Comparison of the misreading induced by streptomycin and neomycin

In a poly(U)-programmed translation system, neomycin stimulates the misincorporation of tyrosine and of serine which, according to Thompson and Stone (Thompson, R.C. and Stone, P.J. (1977) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 74, 198-202), are normally rejected at an initial discrimination step during the binding of charged tRNAs to the ribosome. In contrast, streptomycin favors the misincorporation of isoleucine which is normally rejected at a subsequent GTP-dependent discrimination step, the so-called proofreading step. The labeling of the ribosome with N-ethylmaleimide mimics the effect of streptomycin in that it stimulates the misincorporation of isoleucine but not of tyrosine or serine. This effect is correlated with the labeling of protein S18 but not with that of protein S1. These observations indicate that the sulfhydryl group of protein S18 is located within a ribosomal domain involved in the proofreading control of tRNA selection. Taking into account our previous results that streptomycin and neomycin perturb ribosomal areas around the sulfhydryl groups of proteins S18 and S1, respectively, we suggest that these antibiotics induce misreading by different mechanisms which are linked to such perturbations.     

Streptomycin-induced conformational changes in the 70-S bacterial ribosome.

Conformational alterations induced by streptomycin in the bacterial ribosome have been investigated using as probes, ethidium bromide, N-[14C]ethylmaleimide and a spin label nitroxide analog of N-ethylmaleimide. 1. The binding of the antibiotic to the ribosome does not affect the reactivity of sulfhydryl groups towards N-ethylmaleimide. 2. The motional freedom of spin labels bound to ribosomal proteins S1 and S18 is increased but it is hardly affected at other labeled sites. This observation suggests that the binding of streptomycin causes a local loosening of the ribosomal structure. 3. Ribosomes are found to bind less ethidium bromide in the presence of streptomycin, which suggests that the binding of streptomycin decreases the degree of organization of ribosomal RNA.     

Selective spin-labeling of the ribosomal proteins of 70S ribosomes from Escherichia coli.

We have used a series of N-(1-oxyl-2,2,5,5-tetramethyl-3-pyrrolidinyl) maleimide spin labels of different length to label, covalently and selectively, the most reactive sulfhydryl groups of 70S ribosomal proteins of Escherichia coli. Under short periods of labeling (1--2 min), less than two spin labels per ribosome are incorporated and were shown to be distributed mainly on five ribosomal proteins in the following order: S18 greater than S21, L27 greater than S17, and S12. With a long period of labeling (3 h) up to 13 spin labels are attached to the ribosome, and protein S1 is the most labeled. The shape of the electron paramagnetic resonance (epr) signal shows two components with a predominance for the strongly immobilized orientation, and the percentage of these components in each spectra has been evaluated. When the distance between the nitroxide group and the maleimide-attaching group exceeds 6 A (1 A = 0.1 nm) the strongly immobilized orientation disappears. The effect of magnesium ions on these selectively spinlabeled ribosomes shows that the dissociation into subunits does not affect the epr signal, but more spin labels are incorporated into the subunits if labeling is performed under conditions of dissociation.     

Fluorescence studies on a streptomycin-induced conformational change in ribosomes which correlates with misreading

The fluorescent reagent N-(iodoacetylaminoethyl)-5-naphthylamine-1-sulfonic acid (I-AEDANS) was employed to detect and study the previously reported conformational change in the Escherichia coli ribosome induced by streptomycin. Labeling of ribosomes with this probe, which results in the derivatization of proteins S18 and L31', described earlier, inhibits neither their ribosomal protein synthesizing nor misreading ability. To calculate the amount of streptomycin bound to the ribosome, we determined the K'D for streptomycin, which is 0.24 micron, indicating that under our conditions, bound streptomycin/ribosome molar ratios are low, not in excess of 1. Under these conditions, streptomycin addition induces fluorescence quenching by 15% but does not affect streptomycin-resistant ribosomes. Maximal misreading occurs at these same ratios. Removal of AEDANS-L31' from the ribosomes drastically reduces streptomycin-induced quenching indicating the involvement of the environment of this protein in streptomycin action. The finding that streptomycin decreases AEDANS-L31' affinity for the ribosome supports this view. Streptomycin has been shown to bind to the 30 S subunit protein S4 while the 50 S protein L31' has been shown to be localized at the subunit interface. Thus, the observation that streptomycin influences this 50 S subunit protein L31', combined with the tight correlation between the effects of streptomycin on quenching and on misreading, strongly suggests that this antibiotic induces a conformational change at the subunit interface of the ribosome, and that this results in misreading. Polyuridylic acid also induces a conformational change in the ribosome but the polynucleotide and streptomycin seem to act independently. Streptomycin-resistant ribosomes, which undergo neither streptomycin-induced fluorescence nor streptomycin-induced misreading, are resistant to misreading induced by high Mg2+ as well.     

