Theoretical models for estimating dose-effect relationships after combined exposure to cytotoxicants

Two classes of dose-effect models for cell killing (additive damage and independent effects) are developed under alternative hypotheses about the damage that leads to cell death. Generalized models, along with specific models for cell killing after exposure to a specific cytotoxicant, are used to make predictions about the effects of sequential or simultaneous exposure to different cytotoxicants. It is demonstrated that with the additive damage models developed one can adequately account for the combined effects of the cytotoxicants considered. Theoretical results are presented which suggest that after simultaneous exposure of cells to low total doses (<0.1 Gy) of different ionizing radiations, use of the conventional relative biological effectiveness approach to predict cell killing risks is unnecessary; cell killing risks can adequately be determined by assuming the effects of the different radiations to be independent. Also, for simultaneous exposure of cells to total doses of different radiations much larger than 0.1 Gy, use of the conventional RBE approach to arrive at cell killing risk could lead to overestimation of the risk.     

Systemic approach to radiobiological studies

The principles of information theory were applied for analysis of radiobiological effects. The perception of ionizing radiations as a signal enables living organism to discern their benefits or harm, to react to absolute and relatively small deviations, to keep the logic and chronicle of events, to use the former experience for reacting in presence, to forecast consequences. The systemic analysis of organism's response to ionizing radiations allows explaining the peculiarities of effects of different absorbed doses, hormesis, apoptosis, remote consequences and other post-radiation effects.     

The estimation of low-dose hazards by extrapolation from high doses.

Empirical information on the effects of low doses of ionizing radiation is beset by severe limitations. Theoretical considerations of biophysics can guide the analysis of epidemiological data by indicating certain dose-response relations or eliminating others. Thus, it can be shown that at low doses there must be proportionality between dose and effect on non-interacting cells and that one must anticipate different dose-effect relations upon exposure to markedly different types of radiation.     

Comparison of cytogenetic tests for monitoring overexposures from ionizing radiation

The frequencies of chromosome aberrations induced by ionizing radiations were studied for use in assessment of doses in radiation accidents. The dose-effect relationships of formations of dicentric and acentric aberrations are compared with that of micronuclei detected in cultured human lymphocytes. The data suggest the applicability of micronucleus test as "biological dosimeter" with a similar sensitivity like the widely used dicentric analysis.     

Interrelationships amongst radiation-induced genomic instability, bystander effects, and the adaptive response

Over the past two decades, our understanding of radiation biology has undergone a fundamental shift in paradigms away from deterministic "hit-effect" relationships and towards complex ongoing "cellular responses". These responses include now familiar, but still poorly understood, phenomena associated with radiation exposure such as bystander effects, genomic instability, and adaptive responses. All three have been observed at very low doses, and at time points far removed from the initial radiation exposure, and are extremely relevant for linear extrapolation to low doses; the adaptive response is particularly relevant when exposure is spread over a period of time. These are precisely the circumstances that are most relevant to understanding cancer risk associated with environmental and occupational radiation exposures. This review will provide a synthesis of the known, and proposed, interrelationships amongst low-dose cellular responses to radiation. It also will examine the potential importance of non-targeted cellular responses to ionizing radiation in setting acceptable exposure limits especially to low-LET radiations.     

Principal inferences from studies of radiobiological effects for radiation protection purposes

The most recent Recommendations (Publication 103) issued by the International Commission for Radiological Protection (ICRP) are based on the data that have been published since 1990 up to now. The basic task of the ICRP Committee 1 was to formulate the key implications of studies on radiobiological effects for the purposes of radiological protection. Presented in the paper are the new achievements in the field of biology, radiobiology and radiation epidemiology which were taken into account by the ICRP in the process of Publication 103 preparation. The Recommendations provide present-day values of weighting factors for radiation exposure and tissue weighting factors, as well as radiation detriment and radiogenic risk factors for cancer and genetic diseases. Also considered are tissue reactions to radiation exposure, consequences of in utero exposure and the risks of developing non-cancer diseases for exposed individuals. It should be noted that the key inferences and recommendations are to a considerable degree related to biological effects accounted for by acute and chronic exposure to ionizing radiation in the range of small doses (up to 100 mSv).     

