Analysis of B-cell subpopulations. I. Relationships among splenic xid, Ly 1+, and Lyb 5+ B cells

The phenotypic and functional relationships among the various B-cell subsets is of importance for better understanding studies of the immune system. In this report, the realm of B cells encompassed by Lyb 5, Ly 1, and xid has been examined through the use of the alloantiserum anti-Lyb 5, the unique functional properties of Ly 1+ B cells, and the spontaneous autoantibody producing congenic xid mice, NZB.xid. By functional and phenotypic analysis, we have shown that (i) Lyb 5- B cells and B cells of xid mice are largely, but not completely, overlapping; (ii) xid spleen cells contain a population which is Lyb 5+; (iii) Ly 1+ B cells fall largely in the Lyb 5+ compartment; and (iv) the autoantibody-producing Ly 1+ B cells are predominantly Lyb 5+.     

Resistance to tolerance induction in B cells of autoimmune mice—Abnormal expansion of low affinity IgG-producing B-cell population

Several strains of mice are known to develop spontaneous autoimmune diseases like lupus erythematosus and they show various immunological abnormalities as well. Despite different genetic backgrounds, they manifest various immunological abnormalities in common, e.g., polyclonal B-cell activation (PBA) and resistance to tolerance induction. To elucidate mechanisms of the development of autoimmunity, tolerance inducibility was examined in autoimmune and normal mice using trinitrophenylated carboxymethyl cellulose (TNP-CMC) as tolerogen which is known to induce TNP-specific B-cell tolerance without the participation of T cells. NZB and MRL/Mp-lpr/lpr mice were used as autoimmune mice and C57BL/6, BALB/c, and MRL/Mp-+/+ mice as nonautoimmune mice. When TNP-CMC-injected mice were challenged with T-independent antigens, all of the mice tested were shown to be tolerant. In contrast, when TNP-CMC-injected mice were challenged with T-dependent antigen and secondary IgG responses were assessed, autoimmune mice showed rather hyperreactivity, while nonautoimmune mice showed hyporesponsiveness. Cyclophosphamide improved this defective tolerance inducibility. By the solid-phase radioimmunoassay it was revealed that average affinity of serum anti-TNP antibodies produced in TNP-CMC-injected mice was low. Such low affinity antibodies were produced in large amount in autoimmune mice. Hence, it was suggested that B-cell clones destined to produce low affinity IgG antibodies were responsible for the resistance to tolerance induction and such clones were expanding in autoimmune mice.     

Tolerance defects in New Zealand Black and New Zealand Black X New Zealand White F1 mice

The susceptibility of autoimmune NZB and (NZB X NZW)F1 mice to the induction of tolerance by monomeric BSA was compared with several normal mouse strains. Unresponsiveness in T and B lymphocyte compartments was probed by challenging with DNP8BSA and measuring anti-DNP and anti-BSA antibodies separately. Tolerance induced by monomeric BSA was carrier specific, and there was no evidence of epitope-specific suppression. Normal NZW, NFS, and B10.D2 mice were easily rendered tolerant with monomeric BSA and did not produce anti-DNP or anti-BSA antibodies after challenge with DNP8BSA. By contrast, the lack of anti-DNP antibody response in similarly treated NZB mice was dependent on the dose of monomeric BSA, indicating that the helper T cells were partially resistant to tolerance induction. NZB mice treated with a high dose of monomeric BSA produced anti-BSA, but not anti-DNP, antibodies after immunization. Thus, the anti-carrier B cells in NZB mice may have been primed by monomeric BSA. The presence of the xid gene on the NZB background rendered the mice susceptible to induction of tolerance, suggesting that the tolerance defect in NZB mice involves the B cell compartment. This abnormal antibody response was a dominant trait: (NZB X NFS)F1 and (NZB X B10.D2)F1 mice had the same characteristics as NZB mice. These F1 hybrids do not develop autoimmune disease, indicating that resistance to experimental tolerance induction expressed at a B cell level may not be sufficient for disease development. In contrast to NZB and other NZB F1 hybrids, (NZB X NZW)F1 hybrids treated with monomeric BSA and challenged with DNP8BSA responded to both DNP and BSA. The contribution of a B cell defect to the tolerance abnormality of (NZB X NZW)F1 mice was examined by analyzing the effect of the xid gene on the progeny of (NZB.xid X NZW)F1 mice. Unlike the effect of the xid gene on NZB mice, both phenotypically normal heterozygous female and phenotypically xid hemizygous male mice produced anti-DNP and anti-BSA antibodies after tolerance induction and immunization, demonstrating that a major helper T cell abnormality was present in (NZB X NZW)F1 mice. The (NZW X B10.D2)F1 hybrid was rendered tolerant by this procedure, indicating that the helper T cell defect (NZB X NZW)F1 mice may have resulted from gene complementation with the NZB mice contributing partial resistance of T helper cells to tolerance induction.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Defective B cell tolerance induction in New Zealand black mice. I. Macrophage independence and comparison with other autoimmune strains

