Resistance of primary CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes to lysis by cytotoxic granules from cloned T cell lines

Recent evidence has shown that cloned, murine CTL cell lines are resistant to the cytotoxic components of the toxic granules they release upon specific interaction with their target cells. Inasmuch as the resistance might be due to selection in culture over many months by repeated exposure to these cytolytic components (which are released repeatedly as a result of the cultured CTL being periodically stimulated by target cells), we asked whether primary CTL are also resistant. The primary CTL were elicited in vivo by i.p. injection of allogeneic tumor cells or in vitro by 5- to 6-day MLC or by 48-h exposure to the lectin Con A. The responding cells were separated into purified CD8+ (i.e., CD4-, CD8+) and purified CD4+ (i.e., CD4+, CD8-) T cell populations that were analyzed for cytolytic activity and for resistance to lysis by toxic secretory granules derived from cloned CTL cell lines. The CD8+ T cells were highly cytolytic and relatively resistant; they retained their cytolytic activity and were lysed to a minimal extent (0 to 10%) by quantities of isolated granules that lysed 80 to 90% of the P815 tumor cell line (tested as a representative standard cell line). The CD4+ T cells, in contrast, had only minimal cytolytic activity and were far more susceptible to granule-mediated lysis. Although the resistance of primary CD8+ T cells is impressive, it is not as pronounced as the resistance of the cloned CTL cell lines, indicating that during long-term culture there is some selection for increased resistance to granule-mediated lysis. In contrast to T cells (especially CD8+ T cells), Ia+ macrophages, isolated from primary immune peritoneal exudates, were highly susceptible to granule-mediated lysis.     

Expression and function of synaptotagmin VII in CTLs

The Ca(2+) sensor synaptotagmin (Syt) VII regulates the exocytosis of conventional lysosomes in several cell types. In CTLs, the Ca(2+)-regulated exocytosis of lytic granules/secretory lysosomes is responsible for the perforin/granzyme-mediated lysis of target cells. To investigate the role of Syt VII in CTL effector function, the expression and function of Syt VII were examined in wild-type and Syt VII-deficient mice. In comparison with Syt VII(+/+) controls, Syt VII(-/-) animals were impaired in their ability to clear an infection with the intracellular pathogen Listeria monocytogenes. When isolated CTLs were examined, we found that Syt VII is expressed upon CTL activation and localizes to granzyme A-containing lytic granules. Syt VII-deficient CTLs have no defects in proliferation and cytokine production, and their lytic granules contain normal amounts of perforin and granzyme A and polarize normally at the immunological synapse. However, despite normal conjugate formation with target cells, CTLs from Syt VII(-/-) mice exhibit reduced effector activity, when compared with controls. Treatment of Syt VII(+/+) or Syt VII(-/-) CTLs with an inhibitor of the perforin-mediated lytic pathway resulted in comparable levels of cytotoxic activity, suggesting that Syt VII regulates perforin-mediated cytolytic CTL responses.     

Lack of DNA degradation in target cells lysed by granules derived from cytolytic T lymphocytes

It has been shown previously that fragmentation of target cell DNA is an early event in lysis mediated by cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL). In this study, we have investigated whether CTL-derived granules that exhibit lytic activity also induce DNA fragmentation in murine target cells. Cytolytic granules isolated from three different alloreactive CTL clones were tested for the induction of DNA fragmentation in P815 and EL4 target cells, by using a Triton X-100-facilitated, radiolabeled DNA release assay. In contrast to the CTL clones from which they were derived, the cytolytic granules did not induce DNA fragmentation. Agarose gel electrophoretic analysis of DNA confirmed the lack of discrete DNA fragments in target cells lysed by CTL-derived granules. Possible explanations for the difference in the ability of CTL and CTL-derived granules to trigger DNA fragmentation are discussed.     

