Desiccation‐induced alterations in surface topography of thylakoids from resurrection plant Haberlea rhodopensis studied by atomic force microscopy,electrokinetic and optical measurements

With their ability to survive complete desiccation, resurrection plants are a suitable model system for studying the mechanisms of drought tolerance. In the present study, we investigated desiccation‐induced alterations in surface topography of thylakoids isolated from well‐hydrated, moderately dehydrated, severely desiccated and rehydrated Haberlea rhodopensis plants by means of atomic force microscopy (AFM), electrokinetic and optical measurements. According to our knowledge, so far, there were no reports on the characterization of surface topography and polydispersity of thylakoid membranes from resurrection plants using AFM and dynamic light scattering. To study the physicochemical properties of thylakoids from well‐hydrated H. rhodopensis plants, we used spinach thylakoids for comparison as a classical model from higher plants. The thylakoids from well‐hydrated H. rhodopensis had a grainy surface, significantly different from the well‐structured spinach thylakoids with distinct grana and lamella, they had twice smaller cross‐sectional area and were 1.5 times less voluminous than that of spinach. Significant differences in their physicochemical properties were observed. The dehydration and subsequent rehydration of plants affected the size, shape, morphology, roughness and therefore the structure of the studied thylakoids. Drought resulted in significant enhancement of negative charges on the outer surface of thylakoid membranes which correlated with the increased roughness of thylakoid surface. This enhancement in surface charge density could be due to the partial unstacking of thylakoids exposing more negatively charged groups from protein complexes on the membrane surface that prevent from possible aggregation upon drought stress.     

Increased thermal stability of pigment-protein complexes of pea thylakoids following catalytic hydrogenation of membrane lipids

The membrane lipids of pea thylakoids were hydrogenated in situ using the homogeneous catalyst palladiumdi-(sodium alizazine monosulphonate). Following hydrogenation, particle-free patches corresponding to phase-separated gel-phase lipids were observed in the fracture-faces of thylakoid membranes. Freeze-fracture studies on samples of hydrogenated thylakoids incubated at elevated temperatures indicated that hydrogenation reduces the tendency of the heated membranes to destack and vesiculate at higher temperatures. Measurements of chlorophyll a fluorescence emission and the thermal properties of hydrogenated thylakoids suggest that the hydrogenation process also leads to an increase in the thermal stability of pigment-protein complexes of the Photosystem II light-harvesting apparatus.     

A Comparison of the Effects of Chilling on Thylakoid Electron Transfer in Pea (Pisum sativum L.) and Cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.)

Experiments comparing the photosynthetic responses of a chilling-resistant species (Pisum sativum L. cv Alaska) and a chilling-sensitive species (Cucumis sativus L. cv Ashley) have shown that cucumber photosynthesis is adversely affected by chilling temperatures in the light, while pea photosynthesis is not inhibited by chilling in the light. To further investigate the site of the differential response of these two species to chilling stress, thylakoid membranes were isolated under various conditions and rates of photosynthetic electron transfer were determined. Preliminary experiments revealed that the integrity of cucumber thylakoids from 25°C-grown plants was affected by the isolation temperature; cucumber thylakoids isolated at 5°C in 400 millimolar NaCl were uncoupled, while thylakoids isolated at room temperature in 400 millimolar NaCl were coupled, as determined by addition of gramicidin. The concentration of NaCl in the homogenization buffer was found to be a critical factor in the uncoupling of cucumber thylakoids at 5°C. In contrast, pea thylakoid membranes were not influenced by isolation temperatures or NaCl concentrations. In a second set of experiments, thylakoid membranes were isolated from pea and cucumber plants at successive intervals during a whole-plant light period chilling stress (5°C). During wholeplant chilling, thylakoids isolated from cucumber plants chilled in the light were uncoupled even when the membranes were isolated at warm temperatures. Pea thylakoids were not uncoupled by the whole-plant chilling treatment. The difference in integrity of thylakoid membrane coupling following chilling in the light demonstrates a fundamental difference in photosynthetic function between these two species that may have some bearing on why pea is a chilling-resistant plant and cucumber is a chilling-sensitive plant.     

