Robinson cytologic grading of invasive ductal breast carcinoma: correlation with histologic grading and regional lymph node metastasis

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the importance of cytologic grading of breast carcinoma and its association with histologic grading and the existence of axillary lymph node metastasis. STUDY DESIGN: Aspirates and surgical samples from 100 patients with invasive ductal breast carcinoma not otherwise specified were studied. In 50 patients, > or = 1 metastatic nodes were identified. The cytologic grade was evaluated using the Robinson method and the histologic grade using the Elston modification of the Bloom-Richardson method. A study was undertaken to establish the association between histologic and cytologic grades and to compare the various parameters used to evaluate cytologic grade with the presence of axillary node metastasis. RESULTS: A statistically significant association was observed between cytologic and histologic grades (p < 0.0005) and between cytologic grade and presence of axillary metastasis (p < 0.0005). Similarly, cell dissociation (p < 0.0005), cell uniformity (p = 0.0010) and the appearance of nuclear margins (p < 0.0005) all displayed a positive correlation with regional metastasis. CONCLUSION: Cytologic grade may provide relevant information on the aggressiveness of invasive ductal breast carcinoma and could be a useful parameter to take into consideration when selecting neoadjuvant therapy.     

Cytologic grading and DNA image cytometry of breast carcinoma on fine needle aspiration cytology smears

OBJECTIVE: To correlate the cytologic grade of breast carcinoma with DNA image cytometry (ICM) and nuclear area on fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) smears. STUDY DESIGN: In this prospective study, FNAC material from 28 breast carcinomas were studied for cytologic grade and DNA ICM. Breast carcinomas were classified as grade 1-3 (low to high). DNA histograms were classified by the modified Auer method. Degree of hyperploidy (DH), ploidy balance (PB) and nuclear area (NA) were measured on Feulgen-stained smears by a CAS 200 image cytometer. Cytologic grade was correlated with DNA ICM findings and NA. RESULTS: There were 3 cytologic grade 1, 13 grade 2 and 12 grade 3 breast carcinomas. Seven of eight cases of hypertetraploid aneuploidy were grade 3 tumors. All cytologic grade 1 tumors were diploid. There were significant differences in DH, PB and NA in different grades of breast carcinoma (one-way ANOVA). CONCLUSION: DNA image cytometry in combination with cytologic grading might offer additional information for the characterization of breast carcinomas diagnosed by FNAC. These observations are of particular interest with the introduction of preoperative chemotherapy.     

Differential cytology of breast cancer.

The aim of the study was to investigate the possibility of predicting the histologic type of different breast cancers by semi-quantitative screening of cytologic criteria. Cytologic material was obtained by the aspiration technique. The frequency of ten cytologic criteria was correlated to five histologic types of breast cancer. Hitherto, it has not been possible to define histologic types of breast carcinomas on the basis of cytologic criteria alone. While the occurrence of cellularity, intercellular cohesion, foam cells and necroses often varies from slide to slide within one particular carcinoma, other features such as nuclear diameter, polymorphism, anisonucleosis, apocrine carcinoma cells, and enlarged nucleoli are more or less uniformly distributed. The application of these cytologic criteria thus uniformly represented in a tumour may prove to be a more reliable method for classifying breast carcinomas than the use of histologic growth patterns which are often inhomogenous within each individual neoplasm.     

Apoptosis in breast cancer

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate apoptotic rates on fine needle aspiration (FNA) samples of infiltrating duct carcinoma of the breast and to determine whether cytologic grading improved with consideration of the apoptotic rate in comparison with histologic grading. STUDY DESIGN: We studied 35 women who underwent mastectomy following an FNA diagnosis of infiltrating ductal carcinoma. Concordance between cytologic and histologic grades was calculated. Next, cytologic grades were considered with the apoptotic rates and compared with the histologic grades. RESULTS: An overall concordance of 82.9% was noted between the cytologic and histologic grading systems, with maximum concordance in grade 1 and minimum in grade 3 breast cancers. A highly significant difference in the apoptotic rates, as calculated on cytology, existed between the three histologic grades, indicating a significant increase in apoptosis with rising histologic grade. Applying multiple regression analysis, a significant improvement of cytologic grade with consideration of the apoptotic rate was observed. CONCLUSION: Employing histologic grade as the yardstick, cytology was less sensitive for the purpose of grading breast ductal carcinoma. However, by considering the apoptotic rates, the sensitivity of cytologic grading significantly rose in relation to histologic grade. Larger studies are required to determine whether apoptosis can be incorporated into the existing cytologic grading systems to increase their sensitivity.     