B cell unresponsiveness was examined in vitro by using spleen cells from autoimmune NZB, BXSB/Mp male, MRL/Mp-Ipr/Ipr (MRL/l), and control mice, and the tolerogen trinitrophenyl human gamma-globulin (TNP-HGG). The B cell subset responsive to TNP-Brucella abortus in each autoimmune and control strain that was tested was highly susceptible to tolerance induction with the use of high epitope density conjugates (TNP30HGG and TNP32HGG). When a tolerogen with a lower epitope density was used (TNP7HGG), several control strains were all rendered tolerant in a thymic-independent and hapten-specific manner. NZB B cells were resistant to all concentrations of TNP7HGG tested, whereas B cells from BXSB/Mp male and MRL/1 mice were resistant to low concentrations of this tolerogen. NZB mice were resistant in addition to tolerance induction with TNP9HGG, TNP10HGG, and TNP12.7HGG. Experiments were performed to determine whether splenic macrophages played a role in resistance to tolerance in NZB mice. The mixing of NZB and control DBA/2J T cell-depleted splenocytes revealed no modulatory effects by the accessory cells in culture. Moreover, B cells rigorously depleted of macrophages by double Sephadex G-10 column passage exhibited characteristic patterns of resistance or susceptibility in NZB and control strains, respectively. These findings support the conclusion that resistance to tolerance in NZB mice is determined at the B cell level and are consistent with the hypothesis that diverse immunoregulatory disturbances contribute in varying degrees to the development of systemic lupus erythematosus in different inbred strains of mice.     

Abnormalities of B lineage cells are demonstrable in long term lymphoid bone marrow cultures of New Zealand black mice

The formation of B lymphocytes in young New Zealand Black (NZB) mice proceeds at an accelerated rate resulting in a deficiency of B lineage precursors in adult (greater than 15 wk old) animals. To study the characteristics of B lineage cells in young (4 wk) and old (6 mo) NZB mice, bone marrow from these animals was used to initiate long term lymphoid bone marrow cultures (LBMC) that permit the long term maintenance of B cells and their precursors. Age-matched cultures from BALB/c mice and NZB.xid marrow were established in parallel. Primary LBMC were readily established from these strains and showed similar patterns of growth for the 3-mo observation period. No significant differences in numbers of 14.8 positive cells were observed. However, NZB mice at both ages had a higher percentage of membrane IgM (mIgM)-expressing cells. Significant levels of supernatant IgM were found only in cultures of 6-mo NZB and BALB/c mice; levels were highest in NZB culture supernatants and were often more than 500 ng/ml; significant, although much lower, levels of IgG were likewise detected. Lymphoid cells from NZB.xid mice were unable to generate significant levels of IgM in supernatant fluids indicating the effects of the xid gene were displayed in vitro. Autoantibodies were not detected in any of the culture supernatants. Additional evidence for NZB hyperactivity in primary B lymphopoiesis was observed upon initiation of primary myeloid bone marrow cultures (MBMC) from these strains of mice and subsequently transferring them to LBMC conditions. This results in the cessation of myelopoiesis at the initiation of B lymphopoiesis. At the time of converting MBMC to LBMC, cultures of NZB and BALB/c mice morphologically resembled myeloid cultures and had neither B cell colony-forming units nor cells that expressed 14.8 or mIgM. However, following the switch, NZB mice had a 5-fold higher number of B cell colony-forming units. Further, MBMC established from NZB bone marrow cells had a reduced capacity to form colonies in the granulocyte-macrophage colony-forming unit assay. These studies indicate that defects of NZB hemopoietic cells are manifest in vitro and suggest the use of in vitro long term cultures as a valuable technique to further dissect the hematopoietic abnormalities of NZB mice and possible underlying microenvironmental defects.     