Correlation between spatial (3D) structure of pea and bean thylakoid membranes and arrangement of chlorophyll-protein complexes

ABSTRACT: BACKGROUND: The thylakoid system in plant chloroplasts is organized into two distinct domains: granaarranged in stacks of appressed membranes and non-appressed membranes consisting ofstroma thylakoids and margins of granal stacks. It is argued that the reason for thedevelopment of appressed membranes in plants is that their photosynthetic apparatus need tocope with and survive ever-changing environmental conditions. It is not known however,why different plant species have different arrangements of grana within their chloroplasts. Itis important to elucidate whether a different arrangement and distribution of appressed andnon-appressed thylakoids in chloroplasts are linked with different qualitative and/orquantitative organization of chlorophyll-protein (CP) complexes in the thylakoid membranesand whether this arrangement influences the photosynthetic efficiency. RESULTS: Our results from TEM and in situ CLSM strongly indicate the existence of differentarrangements of pea and bean thylakoid membranes. In pea, larger appressed thylakoids areregularly arranged within chloroplasts as uniformly distributed red fluorescent bodies, whileirregular appressed thylakoid membranes within bean chloroplasts correspond to smaller andless distinguished fluorescent areas in CLSM images. 3D models of pea chloroplasts show adistinct spatial separation of stacked thylakoids from stromal spaces whereas spatial divisionof stroma and thylakoid areas in bean chloroplasts are more complex. Structural differencesinfluenced the PSII photochemistry, however without significant changes in photosyntheticefficiency. Qualitative and quantitative analysis of chlorophyll-protein complexes as well asspectroscopic investigations indicated a similar proportion between PSI and PSII corecomplexes in pea and bean thylakoids, but higher abundance of LHCII antenna in pea ones.Furthermore, distinct differences in size and arrangements of LHCII-PSII and LHCI-PSIsupercomplexes between species are suggested. CONCLUSIONS: Based on proteomic and spectroscopic investigations we postulate that the differences in thechloroplast structure between the analyzed species are a consequence of quantitativeproportions between the individual CP complexes and its arrangement inside membranes.Such a structure of membranes induced the formation of large stacked domains in pea, orsmaller heterogeneous regions in bean thylakoids. Presented 3D models of chloroplasts showed that stacked areas are noticeably irregular with variable thickness, merging with eachother and not always parallel to each other.     

Membrane rupture is the common cause of damage to chloroplast membranes in leaves injured by freezing or excessive wilting

The effects of freezing and desiccation of spinach leaves (Spinacia oleracea L. cv Yates) on the thylakoid membranes were assessed using antibodies specific for thylakoid membrane proteins. The peripheral part of the chloroplast coupling factor ATPase (CF1) was used as a molecular marker for chemical membrane damage by chaotropic solutes. Plastocyanin, a soluble protein localized inside the closed thylakoid membrane system, was a marker for damage by mechanical membrane rupture. After freezing and wilting of leaves which resulted in damage, very little CF1 was detached from the membranes, whereas almost all plastocyanin was released from the thylakoids. It is suggested that in vivo dehydration both by freezing and desiccation results in membrane rupture rather than in the dissociation of peripheral thylakoid membrane proteins.     

Dark-adapted spinach thylakoid protein heterogeneity offers insights into the photosystem II repair cycle

In higher plants, thylakoid membrane protein complexes show lateral heterogeneity in their distribution: photosystem (PS) II complexes are mostly located in grana stacks, whereas PSI and adenosine triphosphate (ATP) synthase are mostly found in the stroma-exposed thylakoids. However, recent research has revealed strong dynamics in distribution of photosystems and their light harvesting antenna along the thylakoid membrane. Here, the dark-adapted spinach (Spinacia oleracea L.) thylakoid network was mechanically fragmented and the composition of distinct PSII-related proteins in various thylakoid subdomains was analyzed in order to get more insights into the composition and localization of various PSII subcomplexes and auxiliary proteins during the PSII repair cycle. Most of the PSII subunits followed rather equal distribution with roughly 70% of the proteins located collectively in the grana thylakoids and grana margins; however, the low molecular mass subunits PsbW and PsbX as well as the PsbS proteins were found to be more exclusively located in grana thylakoids. The auxiliary proteins assisting in repair cycle of PSII were mostly located in stroma-exposed thylakoids, with the exception of THYLAKOID LUMEN PROTEIN OF 18.3 (TLP18.3), which was more evenly distributed between the grana and stroma thylakoids. The TL29 protein was present exclusively in grana thylakoids. Intriguingly, PROTON GRADIENT REGULATION5 (PGR5) was found to be distributed quite evenly between grana and stroma thylakoids, whereas PGR5-LIKE PHOTOSYNTHETIC PHENOTYPE1 (PGRL1) was highly enriched in the stroma thylakoids and practically missing from the grana cores. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Photosynthesis Research for Sustainability: Keys to Produce Clean Energy.     

