The self determinants recognized by human virus-immune T cells can be distinguished from the serologically defined HLA antigens

The self specificity of human influenza virus-immune cytotoxic T cells has been analyzed in order to clarify the relationship between the self antigens that they recognize and the serologically defined HLA-A and -B antigens. Virus-immune effectors from HLA-A2-positive donors were tested on panels of virus-infected target cells from donors who were either HLA-mismatched or matched only for HLA-A2. Virus-immune T cells from 11 out of 11 A2-positive donors lysed all A2-matched virus-infected target cells (and no HLA-mismatched targets), except that each of these effector cells consistently failed to lyse virus-infected target cells from one A2-positive donor (designated M7). Although the A2 specificity of donor M7 could also be distinguished from the A2 antigen of other donors by alloimmune cytotoxic T cells, no differences in the A2 antigen of donor M7 could be defined by extensive serologic analyses. These results indicate that there is a strong but incomplete association between a self antigen recognized by virus-immune T cells and the serologically defined HLA-A2 specificity.     

Vaccinia virus-specific human CD4+ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte clones.

Vaccinia virus-specific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) clones were established from a healthy donor, who had been immunized with vaccinia virus vaccine, by stimulation of peripheral blood lymphocytes with UV-inactivated vaccinia virus antigen. The phenotype of all of the clones established was CD3+ CD4+ CD8- Leu11-. We used a panel of allogenic vaccinia virus-infected B-lymphoblastoid cell lines and demonstrated that some of the clones recognized vaccinia virus epitopes presented by human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class II molecules. Monoclonal antibodies specific for either HLA-DP or HLA-DR determinant reduced the cytotoxicity of specific clones. The HLA-restricted cytotoxicity of the clones is vaccinia virus specific, because vaccinia virus-infected but not influenza virus-infected autologous target cells were lysed. Using vaccinia virus deletion mutants, we found that some of the CTL clones recognize an epitope(s) that lies within the HindIII KF regions of the vaccinia virus genome. These results indicate that heterogeneous CD4+ CTL clones specific for vaccinia virus are induced in response to infection and may be important in recovery from and protection against poxvirus infections.     

Polymorphism of cytotoxic T-lymphocyte clones that recognize a defined nine-amino-acid immunodominant domain of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus glycoprotein

To assess the heterogeneity of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) directed against viral epitopes, we studied six class I major histocompatibility complex-restricted (H-2Db) CTL clones that recognize the same 9-amino-acid immunodominant epitope, amino acids 278 to 286 from envelope glycoprotein 2 (GP2) of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV). Using Southern blot analysis of beta-chain rearrangements, we found that each clone has a unique restriction pattern, providing evidence of the independent derivation of the clones and suggesting that the clones express different beta-chain sequences for their T-cell receptor. All these clones killed syngeneic target cells infected with strain Armstrong or WE of LCMV; however, two of the six clones failed to recognize target cells infected with the Pasteur strain of LCMV. Sequence analysis of LCMV Armstrong, WE, and Pasteur GP in the region of amino acids 272 to 293 demonstrated a single-amino-acid substitution at amino acid 278 in the region of the defined epitope in the Pasteur strain. Interestingly, one of the two CTL clones that failed to lyse LCMV Pasteur-infected target cells nevertheless efficiently and specifically killed uninfected target cells coated with the appropriate LCMV Pasteur peptide, while the other clone failed to do so. This indicated a dichotomy between processing of the synthesized protein initiated by infection and a peptide exogenously applied. Dose-response studies utilizing several peptides with substitutions in GP amino acid 278 indicate that CTL recognition occurs at the level of a single amino acid and suggest that this difference is likely recognized at the level of the T-cell receptor.     

