Reducing mutational bias in random protein libraries

The success of protein optimization through directed molecular evolution depends to a large extent on the size and quality of the displayed library. Current low-fidelity DNA polymerases that are commonly used during random mutagenesis and recombination in vitro display strong mutational preferences, favoring the substitution of certain nucleotides over others. The result is a biased and reduced functional diversity in the library under selection. In an effort to reduce mutational bias, we combined two different low-fidelity DNA polymerases, Taq and Mutazyme, which have opposite mutational spectra. As a first step, random mutants of the Bacillus thuringiensis cry9Ca1 gene were generated by separate error-prone polymerase chain reactions (PCRs) with each of the two polymerases. Subsequent shuffling by staggered extension process (StEP) of the PCR products resulted in intermediate numbers of AT and GC substitutions, compared to the Taq or Mutazyme error-prone PCR libraries. This strategy should allow generating unbiased libraries or libraries with a specific degree of mutational bias by applying optimal mutagenesis frequencies during error-prone PCR and controlling the concentration of template in the shuffling reaction while taking into account the GC content of the target gene.     

Random-priming in vitro recombination: an effective tool for directed evolution.

A simple and efficient method for in vitro mutagenesis and recombination of polynucleotide sequences is reported. The method involves priming template polynucleotide(s) with random-sequence primers and extending to generate a pool of short DNA fragments which contain a controllable level of point mutations. The fragments are reassembled during cycles of denaturation, annealing and further enzyme-catalyzed DNA polymerization to produce a library of full-length sequences. Screening or selecting the expressed gene products leads to new variants with improved functions, as demonstrated by the recombination of genes encoding different thermostable subtilisins in order to obtain enzymes more stable than either parent.     

Random mutagenesis and recombination of sam1 gene by integrating error-prone PCR with staggered extension process

An efficient method for creating a DNA library is presented in which gene mutagenesis and recombination can be introduced by integrating error-prone PCR with a staggered extension process in one test tube. In this process, less than 15 cycles of error-prone PCR are used to introduce random mutations. After precipitated and washed with ethanol solution, the error-prone PCR product is directly used both as template and primers in the following staggered extension process to introduce DNA recombination. The method was validated by using adenosyl-methionine (AdoMet) synthetase gene, sam1, as a model. The full-length target DNA fragment was available after a single round. After being selected with a competitive inhibitor, ethionine, a mutated gene was obtained that increased AdoMet accumulation in vivo by 56%.     

Molecular evolution of AdoMet synthetase by DNA recombination with a novel separate-mixing method

We describe a new approach to in vitro DNA recombination termed Separate-Mixing method in this study. The reaction process of this method consists of two stages: at the first stage the reaction was implemented in two parallel teams, which generated random recombination by template-switching of growing polynucleotides from primers in the presence of unidirectional single-stranded DNA fragments used as templates, and then both teams were mixed together for further extension and recombination of DNA sequences at the second stage. Because of the particular strategy, the reaction process was also accompanied by the other two processes of DNA shuffling and StEP simultaneously. Two AdoMet synthetase genes sam2 from Saccharomyces cerevisiae and metK from Escherichia coli, which have only 56% homology on the DNA level were used for recombination with Separate-Mixing method. DNA recombination was available after a single round of reaction. With sequencing of 10 randomly selected recombinants, no unshuffled parental clone was found, and also no unexpected insertion, deletion or rearrangement was detected. An evolved gene sam' was obtained after screen and selection, which could obviously increase the accumulation of AdoMet in S. cerevisiae.     

