Enhancing recombinant protein production with an Escherichia coli host strain lacking insertion sequences

The genomic stability and integrity of host strains are critical for the production of recombinant proteins in biotechnology. Bacterial genomes contain numerous jumping genetic elements, the insertion sequences (ISs) that cause a variety of genetic rearrangements, resulting in adverse effects such as genome and recombinant plasmid instability. To minimize the harmful effects of ISs on the expression of recombinant proteins in Escherichia coli, we developed an IS-free, minimized E. coli strain (MS56) in which about 23 % of the genome, including all ISs and many unnecessary genes, was removed. Here, we compared the expression profiles of recombinant proteins such as tumor necrosis factor-related apoptosis-inducing ligand (TRAIL) and bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP2) in MG1655 and MS56. Hopping of ISs (IS1, IS3, or IS5) into the TRAIL and BMP2 genes occurred at the rate of ~10^?8/gene/h in MG1655 whereas such events were not observed in MS56. Even though IS hopping occurred very rarely (10^?8/gene/h), cells containing the IS-inserted TRAIL and BMP2 plasmids became dominant (~52 % of the total population) 28 h after fermentation began due to their growth advantage over cells containing intact plasmids, significantly reducing recombinant protein production in batch fermentation. Our findings clearly indicate that IS hopping is detrimental to the industrial production of recombinant proteins, emphasizing the importance of the development of IS-free host strains.     

Activation of expression of a cloned archaebacterial gene in Escherichia coli by IS2, IS5, or deletions

Summary A DNA fragment from the methanogenic archaebacterium Methanococcus voltae, when cloned into the PstI site of the plasmid vector pBR322, complements the Escherichia coli argG mutation strongly or weakly depending on its orientation. Faster-growing variants derived from a strain containing the poorly expressed fragment were found to harbor plasmids which had undergone genetic rearrangements. Some of the plasmids were shown to have acquired an insertion element (IS2 or IS5), derived from the E. coli chromosome, close to the region essential for complementing activity. Other plasmids exhibited no homology with E. coli chromosomal DNA. These were found to represent multimeric forms of the parental plasmid in which 2–3 kb of DNA between the tet promoter and the argG-complementing region had been deleted. Growth rates of the variant strains in the absence of arginine varied significantly, suggesting differences in efficiency of activation of the cloned DNA.     

Intermolecular Transposition of Is10 Causes Coupled Homologous Recombination at the Transposition Site

Interplasmid and chromosome to plasmid transposition of IS10 were studied by assaying inactivation of the phage 434 cI gene, carried on a low copy number plasmid. This was detected by the activity of the tet gene expressed from the phage 434 P(R) promoter. Each interplasmid transposition resulted in the fusion of the donor and acceptor plasmids into cointegrate structure, with a 9-bp duplication of the target DNA at the insertion site. Cointegrate formation was abolished in δrecA strains, although simple insertions of IS10 were observed. This suggests a two-stage mechanism involving IS10 conservative transposition, followed by homologous recombination between the donor and the acceptor. Two plasmids carrying inactive IS10 sequences were fused to cointegrates at a 100-fold lower frequency, suggesting that homologous recombination is coupled to and stimulated by the transposition event. Each IS10 transposition from the chromosome to the acceptor plasmid involved replicon fusion, providing a mechanism for IS10-mediated integration of extrachromosomal elements into the chromosome. This was accompanied by the formation of an additional copy of IS10 in the chromosome. Thus, like replicative transposition, conservative transposition of IS10 is accompanied by cointegrate formation and results in duplication of the IS10.     

Escherichia coli K-12 F′ plasmids carrying insertion sequences IS1 and IS5

A simple method is described for the detection of the insertion elements IS1 and IS5 in Escherichia coli F′ plasmids. Several of these insertion elements are normal constituents of the E. coli chromosome and are located on chromosomal regions carried by the F′ plasmids, while several others were probably acquired during the isolation or propagation of the F′ plasmids. The F′ plasmids carrying copies of IS1 or IS5 have been transferred into Salmonella (a host lacking chromosomal copies of IS1 and IS5) where individual copies can be examined for a variety of properties, including structural similarities and ability to transpose to new sites.     

4',4' adenyltransferase activity on conjugative plasmids isolated from Staphylococcus aureus is encoded on an integrated copy of pUB110.