CTLs contain and use intracellular stores of FasL distinct from cytolytic granules

CTL lyse target cells through the release of cytolytic granule contents and cell surface expression of Fas ligand (FasL). Current models suggest that FasL is stored in cytolytic granules and that FasL cell surface expression would be subject to the same controls as degranulation. We demonstrate that murine CTLs undergo two waves of FasL cell surface expression after stimulation. The first wave is from a pre-existing pool of FasL, and the second wave requires new protein synthesis. Signaling for FasL expression appears to be finely tuned as a weak signal preferentially induced surface translocation of the stored FasL, whereas a strong signal preferentially triggered the expression of de novo synthesized FasL. The early FasL is differentially regulated from degranulation, as there were multiple circumstances whereby rapid FasL cell surface expression and FasL-dependent killing occurred in the absence of detectable degranulation. Furthermore, we found through confocal microscopy that stored FasL resides in vesicles distinct from cytolytic granules. Our data clearly show that CTL degranulation and FasL lytic mechanisms are fully independent with respect to stored component localization and regulation.     

Protein kinase C theta regulates stability of the peripheral adhesion ring junction and contributes to the sensitivity of target cell lysis by CTL

Destruction of virus-infected cells by CTL is an extremely sensitive and efficient process. Our previous data suggest that LFA-1-ICAM-1 interactions in the peripheral supramolecular activation cluster (pSMAC) of the immunological synapse mediate formation of a tight adhesion junction that might contribute to the sensitivity of target cell lysis by CTL. Herein, we compared more (CD8(+)) and less (CD4(+)) effective CTL to understand the molecular events that promote efficient target cell lysis. We found that abrogation of the pSMAC formation significantly impaired the ability of CD8(+) but not CD4(+) CTL to lyse target cells despite having no effect of the amount of released granules by both CD8(+) and CD4(+) CTL. Consistent with this, CD4(+) CTL break their synapses more often than do CD8(+) CTL, which leads to the escape of the cytolytic molecules from the interface. CD4(+) CTL treatment with a protein kinase Ctheta inhibitor increases synapse stability and sensitivity of specific target cell lysis. Thus, formation of a stable pSMAC, which is partially controlled by protein kinase Ctheta, functions to confine the released lytic molecules at the synaptic interface and to enhance the effectiveness of target cell lysis.     

Heat-shocked A20 lymphoma cells fail to induce degranulation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes: possible mechanism of resistance

A20 lymphoma cells were subjected to heat shock for 2 h at 42 and 43 +/- 0.1 degrees C and then evaluated at 37 degrees C for sensitivity to lysis by intact allo-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs), perforin-containing granules isolated from CTLs, and Fas-mediated apoptosis. Heat shock at 42 degrees C caused little change in sensitivity of the lymphoma cell line to lysis by intact CTLs or their isolated cytotoxic granules, but caused increased sensitivity to Fas-mediated apoptosis. However, A20 cells shocked at 43 degrees C declined significantly in sensitivity to lysis by intact CTLs, while remaining very sensitive to perforin granules and to Fas-mediated apoptosis. Expression of the inducible heat shock protein was observed in A20 cells incubated at 43 degrees C, but not in those incubated at 42 degrees C, suggesting a role for heat shock proteins. Furthermore, A20 cells shocked at 43 degrees C did not provoke degranulation and secretion of granzymes by antigen-specific CTLs, although formation of CTL-target conjugates and levels of MHC class I molecules remained unchanged. These observations demonstrate that hyperthermia or febrile conditions may reduce susceptibility of target cells to CTL attack due to failure of antigen presentation and the inability of CTLs to recognize heat stressed targets, thus enabling targets to escape CTL attack.     

Secretory lysosomes - a special mechanism of regulated secretion in haemopoietic cells

The secretory granules o f cells derived from the haemopoietic lineage are 'secretory lysosomes' containing both lysosomal hydrolases and secretory proteins. Studies on cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) have elucidated several of the mechanisms that regulate protein sorting to, and secretion from, this unusual secretory organelle. In particular, recent findings from a CTL mutant have led to the hypothesis that CTLs, and other cells of the haemopoietic lineage, use specialized sorting and secretory mechanisms in which the lysosome functions as a regulated secretory granule.     

