The dynamics of assembly of a cytoplasmic membrane protein in Escherichia coli.

The topology of integral cytoplasmic membrane proteins can be analyzed using alkaline phosphatase fusions by determining which constructs have low and which have high specific activity. We show that in all cases the enzymatic activity is due to the fraction of the alkaline phosphatase moiety of the fusion protein localized to the periplasm. We present evidence that these fusions can also be used to analyze the process of assembly of cytoplasmic proteins into the membrane. The rate of acquisition of protease resistance of the alkaline phosphatase moiety of such hybrid proteins is compared for fusions to periplasmic and cytoplasmic domains. We show that this process, which is assumed to be representative of export of alkaline phosphatase, is significantly slower for fusions to cytoplasmic and certain periplasmic domains than for most periplasmic domains. These results are discussed in the context of the normal assembly of integral membrane proteins.     

Membrane topology of the pBR322 tetracycline resistance protein. TetA-PhoA gene fusions and implications for the mechanism of TetA membrane insertion.

The tetracycline resistance gene of pBR322 encodes a 41-kDa inner membrane protein (TetA) that acts as a tetracycline/H+ antiporter. Based on hydrophobicity profiles, we identified 12 potential transmembrane segments in TetA. We used oligonucleotide deletion mutagenesis to fuse alkaline phosphatase (PhoA) to the C-terminal edge of each of the predicted periplasmic and cytoplasmic segments of TetA. In general, the PhoA activities of the TetA-PhoA fusions support a TetA topology model consisting of 12 transmembrane segments with the N and C termini in the cytoplasm. However, several TetA-PhoA fusions have unexpected properties. One PhoA fusion to a predicted cytoplasmic segment (C6) has high activity. However, previous protease accessibility studies on the related Tn10 TetA protein indicated that C6 is cytoplasmically localized as predicted (Eckert, B., and Beck, C. F. (1989) J. Biol. Chem. 264, 11663-11670). PhoA fusions to three predicted periplasmic segments (P1, P2, and P5) have low to intermediate activity. In each case, the preceding transmembrane segment (TM1, TM3, and TM9) contains an aspartate (Asp17, Asp86, and Asp287). We show that these aspartates act like signal sequence mutations for PhoA export: (i) Asp----Ala mutations increase the PhoA activity of fusions to P1, P2, and P5. (ii) The signal sequence mutation suppressor prlA402 increases the PhoA activity of these same fusions. We also show that the aspartates in TM1, TM3, and TM9 are critical for wild-type TetA function; they are conserved in related TetA proteins and Asp----Ala mutations reduce or eliminate tetracycline resistance. The properties of the anomalous TetA-PhoA fusions suggest that TetA sequences C-terminal to some cytoplasmic and periplasmic segments are required for the proper localization of those segments, i.e. long range interactions may be more important in determining the membrane topology of TetA than suggested in some general models.     

Yersinia spp. HMWP2, a cytosolic protein with a cryptic internal signal sequence which can promote alkaline phosphatase export.

The iron starvation-induced, 2,042-amino-acid protein HMWP2 of Yersinia enterocolitica has two internal hydrophobic segments which might promote its export and association with the cytoplasmic membrane. To determine whether part of HMWP2 could be exported beyond the periplasmic face of the cytoplasmic membrane, we used TnphoA mutagenesis to construct 10 hybrid proteins in which periplasmic alkaline phosphatase (PhoA) was fused to the end of C-terminally truncated HMWP1 (at amino acid positions 1751 and 1753 two independent isolates]) had high alkaline phosphate activity (close to that of the native enzyme), both in Escherichia coli and in Y. pseudotuberculosis, indicating that the PhoA segment of the hybrid reached the periplasm. Deletion studies showed that the export signal resides in the second hydrophobic segment of HMWP2. This result would be compatible with the topology of the protein in the cytoplasmic membrane predicted from the distribution of charged amino acids at either end of the two hydrophobic segments. However, two hybrids in which the junction was even further toward the C terminus of HMMWP2 (at positions 1793 and 1999) had only weak alkaline phosphatase activity, suggesting that the predicted topology is incorrect. The location of HMWP2 was therefore determined by subcellular fractionation. The results indicate that HMPW2 is mainly cytoplasmic, consistent with its presumed role in the ATP-dependent, nonribosomal synthesis of an unknown peptide. We propose that the high alkaline phosphatase activity associated with some of the HMWP-2-PhoA hybrids results from the unmasking of the cryptic export signal activity in the second hydrophobic segment of HMPW2.     