In staphylococci, linked resistance to the aminoglycosides kanamycin, neomycin, paromomycin, and tobramycin (KmNmPmTmr) is generally mediated by an aadD determinant which encodes production of an adenyltransferase aminoglycoside modifying enzyme, AAD(4',4'). The aadD resistance determinant is located on small multicopy plasmids such as pUB110, and has also been found on large multiresistance plasmids and on the chromosome in some strains. Examination of two conjugative plasmids from strains of Staphylococcus aureus isolated in North America indicated that the aadD determinant on these plasmids is located on an integrated copy of pUB110. The integrated pUB110 is flanked by direct repeats of the staphylococcal insertion sequence IS257. Analysis of the conjugative plasmid pSK41 showed an 8-bp duplication of the pUB110 sequence immediately adjacent to flanking IS257 elements, suggesting that integration of pUB110 was mediated by IS257.     

Identification of IS 1206, a Corynebacterium glutamicum IS3-related insertion sequence and phylogenetic analysis

Integration of plasmid pCGL320 into a Corynebacterium glutamicum ATCC21086 derivative led to tandem amplification of the inserted plasmid (Labarre et a/., 1993). One amplification event was associated with integration of an insertion sequence that we have named IS 1206. Hybridizing sequences were only found in C. glutamicum strains and at various copy numbers. IS1206 is 1290bp long, carries 32 bp imperfect inverted repeats and generates a 3bp duplication of the target DNA upon insertion. IS1206 presents the features characteristic of the IS3 family and part of the DNA sequence centering on the putative transposase region (orfB) is similar to those of IS3 and some other related elements. Phylogenetic analysis of orfB deduced protein sequences from IS 1206 and IS3-related elements contradicts the phylogeny of the species, suggesting that evolution of these elements might be complex. Horizontal transfer could be invoked but other alternatives like ancestral polymorphism or/and different rates of evolution could also be involved.     

Analysis of IS21-mediated mobilization of plasmid pACYC184 by R68.45 in Escherichia coli

Escherichia coli plasmids like pACYC184 or pBR325 can be mobilized by the P-type plasmid R68.45, which carries a tandem duplication of insertion element IS21, at a frequency of 10^?3–10^?5 per donor cell. Analysis of exconjugant cells revealed that plasmid mobilization occurs via cointegrate formation involving transposition of IS21. No resolution of cointegrates of pACYC184 and the P-type plasmid could be found in recA recipient cells. In the cointegrate, the E. coli plasmid is flanked by single copies of IS21 in direct orientation. After resolution of the cointegrate in recA⁺ recipients, the mobilizing plasmid R68.45 lost one copy of IS21 becoming indistinguishable from plasmid R68. It was shown that during mobilization, insertion element IS21 transposes to the mobilized plasmid. Insertion sites and orientations of IS21 in 33 pACYC184::IS21 insertion mutants have been determined: IS21 was found to be integrated in plasmid pACYC184 in different regions but only in one orientation. The IS21 tandem structure of plasmid R68.45 and its role in the mobilization process is discussed.     

Identification and distribution of sequences having similarity to mitochondrial plasmids in mitochondrial genomes of filamentous fungi

Mitochondrial plasmids are autonomously replicating genetic elements commonly associated with fungal and plant species. Analysis of several plant and fungal mitochondrial genomes has revealed regions that show significant homology to mitochondrial plasmids, suggesting that plasmids have had a long-term association with their mitochondrial hosts. To assess the degree to which plasmids have invaded fungal mitochondrial genomes, BLAST search parameters were modified to identify plasmid sequences within highly AT-rich mtDNAs, and output data were parsed by E value, score, and sequence complexity. High scoring hits were evaluated for the presence of shared repetitive elements and location within plasmids and mtDNAs. Our searches revealed multiple sites of sequence similarity to four distinct plasmids in the wild-type mtDNA of Neurospora crassa, which collectively comprise more than 2% of the mitochondrial genome. Regions of plasmid similarity were not restricted to plasmids known to be associated with senescence, indicating that all mt plasmids can potentially integrate into mitochondrial DNA. Unexpectedly, plasmid-related sequences were found to be clustered in regions that have disproportionately low numbers of PstI palindromic sequences, suggesting that these repetitive elements may play a role in eliminating foreign DNA. A separate class of GC-rich palindromes was identified that appear to be mobile, as indicated by their occurrence within regions of plasmid homology. Sites of sequence similarity to mitochondrial plasmids were also detected in other filamentous fungi, but to a lesser degree. The tools developed here will be useful in assessing the contribution plasmids have made to mitochondrial function and in understanding the co-evolution of mitochondrial plasmids and their hosts.Electronic Supplementary Material Supplementary material is available for this article at     

Factors determining the frequency of plasmid cointegrate formation mediated by insertion sequence IS3 from Escherichia coli.