Perforin mRNA in primary peritoneal exudate cytotoxic T lymphocytes

Considerable evidence indicates that cloned CTL cell lines kill target cells by releasing toxic granules that contain a cytolytic protein, called perforin, and several serine esterases (granzymes A to F). However, primary CTL, such as the highly cytolytic peritoneal exudate lymphocyte (PEL) cell population, have been found by a hemolytic assay to have no perforin, or perhaps only borderline levels of that protein, suggesting that these cells use a different lytic mechanism. To determine whether or not primary CTL express the perforin gene, we have here compared mRNA from PEL CTL and from a cloned CTL cell line, 2C, by Northern blot analysis using a perforin cDNA probe. CD8+ PEL CTL contain approximately 30% of the amount of perforin message present in 2C. Moreover, depletion of CD8+ T cells from the total peritoneal exudate cell population removes both cytolytic activity and perforin message. We have previously shown that PEL CTL elicit the same changes in target cells as cloned CTL cell lines and are resistant to lysis by the toxic granules purified from these cells lines. Taken together these results are consistent with the view that primary CTL, as well as long term cloned CTL cell lines, exercise their cytolytic activity by means of perforin.     

Clonal analysis in the ultrastructure of cell-to-cell interaction between a human glioma cell line and autologous tumor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes

The clonal analysis in the ultrastructure of tumor-lymphocyte interaction was carried out in order to investigate the precise mechanism responsible for CTL-mediated cytolysis of tumor cells. A glioma-derived cell line (GI-1) and autologous tumor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones were established. The CTL lines were composed of the morphologically homogeneous lymphocytes with intracytoplasmic electron-dense secretory granules. After the stimulation by GI-1, the size of the CTLs increased, and the intracytoplasmic organellas were developed. It was noted that the intracytoplasmic secretory granules markedly increased in number and size, and many of them exhibited an "immature" appearance. On the other hand, the tumor cells underwent a progressive degeneration. In contrast, the stimulation by other antigens caused only small morphological changes in the CTLs. It is suggested, therefore, that the secretory function of tumor-specific CTLs is activated by the stimulation of the specific antigen, and that soluble factors in the secretory granules in the CTLs may be closely associated with the mechanism of target cell lysis.     

Highly lytic in vivo primed cytolytic T lymphocytes devoid of lytic granules and BLT-esterase activity acquire these constituents in the presence of T cell growth factors upon blast transformation in vitro

Demonstration of C-like "rings," lytic granules, and the Ca2+-dependent lytic proteins--perforin/cytolysin--thereof, in certain cytocidal lymphocytes has led to the hypothesis of a mechanism of lytic granule-exocytosis and a common terminal lytic step in lymphocyte and C-induced lysis. However, neither cytolytic granules, nor formation of C-like rings during lysis have been detected in mature, highly potent, peritoneal exudate CTL (PEL) derived directly from the site of allograft rejection or in cytocidal hybridomas derived from them (PEL hybridomas). We now report that when stimulated in vitro in the presence of Con A supernatant, as a source of T cell growth factors (TCGF) or rIL-2, small in vivo primed PEL transform into large, dividing cytolytic T cells (PEL blasts) that express the same lytic specificity of the original PEL in short term lytic assays. The PEL blasts, in contrast to PEL, possess massive quantities of lytic granules, and protease (N-alpha-benzyloxycarbonyl-L-lysine thiobenzyl ester esterase) (BLT-esterase) activity as well as non-specific, cell-mediated cytolytic activity in a long term (4-h) assay. These results suggest that the proposed lytic mechanism involving exocytosis of lytic granules, perforin, and BLT-esterases and the formation of 10 to 20-nm lesions may apply to lysis induced by granule-containing effectors such as large granular lymphocytes and TCGF-dependent CTL lines, such as PEL blasts. However, killing by mature, in vivo primed CTL, such as PEL or their hybridomas, appears to be effected through an alternative, contact-induced, self-destruction process(es) of the target not involving secretory lytic granules or the above lesions. Hence, although the expression of lytic granules and BLT-esterase activities in cytolytic lymphocytes devoid of these components is induced by TCGF, these cellular constituents are not necessary for the expression of CTL-mediated target cell lysis by mature effector cells.     

