Antitubulin antibodies. II. Natural autoantibodies and induced antibodies recognize different epitopes on the tubulin molecule

Natural and induced antitubulin antibodies were compared for their epitope recognition on alpha- and beta-tubulin subunits by immunoenzymatic assays and Western blot techniques on partially digested tubulin molecules. Our results indicated that natural autoantibodies recognized different epitopes from those recognized by induced antibodies, because: 1) all polyspecific natural autoantibodies tested so far recognized the same or very overlapping epitopes in the central part of both alpha- and beta-subunits (between positions 100 and 300 on the tubulin amino acid sequence) and that this epitope differed from the various epitopes recognized by induced antitubulin antibodies on the amino-terminal or carboxy-terminal parts of the tubulin subunits; 2) one human myeloma protein (monoclonal (m)IgA, kappa) with a monospecific antitubulin activity bound to an epitope around position 310 on both alpha- and beta-subunits and a second human mIg (mIgM, kappa) with a monospecific anti-beta activity bound to an epitope on the carboxy-terminal part of the subunit around amino acid position 350. Both epitopes differed from epitopes recognized by induced antitubulin antibodies. These results thus confirmed our previous findings indicating that natural and induced antitubulin antibodies do not share cross-reactive idiotopes.     

Effects of antibodies against tubulin on the movement of reactivated sea urchin sperm flagella

Antibodies binding to sea urchin flagellar outer-doublet tubulin have been isolated from rabbit sera by tubulin-affinity chromatography employing electrophoretically purified tubulin as the immobilized substrate. This procedure provides "induced" antitubulin antibody from immune sera and "spontaneous" antitubulin antibody from preimmune sera. These antitubulins were characterized in terms of their specificity, ability to bind to sea urchin axonemes, and effects on the motility of reactivated spermatozoa. Induced antitubulin antibody specifically reduced the bend angle and symmetry of the movement of demembranated reactivated spermatozoa without affecting the beat frequency. At identical concentrations, spontaneous antitubulin had no effect on motility. Affinity-purified induced antitubulins from three other rabbits all gave specific bend-angle inhibition, whereas their corresponding spontaneous antitubulins had no effect on the flagellar movement. The effects of antitubulin on microtubule sliding were examined by observing the sliding disintegration of elastase-digested axonemes induced by MgATP2+-. Affinity-purified induced antitubulin antibody, in quantities sufficient to completely paralyze reactivated flagella, did not inhibit microtubule sliding. The amplitude-inhibiting effect of induced antitubulin on reactivated spermatozoa may be caused by action on a mechanism responsible for controlling flagellar bending rather than by interference with the active sliding process. This is the first report of an antitubulin antibody having an inhibitory activity on microtubule-associated movement.     

A radioligand binding assay for antitubulin activity in tumor cells

The benzamide RH-5854 is shown to be highly potent toward tumor cells and to arrest nuclear division by a highly specific covalent binding to the beta-subunit of tubulin in the colchicine binding region. Binding of 3H-RH-5854 to beta-tubulin in HCT-116 colon cancer cells is saturable and has been exploited in the development of a cell-based competitive binding assay, which allows antitubulin effects to be detected in whole cells. 3H-RH-5854 binding is strongly inhibited by preincubating the cells with compounds that bind to the colchicine site and with paclitaxel. Binding of 3H-RH-5854 is enhanced by preincubating the cells with vinblastine but not by other agents that bind at or near the vinblastine site (ansamitocin P-3 and phomopsin A). Various cytotoxic agents that do not act on tubulin do not affect binding of 3H-RH-5854 in HCT-116 cells, demonstrating specificity of the assay for detection of antitubulin activity. As an alternative to traditional assays that employ isolated brain tubulin, the 3HRH-5854 binding assay enables screening for antitubulin effects directly in tumor cells, providing an assay that accounts for cell-specific criteria that influence sensitivity such as different tubulin isotypes, tubulin mutations, drug metabolism, and efflux mechanisms.     

