Chromosome aberration in human lymphocytes after X-irradiation in vitro. II. Analysis of primary processes in the formation of dicentric chromosomes

The rejoining distance for the formation of dicentric chromosomes in human lymphocytes has been derived on the basis of microdosimetric concepts. For the formation of a dicentric chromosome, primary lesions produced by absorption events can interact within the nucleus over a distance of at least 1 μm. The dispersion of dicentrics is near to 1 and corresponds to a site number between 17 and 120.     

Chromosome engineering: generation of mono- and dicentric isochromosomes in a somatic cell hybrid system

The most common isochromosome found in humans involves the long arm of the X, i(Xq), and is associated with a subset of Turner syndrome cases. To study the formation and behavior of isochromosomes in a more tractable experimental system, we have developed a somatic cell hybrid model system that allows for the selection of mono- or dicentric isochromosomes involving the short arm of the X, i(Xp). Simultaneous positive and negative counterselection of a mouse/human somatic cell hybrid containing a human X chromosome, selecting for retention of the UBE1 locus in Xp but against the HPRT locus in Xq, results in a variety of abnormalities of the X chromosome involving deletions of Xq. We have generated 70 such ”Pushmi-Pullyu” hybrids derived from seven independent X chromosomes. Cytogenetic analysis of these hybrids using fluorescence in situ hybridization showed i(Xp) chromosomes in ∼19% of the hybrids. Southern blot and polymerase chain reaction analyses of the Pushmi-Pullyu hybrids revealed a distribution of breakpoints along Xq. The distance between the centromeres of the dicentric i(Xp)s generated ranged from ∼2 Mb to ∼20 Mb. To examine centromeric activity in these dicentric i(Xp)s, we used indirect immunofluorescence with antibodies to centromere protein E (CENP-E). CENP-E was detected at only one of the centromeres of a dicentric i(Xp) with ∼2–3 Mb of Xq DNA. In contrast, CENP-E was detected at both centromeres of a dicentric i(Xp) with ∼14 Mb of Xq DNA. Two other dicentric i(Xp) chromosomes were heterogeneous with respect to centromeric activity, suggesting that centromeric activity and chromosome stability of dicentric chromosomes may be more complicated than previously thought. The Pushmi-Pullyu model system presented in this study may provide a tool for examining the structure and function of mammalian centromeres. Received: 15 December 1998; in revised form: 2 March 1999 / Accepted: 5 April 1999     

Behavior of dicentric chromosomes in budding yeast

DNA double-strand breaks arise in vivo when a dicentric chromosome (two centromeres on one chromosome) goes through mitosis with the two centromeres attached to opposite spindle pole bodies. Repair of the DSBs generates phenotypic diversity due to the range of monocentric derivative chromosomes that arise. To explore whether DSBs may be differentially repaired as a function of their spatial position in the chromosome, we have examined the structure of monocentric derivative chromosomes from cells containing a suite of dicentric chromosomes in which the distance between the two centromeres ranges from 6.5 kb to 57.7 kb. Two major classes of repair products, homology-based (homologous recombination (HR) and single-strand annealing (SSA)) and end-joining (non-homologous (NHEJ) and micro-homology mediated (MMEJ)) were identified. The distribution of repair products varies as a function of distance between the two centromeres. Genetic dependencies on double strand break repair (Rad52), DNA ligase (Lif1), and S phase checkpoint (Mrc1) are indicative of distinct repair pathway choices for DNA breaks in the pericentromeric chromatin versus the arms.     

