Light-induced unfolding of photoactive yellow protein mutant M100L

Light-activation of the PAS domain protein photoactive yellow protein (PYP) is believed to trigger a negative phototactic response in the phototropic bacterium Halorhodospira halophila. To investigate transient conformational changes of the PYP photocycle, we utilized the PYP mutant M100L that displays an increased lifetime of the putative signaling-state photointermediate PYP(M) by 3 orders of magnitude, as previously reported for the M100A mutant [Devanathan, S., Genick, U. K., Canestrelli, I. L., Meyer, T. E., Cusanovich, M. A., Getzoff, E. D., and Tollin, G. Biochemistry (1998) 37, 11563-11568]. The FTIR difference spectrum of PYP(M) and the ground state of M100L demonstrated extensive peptide-backbone structural changes as observed in the FTIR difference spectrum of the wild-type protein and PYP(M). The conformational change investigated by CD spectroscopy in the far-UV region showed reduction of the alpha-helical content by approximately 40%, indicating a considerable amount of changes in the secondary structure. The optical activity of the p-coumaric acid chromophore completely vanished upon PYP(M) in contrast to the dark state, indicating deformation of the binding pocket structure in PYP(M). The tertiary structural changes were further monitored by small-angle X-ray scattering measurements, which demonstrated a significant increase of the radius of gyration of the molecule by approximately 5% in PYP(M). These structural changes were reversed concomitantly with the chromophore anionization upon the dark state recovery. The observed changes of the quantities provided a more vivid view of the structural changes of the mutant PYP in going from PYP(M) to PYP(dark), which can be regarded as a process of folding of the secondary and the tertiary structures of the "PAS" domain structure, coupled with the p-coumaric acid chromophore deprotonation and isomerization.     

Light induces destabilization of photoactive yellow protein

To understand the effect of visible light on the stability of photoactive yellow protein (PYP), urea denaturation experiments were performed with PYP in the dark and with PYP(M) under continuous illumination. The urea concentrations at the midpoint of denaturation were 5.26 +/- 0.29 and 3.77 +/- 0.19 M for PYP and PYP(M), respectively, in 100 mM acetate buffer, and 5.26 +/- 0.24 and 4.11 +/- 0.12 M for PYP and PYP(M), respectively, in 100 mM citrate buffer. The free energy change upon denaturation (DeltaG(D)(H2O)), obtained from the denaturation curve, was 11.0 +/- 0.4 and 7.6 +/- 0.2 kcal/mol for PYP and PYP(M), respectively, in acetate buffer, and 11.5 +/- 0.3 and 7.8 +/- 0.1 kcal/mol for PYP and PYP(M), respectively, in citrate buffer. Even though the DeltaG(D)(H2O) value for PYP(M) is almost identical in the two buffer systems, the urea concentration at the midpoint of denaturation is lower in acetate buffer than in citrate buffer. Although their CD spectra indicate that the protein conformations of the denatured states of PYP and PYP(M) are indistinguishable, the configurations of the chromophores in their denatured structures are not necessarily identical. Both denatured states are interconvertible through PYP and PYP(M). Therefore, the free energy difference between PYP and PYP(M) is 3.4-3.7 kcal/mol for the protein moiety, plus the additional contribution from the difference in configuration of the chromophore.     

Resonance Raman spectroscopy and quantum chemical calculations reveal structural changes in the active site of photoactive yellow protein

Photoactive yellow protein (PYP) is a bacterial photoreceptor containing a 4-hydroxycinnamyl chromophore. Photoexcitation of PYP triggers a photocycle that involves at least two intermediate states: an early red-shifted PYP(L) intermediate and a long-lived blue-shifted PYP(M) intermediate. In this study, we have explored the active site structures of these intermediates by resonance Raman spectroscopy. Quantum chemical calculations based on a density functional theory are also performed to simulate the observed spectra. The obtained structure of the chromophore in PYP(L) has cis configuration and no hydrogen bond at the carbonyl oxygen. In PYP(M), the cis chromophore is protonated at the phenolic oxygen and forms the hydrogen bond at the carbonyl group. These results allow us to propose structural changes of the chromophore during the photocycle of PYP. The chromophore photoisomerizes from trans to cis configuration by flipping the carbonyl group to form PYP(L) with minimal perturbation of the tightly packed protein interior. Subsequent conversion to PYP(M) involves protonation on the phenolic oxygen, followed by rotation of the chromophore as a whole. This large motion of the chromophore is potentially correlated with the succeeding global conformational changes in the protein, which ultimately leads to transduction of a biological signal.     

