Saprophytic survival of Gaeumannomyces graminis and Phialophora spp. at various temperature-moisture regimes

The saprophytic survival of the pathogen, Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici and two isolates each of three avirulent fungi, G. graminis var. graminis, Phialophora graminicola and a lobed-hyphopodiate Phialophora sp. was studied in two soil types under controlled temperature and moisture conditions in the laboratory. In general, the fungi survived longest in the cool, dry soil (15°C, < -10 MPa) followed by the warm dry soil (30°C, < -10 MPa). All the fungi were virtually eliminated from the warm, moist soil (30°C, -0.3 MPa) after 3 months. Survival was intermediate under cool, moist conditions (15°C, -0.3 MPa). Under cool, moist conditions, G. graminis var. graminis survived better than the other three fungi in the first 3 months in both soil types and continued to do so for a further 3 months in one soil. Both isolates of the lobed-hyphopodiate Phialophora sp. survived poorly in the two soil types being almost eliminated after 3 months. There were considerable differences between the survival of the two isolates each of G. graminis var. graminis and P. graminicola, especially under cool, moist conditions. Of the six avirulent isolates studied, one isolate of G. graminis var. graminis (DAR24167) survived best under the three temperature-moisture regimes which showed differences. It also survived better than the take-all fungus under moist, cool conditions and at a comparable rate under dry conditions. Therefore, this variation in survival should be considered when selecting antagonists for the biological control of take-all.     

Effect of temperature on growth of some avirulent fungi and cross-protection against the wheat take-all fungus

The linear growth rates of Gaeumannomyces graminis var. graminis, G. graminis var. tritici, Phialophora radicicola var. graminicola and a lobed hyphopodiate Phialophora sp. were studied on agar at various temperatures between 5 and 30 °C and on wheat roots at two temperature regimes (12 h at 7°/12 h at 13 °C and 12 h at 17°/12 h at 23 °C). On agar at 30 °C, the isolates of G. graminis graminis grew faster than those of G. graminis tritici and Phialophora sp. but three isolates of G. g. graminis grew more slowly than the other two fungi at 5 and 10 °C. Two other isolates of G. g. graminis were cold-tolerant and had growth rates comparable to those of G. g. tritici and Phialophora sp. at 10 °C. The growth rates of Australian isolates of P. radicicola graminicolu were similar to that of a British isolate and were about a third to a half those of the other three fungi at most temperatures. The growth rates of the fungi on wheat roots at the low and high temperature regimes were correlated with the growth rates on agar at 10 and 20 °C respectively. The correlation was better at low temperatures r= 0.81) than at high temperatures (r = 0.62). Cross-protection experiments using two G. g. graminis isolates which grow poorly at temperatures below 15 °C and a cold-tolerant isolate each of G. g. graminis and Phialophora sp. showed that, while all four fungi protected wheat against take-all at high temperatures (17/23 °C) as evidenced by less severe disease and significantly greater dry weights, only the cold-tolerant fungi were effective at low temperatures (7/13 °C). The use of cold-tolerant isolates of avirulent fungi in field experiments may result in better protection in the early stages of wheat growth when Australian soil temperatures are mostly below 15 °C.     

Control of Ophiobolus patch in Agrostis turf using avirulent fungi and take-all suppressive soils in pot experiments

The incorporation of avirulent fungi such as Gaeumannomyces graminis var. graminis, an avirulent isolate of G. graminis var. tritici, a Phialophora sp. with lobed hyphopodia synonymous with Phialophora radiciola var. radicicola sensu Deacon and P. radicicola var. graminicola at the time of seeding Agrostis turf in pots of sterilised soil completely controlled Ophiobolus patch disease. The addition of a 5 mm layer of take-all suppressive (TAS) soils, artifically developed by the repeated addition of live mycelium of the varieties avenae, tritici and graminis of G. graminis to soil, controlled the disease to a lesser extent. However, a 20 mm layer of a TAS soil developed from live mycelium of G. g. avenae almost completely suppressed the disease. A survey of 66 golf and bowling greens in four states of Australia showed that P. r. graminicola was the most prevalent avirulent fungus.     