Assembly of Two Subunits of the Cyanobacterial Photosystem I on the n-Side of Thylakoid Membranes

Photosystem I contains several peripheral membrane proteins that are located on either positive (luminal) or negative (stromal or cytoplasmic) sides of thylakoid membranes of chloroplasts or cyanobacteria. Incorporation of two peripheral subunits into photosystem I of the cyanobacterium Synechocystis species PCC 6803 was studied using a reconstitution system in which radiolabeled subunits II (PsaD) and IV (PsaE) were synthesized in vitro and incubated with the isolated thylakoid membranes. After such incubation, the subunits were found in the membranes and were resistant to digestion with proteases and removal by 2 molar NaBr. All of the radioactive proteins incorporated in the membrane were found in the photosystem I complex. The subunit II was assembled specifically into cyanobacterial thylakoid membranes and not into Escherichia coli cell membranes or thylakoid membranes isolated from spinach. The assembly process did not require ATP or proton motive force, and it was not stimulated by ATP. The assembly of subunits II and IV into thylakoid membranes isolated from the strain AEK2, which lacks the gene psaE, was increased two- to threefold. The incorporation of subunit II was 15 to 17 times higher in the thylakoids obtained from the strain ADK3 in which the gene psaD has been inactivated. However, assembly of subunit IV in the same thylakoids was reduced by 65%, demonstrating that the presence of subunit II is required for the stable assembly of subunit IV. Large deletions in subunit II prevented its incorporation into thylakoids and assembly into photosystem I, suggesting that the overall conformation of the protein rather than a specific targeting sequence is required for its assembly into photosystem I.     

Presence in Photosystem II Core Complexes of a 34-Kilodalton Polypeptide Required for Water Photolysis

Photosystem II (PSII) reaction center core complexes have been isolated and characterized from wild type (WT) Scenedesmus obliquus and from its LF-1 mutant. LF-1 thylakoids are blocked on the oxidizing side of PSII and have a reduced Mn content. Visible absorption and low temperature fluorescence spectra of both core complexes are identical and resemble those reported for spinach (Satoh, Butler 1978 Plant Physiol 61: 373-379). Lithium dodecyl sulfate-polycrylamide gel electrophoresis reveals that a protein alteration, originally observed in thylakoid membranes (Metz, Wong, Bishop 1980 FEBS Lett 114: 61-66), is retained in the PSII core particles. That is, a 34-kilodalton (kD) polypeptide, present in the WT core complex, is missing in the mutant, and the core complex of the mutant contains a 36-kD protein not present in the WT. The 34-kD intrinsic protein is also observed in O₂-evolving PSII preparations and PSII core complexes from spinach. It is distinct from the 33-kD extrinsic protein first reported by T. Kuwabara and N. Murata (1979 Biochim Biophys Acta 581: 228-236). We suggest that the 34-kD protein is a site of Mn binding in the PSII membrane.     

Lateral Distribution of the Cytochrome b(6)/f and Coupling Factor ATP Synthetase Complexes of Chloroplast Thylakoid Membranes

We have visualized directly the distribution of the cytochrome b₆/f and coupling factor ATP synthetase complexes in thylakoid membranes of embedded, thin-sectioned, intact chloroplasts by using rabbit antibodies directed against each complex, followed by ferritin-conjugated goat anti- (rabbit immunoglobulin G) antibodies. The labeling patterns indicate that in spinach (Spinacia oleracea) chloroplasts the cytochrome b₆/f complex is distributed laterally throughout both stacked grana and unstacked stroma membrane regions, whereas the coupling factor ATP synthetase complex is found exclusively in stroma thylakoids and in the marginal and end membranes of grana.     