Elongation factor Tu-induced conformational changes of ribosomes detected by iodination

The effect of elongation factor (EF) Tu, bound to the ribosome with the help of poly(uridylic) acid, Phe-tRNA and guanyl-5-yl methylene diphosphonate, on the conformation and/or chemical environment of ribosomal proteins has been examined using, as a probe, protein iodination. Ribosomes complexed only with poly(uridylic acid) and Phe-tRNA have been used as a control. EF-Tu on the ribosome significantly increases the iodination of proteins S7, S10 and L3 and decreases that of S21 and L18.     

Succinate and phenylsuccinate as modifiers of sulfhydryl groups of inner mitochondrial membrane protein. Study by EPR

Paramagnetic labels specific for sulfhydryl (SH) groups have been used to study the conformational changes of the inner mitochondrial membrane. The EPR spectra of the SH-groups spin-labeled with maleimide or iodoacetamide show the existence of two populations of sulfhydryl groups, differing in their mobility (one weakly, the other strongly immobilized). The incubation with succinate or phenylsuccinate decreased the binding of these labels of the weakly immobilized sites while the number of total SH groups was the same before and after the incubation. These results suggest that succinate or phenylsuccinate induce a reversible change in protein conformation or in protein arrangement within the inner mitochondrial membrane. This change is concomitant to the protein movement between inner membrane and perimembranal space induced by either of these two molecules.     

Pleiotropic effects resulting from mutations in genes for ribosomal proteins: analysis of revertants from streptomycin dependence

In order to study the functions of the individual ribosomal proteins and their interaction, a group of revertants from streptomycin dependence to independence was analyzed. Reversion from dependence resulted from a number of different mutational events, all resulting in altered ribosome function. The mutants selected for study exhibited extensive pleiotropy—in addition to the elimination of the requirement for streptomycin for growth, the strains differed from the dependent parent and each other in growth rate, level of streptomycin resistance, effect of antibiotics on viability, rate of subunit assembly in vivo, affinity of isolated ribosomes for streptomycin and functionality of ribosomes in various cell-free assays.There appear to be strong correlations between the level of resistance to streptomycin in growing cells and the ability of the isolated ribosomes to bind streptomycin, the effect of antibiotic on cell-free protein synthesis programmed with natural message (but not poly(U)) and the degree of translational fidelity. There seems to be no relation between level of antibiotic resistance and the overall growth rate, the presence of a defect in ribosome assembly or the ribosomal protein altered by the mutation. Mutations in genes for 30 S proteins S4 and S5 can result in the same phenotype, while different changes in S4 in otherwise isogenic strains result in widely varying phenotypes.The wide variety of effects resulting from single mutational events suggests that each of these changes in a ribosomal protein changes the conformation of the ribosome or its ability to undergo configurational changes.     

Effects of aminoethylation of cysteine residues on the structural and functional activities of the Escherichia coli 30 S ribosomal proteins

The purified 30 S ribosomal proteins from Escherichia coli strain Q13 were chemically modified by reaction with ethyleneimine, specifically converting cysteine residues to S-2-aminoethylcysteine residues. Proteins S1, S2, S4, S8, S11, S12, S13, S14, S17, S18 and S21 were found to contain aminoethylcysteine residues after modification, whereas proteins S3, S5, S6, S7, S9, S10, S15, S16, S19 and S20 did not. Aminoethylated proteins S4, S13, S17 and S18 were active in the reconstitution of 30 S ribosomes and did not have altered functional activities in poly(U)-dependent polyphenylalanine synthesis, R17-dependent protein synthesis, fMet-tRNA binding and Phe-tRNA binding. Aminoethylated proteins S2, S11, S12, S14 and S21 were not active in the reconstitution of complete 30 S ribosomes, either because the aminoethylated protein did not bind stably to the ribosome (S2, S11, S12 and S21) or because the aminoethylated protein did not stabilize the binding of other ribosomal proteins (S14). The functional activities of 30 S ribosomes reconstituted from a mixture of proteins containing one sensitive aminoethylated protein (S2, S11, S12, S14 or S21) were similar to ribosomes reconstituted from mixtures lacking that protein. These results imply that the sulfhydryl groups of the proteins S4, S13, S17 and S18 are not necessary for the structural or functional activities of these proteins, and that aminoethylation of the sulfhydryl groups of S2, S11, S12, S14 and S21 forms either a kinetic or thermodynamic barrier to the assembly of active 30 S ribosomes in vitro.     