Analysis of protein localization by use of gene fusions with complementary properties.

This report describes a new transposon designed to facilitate the combined use of beta-galactosidase and alkaline phosphatase gene fusions in the analysis of protein localization. The transposon, called TnlacZ, is a Tn5 derivative that permits the generation of gene fusions encoding hybrid proteins carrying beta-galactosidase at their C termini. In tests with plasmids, TnlacZ insertions that led to high cellular beta-galactosidase activity were restricted to sequences encoding either cytoplasmic proteins or cytoplasmic segments of a membrane protein. The fusion characteristics of TnlacZ are thus complementary to those of TnphoA, a transposon able to generate alkaline phosphatase fusions whose high-activity insertion sites generally correspond to periplasmic sequences. The structure of TnlacZ allows the conversion of a TnlacZ fusion into the corresponding TnphoA fusion (and vice versa) through recombination or in vitro manipulation in a process called fusion switching. Fusion switching was used to generate the following two types of fusions with unusual properties: a low-specific-activity beta-galactosidase-alkaline phosphatase gene fusion and two toxic periplasmic-domain serine chemoreceptor-beta-galactosidase gene fusions. The generation of both beta-galactosidase and alkaline phosphatase fusions at exactly the same site in a protein permits a comparison of the two enzyme activities in evaluating the subcellular location of the site, such as in studies of membrane protein topology. In addition, fusion switching makes it possible to generate gene fusions whose properties should facilitate the isolation of mutants defective in the export or membrane anchoring of different cell envelope proteins.     

The Tsr chemosensory transducer of Escherichia coli assembles into the cytoplasmic membrane via a SecA-dependent process

The Tsr protein of Escherichia coli is a chemosensory transducer that mediates taxis toward serine and away from certain repellents. Like other bacterial transducers, Tsr spans the cytoplasmic membrane twice, forming a periplasmic domain of about 150 amino acids and a cytoplasmic domain of about 300 amino acids. The 32 N-terminal amino acids of Tsr resemble the consensus signal sequence of secreted proteins, but they are not removed from the mature protein. To investigate the function of this N-terminal sequence in the assembly process, we isolated translational fusions between tsr and the phoA and lacZ genes, which code for the periplasmic enzyme alkaline phosphatase and the cytoplasmic enzyme beta-galactosidase, respectively. All tsr-phoA fusions isolated code for proteins whose fusion joints are within the periplasmic loop of Tsr, and all of these hybrid proteins have high alkaline phosphatase activity. The most N-terminal fusion joint is at amino acid 19 of Tsr. Tsr-lacZ fusions were found throughout the tsr gene. The beta-galactosidase activity of the LacZ-fusion proteins varies greatly, depending on the location of the fusion joint. Fusions with low activity have fusion joints within the periplasmic loop of Tsr. The expression of these fusions is most likely reduced at the level of translation. In addition, one of these fusions markedly reduces the export and processing of the periplasmic maltose-binding protein and the outer membrane protein OmpA, but not of intact PhoA or of the outer membrane protein LamB. A temperature-sensitive secA mutation, causing defective protein secretion, stops expression of new alkaline phosphatase activity coded by a tsr-phoA fusion upon shifting to the nonpermissive temperature. The same secA mutation, even at the permissive temperature, increases the activity and the level of expression of LacZ fused to the periplasmic loop of Tsr relative to a secA+ strain. We conclude that the assembly of Tsr into the cytoplasmic membrane is mediated by the machinery responsible for the secretion of a subset of periplasmic and outer membrane proteins. Moreover, assembly of the Tsr protein seems to be closely coupled to its synthesis.     