Robinson cytologic grading in invasive ductal carcinoma of the breast: correlation with E-cadherin and alpha-, beta- and gamma-catenin expression and regional lymph node metastasis

OBJECTIVE: To correlate the cytologic grade of breast carcinoma with the expression of E-cadherin/catenin system molecules and the presence of metastasis in regional lymph nodes. STUDY DESIGN: Aspirate smears were examined together with histologic sections from the corresponding neoplasms taken from 100 patients with invasive ductal carcinoma. In 50 cases, > or = 1 metastatic nodes were identified. Cytologic grading of the smears was performed using the Robinson method. Immunohistochemical expression of E-cadherin and of alpha-, beta- and gamma-catenin was studied. RESULTS: A statistically significant relationship was observed between E-cadherin/catenin expression and cytologic grade (p < 0.0005). This association was particularly relevant to the cell dissociation parameter (p < 0.0005). CONCLUSION: The cytological grade established in preoperative studies may provide relevant information on the aggressiveness of invasive ductal carcinoma and its tendency to produce regional metastasis. This finding could be particularly useful in cases of breast carcinoma in which neoadjuvant therapy is the method of choice.     

Nuclear image morphometry and cytologic grade of breast carcinoma

OBJECTIVE: To correlate visual cytologic grade with automated nuclear morphometry of carcinoma of the breast. STUDY DESIGN: We randomly selected 24 histologically proven infiltrating ductal carcinomas of the breast and 10 benign breast lesions (fibroadenoma). Hematoxylin-eosin-stained fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) smears were selected for both cytologic grade and automated image morphometry. The same hematoxylin-eosin-stained FNAC smears were studied for area, convex area, standard deviation of nuclear area, diameter, perimeter and convex perimeters of nucleus. At least 100 cells from each case were measured with an image cytometer. RESULTS: Mean nuclear area, standard deviation of nuclear area, nuclear diameter, convex area, convex perimeter and perimeter were significantly increased from benign versus grade 1 carcinomas and grade 1 versus grade 2 and 3 carcinomas (one way ANOVA test). However, there was no significant difference in grade 2 versus grade 3 carcinomas. CONCLUSION: Automated image cytometry rapidly and successfully measures various nuclear parameters. The measurement of various nuclear parameters would be helpful in future applications of automated diagnosis and grading of breast carcinomas from cytologic material.     

Stereologic estimates of volume-weighted mean nuclear volume in aspiration smears of ductal breast carcinoma. Correlation with cytologic grade, tumor size and lymph node status

OBJECTIVE: To estimate cytologic volume-weighted mean nuclear volume and correlate it with other prognostic factors, such as tumor diameter and cytologic grading in relation to nodal infiltration. STUDY DESIGN: The relationships between nodal status and nuclear VV, tumor diameter and cytologic grading, according to the modified Black nuclear grading system, were analyzed on fine needle aspirates of 49 cases of breast cancer by univariate and multivariate logistic regression. RESULTS: Volume-weighted mean nuclear volume (nuclear VV) estimated on fine needle aspiration smears showed a significant correlation with grade of tumor differentiation. CONCLUSION: Stereologic evaluation of nuclear size by nuclear VV is an objective method for the cytologic grading of ductal carcinoma of the breast and has independent prognostic value in relation to nodal status higher than those of tumor diameter and cytologic grade.     