Chromosome abnormalities in tuberous sclerosis

Summary In fibroblasts cultured from biopsies of the skin lesions of six patients with tuberous sclerosis (TS) there was a variable but consistent degree of karyotypic variation. Premature centromere disjunction (PCD) of all or part of the chromosomes, micronuclei, an increased incidence of breaks, dicentric chromosomes and the presence of polyploid metaphases were found in all cultures. The PCD was of the type encountered in Roberts syndrome and its frequency varied from 8% to 30%. In metaphases with PCD of one and of two chromosomes, the chromosome involved were identified, and chromosome 3 was involved 21 times among 59 chromosomes with PCD. Chromosome 3 tends to be preferentially involved in dicentric formation. In lymphocyte cultures from the same patients there were no metaphases with PCD, but there was a slight increase of breaks and the presence of dicentric chromosomes, also involving chromosome 3. Polyploid metaphases were increased in some of the cases. Karyotypic variation can be considered a cellular phenotypic characteristic of TS in fibroblasts cultured from the skin lesions, and its type indicates disturbances in the mechanics of centromere division and of chromosome distribution at cell division.     

The parental origin and mechanism of formation of three dicentric X chromosomes

Summary Cytogenetic and molecular analyses of three dicentric X chromosomes were performed in an attempt to identify the parental origin and mechanism of formation of the aberant chromosomes. Results indicate that, in these three cases, the dicentric chromosomes were formed by chromatid breakage and reunion of sister chromatids at the breakpoint. In two cases the abnormal chromosomes were paternal in origin; in the third case the dicentric originated from the maternal X chromosome.     

Telomere Disruption Results in Non-Random Formation of De Novo Dicentric Chromosomes Involving Acrocentric Human Chromosomes

Genome rearrangement often produces chromosomes with two centromeres (dicentrics) that are inherently unstable because of bridge formation and breakage during cell division. However, mammalian dicentrics, and particularly those in humans, can be quite stable, usually because one centromere is functionally silenced. Molecular mechanisms of centromere inactivation are poorly understood since there are few systems to experimentally create dicentric human chromosomes. Here, we describe a human cell culture model that enriches for de novo dicentrics. We demonstrate that transient disruption of human telomere structure non-randomly produces dicentric fusions involving acrocentric chromosomes. The induced dicentrics vary in structure near fusion breakpoints and like naturally-occurring dicentrics, exhibit various inter-centromeric distances. Many functional dicentrics persist for months after formation. Even those with distantly spaced centromeres remain functionally dicentric for 20 cell generations. Other dicentrics within the population reflect centromere inactivation. In some cases, centromere inactivation occurs by an apparently epigenetic mechanism. In other dicentrics, the size of the α-satellite DNA array associated with CENP-A is reduced compared to the same array before dicentric formation. Extra-chromosomal fragments that contained CENP-A often appear in the same cells as dicentrics. Some of these fragments are derived from the same α-satellite DNA array as inactivated centromeres. Our results indicate that dicentric human chromosomes undergo alternative fates after formation. Many retain two active centromeres and are stable through multiple cell divisions. Others undergo centromere inactivation. This event occurs within a broad temporal window and can involve deletion of chromatin that marks the locus as a site for CENP-A maintenance/replenishment.     

Condensation anomalies and exclusion in micronuclei of rearranged chromosomes in human fibroblasts cultured in vitro

Anomalies of chromatin condensation, such as fragmentation, uncoiling and pulverization, were observed in XP9UV25, a xeroderma pigmentosum fibroblast clone in which a high proportion of cells carried an end-to-end dicentric chromosome, dic (5;16) (p15.2;q24), that gives rise during propagation in culture to a variety of dicentric and monocentric derivatives. The coiling anomaly affected exclusively part of a rearranged chromosome, in particular the region previously involved in breakage events. The heterochromatic 16q region, which is a preferential breakpoint in the formation of dicentric and monocentric derivatives, was consistently the limit of the uncoiled or pulverized regions. This observation suggests that the anomalous chromatin behavior could derive from alteration of a region relevant for the correct condensation of the chromosome. In XP9UV25 the frequency of nuclei with associated micronuclei increased with time in culture, in parallel with that of mitoses with dicentric chromosomes. In situ hybridization with DNA probes specific for chromosomes 5 and 16 revealed hybridization signals in about 40% of micronuclei. Since the frequency of micronuclei is about ten times less than that of dicentrics, it is probable that only the rearranged chromosomes undergoing coiling anomalies are excluded in micronuclei.     