Restoration of pine plantations after effect of ionizing radiation in the region of the accident at the Chernobyl Atomic Energy Station

The main results of the 12-year radiation-genetic monitoring of radiobiological, cytogenetic, and genetic parameters in the Pinus sylvestris L. forest plantations from the zone of the accident at the Chernobyl nuclear power plant presented. Acute ionizing irradiation at doses > 1 Gy was shown to induce the formation of morphoses and depressed growth; at doses > 2 Gy, the reproductive ability of the trees declined. The radiobiological parameters showed a linear (or close to linear) dose-effect relationship. Acute irradiation at a dose of 0.5 Gy induced cytogenetic and genetic effects that were significantly higher than the corresponding control values. The relationship between the cytogenetic effects and the absorbed dose was exponential. The dependence of the mutation frequency at specific loci on the absorbed dose was described by a nonlinear curve. The results of cytogenetic analysis of sprouts obtained from seeds annually (1986-1998) collected in zones of slight, moderate, and strong damage of Pinus sylvestris L. are presented.     

Effects of sparsely and densely ionizing radiation on plants

One of the main purposes leading botanists to investigate the effects of ionizing radiations is to understand plant behaviour in space, where vegetal systems play an important role for nourishment, psychological support and functioning of life support systems. Ground-based experiments have been performed with particles of different charge and energy. Samples exposed to X- or γ-rays are often used as reference to derive the biological efficiency of different radiation qualities. Studies where biological samples are exposed directly to the space radiation environment have also been performed. The comparison of different studies has clarified how the effects observed after exposure are deeply influenced by several factors, some related to plant characteristics (e.g. species, cultivar, stage of development, tissue architecture and genome organization) and some related to radiation features (e.g. quality, dose, duration of exposure). In this review, we report main results from studies on the effect of ionizing radiations, including cosmic rays, on plants, focusing on genetic alterations, modifications of growth and reproduction and changes in biochemical pathways especially photosynthetic behaviour. Most of the data confirm what is known from animal studies: densely ionizing radiations are more efficient in inducing damages at several different levels, in comparison with sparsely ionizing radiation.     

A comparative study of microdosimetric properties of x-rays, γ-rays,and β-rays

The objective of this study was the computation of microdosimetric functions and quantities for sparsely ionizing radiations. The calculations are performed on simulated electron tracks generated by Monte-Carlo techniques. Ten different radiations of biomedical interest are considered. The comparison of radiation qualities shows marked differences between these sparsely ionizing radiations. The microdosimetric data are represented graphically for use in radiation biology and in clinical applications.     

An isoeffect approach to the study of combined effects of mixed radiations--the nonparametric analysis of in vivo data

The combined effects of mixed radiations can be examined using a system of simple isoeffect relations which are derived from a recent analysis of in vitro results obtained for a variety of radiation mixtures. Similar isoeffect analysis methods have been used for over two decades in studies of the combined action of toxic agents such as drugs and antibiotics. Because of the isoeffect approach, the method is particularly useful for the analysis of ordinal data for which conventional models that are based on parametric dose-effect relations may not be suitable. This is illustrated by applying the method to the analysis of a set of recently published in vivo data using the mouse foot skin reaction system for mixtures of neutrons and X rays. The good agreement between this method and the ordinal data also helps to provide further experimental support for the existence of a class of radiobiological data for which the simple isoeffect relations are valid.     

