Gilbert's conjecture: the search for DNA (cytosine-5) demethylases and the emergence of new functions for eukaryotic DNA (cytosine-5) methyltransferases

In 1985 Walter Gilbert challenged members of the DNA methylation community assembled at a National Institutes of Health meeting organized by Giulio Cantoni and Ahron Razin with the following words: "The most exciting aspect about the methyl groups on DNA is the thought that they might provide a locally inherited change in a DNA structure. However, for that to be interesting, those changes have to be different in different cells. Furthermore, the alterations in methylation have to be freely imposable and have to be maintained. It is not yet clear that all these properties are true. So I don't think one will find that methylation ever is one of the primary, top-level controls on gene expression."In essence, Gilbert's conjecture, that DNA methylation is not one of the top-level controls on gene expression, assumes that evidence in favor of both of its testable propositions will not be obtained. Evidence for the first proposition, that alterations in methylation status associated with gene-expression states have to be maintained, was already available in 1985 and has been strengthened by a number of very recent experiments. However, the extensive effort to obtain evidence for the second proposition, that alterations in methylation status be freely imposable, has not been successful in its original intent. The effort has, on the other hand, resulted in the emergence of new functions for 5-methylcytosine and the cytosine methyltransferases in eukaryotic DNA repair, recombination and chromosome stability.     

Roles,and establishment,maintenance and erasing of the epigenetic cytosine methylation marks in plants

Heritable information in plants consists of genomic information in DNA sequence and epigenetic information superimposed on DNA sequence. The latter is in the form of cytosine methylation at CG, CHG and CHH elements (where H = A, T or C) and a variety of histone modifications in nucleosomes. The epialleles arising from cytosine methylation marks on the nuclear genomic loci have better heritability than the epiallelic variation due to chromatin marks. Phenotypic variation is increased manifold by epiallele comprised methylomes. Plants (angiosperms) have highly conserved genetic mechanisms to establish, maintain or erase cytosine methylation from epialleles. The methylation marks in plants fluctuate according to the cell/tissue/organ in the vegetative and reproductive phases of plant life cycle. They also change according to environment. Epialleles arise by gain or loss of cytosine methylation marks on genes. The changes occur due to the imperfection of the processes that establish and maintain the marks and on account of spontaneous and stress imposed removal of marks. Cytosine methylation pattern acquired in response to abiotic or biotic stress is often inherited over one to several subsequent generations. Cytosine methylation marks affect physiological functions of plants via their effect(s) on gene expression levels. They also repress transposable elements that are abundantly present in plant genomes. The density of their distribution along chromosome lengths affects meiotic recombination rate, while their removal increases mutation rate. Transposon activation due to loss of methylation causes rearrangements such that new gene regulatory networks arise and genes for microRNAs may originate. Cytosine methylation dynamics contribute to evolutionary changes. This review presents and discusses the available evidence on origin, removal and roles of cytosine methylation and on related processes, such as RNA directed DNA methylation, imprinting, paramutation and transgenerational memory in plants.     

A gene required for very short patch repair in Escherichia coli is adjacent to the DNA cytosine methylase gene.

Deamination of 5-methylcytosine in DNA results in T/G mismatches. If unrepaired, these mismatches can lead to C-to-T transition mutations. The very short patch (VSP) repair process in Escherichia coli counteracts the mutagenic process by repairing the mismatches in favor of the G-containing strand. Previously we have shown that a plasmid containing an 11-kilobase fragment from the E. coli chromosome can complement a chromosomal mutation defective in both cytosine methylation and VSP repair. We have now mapped the regions essential for the two phenotypes. In the process, we have constructed plasmids that complement the chromosomal mutation for methylation, but not for repair, and vice versa. The genes responsible for these phenotypes have been identified by DNA sequence analysis. The gene essential for cytosine methylation, dcm, is predicted to code for a 473-amino-acid protein and is not required for VSP repair. It is similar to other DNA cytosine methylases and shares extensive sequence similarity with its isoschizomer, EcoRII methylase. The segment of DNA essential for VSP repair contains a gene that should code for a 156-amino-acid protein. This gene, named vsr, is not essential for DNA methylation. Remarkably, the 5' end of this gene appears to overlap the 3' end of dcm. The two genes appear to be transcribed from a common promoter but are in different translational registers. This gene arrangement may assure that Vsr is produced along with Dcm and may minimize the mutagenic effects of cytosine methylation.     