Population coverage by HLA class-I restricted cytotoxic T-lymphocyte epitopes

Vaccination using cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) epitopes has become a widely used immunization strategy, especially because their structure makes them an attractive alternative to the delivery of whole proteins as immunogens. Nonetheless, their use is limited, in particular because of their specificity, being recognized only by cognate HLA alleles. The potential for immunizing a substantial portion of an ethnically diverse population using a modest number of peptides has been aided by the identification of HLA supertypes. However, the derivation of epitopes is often guided by methods that do not guarantee cross-reactivity, so we consider the feasibility of providing vaccine coverage to a multi-ethnic population under different assumptions. In particular, two large datasets are used to estimate the number of peptides needed to provide > or =90% group-specific coverage of a multiethnic population, when specificity is assumed to be either to a single serologic or molecular type. These assumptions are evaluated utilizing a clinically important epitope repertoire derived from two human cytomegalovirus proteins, and data on the in vitro memory response elicited by these peptides is presented. In summary, our combined theoretical and empiric studies suggest that 90% coverage of some ethnic groups is attainable with 11 uniquely defined HLA-restricted CTL epitopes. The derivation of four or more additional CTL epitopes is needed to attain 90% coverage of Blacks or Asians, the minimally covered groups. Ninety percent coverage of all major ethnic groups in a multi-ethnic population appears feasible without relying on cross-reactivity, but may require two to three times more CTL epitopes than estimated for serologic data, homogenous populations, or HLA alleles grouped as supertypes.     

CTL and serologically defined antigens of B2m,H-3 region

The antigens of the B2m,H-3 region of 13 chromosome 2 congenic strains and seven inbred strains have been studied by using CML and serologic techniques. Nine patterns of cross-reactivity have been defined by CML assays. These results are in agreement with an extend previously described cross-reactivity studies. The reactivities of three monoclonal antibodies previously thought to be reacting with B2M-B are shown to differ: Ly-m11 and J-5 react with cells of strain B10-pa,at and clone 23 does not. Two H-3 region loci are hypothesized on the basis of CML and serologic activity: B2m and H-3. The CTL responses to the B2M antigens are H-2K restricted; the CTL responses to H-3 antigens are H-2D restricted. The restriction of the response to the H-3 antigen requires effector-target identity of the H-2D molecule but not the B2M molecule of the class I antigen. These loci have been separated by recombination from H-42 in the production of the congenic strain B10.FS-a. A gene order of B2m, H-3, H-42 is suggested.     

Individual differences in the cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response in man to public HLA determinants

The allospecific anti-HLA response of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) from 22 unrelated individuals and 7 monozygous twin pairs was examined. From each responder, CTL were generated in several responder-stimulator combinations, each mismatched for one HLA-A or -B antigen. The CTL were assayed in the cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) on panels of third-party target cells, comprising cells that express the stimulating antigen (specific target cells), cells that express an antigen cross-reactive with the stimulating antigen (CREG target cells), and cells that do not express either the stimulating or a cross-reactive antigen (nonsharing target cells). Individual variations in the allo-CTL response were observed. We identified individuals (responders) who showed a consistently narrow CTL response and those who showed a broad reaction pattern to various stimulator cells. The narrow response was restricted almost entirely to specific target cells; the broad response comprised lysis of specific, CREG, and nonsharing target cells. These differences were evidently not dependent on the HLA-A, -B, -C phenotype of the responder, because HLA-A, -B, (-C)-identical individuals responded differently to the same stimulator. The identical response of monozygous twins indicates that the allogeneic CTL response is genetically controlled. The CTL response is not regulated by the HLA-DR antigens of the responder, nor is it influenced by the DR mismatch between responder and stimulator. The observed differences were not dependent on sex or age and could not be explained by differences in the T-lymphocyte subsets (OKT3+, OKT4+, OKT8+) or by differences in proliferative reactivity to mitogens (phytohemagglutinin, concanavalin A, phorbol-myristate acetate, pokeweed mitogen, anti-T3 monoclonal antibodies). The IL-2 activity in the supernatants of mixed lymphocyte cultures of broad and narrow responder-stimulator combinations did not differ.     

