Can an a priori strategy be developed for biological control? The case of Onopordum spp. thistles in Australia

Abstract  Between 1992 and 2000, seven insect agents were released in Australia for the biological control of Onopordum spp. thistles. This paper describes the protocol used for the selection of these agents, starting with the development of a preliminary strategy, based on the ecology and population dynamics of the target weed. The strategy informed the surveys for natural enemies in the native range of Onopordum , targeting insects that attacked key transitional stages of the weed's life cycle. Ongoing studies of Onopordum populations in both Australia and Europe, plus experimental studies on the ecology, potential impact and preliminary host specificity of the agents, led to the refinement of the strategy and the selection and prioritisation of the agents. It is argued that development of an explicit strategy prior to release should be encouraged, as it forces researchers to revisit the rationale for and aims of particular biological control projects, ensuring that the process of agent selection remains focused. It also provides a tool to improve the process of agent selection, as subsequent results can be measured against the strategy and agent success or failure evaluated against the a priori expectations.     

Structure of the phytophagous insect fauna of Onopordum thistles in the northern Mediterranean basin

Thistles of the genus Onopordum (Asteraceae: Cardueae) have become serious weed problems in parts of Australia and North America following introduction from their native Eurasian ranges, and are the target of a biological control programme in Australia. This paper analyses the results of three separate surveys of insects feeding and breeding on thistles of the genus Onopordum in the Mediterranean region. Of the 129 species found feeding, 74 species also bred on these thistles. Endophages comprised 54% of the breeding insects, with species that fed in the capitula and within the rosette crown/root area predominating. The Coleoptera and Hemiptera were the dominant endophage and ectophage taxa, respectively. Differences in the Onopordum fauna were noted between host species and between geographic regions, but this was largely due to the generalist component of the fauna. Onopordum specialists showed little variability across regions or between different species within the host genus. On comparing the fauna of Onopordum with that of other thistle genera, it was suggested that plant-herbivore interactions between Onopordum and its fauna are less highly evolved, in that there is less host specialization and a lesser degree of niche partitioning. This appears to be related to the low rate of speciation and habitat specialization within the host genus itself. The potential of certain genus-specific insects as biological control agents for Onopordum spp. is discussed. It is argued that the absence of a high degree of niche specialization could favour successful biological control, as the agent would be capable of inflicting damage over a wider range of resource gradients.     

Potential Impact of the Stem-boring Weevil Lixus cardui on the Growth and Reproductive Capacity of Onopordum Thistles

Using plants grown in large field cages, it was shown that heavy feeding by the weevil, Lixus cardui, reduced both the plant growth and reproductive capacity of Onopordum thistles. At high initial densities of adult weevils, the plant height and biomass were reduced by up to 50%. Fewer capitula were produced on Lixus -attacked plants, and these were smaller, suffered higher levels of abortion and produced ca. 80% fewer viable seeds. Attacked plants senesced 2-3 weeks earlier than unattacked plants and late-developing capitula aborted, causing a shortening of the normal flowering period. At extreme density levels, where survival of the weevils themselves was affected, damage levels were even greater. It was not possible to separate the contributions of damage by adults, which destroyed 30-40% of leaf tissue, from that by larvae, which hatched from eggs laid in the stems and mined the pith and cambium tissue. This was, however, not essential for the purpose of demonstrating the weevil's potential to contribute to biological control of the target thistles. It was considered that even a lower impact in the field would enable L. cardui to complement agents that had already been released, or were planned for release against Onopordum spp. in Australia and would reduce the competitiveness of these weeds in infested pastures.     

Effects of grazing on soil seed bank dynamics: An approach with functional groups