Differential modulation of specific gene expression following high- and low-LET radiations

Experiments were designed to examine the effects of radiation quality on specific gene expression within the first 3 h following radiation exposure in Syrian hamster embryo (SHE) cells. Preliminary work demonstrated the induction of c-fos and alpha-interferon genes following exposure to low-linear-energy-transfer (low-LET) radiations (X rays or gamma rays). More detailed experiments revealed induction of c-fos mRNA within the first 3 h following exposure to either X rays (75 cGy) or gamma rays (90 cGy). We could not detect induction of c-fos following exposure of SHE cells to fission-spectrum neutrons (high-LET) from the JANUS reactor administered at either high (12 cGy/min) or low (0.5 cGy/min) dose rates. Expression of alpha-interferon mRNA was similarly induced by low-LET radiations but only modestly by JANUS neutrons. The induction by gamma rays was dose-dependent, while induction by neutrons was specific for low doses and low dose rates. These experiments demonstrate the differential gene inductive response of cells following exposure to high- and low-LET radiations. These experiments suggest that these different qualities of ionizing radiation may have different mechanisms for inducing many of the cellular consequences of radiation exposure, such as cell survival and cell transformation.     

In vivo interactions between ionizing radiation, inflammation and chemical carcinogens identified by increased DNA damage responses

Exposure to ionizing radiation or a variety of chemical agents is known to increase the risk of developing malignancy and many tumors have been linked to inflammatory processes. In most studies, the potentially harmful effects of ionizing radiation or other agents are considered in isolation, mainly due to the large number of experiments required to assess the effects of mixed exposures with different doses and different schedules, and the length of time and expense of studies using disease as the measure of outcome. Here, we have used short-term DNA damage responses to identify interactive effects of mixed exposures. The data demonstrate that exposure to ionizing radiation on two separate occasions ten days apart leads to an increase in the percentage of cells with a sub-G(0) DNA content compared to cells exposed only once, and this is a greater than additive effect. Short-term measurements of p53 stabilization, induction of p21/Cdkn1a and of apoptosis also identify these interactive effects. We also demonstrate similar interactive effects of radiation with the mutagenic chemical methyl-nitrosourea and with a nonspecific pro-inflammatory agent, lipopolysaccharide. The magnitude of the interactive effects is greater in cells taken from mice first exposed as juveniles compared to adults. These data indicate that short-term measurements of DNA damage and response to damage are useful for the identification of interactions between ionizing radiation and other agents.     

A New Model of Biodosimetry to Integrate Low and High Doses

Biological dosimetry, that is the estimation of the dose of an exposure to ionizing radiation by a biological parameter, is a very important tool in cases of radiation accidents. The score of dicentric chromosomes, considered to be the most accurate method for biological dosimetry, for low LET radiation and up to 5 Gy, fits very well to a linear-quadratic model of dose-effect curve assuming the Poisson distribution. The accuracy of this estimation raises difficulties for doses over 5 Gy, the highest dose of the majority of dose-effect curves used in biological dosimetry. At doses over 5 Gy most cells show difficulties in reaching mitosis and cannot be used to score dicentric chromosomes. In the present study with the treatment of lymphocyte cultures with caffeine and the standardization of the culture time, metaphases for doses up to 25 Gy have been analyzed. Here we present a new model for biological dosimetry, which includes a Gompertz-type function as the dose response, and also takes into account the underdispersion of aberration-among-cell distribution. The new model allows the estimation of doses of exposures to ionizing radiation of up to 25 Gy. Moreover, the model is more effective in estimating whole and partial body exposures than the classical method based on linear and linear-quadratic functions, suggesting their effectiveness and great potential to be used after high dose exposures of radiation.     

Variability of the adaptive response to ionizing radiations in humans

Human lymphocytes exposed to low doses of ionizing radiations from incorporated tritiated thymidine ([3H]dThd) or from X-rays become less susceptible to the induction of chromatid aberrations by high doses of X-rays. This indicates that low doses of ionizing radiation can produce an effect similar to the adaptive response observed with alkylating agents in prokaryotes, animal and plant cells. To determine whether there is individual variability in the adaptive response to ionizing radiations we exposed human lymphocytes from 18 different healthy donors to 'adapting' doses of [3H]dThd (0.01 microCi/ml) or X-rays (0.01 Gy) and subsequently to a 'challenge' treatment of 0.75 Gy of X-rays delivered 2 h before fixation. Four of the 18 donors did not show an adaptive response; in some cases in these individuals a synergistic response of increased, rather than decreased, damage was found. Two of these 4 donors showed no adaptive response in 3 subsequent experiments separated by 4-month intervals. This suggests that the human population exhibits a heterogeneity in the adaptive response to ionizing radiations which might be, at least in part, genetically determined.     

