Principles of affinity-based biosensors

Despite the amount of resources that have been invested by national and international academic, government, and commercial sectors to develop affinity-based biosensor products, little obvious success has been realized through commercialization of these devices for specific applications (such as the enzyme biosensors for blood glucose analysis). Nevertheless, the fastest growing area in the biosensors research literature continues to involve advances in affinity-based biosensors and biosensor-related methods. Numerous biosensor techniques have been reported that allow researchers to better study the kinetics, structure, and (solid/liquid) interface phenomena associated with protein-ligand binding interactions. In addition, potential application areas for which affinity-based biosensor techniques show promise include clinical/diagnostics, food processing, military/antiterrorism, and environmental monitoring. The design and structural features of these devices—composed of a biological affinity element interfaced to a signal transducer—primarily determine their operational characteristics. This paper although not intended as a comprehensive review, will outline the principles of affinity biosensors with respect to potential application areas.     

T cell regulation of light chain expression: preferential enhancement of Ig kappa in a primary thymus-dependent response does not require affinity-based selection

Previously we reported that the proportion of Ig kappa to Ig lambda anti-DNP antibodies produced by day 5 of a primary response to thymus-dependent antigens was fivefold greater than the Ig kappa:Ig lambda ratios found in responses to thymus-independent antigens. To determine whether an affinity-based process explained the differences in kappa/lambda ratios seen, we measured the affinity of Ig kappa and Ig lambda antibody by using the binding ratio radioimmunoassay method, which measures the affinity of antibodies of particular isotypes without the need for prior purification. By the addition of a mild reduction step, the affinities of IgG and IgM antibody could be simultaneously measured. The affinity of day 5 Ig kappa anti-DNP evoked by DNP-KLH is not significantly higher than that of Ig lambda anti-DNP evoked by DNP-Ficoll, nor is it significantly different from that of Ig lambda antibody produced. As an alternative to affinity-based selection, it is suggested that T cells can preferentially augment Ig kappa responses.     

Fine affinity discrimination by normalized fluorescence activated cell sorting in staphylococcal surface display

We have investigated a staphylococcal surface display system for its potential future use as a protein library display system in combinatorial biochemistry. Efficient affinity-based selections require a system capable of fine affinity discrimination of closely related binders to minimize the loss of potentially improved variants. In this study, a significant breakthrough was achieved to avoid biases due to potential cell-to-cell variations in surface expression levels, since it was found that a generic protein tag, present within the displayed recombinant surface proteins on the cells, could be successfully employed to obtain normalization of the target-binding signal. Four mutated variants of a staphylococcal protein A domain with different affinity to human IgG were successfully expressed on the surface of recombinant Staphylococcus carnosus cells. The system was evaluated for affinity-based cell sorting experiments, where cell-displayed protein A domains with an 8-fold difference in target affinity were mixed at a ratio of 1:1000 and sorted using FACS. Enrichment factors around 140-fold were obtained from a single round of sorting under normal library sorting conditions when the top 0.1% fraction having the highest antigen binding to surface expression level ratio was sorted. The results demonstrate that the system would have a potential as a selection system in protein library display applications, and the normalization strategy should indeed make it possible to achieve fine affinity discriminations in future library selections.     

Challenges and recent advances in affinity purification of tag-free proteins

There is currently no generic, simple, low-cost method for affinity chromatographic purification of proteins in which the purified product is free of appended tags. Existing approaches for the purification of tagless proteins fall into two broad categories: (1) direct affinity-based capture of tag-free proteins that utilize affinity ligands specific to the target protein or class of target protein, and (2) removal of an appended affinity tag following tag-mediated protein capture. This paper reviews current state-of-the-art approaches for tagless protein purification in both categories, including specific examples of affinity ligands used for the capture of different classes of proteins and cleavage systems for affinity tag removal following chromatographic capture. A particular focus of this review is on recent developments in affinity tag removal systems utilizing split inteins.     