Early molecular events in the photoactive yellow protein: role of the chromophore photophysics.

We report a comparative study of the isomerization reaction in native and denatured photoactive yellow protein (PYP) and in various chromophore analogues in their trans deprotonated form. The excited-state relaxation dynamics was followed by subpicosecond transient absorption and gain spectroscopy. The free p-hydroxycinnamate (pCA(2-)) and its amide analogue (pCM(-)) are found to display a quite different transient spectroscopy from that of PYP. The excited-state deactivation leads to the formation of the ground-state cis isomer without any detectable intermediate with a mechanism comparable to trans-stilbene photoisomerization. On the contrary, the early stage of the excited-state deactivation of the free thiophenyl-p-hydroxycinnamate (pCT(-)) and of the denatured PYP is similar to that of the native protein. It involves the formation of an intermediate absorbing in the spectral region located between the bleaching and gain bands in less than 2 ps. However, in these two cases, the formation of the cis isomer has not been proved yet. This difference with pCA(-) and pCM(-) might result from the fact that, in the thioester substituted chromophore, simultaneous population of two quasi-degenerate excited states occurs upon excitation. This comparative study highlights the determining role of the chromophore structure and of its intrinsic properties in the primary molecular events in native PYP.     

Low-temperature Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy of photoactive yellow protein

The photocycle intermediates of photoactive yellow protein (PYP) were characterized by low-temperature Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. The difference FTIR spectra of PYP(B), PYP(H), PYP(L), and PYP(M) minus PYP were measured under the irradiation condition determined by UV-visible spectroscopy. Although the chromophore bands of PYP(B) were weak, intense sharp bands complementary to the 1163-cm(-1) band of PYP, which show the chromophore is deprotonated, were observed at 1168-1169 cm(-1) for PYP(H) and PYP(L), indicating that the proton at Glu46 is not transferred before formation of PYP(M). Free trans-p-coumaric acid had a 1294-cm(-1) band, which was shifted to 1288 cm(-1) in the cis form. All the difference FTIR spectra obtained had the pair of bands corresponding to them, indicating that all the intermediates have the chromophore in the cis configuration. The characteristic vibrational modes at 1020-960 cm(-1) distinguished the intermediates. Because these modes were shifted by deuterium-labeling at the ethylene bond of the chromophore while labeling at the phenol part had no effect, they were attributed to the ethylene bond region. Hence, structural differences among the intermediates are present in this region. Bands at about 1730 cm(-1), which show that Glu46 is protonated, were observed for all intermediates except for PYP(M). Because the frequency of this mode was constant in PYP(B), PYP(H), and PYP(L), the environment of Glu46 is conserved in these intermediates. The photocycle of PYP would therefore proceed by changing the structure of the twisted ethylene bond of the chromophore.     

Predicting the signaling state of photoactive yellow protein

As a bacterial blue light sensor the photoactive yellow protein (PYP) undergoes conformational changes upon signal transduction. The absorption of a photon triggers a series of events that are initially localized around the protein chromophore, extends to encompass the whole protein within microseconds, and leads to the formation of the transient pB signaling state. We study the formation of this signaling state pB by molecular simulation and predict its solution structure. Conventional straightforward molecular dynamics is not able to address this formation process due to the long (microsecond) timescales involved, which are (partially) caused by the presence of free energy barriers between the metastable states. To overcome these barriers, we employed the parallel tempering (or replica exchange) method, thus enabling us to predict qualitatively the formation of the PYP signaling state pB. In contrast to the receptor state pG of PYP, the characteristics of this predicted pB structure include a wide open chromophore-binding pocket, with the chromophore and Glu(46) fully solvent-exposed. In addition, loss of alpha-helical structure occurs, caused by the opening motion of the chromophore-binding pocket and the disruptive interaction of the negatively charged Glu(46) with the backbone atoms in the hydrophobic core of the N-terminal cap. Recent NMR experiments agree very well with these predictions.     