Differential recognition of the serologically defined HLA-A2 antigen by allogeneic cytotoxic T Cells

Human alloimmune cytotoxic T cells, sensitized selectively against the HLA-A2 antigen, were tested on a panel of selected target cells. Five HLA-A2 positive outlier cells could be identified. These outlier cells were only weakly lysed by HLA-A2 specific CTLs, although they were serologically indistinguishable from the other HLA-A2 positive, strongly lysed target cells. Furthermore, it was found that the outlier cells were poor cold target inhibitors in contrast to the other HLA-A2 positive target cells, which showed adequate inhibition of specific lysis of HLA-A2 positive target cells. Population studies indicate that the frequency of such HLA-A2 outlier cells may be approximately 10%.     

Bystander target cell lysis and cytokine production by dengue virus-specific human CD4(+) cytotoxic T-lymphocyte clones

Dengue hemorrhagic fever, the severe form of dengue virus infection, is believed to be an immunopathological response to a secondary infection with a heterologous serotype of dengue virus. Dengue virus capsid protein-specific CD4(+) cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) clones were shown to be capable of mediating bystander lysis of non-antigen-presenting target cells. After activation by anti-CD3 or in the presence of unlabeled antigen-presenting target cells, these clones could lyse both Jurkat cells and HepG2 cells as bystander targets. Lysis of HepG2 cells suggests a potential role for CD4(+) CTL in the liver involvement observed during dengue virus infection. Three CD4(+) CTL clones were demonstrated to lyse cognate, antigen-presenting target cells by a mechanism that primarily involves perforin, while bystander lysis occurred through Fas/Fas ligand interactions. In contrast, one clone used a Fas/Fas ligand mechanism to lyse both cognate and bystander targets. Cytokine production by the CTL clones was also examined. In response to stimulation with D2 antigen, CD4(+) T-cell clones produced gamma interferon, tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha) and TNF-beta. The data suggest that CD4(+) CTL clones may contribute to the immunopathology observed upon secondary dengue virus infections through direct cytolysis and/or cytokine production.     

Differential recognition of the serologically defined HLA-A2 antigen by allogeneic cytotoxic T cells

A comprehensive analysis of human alloimmune cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) specific for the HLA-A2 antigen identified 11% of HLA-A2 positive cells as outliers. In total, 11 unrelated serologically indistinguishable, but distinguishable by cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) HLA-A2 positive outlier cells were identified. The outlier cells could be subdivided in two subgroups according to reactivity patterns obtained with CTLs directed against the HLA-A2 antigen of outlier cells and their inhibitory capacity in specific competitive inhibition experiments. Thus, the serologically defined HLA-A2 specificity can be divided into at least three subtypes using CTLs specific for the HLA-A2 antigen. Moreover, CTLs specific for an HLA-A2 subtype could be induced when responder cells expressed a different HLA-A2 subtype antigen. On the basis of several family studies, we conclude that the subtype HLA-A2 antigens are inherited in a codominant way.     

On the kinetics and optimal specificity of cytotoxic reactions mediated by T-lymphocyte clones

Using the chromium release assay and the single cell assay in agarose, we study the cytotoxic reaction of the MHC-restricted T lymphocyte clones P89:15 and P1:3, which recognize distinct but specific tumour antigens on the surface of syngeneic P815 mastocytoma cells. We propose a mathematical model which describes these experiments, accounts for the strongly non-Michaelian behaviour of the reaction and permits us to estimate the kinetic parameters characterizing effector-target conjugation and lethal hit delivery. The results show that the binding and lytic activity of effector cells is modulated by the number of targets bound to them. The binding of a second target by an effector having already a target bound is facilitated; on the other hand, an effector having bound two targets delivers a lethal hit more slowly than one with a single target bound. We investigate the role of these kinetic properties in the competition between the process of tumour progression due to cancer cell replication and the process of tumour regression due to T lymphocyte cytotoxic activity. For both clones, we estimate the effector-target ratio beyond which rejection prevails. This ratio is nine times larger for P1:3 than for P89:15. Furthermore, our analysis suggests that there exists an optimal specificity minimizing this ratio. Deviations from this optimum, be it in the sense of an increase or decrease of specificity, tendsto stabilize the tumoural state: a situation which in the broader context of the immune response evolution and regulation can be viewed as animmune response dilemma.     

