The specific cytotoxicity of immunoconjugates containing blocked ricin is dependent on the residual binding capacity of blocked ricin: evidence that the membrane binding and A-chain translocation activities of ricin cannot be separated.

Recently we have developed blocked ricin, a derivative of native ricin in which the galactose-binding sites of the B-chain are blocked by covalent modification with affinity ligands. This modification impedes the binding function of the B-chain, while sparing its ability to facilitate the entry of the toxic subunit of ricin, the A-chain, into the cytoplasm. Immunotoxins prepared with blocked ricin approach the cytotoxic potency of native ricin with antibody-dependent specificity. Here we report that the high cytotoxic potency of these immunoconjugates, which is attributed to the preserved translocation function of the ricin B-chain, is dependent on the minimal residual lectin activity of blocked ricin. Our findings support the notion that two functions of ricin, membrane binding and translocation, cannot be separated.     

The galactose-binding sites of the cytotoxic lectin ricin can be chemically blocked in high yield with reactive ligands prepared by chemical modification of glycopeptides containing triantennary N-linked oligosaccharides.

A glycopeptide containing a triantennary N-linked oligosaccharide from fetuin was modified by a series of chemical and enzymic reactions to afford a reagent that contained a terminal residue of 6-(N-methylamino)-6-deoxy-D-galactose on one branch of the triantennary structure and terminal galactose residues on the other two branches. Binding assays and gel filtration experiments showed that this modified glycopeptide could bind to the sugar-binding sites of ricin. The ligand was activated at the 6-(N-methylamino)-6-deoxy-D-galactose residue by reaction with cyanuric chloride. The resulting dichlorotriazine derivative of the ligand reacts with ricin, forming a stable covalent linkage. The reaction was confined to the B-chain and was inhibited by lactose. Bovine serum albumin and ovalbumin were not modified by the activated ligand under similar conditions, and we conclude, therefore, that the reaction of the ligand with ricin B-chain was dependent upon specific binding to sugar-binding sites. Ricin that had its galactose-binding sites blocked by the covalent reaction with the activated ligand was purified by affinity chromatography. The major species in this fraction was found to contain 2 covalently linked ligands per ricin B-chain, while a minor species contained 3 ligands per B-chain. The cytotoxicity of blocked ricin was at least 1000-fold less than that of native ricin for cultured cells in vitro, even though the activity of the A-chain in a cell-free system was equal to that from native ricin. Modified ricin that contained only 1 covalently linked ligand was also purified. This fraction retained an ability to bind to galactose affinity columns, although with a lower affinity than ricin, and was only 5- to 20-fold less cytotoxic than native ricin.     

Effect of pH on the conformation and stability of the plant toxin ricin

Intrinsic protein fluorescence of native plant toxin and its isolated subunits were studied. The effect of pH was studied on: conformation of ricin and its A- and R-chains; affinity to galactose of ricin and its binding B-subunit. At two pH 5.0 and 7.0, the structural stability of toxin and subunits was estimated according to denaturational action of guanidine chloride. It was demonstrated that position of maximum and the spectrum shape of fluorescence of native toxin and catalytical A-subunit insignificantly depends on pH in the range of 3-8, whereas sufficient changes of the separameters for the ricin B-chain reveal structural transition at pH 4-5. The affinity of galactose of ricin and its isolated B-chain depends on pH, the maximal binding is observed at pH 7. The structural stability of ricin and isolated chains significantly differs at pH 7.5 and 5.0, thus the structure stability of ricin and A-chain increases, and that of B-chain decreases at pH 5.0.     

Blockade of the galactose-binding sites of ricin by its linkage to antibody. Specific cytotoxic effects of the conjugates

