Chain termini cross-talk in the swapping process of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease

3D domain swapping is the process by which two or more protein molecules exchange part of their structure to form intertwined dimers or higher oligomers. Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A) is able to swap the N-terminal α-helix (residues 1-13) and/or the C-terminal β-strand (residues 116-124), thus forming a variety of oligomers, including two different dimers. Cis-trans isomerization of the Asn113-Pro114 peptide group was observed when the protein formed the C-terminal swapped dimer. To study the effect of the substitution of Pro114 on the swapping process of RNase A, we have prepared and characterized the P114A monomeric and dimeric variants of the enzyme. In contrast with previous reports, the crystal structure and NMR data on the monomer reveals a mixed cis-trans conformation for the Asn113-Ala114 peptide group, whereas the X-ray structure of the C-terminal swapped dimer of the variant is very close to that of the corresponding dimer of RNase A. The mutation at the C-terminus affects the capability of the N-terminal α-helix to swap and the stability of both dimeric forms. The present results underscore the importance of the hydration shell in determining the cross-talk between the chain termini in the swapping process of RNase A.     

Propensity for C-terminal domain swapping correlates with increased regional flexibility in the C-terminus of RNase A

Domain swapping is a type of oligomerization in which monomeric proteins exchange a structural element, resulting in oligomers whose subunits recapitulate the native, monomeric fold. It has been implicated as a potential mechanism for protein aggregation, which provides a strong impetus to understand the structural determinants and folding mechanisms that trigger domain swapping. Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) is a well-studied protein known to domain swap under extreme conditions, such as lyophilization from acetic acid. The major domain-swapped dimer form of RNase A exchanges a β-strand at its C-terminus to form a C-terminal domain-swapped dimer. To study the mechanism by which C-terminal swapping occurs, we used a variant of RNase A containing a P114G mutation that readily domain swaps under physiological conditions. Using NMR and hydrogen-deuterium exchange, we find that the P114G variant has decreased protection from hydrogen exchange compared to the wild-type protein near the C-terminal hinge region. Our results suggest that domain swapping occurs via a local high-energy fluctuation at the C-terminus.     

A domain-swapped RNase A dimer with implications for amyloid formation

Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A) forms two types of dimers (a major and a minor component) upon concentration in mild acid. These two dimers exhibit different biophysical and biochemical properties. Earlier we reported that the minor dimer forms by swapping its N-terminal alpha-helix with that of an identical molecule. Here we find that the major dimer forms by swapping its C-terminal beta-strand, thus revealing the first example of three-dimensional (3D) domain swapping taking place in different parts of the same protein. This feature permits RNase A to form tightly bonded higher oligomers. The hinge loop of the major dimer, connecting the swapped beta-strand to the protein core, resembles a short segment of the polar zipper proposed by Perutz and suggests a model for aggregate formation by 3D domain swapping with a polar zipper.     

Crystal structure of the human prion protein reveals a mechanism for oligomerization

The pathogenesis of transmissible encephalopathies is associated with the conversion of the cellular prion protein, PrP(C), into a conformationally altered oligomeric form, PrP(Sc). Here we report the crystal structure of the human prion protein in dimer form at 2 A resolution. The dimer results from the three-dimensional swapping of the C-terminal helix 3 and rearrangement of the disulfide bond. An interchain two-stranded antiparallel beta-sheet is formed at the dimer interface by residues that are located in helix 2 in the monomeric NMR structures. Familial prion disease mutations map to the regions directly involved in helix swapping. This crystal structure suggests that oligomerization through 3D domain-swapping may constitute an important step on the pathway of the PrP(C) --> PrP(Sc) conversion.     

Dynamic properties of the N-terminal swapped dimer of ribonuclease A

Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A) forms two 3-dimensional domain-swapped dimers with different quaternary structures. One dimer is characterized by the swapping of the C-terminal region (C-Dimer) and presents a rather loose structure. The other dimer (N-Dimer) exhibits a very compact structure with exchange of the N-terminal helix. Here we report the results of a molecular dynamics/essential dynamics (MD/ED) study carried out on the N-Dimer. This investigation, which represents the first MD/ED analysis on a three-dimensional domain-swapped enzyme, provides information on the dynamic properties of the active site residues as well as on the global motions of the dimer subunits. In particular, the analysis of the flexibility of the active site residues agrees well with recent crystallographic and site-directed mutagenesis studies on monomeric RNase A, thus indicating that domain swapping does not affect the dynamics of the active sites. A slight but significant rearrangement of N-Dimer quaternary structure, favored by the formation of additional hydrogen bonds at subunit interface, has been observed during the MD simulation. The analysis of collective movements reveals that each subunit of the dimer retains the functional breathing motion observed for RNase A. Interestingly, the breathing motion of the two subunits is dynamically coupled, as they open and close in phase. These correlated motions indicate the presence of active site intercommunications in this dimer. On these bases, we propose a speculative mechanism that may explain negative cooperativity in systems preserving structural symmetry during the allosteric transitions.     