The meiotic behaviour of inversions in polyploid aloineae

In addition to the four classical inversion phenomena, meiosis in tetraploid paracentric inversion heterozygotes produces multiple dicentric and complex tricentric bridges which were previously little understood. Also formed are open loop chromatids which can give rise to dicentric chromosomes in the progeny. A qualitative and quantitative study of the first and second meiotic division in Gasteria nigricans var. crassifolia (Liliaceae, Aloineae) agrees closely with theoretical considerations. Breakage of dicentric bridges results in the formation of chromosomes carrying large terminal deletions. These are shown to be viable in the diploid gametes produced by tetraploids because of the buffering effect of the second haploid set of chromosomes.     

Characterization of kinetochores in multicentric chromosomes

Long-term cultures of certain rat and mouse cell lines carry several dicentric and some multicentric chromosomes. Using antikinetochore antibodies obtainable from serum of scleroderma (var. CREST) patients we studied the number of kinetochores formed along the length of these chromosomes. The rat cells displayed as many kinetochores as there were centromeres. However, mouse cells showed the synthesis of only one kinetochore in dicentric and multicentric chromosomes which had been in the culture for a period of 1 year or more. When translocations were induced by bleomycin in mouse L cells, the newly formed dicentric chromosomes showed the formation of two kinetochores. It is not known when the accessory centromeres lose their capacity to assemble kinetochore proteins. Possibly, in the rat the latent kinetochores lack a specific component which renders them ineffective for microtubule binding. The reason for the formation of only one kinetochore in mouse multicentric chromosomes is not clear. It may be due to the accumulation of mutations, modification of the kinetochore protein so that it lacks the antibody binding component, or a more effective regulatory gene than in the rat.     

Analysis of the time relationship for the interaction of X-ray induced primary breaks in the formation of dicentric chromosomes.

In split-dose experiments, the time relationship for the interaction of primary breaks in the formation of dicentric chromosomes was analysed. Human peripheral lymphocytes were irradiated with a dose of 340 R of 220 kV X-rays split into two equal fractions separated by intervals up to 360 min. Assuming an exponential decline of the time-dependent quadratic component of the dose realtion of dicentrics a theoretical formula was deduced. Fitting this formula to the empirical data a mean time of 110 min could be calculated in which primary breaks induced by both dose-fractions can interact to form dicentric chromosomes.     

Observations on dicentrics in living cells

Summary In previously irradiated endosperm cells of Haemanthus katherinae studied in vitro by means of micro-cinematography, two-kinetochore chromatids and dicentric chromosomes have been observed. Breaking of such dicentric chromatids and chromosomes has been analysed. Behaviour of some of the dicentric chromosomes during anaphase deserves special attention: interlocking dicentrics cut one through another and rejoin in a few minutes. In this way from a metaphase interlocking dicentric, two sister anaphase dicentrics are formed. Interlocked dicentrics can also uncoil and not break at all. In this case no activity was observed in one kinetochore of one dicentric in later stages of anaphase (two kinetochores were active in one dicentric and only one in its sister). Analysis of chromosome movements in two-kinetochore chromatids and dicentrics is also presented.     