Failure of in vitro growth inhibition by cysteine to differentiate between Australian Gaeumannomyces graminis isolates pathogenic and non-pathogenic to oats

Radial growth of oat and non oat-attacking Australian isolates of Gaeumannomyces graminis was greatly inhibited by increasing concentration of DL-cysteine in basal medium agar, and growth was completely inhibited by cysteine concentrations of 3 μM. As a group, isolates of G. graminis var. tritici (both oat and non oat-attacking forms) were more inhibited than isolates of G.graminis var.avenae at 1 μM cysteine, but differences did not occur at other concentrations. Isolates of a lobed-hyphodiate fungus similar to G. graminis var. graminis were more tolerant of cysteine than other isolates. The findings indicate that in vitro inhibition of Australian G. graminis isolates by cysteine is not useful for differentiation between oat and non oat-attacking types, and is unlikely to be fundamentally related to the ability of isolates to attack oats.     

Detoxification of Benzoxazolinone Allelochemicals from Wheat by Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici, G. graminis var. graminis, G. graminis var. avenae, and Fusarium culmorum

The ability of phytopathogenic fungi to overcome the chemical defense barriers of their host plants is of great importance for fungal pathogenicity. We studied the role of cyclic hydroxamic acids and their related benzoxazolinones in plant interactions with pathogenic fungi. We identified species-dependent differences in the abilities of Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici, Gaeumannomyces graminis var. graminis, Gaeumannomyces graminis var. avenae, and Fusarium culmorum to detoxify these allelochemicals of gramineous plants. The G. graminis var. graminis isolate degraded benzoxazolin-2(3H)-one (BOA) and 6-methoxy-benzoxazolin-2(3H)-one (MBOA) more efficiently than did G. graminis var. tritici and G. graminis var. avenae. F. culmorum degraded BOA but not MBOA. N-(2-Hydroxyphenyl)-malonamic acid and N-(2-hydroxy-4-methoxyphenyl)-malonamic acid were the primary G. graminis var. graminis and G. graminis var. tritici metabolites of BOA and MBOA, respectively, as well as of the related cyclic hydroxamic acids. 2-Amino-3H-phenoxazin-3-one was identified as an additional G. graminis var. tritici metabolite of BOA. No metabolite accumulation was detected for G. graminis var. avenae and F. culmorum by high-pressure liquid chromatography. The mycelial growth of the pathogenic fungi was inhibited more by BOA and MBOA than by their related fungal metabolites. The tolerance of Gaeumannomyces spp. for benzoxazolinone compounds is correlated with their detoxification ability. The ability of Gaeumannomyces isolates to cause root rot symptoms in wheat (cultivars Rektor and Astron) parallels their potential to degrade wheat allelochemicals to nontoxic compounds.     

Pectolytic enzymes activity and pathogenicity ofGaeumannomyces graminis var.tritici and related Phialophora-like fungi

Gaeumannmyces graminis var.tritici (Ggt), Phialophora sp. (lobed hyphopodia) andPhialophora graminicola vere grown in a liquid medium with pectin and on autoclaved wheat roots (root media) and the activity of pectolytic enzymes in culture filtrates was measured. Most strains of the fungi exhibited polygalacturonate trans-eliminase activity but no pectin methylesterase activity was detected.Ggt polygalacturonase was found in culture filtrates from all the media used whilePhialophora sp. did not exhibit activity of this enzyme in the unbuffered root media. No polygalacturonase activity was demonstrated forP. graminicola. A correlation was found (r=0.548) betweenin vitro polygalacturonase activity and the pathogenicity ofGgt to wheat seedlings.     