A method is described for preparing specific cytotoxic agents by linking intact ricin to antibodies in a manner that produces obstruction of the galactose-binding sites on the B chain of the toxin and so diminishes the capacity of the conjugate to bind non-specifically to cells. The conjugates were synthesised by reacting iodoacetylated ricin with thiolated immunoglobulin and the components of conjugate with reduced galactose-binding capacity were separated by affinity chromatography on Sepharose (a beta-galactosyl matrix) and asialofetuin-Sepharose. Fluorescence-activated cell sorter (FACS) analyses revealed that the fraction of a monoclonal anti-Thy1.1-ricin conjugate that passed through a Sepharose column had markedly diminished capacity to bind non-specifically to Thy1.2-expressing CBA thymocytes and EL4 lymphoma cells. The fraction of conjugate that passed through an asialofetuin-Sepharose column displayed no detectable non-specific binding. Both fractions of conjugate were potent cytotoxic agents for Thy1.1-expressing AKR-A lymphoma cells in tissue culture. They reduced the [3H]leucine incorporation of the cells by 50% at a concentration of 2-5 pM. Comparable inhibition of EL4 cells was only achieved with 3000-7500-fold greater concentrations of conjugate. By contrast, the fraction of anti-Thy1.1-ricin that retained Sepharose-binding capacity showed marked non-specific binding and toxicity to EL4 cells. A conjugate with diminished galactose-binding capacity was also prepared from the W3/25 monoclonal antibody which recognises an antigen upon helper T-lymphocytes in the rat. It elicited powerful and specific toxic effects upon W3/25 antigen-expressing rat T-leukaemia cells. This finding is of particular importance because isolated ricin A-chain disulphide-linked to W3/25 antibody is not cytotoxic. The property of the B-chain in intact ricin conjugates that facilitates delivery of the A-chain to the cytosol thus appears to be independent of galactose recognition. It is concluded that the 'blocked' ricin conjugates combine the advantages of high potency, which is often lacking in antibody-A-chain conjugates, with high specificity, which previously was lacking in intact ricin conjugates.     

The expression of functional ricin B-chain in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Yeast cells transformed with plasmids containing ricin B-chain coding sequences expressed this heterologous protein. When ricin B-chain was expressed in a form which resulted in its deposition in the yeast cytosol it formed insoluble aggregates which were devoid of galactose-binding activity. In contrast, when DNA fusions were constructed, in which the B-chain coding sequence was preceded by either the preproalpha-factor leader sequence or the native preproricin signal sequence, the recombinant B-chain products were soluble and biologically active. Both the homologous yeast signal peptide and the heterologous plant signal peptide directed the expressed product into the lumen of the yeast endoplasmic reticulum. As a result, the recombinant B-chain products were processed at the N-terminus, glycosylated and folded into an active conformation, presumably stabilized by correct intrachain disulphide bond formation.     

Blocked and non-blocked ricin immunotoxins against the CD4 antigen exhibit higher cytotoxic potency than a ricin A chain immunotoxin potentiated with ricin B chain or with a ricin B chain immunotoxin

Summary An immunotoxin consisting of ricin A chain linked to the monoclonal antibody M-T151, recognising the CD4 antigen, was weakly toxic to the human T-lymphoblastoid cell line CEM in tissue culture. The incorporation of [³H]leucine by CEM cells was inhibited by 50% at an M-T151-ricin-A-chain concentration (IC₅₀) of 4.6 nM compared with an IC₅₀ of 1.0 pM for ricin. In contrast, immunotoxins made by linking intact ricin to M-T151 in such a way that the galactose-binding sites of the B chain subunit were either blocked sterically by the antibody component or were left unblocked, were both powerfully cytotoxic with IC₅₀ values of 20–30 pM. The addition of ricin B chain to CEM cells treated with M-T151—ricin-A-chain enhanced cytotoxicity by only eight-fold indicating that isolated B chain potentiated the action of the A chain less effectively than it did as an integral component of an intact ricin immunotoxin. Ricin B chain linked to goat anti-(mouse immunoglobulin) also potentiated weakly.Lactose completely inhibited the ability of isolated ricin B chain to potentiate the cytotoxicity of M-T151—ricin-A-chain and partially (3- to 4-fold) inhibited the cytotoxicity of the blocked and non-blocked ricin immunotoxins. Thus, in this system, the galactose-binding sites of the B chain contributed to cell killing regardless of whether isolated B chain was associated with the A chain immunotoxin or was present in blocked or non-blocked form as part of an intact ricin immunotoxin. The findings suggest that the blocked ricin immunotoxin may become unblocked after binding to the target antigen to re-expose the cryptic galactose-binding sites. However, the unblocking cannot be complete because the maximal inhibition of [³H]leucine incorporation by the blocked immunotoxin was only 80% compared with greater than 99% inhibition by the non-blocked immunotoxin.     

