Genetic analysis of the mechanism of the Salmonella phase variation site specific recombination system

Summary Phase variation, the alternation of expression of flagellar antigens H1 and H2, in Salmonella typhimurium is mediated by site specific inversion of a 995 bp DNA segment of the chromosome. Hin, a protein encoded within the 995 bp segment, is thought to catalyze the recombination reaction between 14 bp inverted repeats flanking the 995 bp segment. By comparison of the relative rates of inversion of two different plasmids containing the H2 inversion segment flanked by different sequences, we conclude that the sequences adjacent to the inversion segment affect the rate of inversion. Homologous pairing of the repeats is important in H2 inversion since the orientation of the repeats on the host molecule(s) determines the result of the recombination reaction. The presence of the hin gene mediates the fusion of two plasmids when each contains one of the 14 bp repeat sequences. When the 14 bp sequences are direct repeats on a single molecule the sequence between them is deleted. These results support the hypothesis that the H2 inversion system functions by homologous, conservative, site specific recombination which is similar to the systems found associated with TnA transposons and temperate bacteriophage.     

Phase variation and the Hin protein: in vivo activity measurements, protein overproduction, and purification.

The alternate expression of the Salmonella flagellin genes H1 and H2 is controlled by the orientation of a 995-base-pair invertible segment of DNA located at the 5' end of the H2 gene. The hin gene, which is encoded within the invertible region, is essential for the inversion of this DNA segment. We cloned the hin gene into Escherichia coli and placed it under the control of the PL promoter of bacteriophage lambda. These cells overproduced the Hin protein. In vivo inversion activity was measured by using a recombinant lambda phage which contains the H2 and lacZ genes under the control of the invertible region. Using this phage, we showed that the amount of inversion activity is proportional to the amount of Hin protein in the cell. An inactive form of the protein was purified by using the unusual solubility properties of the overproduced protein. The amino acid composition of the protein agreed with the DNA sequence of the hin gene. Antibodies were made to the isolated protein. These antibodies cross-reacted with two other unidentified E. coli proteins.     

Role of arginine-43 and arginine-69 of the Hin recombinase catalytic domain in the binding of Hin to the hix DNA recombination sites

The Hin recombinase mediates the site-specific inversion of a segment of the Salmonella chromosome between two flanking 26 bp hix DNA recombination sites. Mutations in two amino acid residues, R43 and R69 of the catalytic domain of the Hin recombinase, were identified that can compensate for loss of binding resulting from elimination of certain major and minor groove contacts within the hix recombination sites. With one exception, the R43 and R69 mutants were also able to bind a hix sequence with an additional 4 bp added to the centre of the site, unlike wild-type Hin. Purified Hin mutants R43H and R69C had both partial cleavage and inversion activities in vitro while mutants R43L, R43C, R69S, and R69P had no detectable cleavage and inversion activities. These data support a model in which the catalytic domain plays a role in DNA-binding specificity, and suggest that the arginine residues at positions 43 and 69 function to position the Hin recombinase on the DNA for a step in the recombination reaction which occurs either at and/or prior to DNA cleavage.     

A linear plasmid truncation induces unidirectional flagellar phase change in H:z66 positive Salmonella Typhi

The process by which bacteria regulate flagellar expression is known as phase variation and in Salmonella enterica this process permits the expression of one of two flagellin genes, fliC or fljB, at any one time. Salmonella Typhi (S. Typhi) is normally not capable of phase variation of flagellar antigen expression as isolates only harbour the fliC gene (H:d) and lacks an equivalent fljB locus. However, some S. Typhi isolates, exclusively from Indonesia, harbour an fljB equivalent encoded on linear plasmid, pBSSB1 that drives the expression of a novel flagellin named H:z66. H:z66+S. Typhi isolates were stimulated to change flagellar phase and genetically analysed for the mechanism of variation. The phase change was demonstrated to be unidirectional, reverting to expression from the resident chromosomal fliC gene. DNA sequencing demonstrated that pBSSB1 linear DNA was still detectable but that these derivatives had undergone deletion and were lacking fljA(z66) (encoding a flagellar repressor) and fljB(z66). The deletion end-point was found to involve one of the plasmid termini and a palindromic repeat sequence within fljB(z66), distinct to that found at the terminus of pBSSB1. These data demonstrate that, like some Streptomyces linear elements, at least one of the terminal inverted repeats of pBSSB1 is non-essential, but that a palindromic repeat sequence may be necessary for replication.     