Interstitial deletions of repetitive DNA blocks in dicentric human Y chromosomes

Cytogenetic analysis of aberrant human Y chromosomes was done by fluorescence in situ hydbridization (FISH) with Y specific repetitive DNA probes. It revealed an interstitial deletion of different DNA blocks in two dicentric chromosome structures. One deletion includes the total alphoid DNA structure of one centromeric region. The second deletion includes the total repetitive DYZ5 DNA structure in the pericentromeric region of one short Y arm. Both dicentric Y chromosomes were iso(Yp) chromosomes with break and fusion point located in Yq11, the euchromatic part of the long Y arm. Their phenotypic appearance was abnormal, resembling small monocentric Yq-chromosomes in metaphase plates. Mosaic cell lines, usually included in karyotypes with dicentric Y chromosomes, were not observed. It is assumed that both deletion events suppress the kinetochore activity in one Y centromeric region and thus stabilize its dicentric structure. Local interstitial deletion events had not been described in dicentric human Y chromosomes, but are common in dicentric yeast chromosomes. This raises the question of whether deletion events in dicentric human chromosomes are rare or restricted to the Y chromosome or also represent a general possibility for stabilization of a dicentric chromosome structure in human.     

Lack of specificity of chromosome breaks resulting from radiation-induced genomic instability in Chinese hamster cells

In V79 Chinese hamster cells, radiation-induced genomic instability results in a persistently increased frequency of micronuclei, dicentric chromosomes and apoptosis and in decreased colony-forming ability. These manifestations of radiation-induced genomic instability may be attributed to an increased rate of chromosome breakage events many generations after irradiation. This chromosomal instability does not seem to be a property which has been inflicted on individual chromosomes at the time of irradiation. Rather, it appears to be secondary to an increased level of non-specific clastogenic factors in the progeny of most if not all irradiated cells. This conclusion is drawn from the observations presented here, that all the chromosomes in surviving V79 cells are involved in the formation of dicentric chromosome aberrations 1 or 2 weeks after irradiation with about equal probability if corrections are made for chromosome length. Received: 5 March 1998 / Accepted in revised form: 1 July 1998     

Time course study of the chromosome-type breakage-fusion-bridge cycle in maize.

The B chromosome of maize has been used in a study of dicentric chromosomes. TB-9Sb is a translocation between the B and chromosome 9. The B-9 of TB-9Sb carries 60% of the short arm of 9. For construction of dicentrics, a modified B-9 chromosome was used, B-9-Dp9. It consists of the B-9 chromosome plus a duplicated 9S region attached to the distal end. In meiosis, fold-back pairing and crossing over in the duplicated region gives a chromatid-type dicentric B-9 that subsequently initiates a chromatid-type breakage-fusion-bridge cycle. In the male, it forms a single bridge in anaphase II of meiosis and at the first pollen mitosis. However, the cycle is interrupted by nondisjunction of the B centromere at the second pollen mitosis, which sends the B-9 dicentric to one pole and converts it from a chromatid dicentric to a chromosome dicentric. As expected, the new dicentric undergoes the chromosome-type breakage-fusion-bridge cycle and produces double bridges. A large number of plants with chromosome dicentrics were produced in this way. The presence of double bridges in the root cells of plants with a chromosome dicentric was studied during the first 10 wk of development. It was found that the number of plants and cells showing double bridges declined steadily over the 10-wk period. Several lines of evidence indicate that there was no specific developmental time for dicentric loss. "Healing" of broken chromosomes produced by dicentric breakage accounted for much of the dicentric loss. Healing produced a wide range of derived B-9 chromosomes, some large and some small. A group of minichromosomes found in these experiments probably represents the small end of the scale for B-9 derivatives.     

The transmission of fragmented chromosomes in Drosophila melanogaster.

We investigated the fate of dicentric chromosomes in the mitotic divisions of Drosophila melanogaster. We constructed chromosomes that were not required for viability and that carried P elements with inverted repeats of the target sites (FRTs) for the FLP site-specific recombinase. FLP-mediated unequal sister-chromatid exchange between inverted FRTs produced dicentric chromosomes at a high rate. The fate of the dicentric chromosome was evaluated in the mitotic cells of the male germline. We found that dicentric chromosomes break in mitosis, and the broken fragments can be transmitted. Some of these chromosome fragments exhibit dominant semilethality. Nonlethal fragments were broken at many sites along the chromosome, but the semilethal fragments were all broken near the original site of sister-chromatid fusion, and retained P element sequences near their termini. We discuss the implications of the recovery and behavior of broken chromosomes for checkpoints that detect double-strand break damage and the functions of telomeres in Drosophila.     