Milk inhibits the biological activity of ricin

Ricin is a highly toxic protein produced by the castor plant Ricinus communis. The toxin is relatively easy to isolate and can be used as a biological weapon. There is great interest in identifying effective inhibitors for ricin. In this study, we demonstrated by three independent assays that a component of reconstituted powdered milk has a high binding affinity to ricin. We discovered that milk can competitively bind to and reduce the amount of toxin available to asialofetuin type II, which is used as a model to study the binding of ricin to galactose cell-surface receptors. Milk also removes ricin bound to the microtiter plate. In parallel experiments, we demonstrated by activity assay and by immuno-PCR that milk can bind competitively to 1 ng/ml ricin, reducing the amount of toxin uptake by the cells, and thus inhibit the biological activity of ricin. The inhibitory effect of milk on ricin activity in Vero cells was at the same level as by anti-ricin antibodies. We also found that (a) milk did not inhibit ricin at concentrations of 10 or 100 ng/ml; (b) autoclaving 10 and 100 ng/ml ricin in DMEM at 121 °C for 30 min completely abolished activity; and (c) milk did not affect the activity of another ribosome inactivating protein, Shiga toxin type 2 (Stx2), produced by pathogenic Escherichia coli O157:H7. Unlike ricin, which is internalized into the cells via a galactose-binding site, Stx2 is internalized through the cell surface receptor glycolipid globotriasylceramides Gb3 and Gb4. These observations suggest that ricin toxicity may possibly be reduced at room temperature by a widely consumed natural liquid food.     

Identification and characterization of a monoclonal antibody recognizing a galactose-binding domain of the toxin ricin

A monoclonal antibody raised against purified ricin B chain, 75/3B12, blocked ricin toxicity 30- to 100-fold in vitro. The 75/3B12 IgG and F(ab')2 blocked ricin binding to cell surface galactose-containing receptors. The 75/3B12 Fab bound ricin D with a Ka of 10(7) M-1, and this binding was blocked by asialofetuin, lactose, and N-acetylgalactosamine--molecules which interact with the ricin galactose-binding site--but not by fetuin, sucrose, or glucose. The 75/3B12 Fab contained no detectable carbohydrate and, according to several lines of evidence, did not bind ricin via Ig carbohydrate determinants. The monoclonal antibody appears to recognize a galactose-binding site on ricin D via the variable region of the antibody. The 75/3B12 Fab bound ricin E only 1/50 as well as ricin D and bound the Ricinus agglutinin only 1/80 as well as ricin D. The antibody specificity indicates that structural differences exist in the galactose-binding sites of the Ricinus communis lectins. Abrin and other lectins which bind galactose or N-acetylgalactosamine were not significantly bound by the monoclonal antibody. In vitro, the antibody blocked the nontarget toxicity of immunotoxins similarly to lactose. However, in vivo, unlike lactose, the 75/3B12 antibody protected mice from ricin toxicity.     

Cell surface and intracellular functions for ricin galactose binding.

The role of the two galactose binding sites of ricin B chain in ricin toxicity was evaluated by studying a series of ricin point mutants. Wild-type (WT) ricin and three ricin B chain point mutants having mutations in either 1) the first galactose binding domain (site 1 mutant, Met in place of Lys-40 and Gly in place of Asn-46), 2) the second galactose binding domain (site 2 mutant, Gly in place of Asn-255), or 3) both galactose binding domains (double site mutant containing all three amino acid replacements formerly stated) were expressed in Xenopus oocytes and then reassociated with recombinant ricin A chain. The different ricin B chains were mannosylated to the same extent. Cytotoxicity of these toxins was evaluated when cell entry was mediated either by galactose-containing receptors or through an alternate receptor, the mannose receptor of macrophages. WT ricin and each of the single domain mutants was able to kill Vero cells following uptake by galactose containing receptors. Lactose blocked the toxicity of each of these ricins. Site 1 and 2 mutants were 20-40 times less potent than WT ricin, and the double site mutant had no detectable cytotoxicity. WT ricin, the site 1 mutant, and the site 2 mutant also inhibited protein synthesis of mannose receptor-containing cells. Ricin can enter these cells through either a cell-surface galactose-containing receptor or through the mannose receptor. By including lactose in the cell medium, galactose-containing receptor-mediated uptake is blocked and cytotoxicity occurs solely via the mannose receptor. WT ricin, site 1, and site 2 mutants were cytotoxic to macrophages in the presence of lactose with the relative potency, WT greater than site 2 mutant greater than site 1 mutant. The double site mutant lacked cytotoxicity either in the absence or presence of lactose. Thus, even for mannose receptor-mediated toxicity of ricin, at least one galactose binding site remains necessary for cytotoxicity and two galactose binding sites further increases potency. These results are consistent with the model that the ricin B chain galactose binding activity plays a role not only in cell surface binding but also intracellularly for ricin cytotoxicity.     