Ultrafast light-induced response of photoactive yellow protein chromophore analogues.

The fluorescence decays of several analogues of the photoactive yellow protein (PYP) chromophore in aqueous solution have been measured by femtosecond fluorescence up-conversion and the corresponding time-resolved fluorescence spectra have been reconstructed. The native chromophore of PYP is a thioester derivative of p-coumaric acid in its trans deprotonated form. Fluorescence kinetics are reported for a thioester phenyl analogue and for two analogues where the thioester group has been changed to amide and carboxylate groups. The kinetics are compared to those we previously reported for the analogues bearing ketone and ester groups. The fluorescence decays of the full series are found to lie in the 1-10 ps range depending on the electron-acceptor character of the substituent, in good agreement with the excited-state relaxation kinetics extracted from transient absorption measurements. Steady-state photolysis is also examined and found to depend strongly on the nature of the substituent. While it has been shown that the ultrafast light-induced response of the chromophore in PYP is controlled by the properties of the protein nanospace, the present results demonstrate that, in solution, the relaxation dynamics and pathway of the chromophore is controlled by its electron donor-acceptor structure: structures of stronger electron donor-acceptor character lead to faster decays and less photoisomerisation.     

The crystal structure of the R52Q mutant demonstrates a role for R52 in chromophore pKa regulation in photoactive yellow protein

Mutating arginine 52 to glutamine (R52Q) in photoactive yellow protein (PYP) increases the pK(a) of the chromophore by 1 pH unit. The structure of the R52Q PYP mutant was determined by X-ray crystallography and was compared to the structure of wild-type PYP to assess the role of R52 in pK(a) regulation. The essential differences between R52Q and the wild type were confined to the loop region containing the 52nd residue. While the hydrogen bonds involving the chromophore were unchanged by the mutation, removing the guanidino group generated a cavity near the chromophore; this cavity is occupied by two water molecules. In the wild type, R52 forms hydrogen bonds with T50 and Y98; these hydrogen bonds are lost in R52Q. Q52 is linked to Y98 by hydrogen bonding through the two water molecules. R52 acts as a lid on the chromophore binding pocket and controls the accessibility of the exterior solvent and the pK(a) of the chromophore. R52 is found to flip out during the formation of PYP(M). The result of this movement is quite similar to the altered structure of R52Q. Thus, we propose that conformational changes at R52 are partly responsible for pK(a) regulation during the photocycle.     

Signal transduction in the photoactive yellow protein. I. Photon absorption and the isomerization of the chromophore

Molecular dynamics simulation techniques together with time-dependent density functional theory calculations have been used to investigate the effect of photon absorption by a 4-hydroxy-cinnamic acid chromophore on the structural properties of the photoactive yellow protein (PYP) from Ectothiorodospira halophila. The calculations suggest that the protein not only modifies the absorption spectrum of the chromophore but also regulates the subsequent isomerization of the chromophore by stabilizing the isomerization transition state. Although signaling from PYP is thought to involve partial unfolding of the protein, the mechanical effects accompanying isomerization do not appear to directly destabilize the protein.     

Formation of a new buried charge drives a large-amplitude protein quake in photoreceptor activation

Photoactive yellow protein (PYP) is a eubacterial photoreceptor and a structural prototype of the PAS domain superfamily of receptor and regulatory proteins. We investigate the activation mechanism of PYP using time-resolved Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy. Our data provide structural, kinetic, and energetic evidence that the putative signaling state of PYP is formed during a large-amplitude protein quake that is driven by the formation of a new buried charge, COO(-) of the conserved Glu46, in a highly hydrophobic pocket at the active site. A protein quake is a process consisting of global conformational changes that are triggered and driven by a local structural "fault". We show that large, global structural changes take place after Glu46 ionization via intramolecular proton transfer to the anionic p-coumarate chromophore, and are suppressed by the absence of COO(-) formation in the E46Q mutant. Our results demonstrate the significance of buried charge formation in photoreceptor activation. This mechanism may serve as one of the general themes in activation of a range of receptor proteins. In addition, we report the results of time-resolved FTIR spectroscopy of PYP crystals. The direct comparison of time-resolved FTIR spectroscopic data of PYP in aqueous solution and in crystals reveals that the structure of the putative signaling state is not developed in P6(3) crystals. Therefore, when the structural developments during the functional process of a protein are experimentally determined to be very different in crystals and solutions, one must be cautious in drawing conclusions regarding the functional mechanism of proteins based on time-resolved X-ray crystallography.     