Lack of correlation between morphometric analysis and presence of microsatellite alterations in proliferative ductal lesions of the breast

OBJECTIVE: To apply morphometric studies using an image analyzer to a previously reported group of proliferative duct lesions and to compare results to see if there was a correlation between nuclear size range and monoclonality. STUDY DESIGN: Fifteen proliferative lesions of the breast from 12 subjects who had no history of breast malignancy were retrieved from archival pathology specimens. Evidence of monoclonality was studied using a panel of polymerase chain reaction primers to examine microsatellite alterations on microdissected paraffin-embedded specimens. Variation in nuclear size was studied using an image analyzer. RESULTS: Of six proliferative breast lesions with demonstrated genetic instability, three showed cytologic evidence of uniformity in nuclear size, a cytologic feature of malignancy. One of the six, which showed microsatellite alterations at three loci, demonstrated a wide range of nuclear size variation. Of the eight proliferative lesions that showed no genetic instability, three showed very uniform nuclear size, and five showed significant variations in nuclear size. One lesion, which fell into the "uncertain but probably genetic instable" category, showed diverse nuclear size ranges. CONCLUSION: This study demonstrated that there is no correlation between monoclonality and monomorphic cell cytology of histologic proliferative breast lesions.     

Fine needle aspiration cytologic findings of breast mucinous neoplasms: differential diagnosis between mucocelelike tumor and mucinous carcinoma

OBJECTIVE: To report the cytologic findings of mucocelelike tumor and mucinous carcinoma. STUDY DESIGN: All mucinous neoplasms diagnosed by fine needle aspiration and confirmed by histologic examination were reviewed to detect the cytologic findings helpful for the differentiation. The cytologic findings were correlated with the histologic findings. RESULTS: Cytologically, mucinous carcinomas were highly cellular and showed many single epithelial cells and variably formed epithelial cell clusters in abundant extracellular mucin. Malignant cells exhibited round, atypical nuclei; granular chromatin; and small nucleoli. Mucocele like tumor showed low cellularity with scanty, monolayered, small sheets of epithelial cells and abundant, extracellular mucin. Myoepithelial cells were present within the epithelial cell sheets. Tumor cells were usually small, with uniform, round nuclei; fine chromatin; and absence of nucleoli. CONCLUSION: Cytologic findings of mucocelelike tumor and mucinous carcinoma were different in cellularity, shape of cell clusters and nuclear features, although mucocelelike tumors having a carcinoma component were similar to mucinous carcinoma. Awareness of the cytologic findings of breast mucinous neoplasms is important to make a specific diagnosis.     

Cytologic evaluation of prognostic markers in breast carcinoma

To type breast carcinomaon on fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) material and correlate the results with histologic typing, to grade breast carcinoma on FNAC material and correlate the findings with Bloom-Richardson histologic grading, and to determine the estrogen receptor (ER) status in cases of breast carcinoma by immunocytochemical (ICC) staining of FNA cytologic material and correlate the findings with ER status, as determined by immunohistochemical (IHC) staining of tissue sections. STUDY DESIGN: Seventy-seven cases of breast carcinoma diagnosed on FNAC formed the basis of this study. Typing was done in all cases on the basis of cytologic features and grading in 62. (Fifteen cases were special types of breast carcinoma). In all cases, ER status was determined by immunostaining of cytologic smears. Results of tumor typing, grading and ER status on cytologic material were compared with the results of histologic typing, grading and immunostaining of histologic material obtained from mastectomy or wide excision specimens. RESULTS: Tumor typing was accurate in 73 of 77 cases (94.8%). Fifteen of 18 cases that were cytologically grade 3 were confirmed on histology, while 3 proved to be grade 2. Of 40 cytologic grade 2 cases, 26 were confirmed on histology, while 14 cases were grade 3. Three of 4 cytologically grade 1 cases were confirmed on histology while 1 was grade 2. The overall accuracy for cytologic grading was 71% (44 of 62 cases). Thirty-seven of 40 ER-positive cases (92.5%) were labeled ER positive on ICC. One case was ER negative on cytology, while in 2 cases the cellularity of the cytologic smear was insufficient to assess ER expression. Thirty-seven cases were negativefor ER on IHC. Nine of these showed ER positivity on ICC, 26 were negative, and 2 had cellularity that was inadequate for assessment of ER. Sensitivity and specificity rates for ER detection on ICC were 97.4% and 74.3%, respectively. CONCLUSION: Tumor typing, grading and evaluation of ER status on FNA C material in breast carcinomas are simple, quick and moderately reliable techniques that compare and correlate favorably with histologic typing, grading and ER status on IHC.     