Structure of ricin B-chain at 2.5 A resolution

The heterodimeric plant toxin ricin has been refined to 2.5 A resolution. The B-chain lectin (RTB) is described in detail. The protein has two major domains, each of which has a galactose binding site. RTB has no regular secondary structure but displays several omega loops. Each RTB domain is made of three copies of a primitive 40 residue folding unit, which pack around a pseudo threefold axis. In each domain, galactose binds in a shallow cleft formed by a three residue peptide kink on the bottom and an aromatic ring on the top. At the back of the cleft, an aspartate forms hydrogen bonds to the C3 and C4 hydroxyls of galactose, whereas a glutamine bonds to the C4 alcohol, helping to define specific epimer binding. In addition to analyzing the sugar binding mechanism, the assembly of subdomain units around the pseudo threefold axis of each domain is described. The subdomains contribute conserved Trp, Leu, and Ile residues to a compact central hydrophobic core. This tight threefold binding probably drives the peptide folding and stabilizes the protein structure.     

Hybridoma cells containing intracellular anti-ricin antibodies show ricin meets secretory antibody before entering the cytosol

Hybridoma cells which synthesize monoclonal antibodies (mAb) that block ricin toxicity were 50-300-fold resistant to ricin compared with other hybridomas. Two of the mAb blocked two isozymes of ricin, D and E, to different and opposite extents, and the hybridoma cell resistance to the two forms of ricin closely corresponded with the mAb reactivity. The hybridoma cell resistance to ricin was therefore due to the binding activity of the mAb produced by the cells. Neither rabbit polyclonal antibodies, which neutralized extracellular anti-ricin mAb, nor quantitative removal of hybridoma cell surface IgG with papain affected the cellular resistance to ricin. Therefore, neither extracellular or cell surface antibodies contributed to the resistance of the hybridoma cells. In contrast, inhibition of protein synthesis by cycloheximide or puromycin, which selectively decreased levels of intracellular secretory IgG, decreased the hybridoma cell resistance to ricin. We conclude that intracellular mAb, synthesized de novo for subsequent secretion, block ricin toxicity. Ricin therefore must meet intracellular secretory antibodies before reaching the cytosol. The monoclonal antibodies can also be used to study toxin function within intracellular compartments. An antibody specific for the galactose-binding site of ricin blocks ricin intracellularly, showing that the ricin galactose-binding activity is required in an intracellular compartment for transport of ricin A chain to the cytosol.     

Internalization of ricin in Chinese hamster ovary cells.

Internalization of ricin into Chinese hamster ovary cells has been investigated. Combined treatment with galactose and pronase at 0 degrees C resulted in a complete release of surface-bound [125I]ricin into the media. Galactose-pronase-resistant cell-bound [125I]ricin represents internalized ricin molecules inside the cells. The internalization process is time, temperature, and concentration dependent. The pH optimum of internalization of ricin is about pH 7. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis has revealed that intact ricin molecules are internalized. Neither reduction nor proteolytic processing of ricin is required for the entry of ricin into Chinese hamster ovary cells.     

Circular dichroism of isolated ricin A- and B-chains

An analysis of the circular dichroism (CD) spectra of isolated ricin A- and B-chains revealed several bands not apparent in the spectrum of intact ricin. Arithmetic combination of the A- and B-chain spectra gave a composite spectrum resembling that of native ricin, indicating that the two chains did not undergo any major conformational change upon dissociation. The addition of lactose to the B-chain at pH 7.2 caused a slight perturbation of a tryptophan-derived negative CD band centred at 283 nm without change to the overall structure of the polypeptide.     