Structures of the two 3D domain-swapped RNase A trimers

When concentrated in mildly acidic solutions, bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A) forms long-lived oligomers including two types of dimer, two types of trimer, and higher oligomers. In previous crystallographic work, we found that the major dimeric component forms by a swapping of the C-terminal beta-strands between the monomers, and that the minor dimeric component forms by swapping the N-terminal alpha-helices of the monomers. On the basis of these structures, we proposed that a linear RNase A trimer can form from a central molecule that simultaneously swaps its N-terminal helix with a second RNase A molecule and its C-terminal strand with a third molecule. Studies by dissociation are consistent with this model for the major trimeric component: the major trimer dissociates into both the major and the minor dimers, as well as monomers. In contrast, the minor trimer component dissociates into the monomer and the major dimer. This suggests that the minor trimer is cyclic, formed from three monomers that swap their C-terminal beta-strands into identical molecules. These conclusions are supported by cross-linking of lysyl residues, showing that the major trimer swaps its N-terminal helix, and the minor trimer does not. We verified by X-ray crystallography the proposed cyclic structure for the minor trimer, with swapping of the C-terminal beta-strands. This study thus expands the variety of domain-swapped oligomers by revealing the first example of a protein that can form both a linear and a cyclic domain-swapped oligomer. These structures permit interpretation of the enzymatic activities of the RNase A oligomers on double-stranded RNA.     

A Hinge Region cis-Proline in Ribonuclease A Acts as a Conformational Gatekeeper for C-Terminal Domain Swapping

Domain swapping, the process in which a structural unit is exchanged between monomers to create a dimer containing two subunits of the monomeric fold, is believed to be an important mechanism for oligomerization and the formation of amyloid fibrils. Structural studies have implicated proline as an important residue for domain swapping due to its increased frequency in hinge regions preceding swapped arms. We hypothesized that proline's unique ability to populate both cis and trans peptide bond conformations may allow proline to act as a conformational gatekeeper, regulating interconversion between monomer and domain-swapped dimer forms. The hinge region of RNase A contains a proline at residue 114 that adopts a cis conformation in the monomer and extends to a trans conformation in the C-terminal domain-swapped dimer. Substitution of P114 with residues that strongly prefer a trans peptide bond (Ala, Gly) results in significant population of the C-terminal domain-swapped dimer under near-physiological conditions (pH 8.0, 37 °C). This is in stark contrast to dimerization of wild-type RNase A, which requires incubation under extreme conditions such as lyophilization from acetic acid or elevated temperature. In addition, we observe similar results when cis-P114 is mutated to glycine in a homologous RNase, human pancreatic RNase 1. Our results suggest that isomerization at P114 may facilitate population of a partially unfolded intermediate or alternative structure competent for domain swapping and provide support for a more general role for proline isomerization as a conformational gatekeeper in domain swapping and oligomerization.     

Single-site mutations induce 3D domain swapping in the B1 domain of protein L from Peptostreptococcus magnus.

BACKGROUND: Thermodynamic and kinetic studies of the Protein L B1 domain (Ppl) suggest a folding pathway in which, during the folding transition, the first beta hairpin is formed while the second beta hairpin and the alpha helix are largely unstructured. The same mutations in the two beta turns have opposite effects on the folding and unfolding rates. Three of the four residues composing the second beta turn in Ppl have consecutive positive phi angles, indicating strain in the second beta turn. RESULTS: We have determined the crystal structures of the beta turn mutants G55A, K54G, and G15A, as well as a core mutant, V49A, in order to investigate how backbone strain affects the overall structure of Ppl. Perturbation of the hydrophobic interactions at the closed interface by the V49A mutation triggered the domain swapping of the C-terminal beta strand that relieved the strain in the second beta turn. Interestingly, the asymmetric unit of V49A contains two monomers and one domain-swapped dimer. The G55A mutation escalated the strain in the second beta turn, and this increased strain shifted the equilibrium toward the domain-swapped dimer. The K54G structure revealed that the increased stability is due to the reduction of strain in the second beta turn, while the G15A structure showed that increased strain alone is insufficient to trigger domain swapping. CONCLUSIONS: Domain swapping in Ppl is determined by the balance of two opposing components of the free energy. One is the strain in the second beta turn that favors the dimer, and the other is the entropic cost of dimer formation that favors the monomer. A single-site mutation can disrupt this balance and trigger domain swapping.     

