Probing 2-dimensional protein-protein interactions on model membranes

This protocol describes an in vitro approach for measuring the kinetics and affinities of interactions between membrane-anchored proteins. This method is particularly established for dissecting the interaction dynamics of cytokines with their receptor subunits. For this purpose, the receptor subunits are tethered in an orientated manner onto solid-supported lipid bilayers by using multivalent chelator lipids. Interaction between the ligand with the receptor subunits was probed by a combination of surface-sensitive spectroscopic detection techniques. Label-free detection by reflectance interferometry is used for following assembly of the membrane and tethering of the receptor subunits in quantitative terms. Total internal reflection spectroscopy is used for monitoring ligand binding to the membrane-anchored receptor, for monitoring ligand-receptor interactions by FRET and for monitoring ligand-exchange kinetics. These assays can be used for determining the affinities and stabilities of ligand-receptor complexes in plane of the membrane. The techniques described in this protocol can be established in 2-3 months.     

Synthesis of the chelator lipid nitrilotriacetic acid ditetradecylamine (NTA-DTDA) and its use with the IAsys biosensor to study receptor-ligand interactions on model membranes

This work describes the synthesis and use of the chelator lipid, nitrilotriacetic acid ditetradecylamine (NTA-DTDA). This lipid is readily dispersed in aqueous media, both alone and when mixed with carrier lipids like dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC). Fluorescence microscopic examination of membranes deposited from NTA-DTDA-containing liposomes shows that NTA-DTDA mixes uniformly with the carrier lipid, and does not phase separate. NTA-DTDA-membranes deposited onto the sensing surface of IAsys biosensor cuvettes show good stability, permitting use of the biosensor to study protein interactions. Hexahistidine-tagged proteins including recombinant forms of the extracellular regions of murine B7.1 (B7.1-6H) and of the human erythropoietin receptor (EPOR-6H) bind to NTA-DTDA-membranes; the stability of binding is dependent on both protein concentration, and density of NTA-DTDA. Kinetic measurements show that high stability of anchored proteins (t(1/2) approximately 10-20 h, apparent K(d) approximately 1 nM) can be achieved using membranes containing 25 mol% NTA-DTDA, but low levels of bound protein (<200 arc seconds). The system is used to study the interaction of human EPO with the EPOR anchored onto NTA-DTDA-membranes. In addition to the biological applications reported recently, the results show that NTA-DTDA can be a useful reagent in the study of receptor-ligand interactions.     

Atg8, a ubiquitin-like protein required for autophagosome formation, mediates membrane tethering and hemifusion

Autophagy involves de novo formation of double membrane-bound structures called autophagosomes, which engulf material to be degraded in lytic compartments. Atg8 is a ubiquitin-like protein required for this process in Saccharomyces cerevisiae that can be conjugated to the lipid phosphatidylethanolamine by a ubiquitin-like system. Here, we show using an in vitro system that Atg8 mediates the tethering and hemifusion of membranes, which are evoked by the lipidation of the protein and reversibly modulated by the deconjugation enzyme Atg4. Mutational analyses suggest that membrane tethering and hemifusion observed in vitro represent an authentic function of Atg8 in autophagosome formation in vivo. In addition, electron microscopic analyses indicate that these functions of Atg8 are involved in the expansion of autophagosomal membranes. Our results provide further insights into the mechanisms underlying the unique membrane dynamics of autophagy and also indicate the functional versatility of ubiquitin-like proteins.     

