring protection to malaria and in the identification of vaccine candidate antigens and their genes. Several new vaccines have entered Phase I/II trials recently, new adjuvants have been developed for human use and new approaches, such as DNA vaccines and structural modification of antigens to circumvent some of the strategies the parasite uses to avoid the immune response, are being applied. Thus, from the TDR perspective, global malaria vaccine development is entering a crucial period with unprecedented opportunities.     

A review of combination adjuvants for malaria vaccines: a promising approach for vaccine development

It is obvious that there is a critical need for an efficient malaria vaccine to accelerate malaria eradication. Currently, recombinant subunit vaccination against malaria using proteins and peptides is gaining attention. However, one of the major drawbacks of this approach is the lack of an efficient and durable immune response. Therefore, subunit vaccines require adjuvants to make the vaccine sufficiently immunogenic. Considering the history of the RTS,S vaccine, it seems likely that no single adjuvant is capable of eliciting all the protective immune responses required in many malarial subunit vaccines and the use of combination adjuvants will be increasingly important as the science of malaria vaccines advances. In light of this, it appears that identifying the most effective mixture of adjuvants with minimal adverse effects offers tremendous opportunities in improving the efficacy of vaccines against malaria. Owing to the importance of a multi-adjuvanted approach in subunit malaria vaccine development, this review paper outlines some of the best known combination adjuvants used in malaria subunit vaccines, focusing on their proposed mechanisms of action, their immunological properties, and their notable results. The aim of the present review is to consolidate these findings to aid the application of these combination adjuvants in experimental malaria vaccines.     

Human immune responses against sexual stages of malaria parasites: considerations for malaria vaccines

Studies on the natural immune responses to the sexual stages of malaria parasites have been reviewed in the context of human malaria transmission-blocking vaccines. Antibodies against the sexual stages of the malaria parasite, gametocytes and gametes, are readily evoked by natural malaria infections. These antibodies that suppress infectivity at high concentrations can, at low concentrations, enhance the development of the parasite in the mosquito; however, because enhancing antibodies are prevalent during natural malaria infections, it is likely that a vaccine would rapidly boost these antibodies to blocking levels. The immunogenicity of sexual stage antigens appears to be constrained in the human host, probably due to T epitope polymorphism and MHC restriction in humans. These constraints apply mainly to those antigens that are sensitive targets of host immunity such as the gamete surface antigens and not to internal gamete antigens, indicating that antigenic polymorphism may have evolved in response to immune selection pressure. Evidence for immunosuppression of the host by exposure to endemic malaria is presented and its consequences on vaccine development are discussed.     

A whole parasite vaccine to control the blood stages of Plasmodium: the case for lateral thinking

Now, 27 years following the cloning of malaria antigens with the promise of the rapid development of a malaria vaccine, we face significant obstacles that are belatedly being addressed. Poor immunogenicity of subunit vaccine antigens and significant antigenic diversity of target epitopes represent major hurdles for which there are no clear strategies for a way forward within the current paradigm. Thus, a different paradigm - a vaccine that uses the whole organism - is now being examined. Although most advances in this approach relate to a vaccine for the pre-erythrocytic stages (sporozoites, liver stages), this opinion paper will outline the possibilities of developing a whole parasite vaccine for the blood stage and address some of the challenges for this strategy, which are entirely different to the challenges for a subunit vaccine. It is the view of the author that both vaccine paradigms should be pursued, but that success will come more quickly using the paranormal approach of exposing individuals to ultra-low doses of whole attenuated or killed parasites.     

Immunity to asexual blood stage malaria and vaccine approaches

The development of a malaria vaccine seems to be a definite possibility despite the fact that even individuals with a life time of endemic exposure do not develop sterile immunity. An effective malaria vaccine would be invaluable in preventing malaria-associated deaths in endemic areas, especially amongst children less than 5 years of age and pregnant women. This review discusses our current understanding of immunity against the asexual blood stage of malaria - the stage that is responsible for the symptoms of the disease - and approaches to the design of an asexual blood stage vaccine.     

DNA vaccine against malaria: a long way to go

Vaccination is the attempt to mimic certain aspects of an infection for the purpose of causing an immune response that will protect the individual from that infection. Malaria, a disease responsible for immense human suffering, is caused by infection with Plasmodium spp. parasites, which have a very complex life cycle--antigenically unique stages infect different tissues of the body. It is a parasitic disease for which no successful vaccine has been developed so far, despite considerable efforts to develop a subunit vaccine that offers protective immunity. Due to the spread of drug-resistant malaria, efforts to develop an effective vaccine have become increasingly critical. DNA vaccination provides a stable and long-lived source of protein vaccine capable of inducing both antibody- and cell-mediated immune responses to a wide variety of antigens. Injected DNA enters the cells of the host and makes the protein, which triggers the immune response. According to present needs, the flexibility of DNA vaccine technology permits the combination of multiple antigens from both the preerythrocytic and erythrocytic stages of malaria parasite. DNA vaccines with genes coding for different antigenic parts of malaria proteins have been created and presently some of these are undergoing field trials. The results from these trials will help to determine the likelihood of success of this technology in humans. This review presents an update of the studies carried out in malaria using DNA vaccine approach, the challenges, and the future prospects.     

An update on the search for a Plasmodium vivax vaccine

Although Plasmodium falciparum is the leading cause of morbidity and mortality due to malaria worldwide, nearly 2.5 billion people, mostly outside Africa, are also at risk from malaria caused by Plasmodium vivax infection. Currently, almost all efforts to develop a malaria vaccine have focused on P. falciparum. For example, there are 23 P. falciparum vaccine candidates undergoing advanced clinical studies and only two P. vivax vaccine candidates being tested in preliminary (Phase I) clinical trials, with few others being assessed in preclinical studies. More investment and a greater effort toward the development of P. vivax vaccine components for a multi-species vaccine are required. This is mainly because of the wide geographical coexistence of both parasite species but also because of increasing drug resistance, recent observations of severe and lethal P. vivax cases and relapsing parasite behaviour. Availability of the P. vivax genome has contributed to antigen discovery but new means to test vaccines in future trials remain to be designed.