A structural pathway for signaling in the E46Q mutant of photoactive yellow protein

In the bacterial photoreceptor photoactive yellow protein (PYP), absorption of blue light by its chromophore leads to a conformational change in the protein associated with differential signaling activity, as it executes a reversible photocycle. Time-resolved Laue crystallography allows structural snapshots (as short as 150 ps) of high crystallographic resolution (approximately 1.6 A) to be taken of a protein as it functions. Here, we analyze by singular value decomposition a comprehensive time-resolved crystallographic data set of the E46Q mutant of PYP throughout the photocycle spanning 10 ns-100 ms. We identify and refine the structures of five distinct intermediates and provide a plausible chemical kinetic mechanism for their inter conversion. A clear structural progression is visible in these intermediates, in which a signal generated at the chromophore propagates through a distinct structural pathway of conserved residues and results in structural changes near the N terminus, over 20 A distant from the chromophore.     

Protonation/deprotonation reactions triggered by photoactivation of photoactive yellow protein from Ectothiorhodospira halophila.

Light-dependent pH changes were measured in unbuffered solutions of wild type photoactive yellow protein (PYP) and its H108F and E46Q variants, using two independent techniques: transient absorption changes of added pH indicator dyes and direct readings with a combination pH electrode. Depending on the absolute pH of the sample, a reversible protonation as well as a deprotonation can be observed upon formation of the transient, blue-shifted photocycle intermediate (pB) of this photoreceptor protein. The latter is observed at very alkaline pH, the former at acidic pH values. At neutral pH, however, the formation of the pB state is not paralleled by significant protonation/deprotonation of PYP, as expected for concomitant protonation of the chromophore and deprotonation of Glu-46 during pB formation. We interpret these results as further evidence that a proton is transferred from Glu-46 to the coumaric acid chromophore of PYP, during pB formation. One cannot exclude the possibility, however, that this transfer proceeds through the bulk aqueous phase. Simultaneously, an amino acid side chain(s) (e.g. His-108) changes from a buried to an exposed position. These results, therefore, further support the idea that PYP significantly unfolds in the pB state and resolve the controversy regarding proton transfer during the PYP photocycle.     

Mimic of photocycle by a protein folding reaction in photoactive yellow protein

The blue light receptor photoactive yellow protein (PYP) displays rhodopsin-like photochemistry based on the trans to cis photoisomerization of its p-coumaric acid chromophore. Here, we report that protein refolding from the acid-denatured state of PYP mimics the last photocycle transition in PYP. This implies a direct link between transient protein unfolding and photosensory signal transduction. We utilize this link to study general issues in protein folding. Chromophore trans to cis photoisomerization in the acid-denatured state strongly decelerates refolding, and converts the pH dependence of the barrier for refolding from linear to nonlinear. We propose transition state movement to explain this phenomenon. The cis chromophore significantly stabilizes the acid-denatured state, but acidification of PYP results in the accumulation of the acid-denatured state containing a trans chromophore. This provides a clear example of kinetic control in a protein unfolding reaction. These results demonstrate the power of PYP as a light-triggered model system to study protein folding.     

Water structural changes involved in the activation process of photoactive yellow protein

Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy was applied to the blue-light photoreceptor photoactive yellow protein (PYP) to investigate water structural changes possibly involved in the photocycle of PYP. Photointermediates were stabilized at low temperature, and difference IR spectra were obtained between intermediate states and the original state of PYP (pG). Water structural changes were never observed in the >3570 cm(-)(1) region for the intermediates stabilized at 77-250 K, such as the red-shifted pR and blue-shifted pB intermediates. In contrast, a negative band was observed at 3658 cm(-)(1) in the pB minus pG spectrum at 295 K, which shifts to 3648 cm(-)(1) upon hydration with H(2)(18)O. The high frequency of the O-H stretch of water indicates that the water O-H group does not form hydrogen bonds in pG, and newly forms these upon pB formation at 295 K, but not at 250 K. Among 92 water molecules in the crystal structure of PYP, only 1 water molecule, water-200, is present in a hydrophobic core inside the protein. The amide N-H of Gly-7 and the imidazole nitrogen atom of His-108 are its possible hydrogen-bonding partners, indicating that one O-H group of water-200 is free to form an additional hydrogen bond. The water band at 3658 cm(-)(1) was indeed diminished in the H108F protein, which strongly suggests that the water band originates from water-200. Structural changes of amide bands in pB were much greater in the wild-type protein at 295 K than at 250 K or in the H108F protein at 295 K. The position of water-200 is >15 A remote from the chromophore. Virtually no structural changes were reported for regions larger than a few angstroms away from the chromophore, in the time-resolved X-ray crystallography experiments on pB. On the basis of the present results, as well as other spectroscopic observations, we conclude that water-200 (buried in a hydrophobic core in pG) is exposed to the aqueous phase upon formation of pB in solution. In neither crystalline PYP nor at low temperature is this structural transition observed, presumably because of the restrictions on global structural changes in the protein under these conditions.     

Transient exposure of hydrophobic surface in the photoactive yellow protein monitored with Nile Red

In this study we have investigated binding of the fluorescent hydrophobicity probe Nile Red to the photoactive yellow protein (PYP), to characterize the exposure and accessibility of hydrophobic surface upon formation of the signaling state of this photoreceptor protein. Binding of Nile Red, reflected by a large blue shift and increase in fluorescence quantum yield of the Nile Red emission, is observed exclusively when PYP resides in its signaling state. N-terminal truncation of the protein allows assignment of the region surrounding the chromophore as the site where Nile Red binds to PYP. We also observed a pH dependence of the affinity of Nile Red for pB, which we propose is caused by pH dependent differences of the structure of the signaling state. From a comparative analysis of the kinetics of Nile Red binding and transient absorption changes in the visible region we can conclude that protonation of the chromophore precedes the exposure of a hydrophobic surface near the chromophore binding site, upon formation of the signaling state. Furthermore, the data presented here favor the view that the signaling state is structurally heterogeneous.     

pH dependence of the photoactive yellow protein photocycle investigated by time-resolved crystallography

Visualizing the three-dimensional structures of a protein during its biological activity is key to understanding its mechanism. In general, protein structure and function are pH-dependent. Changing the pH provides new insights into the mechanisms that are involved in protein activity. Photoactive yellow protein (PYP) is a signaling protein that serves as an ideal model for time-dependent studies on light-activated proteins. Its photocycle is studied extensively under different pH conditions. However, the structures of the intermediates remain unknown until time-resolved crystallography is employed. With the newest beamline developments, a comprehensive time series of Laue data can now be collected from a single protein crystal. This allows us to vary the pH. Here we present the first structure, to our knowledge, of a short-lived protein-inhibitor complex formed in the pB state of the PYP photocycle at pH 4. A water molecule that is transiently stabilized in the chromophore active site prevents the relaxation of the chromophore back to the trans configuration. As a result, the dark-state recovery is slowed down dramatically. At pH 9, PYP stops cycling through the pB state altogether. The electrostatic environment in the chromophore-binding site is the likely reason for this altered kinetics at different pH values.     

Site-specific mutations provide new insights into the origin of pH effects and alternative spectral forms in the photoactive yellow protein from Halorhodospira halophila

Acid/base titrations of wild-type PYP and mutants, either in buffer or in the presence of chaotropes such as thiocyanate, establish the presence of four spectral forms including the following: a neutral form (446-476 nm), an acidic form (350-355 nm), an alkaline form (430-440 nm), and an intermediate wavelength form (355-400 nm). The acidic species is formed by protonation of the oxyanion of the para-hydroxy-cinnamyl cysteine chromophore as a secondary result of acid denaturation (with pK(a) values of 2.8-5.4) and often results in precipitation of the protein, and in the case of wild-type PYP, eventual hydrolysis of the chromophore thioester bond at pH values below 2. Thus, the large and complex structural changes associated with the acidic species make it a poor model for the long-lived photocycle intermediate, I(2), which undergoes more moderate structural changes. Mutations at E46, which is hydrogen-bonded to the chromophore, have only two spectral forms accessible to them, the neutral and the acidic forms. Thus, an intact E46 carboxyl group is essential for observation of either intermediate or alkaline wavelength forms. The alkaline form is likely to be due to ionization of E46 in the folded protein. We postulate that the intermediate wavelength form is due to a conformational change that allows solvent access to E46 and formation of a hydrogen-bond from a water molecule to the carboxylic acid group, thus weakening its interaction with the chromophore. Increasing solvent access to the intermediate spectral form with denaturant concentration results in a continuously blue-shifted wavelength maximum.     