Evidence for tubulin-binding sites on cellular membranes: plasma membranes, mitochondrial membranes, and secretory granule membranes

We describe the interaction of pure brain tubulin with purified membranes specialized in different cell functions, i.e., plasma membranes and mitochondrial membranes from liver and secretory granule membranes from adrenal medulla. We studied the tubulin-binding activity of cellular membranes using a radiolabeled ligand-receptor assay and an antibody retention assay. The tubulin-membrane interaction was time- and temperature-dependent, reversible, specific, and saturable. The binding of tubulin to membranes appears to be specific since acidic proteins such as serum albumin or actin did not interfere in the binding process. The apparent overall affinity constant of the tubulin- membrane interaction ranged between 1.5 and 3.0 X 10(7) M-1; similar values were obtained for the three types of membranes. Tubulin bound to membranes was not entrapped into vesicles since it reacted quantitatively with antitubulin antibodies. At saturation of the tubulin-binding sites, the amount of reversibly bound tubulin represents 5-10% by weight of membrane protein (0.4-0.9 nmol tubulin/mg membrane protein). The high tubulin-binding capacity of membranes seems to be inconsistent with a 1:1 stoichiometry between tubulin and a membrane component but could be relevant to a kind of tubulin assembly. Indeed, tubulin-membrane interaction had some properties in common with microtubule formation: (a) the association of tubulin to membranes increased with the temperature, whereas the dissociation of tubulin- membrane complexes increased by decreasing temperature; (b) the binding of tubulin to membranes was prevented by phosphate buffer. However, the tubulin-membrane interaction differed from tubulin polymerization in several aspects: (a) it occurred at concentrations far below the critical concentration for polymerization; (b) it was not inhibited at low ionic strength and (c) it was colchicine-insensitive. Plasma membranes, mitochondrial membranes, and secretory granule membranes contained tubulin as an integral component. This was demonstrated on intact membrane and on Nonidet P-40 solubilized membrane protein using antitubulin antibodies in antibody retention and radioimmune assays. Membrane tubulin content varied from 2.2 to 4.4 micrograms/mg protein. The involvement of membrane tubulin in tubulin-membrane interactions remains questionable since erythrocyte membranes devoid of membrane tubulin exhibited a low (one-tenth of that of rat liver plasma membranes) but significant tubulin-binding activity. These results show that membranes specialized in different cell functions possess high- affinity, large-capacity tubulin-binding sites...     

Rat monoclonal antitubulin antibodies derived by using a new nonsecreting rat cell line

Hybrid myeloma cell lines secreting monoclonal antibodies to tubulin have been prepared using rat myelomas and spleen cells from rats immunized with yeast tubulin. A comparison between the results obtained with the rat myeloma Y3-Ag 1.2.3., which secretes a light chain, and a new line, YB2/O, which does not, shows that they are both excellent parental lines and that the second produces hybrids with no myeloma chain components. The antitubulin antibodies in the serum of rats bearing two of the hybrid myeloma tumors gave titers of up to 1:10(6) from which large amounts of monoclonal antibodies could be easily purified. They recognized tubulin from yeast as well as from birds and mammals. The two antibodies gave clear immunofluorescent staining of yeast mitotic spindles as well as the interphase microtubule network of tissue culture cells. Some difference in the pattern of immunofluorescence staining of yeast cells and nuclei was observed between the two antibodies. The purified antibodies could be conjugated to colloidal gold particles and used for direct labeling of yeast microtubules for electron microscopy.     

New antitubulin derivatives in the combretastatin A4 series: synthesis and biological evaluation

Two series of combretastatin A4 derivatives (acrylamide=carboxamide and carbamate) were synthesized in order to improve the water solubility and stabilize the cis-configuration of the double bond. Their cytotoxic effects were evaluated against MCF-7, KB-3-1 and IGROV human cancer cell lines, as well as their inhibitory activity on tubulin polymerization. Results were compared to those of carboxamide 1, chosen as reference. Potent inhibitions were observed on both tests in the carboxamide series, particularly for compound 4d bearing a fluorine group in replacement of the 3-hydroxyl of CA4. In contrast, most of the carbamates were either inactive or displayed only moderate cytotoxicities. Interestingly, a submicromolar IC(50) was measured on MCF-7 cells for 6g, although this compound was totally devoid of antitubulin activity.     