Abstract. The relationship between intensity and timing of cattle grazing on changes in the size and composition of the soil seed bank were investigated in a 3‐yr study in a Mediterranean grassland in northeastern Israel. Treatments included manipulations of stocking rates and of grazing regimes, in a factorial design. The retrieved soil seed bank community was rich in species, with 133 species accounting for 80% of the 166 species recorded at the site. Within the seed bank, 89% of the species were annuals. Seed bank dynamics was analysed in terms of plant functional groups and germination strategies. In terms of total seed bank density and including all functional groups, 42% of the seeds present in the soil did not germinate under watering conditions. The dormancy level differed greatly among functional groups. The seed bank of annual legumes, crucifers, annual thistles and annual forbs had a large fraction of non‐germinated seeds and characterized areas grazed early in the growing season under high and very high grazing intensity. These functional groups were considered to have a higher potential for persistent seed banks production. In contrast, short and tall annual grasses and tall perennial grasses, that were dominant in ungrazed or moderately grazed paddocks, generally had seed banks with a very small fraction of non‐germinated seeds. Seed bank densities varied widely between grazing treatments and years. Under continuous grazing, heavy grazing pressure reduced seed bank densities of grasses and crucifers in comparison to moderate grazing. The greatest reduction on the seed bank densities resulted from heavy grazing concentrated during the seed‐set stages.     

Comparative biology of two rosette crown-feeding flies of the genus Botanophila (Dipt., Anthomyiidae) with potential for biological control of their thistle hosts

The comparative biology of two anthomyiid flies with potential for biological control of their host thistles, Botanophila turcica on Carthamus lanatus and Botanophila spinosa on Onopordum acanthium , was studied using field surveys and collections, and by rearing collected eggs and larvae in the laboratory in southern France. The thistle hosts are significant weeds outside their native range, particularly in Australia. Both flies attack the rosette meristems of their hosts prior to flowering. Larval stages are described together with natural attack rates (21–33% of field plants) and the mortality of field-collected larvae reared in the laboratory. A successful rearing protocol for these flies is also described. The results of preliminary host-specificity tests showed that both species are highly specific, being restricted to their host genus in the tests conducted. Furthermore, Botanophila turcica could not complete development on safflower (a congener of its natural host) under natural conditions. Botanophila turcica had an adult activity period that lasted 6 months from late autumn and laid fewer eggs per host plant than B. spinosa , which was active for 2 to 3 months in spring. Only one parasitoid was observed, an endoparasitic eucoilid, Trybliographa sp., which attacked both fly species, causing 18–23% mortality.     

土壤种子库的研究进展及若干研究热点

 土壤种子库是指存在于表层土壤（包括凋落物）中的有生命的种子。土壤种子库的研究已是植物生态学研究不可缺少的一部分,现已成为植物种群生态学中比较活跃的领域。土壤种子库时期是植物种群生活史的一个重要阶段,有人称之为潜种群阶段。土壤种子库对一年生植物来说尤其重要。土壤种子库简单地可分为瞬时土壤种子库和长久土壤种子库,即使给予理想的萌发条件如季节、温度、湿度等,土壤种子库中也仍有部分种子保持休眠状态,休眠的种子组成了土壤长久种子库的成分。时空异质性是土壤种子库的基本特性之一,不仅不同植被类型的土壤种子库具有不同的组成、大小和多样性,而且微环境也影响土壤种子库的分布格局。由于萌发、捕食和衰老等原因,土壤种子库具有季节动态,一般在旧种子萌发之后,新种子散布之前达到最低点。在高等植物占据的大多数生境中,以休眠繁殖体形式存在的个体远远超过地上植株的数量;土壤种子库、幼苗库和成年植被相互联系相互影响。由于各种原因如群落类型的差异、群落的演替阶段、取样的时间等,地上植被和土壤种子库之间关系大体上可分为两种情况,即相似性和差异性;研究土壤种子库的方法通常有萌发法和物理分离法。土壤种子库能部分反应群落的历史,对退化生态系统的恢复起着重要的作用。目前土壤种子库的主要研究热点问题可分为以下几个方面：1）土壤种子库的研究方法,2）土壤种子库的分类问题,3）土壤种子库分布的时空格局,4）地上植被和土壤种子库的关系,5）土壤种子库的动态等。     

The taxonomic status of Larinus cynarae F. and Larinus latus Herbst (coleoptera: Curculionidae), and its implications for the biological control of Onopordum (asteraceae: Cardueae) in Australia

Analyses were made of the allozyme frequencies of sympatric populations of the capitulum weevils L. latus Herbst and Larinus cyarae F. in Greece. It was found that the two taxa are genetically isolated and that they can therefore be considered as separate species. This complemented ecological data showing separation of the L. latus and L. cynarae populations by their choice of Onopordum illyricum L. and Cynara cardunculus, respectively, as hosts. Onopordum spp. are serious weed problems in Australia while Cynara contains several crop plants. L. latus is a potential biological control agent of Onopordum spp., but its use had been compromised by the uncertainty of the taxonomic distinctness from L. cynarae, biotypes of which are pests of artichoke Cynara scolymus L. Clarification of its taxonomic status lifts these reservations and clears the way for the introduction of L. latus into Australia for the biological control of Onopordum thistles.     

