Multiplex amplification enabled by selective circularization of large sets of genomic DNA fragments

We present a method to specifically select large sets of DNA sequences for parallel amplification by PCR using target-specific oligonucleotide constructs, so-called selectors. The selectors are oligonucleotide duplexes with single-stranded target-complementary end-sequences that are linked by a general sequence motif. In the selection process, a pool of selectors is combined with denatured restriction digested DNA. Each selector hybridizes to its respective target, forming individual circular complexes that are covalently closed by enzymatic ligation. Non-circularized fragments are removed by exonucleolysis, enriching for the selected fragments. The general sequence that is introduced into the circularized fragments allows them to be amplified in parallel using a universal primer pair. The procedure avoids amplification artifacts associated with conventional multiplex PCR where two primers are used for each target, thereby reducing the number of amplification reactions needed for investigating large sets of DNA sequences. We demonstrate the specificity, reproducibility and flexibility of this process by performing a 96-plex amplification of an arbitrary set of specific DNA sequences, followed by hybridization to a cDNA microarray. Eighty-nine percent of the selectors generated PCR products that hybridized to the expected positions on the array, while little or no amplification artifacts were observed.     

A PCR-based amplification method retaining the quantitative difference between two complex genomes

With the increasing emergence of genome-wide analysis technologies (including comparative genomic hybridization (CGH), expression profiling on microarrays, differential display (DD), subtractive hybridization, and representational difference analysis (RDA)), there is frequently a need to amplify entire genomes or cDNAs by PCR to obtain enough material for comparisons among target and control samples. A major problem with PCR is that amplification occurs in a nonlinear manner and reproducibility is influenced by stray impurities. As a result, when two complex DNA populations are amplified separately, the quantitative relationship between two genes after amplification is generally not the same as their relation before amplification. Here we describe balanced PCR, a procedure that faithfully retains the difference among corresponding amplified genes by using a simple principle. Two distinct genomic DNA samples are tagged with oligonucleotides containing both a common and a unique DNA sequence. The genomic DNA samples are pooled and amplified in a single PCR tube using the common DNA tag. By mixing the two genomes, PCR loses the ability to discriminate among the different alleles and the influence of impurities is eliminated. The PCR-amplified pooled samples can be separated using the DNA tag unique to each individual genomic DNA sample. The principle of this method has been validated with synthetic DNA, genomic DNA, and cDNA applied on microarrays. By removing the bias of PCR, this method allows a balanced amplification of allelic fragments from two complex DNAs even after three sequential rounds of PCR. This balanced PCR approach should allow genetic analysis in minute laser-microdissected tissues, paraffin-embedded archived material, or single cells.     

The Isolation of differentially expressed mRNA sequences by selective amplification via biotin and restriction-mediated enrichment

Molecular analysis of development frequently implies the isolation and characterization of genes with specific spatial and temporal expression patterns. Several methods have been developed to identify such DNA sequences. The most comprehensive technique involves the genomewide probing of DNA sequence microarrays with mRNA sequences. However, at present this technology is limited to the few organisms for which the entire genome has been sequenced. Here, we describe a subtractive hybridization technique, called selective amplification via biotin and restriction-mediated enrichment (SABRE), which allows the selective amplification of cDNA fragments representing differentially expressed mRNA species. The method involves the competitive hybridization of an excess of driver cDNA fragments (D) to a trace of tester cDNA fragments (T), and the subsequent purification of tester homohybrids (in which both strands are contributed by the tester cDNA). After competitive hybridization, cDNA fragments that are more abundant in the tester than in the driver are enriched in the tester homohybrids. However, as the fraction of tester homohybrids is very small [T(2)/(D + T)(2)], their purification requires highly efficient procedures. In SABRE, the isolation of tester homohybrids is afforded by a combination of three successive steps: removal of biotinylated terminal sequences from most of the heterohybrids by S1 nuclease digestion, capture of biotinylated hybrids with streptavidin-coated paramagnetic beads, and specific release of homohybrids from the beads by restriction nuclease digestion. If several rounds of SABRE selection are performed in series, even relatively rare differentially expressed mRNA sequences may result in the production of predominant cDNA fragments in the final tester homohybrid population.     

A family of lambda phage cDNA cloning vectors, lambda SWAJ, allowing the amplification of RNA sequences

This paper describes the construction and characterization of a family of lambda phage cDNA cloning vectors that allows high-efficiency directional cDNA cloning and selective amplification of either sense or antisense cRNA sequences. These vectors contain several unique restriction sites (EcoRI, XbaI, and SacI) positioned between two specific phage promoters, SP6 and T7. This system facilitates the in vitro preparation of single-stranded (ss) RNA molecules that should be useful in subtractive hybridization and in situ hybridization procedures. Using subtractive hybridization and this vector system, it should be possible to identify sequences present in one cDNA library and not another. In addition, it should be possible to construct subtracted cDNA libraries in these vectors and to generate high specific activity, ss, antisense cRNA probes directly from DNA prepared from the whole subtracted library or from individual clones.     