Mammalian SCAN domain dimer is a domain-swapped homolog of the HIV capsid C-terminal domain

Retroviral assembly is driven by multiple interactions mediated by the Gag polyprotein, the main structural component of the forming viral shell. Critical determinants of Gag oligomerization are contained within the C-terminal domain (CTD) of the capsid protein, which also harbors a conserved sequence motif, the major homology region (MHR), in the otherwise highly variable Gag. An unexpected clue about the MHR function in retroviral assembly emerges from the structure of the zinc finger-associated SCAN domain we describe here. The SCAN dimer adopts a fold almost identical to that of the retroviral capsid CTD but uses an entirely different dimerization interface caused by swapping the MHR-like element between the monomers. Mutations in retroviral capsid proteins and functional data suggest that a SCAN-like MHR-swapped CTD dimer forms during immature particle assembly. In the SCAN-like dimer, the MHR contributes the major part of the large intertwined dimer interface explaining its functional significance.     

Insight into ribonuclease A domain swapping by molecular dynamics unfolding simulations

Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A) deserves a special place among the numerous proteins that form oligomers by three-dimensional domain swapping. In fact, under destabilizing conditions and at high protein concentrations, it can swap two different domains, the N-terminal alpha-helix or the C-terminal beta-strand, leading to dimers with different quaternary structures. With the change in the unfolding conditions, the relative abundance of the two dimers varies, and the prevalence of one dimer over the other is inverted. To investigate the dynamic behavior of the termini, four independent 10 ns high-temperature molecular dynamics simulations of RNase A were carried out at two different pH values in an attempt to reproduce the experimental conditions of neutral and very low pH that favor the formation of the N- and C-terminal domain-swapped dimers, respectively. In agreement with experimental data, under mild unfolding conditions, a partial or complete opening of the N-terminal arm is observed, whereas the dislocation of the C-terminus away from the core of the structure occurs only during the low-pH simulations. Furthermore, the picture emerging from this study indicates that the same protein can have different pathways for domain swapping. Indeed, in RNase A the C-terminal swapping requires a substantial unfolding of the monomers, whereas the N-terminal swapping can occur through only partial unfolding.     

Dramatic Structural Changes Resulting from the Loss of a Crucial Hydrogen Bond in the Hinge Region Involved in C-Terminal Helix Swapping in SurE: A Survival Protein from Salmonella typhimurium

Domain swapping is an interesting feature of some oligomeric proteins in which each protomer of the oligomer provides an identical surface for exclusive interaction with a segment or domain belonging to another protomer. Here we report results of mutagenesis experiments on the structure of C-terminal helix swapped dimer of a stationary phase survival protein from Salmonella typhimurium (StSurE). Wild type StSurE is a dimer in which a large helical segment at the C-terminus and a tetramerization loop comprising two β strands are swapped between the protomers. Key residues in StSurE that might promote C-terminal helix swapping were identified by sequence and structural comparisons. Three mutants in which the helix swapping is likely to be avoided were constructed and expressed in E. coli. Three-dimensional X-ray crystal structures of the mutants H234A and D230A/H234A could be determined at 2.1 Å and 2.35 Å resolutions, respectively. Contrary to expectations, helix swapping was mostly retained in both the mutants. The loss of the crucial D230 OD2– H234 NE2 hydrogen bond (2.89 Å in the wild type structure) in the hinge region was compensated by new inter and intra-chain interactions. However, the two fold molecular symmetry was lost and there were large conformational changes throughout the polypeptide. In spite of these changes, the dimeric structure and an approximate tetrameric organization were retained, probably due to the interactions involving the tetramerization loop. Mutants were mostly functionally inactive, highlighting the importance of precise inter-subunit interactions for the symmetry and function of StSurE.     

Folding and association of the human cell cycle regulatory proteins ckshs1 and ckshs2.