Biochemical and physical characterization of exonuclease V from Escherichia coli. Comparison of the catalytic activities of the RecBC and RecBCD enzymes

Biochemical evidence is presented that confirms exonuclease V of Escherichia coli consists of three distinct subunits encoded by the recB, recC, and recD genes. The recD gene encodes a Mr 60,000 polypeptide and physically maps 3' to the recB structural gene. The role of the recD subunit in exonuclease V function has been examined by comparing the catalytic activities of the purified RecBCD enzyme with the RecBC enzyme. The RecBC enzyme retains significant levels of DNA-dependent ATPase activity and DNA helicase activity. Endonucleolytic activity on single-stranded covalently closed DNA becomes ATP-dependent. Exonucleolytic activity on either single- and double-stranded DNA was not detected. Taken together with the phenotypic properties of recD null mutants, it appears that the exonucleolytic activities of the RecBCD enzyme are not required for genetic recombination and the repair of either UV-induced photoproducts or mitomycin C-generated DNA cross-links, but are essential for the repair of methyl methanesulfonate-induced methylation.     

Gene conversion in Escherichia coli. Resolution of heteroallelic mismatched nucleotides by co-repair

We have constructed heteroduplex plasmid DNA that is similar in structure to the heteroduplex DNA expected to be produced during genetic recombination of plasmids, and studied its repair after transformation into different Escherichia coli strains. The heteroduplex DNA was constructed using two different parental plasmids, each of which contained a different ten-nucleotide insertion mutation. The effect of different defined states of dam-methylation on repair was also examined. We found that heteroduplex DNA repair occurred prior to the replication of the substrate DNA 60 to 80% of the time, regardless of the state of DNA methylation. Most excision/synthesis tracts covered two markers separated by 1243 base-pairs, and this process has been termed co-repair. The most efficient co-repair pathway was the Dam-instructed repair pathway that required the mutH, mutL, mutS and uvrD gene products and preferentially used the methylated strand as the template for DNA synthesis. If there was no methylation asymmetry, mismatch nucleotide repair occurred with a similar frequency; however, no strand bias was observed. Co-repair of symmetrically methylated heteroduplex DNA required the mutS and uvrD gene products, while repair of unmethylated heteroduplex DNA also required the mutL and mutH gene products.     

Active DNA demethylation and DNA repair

DNA methylation on cytosine is an epigenetic modification and is essential for gene regulation and genome stability in vertebrates. Traditionally DNA methylation was considered as the most stable of all heritable epigenetic marks. However, it has become clear that DNA methylation is reversible by enzymatic “active” DNA demethylation, with examples in plant cells, animal development and immune cells. It emerges that “pruning” of methylated cytosines by active DNA demethylation is an important determinant for the DNA methylation signature of a cell. Work in plants and animals shows that demethylation occurs by base excision and nucleotide excision repair. Far from merely protecting genomic integrity from environmental insult, DNA repair is therefore at the heart of an epigenetic activation process.     

酵母模式生物研究表观遗传调控基因组稳定性的进展

基因组的遗传稳定性是维持正常的细胞复制、增殖和分化的关键。外源因素和内源因素造成的DNA损伤及其修复失败, 是各种遗传疾病发生的根本原因。表观遗传调控(包括DNA甲基化、组蛋白修饰和非编码RNA)在DNA损伤修复和细胞周期调控方面发挥着重要的作用, 也是维持基因组稳定性的基础。酵母作为单细胞真核生物, 是最早开展表观遗传学研究的物种之一, 特别是在DNA损伤修复和异染色质形成等方面的研究, 为揭示遗传稳定性的本质提供了理论依据。国际上前期以酵母为模式生物研究表观遗传学的报道主要集中于组蛋白修饰领域; 近期利用裂殖酵母作为模式生物研究RNAi指导的组蛋白修饰也有了一定的进展。文章以酵母作为模式生物, 论述了表观遗传修饰在维持基因组遗传稳定性中的研究进展、作用机制和今后的发展趋势。     