Maize DNA enrichment by representational difference analysis in a maize chromosome addition line of oat

 The recent recovery of maize (Zea mays L.) single-chromosome addition lines of oat (Avena sativa L.) from oat x maize crosses has provided novel source materials for the potential isolation of maize chromosome-specific sequences for use in genetic mapping and gene cloning. We report here the application of a technique, known as representational difference analysis (RDA), to selectively isolate maize sequences from a maize chromosome-3 addition line of oat. DNA fragments from the addition line and from the oat parent were prepared using BamHI digestion and primer ligation followed by PCR amplification. A subtractive hybridization technique using an excess of the oat parental DNA was employed to reduce the availability for amplification of DNA fragments from the addition lines that were in common with the ones from the oat parental line. After three rounds of hybridization and amplification, the resulting DNA fragments were cloned into a plasmid vector. A DNA library containing 400 clones was constructed by this method. In a test of 18 clones selected at random from this library, four (22%) detected maize-specific repetitive DNA sequences and nine (50%) showed strong hybridization to genomic DNA of maize but weak hybridization to genomic DNA of oat. Among these latter nine clones, three detected low-copy DNA sequences and two of them detected DNA sequences specific to chromosome 3 of maize, the chromosome retained in the source maize addition line of oat. The other eight out of the 13 clones that had strong hybridization to maize DNA detected repetitive DNA sequences or high-copy number sequences present on most or all maize chromosomes. We estimate that the maize DNA sequences were enriched from about 1.8% to over 72% of the total DNA by this procedure. Most of the isolated DNA fragments detected multiple or repeated DNA sequences in maize, indicating that the major part of the maize genome consists of repetitive DNA sequences that do not cross-hybridize to oat genomic sequences. Received: 18 November 1997 / Accepted: 12 March 1998     

Amplification of CFTR Exon 9 Sequences to Multiple Locations in the Human Genome

Cloning and characterization of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene led to the identification and isolation of cDNA and genomic sequences that cross-hybridized to the first nucleotide binding fold of CFTR. DNA sequence analysis of these clones showed that the cross-hybridizing sequences corresponded to CFTR exon 9 and its flanking introns, juxtapositioned with two segments of LINE1 sequences. The CFTR sequence appeared to have been transcribed from the opposite direction of the gene, reversely transcribed, and co-integrated with the L1 sequences into a chromosome location distinct from that of the CFTR locus. Based on hybridization intensity and complexity of the restriction fragments, it was estimated that there were at least 10 copies of the “amplified” CFTR exon 9 sequences in the human genome. Furthermore, when DNA segments adjacent to the insertion site were used in genomic DNA blot hybridization analysis, multiple copies were also detected. The overall similarity between these CFTR exon 9-related sequences suggested that they were derived from a single retrotransposition event and subsequent sequence amplification. The amplification unit appeared to be greater than 30 kb. Physical mapping studies includingin situhybridization to human metaphase chromosomes showed that multiple copies of these amplified sequences (with and without the CFTR exon 9 insertion) were dispersed throughout the genome. These findings provide insight into the structure and evolution of the human genome.     

The gene for ornithine decarboxylase is co-amplified in hydroxyurea-resistant hamster cells

We have constructed a cDNA library from the highly hydroxyurea-resistant hamster cell line 600H in which the activity of ribonucleotide reductase is elevated more than 80-fold. Using the technique of differential hybridization, we have isolated a number of cDNA clones from this library which are homologous to genomic DNA sequences amplified in the 600H cell line compared to the V79 parental line. One of these cDNA clones by sequence analysis was found to code for ornithine decarboxylase. This was confirmed by in vitro translation of poly(A+) RNA isolated by hybridization-selection followed by immunoprecipitation with antiserum specific for mouse ornithine decarboxylase. Genomic sequences homologous to the cDNA clone were shown to be sequentially amplified 6-20-fold in hamster cell lines selected stepwise for resistance to increasing concentrations of hydroxyurea. Genomic sequences homologous to a cDNA for the M2 subunit of ribonucleotide reductase were also amplified in these cell lines, and the degree of M2 sequence amplification corresponded to the degree of amplification of ornithine decarboxylase sequences, suggesting that the two genes had been co-amplified during the selection of the hydroxyurea-resistant phenotype.     