Biological and polymeric self-assembled hybrid systems: Structure and properties of thylakoid/polyelectrolyte complexes

A novel hybrid system composed of biological components and synthetic polymer, thylakoid/polycation complex, has been formed and studied. Effects of complex formation on the structure, electrostatics and functioning of thylakoid membranes have been examined. Thylakoids from bean leaves were used to form complexes with polycation polyallylamine hydrochloride (PAAH) in two systems: (i) thylakoid/polycation complexes formed in an aqueous bulk phase, and (ii) immobilized thylakoid/polycation planar complexes. Immobilized on a solid substrate surface, thylakoid/polycation complexes were prepared using layer-by-layer stepwise alternate adsorption technique, i.e., via the sequential alternate adsorption of thylakoids and polycation molecules. The morphology of built up structures was investigated by scanning electron microscopy. Light-induced electron transport in chloroplasts was studied by the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) method. Spin probe technique was employed to study the structural and electrostatic characteristics of thylakoid membranes. We have found that efficiency of light-induced electron transport in thylakoid membranes and membrane structure were not changed noticeably by PAAH binding to thylakoids in a wide range of PAAH concentrations. The data obtained indicate the physiologically-soft character of polycation interactions with thylakoid membranes and demonstrate effectiveness of interfacial self-assembly approach to fabrication of complex planar functional nanostructures from biological components and synthetic polymers.     

Biological and polymeric self-assembled hybrid systems: structure and properties of thylakoid/polyelectrolyte complexes

A novel hybrid system composed of biological components and synthetic polymer, thylakoid/polycation complex, has been formed and studied. Effects of complex formation on the structure, electrostatics and functioning of thylakoid membranes have been examined. Thylakoids from bean leaves were used to form complexes with polycation polyallylamine hydrochloride (PAAH) in two systems: (i) thylakoid/polycation complexes formed in an aqueous bulk phase, and (ii) immobilized thylakoid/polycation planar complexes. Immobilized on a solid substrate surface, thylakoid/polycation complexes were prepared using layer-by-layer stepwise alternate adsorption technique, i.e., via the sequential alternate adsorption of thylakoids and polycation molecules. The morphology of built up structures was investigated by scanning electron microscopy. Light-induced electron transport in chloroplasts was studied by the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) method. Spin probe technique was employed to study the structural and electrostatic characteristics of thylakoid membranes. We have found that efficiency of light-induced electron transport in thylakoid membranes and membrane structure were not changed noticeably by PAAH binding to thylakoids in a wide range of PAAH concentrations. The data obtained indicate the physiologically-soft character of polycation interactions with thylakoid membranes and demonstrate effectiveness of interfacial self-assembly approach to fabrication of complex planar functional nanostructures from biological components and synthetic polymers.     

Assembly of Newly Imported Oxygen-Evolving Complex Subunits in Isolated Chloroplasts: Sites of Assembly and Mechanism of Binding

We have examined the assembly of the nuclear-encoded subunits of the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) after their import into isolated intact chloroplasts. We showed that all three subunits examined (OE33, OE23, and OE17) partition between the thylakoid lumen and a site on the inner surface of the thylakoid membrane after import in a homologous system (e.g., pea or spinach subunits into pea or spinach chloroplasts, respectively). Although some interspecies protein import experiments resulted in OEC subunit binding, maize OE17 did not bind thylakoid membranes in chloroplasts isolated from peas. Newly imported OE33 and OE23 were washed from the membranes at the same concentrations of urea and NaCl as the native, indigenous proteins; this observation suggests that the former subunits are bound productively within the OEC. Inhibition of neither chloroplast protein synthesis nor light- or ATP-dependent energization of the thylakoid membrane significantly affected these assembly reactions, and we present evidence suggesting that incoming subunits actively displace those already bound to the thylakoid membrane. Transport of OE33 took place primarily in the stromal-exposed membranes and proceeded through a protease-sensitive, mature intermediate. Initial binding of OE33 to the thylakoid membrane occurred primarily in the stromal-exposed membranes, from where it migrated with measurable kinetics to the granal region. In contrast, OE23 assembly occurred in the granal membrane regions. This information is incorporated into a model of the stepwise assembly of oxygen-evolving photosystem II.     