Direct visualization of fluorescein-labeled microtubules in vitro and in microinjected fibroblasts

Microtubule proteins and tubulin have been purified from brain and labeled with dichlorotriazinyl fluorescein (DTAF). This procedure compromises neither the polymerizability of the proteins nor their affinities for unlabeled proteins. Within 15 min after microinjection of either DTAF-microtubule proteins or DTAF-tubulin into cultured gerbil fibroma cells, there was an evolution of a fluorescent fibrillar pattern with a distribution similar to that of the microtubular network seen after staining with fluorescent antitubulin. These filaments were colchicine sensitive and could be seen to elongate with time. DTAF- labeled microtubule accessory proteins from brain were not incorporated into filaments and appeared to label autophagic vacuoles.     

Microheterogeneity of tubulin proteins in neuronal and glial cells from the mouse brain in culture

The microheterogeneity of the alpha and beta isoforms of tubulin in brain cells in culture was studied. The cells were prepared from two precise regions of the embryonic mouse brain (ED15), the striatum and the mesencephalon. It was possible to maintain virtually pure cultures of neuronal or glial cells up to 1 and 4 weeks in vitro, respectively. The tubulin heterogeneity of striatal and mesencephalic neurons was found to be very similar after a few days in culture. More precise examination of pure neurons from the striatum revealed that their tubulin content after 7 days in vitro exhibited the same degree of complexity as a control extract from a 4 day-old mouse brain. In fact, we could detect the presence of at least six alpha and nine beta tubulin isoforms. Among these isoforms a specific family of beta proteins (beta' tubulin) and the more acidic alpha proteins were present. Since these isoforms have, up to now, been found only in tubulin extracts prepared from the nervous system, our experiments suggest that they belong to the neuronal subpopulation of this tissue. This point is reinforced by their complete absence from the tubulin proteins extracted from pure glial cells even after several weeks in vitro. These results lead us to propose that brain tubulin microheterogeneity is associated with the presence of neurons and not of glia and may, therefore, play a specific role in maintaining neuronal shape and function.     

Synthesis and biological evaluation of 2-amino-7,7-dimethyl 4-substituted-5-oxo-1-(3,4,5-trimethoxy)-1,4,5,6,7,8-hexahydro-quinoline-3-carbonitrile derivatives as potential cytotoxic agents

A large number of antimitotic drugs, derived from natural sources or chemically synthesized, have been identified and shown to interfere with the tubulin system. Inhibition of tubulin polymerization is among the important targets useful in the cancer therapy.The present work reports the synthesis of some novel quinoline derivatives bearing a trimethoxyphenyl moiety. The trimethoxybenzene moiety has been reported to be crucial to obtain relevant cytotoxic and antitubulin responses. All the newly synthesized compounds were evaluated for their in vitro anticancer activity. Several compounds showed interesting cytotoxic activities compared to the used reference drug.     

The isolation and in situ location of adligin: the microtubule cross- linking protein from Caenorhabditis elegans

Microtubules isolated from the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans contain long stretches of periodic cross-links formed by microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs). These cross-links are 5.7 nm long, 3 nm wide, and occur at one tubulin dimer (8-nm) intervals along the walls of microtubules (Aamodt, E., and J. Culotti, 1986. J. Cell Biol. 103:23-31). The structural protein of the cross-links was isolated from the MAPs by centrifugation and exclusion chromatography. The cross-links were formed exclusively from the most prevalent MAP, a 32,000 mol wt protein. We suggest the name adligin for this MAP. Adligin eluted from the exclusion column at 33,000 mol wt indicating that it was a monomer in solution. Antibodies were made against the purified adligin and affinity purified. The affinity-purified antibodies were used to locate adligin in situ and to determine its distribution relative to that of tubulin by the use of double label immunofluorescence. The anti-adligin antibodies labeled a fibrous network in the cytoplasm of most cells of C. elegans. Neurons were labeled especially well. This labeling pattern was similar to the labeling pattern obtained with antitubulin, but anti-adligin labeled some granules in the gut that were not labeled with antitubulin. These results suggest that adligin may be part of the interphase microtubule network in C. elegans.     