A kinetic model for subtractive hybridization.

Nucleic acid sequences that differ in abundance between two populations (target sequences) can be cloned by multiple rounds of subtractive hybridization and amplification by PCR. These sequences can be cDNAs representing up-regulated mRNAs, or genomic DNAs from deletion mutants. We have derived an equation that describes the recovery of such sequences, and have used this to simulate the outcome of up to 10 rounds of subtractive hybridization and PCR amplification. When the model was tested by comparing its predictions with the published results from genomic and cDNA subtractions, the predictions of the model were generally in good agreement with the published data. We have modelled the outcomes of genomic subtractions, for a variety of genomes, and have used it to compare various strategies for enriching targets. The model predicts that for genomes of less than 5 x 10(8) bp, deletions of as small as 1 kbp should represent > 99% of the DNA after three to six rounds of hybridization (depending on the enrichment procedure). As genomes increase in size, the kinetics of hybridization become an important limiting factor. However, even for genomes as large as 3 x 10(9) bp, it should be possible to isolate deletions of 5 kbp using the appropriate conditions. These simulations suggest that such methods offer a realistic alternative to chromosome walking for identifying genomic deletions for which there are known phenotypes, thereby considerably reducing time and effort. For cDNA subtractive hybridization, the model predicts that after six rounds of hybridization, sequences that do not differ in abundance between the tester and driver populations (the background) will represent < 1% of the subtracted population, and even quite modestly upregulated cDNAs should be successfully enriched. Where several up-regulated cDNAs are present, the predicted final representation is dependent on both the initial abundance and the degree of up-regulation.     

A novel method to isolate the common fraction of two DNA samples: hybrid specific amplification (HSA)

Hybrid specific amplification (HSA) is a novel simple method elaborated in order to isolate the common fraction of two DNA samples while avoiding the background due to repeated sequences. The method is based on the suppressive PCR principle, associated with a Cot1 pre-hybridization step. In recent work we demonstrated that hyperprolificity observed in Booroola ewes is associated with a mutation in the bone morphogenetic protein receptor IB gene (BMPR-IB). We applied HSA between ovarian cDNA and DNA from four BAC clones containing BMPR-IB in order to test for the presence of other genes expressed in ovary and to isolate additional BMPR-IB exon sequences. Of the 460 clones obtained, none contained repeated sequences. We successfully obtained 37 clones representing the major part of BMPR-IB coding sequence, together with 5′- and 3′-UTR sequences. Here we have successfully applied HSA to a particular tissue, but it should be possible to trap the common fraction of two DNA samples, whatever their nature.     

Improving specificity of DNA hybridization-based methods

Methods based on DNA reassociation in solution with the subsequent PCR amplification of certain hybrid molecules, such as coincidence cloning and subtractive hybridization, all suffer from a common imperfection: cross-hybridization between various types of paralogous repetitive DNA fragments. Although the situation can be slightly improved by the addition of repeat-specific competitor DNA into the hybridization mixture, the cross-hybridization outcome is a significant number of background chimeric clones in resulting DNA libraries. In order to overcome this challenge, we developed a technique called mispaired DNA rejection (MDR), which utilizes a treatment of resulting reassociated DNA with mismatch-specific nucleases. We examined the MDR efficiency using cross-hybridization of complex, whole genomic mixtures derived from human and chimpanzee genomes, digested with frequent-cutter restriction enzyme. We show here that both single-stranded DNA-specific and mismatched double-stranded DNA-specific nucleases can be used for MDR separately or in combination, reducing the background level from 60 to 4% or lower. The technique presented here is of universal usefulness and can be applied to both cDNA and genomic DNA subtractions of very complex DNA mixtures. MDR is also useful for the genome-wide recovery of highly conserved DNA sequences, as we demonstrate by comparing human and pygmy marmoset genomes.     

Sequences homologous to glutamic acid decarboxylase cDNA are present on mouse chromosomes 2 and 10

The chromosomal locations of mouse DNA sequences homologous to a feline cDNA clone encoding glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) were determined. Although cats and humans are thought to have only one gene for GAD, GAD cDNA sequences hybridize to two distinct chromosomal loci in the mouse, chromosomes 2 and 10. The chromosomal assignment of sequences homologous to GAD cDNA was determined by Southern hybridization analysis using DNA from mouse-hamster hybrid cells. Mouse genomic sequences homologous to GAD cDNA were isolated and used to determine that GAD is encoded by a locus on mouse chromosome 2 (Gad-1) and that an apparent pseudogene locus is on chromosome 10 (Gad-1ps). An interspecific backcross and recombinant inbred strain sets were used to map these two loci relative to other loci on their respective chromosomes. The Gad-1 locus is part of a conserved homology between mouse chromosome 2 and the long arm of human chromosome 2.     