Modification of Escherichia coli ribosomes with the fluorescent reagent N-[[(iodoacetyl)amino]ethyl]-5-naphthylamine-1-sulfonic acid. Identification of derivatized L31' and studies on its intraribosomal properties

N-[[(Iodoacetyl)amino]ethyl]-5-naphthylamine-1-sulfonic acid (IAEDANS) is a fluorescent reagent which reacts covalently with the free thiol groups of proteins. When the reagent is reacted with the Escherichia coli ribosome under mild conditions, gel electrophoresis shows modification of predominantly two proteins, S18 and L31', which become labeled to an equal extent. When the native (i.e., untreated) ribosome is dissociated into 30S and 50S subunits, only the 30S ribosomal protein S18 reacts with IAEDANS despite the fact that L31' is still present on the large subunit. Upon heat activation of the subunits, a procedure which alters subunit conformation, S18 plus a number of higher molecular weight proteins is modified, but not L31'; the latter reacts with IAEDANS only in the 70S ribosome or when it is free. In contrast to the relatively stable association of L31' with native or with dissociated ribosomes, dissociation of N-[(acetylamino)ethyl]-5-naphthylaminesulfonic acid (AEDANS)-treated ribosomes weakens the AEDANS-L31'/ribosome interaction, resulting, upon gel filtration analysis, in ribosomes devoid of this derivatized protein.     

Conformational changes in ribosomes upon interaction with elongation factors

Conformational changes in the ribosomes upon interaction with EF-Tu were studied by limited proteolysis with a set of proteases. The main results are: (1) The cleavage rate of S1 protein strongly depends on the cooperative effect of poly(U) and tRNA: (2) The conformation of L7/L12 proteins is modulated by interaction of elongation factors with the ribosome and depends on hydrolysis of GTP; (3) The sensitivity of some ribosomal proteins (S6, S7, S18, S19, L9, L16, L19, and L27) to proteases changes upon binding of EF-Tu and depends on the ribosome functional state in accordance with GTP hydrolysis. Most of these proteins are located far from the factor-binding center of the ribosome. The possible mechanism of conformational changes is discussed.     

Conformational changes induced in Escherichia coli ribosomes by streptomycin. A spin label study

A spin-labeling study, with a nitroxide analog of N-ethylmaleimide, was carried out to investigate the effect of streptomycin on the conformation of ribosomes from E. coli. Spin-labeling of 70S ribosomes and 30S subunits was performed before and after the addition of streptomycin. Streptomycin has no effect if added after labeling, which confirms that the blocking of sulfhydryl groups of ribosomal proteins interferes with the binding of the antibiotic. However, when the antibiotic is added before labeling, there is a decrease in the rotational correlation time of the labels. This result indicates that the binding of streptomycin to ribosomes loosens the ribosomal structure.     

Alteration of 5S RNA conformation by ribosomal proteins L18 and L25.

The effects of ribosomal proteins L18, L25 and L5 on the conformation of 5S RNA have been studied by circular dichroism and temperature dependent ultraviolet absorbance. The circular dichroism spectrum of native 5S RNA is characterized in the near ultraviolet by a large positive band at 267 nm and a small negative band at 298 nm. The greatest perturbation in the spectrum was produced by protein L18 which induced a 20% increase in the 267 nm band and no change in the 298 nm band. By contrast, protein L25 caused a small decrease in both bands. No effect was observed with protein L5. Simultaneous binding of proteins L18 and L25 resulted in CD changes equivalent to the sum of their independent effects. The UV absorbance thermal denaturation profile of the 5S RNA L18 complex lacked the pre-melting behavior characteristic of 5S RNA. Protein L25 had no effect on the 5S RNA melting profile. We concluded that protein L18 increases the secondary, and possible the tertiary structure of 5S RNA, and exerts a minor stabilizing effect on its conformation while protein L25 causes a small decrease in 5S RNA secondary structure. The implications of these findings for ribosome assembly and function are discussed.     