土壤种子库的研究现状与进展综述

土壤种子库是指存在于土壤表层掉落物和土壤中全部活性种子的总和。土壤种子库是现在植物种群生态学研究中不可缺少的一部分。土壤种子库时期是植物种群生活史的一个重要阶段,有人称之为潜种群阶段,是种群的定居、生存、繁衍和扩散的基础。土壤种子库理论作为群落生态学和恢复生态学的基础理论,是退化生态系统重建的重要组成部分,已成为植物生态学研究的热点问题。随着其发生发展,土壤种子库研究方法更加科学准确,研究内容得到了不间断的更新和补充,研究领域涉及了植物学、遗传学、生态学、杂草科学和农学等各科学。至此,土壤种子库已经形成了相对完善的理论框架,主要包括:1.土壤种子库的研究的沿革;2.土壤种子库的特征3.土壤种子库的动态变化4.土壤种子库的分类问题5.土壤种子库的研究方法6.对植物生态学的贡献。     

The role of area enclosures and fallow age in the restoration of plant diversity in northern Ethiopia

This study investigated the roles played by area enclosures and fallow age in the restoration of plant species richness and soil seed bank species richness in degraded mountain rangelands in northern Ethiopia. Management types (enclosures versus grazed) influenced woody and herbaceous species richness, while fallow age showed no effect on the woody species. Management, age and the doubling of fallow age influenced the herbaceous species richness and species diversity. Management showed no effect on soil seed bank species richness. Fallow age and the doubling of fallow time also showed no influence on the soil seed bank of grass species, but they were influential on the forbs species soil seed bank. The trends for restoration of plant species richness and diversity and grass seed bank in response to fallow age were positive‐linear, but they declined when the fallow ages were doubled. The exception was the forbs seed bank showed linear trends when age of restoration was doubled. The data suggest that the restoration of degraded rangelands in the high mountain zones of northern Ethiopia was still in the weedy succession stages. Long‐term monitoring will be required to gain an informed understanding of the roles played by area enclosures and fallow age in the restoration of plant biodiversity.     

Host-specificity of Candidate Agents for the Biological Control of Onopordum spp. Thistles in Australia: an Assessment of Testing Procedures

This paper describes a series of host-specificity tests carried out to evaluate the safety of eight insects for release in Australia as biological control agents of Onopordum spp. thistles; Larinus latus L., Lixus cardui Ol. and Trichosirocalus briesei Alonso-Zarazaga & Sanchez-Ruiz (Coleoptera: Curculionidae), Tephritis postica Loew and Urophora terebrans Loew (Diptera: Tephritidae), Botanophila spinosa Rondani (Diptera: Anthomyiidae), Tettigometra sulphurea Mulsant & Rey. (Hemiptera: Fulgoroidae) and Eublemma amoena (Hbn.) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). Preliminary tests were first carried out against key test plants in the country of origin to determine whether it was worth proceeding with formal testing under quarantine conditions in Australia. In the formal testing procedure, the test plant list was based solely on phylogenetic relationships. The life-stage of each insect tested was selected with respect to its biology and behaviour, e.g. only oviposition was tested for insect species with immobile endophagous larvae, while larval host utilization was tested for those with mobile larval stages. The initial laboratory experiments for each species used were caged no-choice tests, as confinement without choice can elicit extreme behavioural responses, making negative results extremely robust. Where positive results occurred, insects where re-exposed to the plant, but this time given a choice between the target and non-target plants. The results of these tests, plus data from open-field preliminary tests in the country of origin, helped interpret results and determine the risk posed by each candidate biological control agent to non-target plant species. Following submission, all eight candidates were approved for release by the Australian plant biosecurity and conservation authorities. Based on a comparison of the eight species tested, it is recommended that host-specificity testing be kept flexible and pragmatic, rather than moving towards a formulaic risk assessment procedure. Moreover, given the improved state of knowledge of plant phylogenies and the evolution of host utilization, it is time to base testing procedures purely on phylogenetic grounds, without the need to include less related test species solely because of economic or conservation reasons.     

Amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) reveals introgression in weedy Onopordum thistles: hybridization and invasion

Onopordum L. (Compositae) is an extremely diverse genus of thistles, which includes several species that have become serious pasture weeds in several regions of the world. We present a comparison of the genetic diversity in invasive forms of Onopordum from Australia with several known native European species. A total of 108 polymorphic genetic markers was generated using amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) fingerprinting. Non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS) revealed that Australia contained O. acanthium, O. illyricum and a full range of genetic intermediates between these species. Intermediates largely comprised segregating fragments diagnostic for European O. acanthium and O. illyricum with a low frequency of fragments that were diagnostic for other species never recorded in Australia. The current genetic patterns in Australia may be best explained by a combination of processes, both in the native and in the alien range. These include multiple introductions of seed, including hybrid material, and the continuous dispersal in Australia, leading to an increase in the contact among hybridizing taxa. Such processes appear to have produced more widespread hybridization and introgression in Australian Onopordum than is found in Europe.     

Grazing impact on desert plants and soil seed banks: Implications for seed-eating animals

We assess whether the knowledge of livestock diet helps to link grazing effects with changes in plant cover and soil seed bank size, aiming at inferring the consequences of grazing on seed-eating animals. Specifically, we test whether continuous and heavy grazing reduce the cover, number of reproductive structures and seed reserves of the same grass species whose seeds are selected and preferred by granivorous animals in the central Monte desert, Argentina. Grass cover and the number of grass spikes usually diminished under grazing conditions in the two localities studied (Telteca and Ñacuñán), and soil seed bank was consistently reduced in all three years evaluated owing to a decline of perennial grass and forb seeds. In particular, the abundance of those seeds selected and preferred by birds and ants (in all cases grass species) declined 70–92% in Ñacuñán, and 52–72% in Telteca. Reduction of perennial grass cover and spike number in grazed sites reinforced the causal link between livestock grazing and the decline of grass soil seed reserves throughout failed plant reproduction. Grass seed bank depletion suggests that grazing may trigger a “cascade” of mechanisms that affect the abundance and persistence of valuable fodder species as well as the availability of seed resources for granivorous animals.     

沙丘生态系统种子库研究现状、趋势与挑战

风蚀和沙埋赋予沙丘生态系统独特的自然物理和生物过程。沙丘生态系统种子库研究对于沙区植物多样性保护和生态恢复至关重要。但是人们对沙丘生态系统种子库的时空格局、形成机制和生态功能的认识还很肤浅。近些年, 沙丘生态系统种子库开始受到关注。该文对20年来沙丘生态系统种子库研究进行了回顾总结, 论述了沙丘生态系统种子库研究现状, 剖析了沙丘生态系统种子库现有结论, 阐述了沙丘生态系统种子库研究趋势与面临的挑战。沙丘生态系统种子库研究已获得以下认识: 1)沙丘生态系统类型、部位和深度决定种子库大小与组成; 2)沙丘生态系统种子库季节、年际变化受风沙活动和降水调控; 3)沙丘生态系统种子库受各种干扰的综合影响; 4)生境对沙丘生态系统种子库具有重要影响; 5)沙丘生态系统种子库结构和组成与植物繁殖对策密切关联; 6)种子库对沙丘生态系统植被恢复贡献率因沙丘类型而异。沙丘生态系统种子库研究应强化如下方面: 1)种子库区域分异规律研究; 2)种子库与植物生活史阶段的联系的研究; 3)多种干扰方式综合影响下的种子库研究; 4)种子库对沙丘生态系统植被恢复贡献的研究; 5)沙丘生态系统自然物理过程与种子库耦联关系的研究。     

Earthworms promote greater richness and abundance in the emergence of plant species across a grassland-forest ecotone