SpeedScreen: The "missing link" between genomics and lead discovery

SpeedScreen is a novel, label-free, in-solution, affinity-based selection methodology for high-throughput screening (HTS) developed at Novartis Pharma. The SpeedScreen protocol comprises in-solution affinity selection, followed by size exclusion chromatography in combination with microbore-liquid-chromatography/electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry (micro-LC/ESI-MS). The authors describe the basic concept behind assay development, HTS, and data analysis with the SpeedScreen technology. Advantages and limitations of SpeedScreen compared to alternative screening technologies are discussed, and an example is given from a SpeedScreen campaign applying this innovative affinity selection concept in HTS.     

An optimized procedure for efficient phage display of antibody fragments with a low folding efficiency

We recently developed an efficient bacterial expression system for phagemid-coded antigen-binding fragments of antibody (Fabs) without the use of a helper bacteriophage. This system is characterized by an unusually long cultivation at a low temperature and gentle induction of Fab expression without the addition of the inducer isopropyl-β-D-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG). This method allows for a high yield production of Fabs fused with phage gene III coat protein, even when the protein is defective in its folding ability. With this cultivation procedure, we aimed here at improving the production and selection efficiency of filamentous bacteriophages displaying functional Fabs on their surface (Fab-phages) that have high affinity but low folding ability. The Fab components of the Fab-phages used were clonally related but differed in their affinity and folding ability. The production of the functional Fab-phages was quantitatively evaluated under various culture conditions. With conventional phage particle preparation, the production of functional Fab-phages was significantly biased according to the folding ability of the displayed Fabs, and affinity-based biopanning was therefore unsuccessful. In contrast, with the present procedure employing cultivation at 25 °C for 16 h without IPTG induction, functional Fab-phages were produced without any such dependence on folding ability. With this optimized library, affinity-based biopanning was successful. Especially noteworthy, bead-based biopanning accurately discriminated between high affinity Fab-phages and Fab-phages with low or middling affinity. In obtaining Fab-phages with high affinity but low folding ability, these optimized procedures for both cultivation and selection were essential.     

Affinity as a tool in life science

The use of affinity-based tools has become invaluable as a platform for basic research and in the development of drugs and diagnostics. Applications include affinity chromatography and affinity tag fusions for efficient purification of proteins as well as methods to probe the protein network interactions on a whole-proteome level. A variety of selection systems has been described for in vitro evolution of affinity reagents using combinatorial libraries, which make it possible to create high-affinity reagents to virtually all biomolecules, as exemplified by generation of therapeutic antibodies and new protein scaffold binders. The strategies for high-throughput generation of affinity reagents have also opened up the possibility of generating specific protein probes on a whole-proteome level. Recently, such affinity proteomics have allowed the detailed analysis of human protein expression in a comprehensive manner both in normal and disease tissue using tissue microarrays and confocal microscopy.     

Design and synthesis of ATP-based nucleotide analogues and profiling of nucleotide-binding proteins

Two nucleotide-based probes were designed and synthesized in order to enrich samples for specific classes of proteins by affinity-based protein profiling. We focused on the profiling of adenine nucleotide-binding proteins. Two properties were considered in the design of the probes: the bait needs to bind adenine nucleotide-binding proteins with high affinity and carry a second functional group suitable and easily accessible for coupling to a chromatography resin. For this purpose, we synthesized p-biotinyl amidobenzoic acid-ATP (p-BABA-ATP) and p-biotinyl aminomethylbenzoic acid-ATP (p-BAMBA-ATP). p-BABA-ATP and p-BAMBA-ATP both bind to ATP-binding cassette (ABC) proteins with at least 10-fold higher affinity than ATP. Several ABC transporters could be enriched using p-BABA-ATP or p-BAMBA-ATP.     