Inhibition of the lytic activity of perforin by lipoproteins

Cytoplasmic granules isolated from cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) lyse red blood cells or tumor cell lines in a nonspecific manner. The activity of highly purified granules was inhibited by human or rabbit serum at dilutions as high as 1/10,000. The main inhibitory activity of human serum was isolated by chromatography and was determined to be high density lipoprotein (HDL). HDL not only inhibited at a concentration of 70 ng/ml the lytic activity of isolated granules, but also of the purified, pore-forming protein perforin present in the granules. Purified low density lipoprotein was equally active. Because the CTL granule activity was inhibited by pure egg lecithin vesicles at a concentration equivalent to the phospholipid content of lipoproteins, the lipid portion of lipoproteins is the likely candidate for granule inactivation. Lipoproteins also decreased in a dose-dependent manner the cytotoxic activity of intact cytolytic T cells. However, cytotoxicity was not completely suppressed, and only in the case of CTL exhibiting low efficiency in killing their targets. It is proposed that lipoproteins inactivate perforin and may thereby inhibit a possible lysis of innocent bystander cells.     

Target cell lysis by cytotoxic T lymphocytes that lack detectable hemolytic perforin activity

When mouse target cells are subjected to cytolytic attack by mouse CTL cell lines that have been cultured for many months in high levels of IL-2, and have abundant perforin-rich secretory granules, they exhibit two prominent changes: 1) rapid and massive increase (greater than 10-fold) in intracellular Ca2+ concentration and 2) fragmentation of DNA into nucleosome-sized fragments. We show here that when the same target cells are subjected to cytolytic attack by perforin-deficient CTL, either human CTL or primary mouse CTL from peritoneal exudates, the same changes are observed, suggesting that perforin-rich and perforin-deficient CTL kill their target cells by similar (if not identical) mechanisms. It is possible that perforin-deficient CTL produce enough perforin to destroy target cells but not enough to be detected by currently available methods.     

Resistance of cytolytic lymphocytes to perforin-mediated killing. Murine cytotoxic T lymphocytes and human natural killer cells do not contain functional soluble homologous restriction factor or other specific soluble protective factors

CTL and NK cells produce a cytolytic pore-forming protein (perforin, cytolysin) localized in their cytoplasmic granules. These cytotoxic cells are resistant to killing mediated by other lymphocytes and by purified perforin. A membrane factor, known as homologous restriction factor (HRF), has been suggested to confer protection to different cell types against both C- and perforin-mediated lysis. The granules of human large granular lymphocytes have been reported to contain, in addition to perforin, a soluble HRF activity that can be eluted from anion-exchange columns at 115 mM NaCl. Here, we report that a soluble HRF activity is absent in the granules or the cytosol of murine CTL and human NK cells. Our data indicate that the inhibition attributed to HRF could be explained by exogenous EDTA added during granule fractionation. EDTA was shown to bind to Mono Q and to elute at 90 to 120 mM NaCl. A second perforin-inhibitory activity was also eluted from such a column. However, it was present in preparations obtained not only from CTL and NK cells, but also from some perforin-susceptible tumor cell lines, indicating that it has nonrestricted distribution and suggesting that it is probably irrelevant to the perforin-protection mechanism. Our results argue against a role for soluble granule HRF or other soluble factors in mediating resistance of cytotoxic lymphocytes against perforin-mediated lysis.     

Tumor-specific CTL kill murine renal cancer cells using both perforin and Fas ligand-mediated lysis in vitro, but cause tumor regression in vivo in the absence of perforin