Protein diffusion on charged membranes: a dynamic mean-field model describes time evolution and lipid reorganization

As charged macromolecules adsorb and diffuse on cell membranes in a large variety of cell signaling processes, they can attract or repel oppositely charged lipids. This results in lateral membrane rearrangement and affects the dynamics of protein function. To address such processes quantitatively we introduce a dynamic mean-field scheme that allows self-consistent calculations of the equilibrium state of membrane-protein complexes after such lateral reorganization of the membrane components, and serves to probe kinetic details of the process. Applicable to membranes with heterogeneous compositions containing several types of lipids, this comprehensive method accounts for mobile salt ions and charged macromolecules in three dimensions, as well as for lateral demixing of charged and net-neutral lipids in the membrane plane. In our model, the mobility of membrane components is governed by the diffusion-like Cahn-Hilliard equation, while the local electrochemical potential is based on nonlinear Poisson-Boltzmann theory. We illustrate the method by applying it to the adsorption of the anionic polypeptide poly-Lysine on negatively charged lipid membranes composed of binary mixtures of neutral and monovalent lipids, or onto ternary mixtures of neutral, monovalent, and multivalent lipids. Consistent with previous calculations and experiments, our results show that at steady-state multivalent lipids (such as PIP₂), but not monovalent lipid (such as phosphatidylserine), will segregate near the adsorbing macromolecules. To address the corresponding diffusion of the adsorbing protein in the membrane plane, we couple lipid mobility with the propagation of the adsorbing protein through a dynamic Monte Carlo scheme. We find that due to their higher mobility dictated by the electrochemical potential, multivalent lipids such as PIP₂ more quickly segregate near oppositely charged proteins than do monovalent lipids, even though their diffusion constants may be similar. The segregation, in turn, slows protein diffusion, as lipids introduce an effective drag on the motion of the adsorbate. In contrast, monovalent lipids such as phosphatidylserine only weakly segregate, and the diffusions of protein and lipid remain largely uncorrelated.     

A ubiquitin-like protein involved in membrane fusion

Atg8 is a ubiquitin-like protein involved in autophagy in yeast that is targeted to membranes through conjugation to the lipid phosphatidylethanolamine (PE). In this issue of Cell, Nakatogawa et al. (2007) show that Atg8 conjugated to PE mediates tethering between adjacent membranes and stimulates membrane hemifusion, an event that may mimic expansion of the autophagosomal membrane during autophagy.     

The HOPS/Class C Vps Complex Tethers High‐Curvature Membranes via a Direct Protein–Membrane Interaction

Membrane tethering is a physical association of two membranes before their fusion. Many membrane tethering factors have been identified, but the interactions that mediate inter‐membrane associations remain largely a matter of conjecture. Previously, we reported that the homotypic fusion and protein sorting/Class C vacuolar protein sorting (HOPS/Class C Vps) complex, which has two binding sites for the yeast vacuolar Rab GTPase Ypt7p, can tether two low‐curvature liposomes when both membranes bear Ypt7p. Here, we show that HOPS tethers highly curved liposomes to Ypt7p‐bearing low‐curvature liposomes even when the high‐curvature liposomes are protein‐free. Phosphorylation of the curvature‐sensing amphipathic lipid‐packing sensor (ALPS) motif from the Vps41p HOPS subunit abrogates tethering of high‐curvature liposomes. A HOPS complex without its Vps39p subunit, which contains one of the Ypt7p binding sites in HOPS, lacks tethering activity, though it binds high‐curvature liposomes and Ypt7p‐bearing low‐curvature liposomes. Thus, HOPS tethers highly curved membranes via a direct protein–membrane interaction. Such high‐curvature membranes are found at the sites of vacuole tethering and fusion. There, vacuole membranes bend sharply, generating large areas of vacuole‐vacuole contact. We propose that HOPS localizes via the Vps41p ALPS motif to these high‐curvature regions. There, HOPS binds via Vps39p to Ypt7p in an apposed vacuole membrane.      

Kinetics of lipid-membrane binding and conformational change of L-BABP

We designed an experimental approach to differentiate the kinetics of protein binding to a lipid membrane from the kinetics of the associated conformational change in the protein. We measured the fluorescence intensity of the single Trp6 in chicken liver bile acid-binding protein (L-BABP) as a function of time after mixing the protein with lipid membranes. We mixed the protein with pure lipid membranes, with lipid membranes in the presence of a soluble quencher, and with lipid membranes containing a fluorescence quencher attached to the lipid polar head group. We fitted simultaneously the experimental curves to a three-state kinetic model. We conclude that in a first step, the binding of L-BABP to the interfacial region of the anionic lipid polar head groups occurred simultaneously with a conformational change to the partly unfolded state. In a second slower step, Trp6 buried within the polar head group region, releasing contacts with the aqueous phase.     