Molecular evolution of adomet synthetase by DNA recombination with a novel Separate-Mixing method

We describe a new approach to in vitro DNA recombination termed the Separate-Mixing method in this study. The reaction process of this method consists of two stages: at the first stage the reaction was implemented in two parallel teams, which generated random recombination by template-switching of growing poly-nucleotides from primers in the presence of unidirectional single-stranded DNA fragments used as templates, and then both teams were mixed together for further extension and recombination of DNA sequences at the second stage. Due to this particular strategy, the reaction process was also accompanied by two other processes of DNA shuffling and StEP simultaneously. Two AdoMet synthetase genes, sam2 from Saccharomyces cerevisiae and metK from Escherichia coli, which have only 56% homology on the DNA level, were used for recombination with the Separate-Mixing method. DNA recombination was available after a single round of reaction. When 10 randomly selected recombinants were sequenced, an unshuffled parental clone was not found, nor was unexpected insertion, deletion, or rearrangement detected. An evolved gene, sam’, was obtained after screening and selection, which could obviously increase the accumulation of AdoMet in S. cerevisiae. Published in Russian in Molekulyarnaya Biologiya, 2006, Vol. 40, No. 3, pp. 546–553. This article was submitted by the authors in English.     

Synthesis and modification of genes through artificial splicing by directed ligation (ASDL).

An approach to the directed genetic recombination in vitro mediated by synthetic oligodeoxynucleotides and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is devised, which allows the joining, in a predetermined chemical-enzymatic way, of a series of DNA segments to give a precisely spliced polynucleotide sequence (Artificial Splicing by Directed Ligation, ASDL). The approach can thus lead to the totally processed eukaryotic genes using genomic DNA, with no mRNA needed. This approach has been used for the synthesis of artificial genes of interleukin-1 alpha and, in combination with PCR on the mRNA-cDNA duplex as template, of interleukin-1 receptor antagonist and their analogues, as well as for the modified genes.     

Rapid evolution of beta-glucuronidase specificity by saturation mutagenesis of an active site loop

Protein engineers have widely adopted directed evolution as a design algorithm, but practitioners have not come to a consensus about the best method to evolve protein molecular recognition. We previously used DNA shuffling to direct the evolution of Escherichia coli beta-glucuronidase (GUS) variants with increased beta-galactosidase activity. Epistatic (synergistic) mutations in amino acids 557, 566, and 568, which are part of an active site loop, were identified in that experiment (Matsumura, I., and Ellington, A. D. (2001) J. Mol. Biol. 305, 331-339). Here we show that site saturation mutagenesis of these residues, overexpression of the resulting library in E. coli, and high throughput screening led to the rapid evolution of clones exhibiting increased activity in reactions with p-nitrophenyl-beta-d-xylopyranoside (pNP-xyl). The xylosidase activities of the 14 fittest clones were 30-fold higher on average than that of the wild-type GUS. The 14 corresponding plasmids were pooled, amplified by long PCR, self-ligated with T4 DNA ligase, and transformed into E. coli. Thirteen clones exhibiting an average of 80-fold improvement in xylosidase activity were isolated in a second round of screening. One of the evolved proteins exhibited a approximately 200-fold improvement over the wild type in reactivity (k(cat)/K(m)) with pNP-xyl, with a 290,000-fold inversion of specificity. Sequence analysis of the 13 round 2 isolates suggested that all were products of intermolecular recombination events that occurred during whole plasmid PCR. Further rounds of evolution using DNA shuffling and staggered extension process (StEP) resulted in modest improvement. These results underscore the importance of epistatic interactions and demonstrate that they can be optimized through variations of the facile whole plasmid PCR technique.     

Interaction of the FLP recombinase of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae 2 micron plasmid with mutated target sequences.

The 2 micron plasmid of Saccharomyces cerevisiae codes for a site-specific recombinase, the FLP protein, that catalyzes efficient recombination across two 599-base-pair (bp) inverted repeats of the plasmid DNA both in vivo and in vitro. We analyzed the interaction of the purified FLP protein with the target sequences of two point mutants that exhibit impaired FLP-mediated recombination in vivo. One mutation lies in one of the 13-bp repeat elements that had been previously shown to be protected from DNase digestion by the FLP protein. This mutation dramatically reduces FLP-mediated recombination in vitro and appears to act by reducing the binding of FLP protein to its target sequence. The second mutation lies within the 8-bp core region of the FLP target sequence. The FLP protein introduces staggered nicks surrounding this 8-bp region, and these nicks are thought to define the sites of strand exchange. The mutation in the core region abolishes recombination with a wild-type site. However, recombination between two mutated sites is very efficient. This result suggests that proper base pairing between the two recombining sites is an important feature of FLP-mediated recombination.     