Studies on the influence of the internal environment on autoantibody production by B cells

Purified splenic B cells from autoimmune NZB and nonautoimmune DBA/2 mice were transferred to unmanipulated H-2 compatible xid recipients. The number of autoantibody-secreting clones present in recipient mice was quantitated at varying times after transfer using a splenic fragment assay. We found that NZB and DBA/2 B cells expanded equally well in equivalent xid environments. Cells from either donor expanded significantly better in autoimmune-prone NZB.xid as compared with DBA/2.xid recipients. Moreover, clones producing antibodies reactive with T cell surface antigens, bromelain-treated mouse red cells, or DNA expanded more rapidly than did cells producing antibodies to the nonautoantigen TNP-KLH. Serum autoantibody levels rose in concert with the increased numbers of autoantibody-producing lymphocytes. We conclude that factors present in the internal milieu of autoimmune-prone NZB.xid mice, rather than an intrinsic B cell defect, facilitate the expansion of (auto)antibody-secreting B cells.     

Responses of B cells from autoimmune mice to IL-5

Three strains of mice (NZB/W F1 X NZW (NZB/W), BXSB, and MRL/Mp-lpr/lpr (MRL/lpr] develop an autoimmune disease that is clinically and immunologically similar to human SLE. A characteristic of these mice is polyclonal B cell hyperactivity. To explore whether this may be related to hyper-responsiveness to B cell stimulatory factors, we investigated the proliferative and secretory responses of B cells from these mice to semi-purified natural and rIL-5, a major regulator of B cell development in the mouse. As this lymphokine stimulates growth and differentiation of activated B cells, attention was focused on in vivo-activated B cell populations, obtained from the interface of 50/65% Percoll density gradients, from normal or autoimmune mice. This cell population from NZB/W mice secreted IgM and incorporated [3H]TdR at significantly higher levels in response to IL-5, and was more sensitive to IL-5, than a comparable population from several normal murine strains. NZB/W female and male mice displayed heightened responses to IL-5, indicating that this is characteristic of the strain in general and is not associated with the accelerated severe disease of the females. Small resting B cells from NZB/W and normal mice were insensitive to IL-5 stimulation. In contrast to NZB/W mice, no difference was observed in the magnitude of either proliferative or Ig secretory responses between in vivo-activated B cell populations from autoimmune BXSB and MRL/lpr or normal mice. Thus, B cell hyper-responsiveness to IL-5 is a characteristic of NZB/W mice but not of two other lupus-prone murine strains. As one unique feature of NZB/W mouse B cells compared to normal and other autoimmune B cells is an elevated proportion of Ly-1+ B cells, the possibility of IL-5 hyper-responsiveness being associated with this B cell subpopulation was investigated. Fluorescence-activated cell sorter sorted Ly-1+ and Ly-1- B cells both responded to IL-5, however Ly-1+ B cells consistently showed a higher stimulation index in both proliferative and Ig secretory responses to this lymphokine.     

Similar in vivo expansion of B cells from normal DBA/2 and autoimmune NZB mice in xid recipients

B cells from normal DBA/2 and autoimmune NZB mice were transferred into H-2-compatible xid recipients where they engrafted without irradiation or other manipulation of the host. The properties of these cells and their interaction with the host environment were analyzed at the single cell level with a splenic focus assay. When similar numbers of NZB and DBA/2 anti-DNA-producing B cell precursors were transferred, they expanded at similar rates in xid recipients. The rate of expansion varied with the strain of the recipient: it was fastest in autoimmune-prone NZB . xid and slowest in DBA/2 . xid hosts. Cells producing antibodies reactive with the autoantigen DNA proliferated substantially faster than those reactive with the non-autoantigen trinitrophenylated keyhole limpet hemocyanin. These results suggest that 1) B cells from NZB mice do not behave differently from DBA/2 B cells, 2) the internal milieu of the recipient into which the cells are transferred has an important effect on B cell proliferation, and 3) B cells capable of autoantibody production may have a selective growth and/or differentiation advantage relative to other B cells.     