Identification of neighbouring proteins by cross-linking of intact 70 S ribosomes from Escherichia coli

70 S ribosomes from Escherichia coli have been reacted with the bifunctional reagent 1,4-phenyldiglyoxal under near physiological conditions. As a result of the cross-linking reaction a number of high-molecular-weight protein fractions with altered electrophoretic mobility could be isolated. A new chemical procedure has been introduced to reverse the cross-links between proteins at least partially. The cleavage reaction did not affect the gel electrophoretic mobility of the proteins. Thus a direct identification of cross-linked proteins using one- or two-dimensional gels was made possible. Two protein trimers, S3-S4-S5 and L1-S4-S5, as well as five protein dimers, S3-S4, L6-L7/12, L10-L7/12, S9-L19 and L18-L19 could be identified as close neighbours in the E. coli 70 S ribosome. The protein pairs S9-L19 and L18-L19 had previously not been identified as near neighbours using cross-linking studies.     

Structural arrangement of tRNA binding sites on Escherichia coli ribosomes, as revealed from data on affinity labelling with photoactivatable tRNA derivatives

A systematic study of protein environment of tRNA in ribosomes in model complexes representing different translation steps was carried out using the affinity labelling of the ribosomes with tRNA derivatives bearing aryl azide groups scattered statistically over tRNA guanine residues. Analysis of the proteins crosslinked to tRNA derivatives showed that the location of the derivatives in the aminoacyl (A) site led to the labelling of the proteins S5 and S7 in all complexes studied, whereas the labelling of the proteins S2, S8, S9, S11, S14, S16, S17, S18, S19, S21 as well as L9, L11, L14, L15, L21, L23, L24, L29 depended on the state of tRNA in A site. Similarly, the location of tRNA derivatives in the peptidyl (P) site resulted in the labelling of the proteins L27, S11, S13 and S19 in all states, whereas the labelling of the proteins S5, S7, S9, S12, S14, S20, S21 as well as L2, L13, L14, L17, L24, L27, L31, L32, L33 depended on the type of complex. The derivatives of tRNA(fMet) were found to crosslink to S1, S3, S5, S7, S9, S14 and L1, L2, L7/L12, L27. Based on the data obtained, a general principle of the dynamic functioning of ribosomes has been proposed: (i) the formation of each type of ribosomal complex is accompanied by changes in mutual arrangement of proteins - 'conformational adjustment' of the ribosome - and (ii) a ribosome can dynamically change its internal structure at each step of initiation and elongation; on the 70 S ribosome there are no rigidly fixed structures forming tRNA-binding sites (primarily A and P sites).     

The mechanism of covalent reaction of bromoacetyl-phenylalanyl-transfer RNA with the peptidyl-transfer RNA binding site of the Escherichia coli ribosome

Results are presented to prove that bromoacetyl-phenylalanyl-transfer RNA reacts covalently with 50 S ribosomal proteins L2 and L27 while it is bound correctly to the peptidyl site on the 70 S ribosome. Attachment of the BrAcPhe moiety to tRNA causes a 100-fold enhancement of its reactivity with ribosomes. This reactivity closely parallels binding of tRNA whether measured by poly(U) stimulation or competition with deacylated tRNA. BrAcPhe-tRNA can bind correctly to the P site as judged by puromycin releasibility and lack of tetracycline inhibition. Little significant reaction of BrAcPhe-tRNA with L2 and L27 occurs during procedures used to purify and analyze ribosomal proteins. If ribosomes are first incubated with BrAcPhe-tRNA and subsequently treated with puromycin before analysis, little inhibition of the covalent reaction with L2 and L27 is observed. In contrast, a few minor reaction products are markedly suppressed. Covalently attached BrAcPhe-tRNA is still capable of accepting an amino acid from Phe-tRNA or puromycin. The products from this reaction are found attached to proteins L2 and L27 and to a lesser extent to L15 and L16. This shows that true affinity labeling of proteins in the peptidyl binding site has been accomplished.Some covalent reaction of BrAcPhe-tRNA with the 30 S protein S18 is also observed. This reaction is not poly(U)-dependent, however, and S18-reacted BrAcPhe-tRNA is not capable of peptide bond formation with Phe-tRNA. It seems likely that reaction with S18 results from a non-functional interaction of the affinity label with the ribosome.     