Two restriction endonucleases from Bacillus globiggi.

The sites of action of the restriction enzyme Bgl II on lambda DNA are mapped. This enzyme recognises the sequence 5' ...AGATCT...3' and makes staggered cuts producing sticky ends. In lambda DNA, the second A in this sequence is methylated about 50% of the time by a bacterial methylase absent in E. coli dam. In contrast to Bgl II, Bgl I makes many cuts in lambda DNA and produces 5' terminals which are not substrates for polynucleotide kinase.     

Site-specific cleavage of DNA by E. coli DNA gyrase.

E. coli DNA gyrase, which catalyzes the supercoiling of DNA, cleaves DNA site-specifically when oxolinic acid and sodium dodecylsulfate are added to the reaction. We studied the structure of the gyrasecleaved DNA because of its implications for the reaction mechanism and biological role of gyrase. Gyrase made a staggered cut, creating DNA termini with a free 3' hydroxyl and a 5' extension that provided a template primer for DNA polymerase. The cleaved DNA was resistant to labeling with T4 polynucleotide kinase even after treatment with proteinase K. Thus the denatured enzyme that remains attached to cleaved DNA is covalently bonded to both 5' terminal extensions. The 5' extensions of many gyrase cleavage fragments from phi X174, SV40 and Col E1 DNA were partially sequenced using repair with E. coli DNA polymerase I. No unique sequence existed within the cohesive ends, but G was the predominant first base incorporated by DNA polymerase I. The cohesive and sequences of four gyrase sites were determined, and they demonstrated a four base 5' extension. The dinucleotide TG, straddling the gyrase cut on one DNA strand, provided the only common bases within a 100 bp region surrounding the cleavage sites. Analysis of other cleavage fragments showed that cutting between a TG doublet is common to most, or all, gyrase cleavages. Other bases common to some of the sequenced sites were clustered nonrandomly around the TG doublet, and may be variable components of the cleavage sequence. This diverse recognition sequence with common elements is a pattern shared with several other specific nucleic acid-protein interactions.     

Modified colorimetric assay for uricase activity and a screen for mutant Bacillus subtilis uricase genes following StEP mutagenesis.

This study describes a modified colorimetric assay for uricase activity in flexible 96-well microtiter plates using the uricase/uric acid/horseradish peroxidase/4-aminoantipyrine/3,5-dichloro-2-hydroxybenzene sulfonate colorimetric reaction. The utility of this assay was demonstrated in a screen for mutant uricase enzymes derived from the uricase gene of the thermophilic bacterium Bacillus subtilis by a modified staggered extension process (StEP) mutagenesis. An Escherichia coli library of StEP-derived uricase mutant clones was screened yielding two identical active mutant uricase genes. Two motifs conserved in eukaryotic and prokaryotic uricases are highly conserved in the mutant uricase. The mutant uricase protein was found to exhibit high uricase activity (13.1 U.mg(-1)). Finally, the modified colorimetric method is much more efficient than the conventional ones and greatly reduces assay time from 4 days to less than 20 h.     