Cell cycle analysis of lymphocyte activation in normal and autoimmune strains of mice

The spontaneous spleen cell proliferation and the proliferation induced by in vivo or in vitro stimulation with such polyclonal B cell activators (PBA) as LPS, poly rI.rC, and anti-mu were studied in normal and autoimmune mice. The various murine models of autoimmunity differ in the level of naturally occurring splenic cellular hyperactivity as well as in the ability of their spleen cells to be further stimulated in vitro by polyclonal stimulators. Both the NZB strain and the MRL/Ipr strain had markedly increased numbers and percentages of spontaneously proliferating spleen cells, whereas the BXSB strain did not. Nonautoimmune strains were found to have very small numbers of activated cells in the spleen. However, such normal strains could be induced in vivo to mimic the natural splenic hyperactivity observed in older NZB and MRL/Ipr autoimmune strains by the injection of polyclonal B lymphocyte stimulators. In contrast, old hyperactive NZB mice were not further induced to undergo proliferation by in vivo administration of such stimulators. Density-separated, T depleted, spleen cells of normal and autoimmune mice were stimulated in vitro with PBA in 48-hr cultures. Cells from old MRL/Ipr and NZB mice were abnormal in both the anti-mu response and the LPS response; BXSB mice had normal anti-mu responses. These studies suggest that there is no prerequisite for spontaneous splenic hyperactivity in the development of autoimmunity. In addition, different PBA stimulate separate subsets of B cells that differ in their state of activation in the various autoimmune strains. Finally, different B cell subsets appear to be abnormal in different types of autoimmune mice.     

Intracellular protein modification associated with altered T cell functions in autoimmunity

Posttranslational protein modifications influence a number of immunologic responses ranging from intracellular signaling to protein processing and presentation. One such modification, termed isoaspartyl (isoAsp), is the spontaneous nonenzymatic modification of aspartic acid residues occurring at physiologic pH and temperature. In this study, we have examined the intracellular levels of isoAsp residues in self-proteins from MRL(+/+), MRL/lpr, and NZB/W F(1) mouse strains compared with nonautoimmune B10.BR mice. In contrast to control B10.BR or NZB/W mice, the isoAsp content in MRL autoimmune mice increased and accumulated with age in erythrocytes, brain, kidney, and T lymphocytes. Moreover, T cells that hyperproliferate to antigenic stimulation in MRL mice also have elevated intracellular isoAsp protein content. Protein l-isoaspartate O-methyltransferase activity, a repair enzyme for isoAsp residues in vivo, remains stable with age in all strains of mice. These studies demonstrate a role for the accumulation of intracellular isoAsp proteins associated with T cell proliferative defects of MRL autoimmune mice.     

Elicitation of experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) in mice with the aid of pertussigen

Seeking common abnormalities in mice genetically predisposed to lupus-like autoimmune disease, we investigated (1) the ontogeny of Ia antigens (I-A/I-E) on the surfaces of resident peritoneal macrophages (rpM phi) of lupus and normal mice, (2) spontaneous and lectin-induced in vitro production of M phi-stimulating factors (interferon, IFN; M phi-activating factor, MAF; M phi-Ia-inducing/recruiting factor, MIRF), and (3) responses of rpM phi from such animals to Ia-inducing signals. Indirect immunofluorescence techniques showed that Ia+ rpM phi increased numerically during the life spans of MRL/Mp lpr/lpr, while no such increase was observed in age-matched non-lpr MRL/Mp +/+ or (MRL/Mp lpr/lpr X MRL/Mp +/+)F1 hybrid mice. However, neonatal thymectomy, which prevents lymphoproliferation and autoimmune disease in MRL/Mp lpr/lpr mice, had no effect on this enhanced M phi I-A/I-E expression. NZB mice developed a similar increase with age, whereas BXSB and (NZB X NZW)F1 lupus mice, like immunologically normal controls, had low numbers of I-A/I-E+ rpM phi. Cultured splenocytes of lupus mice, including those with high percentages of I-A/I-E+ rpM phi, did not spontaneously (in the absence of mitogens) elaborate MIRF, MAF, or IFN activity. Furthermore, concanavalin A-stimulated splenocytes from lupus mice, particularly strains with early autoimmune disease manifestations [MRL/Mp lpr/lpr, male BXSB, and female (NZB X NZW)F1] produced levels of these lymphokines that were lower than normal controls. MRL/Mp lpr/lpr and NZB rpM phi, when stimulated in vitro with the supernatant of a MIRF-producing T cell hybridoma, did not hyperrespond. Our study shows that increased I-A/I-E+ rpM phi occur in some, but not all, lupus mice and this increase does not correlate with increased spontaneous or mitogen-induced production of M phi-stimulating lymphokines nor with hyperresponsiveness to Ia-inducing signals.     