Cytologic grading of invasive breast carcinoma. Correlation with clinicopathologic variables and predictive value of nodal metastasis

OBJECTIVE: To estimate cytologic grade and correlate it with the other known prognostic factors, such as tumor differentiation, growth fraction, estrogen receptor status and nodal status. STUDY DESIGN: Fine needle aspirates from 104 invasive ductal carcinomas were stained by the Papanicolaou method and examined for necrosis, cellular size, nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio, nuclear pleomorphism, nucleoli, chromatin granularity and density of chromatin. We established a semiquantitative scoring system based on the above features and correlated cytologic findings with clinicopathologic variables. RESULTS: Histologic grade correlated positively with cytologic grade and negatively with estrogen receptor positivity. Moreover, high cytologic grade was associated with nodal metastasis and proliferative index labeling by MIB-1. CONCLUSION: This study showed that our grading system for breast cancer on fine needle aspiration cytology is feasible on a routine diagnostic basis. Cytologic grading can provide more information than usual on tumor biologic behavior.     

Accuracy of cytology vs. microbiopsy for the diagnosis of well-differentiated hepatocellular carcinoma and macroregenerative nodule. Definition of standardized criteria from a study of 100 cases

OBJECTIVE: To determine the accuracy of ultrasound (US)-guided fine needle aspiration (FNA) for the diagnosis of well-differentiated hepatocellular carcinoma (wd HCC) and macroregenerative nodule (MRN) and to identify the most useful cytologic and histologic criteria to distinguish between those two diagnoses. STUDY DESIGN: Cytologic and histologic specimens of 50 wd HCC and 50 MRN were reviewed blindly and the diagnosis compared to the final clinical diagnosis. Twenty-eight cytologic and 25 histologic criteria were examined and subjected to statistical analysis. RESULTS: Among 100 cases studied, the final diagnosis was available for 43. In those 43 cases, combining analysis of cytologic and histologic specimens, the sensitivity of US-guided FNA was of 75% and the specificity 100%. Cytologic analysis was better than isolated histologic analysis, with a sensitivity of 75% vs. 68%, respectively. Sensitivity of cytologic diagnosis was lower for smaller nodules and for those located in poorly accessible hepatic segments. With the use of stepwise logistic regression analysis, four cytologic features (increased nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio, cellular monomorphism, nuclear crowding, loss of bile duct cells) and four histologic features (increased nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio, decreased Kupffer cells, cellular monomorphism, increased trabeculae thickness) were identified as predictive of HCC.     

Ploidy and nuclear area as a predictive factor of histologic grade in primary breast cancer

OBJECTIVE: To compare ploidy and nuclear area with histologic grade in breast cancer using cytologic samples. STUDY DESIGN: Fine needle aspirates from 85 patients with primary breast cancer were analyzed to identify ploidy and nuclear area. The Feulgen technique was used to stain the material. We used the SAMBA 4000 image analysis system (Grenoble, France) for analyzing ploidy and nuclear area. Each patient underwent a biopsy, and the histologic grade was analyzed. RESULTS: A significant association was found between ploidy and nuclear area, between histologic grade and nuclear area, and between ploidy and histologic grade. As ploidy became aneuploid and polyploid and nuclear area became larger, histologic grade became higher. CONCLUSION: A reliable and rapid evaluation of variables for breast cancer can be achieved using cytologic preparations by measuring ploidy and nuclear area of malignant cells with an image analysis system. Ploidy and nuclear area have a significant association with histologic grade.     