Origin and Inheritance of Group I Introns in 26S rRNA Genes of Gaeumannomyces graminis

Studies of the distribution of the three group I introns (intron A, intron T, and intron AT) in the 26S rDNA of Gaeumannomyces graminis had suggested that they were transferred to a common ancestor of G. graminis var. avenae and var. tritici after it had branched off from var. graminis. Intron AT and intron A exhibited vertical inheritance and coevolved in concert with their hosts. Intron loss could occur after its acquisition. Loss of any one of the three introns could occur in var. tritici whereas only loss of intron T had been found in the majority of var. avenae isolates. The existence of isolates of var. tritici and var. avenae with three introns suggested that intron loss could be reversed by intron acquisition and that the whole process is a dynamic one. This process of intron acquisition and intron loss reached different equilibrium points for different varieties and subgroups, which explained the irregular distribution of these introns in G. graminis. Each of the three group I introns was more closely related to other intron sequences that share the same insertion point in the 26S rDNA than to each other. These introns in distantly related organisms appeared to have a common ancestry. This system had provided a good model for studies on both the lateral transfer and common ancestry of group I introns in the 26S rRNA genes. Received: 17 May 1996 / Accepted: 14 January 1997     

DNA Probe for Identification of the Take-All Fungus, Gaeumannomyces graminis

A 4.3-kilobase mitochondrial DNA fragment was cloned from Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici, the causative agent of take-all disease of wheat. Although this DNA fragment hybridized with all three varieties of G. graminis, it showed little homology with DNA from other fungi and thus should be useful for identification of Gaeumannomyces sp. recovered from infected plants.     

Virus-like particles in the take-all fungus, Gaeumannomyces graminis

Isometric virus-like particles (VLP) measuring 35 nm and 27 nm occurred in cultured mycelium of Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici and G. graminis var. avenae. These VLP had, respectively, sedimentation coefficients (s°_{20, W}) 148S and 110S and ultraviolet absorption (maximum 260 nm, minimum 240 nm) typical of nucleoprotein (A260:280 = 1.6, A260:240 = 1.2). Preparations of the 35 nm particles had two major and one minor component in caesium chloride, and 27 nm particles had two components (buoyant densities 1.37, 1.36, 1.30, 1.35, and 1.29 g/cm³ respectively). Preparations of the 35 nm particles or 35 nm plus 27 nm particles had one major protein species with estimated molecular weight 70000 daltons. The 35 nm VLP were absent from 11 isolates of G. graminis var. tritici from first cereal crops after fallow or non-susceptible break crops; two of these contained the 27 nm particles. More than half of 145 isolates, from cereals after 2–12 consecutive susceptible crops, contained either 35 nm or 27 nm VLP. VLP were not confined to G. graminis isolates from soils exhibiting ‘take-all decline’ nor consistently associated with weak pathogenicity or with isolates of unusual growth, morphology, pigmentation, lysis or readiness to form perithecia. Isolates with one kind of particle were mostly more pathogenic and those with both kinds less pathogenic than isolates without VLP. The proportion of isolates with 27 nm and 35 nm particles increased progressively in samples from different consecutive crops during the first 9 years of cropping, then decreased. Isolates did not gain or lose VLP during infection and re-isolation from wheat seedlings grown in sand. Four ‘infected’ isolates were freed from VLP either by culturing ascospores or by growing hyphal tips excised from colonies kept near their thermal death point. Both VLP appeared in cultures which had undergone anastomosis with infected isolates.     

Analysis of Mycelial Growth Rates and RAPD-PCR Profiles in a Population of Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici Originating from Wheat Plants Grown from Fungicide-treated Seed

Linear mycelial growth rates of 70 isolates of Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici on agar medium amended or unamended with the fungicide silthiofam were not correlated. Mycelial growth rate was not influenced by the fungicide applied to the seed of the plants from, which the isolates originated. DNA polymorphism determined by randomly amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) polymerase chain reaction was used to assess genetic variation among isolates. Thirty RAPD markers generated with five arbitrary 10‐mer primers revealed DNA polymorphism suitable for assessing variability in this fungal population. Cluster analysis of RAPD data identified two groups at the 54% similarity level. There was a significant relationship between the presence of 11 markers and sensitivity to silthiofam.     