Summary Transposition events mediated by plasmid-borne copies of the insertion sequence IS3 of Escherichia coli are difficult to detect because of a low frequency of cointegrate formation. We found that cointegration activity could be strongly enhanced by using plasmid constructions in which a second IS3 element, disabled by a large deletion, was placed adjacent to an intact IS3 copy. Attempts to construct plasmids containing two adjacent intact IS3 copies were unsuccessful, probably because of instability. Transpositional hyperactivity of tandemly duplicated IS sequences was previously described for spontaneous duplications of IS21 and IS30 and may well be a more general phenomenon. The frequency of cointegration events was also strongly increased in an E. coli strain deficient in Dam methylation, suggesting that IS3, like some other Dam site-containing IS elements, is regulated by the Dam methylation system. Insertion sites were strongly clustered within the target lambda repressor gene; however no sequence specificity determinants could be identified. All insertions analyzed carried the IS element in the same orientation; target sequence duplications were mostly 3 bp, but in some cases 4 by long. To obtain information about the roles of the open reading frames (ORFs) in IS3, we constructed plasmid-borne mutant elements in which potentially functional reading frames were inactivated by site-directed mutations; the mutants were introduced into partial tandem constructions and tested in cointegration assays. Mutations inactivating the putative initiation codons of ORF I and 11 in the intact element reduced insertion activity to less than 4% of the wild type, whereas the introduction of a termination codon into ORF IV had no effect on cointegration frequency. We conclude that translation of ORFs I and II is essential for cointegration activity and that the mutagenized ATG codons most probably serve as the normal initiation codons in the wild-type element. In contrast, ORF IV could either be non-functional or its gene product could be supplied in trans from chromosomal elements.     

Analysis of chromosome mobilization using hybrids between plasmid RP4 and a fragment of bacteriophage λ carrying IS1

In vitro recombination was used to generate RP4 plasmids with an inserted restriction fragment of bateriophage λ. In some cases the λ DNA also carried the insertion sequence IS1. Comparisons were made between the abilities of these plasmids to mobilize the Escherichia coli K-12 chromosome in different genetic backgrounds. RP4-borne IS1 acting alone promoted chromosome transfer but with an efficiency 1% of that resulting from more extensive plasmid-chromosome homology. A recA mutation in the donor depressed the mobilization frequency below the level of detection. Correlation of the direction of chromosome transfer and the orientation of the cloned λ DNA allowed the direction of RP4 transfer to be determined. Studies on recombinants showed that in general they also acquired an intact, autonomous plasmid, suggesting the process of mobilization by RP4 may differ in certain features from chromosome transfer by F.     

Identification and characterization of IS1 transposition in plasmid amplification mutants of E. coli clones producing DNA vaccines

Merck Research Laboratories has developed a highly productive Escherichia coli fermentation process to produce plasmid DNA for use as vaccines. The process consists of a fed-batch fermentation in a chemically defined medium. Initiation of the feed stream precedes a growth-limited phase in which plasmid DNA is amplified. The fermentation is only maximally productive for a small fraction of E. coli transformants designated as high-producers, while the predominant low-producer population does not amplify plasmid DNA. In experiments undertaken to probe this phenomenon, transposition of the 768-bp E. coli insertion sequence IS1 into an HIV DNA vaccine vector was observed in several low-producer clones. IS1 was found to insert in or near the neomycin resistance gene in nearly a dozen unique sites from within a single population of plasmid molecules. The fraction of IS1-containing plasmids within several clones was determined by quantitative polymerase chain reaction and was found to increase with increasing cultivation time in the chemically defined medium. Because transposition into an antibiotic-resistance gene is unlikely to affect plasmid amplification, the genomes of high- and low-producers of three different HIV DNA vaccine vectors were subsequently profiled by restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis. In all three cases, IS1 insertional mutations were found in the genomes of the predominant low-producers, while the genomes of the high-producers were indistinguishable from untransformed cells. The insertions reside on similarly sized fragments for two of the low-producer clones, and the fragment size is smaller for the third clone. The third clone also produces much less plasmid DNA than a typical low-producer. The results suggest the presence of an IS1 insertional mutation that affects plasmid replication and amplification, possibly in a position-dependent manner.     