Aims Chalk grasslands are subject to vegetation dynamics that range from species-rich open grasslands to tall and encroached grasslands, and woods and forests. In grasslands, earthworms impact plant communities and ecosystem functioning through the modification of soil physical, chemical and microbiological properties, but also through their selective ingestion and vertical transportation of seeds from the soil seed bank. Laboratory experiments showed that seed–earthworm interactions are species specific, but little is known on the impact of seed–earthworm interactions in the field. The overall aim of this study was to better understand seed–earthworm interactions and their impact on the plant community. First we analyzed the composition of seedlings emerging from casts after earthworm ingestion. Then we compared seedling composition in casts to the plant composition of emerging seedlings from the soil and of the aboveground vegetation along four stages of the secondary succession of chalk grasslands.Methods Four stages of the secondary succession of a chalk grassland—from open sward to woods—were sampled in Upper Normandy, France, in February 2010. Within each successional stage (×3 replicates), we sampled the standing vegetation, soil seed bank at three soil depths (0–2, 2–5 and 5–10cm) and earthworm surface casts along transects. Soil and cast samples were water sieved before samples were spread onto trays and placed into a greenhouse. Emerging seedlings were counted and identified. Effect of successional stage and origin of samples on mean and variability of abundance and species richness of seedlings emerging from casts and soil seed banks were analyzed. Plant compositions were compared between all sample types. We used generalized mixed-effect models and a distance-based redundancy multivariate analysis.Important findings Seedling abundance was always higher in earthworm casts than in the soil seed bank and increased up to 5-fold, 4-fold and 3.5-fold, respectively, in the tall grassland, woods and encroached grassland compared to the soil surface layer. Species richness was also higher in earthworm casts than in the soil seed bank in all successional stages, with a 4-fold increase in the encroached grassland. The plant composition of the standing vegetation was more similar to that of seedlings from casts than to that of seedlings from the soil seed bank. Seedlings diversity emerging from casts in the tall and encroached grasslands tended toward the diversity found in woods. Our results indicate that earthworms may promote the emergence of seedlings. We also suggest that the loss of some plant species in the seed bank and the tall grass vegetation in intermediary successional stages modify the local conditions and prevent the further establishment of early-successional plant species.     

The relationship between soil seed bank,above‐ground vegetation and disturbance intensity on old‐field successional permanent plots

Questions: How does disturbance and successional age influence richness, size and composition of the soil seed bank? What is the potential contribution of the soil seed bank to the plant community composition on sites differing in their successional age or disturbance intensity? Location: Experimental Botanical Garden of Göttingen University, central Germany. Methods: Above‐ground vegetation and soil seed bank were studied on formerly arable fields in a 36‐year‐old permanent plot study with five disturbance intensities, ranging from yearly ploughing via mowing to long‐term uninterrupted succession. We compared species compositions, seed densities and functional features of the seed bank and above‐ground vegetation by using several methods in parallel. Results: The seed bank was mainly composed of early successional species typical of strongly disturbed habitats. The difference between seed bank composition and above‐ground vegetation decreased with increasing disturbance intensity. The species of greatest quantitative importance in the seed bank was the non‐native forb Solidago canadensis. Conclusions: The ability of a plant community to regenerate from the soil seed bank dramatically decreases with increasing time since abandonment (successional age) and with decreasing disturbance intensity. The present study underlines that plant species typical of grasslands and woodlands are limited by dispersal capacity, owing to low capacity for accumulation of seeds in the soil and the fact that most species do not build up persistent seed banks. Rare and target species were almost absent from the seed bank and will, after local elimination, depend on reintroduction for continuation of their presence.     

Exotic thistles increase native ant abundance through the maintenance of enhanced aphid populations

Exotic species change the structure and composition of invaded communities in multiple ways, but the sign of their impact on native species is still controversial. We evaluated the effects of the thistles Carduus thoermeri and Onopordum acanthium—two of the most abundant exotic plant species in disturbed areas of the Patagonian steppe—on the native tending ant assemblage. Exotic thistles showed an increased number of plants with aphids and had greater aphid density than native plants. Since native tending ants were present only in plants with aphids, their abundance was higher in infested thistles than in native plants. Path analyses confirmed that ant activity depended more on aphid density than on thistle traits. Our results suggest that the presence of exotic thistles in disturbed areas of NW Patagonia indirectly benefit the native ant assemblage through the maintenance of an increased aphid population. This illustrates how the impact of exotic on native species can depend on the ecological context.     