The potential of non-pathogenic Gaeumannomyces spp., occurring naturally or introduced into wheat crops or preceding crops, for controlling take-all in wheat

Take‐all disease (Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici) in wheat crops is known to be suppressed by naturally occurring antagonistic fungi, closely related to the pathogen, that infect grasses and cereals. This form of suppression was re‐investigated because of the changing importance and role of grass weeds and grass covers in arable farming. Natural populations of the competitive fungus Gaeumannomyces cylindrosporus, allowed to develop under rye‐grass, were more effective than artificially introduced populations in suppressing the development of take‐all in following wheat crops. To be effective, the antagonist needs to be present before the start of wheat cropping. Introducing G. cylindrosporus, but not G. graminis var. graminis (a potential antagonist that is faster growing), into a previous crop, or just after the previous crop, sometimes suppressed take‐all, but the effect was small. It is concluded that, for any future attempts at biocontrol by these fungi, they should be introduced into a preceding crop not susceptible to take‐all. Take‐all inoculum in the soil should be at a minimum and effective hosts of the take‐all pathogen must not be present as weeds or volunteers.     

Control of the take-all fungus byMicrodochium bolleyi,and interactions involvingM. bolleyi,Phialophora graminicola andPericonia macrospinosa on cereal roots

Summary In glasshouse experiments,Microdochium bolleyi (Mb) significantly reduced infection of wheat roots by the take-all fungus,Gaeumannomyces graminis vartritici (Ggt), when inocula were dispersed in soil at ratios of 10∶1 (Mb:Ggt) or more. Spread of take-all lesions up roots from a layer of inoculum also was reduced when Mb was inoculated immediately below the crown. In contrast,Periconia macrospinosa did not control take-all even at an inoculum ratio of 100∶1. M. bolleyi interfered with growth on roots byPhialophora graminicola, a known biocontrol agent of take-all. It is suggested that this phenomenon and control of take-all by these fungi occur by competition for cortical cells that senesce in the normal course of root development.     

Analysis of the resistance of Aegilops squarrosa to the wheatgrass mildew fungus by using the gene-for-gene reationship

Summary Pm10 and Pm15, resistance genes to Erysiphe graminis f. sp. agropyri, are located on the D genome of common wheat. It was determined whether or not they were carried by existing lines of the D genome donor, Aegilops squarrosa, using the gene-for-gene relationship. Two lines of Ae. squarrosa tested (one was var. meyeri and the other was var. anathera) were susceptible to culture Tk-1 of E. graminis f. sp. tritici and were highly resistant to culture Ak-1 of E. graminis f. sp. agropyri. The two lines were inoculated with an F₁ population derived from the cross Ak-1 × Tk-1. Comparative analyses of the segregation patterns revealed that Ppm10 and Ppm15, avirulence genes corresponding to Pm10 and Pm15, respectively, are involved in the avirulence of Ak-1 on var. meyeri and var. anathera, respectively. According to the gene-for-gene relationship, var. meyeri and var. anathera were inferred to carry Pm10 and Pm15, respectively. Analysis with a synthetic hexaploid confirmed the inference.     

Water use and phosphorus and potassium status of wheat seedlings colonized byGaeumannomyces graminis orPhialophora radicicola

Summary The water consumption and levels of phosphorus, potassium, and total minerals were measured for wheat seedlings colonized byGaeumannomyces graminis var.tritici, Phialophora radicicola var.radicicola, orPhialophora radicicola var.graminicola. Infection byG. graminis resulted in a considerable reduction in water consumption, and reduced level of phosphorus when the supply of phosphorus to the seedlings was plentiful. Colonization byP. radicicola var.radicicola increased levels of phosphorus and potassium, but these increases varied according to the isolate of the fungus and the supply of phosphorus and potassium available to the seedlings. Colonization byP. radicicola var.graminicola resulted in reduced water consumption by the seedlings.The results are discussed in relation to stelar cell wall thickening in wheat roots colonized byP. radicicola, and the effects on nutrient uptake of mycorrhizal root systems.     