Design,synthesis and biological evaluation of (E)-3-(3,4-dihydroxyphenyl)acrylylpiperazine derivatives as a new class of tubulin polymerization inhibitors

A series of novel (E)-3-(3,4-dihydroxyphenyl)acrylylpiperazine derivatives had been synthesized and evaluated their biological activities as potential tubulin polymerization inhibitors. Among these compounds, compound 3q exhibited potent antiproliferative activities against three cancer cell lines in vitro, and antitubulin polymerization activity with IC₅₀ of 0.92 μM, which was superior to that of colchicine (IC₅₀ = 1.34 μM). Docking simulation was performed to insert compound 3q into the crystal structure of tubulin at colchicine binding site to determine the probable binding model. These results suggested that compound 3q may be a promising antitubulin agent for the potential treatment of cancer.     

1,1-Diarylalkenes as anticancer agents: dual inhibitors of tubulin polymerization and phosphodiesterase 4

A series of 1,1-diarylalkene derivatives were prepared to optimize the properties of CC-5079 (1), a dual inhibitor of tubulin polymerization and phosphodiesterase 4 (PDE4). By using the 3-ethoxy-4-methoxyphenyl PDE4 pharmacophore as one of the aromatic rings, a significant improvement in PDE4 inhibition was achieved. Compound 28 was identified as a dual inhibitor with potent PDE4 (IC(50)=54 nM) and antitubulin activity (HCT-116 IC(50)=34 nM and tubulin polymerization IC(50) ～1 μM). While the nitrile group at the alkene terminus was generally required for potent antiproliferative activity, its replacement was tolerated if there was a hydroxyl or amino group on one of the aryl rings. Conveniently, this group could also serve as a handle for amino acid derivatization to improve the compounds' solubility. The glycinamide analog 45 showed significant efficacy in the HCT-116 xenograft model, with 64% inhibition of tumor growth upon dosing at 20 mg/kg qd.     

Photobiotin as a sensitive probe for protein labeling

A sensitive method for the nonisotopic in vitro labeling of proteins under physiological conditions using photobiotin, a compound originally developed for labeling nucleic acids (Forster et al. (1985) Nucleic Acids Res. 13, 745), has been developed. Using sheep brain tubulin as a model protein it was shown that labeling with photobiotin resulted in detection limits below 10 pg when avidin-alkaline phosphatase was used in the final step. No significant loss of tubulin polymerization, colchicine binding, recognition by antitubulin antibodies, or changes in electrophoretic behavior were observed. In addition, photobiotinylation of antitubulin antibodies did not affect their recognition of unlabeled tubulin. The use of photobiotin labeling with avidin-alkaline phosphatase detection for electrophoretic separations of molecular weight standards, crude protein supernatants, and tubulin gave a 64 to 1024-fold increase in sensitivity over Coomassie blue staining.     

Antitumor Activity of IMC-038525, a Novel Oral Tubulin Polymerization Inhibitor

Microtubules are a well-validated target for anticancer therapy. Molecules that bind tubulin affect dynamic instability of microtubules causing mitotic arrest of proliferating cells, leading to cell death and tumor growth inhibition. Natural antitubulin agents such as taxanes and Vinca alkaloids have been successful in the treatment of cancer; however, several limitations have encouraged the development of synthetic small molecule inhibitors of tubulin function. We have previously reported the discovery of two novel chemical series of tubulin polymerization inhibitors, triazoles (Ouyang et al. Synthesis and structure-activity relationships of 1,2,4-triazoles as a novel class of potent tubulin polymerization inhibitors. Bioorg Med Chem Lett. 2005; 15:5154-5159) and oxadiazole derivatives (Ouyang et al. Oxadiazole derivatives as a novel class of antimitotic agents: synthesis, inhibition of tubulin polymerization, and activity in tumor cell lines. Bioorg Med Chem Lett. 2006; 16:1191-1196). Here, we report on the anticancer effects of a lead oxadiazole derivative in vitro and in vivo. In vitro, IMC-038525 caused mitotic arrest at nanomolar concentrations in epidermoid carcinoma and breast tumor cells, including multidrug-resistant cells. In vivo, IMC-038525 had a desirable pharmacokinetic profile with sustained plasma levels after oral dosing. IMC-038525 reduced subcutaneous xenograft tumor growth with significantly greater efficacy than the taxane paclitaxel. At efficacious doses, IMC-038525 did not cause substantial myelosuppression or peripheral neurotoxicity, as evaluated by neutrophil counts and changes in myelination of the sciatic nerve, respectively. These data indicate that IMC-038525 is a promising candidate for further development as a chemotherapeutic agent.     