Transfer of the Gene Encoding the NapA Acid Phosphatase of Morganella morganii to a Burkholderia cepacia Strain

A composite plasmid was constructed using the broad‐host‐range vector pRK293 and the plasmid pPM9, the latter one harbouring a gene encoding the Nap A acid phosphatase from M. morganii. The recombinant construction was transformed and expressed in E. coli MC1061. Transformant clones were selected and characterized, showing that the relative orientation of both original plasmids with respect to each other affected the expression of the gene, with one of the plasmids (pT4) expressing significantly lower values of activity than the opposite orientation construction (pT5). Zymograms developed to detect acid phosphatase activity also corroborated the gene expression in the E. coli host. The genetic constructions (pT4 and pT5) were transferred to B. cepacia IS‐16 by conjugation. The same effect of the original plasmid orientation in the construction was corroborated in the B. cepacia IS‐16 strain. Compared with the strain lacking the recombinant plasmid, no signifi‐cant improvement of cell‐bound enzymatic activity was achieved by the exconjugant harbouring pT5. However, a significant increase in the extracellular enzyme activity was detected in the recombinant strains. Nometabolic load due to the presence of the recombinant plasmid was detected in both E. coli and Burkholderia hosts.     

Distribution of two Agrobacterium tumefaciens insertion elements in natural isolates: Evidence for stable association between Ti plasmids and their bacterial hosts

Summary A large number of Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains of the biotype III group carry two to ten copies of two related IS elements, IS866 and IS867. A study of the distribution and localization of these elements in 54 strains showed that one IS866 and two IS867 copies are always found at characteristic sites on the octopine/cucumopine and vitopine Ti plasmids, whereas varying amounts of IS866 and IS867 copies occur at different positions on the chromosome. By comparison of the IS patterns, an evolutionary tree could be deduced which shows the phylogenetic relationships between 23 different types of Agrobacterium strains. The structures of the T-regions of the different strains were also compared. Within the octopine/cucumopine group, eight T-region patterns could be defined. These patterns were found to be correlated with the chromosomal IS patterns. This strongly suggests that the IS866 and IS867 containing Ti plasmids are stably associated with their bacterial hosts. The possible role of the IS866 and IS867 elements in Ti plasmid evolution is discussed.     

A cloned immunoglobulin cDNA fragment enhances transposition of IS elements into recombinant plasmids.

Evidence is presented indicating that a novel DNA sequence arrangement generated by in vitro recombination may elicit high frequency transpositions of IS elements. A 109 bp Bam HI fragment of the cDNA for the immunoglobulin kappa light chain from MOPC 321 myeloma was cloned into the Bam HI site of pBR313. The cloned fragment extends from the codon for Gly 57 to the V-J junction. Insertions of IS1 or IS5 were identified in 6 of 50 plasmid DNAs isolated from freshly transformed clones. Additional transposition events were detected after subculturing for several growth cycles. Three independent insertions of IS1 occurred in the promoter region of the TcR operon. All IS5 and the remaining IS1 insertions were located in the TcR region upstream to the cloned DNA sequence. Sequences homologous to the ends of IS1, or corresponding to the consensus sequence at the target site of IS5 are present near the estimated sites of insertion of IS1 or IS5 respectively. Bacteria harboring recombinant plasmids carrying the cloned DNA in either orientation grew at a reduced rate relative to cells harboring pBR313, suggesting that fused gene products made from the two types of plasmid were inhibitory to cell growth. IS insertions, which relieved this inhibitory effect and thereby provided a selective advantage, were found exclusively in plasmids carrying the cloned DNA in only one of the two orientations. The fact that IS elements were not observed in the other type of recombinant plasmid indicates that selective pressure alone is not sufficient to account for the frequent IS insertions observed and that sequences at a distance from the site of IS insertion may be critical in the regulation of transposition frequency.     

DO PHAGES EFFICIENTLY SHUTTLE TRANSPOSABLE ELEMENTS AMONG PROKARYOTES?