Role of a small cytoplasmic domain in the establishment of serine chemoreceptor membrane topology.

The Escherichia coli serine chemoreceptor takes on a simple membrane topology with two transmembrane segments separating cytoplasmically disposed N and C termini from a central periplasmic domain. We investigated the role of the small N-terminal cytoplasmic domain in membrane insertion using alkaline phosphatase gene fusions. Mutations eliminating the positive charge of the domain altered insertion dramatically, with reciprocal effects on hybrids with periplasmic and C-terminal cytoplasmic fusion junctions. Efficient export of the normally cytoplasmic C-terminal domain required that, in addition to the N-terminal changes, a short amphiphatic sequence at the beginning of the C-terminal domain be also absent. These findings document the importance of the positive character of the N-terminal domain in chemoreceptor membrane insertion and imply that partially redundant sequence information controls the orientation of the second transmembrane segment.     

Membrane topology of Escherichia coli prolipoprotein signal peptidase (signal peptidase II)

The lsp gene of Escherichia coli encodes the inner membrane enzyme, signal peptidase II (SPase II). SPase II is comprised of 164 amino acid residues and contains four hydrophobic domains. A series of lsp-phoA and lsp-lacZ gene fusions have been constructed in vitro to determine the topology of SPase II. The fusion junction for each of these gene fusions was determined by DNA sequencing. The lengths of the SPase II fragment in the fusions varied from 12 to 159 amino acid residues. Strains containing SPase II-PhoA fusions to the two predicted periplasmic loops exhibited higher levels of alkaline phosphatase activity than fusions to the predicted cytoplasmic domains. In contrast, SPase II-LacZ fusions at the cytoplasmic and the periplasmic domains of SPase II showed high and low levels of beta-galactosidase activity, respectively, a result opposite to those shown by SPase II-PhoA fusions located at precisely the same amino acid of SPase II. Taken together, these results strongly support the predicted model for SPase II topology, i.e. this enzyme spans the cytoplasmic membrane four times with both the amino and the carboxyl termini facing the cytoplasm.     

Genetic studies on the inability of beta-galactosidase to be translocated across the Escherichia coli cytoplasmic membrane.

When a signal sequence is attached to beta-galactosidase, the normally cytoplasmic protein is unable to fully traverse the cytoplasmic membrane. We used a genetic approach to study those features of beta-galactosidase responsible for the block in translocation. By using both in vivo and in vitro techniques, fragments of beta-galactosidase were interposed between a signal sequence and alkaline phosphatase. The alkaline phosphatase acts as a sensor for any blocking effects of beta-galactosidase on export. From these studies, we show that multiple regions of beta-galactosidase contribute to its failure to be translocated. These results are most easily interpreted if the folding of beta-galactosidase or of domains of it is responsible for the block in export. In addition, in certain constructs, positively charged amino acids directly following the signal sequence interfered with export.     

Gene fusion analysis of membrane protein topology: a direct comparison of alkaline phosphatase and beta-lactamase fusions.

To compare two approaches to analyzing membrane protein topology, a number of alkaline phosphatase fusions to membrane proteins were converted to beta-lactamase fusions. While some alkaline phosphatase fusions near the N terminus of cytoplasmic loops of membrane proteins have anomalously high levels of activity, the equivalent beta-lactamase fusions do not. This disparity may reflect differences in the folding of beta-lactamase and alkaline phosphatase in the cytoplasm.     