Relaxation time, interthiol distance, and mechanism of action of ribosomal protein S1

The two sulfhydryl groups of ribosomal protein S1 from Escherichia coli have been labeled with fluorescent maleimides and the distance between them has been determined by nonradiative energy transfer. This distance was found to be approximately 27 A for both free S1 and S1 bound to 30 S subunits. This value probably represents an upper limit. The position of the fluorescence emission maximum indicates that both sulfhydryl groups are in a relatively hydrophobic environment. When poly(U) is added to labeled S1, either free or in 30 S subunits, the emission maximum shifts to the red by about 3 nm but without a detectable change in the interthiol distance. S1 labeled at one or both of its sulfhydryl groups retains most of its ability to enhance poly(U)-directed polyphenylalanine synthesis. About the same concentration of poly(U) is required to give the maximum shift in fluorescence as is required to give maximum polyphenylalanine synthesis, indicating that S1 binds poly(U) during translation. The peptide initiation inhibitor aurintricarboxylic acid almost completely quenches the fluorescence from either labeled sulfhydryl groups in S1 bound to ribosomes or free in solution. This quenching probably is due to energy transfer from the labeled sulfhydryls to bound aurintricarboxylic acid. Fluorescence anisotropy measurements indicated that the C-terminal domain of S1 is relatively rigid, but retains some independent movement when attached to ribosomes. The overall data are consistent with a model in which a region near the two sulfhydryl groups in the elongated C-terminal domain functions to sequester and bind mRNA to the ribosome during peptide synthesis.     

A strain of Escherichia coli which gives rise to mutations in a large number of ribosomal proteins

Summary A strain of E. coli K12 has been isolated which gives rise to mutations in a large number of ribosomal proteins. Mutant VT, which was derived from A19, shows a novel type of streptomycin dependence and has an altered ribosomal protein S8. Streptomycin-independent isolates from mutant VT contain a great variety of changed proteins on two-dimensional polyacrylamide gels. 120 revertants screened in this way have changes in thirteen 30S proteins and fifteen 50S proteins. Several mutants were found in which additional proteins are present on the ribosome. Further, there is one instance of a ribosomal protein (L1) being absent, and one of apparent doubling of a ribosomal protein (L7/12). The unique properties of mutant VT probably are the result of the altered S8.     

Localization of the protein L2 in the 50 S subunit and the 70 S E. coli ribosome

The protein L2 is found in all ribosomes and is one of the best conserved proteins of this mega-dalton complex. The protein was localized within both the isolated 50 S subunit and the 70 S ribosome of the Escherichia coli bacteria with the neutron-scattering technique of spin-contrast variation. L2 is elongated, exposing one end of the protein to the surface of the intersubunit interface of the 50 S subunit. The protein changes its conformation slightly when the 50 S subunit reassociates with the 30 S subunit to form a 70 S ribosome, becoming more elongated and moving approximately 30 A into the 50 S matrix. The results support a recent observation that L2 is essential for the association of the ribosomal subunits and might participate in the binding and translocation of the tRNAs.     

Functional interaction of neomycin B and related antibiotics with 30S and 50S ribosomal subunits.

Antibiotics of the neomycin, kanamycin and gentamicin, but not streptomycin, groups stabilize the GDP·elongation factor (EF) G·50S subunit·fusidic acid complex. Treatment of 30S subunits, but not of 50S subunits, with neomycin B or kanamycin B, followed by removal of excess unbound antibiotic and supplementation with untreated complementary subunits, promotes poly(U)-dependent binding of Tyr-tRNA to the reassociated ribosomes (misreading). A similar treatment of either ribosomal subunit with neomycin B inhibits the EF-G-dependent translocation of Ac-Phe-tRNA. These results suggest that interaction of neomycin B and related antibiotics with the 30S subunit induces misreading and inhibits translocation, and interaction with the 50S subunit stabilizes EF-G on the ribosome and also inhibits translocation.     

Conformational changes in the ribosome induced by translational miscoding agents

Ribosomes are dynamic complexes responsible for translating the genetic information encoded in mRNAs to proteins. The accuracy of this process is vital to the survival of an organism, and is often compromised by translational miscoding agents. Aminoglycosides are a group of miscoding agents that bind to the ribosome and reduce the fidelity of translation. Previous studies have shown that aminoglycosides alter the higher order structure of the ribosome. Here, we used a toeprinting assay to how that streptomycin, neomycin, kanamycin, gentamycin, and hygromycin B trigger conformational changes within Escherichia coli ribosome. Miscoding agents viomycin and 30% ethanol also cause similar structural changes within the ribosome. In contrast, antibiotics that do not cause miscoding, such as tetracycline, chloramphenicol, erythromycin, fusidic acid and spectinomycin, do not induce the conformational changes triggered by miscoding agents. Furthermore, ribosomes isolated from strains that are either streptomycin resistant or dependent for growth do not show these conformational changes in the presence of streptomycin. These results correlate structural changes in the ribosome induced by miscoding agents in vitro with their in vivo phenotype.