The distribution, dynamics, and evolution of insertion sequences (IS), the most frequent class of prokaryotic transposable elements, are conditioned by their ability to horizontally transfer between cells. IS horizontal transfer (HT) requires shuttling by other mobile genetic elements. It is widely assumed in the literature that these vectors are phages and plasmids. By examining the relative abundance of IS in 454 plasmid and 446 phage genomes, we found that IS are very frequent in plasmids but, surprisingly, very rare in phages. Our results indicate that IS rarity in phages reflects very strong and efficient postinsertional purifying selection, mainly caused by a higher density of deleterious insertion sites in phages compared to plasmids. As they do not tolerate IS insertions, we conclude that phages may be rather poor vectors of IS HT in prokaryotes, in sharp contrast with the conventional view.     

The evolution of DNA sequences in Escherichia coli

It is proposed that certain families of transposable elements originally evolved in plasmids and functioned in forming replicon fusions to aid in the horizontal transmission of non-conjugational plasmids. This hypothesis is supported by the finding that the transposable elements Tn3 and gamma delta are found almost exclusively in plasmids, and also by the distribution of the unrelated insertion sequences IS4 and IS5 among a reference collection of 67 natural isolates of Escherichia coli. Each insertion sequence was found to be present in only about one-third of the strains. Among the ten strains found to contain both insertion sequences, the number of copies of the elements was negatively correlated. With respect to IS5, approximately half of the strains containing a chromosomal copy of the insertion element also contained copies within the plasmid complement of the strain.     

recA-independent recombination between repeated IS50 elements is not caused by an IS50-encoded function.

Certain pBR322-related plasmids containing direct repeats of the insertion element IS50 appear to be unstable in recA Escherichia coli because smaller recombinant derivatives accumulate rapidly in plasmid DNA populations. We show here that (i) this instability is plasmid specific, but not IS50 specific; (ii) it is due to a detrimental effect exerted by these plasmids on bacterial growth; and (iii) the growth impairment is alleviated in cells harboring the smaller recombinant plasmids. Although a recent report had concluded that accumulation of recombinants reflected an IS50-specific recombination function, when correction is made for the relative growth rates of cells containing the parental and recombinant plasmids the evidence for such a recombination function disappears.     

Isolation of a new insertion element of Yersinia intermedia closely related to remnants of mobile genetic elements present on Yersinia plasmids harboring the Yop virulon

A new insertion element present in two alleles, designated IS1635.1 and IS1635.2, was identified on a plasmid of a Yersinia intermedia strain by hybridization with the Yersinia enterocolitica pYV virulence plasmid. IS1635.1 and IS1635.2 are 861 bp long, carry imperfect inverted terminal repeats and possess a single open reading frame encoding a putative transposase of the IS6 family. A truncated IS1635 element is present immediately downstream of element IS1635.2. The capacity of the IS1635 elements to mediate transposition in Yersinia was demonstrated with a R6K-derived suicide vector, where a kanamycin resistance gene had been inserted between IS1635.1 and IS1635.2. Hybridization and sequence alignments showed that remnants of IS1635-like insertion elements harboring large deletions and point mutations are present on the Yop virulon harboring plasmids of pathogenic Yersinia strains. In a few cases, the IS1635 element has also been found on plasmids of apathogenic Yersinia strains.     

Cloning and sequencing of IS1086, an Alcaligenes eutrophus insertion element related to IS30 and IS4351.

A new insertion sequence (IS), designated IS1086, was isolated from Alcaligenes eutrophus CH34 by being trapped in plasmid pJV240, which contains the Bacillus subtilis sacB and sacR genes. The 1,106-bp IS1086 element contains partially matched (22 of 28 bp) terminal-inverted repeats and a long open reading frame. Hybridization data suggest the presence of one copy of IS1086 in the strain CH34 heavy-metal resistance plasmid pMOL28 and at least two copies in its chromosome. Analysis of the IS1086 nucleotide sequence revealed striking homology with two other IS elements, IS30 and IS4351, suggesting that they are three close members in a family of phylogenetically related insertion sequences. One open reading frame of the Spiroplasma citri phage SpV1-R8A2 B was also found to be related to this IS family but to a lesser extent. Comparison of the G+C contents of IS30 and IS1086 revealed that they conform to their respective hosts (46 versus 50% for IS30 and Escherichia coli and 64.5% for IS1086 and A. eutrophus). The pressure on the AT/GC ratio led to a very different codon usage in these two closely related IS elements. Results suggesting that IS1086 transposition might be activated by some forms of stress are discussed.