High-fidelity in vitro recombination using a proofreading polymerase

We describe a convenient PCR-based protocol for in vitro recombination of homologous genes, thereby minimizing the rate of associated point mutations. High-fidelity recombination conditions were obtained using Vent DNA polymerase, which, in contrast to Taq DNA polymerase, shows significant proofreading activity and ranges among the slowest thermostable DNA polymerases, allowing tight control of the polymerase-catalyzed DNA extension. To determine the mutagenesis rate and to analyze the efficiency of recombination, 89 clones from a standard experiment were randomly selected for further analysis. Sequence comparison revealed that 21% (19/89) of the clones result from different recombination events in the marker-containing region (260 bp). The overall mutation rate is only 0.02%, which is the lowest rate thus far reported for in vitro recombination experiments.     

DNA shuffling method for generating highly recombined genes and evolved enzymes

We introduce a method of in vitro recombination or "DNA shuffling" to generate libraries of evolved enzymes. The approach relies on the ordering, trimming, and joining of randomly cleaved parental DNA fragments annealed to a transient polynucleotide scaffold. We generated chimeric libraries averaging 14.0 crossovers per gene, a several-fold higher level of recombination than observed for other methods. We also observed an unprecedented four crossovers per gene in regions of 10 or fewer bases of sequence identity. These properties allow generation of chimeras unavailable by other methods. We detected no unshuffled parental clones or duplicated "sibling" chimeras, and relatively few inactive clones. We demonstrated the method by molecular breeding of a monooxygenase for increased rate and extent of biodesulfurization on complex substrates, as well as for 20-fold faster conversion of a nonnatural substrate. This method represents a conceptually distinct and improved alternative to sexual PCR for gene family shuffling.     

Artificial DNA splicing using directed ligation]

An approach to the directed genetic recombination in vitro has been devised, which allows for joining, in a predetermined chemical-enzymatic way, a series of DNA segments to give a precisely spliced polynucleotide sequence (DNA Splicing by Directed Ligation, SDL). The approach makes use of amplification, by several polymerase chain reactions (PCR), of the chosen DNA segments. The corresponding primers contain recognition sites of the class IIS restriction endonucleases, yielding protruding ends of unique primary structures. The protruding ends of the segments to be joined together are structurally predetermined to make them mutually complementary. Ligation of the mixture of the segments so synthesized gives the desired sequence in an unambiguous way. The suggested approach has been exemplified by the synthesis of a totally processed (intronless) gene encoding human mature interleukin-1 alpha.     

Harnessing homologous recombination in vitro to generate recombinant DNA via SLIC

We describe a new cloning method, sequence and ligation-independent cloning (SLIC), which allows the assembly of multiple DNA fragments in a single reaction using in vitro homologous recombination and single-strand annealing. SLIC mimics in vivo homologous recombination by relying on exonuclease-generated ssDNA overhangs in insert and vector fragments, and the assembly of these fragments by recombination in vitro. SLIC inserts can also be prepared by incomplete PCR (iPCR) or mixed PCR. SLIC allows efficient and reproducible assembly of recombinant DNA with as many as 5 and 10 fragments simultaneously. SLIC circumvents the sequence requirements of traditional methods and functions much more efficiently at very low DNA concentrations when combined with RecA to catalyze homologous recombination. This flexibility allows much greater versatility in the generation of recombinant DNA for the purposes of synthetic biology.     

Site-specific recombinase, R, encoded by yeast plasmid pSR1.

The R gene product (R protein) of Zygosaccharomyces rouxii plasmid pSR1 catalyzes site-specific recombination within a 58 base-pair (bp) sequence present in the 959 bp inverted repeats of this plasmid. The R protein was produced in Escherichia coli and partially purified. The partially purified protein catalyzed site-specific recombination in vitro without the supply of an energy source. Recombination resulted in intramolecular inversion or deletion, depending on whether the orientations of the two recombination sites on the substrate plasmid were the same or opposite. Presumably, R protein is the only protein required for the recombination reaction. A circular DNA molecule appears to be a better substrate than a linear molecule in R-mediated in vitro intramolecular recombination. The R protein binds to a set of six 12 bp elements within the inverted repeats of pSR1. Two of these 12 bp elements are arranged in an inverted configuration with a 7 bp spacer in the 58 bp sequence. The R protein mediates strand cleavage in vitro at the junction between the 12 bp elements and the 7 bp spacer. The cleavage sites on the top and bottom strands are staggered and flanked by polypurine tracts that form part of the 12 bp elements.     