Pathogenicity of ‘take-all’ fungus to oats: Its relationship to the concentration and detoxification of the four avenacins

Data for inhibition of the growth of Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici (Ggt) and var. avenae (Gga), Phialophora radicicola and Fusarium avenaceum, caused by avenacins, are presented. The avenacins found in all oat species examined are sufficient in quantity to totally suppress growth of wheat ‘take-all’ (Ggt), even old roots containing 25 μg/g (fr. wt). Fungal variants that can also attack oats [var. avenae (Gga)] show considerable variations in their tolerance to avenacin A-1, ec₅₀ values being 5–80 μg/ml. Nevertheless, all Gga isolates maintained some growth at avenacin A-1 concentrations as high as 200 μg/ml and it is this ability to grow, albeit slowly, at high concentrations that is the critical difference between Gga and Ggt strains. The pathogenicity towards oats of a range of isolates of Gga is related to the fungicidal activity of avenacins. Gga pathogenicity is shown to increase with poor nutrition of the oat hosts (poor illumination, lack of minerals). Fungal detoxification of avenacins produces mono-deglucosylavenacin A-1, bis-deglucosylavenacin A-1 and, in one case, tris-deglycosylavenacin A-1. Ggt strains left avenacin A-1 almost unaffected giving only traces of mono-deglucosyl product. Gga strains bring about mono- and bis-deglucosylation whilst Fusarium avenaceum causes mainly bis-deglucosylation. Mono-deglucosylavenacin is shown to be less inhibitory to Gga than is avenacin A-1, whilst the bis-deglucosyl compound is still less inhibitory.     

Study of Genetic Variability Among Monopycnidial and Monopycnidiospore Isolates Derived from Single Pycnidia of Stagonospora ssp. and Septoria tritici with the use of RAPD-PCR, MP-PCR and rep-PCR Techniques

Thirty-six isolates of Stagonospora avenae f. sp. triticea, S. nodorum and Septoria tritici recovered from asexual fruiting bodies - pycnidia and their spores were assessed for DNA polymorphism with the use of three molecular techniques: microsatellite-primed polymerase chain reaction (MP-PCR), primers correspond to dispersed repetitive elements (rep-PCR) and random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD-PCR). These polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based techniques were simultaneously evaluated for their capacity to detect genetic variation at DNA level. The most polymorphic DNA profiles of monopycnidial and monopycnidiospore isolates were detected with diverse microsatellite motifs used for PCR priming. The lowest similarity values 0.86, 0.76 and 0.84 were identified among monopycnidiospore isolates derived from the same pycnidium of S. avenae f. sp. triticea, S. nodorum and S. tritici, respectively. The above, rather low similarities, found for isolates recovered from single pycnidia, supported a hypothesis that heterokaryosis resulted from high mutation rate of microsatellites and transposons activity. This would have fundamental consequences for the genetic status of asexual populations of Stagonospora spp. and S. tritici. The data produced by this study indicate that more attention should be paid to asexual reproduction as a possible source of genetic variability among populations of the pathogens.     

The Nature of the Resistance of Oats to the Take-all Fungus: II. INHIBITION OF GROWTH AND RESPIRATION OF OPHIOBOLUS GRAMINIS SACC. AND OTHER FUNGI BY A CONSTITUENT OF OAT SAP