Comparison of recovery from potential mitotic abnormality in mitotically quiescent lens cells after X, neutron, and 56Fe irradiations

After exposure to various doses of 250 kVp X radiation, 0.85 Me V fission spectrum neutrons, or 600 MeV/A iron (Fe) particles, mitotically quiescent rat lens cells showed no visible evidence of radiation injury. However, following the mitogenic stimulus of wounding, mitotic abnormalities became evident when responding cells entered mitosis. Latent damage and recovery therefrom were monitored at 3, 7, 14, and 28 days after irradiation. Following doses of 1 to 10 Gy of X radiation, the recovery rate, indicated by a decrease in abnormalities with time, was proportional to dose, and the dose-effect slope decreased exponentially with time. Virtually no recovery occurred during the 28 days after 1.25 to 2.25 Gy of fission neutron radiation. After doses of 0.5 to 3.0 Gy of Fe particles, an increased expression of mitotic damage or recovery than recovery occurred. As a consequence of the differing patterns in time for expression of damage or recovery following X rays and the high-LET radiations, the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) increased from 3.6 to 16 for neutrons and from 2 to 10 for Fe particles over the 28-day observation period.     

Application of Bayesian inference to characterize risks associated with low doses of low-LET radiation

Improved risk characterization for stochastic biological effects of low doses of low-LET radiation is important for protecting nuclear workers and the public from harm from radiation exposure. Here we present a Bayesian approach to characterize risks of stochastic effects from low doses of low-LET radiation. The stochastic effect considered is neoplastic transformation of cells because it relates closely to cancer induction. We have used a published model of neoplastic transformation called NEOTRANS1. It is based on two different classes of cellular sensitivity for asynchronous, exponentially growing populations (in vitro). One sensitivity class is the hypersensitive cell; the other is the resistant cell. NEOTRANS1 includes the effects of genomic damage accumulation, DNA repair during cell cycle arrest, and DNA misrepair (non-lethal repair errors). The model-associated differential equations are solved for conditions of in vitro irradiation at a fixed rate. Previously published solutions apply only to high dose rates and were incorrectly assumed to apply to only high-LET radiation. Solutions provided here apply to any fixed dose rate and to both high- and low-LET radiations. Markov chain Monte Carlo methods are used to carry out the Bayesian inference of the low-dose risk for neoplastic transformation of aneuploid C3H 10T1/2 cells for X-ray doses from 0 to 1000 mGy. We have assumed that for this low-dose range only the hypersensitive fraction of the cells are affected. Our results indicate that the initial slope of the risk vs dose relationship for neoplastic transformation is as follows: (1) directly proportional to the fraction, f1, of hypersensitive cells; (2) directly proportional to the radiosensitivity of the genomic target; and (3) inversely proportional to the rate at which hypersensitive cells with radiation-induced damage are committed to undergo correct repair of genomic damage. Further, our results indicate that very fast molecular events are associated with the commitment of cells to the correct repair pathway. Results also indicate a relatively large probability for misrepair that leads to genomic instability. Our results are consistent with the view that for very low doses, dose rate is not an important variable for characterizing low-LET radiation risks so long as age-related changes in sensitivity do not occur during irradiation.     