Characterization of the solution structure of the M intermediate of photoactive yellow protein using high-angle solution x-ray scattering

It is widely accepted that PYP undergoes global structural changes during the formation of the biologically active intermediate PYP(M). High-angle solution x-ray scattering experiments were performed using PYP variants that lacked the N-terminal 6-, 15-, or 23-amino-acid residues (T6, T15, and T23, respectively) to clarify these structural changes. The scattering profile of the dark state of intact PYP exhibited two broad peaks in the high-angle region (0.3 A(-1) < Q < 0.8 A(-1)). The intensities and positions of the peaks were systematically changed as a result of the N-terminal truncations. These observations and the agreement between the observed scattering profiles and the calculated profiles based on the crystal structure confirm that the high-angle scattering profiles were caused by intramolecular interference and that the structure of the chromophore-binding domain was not affected by the N-terminal truncations. The profiles of the PYP(M) intermediates of the N-terminally truncated PYP variants were significantly different from the profiles of the dark states of these proteins, indicating that substantial conformational rearrangements occur within the chromophore-binding domain during the formation of PYP(M). By use of molecular fluctuation analysis, structural models of the chromophore-binding region of PYP(M) were constructed to reproduce the observed profile of T23. The structure obtained by averaging 51 potential models revealed the displacement of the loop connecting beta4 and beta5, and the deformation of the alpha4 helix. High-angle x-ray scattering with molecular fluctuation simulation allows us to derive the structural properties of the transient state of a protein in solution.     

Signal transduction in the photoactive yellow protein. II. Proton transfer initiates conformational changes

Molecular dynamics simulation techniques, together with semiempirical PM3 calculations, have been used to investigate the effect of photoisomerization of the 4-hydroxy-cinnamic acid chromophore on the structural properties of the photoactive yellow protein (PYP) from Ectothiorodospira halophila. In this bacteria, exposure to blue light leads to a negative photoactic response. The calculations suggest that the isomerization does not directly destabilize the protein. However, because of the isomerization, a proton transfer from a glutamic acid residue (Glu46) to the phenolate oxygen atom of the chromophore becomes energetically favorable. The proton transfer initiates conformational changes within the protein, which are in turn believed to lead to signaling.     

A role of methionine 100 in facilitating PYP(M)-decay process in the photocycle of photoactive yellow protein

PYP (photoactive yellow protein) is a photoreceptor protein, which is activated upon photo-isomerization of the p-coumaric acid chromophore and is inactivated as the chromophore is thermally back-isomerized within a second (in PYP(M)-to-PYP(dark) conversion). Here we have examined the mechanism of the rapid thermal isomerization by analyzing mutant PYPs of Met100, which was previously shown to play a major role in facilitating the reaction [Devanathan, S. et al. (1998) Biochemistry 37, 11563-11568]. The mutation to Lys, Leu, Ala, or Glu decelerated the dark state recovery by one to three orders of magnitude. By evaluating temperature-dependence of the kinetics, it was found that the retardation resulted unequivocally from elevations of activation enthalpy (DeltaH( double dagger )) but not the other parameters such as activation entropy or heat capacity changes. Another effect exerted by the mutations was an up-shift of the apparent pK(a) of the chromophore [the pK(a) of a titratable group (X) that controls the pK(a) of the chromophore] in the PYP(M)-decay process. The pK(a) up-shift and the DeltaH( double dagger ) elevation show an approximately linear correlation. We, therefore, postulate that the role of Met100 is to reduce the energy barrier of the PYP(M)-decay process by an indirect interaction through X and that the process is thereby facilitated.