Isolation of renal proximal tubular brush-border membranes

This protocol describes a method for the isolation and purification of renal proximal tubular brush-border membranes in high yield and high purity. Based on a different reactivity of the brush-border membrane compared to other cellular membranes with divalent cations, such as Mg2+, purified membrane vesicles can be obtained after a few differential centrifugation steps (within approximately 3 h) that are suitable for in vitro studies, such as transport experiments or protein and lipid analysis.     

The Sec61p complex mediates the integration of a membrane protein by allowing lipid partitioning of the transmembrane domain

We have investigated how the transmembrane (TM) domain of a membrane protein is cotranslationally integrated into the endoplasmic reticulum. We demonstrate that the Sec61p channel allows the TM domain to bypass the barrier posed by the polar head groups of the lipid bilayer and come into contact with the hydrophobic interior of the membrane. Together with the TRAM protein, Sec61p provides a site in the membrane, at the interface of channel and lipid, through which a TM domain can dynamically equilibrate between the lipid and aqueous phases, depending on the hydrophobicity of the TM domain and the length of the polypeptide segment tethering it to the ribosome. Our results suggest a unifying, lipid-partitioning model which can explain the general behavior of hydrophobic topogenic sequences.     

Lipid–protein interactions in biological membranes: A dynamic perspective

Though an increasing number of biological functions at the membrane are attributed to direct associations between lipid head groups and protein side chains or lipid protein hydrophobic attractive forces, surprisingly limited information is available about the dynamics of these interactions. The static in vitro representation provided by membrane protein structures, including very insightful lipid–protein binding geometries, still fails to recapitulate the dynamic behavior characteristic of lipid membranes. Experimental measures of the interaction time of lipid–protein association are very rare, and have only provided order-of-magnitude estimates in an extremely limited number of systems. In this review, a brief outline of the experimental approaches taken in this area to date is given. The bulk of the review will focus on two methods that are promising techniques for measuring lipid–protein interactions: time-resolved fluorescence microscopy, and two-dimensional infrared (2D IR) spectroscopy. Time-resolved fluorescence microscopy is the name given to a sophisticated toolbox of measurements taken using pulsed laser excitation and time-correlated single photon counting (TCSPC). With this technique the dynamics of interaction can be measured on the time scale of nanoseconds to milliseconds. 2D IR is a femtosecond nonlinear spectroscopy that can resolve vibrational coupling between lipids and proteins at molecular-scale distances and at time scales from femtoseconds to picoseconds. These two methods are poised to make significant advances in our understanding of the dynamic properties of biological membranes. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Membrane protein structure and function.     

Interaction of GAPR-1 with lipid bilayers is regulated by alternative homodimerization

Golgi-Associated Plant Pathogenesis-Related protein 1 (GAPR-1) is a mammalian protein that belongs to the superfamily of plant pathogenesis related proteins group 1 (PR-1). GAPR-1 is a peripheral membrane-binding protein that strongly associates with lipid-enriched microdomains at the cytosolic leaflet of Golgi membranes. Little is known about the mechanism of GAPR-1 interaction with membranes. We previously suggested that dimerization plays a role in the function of GAPR-1 and here we report that phytic acid (inositol hexakisphosphate) induces dimerization of GAPR-1 in solution. Elucidation of the crystal structure of GAPR-1 in the presence of phytic acid revealed that the GAPR-1 dimer differs from the previously published GAPR-1 dimer structure. In this structure, one of the monomeric subunits of the crystallographic dimer is rotated by 28.5°. To study the GAPR-1 dimerization properties, we investigated the interaction with liposomes in a light scattering assay and by flow cytometry. In the presence of negatively charged lipids, GAPR-1 caused a rapid and stable tethering of liposomes. [D81K]GAPR-1, a mutant predicted to stabilize the IP6-induced dimer conformation, also caused tethering of liposomes. [A68K]GAPR-1 however, a mutant predicted to stabilize the non-rotated dimer conformation, is capable of binding to liposomes but did not cause liposome tethering. Our combined data suggest that the charge properties of the lipid bilayer can regulate GAPR-1 dynamics as a potential mechanism to modulate GAPR-1 function.     