Removal of N-6-methyladenine by the nucleotide excision repair pathway triggers the repair of mismatches in yeast gap-repair intermediates

Gap-repair assays have been an important tool for studying the genetic control of homologous recombination in yeast. Sequence analysis of recombination products derived when a gapped plasmid is diverged relative to the chromosomal repair template additionally has been used to infer structures of strand-exchange intermediates. In the absence of the canonical mismatch repair pathway, mismatches present in these intermediates are expected to persist and segregate at the next round of DNA replication. In a mismatch repair defective (mlh1Δ) background, however, we have observed that recombination-generated mismatches are often corrected to generate gene conversion or restoration events. In the analyses reported here, the source of the aberrant mismatch removal during gap repair was examined. We find that most mismatch removal is linked to the methylation status of the plasmid used in the gap-repair assay. Whereas more than half of Dam-methylated plasmids had patches of gene conversion and/or restoration interspersed with unrepaired mismatches, mismatch removal was observed in less than 10% of products obtained when un-methylated plasmids were used in transformation experiments. The methylation-linked removal of mismatches in recombination intermediates was due specifically to the nucleotide excision repair pathway, with such mismatch removal being partially counteracted by glycosylases of the base excision repair pathway. These data demonstrate that nucleotide excision repair activity is not limited to bulky, helix-distorting DNA lesions, but also targets removal of very modest perturbations in DNA structure. In addition to its effects on mismatch removal, methylation reduced the overall gap-repair efficiency, but this reduction was not affected by the status of excision repair pathways. Finally, gel purification of DNA prior to transformation reduced gap-repair efficiency four-fold in a nucleotide excision repair-defective background, indicating that the collateral introduction of UV damage can potentially compromise genetic interpretations.     

Methylation in eucaryotes influences the repair of G/T and A/C DNA basepair mismatches

Although methylation of DNA at some sites regulates gene expression, 5mC at many sites does not appear to have any effect. We present evidence that hemimethylation at many different sites can act as a discrimination signal in mismatch repair. Deamination of 5mC in a symmetrically methylated doublet CpG yields the mismatched base pair T/G in a hemi-methylated doublet pair. Because both bases in the mismatched pair are normal constituents of DNA, identifying the incorrect base is problematic. The only apparent distinction of the two is the methylation on the strand opposite the deamination event. Using available methylases we have produced hemi-methylated SV40 DNAs that are mismatched at a single T/G or A/C basepair in a sequence that mimics the lesion resulting from the deamination of a 5mCpG. Methylation at the adjacent cytosine results in the replacement of the T much more frequently than when no methylation is present in the heteroduplex. Cytosine methylation at sites farther removed from the mismatch is equally effective in replacing the incorrect T at the mismatch. Although methylation in vertebrates is almost exclusively on cytosine in the doublet CpG, methylation of cytosines in other doublets, as well as methylation of adenosine, also act as strand discrimination signals. Perhaps some of the excess methylation in vertebrate DNAs may serve to direct mismatch repair.     

DNA excision repair proteins and Gadd45 as molecular players for active DNA demethylation

DNA cytosine methylation represents an intrinsic modification signal of the genome that plays important roles in heritable gene silencing, heterochromatin formation and certain transgenerational epigenetic inheritance. In contrast to the process of DNA methylation that is catalyzed by specific classes of methyltransferases, molecular players underlying active DNA demethylation have long been elusive. Emerging biochemical and functional evidence suggests that active DNA demethylation in vertebrates can be mediated through DNA excision repair enzymes, similar to the well-known repair-based DNA demethylation mechanism in Arabidopsis. As key regulators, non-enzymatic Gadd45 proteins function to recruit enzymatic machineries and promote coupling of deamination, base and nucleotide-excision repair in the process of DNA demethylation. In this article, we review recent findings and discuss functional and evolutionary implications of such mechanisms underlying active DNA demethylation.     