Characterization of Enterococcus faecalis Alkaline Phosphatase and Use in Identifying Streptococcus agalactiae Secreted Proteins

We have identified and characterized an Enterococcus faecalis alkaline phosphatase (AP, encoded by phoZ). The predicted gene product shows homology with alkaline phosphatases from a variety of species; it has especially high similarity with two alkaline phosphatases from Bacillus subtilis. Expression of phoZ in Escherichia coli, E. faecalis, Streptococcus agalactiae (group B streptococcus [GBS]), or Streptococcus pyogenes (group A streptococcus [GAS]) produces a blue-colony phenotype on plates containing a chromogenic substrate, 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolylphosphate (XP or BCIP). Two tests were made to determine if the activity of the enzyme is dependent upon the enzyme's subcellular location. First, elimination of the signal sequence reduced AP activity to 3% of the wild-type activity (or less) in three species of gram-positive bacteria. Restoration of export, using the signal sequence from C5a peptidase, restored AP activity to at least 50% of that of the wild type. Second, we engineered two chimeric proteins in which AP was fused to either a periplasmic domain or a cytoplasmic domain of lactose permease (a membrane protein). In E. coli, the periplasmic fusion had 17-fold-higher AP activity than the cytoplasmic fusion. We concluded that AP activity is export dependent. The signal sequence deletion mutant, phoZDeltass, was used to identify random genomic fragments from GBS that encode exported proteins or integral membrane proteins. Included in this set of fragments were genes that exhibited homology with the Rib protein (a cell wall protein from GBS) or with DppB (an integral membrane protein from GAS). AP acts as a reporter enzyme in GBS, GAS, and E. faecalis and is expected to be useful in a variety of gram-positive bacteria.     

SecY, a multispanning integral membrane protein, contains a potential leader peptidase cleavage site.

SecY is an Escherichia coli integral membrane protein required for efficient translocation of other proteins across the cytoplasmic membrane; it is embedded in this membrane by the 10 transmembrane segments. Among several SecY-alkaline phosphatase (PhoA) fusion proteins that we constructed previously, SecY-PhoA fusion 3-3, in which PhoA is fused to the third periplasmic region of SecY just after the fifth transmembrane segment, was found to be subject to rapid proteolytic processing in vivo. Both the SecY and PhoA products of this cleavage have been identified immunologically. In contrast, cleavage of SecY-PhoA 3-3 was barely observed in a lep mutant with a temperature-sensitive leader peptidase. The full-length fusion protein accumulated in this mutant was cleaved in vitro by the purified leader peptidase. A sequence Ala-202-Ile-Ala located near the proposed interface between transmembrane segment 5 and periplasmic domain 3 of SecY was found to be responsible for the recognition and cleavage by the leader peptidase, since a mutated fusion protein with Phe-Ile-Phe at this position was no longer cleaved even in the wild-type cells. These results indicate that SecY contains a potential leader peptidase cleavage site that undergoes cleavage if the PhoA sequence is attached carboxy terminally. Thus, transmembrane segment 5 of SecY can fulfill both of the two important functions of the signal peptide, translocation and cleavage, although the latter function is cryptic in the normal SecY protein.     

Topology of the Escherichia coli uhpT sugar-phosphate transporter analyzed by using TnphoA fusions.

The Escherichia coli uhpT protein catalyzes the active transport of sugar-phosphates by an obligatory exchange mechanism. To examine its transmembrane topology, we isolated a collection of uhpT-phoA fusions encoding hybrid proteins of different lengths from the N terminus of UhpT fused to alkaline phosphatase by using transposon TnphoA. These fusions displayed different levels of alkaline phosphatase activity, although comparable levels of full-length UhpT-PhoA proteins were produced in maxicells of both high- and low-activity fusions. The full-length protein species were unstable and were degraded to the size of the alkaline phosphatase moiety in the case of a high-activity fusion or to small fragments in the case of a low-activity fusion. The enzyme activity present in low-activity fusions appeared to result from export of a small proportion of the fusion proteins to the periplasmic space. Although fusions were not obtained in all predicted extramembranous loops, the deduced topology of UhpT was consistent with a model of 12 membrane-spanning regions oriented with the amino and carboxyl termini in the cytoplasm.     

Neisseria gonorrhoeae prepilin export studied in Escherichia coli.