Changes in the compositions of the null cell compartment with murine autoimmunity

The subpopulations that comprise the null cell compartment were examined sequentially in various strains of autoimmune-prone mice. Different patterns emerged that were consistent within strains but differed from strain to strain. Abnormalities appear earlier in life in short-lived mice, such as male BXSB and MRL/1 mice, than in relatively long-lived strains, such as female BXSB and NZB mice. The accumulation of T cells in MRL/1 mice was accompanied by null cell changes that contrasted with those that developed in AKR/J mice after their spleens were infiltrated with leukemic T cells. It would seem that lymphocyte perturbations with murine autoimmunity also involve their precursor cells and that these precursor cell changes vary in different strains, perhaps in relation to different genetic factors.     

Role of T cells in regulating expression of the B cell repertoire. Anti-ssDNA precursor frequency of DBA/2 B cells is increased in the presence of T cells from NZB mice

Splenic B cells from DBA/2 and NZB mice were compared with regard to precursor frequency of anti-ssDNA-producing cells. Using a modification of the splenic fragment assay, we show that NZB T cells are capable of increasing the frequency of expression of anti-ssDNA precursors in DBA/2 splenic B cells. When limiting numbers of splenic B cells of DBA/2 origin were adoptively transferred into an irradiated (1200 rad) recipient, the co-transfer of NZB T cells markedly increased the frequency of anti-ssDNA precursors in cultured splenic fragments. The anti-ssDNA produced under these conditions was exclusively IgM and exhibited a high degree of cross-reactivity with TNP and fluorescein. Thus, the increase in anti-ssDNA precursor frequency reflected an expansion of the B cell repertoire to include precursors of polyspecific antibody-producing cells that under normal circumstances are not expressed. The ability of NZB T cells to increase the anti-ssDNA precursor frequency was further defined by the CBA/N immunodeficiency gene xid, in that B cells from DBA/2.xid donors did not exhibit increased anti-ssDNA precursor frequency in the presence of NZB T cells. When NZB splenic B cells were co-transferred with DBA/2 T cells, the anti-DNA precursor frequency of the NZB B cells was not reduced. This study demonstrates that T cells can influence the emergency of B cell clones in an Ag-nonspecific manner. The well documented in vivo spontaneous polyclonal activation of NZB B cells may be secondary to T cell-mediated expansion of the B cell repertoire.     

Functional evidence for abnormal maturation within a B-cell subpopulation of NZB mice

NZB mice develop a systemic autoimmune disease and have a subpopulation of B lymphocytes that spontaneously produce excessive amounts of IgM. These abnormal B cells reside within a specific B-cell subset that is affected by the CBA/N defect. In normal mice, this B-cell subset acquires in vitro responsiveness to certain thymus-independent antigens (TI-2) relatively late in ontogeny. We compared the functional development of neonatal B cells from NZB mice to that of normal mice of the same H-2 type. The acquisition of in vitro responsiveness to the TI-1 antigen, TNP-LPS and the TI-2 antigens, TNP-Dextran, TNP-Ficoll, and FITC-Ficoll was examined. TNP-LPS could elicit a response from both normal and NZB neonates. In contrast, responses to the TI-2 antigens were elicited early in life (<1 week) only from or at a higher level from NZB neonates. However, an accelerated appearance of B-cell differentiation antigens was not detected in NZB neonates compared to normal strains. We conclude, therefore, that a maturation or triggering defect occurs in a small B-cell subpopulation of NZB mice very early in life.     