Influence of azide incorporation on binding affinity by small papain inhibitors

In order to develop affinity-based biosensor platforms, appropriate ligands with a functional handle for immobilization onto a biosensor surface are required. To this end, a library of papain inhibitors was designed and synthesized, containing different azide linkers for subsequent immobilization by ‘click’ chemistry, in this particular case by copper-free, strain-promoted azide–alkyne cycloaddition (SPAAC). Furthermore, a molecular docking study was performed to obtain a better insight as to at which position such azide handles could be tolerated without affecting binding affinity. Although the azide moiety is small, in some cases its introduction strongly influenced the binding affinity. For one class of inhibitors a swapped binding mode was proposed to explain the results. In addition, a specific site for linker introduction was identified, which did not significantly affect the binding affinity.     

The differential dynamics of antibody subpopulation expression during affinity maturation in a teleost

A compositional analysis of the antibody response in rainbow trout was conducted using an affinity-based immunopartitioning assay. Trout were immunized with TNP-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (TNP-KLH) and individual serum titers and their affinity distributions analyzed over a period of 27 weeks. The kinetics of antibody affinity subpopulation development revealed certain key features: 1) the lowest affinity subpopulation (log aK, 3.5-3.99) appears early, does not achieve high titer, and was more transient than the higher affinity subpopulations; 2) intermediate affinity subpopulations (log aK, 5.0-5.99) appear later (week 5), achieve relatively high titers and persist longer; and 3) the highest affinity subpopulations (log aK, 6.0-7.49) emerge much later (post week 15), and have comparable titers to the intermediate affinity group. We find that the affinity maturation of the serum antibody response can be resolved into each affinity subpopulation's contribution both in quantity and timing.     

Validation of serum protein profiles by a dual antibody array approach

In recent years, affinity-based technologies have become important tools for serum profiling to uncover protein expression patterns linked to disease state or therapeutic effects. In this study, we describe a path towards the production of an antibody microarray to allow protein profiling of biotinylated human serum samples with reproducible sensitivity in the picomolar range. With the availability of growing numbers of affinity reagents, protein profiles are to be validated in efficient manners and we describe a cross-platform strategy based on data concordance with a suspension bead array to interrogate the identical set of antibodies with the same cohort of serum samples. Comparative analysis enabled to screen for high-performing antibodies, which were displaying consistent results across the two platforms and targeting known serum components. Moreover, data processing methods such as sample referencing and normalization were evaluated for their effects on inter-platform agreement. Our work suggests that mutual validation of protein expression profiles using alternative microarray platforms holds great potential in becoming an important and valuable component in affinity-based high-throughput proteomic screenings as it allows to narrow down the number of discovered targets prior to orthogonal, uniplexed validation approaches.     

Tools and methodologies capable of isolating and identifying a target molecule for a bioactive compound

Elucidating the mechanism of action of bioactive compounds, such as commonly used pharmaceutical drugs and biologically active natural products, in the cells and the living body is important in drug discovery research. To this end, isolation and identification of target protein(s) for the bioactive compound are essential in understanding its function fully. And, development of reliable tools and methodologies capable of addressing efficiently identification and characterization of the target proteins based on the bioactive compounds accelerates drug discovery research. Affinity-based isolation and identification of target molecules for the bioactive compounds is a classic, but still powerful approach. This paper introduces recent progress on affinity chromatography system, focusing on development of practical affinity matrices and useful affinity-based methodologies on target identification. Beneficial affinity chromatography systems with using practical tools and useful methodologies facilitate chemical biology and drug discovery research.     

Proteomics studies of post-translational modifications in plants

Post-translational modifications of proteins greatly increase protein complexity and dynamics, co-ordinating the intricate regulation of biological events. The global identification of post-translational modifications is a difficult task that is currently accelerated by advances in proteomics techniques. There has been significant development in sample preparation methods and mass spectrometry instrumentation. To reduce the complexity and to increase the amount of modified proteins available for analysis, proteins are usually subjected to prefractionation such as chromatographic purification and affinity enrichment. In this review, the post-translational modification studies in plants are summarized. The sample preparation strategies applied to each study are also described. These include affinity-based enrichment methods, immobilized metal affinity chromatography and immunoprecipitation used for phosphorylation and ubiquitination studies, respectively, and the phase partitioning approach for glycosylphosphatidylinositol modification studies.     