DNA sequence adjacent to flagellar genes and evolution of flagellar-phase variation

A variety of factors, including phase variation, are involved in the regulation of flagellin gene expression in Salmonella sp. Flagellar-phase variation refers to the alternate expression of two different flagellin genes, H1 and H2. Site-specific inversion of a DNA segment adjacent to the H2 gene is responsible for switching expression. The segment includes the H2 promoter as well as the hin gene, which is required to mediate the inversion. Sequences in this region have homology with the corresponding sequences adjacent to the H1 flagellin gene in Salmonella sp. and the hag flagellin gene in Escherichia coli. The hin gene has also been shown to be homologous to the gin gene, which is found on bacteriophage Mu. To understand gene expression and the origin of these relationships, we have compared the DNA sequence adjacent to all three flagellin genes. The sequence data suggest a mechanism for the evolution of the hin-H2 locus.     

Phase variation: genetic analysis of switching mutants

Site-specific inversion of a controlling element is responsible for flagellar phase transition in Salmonella. When a 900 bp DNA sequence is in one configuration, it allows the expression of the H2 gene, a structural gene which codes for the flagellar antigen. When it is in the opposite configuration, the H2 gene is not expressed. A hybrid λ phage containing the invertible control region and the adjacent H2 gene was constructed, and expression of the H2 gene was shown to be regulated by the orientation of the inversion region. Transposon Tn5 insertion derivatives of this hybrid phage were isolated and λH2::Tn5 mutants defective for inversion (H2 switching) were selected and characterized. Two classes of switching phenotypes were observed among the mutants—those which had slightly reduced frequencies of transition from expression of the H2 gene (H2 on) to nonexpression (H2 off) (intermediate class) and those in which the frequency of transition was reduced at least three orders of magnitude (null class). Physical mapping of the Tn5 insertion sites revealed that in all mutants the insertion was located inside the inversion region. Tn5 insertion sites in the null class of mutants defined a region of DNA including approximately 500 bp which was necessary for inversion. Genetic complementation tests showed that these λH2::Tn5 mutants could invert the H2 gene control element if the 500 bp region was introduced in the trans configuration. It is concluded that a gene is located inside the inversion segment and codes for a protein which is required for the inversion event. Furthermore, the two sites at which the crossover event occurred functioned in a cis configuration and were required for inversion. The presence of a gene which is involved in controlling site-specific recombination events may be a general feature of transposon-like elements.     

Expressed and cryptic flagellin genes in the H44 and H55 type strains of Escherichia coli

Bacterial H antigens are specified by flagellin molecules, which constitute the flagellar filament. Escherichia coli 781-55 and E2987-73 are the type strains for H44 and H55 antigens, respectively. Unlike E. coli K-12, they possess two flagellin genes, fliC and fllA, on their chromosomes. However, they are monophasic, expressing exclusively the fllA genes, which specify the type antigens. In this study, the flagellin genes were cloned from these strains and their structure and expression were analyzed. It was found that the fliC genes encode apparently intact flagellin subunits but possess inefficient sigma28-dependent promoters, which may result in these genes being silent. The chromosomal locations of the fllA genes are approximately, but not exactly, identical with that of the phase-2 flagellin gene, fljB, of diphasic Salmonella strains. However, unlike the Salmonella fljB gene, the invertible H segment and the fljA gene responsible for the control of flagellar phase variation are both absent from the fllA loci. The fllA genes are highly homologous to the E. coli fliC gene but distantly related to the Salmonella fljB gene. These results suggest a hypothesis that the fllA genes may have emerged by an intra-species lateral transfer of the fliC gene. This hypothesis is further supported by the observation that the fllA genes are flanked by several IS elements and located within cryptic prophage elements.     

Identification, cloning, and sequencing of piv, a new gene involved in inverting the pilin genes of Moraxella lacunata.