The Mechanism of Somatic Association in Common Wheat, TRITICUM AESTIVUM L. IV. Further Evidence for Modification of Spindle Tubulin through the Somatic-Association Genes as Measured by Vinblastine Binding

Treatment with the antitubulin vinblastine was found to disrupt the spindle system in dividing root-tip cells of common wheat, Triticum aestivum L. Genotypes lacking the somatic association suppressor gene on 5B^L, or containing the somatic-association promoter on 5B^S, were found to be more sensitive to the treatment. In genetic lines carrying the somatic association suppressor, sensitivity to vinblastine was lower and there was a direct correlation between dosage of the suppressor gene (0, 2, and 4) and the decrease in spindle disruption on exposure to various concentrations of vinblastine. It is concluded that the somatic association genes affect binding ability of spindle tubulin to vinblastine. Since the same genes affect binding of colchicine to tubulin and since the two alkaloids attach to different sites it is assumed that the somatic association suppressor gene has a broad effect on the tubulin molecules which is not confined to a single site. The relevance of genetic control of antitubulin binding to somatic association is discussed.     

Structural model of a complex between the heterotrimeric G protein, Gsalpha, and tubulin

A number of studies have demonstrated interplay between the cytoskeleton and G protein signaling. Many of these studies have determined a specific interaction between tubulin, the building block of microtubules, and G proteins. The alpha subunits of some heterotrimeric G proteins, including Gsalpha, have been shown to interact strongly with tubulin. Binding of Galpha to tubulin results in increased dynamicity of microtubules due to activation of GTPase of tubulin. Tubulin also activates Gsalpha via a direct transfer of GTP between these molecules. Structural insight into the interaction between tubulin and Gsalpha was required, and was determined, in this report, through biochemical and molecular docking techniques. Solid phase peptide arrays suggested that a portion of the amino terminus, alpha2-beta4 (the region between switch II and switch III) and alpha3-beta5 (just distal to the switch III region) domains of Gsalpha are important for interaction with tubulin. Molecular docking studies revealed the best-fit models based on the biochemical data, showing an interface between the two molecules that includes the adenylyl cyclase/Gbetagamma interaction regions of Gsalpha and the exchangeable nucleotide-binding site of tubulin. These structural models explain the ability of tubulin to facilitate GTP exchange on Galpha and the ability of Galpha to activate tubulin GTPase.     

Coordination of posttranslational modifications of bovine brain alpha-tubulin. Polyglycylation of delta2 tubulin

Microtubules participate in a large number of intracellular events including cell division, intracellular transport and secretion, axonal transport, and maintenance of cell morphology. They are composed of tubulin, a heterodimeric protein, consisting of two similar polypeptides alpha and beta. In mammalian cells, both alpha- and beta-tubulin occur as seven to eight different genetic variants, which also undergo numerous posttranslational modifications that include tyrosination-detyrosination and deglutamylation, phosphorylation, acetylation, polyglutamylation, and polyglycylation. Tyrosination-detyrosination is one of the major posttranslational modifications in which the C-terminal tyrosine residue in alpha-tubulin is added or removed reversibly. Although this modification does not alter the assembly activity of tubulin in vitro, these two forms of tubulin have been found to be distributed differently in vivo and are also correlated with microtubule stability (Gunderson, G. G., Kalnoski, M. H., and Bulinski, J. C. (1984) Cell 38, 779-789). Thus, the question arises as to whether these two forms of tubulin differ in any other modifications. In an effort to answer this question, the tyrosinated and the nontyrosinated forms of the alpha1/2 isoform have been purified from brain tubulin by immunoaffinity chromatography. matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight mass spectrometric analysis of the C-terminal peptide revealed that the tyrosinated form is polyglutamylated with one to four Glu residues, while the Delta2 tubulin is polyglycylated with one to three Gly residues. These results indicate that posttranslational modifications of tubulin are correlated with each other and that polyglutamylation and polyglycylation of tubulin may have important roles in regulating microtubule assembly, stability, and function in vivo.     