The pilE gene of Neisseria gonorrhoeae MS11 and a series of pilE-phoA gene fusions were expressed in Escherichia coli. The PhoA hybrid proteins were shown to be located in the membrane fraction of the cells, and the prepilin product of the pilE gene was shown to be located exclusively in the cytoplasmic membrane. Analysis of the prepilin-PhoA hybrids showed that the first 20 residues of prepilin can function as an efficient export (signal) sequence. This segment of prepilin includes an unbroken sequence of 8 hydrophobic or neutral residues that form the N-terminal half of a 16-residue hydrophobic region of prepilin. Neither prepilin nor the prepilin-PhoA hybrids were processed by E. coli leader peptidase despite the presence of two consensus cleavage sites for this enzyme just after this hydrophobic region. Comparisons of the specific molecular activities of the four prepilin-PhoA hybrids and analysis of their susceptibility to proteolysis by trypsin and proteinase K in spheroplasts allow us to propose two models for the topology of prepilin in the E. coli cytoplasmic membrane. The bulk of the evidence supports the simplest of the two models, in which prepilin is anchored in the membrane solely by the N-terminal hydrophobic domain, with the extreme N terminus facing the cytoplasm and the longer C terminus facing the periplasm.     

Sequences determining the cytoplasmic localization of a chemoreceptor domain.

The Escherichia coli serine chemoreceptor (Tsr) is a protein with a simple topology consisting of two membrane-spanning sequences (TM1 and TM2) separating a large periplasmic domain from N-terminal and C-terminal cytoplasmic regions. We analyzed the contributions of several sequence elements to the cytoplasmic localization of the C-terminal domain by using chemoreceptor-alkaline phosphatase gene fusions. The principal findings were as follows. (i) The cytoplasmic localization of the C-terminal domain depended on TM2 but was quite tolerant of mutations partially deleting or introducing charged residues into the sequence. (ii) The basal level of C-terminal domain export was significantly higher in proteins with the wild-type periplasmic domain than in derivatives with a shortened periplasmic domain, suggesting that the large size of the wild-type domain promotes partial membrane misinsertion. (iii) The membrane insertion of deletion derivatives with a single spanning segment (TM1 or TM2) could be controlled by either an adjacent positively charged sequence or an adjacent amphipathic sequence. The results provide evidence that the generation of the Tsr membrane topology is an overdetermined process directed by an interplay of sequences promoting and opposing establishment of the normal structure.     

Membrane topology of the methyl-accepting chemotaxis protein DcrA fromDesulfovibrio vulgaris Hildenborough

Alkaline phosphatase fusions were used to study the membrane topology of DcrA, a protein of 668 amino acids fromDesulfovibrio vulgaris Hildenborough, which has two potentially membrane-spanning hydrophobic sequences at residues 11 to 29 and 188 to 207. A fusion at amino acid residue 170 in the proposed periplasmic domain exhibited high alkaline phosphatase activity, while low activity was observed for a fusion at amino acid residue 284 in the proposed cytoplasmic domain. The data support a topological model for DcrA similar to that of the methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins of the enteric bacteria.     

Bacillussubtilis holo-cytochrome c-550 can be synthesised in aerobic Escherichia coli

Bacillus subtilis membrane-bound holo-cytochrome c-550 was found to be expressed from the structural gene cloned on a plasmid vector in aerobically grown Escherichia coli and exhibited normal biochemical properties. This occurs despite the lack of endogenous eytochrome c and suggests that eytochrome c-heme lyase activity is also present in aerobic E. coli. The membrane topology of B. subtilis eytochrome c-550 was studied using fusions to alkaline phosphatase (PhoA). The results show that the heme domain (at least when fused to PhoA) can be translocated as apo-cytochrome and confirm that the N-terminal part of the cytochrome functions as both export signal and membrane anchor for the C-tenninal heme domain. A model for the organisation of B. subtilis cytochrome c-550 in the cytoplasmic membrane is presented.     

Topology of the membrane-bound alkane hydroxylase of Pseudomonas oleovorans.