Calcium-dependent affinity chromatography of calmodulin on an immobilized phenothiazine.

The reversible, calcium-dependent binding of a calmodulin to phenothiazines has been demonstrated using an immobilized chlorpromazine analog. Calmodulin has been purified from crude extracts of bovine brain utilizing calcium-dependent binding to phenothiazine-Sepharose 4B as an initial affinity-based chromatographic procedure. Chromatography of a crude extract of bovine brain, prepared under non-denaturing conditions, yielded calmodulin contaminated with several other minor EGTA-elutable components. These components were removed by calcium-dependent affinity chromatography on calmodulin-Sepharose 4B and ion-exchange chromatography.     

From affinity selection to kinetic selection in Germinal Centre modelling

Affinity maturation is an evolutionary process by which the affinity of antibodies (Abs) against specific antigens (Ags) increases through rounds of B-cell proliferation, somatic hypermutation, and positive selection in germinal centres (GC). The positive selection of B cells depends on affinity, but the underlying mechanisms of affinity discrimination and affinity-based selection are not well understood. It has been suggested that selection in GC depends on both rapid binding of B-cell receptors (BcRs) to Ags which is kinetically favourable and tight binding of BcRs to Ags, which is thermodynamically favourable; however, it has not been shown whether a selection bias for kinetic properties is present in the GC. To investigate the GC selection bias towards rapid and tight binding, we developed an agent-based model of GC and compared the evolution of founder B cells with initially identical low affinities but with different association/dissociation rates for Ag presented by follicular dendritic cells in three Ag collection mechanisms. We compared an Ag collection mechanism based on association/dissociation rates of B-cell interaction with presented Ag, which includes a probabilistic rupture of bonds between the B-cell and Ag (Scenario-1) with a reference scenario based on an affinity-based Ag collection mechanism (Scenario-0). Simulations showed that the mechanism of Ag collection affects the GC dynamics and the GC outputs concerning fast/slow (un)binding of B cells to FDC-presented Ags. In particular, clones with lower dissociation rates outcompete clones with higher association rates in Scenario-1, while remaining B cells from clones with higher association rates reach higher affinities. Accordingly, plasma cell and memory B cell populations were biased towards B-cell clones with lower dissociation rates. Without such probabilistic ruptures during the Ag extraction process (Scenario-2), the selective advantage for clones with very low dissociation rates diminished, and the affinity maturation level of all clones decreased to the reference level.     

3',5'-二磷酸核苷酸酶在亲和双水相胶束系统中分配行为研究

以高分子表面活性剂HM-EO为主成相剂,金属螯合表面活性剂Triton X-114-IDA-Cu(Ⅱ)(TX-Cu(Ⅱ))为辅成相剂,构建新型亲和双水相胶束系统(ATPMS)以提高目标产物的萃取选择性,并考察重组蛋白3',5'-二磷酸核苷酸酶(YND)在系统中分配行为。结果表明,系统中不含亲和配基时YND主要分配于胶束缺失相;随着亲和配基含量的增加,YND与TX-Cu(Ⅱ)亲和结合而逐渐分配到胶束富集相并且在系统中显示出优异的稳定性;调节溶液p H能够影响YND亲和分配,最适萃取条件为pH 9.0;增大无机盐浓度,导致更多杂蛋白分配到胶束缺失相,然而对YND分配影响较小。在2.5%HM-EO、0.125%TX-Cu(Ⅱ)、p H 9.0、50 mmol/L Na Cl条件下,实验获得65.8%的酶活回收率。因此亲和ATPMS可以有效用于对富组氨酸蛋白YND的分离纯化,为该体系在重组蛋白的分离纯化试验提供相应的基础依据。     