The two human proteins ckshs1 and ckshs2 are each 79 amino acids in length and consist of a four-stranded beta-sheet capped at one end by two alpha-helices. They are members of the cks family of essential cell cycle regulatory proteins that can adopt two native states, a monomer and a domain-swapped dimer formed by exchange of a C-terminal beta-strand. ckshs1 and ckshs2 both have marginal thermodynamic stability (the free energies of unfolding at 25 degrees C are 3.0 and 2.5 kcal/mol, respectively) and low kinetic stability (the rates of unfolding in water are approximately 1 s(-1)). Refolding of their denatured states to the monomeric forms of the proteins is slowed by transient oligomerization that is likely to occur via domain swapping. The folding behavior of ckshs1 and ckshs2 is markedly different from that of suc1, the cks protein from Schizosaccharomyces pombe, but the domain swapping propensities are similar. The greater thermodynamic and kinetic stability of suc1 and the population of a folding intermediate are most likely a consequence of its larger size (113 residues). The similarity in the domain swapping propensities, despite the contrast in other biophysical properties, may be attributable to the common double-proline motif in the hinge loop that connects the swapped domain to the rest of the protein. The motif was shown previously for suc1 to control the equilibrium between the monomer and the domain-swapped dimer. Finally, according to our model, the kinetic barrier separating the monomer and the domain-swapped dimer arises because the protein must unfold for beta-strand exchange to occur. Consistent with this, interconversion between the two states is much faster in the human proteins than it is for suc1, reflecting the faster unfolding rates of the former.     

Open interface and large quaternary structure movements in 3D domain swapped proteins: insights from molecular dynamics simulations of the C-terminal swapped dimer of ribonuclease A

Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A) forms two three-dimensional (3D) domain swapped dimers. Crystallographic investigations have revealed that these dimers display completely different quaternary structures: one dimer (N-dimer), which presents the swapping of the N-terminal helix, is characterized by a compact structure, whereas the other (C-dimer), which is stabilized by the exchange of the C-terminal end, shows a rather loose assembly of the two subunits. The dynamic properties of monomeric RNase A and of the N-dimer have been extensively characterized. Here, we report a molecular dynamics investigation carried out on the C-dimer. This computational experiment indicates that the quaternary structure of the C-dimer undergoes large fluctuations. These motions do not perturb the proper folding of the two subunits, which retain the dynamic properties of RNase A and the N-dimer. Indeed, the individual subunits of the C-dimer display the breathing motion of the beta-sheet structure, which is important for the enzymatic activity of pancreatic-like ribonucleases. In contrast to what has been observed for the N-dimer, the breathing motion of the two subunits of the C-dimer is not coupled. This finding suggests that the intersubunit communications in a 3D domain swapped dimer strongly rely on the extent of the interchain interface. Furthermore, the observation that the C-dimer is endowed with a high intrinsic flexibility holds interesting implications for the specific properties of 3D domain swapped dimers. Indeed, a survey of the quaternary structures of the other 3D domain swapped dimers shows that large variations are often observed when the structural determinations are conducted in different experimental conditions. The 3D domain swapping phenomenon coupled with the high flexibility of the quaternary structure may be relevant for protein-protein recognition, and in particular for the pathological aggregations.     

The multiple forms of bovine seminal ribonuclease: Structure and stability of a C-terminal swapped dimer

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) acquires an interesting anti-tumor activity associated with the swapping on the N-terminal. The first direct experimental evidence on the formation of a C-terminal swapped dimer (C-dimer) obtained from the monomeric derivative of BS-RNase, although under non-native conditions, is here reported. The X-ray model of this dimer reveals a quaternary structure different from that of the C-dimer of RNase A, due to the presence of three mutations in the hinge peptide 111–116. The mutations increase the hinge peptide flexibility and decrease the stability of the C-dimer against dissociation. The biological implications of the structural data are also discussed.     

Solution NMR study of the monomeric form of p13suc1 protein sheds light on the hinge region determining the affinity for a phosphorylated substrate.

Cyclin-dependent kinase subunit (CKS) proteins bind to cyclin-dependent kinases and target various proteins to phosphorylation and proteolysis during cell division. Crystal structures showed that CKS can exist both in a closed monomeric conformation when bound to the kinase and in an inactive C-terminal beta-strand-exchanged conformation. With the exception of the hinge loop, however, both crystal structures are identical, and no new protein interface is formed in the dimer. Protein engineering studies have pinpointed the crucial role of the proline 90 residue of the p13(suc1) CKS protein from Schizosaccharomyces pombe in the monomer-dimer equilibrium and have led to the concept of a loaded molecular spring of the beta-hinge motif. Mutation of this hinge proline into an alanine stabilizes the protein and prevents the occurrence of swapping. However, other mutations further away from the hinge as well as ligand binding can equally shift the equilibrium between monomer and dimer. To address the question of differential affinity through relief of the strain, here we compare the ligand binding of the monomeric form of wild-type S. pombe p13(suc1) and its hinge mutant P90A in solution by NMR spectroscopy. We indeed observed a 5-fold difference in affinity with the wild-type protein being the most strongly binding. Our structural study further indicates that both wild-type and the P90A mutant proteins adopt in solution the closed conformation but display different dynamic properties in the C-terminal beta-sheet involved in domain swapping and protein interactions.     