Effects of acute low doses of Gamma-radiation on erythrocytes membrane

It is believed that any dose of ionizing radiation may damage cells and that the mutated cells could develop into cancer cells. Additionally, results of research performed over the past century on the effects of low doses of ionizing radiation on biological organisms show beneficial health effects, called hormesis. Much less is known about the cellular response to low doses of ionizing radiation, such as those typical for medical diagnostic procedures, normal occupational exposures or cosmic-ray exposures at flight altitudes. Extrapolating from the effects observed at higher doses to predict changes in cells after low-dose exposure is problematic. We examined the biological effects of low doses (0.01–0.3 Gy) of γ-radiation on the membrane characteristics of erythrocytes of albino rats and carried out osmotic fragility tests and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR). Our results indicate that the lowest three doses in the investigated radiation range, i.e., 0.01, 0.025 and 0.05 Gy, resulted in positive effects on the erythrocyte membranes, while a dose of 0.1 Gy appeared to represent the limiting threshold dose of those positive effects. Doses higher than 0.1 Gy were associated with the denaturation of erythrocyte proteins.     

Adaptive response of human lymphocytes for the repair of radon-induced chromosomal damage

In human lymphocytes low doses of X-rays can decrease the number of chromatid deletions induced by subsequent high doses of sparsely ionizing X-rays. Because of the concern with the carcinogenic effects of low doses of -particles from radon in homes, experiments were carried out to see if low doses of X-rays could also decrease the yield of chromosomal aberrations induced by subsequent exposure to radon. Human peripheral blood lymphocytes were irradiated with low doses of X-rays (2 cGy) at 48 h of culture, exposed to radon at 72 h of culture, and analyzed for the presence of chromatid aberrations at subsequent intervals. The frequency of chromatid aberrations induced by radon alone increased with time after exposure, indicating exaggerated differences in the stage sensitivity of cell cycle stages to high-LET radiation. Furthermore, the numbers of aberrations per cell did not follow a Poisson distribution but were over dispersed, as might be expected since high-LET radiations have a high relative biological effectiveness compared with low-LET radiations. Nevertheless, lymphocytes exposed to 2 cGy of X-rays before radon exposure contained approximately one-half the number of chromatid deletions compared with lymphocytes treated with radon alone and analzed at the same time. Thus, the putative chromosomal repair mechanism induced by low doses of sparsely ionizing radiation is also effective in reducing chromosomal aberrations induced by radon, which hitherto had been thought to be relatively independent of repair processes.     

Micronuclei in humans induced by exposure to low level of ionizing radiation: influence of polymorphisms in DNA repair genes

Understanding the risks deriving from protracted exposure to low doses of ionizing radiation has remarkable societal importance in view of the large number of work settings in which sources of IR are encountered. To address this question, we studied the frequency of micronuclei (MN), which is an indicator of DNA damage, in a population exposed to low levels of ionizing radiation and in matched controls. In both exposed population and controls, the possible influence of single nucleotide polymorphisms in XRCC1, XRCC3 and XPD genes on the frequency of micronuclei was also evaluated. We also considered the effects of confounding factors, like smoking status, age and gender. The results indicated that MN frequency was significantly higher in the exposed workers than in the controls [8.62+/-2.80 versus 6.86+/-2.65; P=0.019]. Radiological workers with variant alleles for XRCC1 or XRCC3 polymorphisms or wild-type alleles for XPD exon 23 or 10 polymorphisms showed a significantly higher MN frequency than controls with the same genotypes. Smoking status did not affect micronuclei frequency either in exposed workers or controls, while age was associated with increased MN frequency in the exposed only. In the combined population, gender but not age exerted an influence on the yield of MN, being higher in females than in males. Even though there is a limitation in this study due to the small number of subjects, these results suggest that even exposures to low level of ionizing radiation could have genotoxic effects and that XRCC3, XRCC1 and XPD polymorphisms might contribute to the increased genetic damage in susceptible individuals occupationally exposed to chronic low levels of ionizing radiation. For a clear conclusion on the induction of DNA damage caused by protracted exposure to low doses of ionizing radiation and the possible influence of genetic polymorphism in DNA repair genes larger studies are needed.