Isolation of a large number of novel mammalian genes by a differential cDNA library screening strategy.

As part of the ongoing human and mouse genome projects, the aim of this study was to isolate novel, previously uncharacterized, genes from mouse testis. Two approaches were compared for their effectiveness in isolating novel genes: random, vs differential, complementary DNA (cDNA) cloning methods. In the differential approach, only the cDNA clones containing rare sequences (as determined by preliminary clone hybridization) are further analyzed; in the random approach, cDNA clones are isolated at random from the cDNA library. More than two hundred cDNA clones altogether were analyzed, using a PCR-mediated amplification and sequencing strategy. A comparison of these sequences to nucleic acid and protein sequence databases, revealed that 84% of the isolated rare cDNA clones represented new, previously uncharacterized mouse genes. In contrast, less than 63% of the cDNA clones isolated at random from cDNA libraries, contained novel genes. Thus, the probability of isolating new, previously uncharacterized, mammalian genes from cDNA libraries can be markedly improved by focusing efforts on clones containing rare sequences.     

Amplification of the UMP synthase gene and enzyme overproduction in pyrazofurin-resistant rat hepatoma cells. Molecular cloning of a cDNA for UMP synthase

The levels of UMP synthase protein and mRNA are increased in rat hepatoma cells that have acquired resistance to pyrazofurin, a potent inhibitor of pyrimidine biosynthesis. A cDNA plasmid library was prepared from partially purified poly(A)+ mRNA isolated from the resistant cell line. Recombinant plasmids with inserts complementary to UMP synthase mRNA were selected by differential hybridization with cDNA prepared from wild type and resistant cell mRNA and analysis of hybrid-selected mRNA by in vitro translation reactions. One plasmid, pUMPS-2, contains a 850-base pair insert and was used to analyze UMP synthase gene sequences in the wild type and resistant cell lines. Blot hybridization of restricted genomic DNA demonstrated amplification of the UMP synthase gene in the resistant cells. The number of UMP synthase genes is increased 15-fold as determined by a modified dot hybridization procedure. Previous studies have shown that the resistant cells have a 16-fold increase in UMP synthase mRNA but a 40-fold increase in synthase activity (Suttle, D.P. (1983) J. Biol. Chem. 258, 7707-7713). To further investigate this discrepancy between the amount of increase in DNA and mRNA versus the increase in enzyme activity, we have determined the relative rate of synthesis and degradation of UMP synthase. The rate of synthesis was 13-fold faster in the resistant cells. The degradation rate was not significantly different between the two cell lines. These data indicate that gene amplification is the major factor contributing to the enzyme overproduction in the pyrazofurin-resistant cells.     

Identification of calconectin, a calcium-binding protein specifically expressed by the mantle of Pinctada margaritifera

Nacre or mother-of-pearl in the shell of Pinctada margaritifera is composed of 95-99% calcium carbonate and 1-5% organic matrix. In this study, we developed an original technique to characterize the genes differentially expressed in nacre-forming cells (NFC) by combining suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH), to establish a cDNA subtractive library, with rapid amplification of cDNA ends (RACE)-PCR. Seventy-two specific cDNA sequences have been obtained so far. These include a protein containing two EF-hand Ca2+-binding domains which was completely sequenced after amplification by RACE-PCR. Its specific expression as well as the specificity of the SSH method was confirmed by semi-quantitative RT-PCR on NFC and mantle cells.     

Colorimetric detection of the tuberculosis complex using cycling probe technology and hybridization in microplates

Cycling probe technology (CPT) is a simple signal amplification method for the detection of specific target DNA sequences. CPT uses a chimeric DNA-RNA-DNA probe that is cut by RNase H when bound to its complementary target sequence. In this study, a hybridization assay was developed to detect biotinylated CPT products that result from the amplification of a Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex sequence. The chimeric probe was specifically designed to avoid the formation of secondary structures. The chosen capture probe was perfectly complementary to and was the same size as OL2, one of the two CPT products. The assay was based on the observation that a long sequence, such as the initial probe, was destabilized when bound to a small capture probe as a result of steric hindrance. The capture probe preferentially bound OL2 rather than the long initial probe. We added a prehybridization step with a helper DNA to enhance this discrimination between the two sequences. Colorimetric detection was performed using a peroxidase-streptavidin conjugate. After optimization, the non-isotopic hybridization assay allowed the detection of around 10 amol of target DNA. Besides being faster and easier to perform, this detection method was compared to electrophoresis separation and gave similar results.