Molecular architecture of the thylakoid membrane: lipid diffusion space for plastoquinone

We have determined the stoichiometric composition of membrane components (lipids and proteins) in spinach thylakoids and have derived the molecular area occupied by these components. From this analysis, the lipid phase diffusion space, the fraction of lipids located in the first protein solvation shell (boundary lipids), and the plastoquinone (PQ) concentration are derived. On the basis of these stoichiometric data, we have analyzed the motion of PQ between photosystem (PS) II and cytochrome (cyt.) bf complexes in this highly protein obstructed membrane (protein area about 70%) using percolation theory. This analysis reveals an inefficient diffusion process. We propose that distinct structural features of the thylakoid membrane (grana formation, microdomains) could help to minimize these inefficiencies and ensure a non-rate limiting PQ diffusion process. A large amount of published evidence supports the idea that higher protein associations exist, especially in grana thylakoids. From the quantification of the boundary lipid fraction (about 60%), we conclude that protein complexes involved in these associations should be spaced by lipids. Lipid-spaced protein aggregations in thylakoids are qualitatively different to previously characterized associations (multisubunit complexes, supercomplexes). We derive a hierarchy of protein and lipid interactions in the thylakoid membrane.     

A protein essential for recovering oxygen evolution in cholate-treated chloroplasts

A novel method for the reconstitution of oxygen evolution in cholate-extracted spinach thylakoid membranes was established and a protein essential for the reconstitution was purified from cholate extracts. Purification of the protein was accomplished by chromatography on a DEAE-Sephacel column. This protein (M_r 17 000) was reinserted into vesicular membranes reconstituted from cholate-extracted thylakoids in the presence of 25% glycerol to reactivate oxygen evolution.     

Further enzymatic characteristics of a thylakoid protein kinase

The enzymatic characteristics of a protein kinase purified from thylakoids are further described. ATP (KM approximately 30 microM) and Mg2+ ion (greater than 1.0 mM) were required for activity, while ADP was a competitive inhibitor (Ki = 100 microM). Activity was 55% inhibited by the sulfhydryl inhibitor p-chloromercuribenzoate (1 mM) and was less sensitive to substituted maleimides. Lysine-rich histones (H1) were utilized as an exogenous phosphorylation substrate both by thylakoid-bound kinase and by isolated enzyme; threonine was predominantly phosphorylated by the in situ enzyme, whereas the isolated enzyme phosphorylated closely related serine residues as determined by peptide mapping. Detergents that proved useful in extracting the kinase from thylakoids markedly inhibited activity of the isolated enzyme, whereas Triton X-100 and 3-[(3-cholamidopropyl)dimethylammonio]-1-propane-sulfonic acid had little effect. The enzyme could be freed from detergent and behaved as an active monomer on size-exclusion chromatography. The phosphate contents of the light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b protein complex of photosystem II isolated from maximally phosphorylated thylakoid membranes of spinach and pea were equivalent to approximately 6% and approximately 19% phosphorylation, respectively. Corresponding values for nonphosphorylated membranes were approximately 3% and approximately 14.5%.     

Superoxide production in aprotic interior of chloroplast thylakoids

The site of superoxide production in spinach thylakoids was found to be the aprotic interior of the thylakoid membranes near the P700 chlorophyll a protein at the reaction center of photosystem I complexes. This conclusion was drawn from the following findings. (i) Cytochrome c reduction by illuminated thylakoids, which was confirmed to be superoxide dependent by the failure of this reaction to occur in anaerobiosis, was completely inhibited by a dibutyl catechol, but partially inhibited by a hydrophilic disulfonated derivative. (ii) P700 chlorophyll a proteins were preferentially iodinated by lactoperoxidase by the use of hydrogen peroxide that was derived from the disproportionation of superoxides in illuminated thylakoids. (iii) Hydrogen peroxide production and oxygen uptake were induced by ammonium chloride, a proton conductor that can permeate through thylakoid membranes, but whole superoxide in the bulk solution was oxidized back to molecular oxygen by cytochrome c. The effective concentration of ammonium chloride decreased to one-sixtieth of the original, when an ammonium ion ionophore, nonactin, was added. Thus, the weak acid allowed superoxide to yield hydrogen peroxide disproportionately in the thylakoid membrane interior.     

Distribution of the early light-inducible protein in the thylakoids of developing pea chloroplasts

The distribution of the early light-inducible protein (ELIP) of pea (Pisum sativum) between grana and stroma thylakoids was studied. An antibody raised against a bacterial-expressed fusion protein containing ELIP sequences was used. Illumination of dark-grown pea seedlings causes an accumulation of the ELIP in the thylakoid membranes with a maximum level at 16 h. During continuous illumination exceeding 16 h the level decreases again. The fractionation of thylakoid membranes of 48-h-illuminated pea seedlings in grana and stroma thylakoids reveals that there is no uniform distribution of ELIP in the thylakoids. Rather 60-70% of ELIP was found in the stroma thylakoids and 30-40% in the grana thylakoids. This distribution is in accordance with that of photosystem I but not with that of photosystem II. After Triton-X-100 solubilization almost all ELIP is found in the photosystem-I-containing fraction. This also supports an association of ELIP with photosystem I.     