Helicobacter pylori CagA-mediated IL-8 induction in gastric epithelial cells is cholesterol-dependent and requires the C-terminal tyrosine phosphorylation-containing domain

Upon infection of the gastric epithelial cells, the Helicobacter pylori cytotoxin-associated gene A (CagA) virulence protein is injected into the epithelial cells via the type IV secretion system (TFSS), which is dependent on cholesterol. Translocated CagA is targeted by the membrane-recruited c-Src family kinases in which a tyrosine residue in the Glu-Pro-Ile-Tyr-Ala (EPIYA)-repeat region, which can be phosphorylated, induces cellular responses, including interleukin-8 (IL-8) secretion and hummingbird phenotype formation. In this study, we explored the role of EPIYA-containing C-terminal domain (CTD) in CagA tethering to the membrane lipid rafts and in IL-8 activity. We found that disruption of the lipid rafts reduced the level of CagA translocation/phosphorylation as well as CagA-mediated IL-8 secretion. By CagA truncated mutagenesis, we identified that the CTD, rather than the N-terminal domain, was responsible for CagA tethering to the plasma membrane and association with detergent-resistant membranes, leading to CagA-induced IL-8 promoter activity. Our results suggest that CagA CTD-containing EPIYAs directly interact with cholesterol-rich microdomains that induce efficient IL-8 secretion in the epithelial cells.     

Phosphorylation of a membrane curvature-sensing motif switches function of the HOPS subunit Vps41 in membrane tethering

Tethering factors are organelle-specific multisubunit protein complexes that identify, along with Rab guanosine triphosphatases, transport vesicles and trigger their SNARE-mediated fusion of specific transport vesicles with the target membranes. Little is known about how tethering factors discriminate between different trafficking pathways, which may converge at the same organelle. In this paper, we describe a phosphorylation-based switch mechanism, which allows the homotypic vacuole fusion protein sorting effector subunit Vps41 to operate in two distinct fusion events, namely endosome-vacuole and AP-3 vesicle-vacuole fusion. Vps41 contains an amphipathic lipid-packing sensor (ALPS) motif, which recognizes highly curved membranes. At endosomes, this motif is inserted into the lipid bilayer and masks the binding motif for the δ subunit of the AP-3 complex, Apl5, without affecting the Vps41 function in endosome-vacuole fusion. At the much less curved vacuole, the ALPS motif becomes available for phosphorylation by the resident casein kinase Yck3. As a result, the Apl5-binding site is exposed and allows AP-3 vesicles to bind to Vps41, followed by specific fusion with the vacuolar membrane. This multifunctional tethering factor thus discriminates between trafficking routes by switching from a curvature-sensing to a coat recognition mode upon phosphorylation.     

Molecular genetic and biochemical approaches for defining lipid-dependent membrane protein folding