Kidney cancer is a devastating disease; however, biological therapies have achieved some limited success. The murine renal cancer Renca has been used as a model for developing new preclinical approaches to the treatment of renal cell carcinoma. Successful cytokine-based approaches require CD8(+) T cells, but the exact mechanisms by which T cells mediate therapeutic benefit have not been completely identified. After successful biological therapy of Renca in BALB/c mice, we generated CTLs in vitro using mixed lymphocyte tumor cultures. These CTL mediated tumor-specific H-2K(d)-restricted lysis and production of IFN-gamma, TNF-alpha, and Fas ligand (FasL) in response to Renca. CTL used both granule- and FasL-mediated mechanisms to lyse Renca, although granule-mediated killing was the predominant lytic mechanism in vitro. The cytokines IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha increased the sensitivity of Renca cells to CTL lysis by both granule- and FasL-mediated death pathways. Adoptive transfer of these anti-Renca CTL into tumor-bearing mice cured most mice of established experimental pulmonary metastases, and successfully treated mice were immune to tumor rechallenge. Interestingly, we were able to establish Renca-specific CTL from mice gene targeted for perforin (pfp(-/-)) mice. Although these pfp(-/-) CTL showed reduced cytotoxic activity against Renca, their IFN-gamma production in the presence of Renca targets was equivalent to that of wild-type CTL, and adoptive transfer of pfp(-/-) CTL was as efficient as wild-type CTL in causing regression of established Renca pulmonary metastases. Therefore, although granule-mediated killing is of paramount importance for CTL-mediated lysis in vitro, some major in vivo effector mechanisms clearly are independent of perforin.     

Identification of a novel population of highly cytotoxic c‐Met‐expressing CD8+ T lymphocytes

CD8⁺ cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) are critical mediators of anti‐tumor immunity, and controlling the mechanisms that govern CTL functions could be crucial for enhancing patient outcome. Previously, we reported that hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) limits effective murine CTL responses via antigen‐presenting cells. Here, we show that a fraction of murine effector CTLs expresses the HGF receptor c‐Met (c‐Met⁺ CTLs). Phenotypic and functional analysis of c‐Met⁺ CTLs reveals that they display enhanced cytolytic capacities compared to their c‐Met^? CTL counterparts. Furthermore, HGF directly restrains the cytolytic function of c‐Met⁺ CTLs in cell‐mediated cytotoxicity reactions in vitro and in vivo and abrogates T‐cell responses against metastatic melanoma in vivo. Finally, we establish in three murine tumor settings and in human melanoma tissues that c‐Met⁺ CTLs are a naturally occurring CD8⁺ T‐cell population. Together, our findings suggest that the HGF/c‐Met pathway could be exploited to control CD8⁺ T‐cell‐mediated anti‐tumor immunity.     

DNA Fragmentation Induced by Cytotoxic T Lymphocytes Can Result in Target Cell Death

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL)-mediated lysis is accompanied by fragmentation of target cell DNA into an oligonucleosome ladder, a hallmark of apoptosis. Is this a fortuitous coincidence, or could CTL be inducing lysis by activation of the suicide signal? In this report we demonstrate that CTL-mediated target cell death can be blocked with the drug aurintricarboxylic acid (ATA). The abrogation of death correlates with the inhibition of DNA fragmentation. While ATA prevented DNA fragmentation, it failed to significantly alter protein, RNA, or DNA synthesis in the cell lines over the dose range used. In addition, there was no inhibition of cell-cell interaction or granule exocytosis during CTL-mediated killing. ATA also significantly inhibited the cytolysis and DNA fragmentation mediated by isolated cytolytic granules, as well as the granular protein fragmentin. We developed an assay in which target cells could be separated from CTL after binding and programming for lysis. Once they had received the "kiss of death," target cells could be rescued from lysis (as indicated by inhibition of DNA fragmentation and increased target cell viability) by treatment with ATA. These results suggest that ATA blocks target cell death by inhibition of DNA fragmentation, and further, that chromatin degradation is a cause rather than a result of cell death in CTL-mediated lysis.     

Cloned cytotoxic T lymphocyte target cells fail to induce early activation events in effector cytotoxic T lymphocytes

We have explored further the basis for resistance of cloned cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) to cell-mediated cytotoxicity. We find that most cloned CTLs recognized as specific target cells by other cloned CTLs used as effector cells fail to activate three early events that may be critical in triggering lysis in the effector CTLs: Ca2+ influx, microtubule organizing center (MTOC) reorientation, and serine esterase release. To the extent that any or all of these events are involved in activation or expression of the lytic pathway in effector CTLs, our results suggest that in addition to being inherently resistant to cytotoxic granule extracts, many CTLs are also unable to induce lytic function in other (effector) CTLs. We have found one CTL clone that can respond to recognizable cloned CTL target cells with at least MTOC reorientation and serine esterase release, although the target CTLs are still not lysed. In this case, the resistance of the target CTL to lysis may be due solely to its resistance to cytoplasmic granule contents.     