Phorbol diester induces phenotypic and functional changes in human T-lymphocyte clones

Tumor promoting phorbol myristate acetate (PMA) induce to enhance the expression of IL2 Receptor and to decrease the antigen receptor expression on the cell surface. The same phenotypic changes are also observed when the T cell clones are stimulated by the specific ligand. In contrast to the IL2 Receptor induced by the specific antigen, the ones induced by PMA are less active.     

Relative dominance of epitope-specific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte responses in human immunodeficiency virus type 1-infected persons with shared HLA alleles.

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) target multiple epitopes in human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-infected persons, and are thought to influence the viral set point. The extent to which HLA class I allele expression predicts the epitopes targeted has not been determined, nor have the relative contributions of responses restricted by different class I alleles within a given individual. In this study, we performed a detailed analysis of the CTL response to optimally defined CTL epitopes restricted by HLA class I A and B alleles in individuals who coexpressed HLA A2, A3, and B7. The eight HIV-1-infected subjects studied included two subjects with acute HIV infection, five subjects with chronic HIV infection, and one long-term nonprogressor. Responses were heterogeneous with respect to breadth and magnitude of CTL responses in individuals of the same HLA type. Of the 27 tested epitopes that are presented by A2, A3, and B7, 25 were targeted by at least one person. However, there was wide variation in the number of epitopes targeted, ranging from 2 to 17. The A2-restricted CTL response, which has been most extensively studied in infected persons, was found to be narrowly directed in most individuals, and in no cases was it the dominant contributor to the total HIV-1-specific CTL response. These results indicate that HLA type alone does not predict CTL responses and that numerous potential epitopes may not be targeted by CTL in a given individual. These data also provide a rationale for boosting both the breadth and the magnitude of HIV-1-specific CTL responses by immunotherapy in persons with chronic HIV-1 infection.     

Expression of human histocompatibility antigens on the surface of murine cells transformed by cosmid clones containing HLA genes

Thymidine kinase-negative C3H mouse L fibroblasts (LMTK⁻) transformed with cosmid clones containing both herpes virus-derived thymidine kinase (TK) and HLA class I genes were first selected in HAT (hypoxanthine, aminopterin, thymidine) medium and subsequently analyzed for the expression of human transplantation antigens. TK⁺-transformed cells expressing HLA class I molecules were characterized by surface radioimmunoassay, cytofluorimetric analysis and immunoperoxidase PAP technique at the light and electron microscopic levels, using a set of monoclonal antibodies. Comparisons were made with human B (Raji) and T (1 301) lymphoblastoid cell lines which respectively express high and low levels of HLA molecules on their surface. The expression of HLA class I in association with murine β2-microglobulin on the surface of transformed cells did not reduce the level of expression of H-2 molecules.     

Multiple epitopes on human and murine cells expressing HLA-B7 as defined by specific murine cytotoxic T cell clones