We provide an overview of lipid-dependent polytopic membrane protein folding and topogenesis. Lipid dependence of this process was determined by employing Escherichia coli cells in which specific lipids can be eliminated, substituted, tightly titrated or controlled temporally during membrane protein synthesis and assembly. The secondary transport protein lactose permease (LacY) was used to establish general principles underlying the molecular basis of lipid-dependent effects on protein domain folding, protein transmembrane domain (TM) orientation, and function. These principles were then extended to several other secondary transport proteins of E. coli. The methods used to follow proper conformational organization of protein domains and the topological organization of protein TMs in whole cells and membranes are described. The proper folding of an extramembrane domain of LacY that is crucial for energy dependent uphill transport function depends on specific lipids acting as non-protein molecular chaperones. Correct TM topogenesis is dependent on charge interactions between the cytoplasmic surface of membrane proteins and a proper balance of the membrane surface net charge defined by the lipid head groups. Short-range interactions between the nascent protein chain and the translocon are necessary but not sufficient for establishment of final topology. After release from the translocon short-range interactions between lipid head groups and the nascent protein chain, partitioning of protein hydrophobic domains into the membrane bilayer, and long-range interactions within the protein thermodynamically drive final membrane protein organization. Given the diversity of membrane lipid compositions throughout nature, it is tempting to speculate that during the course of evolution the physical and chemical properties of proteins and lipids have co-evolved in the context of the lipid environment of membrane systems in which both are mutually dependent on each other for functional organization of proteins. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Protein Folding in Membranes.     

Curvature‐sensitive trans‐assembly of human Atg8‐family proteins in autophagy‐related membrane tethering

In macroautophagy, de novo formation of the double membrane‐bound organelles, termed autophagosomes, is essential for engulfing and sequestering the cytoplasmic contents to be degraded in the lytic compartments such as vacuoles and lysosomes. Atg8‐family proteins have been known to be responsible for autophagosome formation via membrane tethering and fusion events of precursor membrane structures. Nevertheless, how Atg8 proteins act directly upon autophagosome formation still remains enigmatic. Here, to further gain molecular insights into Atg8‐mediated autophagic membrane dynamics, we study the two representative human Atg8 orthologs, LC3B and GATE‐16, by quantitatively evaluating their intrinsic potency to physically tether lipid membranes in a chemically defined reconstitution system using purified Atg8 proteins and synthetic liposomes. Both LC3B and GATE‐16 retained the capacities to trigger efficient membrane tethering at the protein‐to‐lipid molar ratios ranging from 1:100 to 1:5,000. These human Atg8‐mediated membrane‐tethering reactions require trans‐assembly between the membrane‐anchored forms of LC3B and GATE‐16 and can be reversibly and strictly controlled by the membrane attachment and detachment cycles. Strikingly, we further uncovered distinct membrane curvature dependences of LC3B‐ and GATE‐16‐mediated membrane tethering reactions: LC3B can drive tethering more efficiently than GATE‐16 for highly curved small vesicles (e.g., 50 nm in diameter), although GATE‐16 turns out to be a more potent tether than LC3B for flatter large vesicles (e.g., 200 and 400 nm in diameter). Our findings establish curvature‐sensitive trans‐assembly of human Atg8‐family proteins in reconstituted membrane tethering, which recapitulates an essential subreaction of the biogenesis of autophagosomes in vivo.     

Baculovirus display for discovery of low-affinity extracellular receptor–ligand interactions using protein microarrays

When used in conjunction with multivalent protein probes, protein microarrays offer a robust technology for discovery of low-affinity extracellular protein–protein interactions. Probes for receptor-matching screens generally consist of purified extracellular domains fused to affinity tags. Given that approximately two-thirds of extracellular proteins are transmembrane domain-containing proteins, it would be desirable to develop a system to express and display probe receptors in a native-like membrane environment. Toward this end, we evaluated baculovirus display as a platform for generating multivalent probes for protein microarray screens. Virion particles were generated displaying single-transmembrane domain receptors BTLA, CD200, and EFNB2, representing a range of affinities for their interacting partners. Virions directly labeled with Cy5 fluorophore were screened against a microarray containing more than 600 extracellular proteins, and the results were compared with data derived from soluble Fc protein or probe-coated protein A microbeads. An optimized protocol employing a blocking step with a nonrelated probe-expressing control baculovirus allowed identification of the expected interactions with a signal-to-noise ratio similar to or higher than those obtained with the other formats. Our results demonstrate that baculovirus display is suitable for detection of high- and low-affinity extracellular protein–protein interactions on protein microarrays. This platform eliminates the need for protein purification and provides a native-like lipid environment for membrane-associated receptors.     