Moraxella lacunata is a bacterium that is a causative agent of human conjunctivitis and keratitis. We have previously cloned the Q and I pilin (formerly called beta and alpha pilin) genes of Moraxella bovis and determined that an inversion of 2 kilobases (kb) of DNA determines which pilin gene is expressed. Using an M. bovis pilin gene as a hybridization probe to screen a lambda ZAP library of M. lacunata DNA, we have isolated a clone that not only contains the entire type 4 pilin gene inversion region of M. lacunata but inverts the 2-kb region on a plasmid subclone (pMxL1) in Escherichia coli. Deletion derivatives of pMxL1 yielded some plasmids that still had the entire inversion region but were phase locked into one or the other of the two potential orientations. Similarly, insertions of a 2-kb streptomycin-resistant element (omega) within some regions outside of the inversion also resulted in phase-locked plasmids. These deletions and insertions thus localize a probable invertase necessary for the inversion event. The region was sequenced, and an open reading frame with over 98% DNA sequence homology to an open reading frame that we previously found in M. bovis and called ORF2 appeared to be a strong candidate for the invertase. This conclusion was confirmed when a plasmid containing the M. bovis ORF2 supplied, in trans, the inversion function missing from one of the M. lacunata phase-locked inversion mutants. We have named these putative invertase genes piv(ml) (pilin inversion of M. lacunata) and piv(mb) (pilin inversion of M. bovis). Despite previously noted sequence similarities between the M. bovis sites of inversion and those of the Hin family of invertible segments and a 60-base-pair region within the inversion with 50% sequence similarity to the cin recombinational enhancer, there is no significant sequence similarity of the Piv invertases to the Hin family of invertases.     

Host protein requirements for in vitro site-specific DNA inversion

Flagellar phase variation is mediated by a recombination event that occurs at specific sites leading to inversion of a chromosomal segment of DNA. The presence of a 60 bp recombinational enhancer sequence on the DNA substrate molecule results in a 150-fold stimulation in the initial rate of inversion. The protein components required for inversion have been purified. They include the 21,000 dalton recombinase (Hin), a 12,000 dalton host protein (Factor II), and one of the major histone-like proteins of E. coli HU. The dependence of the initial rate of recombination on HU varies with respect to the location of the recombinational enhancer. The role of HU, Factor II, and the enhancer in facilitating site-specific recombination is discussed.     

Conversion of the Salmonella phase 1 flagellin gene fliC to the phase 2 gene fljB on the Escherichia coli K-12 chromosome.

The Escherichia coli-Salmonella typhimurium-Salmonella abortus-equi hybrid strain EJ1420 has the two Salmonella flagellin genes fliC (antigenic determinant i) and fljB (determinant e,n,x) at the same loci as in the Salmonella strains and constitutively expresses the fliC gene because of mutations in the genes mediating phase variation. Selection for motility in semisolid medium containing anti-i flagellum serum yielded 11 motile mutants, which had the active fliC(e,n,x) and silent fljB(e,n,x) genes. Genetic analysis and Southern hybridization indicated that they had mutations only in the fliC gene, not in the fljB gene or the control elements for phase variation. Nucleotide sequence analysis of the fliC(e,n,x) genes from four representative mutants showed that the minimum 38% (565 bp) and maximum 68% (1,013 bp) sequences of the fliC(i) gene are replaced with the corresponding sequences of the fljB(e,n,x) gene. One of the conversion endpoints between the two genes lies somewhere in the 204-bp homologous sequence in the 5' constant region, and the other lies in the short homologous sequence of 6, 8, or 38 bp in the 3' constant region. The conversions include the whole central variable region of the fljB gene, resulting in fliC(e,n,x) genes with the same number of nucleotides (1,503 bp) as the fljB gene. We discuss the mechanisms for gene conversion between the two genes and also some intriguing aspects of flagellar antigenic specificities in various Salmonella serovars from the viewpoint of gene conversion.     

DNA inversions in phages and bacteria

In certain phages and bacteria, there is a recombination system that specifically promotes the inversion of a DNA fragment. These inversion events appear to act as genetic switches allowing the alternate expression of different sets of genes which in general code for surface proteins. The mechanism of inversion in one class of inversion systems (Gin/Hin) has been studied in detail. It involves the formation of a highly specific nucleoprotein complex in which not only the two recombination sites and the DNA invertase participate but also a recombinational enhancer to which the DNA-bending protein Fis is bound.     