Recombinogenic phenotype of human activation-induced cytosine deaminase

Class switch recombination, gene conversion, and somatic hypermutation that diversify rearranged Ig genes to produce various classes of high affinity Abs are dependent on the enzyme activation-induced cytosine deaminase (AID). Evidence suggests that somatic hypermutation is due to error-prone DNA repair that is initiated by AID-mediated deamination of cytosine in DNA, whereas the mechanism by which AID controls recombination remains to be elucidated. In this study, using a yeast model system, we have observed AID-dependent recombination. Expression of human AID in wild-type yeast is mutagenic for G-C to A-T transitions, and as expected, this mutagenesis is increased upon inactivation of uracil-DNA glycosylase. AID expression also strongly induces intragenic mitotic recombination, but only in a strain possessing uracil-DNA glycosylase. Thus, the initial step of base excision repair is required for AID-dependent recombination and is a branch point for either hypermutagenesis or recombination.     

DNA methylation and epigenetic mechanisms

Genes are essential for the transmission of genetic information from generation to generation, and this mechanism of inheritance is fully understood. Genes are also essential for unfolding the genetic program for development, but the rules governing this process are obscure. Epigenetics comprises the study of the switching on and off of genes during development, the segregation of gene activities following somatic cell division, and the stable inheritance of a given spectrum of gene activities in specific cells. Some of these processes may be explained by DNA modification, particularly changes in the pattern of DNA methylation and the heritability of that pattern. There is strong evidence that DNA methylation plays an important role in the control of gene activity in cultured mammalian cells, and the properties of a CHO mutant strain affected in DNA methylation are described. Human diploid cells progressively lose cytosine methylation during serial subculture, and this may be related to their in vitro senescence. There is also evidence that DNA modifications can be inherited through the germ line. Classical genetics is based on the study of all types of change in DNA base sequence, but the rules governing the activity of genes by epigenetic mechanisms are necessarily different. Their elucidation will depend both on a theoretical framework for development and on experimental studies at the molecular, chromosomal, and cellular levels.     

An overview of the analysis of DNA methylation in mammalian genomes

DNA methylation at position C5 of the pyrimidine ring of cytosine in mammalian genomes has received a great deal of research interest due to its importance in many biological phenomena. It is associated with events such as epigenetic gene silencing and the maintenance of genome integrity. Aberrant DNA methylation, particularly that of chromosomal regions called CpG islands, is an important step in carcinogenesis. In order to elucidate methylation profiling of complex genomes, various methods have been developed. Many of these methods are based on the differential reactivity of cytosine and 5-methylcytosine to various chemicals. The combined use of these chemical reactions and other preexisting methods has enabled the discrimination of cytosine and 5-methylcytosine in complex genomes. The use of proteins that preferentially bind to methylated DNA has also successfully been used to discriminate between methylated and unmethylated sites. The chemical and structural dissection of the in vivo processes of enzymatic methylation and the binding of methyl-CpG binding proteins provides evidence for the complex mechanisms that nature has acquired. In this review we summarize the methods available for the discrimination between cytosine and 5-methylcytosine in complex genomes.     

The plant genome's methylation status and response to stress: implications for plant improvement

Plant improvement depends on generating phenotypic variation and selecting for characteristics that are heritable. Classical genetics and early molecular genetics studies on single genes showed that differences in chromatin structure, especially cytosine methylation, can contribute to heritable phenotypic variation. Recent molecular genetic and genomic studies have revealed a new importance of cytosine methylation for gene regulation and have identified RNA interference (RNAi)-related proteins that are necessary for methylation. Methylation differences among plants can be caused by cis- or trans-acting DNA polymorphisms or by epigenetic phenomena. Although regulatory proteins might be important in creating this variation, recent examples highlight the central role of transposable elements and DNA repeats in generating both genetic and epigenetic methylation polymorphisms. The plant genome's response to environmental and genetic stress generates both novel genetic and epigenetic methylation polymorphisms. Novel, stress-induced genotypes may contribute to phenotypic diversity and plant improvement.