Eleven cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones were derived from C57BL/6 spleen cells immunized with HLA-B7 expressing human lymphoblastoid cell lines. Reactivity against HLA-B7 was initially established because the clones lysed 2 target cells that shared only HLA-B7 with the immunizing cell line and they did not lyse five other cell lines that were HLA-B7 negative but expressed other class I or class II antigens found on the immunizing cell. Six of the clones were subsequently shown to lyse all tested HLA-B7-positive B and T lymphoid cell lines, peripheral blood lymphocytes, and a murine L cell that expressed HLA-B7 as a consequence of DNA-mediated gene transfer. On the basis of the inability of the clones to lyse a panel of HLA-B7-negative cell lines, up to 18 other class I antigens could be eliminated as being cross-reactively recognized. However, two of the clones recognized a single HLA-B7-negative cell line. It is suggested that in these cases the clones were cross-reactively recognizing the HLA-B27 or HLA-B40 antigens that were present on these target cells. The remaining five CTL clones failed to lyse one out of seven tested HLA-B7-positive lymphoid lines (either RPMI-1788 or DR1B) and failed to lyse peripheral blood lymphocytes from one out of three tested HLA-B7-positive individuals. These five clones also did not recognize the HLA-B7-positive murine L cell. However, based on analysis with a large target cell panel, the reactivity pattern of these five clones could only be correlated with recognition of HLA-B7. This conclusion is further supported by antibody-blocking studies to be reported elsewhere. As before, lysis of single HLA-B7-negative target cells by two of the clones could be ascribed to recognition of HLA-B27 or HLA-B40. The results show that murine clones raised against HLA-B7 exhibit a high degree of specificity for determinants that are unique or largely confined to the HLA-B7 alloantigen. In addition, these clones define different antigenic determinants on the molecule. Thus, such clones appear to be excellent candidates for use as human tissue typing reagent. The results further show that there is a strong correlation between recognition of particular HLA-B7-positive human cell lines and recognition of the HLA-B7 expressing murine L cell. Possible reasons for such a correlation and their relationship to the general phenomenon of CTL recognition are discussed.     

Differential behavior of cytotoxic effector cells against HLA antigens in strong genetic linkage disequilibrium

Five sets of cytotoxic effector cells were generated, using haploidentical, first degree relatives in five different families, against the HLA-A3; B7 serological determinants combined with different DR antigens. When tested against a panel of cells bearing combinations of the HLA-A, -B and -DR antigens it was shown that the HLA-B7 antigen was as strong a CML target determinant alone as it was in the presence of HLA-A3. The strength of the HLA-A3 antigen as target determinant varied. With effector cells primed to the HLA-A3; B7; DR2 haplotype, the A3 antigen alone behaved as a weak target determinant. When the same target cells were tested with the effector cells generated against HLA-A3; B7 without DR2, the A3 antigen behaved as a strong target determinant. A number of target cells lacking the serologically detectable HLA determinants present on the sensitizing HLA haplotype were identified as being killed by specific effector cells. These data suggest either a number of new CML target determinants controlled by different loci or the presence of a single, new locus with multiple alleles controlling CML targets.     

Human cytotoxic T cell clones directed against herpes simplex virus-infected cells. I. Lysis restricted by HLA class II MB and DR antigens

In contrast to general findings that mouse and human cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) are restricted in cytotoxic activity by major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I antigens, we previously found that some herpes simplex virus (HSV) type I-infected cells that shared no HLA class I antigens with the HSV-1-stimulated lymphocytes were lysed. In this study, we addressed the question of the role of HLA antigens in human T cell-mediated lysis of HSV-1-infected cells by generating clones of HSV-1-directed CTL from two HSV-1-seropositive individuals. CTL clones that lysed autologous HSV-1-infected lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCL), but not natural killer-sensitive K562 cells or uninfected or influenza virus-infected LCL, were tested for cytotoxicity against a panel of allogeneic HSV-1-infected LCL. Clone KL-35 from individual KL lysed only HSV-1-infected LCL sharing the HLA class II MB1 antigen with KL. With all four CTL clones isolated from individual PM, only HSV-1-infected LCL sharing DR1 with PM were lysed. Monoclonal antibody s3/4 (directed against MB1 ), but not TS1/16 or B33 .1 (directed against a DR framework determinant), blocked lysis of autologous HSV-1-infected cells by KL-35. In contrast, B33 .1, but not s3/4, blocked lysis of autologous HSV-1-infected cells by the PM CTL clones but not by KL-35. Together, these results indicate that our five human CTL clones which are directed against HSV-1-infected cells, and which are all OKT3+, OKT4+, OKT8-, are restricted in lytic activity by HLA class II MB and DR antigens. These results suggest that the HLA D region-encoded class II antigens may be important in the recognition and destruction of virus-infected cells by human CTL.