The Pseudomonas oleovorans alkane hydroxylase is an integral cytoplasmic membrane protein that is expressed and active in both Escherichia coli and P. oleovorans. Its primary sequence contains eight hydrophobic stretches that could span the membrane as alpha-helices. The topology of alkane hydroxylase was studied in E. coli using protein fusions linking different amino-terminal fragments of the alkane hydroxylase (AlkB) to alkaline phosphatase (PhoA) and to beta-galactosidase (LacZ). Four AlkB-PhoA fusions were constructed using transposon TnphoA. Site-directed mutagenesis was used to create PstI sites at 12 positions in AlkB. These sites were used to create AlkB-PhoA and AlkB-LacZ fusions. With respect to alkaline phosphatase and beta-galactosidase activity each set of AlkB-PhoA and AlkB-LacZ fusions revealed the expected complementary activities. At three positions, PhoA fusions were highly active, whereas the corresponding LacZ fusions were the least active. At all other positions the PhoA fusions were almost completely inactive, but the corresponding LacZ fusions were highly active. These data predict a model for alkane hydroxylase containing six transmembrane segments. In this model the amino terminus, two hydrophilic loops, and a large carboxyl-terminal domain are located in the cytoplasm. Only three very short loops near amino acid positions 52, 112, and 251 are exposed to the periplasm.     

Biotinylation in vivo as a sensitive indicator of protein secretion and membrane protein insertion.

Escherichia coli biotin ligase is a cytoplasmic protein which specifically biotinylates the biotin-accepting domains from a variety of organisms. This in vivo biotinylation can be used as a sensitive signal to study protein secretion and membrane protein insertion. When the biotin-accepting domain from the 1.3S subunit of Propionibacterium shermanii transcarboxylase (PSBT) is translationally fused to the periplasmic proteins alkaline phosphatase and maltose-binding protein, there is little or no biotinylation of PSBT in wild-type E. coli. Inhibition of SecA with sodium azide and mutations in SecB, SecD, and SecF, all of which slow down protein secretion, result in biotinylation of PSBT. When PSBT is fused to the E. coli inner membrane protein MalF, it acts as a topological marker: fusions to cytoplasmic domains of MalF are biotinylated, and fusions to periplasmic domains are generally not biotinylated. If SecA is inhibited by sodium azide or if the SecE in the cell is depleted, then the insertion of the MalF second periplasmic domain is slowed down enough that PSBT fusions in this part of the protein become biotinylated. Compared with other protein fusions that have been used to study protein translocation, PSBT fusions have the advantage that they can be used to study the rate of the insertion process.     

Use of alkaline phosphatase fusions to study protein secretion in Bacillus subtilis.

We have constructed a vector designed to facilitate the study of protein secretion in Bacillus subtilis. This vector is based on a translational fusion between the expression elements and signal sequence of Bacillus amyloliquefaciens alkaline protease and the mature coding sequence for Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase (phoA). We show that export of alkaline phosphatase from B. subtilis depends on a functional signal sequence and that alkaline phosphatase activity depends upon secretion. The vector design facilitates the insertion of heterologous coding sequences between the signal and phoA to generate three-part translational fusions. Such phoA fusions are easily analyzed by monitoring alkaline phosphatase activity on agar plates or in culture supernatants or by immunological detection. Exploitation of this methodology, which has proven to be extremely useful in the study of protein secretion in E. coli, has a variety of applications for studying protein secretion in B. subtilis.     

Requirements for translocation of periplasmic domains in polytopic membrane proteins.

Periplasmic domains of cytoplasmic membrane proteins require export signals for proper translocation. These signals were studied by using a MalF-alkaline phosphatase fusion in a genetic selection that allowed the isolation of mislocalization mutants. In the original construct, alkaline phosphatase is fused to the second periplasmic domain of the membrane protein, and its activity is thus confined exclusively to the periplasm. Mutants that no longer translocated alkaline phosphatase were selected by complementation of a serB mutation. A total of 11 deletions in the amino terminus were isolated, all of which spanned at least the third transmembrane segment. This domain immediately precedes the periplasmic domain to which alkaline phosphatase was fused. Our results obtained in vivo support the model that amino-terminal membrane-spanning segments are required for translocation of large periplasmic domains. In addition, we found that the inability to export the alkaline phosphatase domain could be suppressed by a mutation, prlA4, in the secretion apparatus.