Class II antigen-specific murine cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL). I. Analysis of bulk populations and establishment of Lyt-2+L3T4- and Lyt-2-L3T4+ bulk CTL lines

Murine allogeneic cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTLs), including long-term bulk CTL lines, were induced in I-region-incompatible combinations of strains in vitro in order to study the phenotypes of class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigen-specific CTLs, as well as the possible functional involvement of accessory cell interaction molecules such as Lyt-2 and L3T4. This report shows that class II-specific allogeneic CTL populations consist of two types of T cells. Lyt-2+L3T4- (2+4-) and Lyt-2-L3T4+ (2-4+), in variable proportions depending on the strain combination, that in vitro bulk CTL lines with each of these phenotypes can be established, that the killing function of 2-4+ CTL is sensitive to the blocking effect of anti-L3T4 antibodies, suggesting functional involvement of this molecule in the CTL-target interaction, that anti-Lyt-2 antibodies fail to block killing by 2+4- cells, suggesting that such CTLs do not utilize this molecule in their killing function, and that while I-A-specific CTLs of both phenotypes are detectable, 2-4+ cells could not be detected among I-E-specific CTL populations.     

Regulation of the expression on mouse T lymphocytes of the epitope identified by monoclonal antibody 3A35

Monoclonal antibody 3A35 (MA 3A35) has previously been shown to be an activation marker of macrophages and T lymphocytes. It immunoprecipitated from macrophages a 200-kDa molecule belonging to the T200 family and from T cells a 85-kDa antigen. In the present work, the factors controlling the expression of the epitope identified by MA 3A35 on polyclonal activated T cells and T-cell clones, as well as the ability of 3A35 alone or together with complement to interfere with T-cell functions, were investigated. Corticoresistant thymocytes unreactive with MA 3A35 became fully reactive after 2 days of in vitro stimulation by PMA and IL-2 and the level of reactivity per cell declined to a low level thereafter. In helper and cytolytic T-cell clones, the expression of the epitope defined by MA 3A35 was also maximal soon after antigenic stimulation then declined. In helper-T-cell clones, the epitope remained detectable during the entire culture period, whereas in cytolytic clones its expression was markedly reduced at the end of the culture. The lineage of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) as studied in a bulk culture of spleen cells primed in vivo against a syngeneic tumor exhibited similar regulation by antigenic stimulation. The CTL precursors were resistant to lysis by MA 3A35 plus complement; after 3 days of culture with the stimulatory antigen, they became highly sensitive but their sensitivity then diminished and mature CTL were completely resistant. MA 3A35 plus complement also killed the activated T cells which responded to macrophage-presented antigens and were thought to be mainly Lyt-1+. Therefore, the epitope identified by MA 3A35 was expressed predominantly at an early stage of T-cell activation. At a late stage, it persisted almost exclusively on helper and Lyt-1+ cells. In addition, MA 3A35 plus complement lysed NK cells, AK cells, and their precursors present in normal spleen. In the absence of complement, MA 3A35 had no detectable effect on T-cell functions.     

Mechanisms of lymphocyte-mediated lysis

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) and natural killer (NK) cells use multiple mechanisms to destroy their target cells. Pore formation resulting in osmotic lysis of the target is one mechanism; the pore-forming protein (perforin) responsible for this activity has been purified. Antigenically and functionally it resembles proteins of the membrane attack complex of complement. The other known mediators of cytotoxicity appear to be closely interrelated. Tumor necrosis factor (TNF), lymphotoxin (LT), and leukalexin are the three members of this group that have been purified, although their mechanisms of action are still unknown. CTLs fragment the DNA of target cells, as do TNF, LT, and leukalexin; this may be one of the mechanisms of action of these mediators. CTLs and NK cells do not self lyse. The basis of this phenomenon is unclear, although recent advances have shed some light on the problem.