Mechanism and evolution of protein dimerization.

We have investigated the mechanism and the evolutionary pathway of protein dimerization through analysis of experimental structures of dimers. We propose that the evolution of dimers may have multiple pathways, including (1) formation of a functional dimer directly without going through an ancestor monomer, (2) formation of a stable monomer as an intermediate followed by mutations of its surface residues, and (3), a domain swapping mechanism, replacing one segment in a monomer by an equivalent segment from an identical chain in the dimer. Some of the dimers which are governed by a domain swapping mechanism may have evolved at an earlier stage of evolution via the second mechanism. Here, we follow the theory that the kinetic pathway reflects the evolutionary pathway. We analyze the structure-kinetics-evolution relationship for a collection of symmetric homodimers classified into three groups: (1) 14 dimers, which were referred to as domain swapping dimers in the literature; (2) nine 2-state dimers, which have no measurable intermediates in equilibrium denaturation; and (3), eight 3-state dimers, which have stable intermediates in equilibrium denaturation. The analysis consists of the following stages: (i) The dimer is divided into two structural units, which have twofold symmetry. Each unit contains a contiguous segment from one polypeptide chain of the dimer, and its complementary contiguous segment from the other chain. (ii) The division is repeated progressively, with different combinations of the two segments in each unit. (iii) The coefficient of compactness is calculated for the units in all divisions. The coefficients obtained for different cuttings of a dimer form a compactness profile. The profile probes the structural organization of the two chains in a dimer and the stability of the monomeric state. We describe the features of the compactness profiles in each of the three dimer groups. The profiles identify the swapping segments in domain swapping dimers, and can usually predict whether a dimer has domain swapping. The kinetics of dimerization indicates that some dimers which have been assigned in the literature as domain swapping cases, dimerize through the 2-state kinetics, rather than through swapping segments of performed monomers. The compactness profiles indicate a wide spectrum in the kinetics of dimerization: dimers having no intermediate stable monomers; dimers having an intermediate with a stable monomer structure; and dimers having an intermediate with a stable structure in part of the monomer. These correspond to the multiple evolutionary pathways for dimer formation. The evolutionary mechanisms proposed here for dimers are applicable to other oligomers as well.     

Domain swapping within PDZ2 is responsible for dimerization of ZO proteins

ZO-1 is a multidomain protein involved in cell-cell junctions and contains three PDZ domains, which are necessary for its function in vivo. PDZ domains play a central role in assembling diverse protein complexes through their ability to recognize short peptide motifs on other proteins. We determined the structure of the second of the three PDZ domains of ZO-1, which is known to promote dimerization as well as bind to C-terminal sequences on connexins. The dimer is stabilized by extensive symmetrical domain swapping of beta-strands, which is unlike any other known mechanism of PDZ dimerization. The canonical peptide-binding groove remains intact in both subunits of the PDZ2 dimer and is created by elements contributed from both monomers. This unique structure reveals an additional example of how PDZ domains dimerize and has multiple implications for both peptide binding and oligomerization in vivo.     

Heat-induced dimerization of BCL-xL through alpha-helix swapping

The dimerization of anti-apoptotic BCL-xL by three-dimensional domain swapping has recently been discovered at alkaline pH; however, the high energetic barrier between the dimer and monomer forms of BCL-xL prevents them from interconverting at room temperature and neutral pH. Here, we demonstrate that BCL-xL dimers can be easily prepared by heating concentrated protein above 50 degrees C. The 38 kDa BCL-xL dimer was fully characterized by multi-resonance nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, and the mechanism of dimerization by alpha-helix swapping was confirmed. Dimerization strongly affects the NMR signals from the turn between helices alpha5 and alpha6 of BCL-xL and a portion of the long loop between helices alpha1 and alpha2. Measurements of residual dipolar couplings demonstrate that the solution structure of the BCL-xL dimer is very close to the crystal structure. Dimer formation does not prevent tight binding of ligands to the hydrophobic cleft of BCL-xL; however, binding of a BID BH3-peptide or a polyphenol drug, gossypol, to BCL-xL significantly slowed monomer-dimer interconversion and is an example of the control of BCL protein oligomerization by ligand binding.