Growth of Ophiobohu gramimt and of O. gramims var. avenae isinhibited by concentrations of 3·3-4·0µg./ml.,and respiration by concentrations of 55µg./nil. of a partiallypurified substance from oat-leaf sap. The two varieties appearto be equally sensitive. The filtrate of boiled sap is inhibitorybut here dilution of the sap permits better growth of isolatesof var. avenae. Sap from oat roots is inhibitory to O.graminisonly, and fractionation of the sap shows that the inhibitorcan be masked by a growth stimulant. Inhibition of growth andrespiration can be reduced by glutathione and ascorbic acid,particularly if the inhibitor and reducing agent are previouslyincubated together for a few hours, suggesting that the inhibitoris inactivated on reduction. The capacity of var. avenae toovercome inhibition in the favourable medium provided by thecrude sap more readily than can the type variety is suggestedas the cause of the slight differential activity of the filtrateof leaf sap and the full differential activity of the root sap.Susceptibility of oats to var. avenae would thus be due to conditionsenabling the fungus to overcome toxicity rather than to an absenceof toxicity. Activity of the inhibitor against growth and respiration ofa number of fungi and a few other organisms has been tested.Bacteria and oat and barley roots are not affected but abouthalf of the fungi tested are inhibited although none is as sensitiveas O. gramims. No members of the fungi imperfecti tested aresensitive.     

Thickening and browning of cortical cell walls in seminal roots of wheat seedlings infected with Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici

This paper examines a little studied reaction of wheat roots to invasion by Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici, namely the thickening and browning of cortical cell walls. Examination was confined to distal segments of young seminal roots grown in sand. Browning and thickening of walls of cells were associated with the lignification of tissue and appeared to be a response of living or recently live cells to invasion by weakly virulent isolates. Wheat genotypes differed in their ability to thicken and lignify cell walls, and the difference between two wheat cultivars appeared to be under simple genetic control. There was some evidence that cortical browning temporarily retarded radial invasion by hyphae of G. graminis into young seminal roots of wheats.     

Effects of temperature on growth rates of fungi from subantarctic Macquarie Island and Casey,Antarctica

Summary The linear growth rates of fungal isolates were measured on agar plates at temperatures ranging from 4° to 35°C. Fungi tested included the major fungal colonizers of leaves and litter of the three dominant plant species on subantarctic Macquarie Island, and major fungal species associated with plant and soil communities near Australia's Casey Station on the Antarctic Continent. All fungi grew at 4°C and were classified as psychrotrophs. Maximum growth rates were recorded at temperatures of 10° to 20°C for 13 of the 15 isolates from Macquarie Island and for all six isolates from Casey. Most of the leaf colonizing fungi from Macquarie Island had optimum growth temperatures of 15°C whereas all litter fungi from Macquarie Island and Casey fungi except Thelebolus microsporus had optimum growth temperatures of 20°C or above. Maximum growth of all species was at temperatures above those normally prevailing in their natural environments, with most species growing at 4°C at between 10% and 30% of their maximum rates. However, microclimatic effects may have resulted at times in temperatures near their growth optima. The highest growth rates at 4°C were recorded for Phoma spp. 1 and 2, Phoma exigua and Mortierella gamsii from Macquarie Island and Mortierella sp. 1 from Casey. Thelebolus microsporus and sterile sp. G from Casey also grew relatively fast at 4°C, and these species, and Phoma sp. 3 and Phoma exigua from Macquarie Island had the lowest Q-₁₀ values for the temperature range 4° to 15°C.     

Methoxyhydroquinone, a Growth Inhibitor of Ophiobolus graminis, in Leaves of Oat Seedlings

A methanol extract of leaves of oat seedlings grown in sand cultures in the dark contained a compound which inhibited the growth of Ophiobolus graminis. The inhibitory factor was isolated and proved to be present in the plant as methoxyhydroquinone glucoside. The glucoside was readily hydrolysed to the corresponding aglucone. The methoxyhydroquinone, or possibly its oxydation product, methoxy-P-benzoquinone, was inhibitory to both Ophiobolus graminis var. graminis and Ophiobolus graminis var. avenae, whereas Fusarmm oxysporum var. lycopcrsici was not affected. Synthetic methoxyhydroquinone at 80 mg/l gave a 100% inhibition of Ophiobolus graminis var. graminis. After being exposed to 80 mg/l of the inhibitor for 24 h the mycelium was unable to initiate growth when transferred to a fresh nutrient solution. Only extracts from young leaves showed inhibitory activity, extracts from mature leaves giving no inhibition. The hydroquinone, or its glucoside, was not detected in roots of young seedlings, where avenacin was the only antifungal compound present.