Studies on the galactose-binding site of ricin and the hybrid toxin man6P-ricin

N-acetylimidazole (NAI) was used to O-acetylate the plant seed toxin ricin. O-acetylation of one to two tyrosine residues per molecule of ricin inhibited ricin binding to Sepharose 4B and decreased toxicity by 90% in a protein synthesis inhibition assay in HeLa cells. Lactose, known to block the binding site on the ricin B subunit, protected ricin from NAI modification of binding or toxicity. Thus NAI, under these conditions, can be a lactose site-specific inhibitor. The lactose site-specific modification of the hybrid toxin, Man6P-ricin, performed under the same conditions, exhibited the same 90% inhibition of Man6P receptor-mediated toxicity as the galactose-containing receptor-mediated toxicity of either Man6P-ricin or ricin. Thus the ricin B chain lactose-binding site appears to be essential for the high potency of Man6P-ricin via the new cell type-specific Man6P receptor. Treatment of fibroblasts with neuraminidase exposes galactose residues, thus increasing the sensitivity to ricin eight fold. The Man6P receptor-mediated toxicity of Man6P-ricin is not affected by this treatment, although the galactose-inhibited route is potentiated eight fold. The Man6P-ricin hybrid appears to require the ricin B chain galactose-binding site to enter the cytosol after initially binding to the Man6P receptor. These data provide some insights into the proper design of hybrid toxins. We discuss a number of possible models for hybrid toxin entry.     

The preparation of deglycosylated ricin by recombination of glycosidase-treated A- and B-chains: effects of deglycosylation on toxicity and in vivo distribution

Deglycosylation of ricin may be necessary to prevent the entrapment of antibody-ricin conjugates in vivo by cells of the reticuloendothelial system which have receptors that recognise the oligosaccharide side chains on the A- and B-chains of the toxin. Carbohydrate-deficient ricin was therefore prepared by recombining the A-chain, which had been treated with alpha-mannosidase, with the B-chain, which had been treated with endoglycosidase H or alpha-mannosidase or both. By recombining treated and untreated chains, a series of ricin preparations was made having different carbohydrate moieties. The removal of carbohydrate from the B-chain did not affect the ability of the toxin to agglutinate erythrocytes, and alpha-mannosidase treatment of the A-chain did not affect its ability to inactivate ribosomes. The toxicity of ricin to cells in culture was only reduced in those preparations containing B-chain that had been treated with alpha-mannosidase, when a 75% decrease in toxicity was observed. The toxicity of the combined ricin preparation to mice varied from double to half that of native ricin, depending on the chain(s) treated and the enzymes used. Removal of carbohydrate greatly reduced the hepatic clearance of the toxin and the levels of toxin in the blood were correspondingly higher. These results suggest that antibody-ricin conjugates prepared from deglycosylated ricin would be cleared more slowly by the liver, inflict less liver damage, and have greater opportunity to reach their target.     

Interaction of ricin and its constituent polypeptides with dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine vesicles

The interaction of ricin and of its constituent polypeptides, the A- and B-chain, with dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) vesicles was investigated. The A- and B-chain were individually associated with DPPC vesicles, although the intact ricin was not associated. The maximum binding and association constants were evaluated to be 154 micrograms per mg of DPPC and Ka = 2.30 X 10(5) M-1 for the A-chain, and 87 micrograms per mg of DPPC and Ka = 14.5 X 10(5) M-1 for the B-chain, respectively. The A-chain could induce the phase transition release of carboxyfluorescein from DPPC vesicles to a greater extent than the B-chain, whereas the release induced by the intact ricin was negligible. The evidence indicated that the hydrophobic regions on the A-chain and on the B-chain were buried inside when the two chains constituted the intact ricin molecule through one interchain disulfide bond, and that the A-chain caused perturbation of the DPPC bilayer at the phase transition temperature with consequent leakage of carboxyfluorescein.     

Isolation and characterization of two mouse L cell lines resistant to the toxic lectin ricin.