Large herbivores as mobile links between isolated nature reserves through adhesive seed dispersal

Question: Do large herbivores contribute to the dispersal of plant seeds between isolated habitats by epizoochory? Location: Nature reserves in Flanders, Belgium. Methods: Epizoochory was studied by brushing plant seeds from the fur of 201 domesticated large herbivores (Galloway cattle, donkeys and horses), grazing in 27 Flemish nature reserves. Several herbivores were examined after transport between different nature reserves as part of the seasonal grazing system in Flanders, allowing detection of seed dispersal both within and between reserves. The seedling emergence method was used to identify the dispersed plant species. Results: In total, 6385 epizoochorous seeds from 75 species germinated, yet the real seed quantity was underestimated by the seedling emergence method. A wide variety of seed morphology, seed weights and plant heights was represented among the dispersed species, many of which had a transient seed bank. There was a gradual turnover in epizoochorous species composition in the course of the vegetation season, and seed dispersal occurred both within and between different nature reserves. Conclusions: Domesticated large herbivores, as models for wild mammals in the present and the past, are important dispersers of many plant species. Through seasonal grazing, the herbivores function as ‘mobile link organisms’, connecting isolated nature reserves through seed dispersal, possibly influencing vegetation development and long‐term survival of plant populations. As such, large herbivores are important instruments in ecological restoration, especially in fragmented ecosystems.     

Recent advances in soil seed bank research

Soil seed bank is an important component of ecosystem resilience and represents a stock of regeneration potential in many plant assemblages. Soil seed banks can be used to predict the composition of new plant recruitment. Species overcome periods of unfavorable weather conditions by building up a large seed bank. With this strategy, the species diversity is preserved and information on their dynamics and structure is retained. The research on soil seed bank has received wide interest because of its important role in plantation renovation and restoration, biological diversity preservation, vegetation succession and diffusion processes and other aspects. This paper reviews the relationship between soil seed bank and disturbance, geographic factor, vegetation and seed size and is aimed at providing some useful reference for future research.     

Soil seed bank and driftline composition along a successional gradient on a temperate salt marsh

Abstract. This study focuses on the relationship between vegetation succession and soil seed bank composition on the Schiermonnikoog (The Netherlands) salt marsh over 100 yr. The importance of driftline material in seed dispersal and the relationship with succession is also investigated. The results indicate that the majority of species have a transient or short‐term seed persistent bank. Seeds of most species are able to float over the salt marsh and become concentrated in the driftline higher up the marsh. After plants have established a seed bank forms, which disappears when vegetation is replaced by later‐successional species. Exceptions are Spergularia mar‐itima, which is still present in the seed bank of late successional stages, and Juncus gerardi and Glaux maritima, which appear in the seed bank of early successional stages, but are absent in the vegetation. Based on the results of this study constraints and possibilities for salt‐marsh restoration by de‐embankment are discussed.     

The role of soil seed banks in the restoration of dry acidic dune grassland after burning of Ulex europaeus scrub

Question: Can the seed bank play a significant role in the restoration of plant communities of dry acidic dune grassland where fire has destroyed Ulex europaeus scrub? Location: Northern French Atlantic coast. Methods: One year after the fire, the seed bank and vegetation were sampled in 1 m × 1 m plots along three transects from the oldest scrub vegetation towards the grassland. Differences in species richness, seed density and contribution of ecological groups in the seed bank and vegetation along the transects were analysed. Results: Seed density and species richness in the seed bank decreased significantly from the grassland towards the centre of the scrub vegetation; 50% of the seed bank consisted of core species of the target plant community, such as Carex arenaria, Aira praecox, Rumex acetosella and Agrostis capillaris. Seeds of these species were also found in the deeper soil layers beneath the oldest scrub vegetation, indicating that they can be considered to be long‐term persistent. Beneath the youngest scrub vegetation, seeds of rare satellite target species also occurred. However, no target species were established on the burned site after one year, resulting in a large discrepancy between seed bank and vegetation. Conclusions: Although the seeds present in the soil indicate that restoration of the acidic grassland based on the seed bank is possible, additional management actions such as mowing and soil disturbance may be necessary to restrict resprouting of Ulex and to stimulate the germination of seeds of target species in the deeper soil layers.