Phosphorylation of thylakoid proteins by a purified kinase

A simplified method is given for the purification of a 64-kilodalton protein kinase from spinach or pea thylakoid membranes (Coughlan, S., and Hind, G. (1986) J. Biol. Chem. 261, 11378-11385). In a heterogeneous reconstitution system comprised of purified kinase and washed thylakoids (having their intrinsic kinase inactivated or removed), endogenous light-harvesting pigment protein of photosystem II could serve as a substrate. Its phosphorylation did not require rebinding of kinase to the thylakoid membrane and, like the phosphorylation of solubilized pigment protein, was not under redox control. No reconstitution was observed upon replacing 64-kilodalton protein kinase with 25-kilodalton protein kinase (Coughlan, S., and Hind, G. (1986) J. Biol. Chem. 261, 14062-14068). Tryptic digestion of phosphorylated membranes removed the site of phosphorylation; the phosphorylated amino acid present in light-harvesting pigment protein and its tryptic peptide was threonine. Immunoglobulin from a polyclonal antiserum, raised against the purified enzyme, fully inhibited kinase activity toward solubilized and endogenous pigment protein. At higher titers, the antibody was effective in totally inhibiting the redox-sensitive phosphorylation of thylakoid proteins by endogenous kinase; inhibition profiles for phosphorylation of pigment protein and thylakoid proteins of 32, 16, and 9 kilodaltons were essentially identical. The 64-kilodalton protein kinase would thus appear to be responsible for all of the observed phosphorylation of thylakoid phosphoproteins.     

The Involvement of the Complexes of Photosystems in the Organization of Chloroplast Ultrastructure in Pea Mutants

We studied the involvement of pigment-protein complexes of photosystems (PS) in the development and spatial arrangement of thylakoids in chloroplasts of pea (Pisum sativum L.) leaves. The initial line (cv. Torsdag) and its mutants, chlorotica 2004 displaying primary disturbances in the PSI reaction centers and chlorotica 2014 containing only 50% of chlorophyll and, as a sequence, the reduced amount of all pigment-protein complexes. A proportional decrease in the content of PSI and PSII complexes in the chlorotica 2014 mutant resulted in a partial reduction of the whole chloroplast membrane system, whereas grana and stroma thylakoid regions were well developed. In contrast, a loss of only 20% of chlorophyll and destruction of PSI complexes in the chlorotica 2004 mutant by 50% resulted in the destruction of stroma thylakoid regions and disturbed longitudinal thylakoid and grana orientation. It was concluded that protein-protein interactions in pigment-protein complexes played a key role in the structure of thylakoid membranes and their longitudinal orientation.     

Differential scanning calorimetric investigation of pea chloroplast thylakoids and thylakoid fractions.

High sensitivity differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) was employed to study the thermal denaturation of components of pea chloroplast thylakoid membranes. In contrast to previous reports utilizing spinach thylakoids, several transitions are reversible, and deconvolution of the calorimetric curves indicates nine transitions in both first and second heating scans, but overlapping transitions obscure at least three transitions in the first heating scans of control thylakoids. Glutaraldehyde fixation increases the denaturation temperature of several transitions which is consistent with a reported increase in thermal stability of thylakoid function due to fixation. Acidic pH treatment has little effect on the DSC curves, although it has been reported to have a significant effect on membrane structure. Separation of grana from stroma thylakoids indicates that components responsible for transitions centered at approximately 56, 73, 77, and 91 degrees C are predominantly or exclusively associated with grana thylakoids, whereas components responsible for transitions centered at approximately 63 and 81 degrees C are predominantly associated with stroma thylakoids. A broad transition centered at 66 degrees C is associated with grana thylakoids, whereas a sharp transition at the same temperature is due to a component associated with stroma thylakoids. Evidence obtained by washing treatments suggests the latter transition originates from the denaturation of the thylakoid ATPase (CF1). Analysis of the calorimetric enthalpy values indicates most components of the grana thylakoids denature irreversibly at high temperature, whereas components associated with the stroma thylakoids have a considerable degree of thermal reversibility.