Abnormal binding of soluble IgG immune complexes to hepatic nonparenchymal cells of autoimmune mice

Because the liver is the major organ responsible for removal of soluble immune complexes (IC), the surface binding characteristics of preformed model IC to unstimulated mouse liver nonparenchymal cells (NPC) in suspension were studied. NPC of non-autoimmune C3H/FeJ, C3H/HeJ, A/J, DBA/2 and the autoimmune NZB/W F1 and MRL/lpr female mice of various ages were isolated by perfusion of the portal vein with collagenase followed by separation of NPC from hepatocytes with a metrizamide gradient. Thirty-five percent of NPC of all mouse strains were nonspecific esterase-positive and phagocytosed latex beads. Radiolabeled mouse IgG anti-DNP covalently cross-linked stable IC were separated by gel filtration and bound to NPC under various conditions. Marked differences were noted in maximal number of IC bound per cell between the autoimmune and non-autoimmune mouse strains: 3.3 to 4.0 X 10(5) in the non-autoimmune strains vs 0.3 to 1.4 X 10(5) molecules of IC bound per cell in the autoimmune strains at 1 to 6 mo. Insignificant differences were noted in Ka by Scatchard plot analysis (3.5 to 5.0 X 10(8) M-1) and rate of reversibility of binding as determined by dissociation of surface-bound IC with an excess of heat-aggregated gamma-globulin (T 1/2:1.5 to 2 min). These data demonstrate a decreased number of available binding sites for IC in unstimulated NPC from NZB/W F1 and MRL/lpr female mice throughout their life spans. Although the findings are consistent with saturation of binding sites of the NPC with native IC, the abnormality found in the 1-mo-old autoimmune mice (who do not have detectable autoantibodies) suggests a primary defect in FC receptor expression or an altered state of activation of NPC that may contribute to the disease process.     

The interaction of the xid and me genes

The murine "motheaten" (me) mutation has been bred onto the NFS background and combined with the X-linked immunodeficiency (xid) mutation to investigate the effect of the xid-induced B cell maturational block on the widespread immune dysfunction, high levels of autoantibodies, and early mortality found in the motheaten mice. The xid markedly reduced spontaneous IgM secretion by spleen cells, serum IgM, anti-ssDNA antibodies, anti-bromelain-treated-erythrocyte antibodies, and T cell binding (but not thymocytotoxic) antibodies; however, neither phenotype nor mortality was affected, suggesting that other factors are responsible for early death. Marked expansion of the Ly-1+ B cell pool was prevented by xid in the motheaten mouse leaving only a very small population of sIgM-positive B cells. This failure of non-Ly-1+ B cell development in me/me X xid mice suggests that me/me leads to inhibition of non-Ly-1+ B cells and preferential expansion of Ly-1+ B cells in motheaten mice, perhaps as a result of their high levels of maturation and activation factors.     

Increased spontaneous polyclonal activation of B lymphocytes in mice with spontaneous autoimmune disease.

Early in life, mice of four kinds [NZB, (NZB X NZW)F1, MRL/1, and male BXSB] with autoimmune disease spontaneously produced far more (greater than 3 S.D.) anti-hapten antibody-forming cells in spleens and greater concentrations of anti-hapten antibodies in sera than immunologically normal strains of mice (AKR, BALB/c, C57BL/6, DBA/1-J, DBA/2J, LG/J, 129, NZW, and female BXSB). This increased nonspecific antibody production by the abnormal animals' B cells correlated well with the spontaneous development of anti-single-stranded DNA antibodies, but not with serum levels of the viral envelope glycoprotein, gp70. These results suggest that the spontaneous formation of autoantibodies in mice whose immunologic disorder is manifested by a lupus-like disease may result from polyclonal activation of B cells by endogenous or exogenous B cell activators.     