Physical polymer matrices based on affinity interactions between peptides and polysaccharides

A rapidly forming polymer matrix with affinity-based controlled release properties was developed based upon interactions between heparin-binding peptides and heparin. Dynamic mechanical testing of 10% (w/v) compositions consisting of a 3:1 molar ratio of poly(ethylene glycol)-co-peptide (approximately 18,000 g/mol) to heparin (approximately 18,000 g/mol) revealed a viscoelastic profile similar to that of concentrated, large molecular weight polymer solutions and melts. In addition, the biopolymer mixtures recovered quickly following thermal denaturation and mechanical insult. These gel-like materials were able to sequester exogenous heparin-binding peptides and could release these peptides over several days at rates dependent on relative heparin affinity. The initial release rates ranged from 3.3% per hour for a peptide with low heparin affinity to 0.025% per hour for a peptide with strong heparin affinity. By altering the affinity of peptides to heparin, a series of peptides can be developed to yield a range of release profiles useful for controlled in vivo delivery of therapeutics.     

Effect of affinity Sorbent on proteomic profiling of isatin-binding proteins of mouse brain

Use of small molecules for isolation of particular sub-proteomes is often complicated by the need for chemical modification of a parent compound for affinity sorbent preparation. Isatin (indoledione-2,3) is an endogenous indole that exhibits a wide spectrum of biological activities. Using 5-aminocaproylisatin for proteomic profiling of fractionated rodent brain homogenates, we previously identified more than sixty individual proteins. However, proteins tested in an optical biosensor study for validation of their isatin-binding capacity demonstrated different affinity for immobilized 5-aminocaproylisatin and 5-aminoisatin. In this study, we comparatively evaluated proteomic profiles of isatin-binding proteins separated using both isatin analogs as the affinity ligands. The total number of identified proteins was higher with the shorter isatin analog (88 versus 66), and only 22 proteins were identical in the two proteomic profiles. Thus, proteomic profiling of brain isatin-binding proteins is significantly influenced by the length of the spacer between the amino group used for affinity ligand coupling to Sepharose and the isatin moiety. This suggests that the actual number of brain proteins interacting with endogenous (unmodified) isatin still remains underestimated due to different affinity of proteins for the isatin analogs used for the affinity-based proteomic profiling.     

A novel approach for affinity-based screening of target specific ligands: application of photoreactive D-glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase

A novel application of the photoaffinity technique has been developed for the efficient discovery of small ligand and macromolecule interaction. The approach, photoaffinity capture, uses a photoreactive protein together with immobilized ligand for the rapid screening of competitive inhibitors. The set of photoreactive glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (photo-GAPDH) and immobilized dye ligand was prepared and examined as a model system. The photo-GAPDH was shown to efficiently capture the immobilized ligand. When nonimmobilized competitive ligands were included in the system, the capture was prevented in accordance with the affinity of the ligands. The present approach would provide an efficient tool for affinity-based screening of ligand libraries.     

An ultraefficient affinity-based high-throughout screening process: application to bacterial cell wall biosynthesis enzyme MurF

The authors describe the discovery of a new class of inhibitors to an essential Streptococcus pneumoniae cell wall biosyn-thesis enzyme, MurF, by a novel affinity screening method. The strategy involved screening very large mixtures of diverse small organic molecules against the protein target on the basis of equilibrium binding, followed by iterative ultrafiltration steps and ligand identification by mass spectrometry. Hits from any affinity-based screening method often can be relatively nonselective ligands, sometimes referred to as "nuisance" or "promiscuous" compounds. Ligands selective in their binding affinity for the MurF target were readily identified through electronic subtraction of an empirically determined subset of promiscuous compounds in the library without subsequent selectivity panels. The complete strategy for discovery and identification of novel specific ligands can be applied to all soluble protein targets and a wide variety of ligand libraries.