Prognostic markers in histologic and cytologic specimens of breast cancer

OBJECTIVE: To correlate histologic and cytologic specimens of breast cancer by the expression of prognostic factors, such as estrogen receptor (ER), progesterone receptor (PR) and c-erbB-2, with immunochemical staining. STUDY DESIGN: Cytologic and histologic specimens from 83 patients were analyzed for expression of ER and PR, and 30 cases were analyzed for overexpression of c-erbB-2 using a standard immunochemical method. The material used for immunocytochemical staining was taken from the needle and syringe after each aspiration and smear preparation. The material was washed into a small container with preservative solution. Immunohistochemical staining was performed on paraffin-embedded specimens. RESULTS: A significant association was found between the histologic specimens and cytologic specimens by means of the expression of immunochemical markers. The best correlation between cytologic and histologic specimens was found when using c-erbB-2. CONCLUSION: A reliable and rapid evaluation of markers for breast cancer can be achieved by immunocytochemical staining on cytologic material. A good association was found between histologic and cytologic specimens using immunostaining.     

Cytological grading of breast carcinoma—a feasible proposition?

Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) of the breast is widely used in the diagnosis of breast carcinoma. In some centres this is sometimes the only diagnostic procedure performed prior to definitive treatment. A grading system based on cytology would be helpful in the selection of patients for appropriate therapy. The aim of this study, therefore, was to devise such a system for grading breast carcinoma based on cytological features alone. The features assessed were the degree of cell clustering, nuclear pleomorphism, nuclear diameter, the presence of multiple, easily visible nucleoli and necrosis. Cytological features were compared to the histological grade of the tumours following excision. Discriminant analysis showed that the features with the closest correlation with histological grade were nuclear diameter, nuclear pleomorphism and the presence of nucleoli. A scoring system based on these three parameters enabled the classification of tumours into high and low cytological grades which showed a close correlation with histological grade.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology of apocrine carcinoma of the breast. Review of cases in a three-year period

OBJECTIVE: To describe the fine needle aspiration cytology findings of apocrine carcinoma of breast and correlate them with the histologic appearance. STUDY DESIGN: The author reviewed the fine needle aspiration cytology findings of two cases of pure apocrine carcinoma of the breast in the files of Pamela Youde Nethersole Eastern Hospital during a three-year period, 1998-2000. RESULTS: The cytologic findings in both cases were similar. The smears were of moderate to high cellularity, consisting of predominantly dispersed or loosely cohesive tumor cells in a focally granular background. The carcinoma cells contained abundant, dense to granular cytoplasm; round or oval and sometimes eccentrically located nuclei; a smooth nuclear outline; evenly dispersed chromatin; and solitary macronucleoli. The cell borders were mostly discrete. In contrast to benign apocrine cells, the malignant cells showed nuclear overlapping, more frequent nuclear pleomorphism, increased nuclear/cytoplasmic ratios and occasional mitotic figures. Histologic examination of the excised specimens showed extensive, solid apocrine carcinoma in situ with focal stromal invasion. CONCLUSION: Apocrine carcinoma, a subtype of breast carcinoma characterized mainly by its cytologic features, needs to be distinguished from benign apocrine lesions or other eosinophilic and granular cell tumors of the breast. Recognition of the subtle cytologic differences renders a definitive preoperative diagnosis possible.     

Papillary breast lesions diagnosed on cytology. Profile of 65 cases

OBJECTIVE: To analyze the cytologic features of nipple discharge and fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytologic smears from breast lesions reported as showing papillary features and to correlate them with histopathologic features. STUDY DESIGN: The study group consisted of FNA smears and/or nipple discharge smears from 65 breast lesions diagnosed on cytology as duct papilloma, papillary lesion, fibrocystic condition, fibroadenoma, papillary neoplasm or papillary carcinoma. Cytomorphologic features assessed included cellularity, cell pattern (clusters, papillary, 3-dimensionality, etc.) and cell characteristics (monomorphism, pleomorphism, apocrine change, plasmacytoid features). Histological material was available for review and cytohistologic correlation in all cases. RESULTS: Forty-six specimens were FNA smears, and 16 were nipple discharge smears; in 3 cases FNA and nipple discharge cytologic smears were available for review. Cytologic study could predict the presence of a papillary pattern in all neoplasms with pure or focal papillary differentiation. There was an overlap in cytomorphologic features between papillary and nonpapillary benign lesions as well as between benign and malignant papillary neoplasms. Frank blood in the aspirate, cell dissociation and atypia, however, were more frequent in the last. CONCLUSION: Overlap of cytologic features in nonneoplastic and neoplastic benign papillary lesions and between benign and malignant papillary neoplasms necessitates histologic evaluation in all cases diagnosed as papillary on cytology. Since 49.2% of lesions showing papillary features on cytology prove to be malignant, all cases reported as papillary on cytology should be excised urgently for histologic assessment.     