Sequence-specific interaction of the Salmonella Hin recombinase in both major and minor grooves of DNA.

The Hin recombinase of Salmonella catalyzes a site-specific recombination event which leads to flagellar phase variation. Starting with a fully symmetrical recombination site, hixC, a set of 40 recombination sites which vary by pairs of single base substitutions was constructed. This set was incorporated into the Salmonella-specific bacteriophage P22 based challenge phage selection and used to define the DNA sequence determinants for the binding of Hin to DNA in vivo. The critical sequence-specific contacts between a Hin monomer and a 13 bp hix half-site are at two T:A base pairs in the major groove of the DNA which are separated by one base pair, and two consecutive A:T contacts in the minor groove. The base substitutions in the major groove recognition portion which were defective in binding Hin still retained residual binding capability in vivo, while the base pair substitutions affecting the minor groove recognition region lost all in vivo binding. Using in vitro binding assays, Hin was found to bind to hix symmetrical sites with A:T base pairs or I:C base pairs in the minor groove recognition sequences, but not to G:C base pairs. In separate in vitro binding assays, Hin was equally defective in binding to either a G:C or a I:C contact in a major groove recognition sequence. Results from in vitro binding assays to hix sites in which 3-deazaadenine was substituted for adenine are consistent with Hin making a specific contact to either the N3 of adenine or O2 of thymine in the minor groove within the hix recombination site on each symmetric half-site. These results taken with the results of previous studies on the DNA binding domain of Hin suggest a sequence-specific minor groove DNA binding motif.     

The use of a gin probe and of an assay for functional complementarity to detect Din+ invertases

Abstract Various bacterial genera have been screened for evidence of DNA inversion as a form of control of gene expression. A probe was constructed using the gin gene of bacteriophage Mu and used to detect homologous DNA. To detect functional homology, a plasmid assay for Hin (the DNA invertase from Salmonella typhimurium complementarity was used.
Some Escherichia coli strains tested had a nucleotide sequence homologous to gin and expressed Hin complementary activity, whereas others had neither. No evidence of gin homology or Hin complementary activity was found in representatives of a variety of other genera tested.     

Pilin-gene phase variation of Moraxella bovis is caused by an inversion of the pilin genes.

Moraxella bovis Epp63 can express either of two different pilin proteins, called alpha and beta. We have previously cloned and sequenced the beta-pilin gene and now report that DNAs isolated from bacteria expressing alpha pilin have hybridization patterns consistently different from those of bacteria expressing beta pilin. The phase variation between alpha- and beta-pilin gene expression appears to be associated with an inversion of about 2 kilobases of DNA, whose endpoints occur within the coding region of the expressed pilin gene. Comparisons of the beta-pilin gene sequence with those of well-studied bacterial inversion systems revealed a stretch of 58% sequence similarity (21 of 36 base pairs) between the left inverted repeat of the Salmonella typhimurium flagellar hin control region and the amino-terminal portion of the beta-pilin gene.     

A novel non-homologous recombination-mediated mechanism for Escherichia coli unilateral flagellar phase variation

Flagella contribute to the virulence of bacteria through chemotaxis, adhesion to and invasion of host surfaces. Flagellar phase variation is believed to facilitate bacterial evasion of the host immune response. In this study, the flnA gene that encodes Escherichia coli H17 flagellin was examined by whole genome sequencing and genetic deletion analysis. Unilateral flagellar phase variation has been reported in E. coli H3, H47 and H17 strains, although the mechanism for phase variation in the H17 strain has not been previously understood. Analysis of phase variants indicated that the flagellar phase variation in the H17 strain was caused by the deletion of an ∼35 kb DNA region containing the flnA gene from diverse excision sites. The presence of covalently closed extrachromosomal circular forms of this excised 35 kb region was confirmed by the two-step polymerase chain reaction. The deletion and complementation test revealed that the Int1157 integrase, a tyrosine recombinase, mediates the excision of this region. Unlike most tyrosine recombinases, Int1157 is suggested to recognize diverse sites and mediate recombination between non-homologous DNA sequences. This is the first report of non-homologous recombination mediating flagellar phase variation.