Peroxisome assembly: matrix and membrane protein biogenesis

Mitochondria are dynamic organelles whose functional integrity requires a coordinated supply of proteins and phospholipids. Defined functions of specific phospholipids, like the mitochondrial signature lipid cardiolipin, are emerging in diverse processes, ranging from protein biogenesis and energy production to membrane fusion and apoptosis. The accumulation of phospholipids within mitochondria depends on interorganellar lipid transport between the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and mitochondria as well as intramitochondrial lipid trafficking. The discovery of proteins that regulate mitochondrial membrane lipid composition and of a multiprotein complex tethering ER to mitochondrial membranes has unveiled novel mechanisms of mitochondrial membrane biogenesis.     

Membrane tethering by the atlastin GTPase depends on GTP hydrolysis but not on forming the cross-over configuration

The membrane-anchored atlastin GTPase couples nucleotide hydrolysis to the catalysis of homotypic membrane fusion to form a branched endoplasmic reticulum network. Trans dimerization between atlastins anchored in opposing membranes, accompanied by a cross-over conformational change, is thought to draw the membranes together for fusion. Previous studies on the conformational coupling of atlastin to its GTP hydrolysis cycle have been carried out largely on atlastins lacking a membrane anchor. Consequently, whether fusion involves a discrete tethering step and, if so, the potential role of GTP hydrolysis and cross-over in tethering remain unknown. In this study, we used membrane-anchored atlastins in assays that separate tethering from fusion to dissect the requirements for each. We found that tethering depended on GTP hydrolysis, but, unlike fusion, it did not depend on cross-over. Thus GTP hydrolysis initiates stable head-domain contact in trans to tether opposing membranes, whereas cross-over formation plays a more pivotal role in powering the lipid rearrangements for fusion.     

Biomimetic design of nanopatterned membranes

The biomimetic approach copying the supramolecular building principle of many archaeal cell envelopes (i.e., a plasma membrane with associated S-layer proteins) has resulted in stable lipid membranes with excellent reconstitution properties for transmembrane proteins. This is a particular challenge as one-third of all proteins in an organism are membrane proteins like pores, ion channels, or receptors. At S-layer supported lipid membranes, spatial well-defined domains on the S-layer protein interact noncovalently with lipid head groups within the lipid membrane resulting in a nanopatterning of a few anchored and scores of diffusional free-lipid molecules. In addition, no impact on the hydrophobic core region and on the function of reconstituted integral proteins has been determined. Among others, particularly S-layer stabilized membranes can be used for structure-function studies on reconstituted integral proteins and also in the membrane protein-based molecular nanotechnology, e.g., in the design of biosensing devices (e.g., lipid chip or lab-on-a-chip), or for receptor or ion channel-based high-throughput screening.     

Perturbations of phospholipid head groups by membrane proteins in biological membranes and recombinants.

P-31 nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spin-lattice relaxation times (T1) have been used to probe the behavior of phospholipid head groups in the presence of membrane proteins. Measurements have been made on rabbit muscle sarcoplasmic reticulum and recombinants of the Ca2+ Mg2+ ATPase, rod outer segment disk membranes and recombinants of rhodopsin, and human erythrocyte ghosts and recombinants of human erythrocyte glycophorin. Recombined membranes with lipid/protein ratios greater than or equal to that found in biological membranes showed T1 behavior similar to the biological membranes and pure phosphatidylcholine. However, recombined membranes with a low lipid/protein ratio exhibited a T1 that was dramatically shorter than any of the other systems. Analysis of the relaxation mechanism and the factors contributing to it implicate a phospholipid head group conformation change at high protein content. It is suggested that this is due to trapping of phospholipid between proteins and is not the same phenomenon as motional restriction at the lipid-protein interface at higher lipid contents.