Automated cell nuclear segmentation in color images of hematoxylin and eosin-stained breast biopsy

OBJECTIVE: To develop an automated, reproducible epithelial cell nuclear segmentation method to quantify cytologic features quickly and accurately from breast biopsy. STUDY DESIGN: The method, based on fuzzy c-mean clustering of the hue-band of color images and the watershed transform, was applied to 39 images from 3 histologic types (typical hyperplasia, atypical hyperplasia, and ductal carcinoma in situ [cribriform and solid]). RESULTS: The performance of the segmentation algorithm was evaluated by visually determining the percentage of badly segmented nuclei (approximately 25% for all types), the percentage of nuclei that remained in clumps (4.5-16.7%) and the percentage of missed nuclei (0.4-1.5%) for each image. CONCLUSION: The segmentation algorithm was sensitive in that a small percentage of nuclei were missed. However, the percentage of badly segmented nuclei was on the order of 25%, and the percentage of nuclei that remained in clumps was on the order of 10% of the total number of nuclei in the duct. Even so, > 600 nuclei per duct, on average, were segmented correctly; that was a sufficient number by which to calculate accurate quantitative, cytologic, morphometric measurements of epithelial cell nuclei in stained tissue sections of breast biopsy.     

Morphometric image analysis of follicular lesions of the thyroid

OBJECTIVE: To determine the role of image morphometry in distinguishing various follicular lesions of the thyroid in cytologic smears. STUDY DESIGN: Archival fine needle aspiration smears of 10 cases each of follicular hyperplasia, follicular adenoma, follicular carcinoma and follicular variant of papillary carcinoma were used for the study. All cases were histopathologically proven. At least 100 random nuclei from each case were subjected to analysis with an image cytometer. Area, convex area, length, width, perimeter, convex perimeter and roundness of nuclei were measured using a 40 x objective (1 pixel = 0.446 micron). RESULTS: ANOVA showed that all the nuclear variables studied were significantly different (P < .05) in follicular hyperplasia as compared to follicular carcinoma and papillary carcinoma. All nuclear variables except roundness were also significantly different (P < .05) between follicular hyperplasia and follicular adenoma. However, between follicular adenoma, follicular carcinoma and papillary carcinoma there was considerable overlap of nuclear morphometric parameters. CONCLUSION: Image morphometry may help to distinguish nonneoplastic follicular lesions (hyperplasia) from neoplastic lesions (adenomas and carcinomas). However, to distinguish benign from malignant follicular lesions, image morphometry might not improve the accuracy of standard cytologic examination.     

Preoperative brush and impression cytology in ocular surface squamous neoplasms

OBJECTIVE: Preoperative cytologic diagnoses of ocular surface squamous neoplasms were evaluated and compared with histologic diagnoses. STUDY DESIGN: Impression cytology (Millipore filter paper) and brush cytology were applied to 32 patients who had conjunctival neoplasms. Papanicolaou-stained cytologic preparations and hematoxylin and eosin-stained histologic sections were examined by light microscopy. RESULTS: The brush technique was used on 27 patients; impression cytology was applied in 5 cases. Cytologic and histologic diagnoses were concordant in 26 cases. Squamous cell carcinoma or carcinoma in situ was diagnosed in 18 and dysplasia in 4 cases. Squamous metaplasia and normal-appearing conjunctival epithelial cells were diagnosed cytologically in four cases; of those histologic diagnoses, one was pterygium and three, conjunctival nevus. Four cases revealed discrepancies between the cytologic and histologic preparations. There was one false positive result, and one case was subconjunctival invasion of basal cell carcinoma of the eyelid. CONCLUSION: Impression and brush cytology are fast, cost-effective, reliable and noninvasive diagnostic tools for ocular surface squamous neoplasms. However, the brush technique has several advantages over impression cytology.