Recombination and chimeragenesis by in vitro heteroduplex formation and in vivo repair.

We describe a simple method for creating libraries of chimeric DNA sequences derived from homologous parental sequences. A heteroduplex formed in vitro is used to transform bacterial cells where repair of regions of non-identity in the heteroduplex creates a library of new, recombined sequences composed of elements from each parent. Heteroduplex recombination provides a convenient addition to existing DNA recombination methods ('DNA shuffling') and should be particularly useful for recombining large genes or entire operons. This method can be used to create libraries of chimeric polynucleotides and proteins for directed evolution to improve their properties or to study structure-function relationships. We also describe a simple test system for evaluating the performance of DNA recombination methods in which recombination of genes encoding truncated green fluorescent protein (GFP) reconstructs the full-length gene and restores its characteristic fluorescence. Comprising seven truncated GFP constructs, this system can be used to evaluate the efficiency of recombination between mismatches separated by as few as 24 bp and as many as 463 bp. The optimized heteroduplex recombination protocol is quite efficient, generating nearly 30% fluorescent colonies for recombination between two genes containing stop codons 463 bp apart (compared to a theoretical limit of 50%).     

Common sites for recombination and cleavage mediated by bacteriophage T4 DNA topoisomerase in vitro

We have previously shown that purified T4 DNA topoisomerase promotes illegitimate recombination between two lambda DNA molecules, or between lambda and plasmid DNA in vitro (Ikeda, H. (1986) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 83, 922-926). Since the recombinant DNA contains a duplication or deletion, it is inferred that the cross-overs take place between nonhomologous sequences of lambda DNA. In this paper, we have examined the sequences of the recombination junctions produced by the recombination between two lambda DNA molecules mediated by T4 DNA topoisomerase. We have shown that there is either no homology or there are 1-5-base pair homologies between the parental DNAs in seven combinations of lambda recombination sites, indicating that homology is not essential for the recombination. Next, we have shown an association of the recombination sites with the topoisomerase cleavage sites, indicating that a capacity of the topoisomerase to make a transient double-stranded break in DNA plays a role in the illegitimate recombination. A consensus sequence for T4 topoisomerase cleavage sites, RNAY decreases NNNNRTNY, was deduced. The cleavage experiment showed that T4 topoisomerase-mediated cleavage takes place in a 4-base pair staggered fashion and produces 5'-protruding ends.     

Intermediates in Hin-mediated DNA inversion: a role for Fis and the recombinational enhancer in the strand exchange reaction.

The site-specific inversion reaction controlling flagellin synthesis in Salmonella involves the function of three proteins: Hin, Fis and HU. The DNA substrate must be supercoiled and contain a recombinational enhancer sequence in addition to the two recombination sites. Using mutant substrates or modified reaction conditions, large amounts of complexes can be generated which are recognized by double-stranded breaks within both recombination sites upon quenching. The cleaved molecules contain 2-bp staggered cuts within the central dinucleotide of the recombination site. Hin is covalently associated with the 5' end while the protruding 3' end contains a free hydoxyl. We demonstrate that complexes generated in the presence of an active enhancer are intermediates that have advanced past the major rate limiting step(s) of the reaction. In the absence of a functional enhancer, Hin is also able to assemble and catalyze site-specific cleavages within the two recombination sites. However, these complexes are kinetically distinct from the complexes assembled with a functional enhancer and cannot generate inversion without an active enhancer. The results suggest that strand exchange leading to inversion is mediated by double-stranded cleavage of DNA at both recombination sites followed by the rotation of strands to position the DNA into the recombinant configuration. The role of the enhancer and DNA supercoiling in these reactions is discussed.