Dendritic and B-cell function during antibody responses in normal and immunodeficient (xid) mouse spleen cultures

Dendritic cells (DC) act as accessory cells for T-dependent antibody responses in two ways. One is to induce a class of stimulating factors (BSF) which allow B lymphocytes to respond to heterologous red cells as antigen. xid DC induce the production of these BSF, but xid B cells totally lack responsiveness. A second mechanism of DC function applies to red cell and haptenated-protein antigens. Here DC, helper T lymphocytes, and antigen-specific B cells interact in discrete clusters. Then the B cells become responsive to BSF. xid DC are fully active in this pathway, and xid B cells develop significant (10-20% of control) responses. This partial reduction in xid B-cell function could be due to the poor viability of xid lymphocytes in vitro. There is a comparable reduction in xid polyclonal responses to alloreactive helper T blasts. The other severe deficit in xid involves antibody formation to haptens on polysaccharide carriers. This response in normal mice is not influenced by DC or by BSF. The only similarity between DNP-Ficoll and RBC plus BSF responses is that both utilize B lymphocytes that do not associate with DC-T clusters, even though helper cells for DNP-Ficoll and for RBC are present in the culture. We conclude that DC function is not altered in xid. The main deficit seems to be in a B-cell activation pathway that is shared by polysaccharide carriers and some but not all BSF, and/or in a B-cell subpopulation that does not interact with carrier-specific helper cells. We speculate that this B-cell alteration primarily involves the Ig delta-poor marginal zone subpopulation of splenic B lymphocytes.     

Effects of calorie restriction on immunologic functions and development of autoimmune disease in NZB mice.

Chronic energy (calorie) intake restriction (CEIR) prolonged life, inhibited autoimmune disease, and influenced immunologic and hematologic parameters in NZB mice. Abnormalities in numbers and proportions of T and B cells populations were corrected. Deficient responses to phytomitogens, mixed lymphocyte reactions, formation of plaque-forming cells to sheep red blood cells in vitro, production of cytotoxic T lymphocytes after in vitro stimulation, and interleukin 2 production were also corrected. CEIR prevented the extreme splenomegaly that normally occurs with age in NZB mice. This influence was associated with reduction of a greatly expanded non-T, non-B lymphoid cell population. Calorie restriction also prevented in NZB mice the rapid decrease in total numbers of colony-forming B cells in bone marrow that is also characteristic of mice of this strain. The influences of CEIR on immune parameters and hematopoiesis were generally less marked in non-autoimmune-prone DBA/2 mice than in autoimmune-prone NZB mice. CEIR has been shown to produce profound influences on several strains of autoimmune-prone mice (NZB x NZW)F1, MRL/lpr, BXSB, and NZB herein). In each of these strains, the pathogenesis and manifestations of autoimmune disease are dissimilar. Therefore, it seems likely that calorie restriction acts on an as yet elusive mechanism that operates to foster development of the diseases associated with aging common to each of these autoimmune strains as well as autoimmune-resistant mice and rats. Further investigation of the molecular and cellular bases of the benefits of CEIR seems urgent.     

Autoimmune CD4+ T cells interfere with immune tolerance to a thymic-independent antigen

The ability of autoimmune T cell subsets to interfere with tolerization of B cells can be studied by using thymic-independent Ag. We have defined an abnormality within the CD4+ T cell compartment in young NZB and MRL-lpr/lpr mice by studying tolerance of spleen and B cells to the thymic independent Ag, fluorescein-Brucella abortus. Tolerization of spleen cells is defective in MRL-lpr/lpr mice, but not MRL-+/+ or C3H.lpr mice, suggesting that the defect requires both the autosomal MRL background and the lpr gene to be present. T enriched cells from NZB mice and from MRL-lpr/lpr mice (but not MRL-+/+ or C3H.lpr mice) reverse tolerance in spleen cells from [NZB X DBA/2]F1 and C3H/HeJ mice, respectively. This interference is removed by treatment with anti-CD4 antibody and C. Supernatants from cultured T cells of NZB and MRL-lpr/lpr mice also prevent tolerance in spleen cells of [NZB X DBA/2]F1 and MRL-+/+ mice, respectively, unless CD4+ cells are removed prior to T cell culture. Removal of T cells from NZB and MRL-lpr/lpr spleen cells allows normal tolerization of B cells, which is abrogated by the addition of syngeneic T cells or cultured T cell supernatants. This effect also depends on the presence of CD4+ T cells. These studies show that in MRL-lpr/lpr mice, through interaction of the lpr and MRL background genes in a T cell subset, and in NZB mice, CD4+ T cells interfere with B cell tolerance to a thymic-independent Ag.