Localization of microfilaments and a tubulin-like protein in crustacean (Rhynchocinetes typus) spermatozoon

Sperm from the decapod crustacean Rhynchocinetes typus undergo dramatic shape changes as they pass from the vas deferens to seawater and interact with the oocyte envelopes. Using FITC-phalloidin and antitubulin antibodies, we were able to localize microfilaments and a tubulin-like protein in R. typus spermatozoon. Microfilaments and the tubulin-like protein were associated with the sperm rays and spines, but were absent at the spike and at its base. Folded and unfolded spermatozoa display similar fluorescence patterns. SDS-PAGE of whole spermatozoa and electrotransfer to nitrocellulose confirmed the presence of actin and two proteins at 97 kd and 120 kd that bind to tubulin antibodies (tubulin-like proteins). These results demonstrate the presence of actin, but not tubulin, and localize microfilaments in these sperm. It is proposed that this cytoskeletal component is active in sperm during crustacean fertilization.     

Simultaneous localization of myosin and tubulin in human tissue culture cells by double antibody staining

We have studied the distribution of myosin and tubulin molecules inside the same tissue culture cells by using two antibodies labeled with contrasting fluorochromes. Antimyosin raised against human platelet myosin was labeled with rhodamine. Antitubulin raised against sea urchin vinblastine-induced tubulin crystals was labeled with fluorescein. The two antibodies stained entirely different structures inside the same flat interphase cell: antimyosin bound to stress fibers and antitubulin bound to thin, wavy fibers thought to be individual microtubules. Compact interphase cells stained diffusely with both antibodies. From prophase through early anaphase both antibodies stained the mitotic spindle, although the fluorescence contrast between the spindle and the cytoplasm was much higher with antitubulin than with antimyosin. From anaphase through telophase, strong antimyosin staining occurred in the cleavage furrow, while antitubulin stained the region between the separated chromosomes. This study established the feasibility of high-resolution fluorescent antibody localization of pairs of motility proteins in the cytoplasm of single cells, an approach which will make it possible to map out the sites of the various contractile protein interactions in situ.     

Electron microscope demonstration of tubulin in cilia and basal bodies of rat tracheal epithelium by the use of an antitubulin antibody

It has been previously demonstrated that both cytoplasmic microtubules and the microtubules of cilia, flagella, and sperm tail contain tubulin. Although the morphology of cytoplasmic microtubules and that of axonemes differs in cells from which they have been isolated, the tubulin of the two structures shares physical and chemical properties. In some mammalian tissues, such as tracheal epithelium, cilia and basal bodies are difficult to isolate and characterize. The use of an enzyme- labeled immunoglobulin probe would facilitate identification and in situ localization of such proteins. Tubulin prepared from porcine brain by ion-exchange chromatography and from rat brain by the method of cyclic polymerization and depolymerization with subsequent disk gel electrophoresis with SDS were injected intravenously into rabbits. The animals were intermittently bled and the antisera extracted. The specificity of the antisera was proved by indirect immunofluorescence staining of the mitotic spindle, specific blocking of spindle staining by purified tubulin and not by other proteins, staining of 3T3 cytoplasmic microtubules, single line on immunoelectrophoresis, failure of control antisera to show any of these, and precipitation of antibody with all tubulin preparations and not with actin. We have shown by electron microscopy of ciliated cells of the tracheal epithelium stained with antitubulin by the indirect enzyme-labeled antibody method that the basal bodies, outer doublets, and central pair of the cilia contain tubulin. This indicates that tubulin in microtubules of cilia and basal bodies of rat tracheal epithelium is antigenically similar to tubulin extracted from cytoplasmic neurotubules of brains from the same species and from a different mammalian species. No other axonemal structures stained with the antitubulin. Three different preparations of tubulin from pigs and rats were used to immunize rabbits. All elicited similar antisera which gave identical staining patterns. The specificity of the staining was demonstrated by the absence of staining with immune serum absorbed with purified tubulin, the absence of staining with preimmune serum, and the absence of staining if any of the reagents were omitted during the staining reaction.