Lack of Spontaneous Sister Chromatid Exchanges in Somatic Cells of DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER

Neural ganglia of wild type third-instar larvae of Drosophila melanogaster were incubated for 13 hours at various concentrations of BUdR (1, 3, 9, 27 micrograms/ml). Metaphases were collected with colchicine, stained with Hoechst 33258, and scored under a fluorescence microscope. Metaphases in which the sister chromatids were clearly differentiated were scored for the presence of sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs). At the lowest concentration of BUdR (1 microgram/ml), no SCEs were observed in either male or female neuroblasts. The SCEs were found at the higher concentrations of BUdR (3, 9, And 27 micrograms/ml) and with a greater frequency in females than in males. Therefore SCEs are not a spontaneous phenomenon in D. melanogaster, but are induced by BUdR incorporated in the DNA. A striking nonrandomness was found in the distribution of SCEs along the chromosomes. More than a third of the SCEs were clustered in the junctions between euchromatin and heterochromatin. The remaining SCEs were preferentially localized within the heterochromatic regions of the X chromosome and the autosomes and primarily on the entirely heterochromatic Y chromosome.--In order to find an alternative way of measuring the frequency of SCEs in the Drosophila neuroblasts, the occurrence of double dicentric rings was studied in two stocks carrying monocentric ring-X chromosomes. One ring chromosome, C(1)TR94--2, shows a rate of dicentric ring formation corresponding to the frequency of SCEs observed in the BUdR-labelled rod chromosomes. The other ring studied, R(1)2, exhibits a frequency of SCEs higher than that observed with both C(1) TR94--2 and rod chromosomes.     

Preferential Breakpoints in the Recovery of Broken Dicentric Chromosomes in Drosophila melanogaster

We designed a system to determine whether dicentric chromosomes in Drosophila melanogaster break at random or at preferred sites. Sister chromatid exchange in a Ring-X chromosome produced dicentric chromosomes with two bridging arms connecting segregating centromeres as cells divide. This double bridge can break in mitosis. A genetic screen recovered chromosomes that were linearized by breakage in the male germline. Because the screen required viability of males with this X chromosome, the breakpoints in each arm of the double bridge must be closely matched to produce a nearly euploid chromosome. We expected that most linear chromosomes would be broken in heterochromatin because there are no vital genes in heterochromatin, and breakpoint distribution would be relatively unconstrained. Surprisingly, approximately half the breakpoints are found in euchromatin, and the breakpoints are clustered in just a few regions of the chromosome that closely match regions identified as intercalary heterochromatin. The results support the Laird hypothesis that intercalary heterochromatin can explain fragile sites in mitotic chromosomes, including fragile X. Opened rings also were recovered after male larvae were exposed to X-rays. This method was much less efficient and produced chromosomes with a strikingly different array of breakpoints, with almost all located in heterochromatin. A series of circularly permuted linear X chromosomes was generated that may be useful for investigating aspects of chromosome behavior, such as crossover distribution and interference in meiosis, or questions of nuclear organization and function.     