Two variant mouse L cell lines (termed CL 3 and CL 6) have been selected for resistant to ricin, a galactose-binding lectin with potent cytotoxic activity. The resistant lines exhibit a 50 to 70% decrease in ricin binding and a 300- to 500-fold increase in resistance to the toxic effects of ricin. Crude membrane preparations of CL 3 cells have increased sialic acid content (200% of control), while the galactose, mannose, and hexosamine content is within normal limits. Both the glycoproteins and glycolipids of CL 3 cells have increased sialic acid, with the GM3:lactosylceramide ratios for parent L and CL 3 cells being 0.29 and 1.5, respectively. In contrast, the membranes of CL 6 cells have a decrease in sialic acid, galactose, and hexosamine content with mannose being normal. Both cell lines have specific alterations in glycosyltransferase activities which can account for the observed membrane sugar changes. CL 3 cells have increased CMP-sialic acid:glycoprotein sialyltransferase and GM3 synthetase activities, while CL 6 cells have decrease UDP-GlcNAc:glycoproteinN-acetylglucosaminyltransferase and DPU-galactose:glycoprotein galactosyltransferase activities. The increased sialic acid content of CL 3 cells serves to mask ricin binding sites, since neuraminidase treatment of this cell line restores ricin binding to essentially normal levels. However, the fact that neuraminidase-treated CL 3 cells are still 45-fold resistant to ricin indicates that either a special class of productive ricin binding sites is not being exposed or that the cell line has a second mechanism for ricin resistance.     

Identification of the tryptophan residue located at the low-affinity saccharide binding site of ricin D

The saccharide binding ability of the low affinity (LA-) binding site of ricin D was abrogated by N-bromosuccinimide (NBS)-oxidation, while in the presence of lactose the number of tryptophan residues eventually oxidized decreased by 1 mol/mol and the saccharide binding ability was retained (Hatakeyama et al., (1986) J. Biochem. 99, 1049-1056). Based on these findings, the tryptophan residue located at the LA-binding site of ricin D was identified. Two derivatives of ricin D which were modified with NBS in the presence and absence of lactose were separated into their constituent polypeptide chains (A- and B-chains), respectively. The modified tryptophan residue or residues was/were found to be contained in the B-chain, but not in the A-chain. From lysylendopeptidase and chymotryptic digests, peptides containing oxidized tryptophan residues were isolated by gel filtration on Bio-Gel P-30 and HPLC. Analysis of the peptides containing oxidized tryptophan revealed that three tryptophan residues at positions 37, 93, and 160 on the B-chain were oxidized in the inactive derivative of ricin D, in which the saccharide binding ability of the LA-binding site was abrogated by NBS-oxidation. On the other hand, the modified residues were determined to be tryptophans at positions 93 and 160 in the active derivative of ricin D which was modified in the presence of lactose, indicating that upon binding with lactose, the tryptophan residue at position 37 of the B-chain was protected from NBS-oxidation. From these results, it is suggested that tryptophan at position 37 on the B-chain is the essential residue for saccharide binding at the LA-binding site of ricin D.     

Preparation and properties of a hybrid toxin of modeccin A-chain and ricin B-chain

Hybrid molecules were prepared from the A- and B-chains of the two toxic lectins ricin and modeccin by dialyzing mixtures of isolated chains to allow a disulfide bridge to be formed between them. Whereas the hybrid consisting of ricin A-chain and modeccin B-chain was non-toxic, the converse hybrid, modeccin A-chain/ricin B-chain, was even more toxic to Vero cells than were the parent toxins, native ricin and modeccin. A number of drugs (NH₄Cl, monensin, trifluoperazine, verapamil, ionophore A23187) which protect cells against modeccin, but not against ricin, protected to some extent against the toxic hybrid, but less so than against native modeccin. The possibility is discussed that the modeccin A-chain of the hybrid may enter the cytosol by two routes, one which is highly efficient and identical to that used by native modeccin and another less efficient one which cannot be used by native modeccin.     

The complete amino acid sequence of the B-chain of ricin E isolated from small-grain castor bean seeds. Ricin E is a gene recombination product of ricin D and ricinus communis agglutinin

The complete amino acid sequence of the B-chain of ricin E has been determined. The reduced and carboxymethylated B-chain was digested with trypsin, followed by separation and purification of the resulting peptides using reverse-phase HPLC. The amino acid sequence of each tryptic peptide was determined employing the DABITC/PITC double-coupling method. The B-chain of ricin E proved to consist of 262 amino acid residues. By comparing the amino acid sequence of the B-chain of ricin E with those of ricin D and of Ricinus communis agglutinin, it was found that the B-chain of ricin E was composed of the N-terminal half of ricin D and the C-terminal half of R. communis agglutinin. This result suggested that the gene recombination probably occurred at the center region of two B-chain genes of ricin D and R. communis agglutinin.