Dicentric chromosomes and 20q11.2 amplification in MDS/AML with apparent monosomy 20

FISH analysis of 41 previously karyotyped cases of MDS and AML with apparent monosomy of chromosome 20 revealed a variety of dicentric abnormalities involving chromosome 20. These usually, but not always, involved a breakpoint in the long arm of chromosome 20 and loss of the common deleted region at 20q12. Not one case of true monosomy 20 was confirmed. We found evidence for dicentric chromosome formation in 21 of 24 unbalanced translocations containing chromosome 20 and that were studied in more detail. Subsequent loss of one of the centromeres had occurred in eight of these 24 cases, and was more frequent than centromere inactivation as a means of resolving the inherent instability of a dicentric chromosome. In the three cases with dicentric chromosomes from which proximal 20q had been excised along with the 20 centromere, the excised segment was retained, and in two of these it was amplified. Proximal 20q was clearly retained in all but three cases, and present in three or more copies in 17 of 41 cases. The retention and amplification of proximal 20q provides support for the hypothesis that there is an oncogene located in this region of 20q that is activated in cases of MDS/AML with del(20q). Apparent monosomy 20 in MDS/AML should be treated as evidence of unidentified chromosome 20 abnormalities, and familiarity with the typical G-banded morphology of these derivatives can help with their identification. The reported incidence of dicentric chromosomes is clearly an under-estimate but is increasing in myeloid disorders as more cases are studied with methods allowing their detection.     

Dicentric chromosomes and the inactivation of the centromere

Summary The origin and behavior of human dicentric chromosomes are reviewed. Most dicentrics between two non-homologous or two homologous chromosomes (isodicentrics), which are permanent members of a chromosome complement, probably originate from segregation of an adjacent quadriradial; such configurations are the result of a chromatid translocation between two nonhomologous chromosomes, or they represent an adjacent counterpart of a mitotic chiasma. The segregation of such a quadriradial may also give rise to a cell line monosomic for the chromosome concerned (e.g., a 45,X line). Contrary to the generally held opinion, isodicentrics rarely result from an isolocal break in two chromatids followed by rejoining of sister chromatids. In this case the daughter centromeres go to opposite poles in the next anaphase, and the resulting bridge breaks at a random point. This mechanism, therefore, leads to the formation of an isodicentric chromosome only if the two centromeres are close together, or if one centromere is immediately inactivated. Observations on the origin of dicentrics in Bloom syndrome support these conclusions. One centromere is permanently inactivated in most dicentric chromosomes, and even when the dicentric breaks into two chromosomes, the centromere is not reactivated. The appearance and behavior of the acentric X chromosomes show that their centromeres are similarly inactivated and not prematurely divided. Two Bloom syndrome lymphocytes, one with an extra chromosome 2 and the other with an extra chromosome 7, each having an inactivated centromere, show that this can also happen in monocentric autosomes.     

The persistence of lymphocytes with dicentric chromosomes following whole-body X irradiation of mice

Thirty-six male C57B1/6 mice were X-irradiated whole body with 3 Gy to generate lymphocytes with dicentric chromosomes to study the persistence of these lymphocytes in the spleen and peripheral blood to estimate the life span of mature B- and T-cells. Peripheral blood and spleen were removed from groups of four mice immediately after radiation exposure and on Days 1, 3, 7, 14, 28, 56, and 112 thereafter. Peripheral blood lymphocytes were cultured with phytohemagglutinin to stimulate T-cell division, and splenic lymphocytes were cultured with either lipopolysaccharide or phytohemagglutinin to stimulate B- or T-cell division, respectively. The initial frequencies of dicentric chromosomes with accompanying fragments observed in splenic T-cells (0.44), splenic B-cells (0.43), and peripheral blood lymphocyte cultures (0.48) initiated on Day 0 were not significantly different. For both splenic and peripheral blood T-lymphocytes, the frequency of cells containing dicentric chromosomes declined in an exponential manner following irradiation, with a 50% reduction in frequency occurring 14 days after exposure. In contrast, the frequency of B-cells containing dicentric chromosomes remained stable through Day 7 but then declined precipitously between Day 7 and Day 14 and remained relatively stable, although slightly above baseline, through Day 112 post-exposure. For both B- and T-cells, less than 5% of the cells contained a dicentric chromosome with accompanying fragments at Day 112. These data indicate that B- and T-lymphocytes with dicentric chromosomes show different decay kinetics and suggest that they may possess different life spans.